Karnataka High Court
The Commissioner Of Income Tax vs Shri H E Mynuddin Pasha on 27 July, 2011
Bench: N.Kumar, Ravi Malimath
E
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATBLKA £1'? BANGAi§RE
BATEE 131:3 THE 2%: mm: QF ._fi}'§.«*£1, 20;:j:.._ *.__
PRESENT ' '
'E'HE HON'BLE; mt JEESTIGE N % T '
THE HOIWBLE wm.JESTICE'--R$VI Mfiigfiéififfi-4 "
INCOME?'/I'AX ;:pp:e:_;a..:m., @353 ;«v13',~§%ii';A Tié'5?"1{}:5W20@8
IN mm No.931 0329.96 g]
B E?T"x7\fEE§ 33:
I . 'E'h:3 Cmngz 1i':s«553:V§;'::1::? {JE6;§'E'3,{§{)1'E'"£,(;":.?'333i" _'
C<3n€'.:'a_I£3-:rcE'{3.__-:_ = ' -- "
C.[R,I3u'i'::c'2;:%»~;;;;,§ _ " '
Q:':.em--1:-3 §%€{>2t:::if;' -~ _ '
E3;';'I1;§2;':L::sr£%.' _ ' '
2, 'E"--'§.1:.€ §}e;:i4a§.}r '£?{v}n':§*::1i:§§§i<}§2er :35 iE:1{:{>::m«3:wt.2i:X .-
.. « .%fl<%¥"i'1i:"a1"§ CiI"'§'?:§.iflfV -2 .
V" C. §.{;'f§3zf:iE{£E'1"sg§5
» " » u§§':.vEv€;"f'é_"*T.§1':'_*Z'.'~ R£§§?i.{§§
V 113:;-1§_:'§§§j3 és:§§"2';; ,. E§E}P§$E,,-§..f§§\§'E'S
A §E;':3§?:?£:§*'%;j'..:3é§*;:¥;'i:1§£ gm §'§"L Mffiz'.:E£~<:%:=3sE":a<%'§'2::z3.2?:§ .:7&:iv{}<%;-:.E:€$;§
z%E-If§§3:
'§~§.E%Z, §VE},r::2;.:.{i<§_3*.:'2 Eifirasi-;§'.§.2,f:
§'{z;1§€~::':<,E.:°2:. :':a§;§;:r::*
§:3§'.:.i'§::{.tsg._,;§2i 5?? 2&2, Q6 §{§§§%§3{}N:Em.}§f:T€y§'
#7' ,
/
§ :/
W
{E'§:s Sari. A. Silélifiiéili' Sré. M. i{.,m=2.:, £X<;iv<}:':2aE::=?$}
aeaarécac V"
32:5 §':"';x filezi Lméiifir S€><:i.i0;': 255% of :.'.1':g¢:':
2:ris'ir1g; :}'u'£'. «:3? <):'dc%:r' tiara'-%<:§ 3if3.ii_2.2G{}EE¥ p2:3S:%;:§.._i:é%'"I '%S'}.%':
'f;'E3I'€{}/286?? gm» gm 3;3§()<*.k Ass;é;%sss::1€:'1i, §3<%:'i{_3--€§._ 0 :';:i;:;;--; 2;' :~:s-£33
{.9 18.82 .2C}(}§. pz'21;:§:1g; E:hat 15:21' Elm? 1*:%2z$:>':1.§;__s;*£.:::f:.z;%s;:§%..h.€r<;i§;':,_
IN I."E'.A N§.935 CF' 2906
E3 HR»-'\?I:§ EN :
1' The C<)£1'm'1is;s:;iz:1":€:z* of §§}(?("§i'E"£<§¥'§£1Z9{
€€>.r'2t.:'a1 C§*{"(T'§i°z --
€«R.£%::.E§di.:}§§,
Qu€€::':"1s R(}2i{i$
E3311§_§'21i0r<::.
{iE%.§3;ié.iE£i;'f':g;
Q:_1eez1s"VE§€:e1€E_:_ _. V . ~
B;*::*;5g5fz§E'<>:j{':g "T1: H A1?}§>§§I.LAN"fS
{E3y7S:"é.. K121 f';E'f'?c"i'§?K§Eifif'"f€3<E'f.~~S'E"§. EX/§i.E?,S€%$E321::h21§22.
§3;{i\?{}{i"/5§'i.tE'E§} VV ' *
AME}: " .
-:*--:-mi. "H . '12:; u<i.;€.3;.i£:
. I No 1; ~3{¥.'?§§
_ V' " ..E{:';%.€% ' ?<':s;€' €}£'§'im m2:.{§.,
- s::;A;.;:1';:;§;a.V">:V5?? 2:92, fir E%;E£SP{}§'€§)E%1?*§'§7
' {Ef§y;.'*"%;r§.L;---.5z':§ S§:a:fi«:a2:' S2': §.;:1*:,.-rzze ;%<§v{;€.223§é?S§
'/¥f$3§~'=%=
" V'VE\"A§31';§sn-2? E'E"}'-'*2 §'i§::':(§ u2':dé?:" Ss:%{:§'é{.t:§"2 2€§€Z}a5-'*3 <12»? §.'E',f§<'r%;,, E§€§E.
.x ";::V;;'§.=%;;§:'1;;§(mi. <2? <'§:"':;E§3:: {i::'é,.:":<i 353a 32.20%? g3e'?:$$€=.:i in E'§'{$$§f~é
'-- _ ii' §§_i\£{} ;"2{E€}£§,,, €<7;'§' %;,§':€: %f;§<3<'tk ;'Xé;§s5;<.%s§s;;§':'2z%:3i. '§3a~::°i<.;<§_ {;%'£..{}4'§5 EEEQQ
'7--%.z$' 3&5}: ,2{E€T}%.§.§ ;}:";§.§=-*i:'z;'§;T%E2z:.§. gm §.§"§§.'*. §'éi?:ii-i?3€.§'{§f§ :'%%;.2Iiéx:%{% i.E"::=7-.2"s:;=:§;r1
{H
ER I3..'iZA N(}.95? G? 2806
E3'IS'?W'i%3 EN :
1.TE';@ €i:)z1T;:1'1i5§$i£3:'1<23' <31" §§'E(){3I"f1(i--?§,.21:{ C§s:=m".ra1 Ci:*::.1ee, C.,REf3z.':.i§c§§:1g€ ..
Qu€en:e; §'{e:>21{i§ I E321.1.1ga§£3rs;
2. 'fh€ Dcp:,;:'iy C«:>:13mi$$£c::::>::f"<25 I:1(:i);e'::1.e-J£,ax,_vg Cemimi Circie »»«»2{2}' -
C£%.£-3:,:iE{ié1"1;§;,
QLIEGIIS R<>.-52:1 ,_ ; , V
B2'mgg1.i{3rs:>r. » ,z?';}'£--'.E*ZE,L}'1?%I'£'S
{E3235 Sri. A:"21Vir:€}." 3%:-::' Sri L $~:3¢és§:E'?;ue1€:§1aI21, fXd'y'{}(iE§_'£<€?€3}' r ' ANE):
Siji. ii . E33.' '£L}.'.>;:c§;1"§<{2i§4;1;t':'é3e:" .
§"iF;.§'»?ifl::si<>:1;f"L< ' "
EH c:=::>ss.
'E'iEz1.E=;23:3';g3§21E', _ ~* 4j::'i*1i:.m'3g;§;=: 4» .:'""f}'?"? 2&2. K4 E'<i§£:r5§:}€'_},:'€§.}§%;f\l'§' V' A A - {Bf};-="."';'§':':';"; S§f':?:«éi.%ié'E«'-:.é§.:" £2 $;ri, ':\'L Elzzxrzh skcizfzjcz-1€'s;%} $$$$ " _ "§'§;%3*§:'.§§; §E§{»:~{% ?;,EE'E{§€E" SestE':.i<m 26{}--;% :3? E.".Ei:%<%€.; 3.98% " ._g:":"§eg£§§g;.{;2,,:%; Va}§7'"<:sz°§i<%:'" {3ai':.§:«:§ 3@$E2,2{}@5 pzissééii in §'§"'§S$},s*% '~ n?€;§€j§.§T¥E;'-%E{ ah {.ié;%Ei2?§é:f:s%:i 1%. Egg? §c:>§§<raviz'2;.§:-- i §j%§'§{'%.;'.2=C%_{_fhé, Es}? %;é2«s:= b§<";s:::Ev_<,, ;"&§€;5;-;:%ssss;;v:":&':z§. E-'%*1.'i{3<i: €3*.'i.,€%4$ EEQS 33:: §%f£}"£ .2539}; g3r;»:j3-*'i:";;;; i.E:a£;. Em' figs: :"§::2'»2.s;<3:f;s§ Sf~3§E1!.{?¥Zi €.h<3§"<;%i'.:":, "5§§'E*;{z%:3é: E;'Efis:«: <:<>:":z§z'2g§ 0:': EEK %:€:::2"i:'3;,; ihés {£213}. 0:' the? :~:~2?:i.d ii:-?z>;a%3ii'~. §r1s:':<>me xzesase i:'1<%z4}:1.:e zzzxci §.'€:','i'E1§3I':{?':'.€Z1'é.E{}1'1 fraiétiz ihss: §}a:'"i4n<';%;'s:2E'1ip §i.m'15:z« ii': W'hi{Tt§'1 i.§:<=:§,-F vs;e1':;%_;g:,*.2=:'_ .'§:1.*?.'.'.£"£-E. Em :'s::ép'l.y ':0 i'f%";£é I}{")ii{,'€;T'. 1.me:§e::' E§<::mi:.}:'1 };i§EEéE._ :{}§'.i,_€ <;:ci>:1i"~§:*m«:%d t.§'.1-at. ifze .s:g<.>.;:xf°_<;'%€ :3?"i':'1e::§f;'::':{%'=1:': i;.E'1:=¥ "
z:%}<>x=*<% :v*'€:::*&~; ;».=.,:'s3: k.."::1:}w:2 ézrz %;.E":£;2 <;ie"p21;'ijr:1::=.:':i }::z1é:.i_'§f§1e';f%:-§;:;.é":?%:'S {er the ase:es:$;1'1c%;':*£. sf Mgs.ExfI.a.i1ikzi':jju.;:g1_ i'%jf._m;.<.,3v:;i=;::x.:fi%%:.s;g; §'g;:
ma 8.SS€§SS}}1€'3E}"§, jwzzr 2000 --V_QVV1V:'.-§§:;21_».$f; tf'iEé3t&:§<<f3:f; §('L2.O{}G5 E"€3'iL£§"§}§Z~E {If Ev1;'s;.%~{§:'£)E'§if<:i,h€sr:{s' a$s~36s$:"nc%m. 316221;"
1.999% 2a<::ta--V0: :';1g~:::_ ..t';.'I2 :"11/2189"E999 and 27132 «EGGS ';2i$_3T1iji3:A:::€,_§:"i€;E~.f{?i.§.'i'1'fE1S ..'i};":'i'E'1i;f{}'§fi.€ of M / S3.$'L§g21E1dh£l P'ia\,vm;z_r;$3,_§p':i_§:" and 200862 w?{3z'<=% .§'E.':€:d 1:11;: E53, 21.1%: _1i..G,20{}{} Pi?-S§}€i{Ei.E'a-»'£".'l}~i Ass 211% 'é'.%7:€.=s;-;z:% .§'fi£?'{i::KA'E§{¥§;{)§"€ E:%":é:* Sf;3§iE"{,'.h in éhe: pr:2;mise$ Q? 1&9, E1E:"3;'I§'{;?5'€§--i§'€j?vf';'f;'f_=E~fi; V;:::§m:.:r1<;%i*z:é.i<>:'; ;:3a'id by €.I;rm:s:==, §'E.m::s3 w:*::3--s; ::.{§<:.22rE.y {§;.i.§:;=:j:jE<>s<~7<£ in f;:§'1:%ir :*sit11ms>:. §E";{-:3; i'3{}§T1'i'€£f.§'1€§%3{i 'éfizags i.E:€;j; .;%éi:<-$523 EEG? ':.z;'1€§§sC§::}§;6{.£ §z'2{:<§§3':e as-*E":.£.::E': {Z2-'3§.§:':§ for 3: V ':s%i;:'.;;:*fné. r::zr{§€r: £3. wz.-:3; ;ai;Es§;{> <:0:';_3fi:z;%::i:§<%s§ ':'.E'":2zi iE2<3;%: §'i:%:4:é&; hzégéi?~&§e*::€i2:<:£.<:<i "SEES E21': §'€?E§§}€'."{_'.§l Ea} :'i':é:= §§'1§.€E'I:*.':'{%§. paid E2': 'é%":<:é%;¢»% V235: // 2"
E1€i's_.!8.'f1<E¥:? {ax 12+; paiai, Lzzxv (R3635; 11:}: :1mZ<,::= 22133--" :§if'§"<2'1"€:':'i:7e zamfi €:.hé::'ef<>;:°:-3. ha S{,§bI'E'1i§'S§ :%1a_t. ihe <,>rde:* 3%" 'the: .iE"r»€§%3'zs_;':z:§ :':2qz..:i:"@$ inEm'f%%:'ez'2<%<:?.
65 F-361" (:<>:':*::1'21. Sri A,8}121:':§€.a§,._ ié%21:'é':e<.§' '€§;;3'z.:.:"::5;'§:;:AEV §':'§r u the re:%p<>x1<1ez:t', s;upp<)z'i.<»:d 'the ;'.:":1.}"f;.1.«.1g?-,*;§.§§:%c~i'T<:s:*C3;~i:;*'; ?. Téze 2é_;3pea.1s \~¥€£"<;'5'"W._é§}£§IT1§E.i.€?{T3;.. Vi.'-Q: §:{}§f'2SiV€?3§V€?§" 'aE:€:
i'»:>I§m-szxlzlg s:,.1bs{':a:1t,ia}V£;:;csi.i(::iéé :>fi:2;\§é<>'LA_r;>z"1 85§Ck5§L("208?:--
"v'J'E1etE1£;%r tbs "'£7;'i'?c:i.1::;ai--- T§§;*.§1$'~(7{}'YY{%{3{. in §1.{}1.din§.%; 4F.,_E=:'21§. €£}1!f? V§_V3'"}:.f(3:}Vi:$'}€' A:35:'::%.%;:<::;ri'§;s3::3iA V§mrssL:san€:= H3 S€3.I'€.'.:f1§~._€3E1}és3i{3i.E58 "§;r§:,:g1':€':».i.€; xii:-EX' in ihifi E-Elaazéég .zs;$';$3s<:.s5!.<.3V3';ta.é;€'iEi§:.;d::%3§§t&v'E.:§1é'**5:a::::€ lzaxxrixxg §1<}'a': '§}e4:=.;": ::Aii;.%:f:i:>:§€s{?'§V .*e»>f'..-?t%,V'é;'§?;1* ;f§.' .5;%;.§;§::§;a;%ie::i 'Ei.1'm% p:"€s5(T::"§hed mgsjieé-%s:'_Sé{:if§:§i§'--'E 'i..h.:: £7335 émci <:m'1:»;e;q'1.:€e:1E..}.y . _vSNE2{)§,;§{§ _E§é:~ §;E'T'i*:E':A'€.[i'i{i'§'%:é% NIL }§E§.€'?{}'E'I1{ff as §}€;'.Z' Ses:iE;'.i<:;':. ,'E .i5é:}':§ 3% E §{;::i:k__:2§7 'E':%§<Et E§<%§.'?
'€i7'§:.ei,§1<:"::" '§E"§{? "E"'r§§3u;':.22§ WE}E§ «:":<:):':'e:?.é. in V u '_.§:Ezai: '£'}':e ;%{ia.;'§:.§'z{:<:: "§'2:z><; §32.E.}?'E'Z.§{':§}i. in %;E"::*: E:2<:}<:2Ie<::es 5}?" <'2E:§"am° i?;'§°z"z:_$ 2'-:a§*3<;§':.,'§§ {§i:esz:?.£:j§:\.
1:2:-3:::§1.::':s:é:*2:iémi 2-.1..'i'1€§ i.§'1.'E€f§'€f$'€i paid Es EEEQE £'i&"$E§€:?;*S&,§i1*£% aarifiuizi Egg? 5:;:.z§§":§<:§s;%:";"i'. 2:: %_4r<;%z1"é;. ihea sszaisi 2;::':2:;2.2:":i. {sf ém:%s.>:21e 93:9 {.*:Ess;<3E{j';:4;::.%<,i zmaii. é;.z::'§§:=% £3 :'>:.:E: £2? i:.E'25 % ;>1.irvz'€:w 91' £3"; £3 "§:3.£:>€r§<: é1$5%i?S§=§:§I'E'E%3I'1'i"
§3:'<>c:€:':-:§.i.i:':g;f:§?"
.F'r{3m i':%'1:;?: g1£2§1":~.:§z1i{i 1":1atm*§a3:ss oz': :*<3<:::»1*§s:§',*-- I."jij:t.:%_ " 7 'V 2131*. mi: if} ciis§pu?;c., '}.'E::e 2_:_s:::s»;:%.ss€%€$ 2x..1':?: g3::;*_i";7:<;:_:"%.;..i:';V..%éf:2:;*ie:::§ f'im'1s. '"E.'h:=::; Ezggve 2-:.t§v'21I1c:e.:i 2a::»a.;n;f,; €10 _2;h§T; §}:;a;iti '£7§.;":I:.::s;._L V'Ej}'1:"~:' s.;a,.§d fi:*m.s §"1z?zx-1: gjaid 359131z.1»:1€:ra.t.é:>i2. {:9 '§',E1€jt3'i-;A. 'E':.<1€::}$2i.é£E fii'1€"I}S hzzve paid iZ1{.(;':§'€?é%'Ei <:1%1V'"'é._};.%§: 1(}€»3..I."}"'1T3(}Ef1%d1%'E¥V(§ E3}; ihe §:'§r:11.sa in aa far as; the: ;_Eii;f,_e:r«z3%fé.E; p;:§*:.:_1za%:i'&;.§s {?{)E1Cf;"'I'.I1f3("§, éfiey hzavfi e;iedL;{:£.ec§ the "fax E'21j;f21b1ff V2311 S'{3.1.I§':Ei:§:v +;'c:- the: a:1':{}:.m£.s; paid by €:h&*;s€;~' i'"iE*:.:<i'r5. gfiii §E:h;é§8é" pé1}*::1§:_:';:£.$ 2-,z:*:'=: rs*:EI<=:«:?:%:.¢3<:¥; H:
the E3::>{)§s:S"<§11f'3;%§;:{>:f£1'§"§{'.£:._ ";?%;7€i:"r":i':'%1;<;%E§E:xz 2121 §.h€3 fiI'1'i'E$ h.:?zv€ flied ':'e:'.i{iI"3'1E.~§ -.3¥;>€:§'€}E'{i*~ ~:«:i::1i,<::> 3115i ix'-:£"<:rsr 2.he'a% s§a=:a..:"<:E1. "E'}1e'z*e£'<_3:."€:*, 4"E,§*"§€=. r::1:1§,*:._i:':'?*e_ :*{:¥é"n:.::"1r:::°2;:.£i0:'1 r{;?<:<;*..iv§%{§ by 'i'E":e:~:~:€ ' V' .E£$S'if§: <%;€i§§--$ ;°:;%§k%e::Ai,Vé?{§"i :: SE16: a{Tf€,T{}E,i.§'}i.E-2% 0? §}{}€}§iE-E} 3? {he fi'E"I"i'1S L_22:1:"Ej_ ""_"§'i'}V:Z1,_§s 4i:"'2::<:§'::;:«::"£,<%s:i. £':a5ss<:%.s»s:+;e€s:; {E1} '§,E"2.a:::ir gym": E':a'1v<: E§,Efi=3{§ ;32»:E:_i VE3fI§\5é'§fiéfi§:i €.£Ti.X, 3%s:~;ss:é§ss:%<i5; have zmé. {E1621} {Em :'e%'§:,;r.:'§s%; 'V.,§3€%§':3:z'<:-"$.55: {me {i:21£'.€§€;. E3' is; 3m? in £§i$§.3':,:é.s% ééiaé, %:.E2:-3 "' §€::.:,2.:'::ifi'_«<§:.:':"é:':g '%,E':§;% E~}£*.'».':Z§I'€ji'§'3 is <5:x';3iai:':.€:<§ ':33; {E252 ass E':2'«§v';1_::_;;§; %;>a%:3;': 21:i:{;§z.:i_:.'e':é<.i §%>:*'r2;3 fizz:-% ;.%{€}'I"§'?§%£-"§§{§ 5+;<'2:.2.z°::%:% {sf §:'*:e%z;:::m% *\:;"""'"