Advanced Medical Optics India Private ... vs Nil on 28 January, 2009

[Cites 0, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

Advanced Medical Optics India Private ... vs Nil on 28 January, 2009

Bench: Mohan Shantanagoudar

Ha amm mama magma ow mwmzwaﬁmw hﬂ mwzmaammm amamm Hmwm wmm mm; mww am gwzmwmw mmum mmmsmm emm m5mgmmm.gm.nQmaHnm zﬁmma mmwzuwzwmmeumx ma.m.za.»mmxmqom wmesmmz"

vu¢wznmw mammary cmamnm mzwHm mwaﬁwam wmzuemm m nommmzw wmmmmammmw azumm amm aoamwmwmm rug. Hmmm mveazm Ham ommmam we za.m» wmzmwmamm macaw mwnmmzmm wzzmxm:m~ q.n.waww. »ﬁ_nxmmm mvzmpwowmuumo omq mmmmmmmzamu wm Ham mawmnacw mzu maqmuwmmmm mHmzmqawm EH.mdZHW mmmrm ... mmawamozmw "mm mxu Hzmmm was"

, ..»,w,, wHw.p»..; ... wmmmczumza .-.,_ awHm. wa0ammzm wméHHHQ mHwmu azumw mawwnmwozmw+m_wmﬁapoa_an wag am emu noamwzumm ,.»nas.wmmmm.mmywHza ao2wmw:mmucnaHuz am MPHUIGM mwdmemukmmmm..nwmHamm»_mzw.¢mmnamHaHmm mwmzaz xnooqna wmmewcmm an ma amm mmmnuwv mmmuaaaaaz 95$H..%um§§E..%.M%_?...M_ mmam. m.wa.v..ama Hz mg 5 zmzauazwu Hz ammammaHaHmz mm nozmmwaw.

amwm nommwzm__manHaHnxz_nwmmzm "mmL mow awumwm ammm awn. amm nacwa.zmum%amm_mnwmaaHgmu ;. . .;a.. M4ao _.T%msmmwnnmua.

M mmbmm awwm wmnwnwaw wm mwwma Han noamwnamnwom om avg Hmawnnwow om wmwmunﬁ mﬂcwnﬁ mwbum aavwnww awn mensnwnwwm ﬁﬁmﬂwﬂﬂ ﬁﬁaoswn. mm nmmowéma aw «aw mmnwnwcwmn nnEumn% we «Wm mweawaw mmuownnwoﬁ aanmm ﬁ.»m.Naam.

N. awe mmnwnweumu naawmﬁw wm muﬁwn ﬁve wHe4HmMcum cm moaﬁwﬁwam mew. wwmm. m,wn«~ ash arena" wm Hunonmoamnmn 95 mm.m.wao¢ asmmn nsa noawﬁwmm man xwnw «km mmuwmnnmn om neawmnwmm wu xmhﬁwwmww. Mn wam mam nemwmnmneﬁ canvas an .% ym»L»; zo.mH, mmumwwona macaw mxnwwﬁmm. wabaxa m. .u;m.@xw;w¢ua. wﬁ. anomm. wnummwewmauma emu. 63$ ..w.&#wWxmwwmndm om nﬁm noawmﬁﬁ an man Oﬁn Hﬂ ﬁﬁﬁ ,;Mm§bnuumuE.ew wmmomwawwGS was mm mowwazmun ﬁﬁaaﬁama .gm;:M:mM$&mmn%nmrMENmvhh&w.v£%a Qnmnnhamnmw ¢._Kmwnmk5w$r MﬂBﬂM%wmugwmhm~ Emwkmws .m_£n.n.Hw_... m.%ww m..ma gm; E smwnvm~aan._wa¢m¢nww}%gm m$%%% raga mum ammnm»uwMqu»%_wmmna ;Hmmw¢awwanmx .ﬁ§Hnm\ n9Hﬁnmm§nms ;awmﬁmcwmmm«p..k% V I! {st in .WH_9&.E a mm 5». Quad in PM Sam an §3,....,,.....Em 3.». 9.55 aim mu, nunbm». 2.3 human nmmmu Hana own mmﬁmnmmx mam .m..$ Smamm em wcémn _. mumﬁhaw nm..: 3. mm» s Emu». nah .. puhﬁmuﬂu. mnmﬁw man» 332; ﬂaw amhmx van." 3 Q33 mma wt». 99. 3.. mwum .

Mn mm m a 9&5. mm on E3 wﬂmpum gm am wmmm um man. 9% hzhugw em mmmmmmn as Hsnﬁ m 3.. D.» mmabmwm man. momuﬁmﬁ man, .23. ﬁanﬁ Hanna wan.» Bum ﬁamnﬁmuwm 3 um." .. 5% am» .. manna ma» 3. omsgiauu muncawnnm baa. ummuaau Qmﬁ mam GM mﬁmkw. wash ban.

awmnﬁumunnem . 2 m. mwwha nmhwaww Sm «Wm mmwwwwaﬁan ; ._.wm@mmaa~ mm 93. m».m.mmmm Hm mm.w.hm.em.ooaxu _ ;;m. .mw¢wa«a;»»uno m&.ea.aoa m£ﬁHn% awmnmm om _ . . EL. mwmmsw wrwem vwmﬁ wmmnma gm H__§.a «.6 gm mum ,...§&..Em mm ﬁggw gm S" %..§mn»m§ mﬁmkm navwnmw am wm.hg»p¢wqu»\;_ m@gyww%%aamn@w om wm.Hox: amaw gam¢u«»ma .wna.mm»w'»w»q¢«maam4.

T, g, A mmwmeasmﬁwy num.gwwaw» mp' Noam. ash & auwm. mm Qﬁ Zaamawan mo. Noam. mum mmnwaawmmﬁ mwmhm agmwwﬁw Mm Hwaanmm we mm.A.q~.Qq.»¢¢x- uwqwaea wane ¢¢.pq"q&¢x- @aﬁHﬂ% mwwnam om mm.»axe mmaﬁ. Qua mwawwaa wmwmunm mwmmw wa vaenmnma mwaum sway. wwm amwwwnwnweb an wﬁﬁmxmnm ,m..

m. mhwwnwm A am «am mnwwnwmm ow wmmonwawwaﬁ cm nsa mmnwnwsﬁmn nevwmw aﬁvoﬁmnm «um naaumbw we Hmaﬁnm wwm nmmwnmw wu mnnouaasnm swam nae wnoawmwaau an ﬂﬁb pan.

x3wW-. are wmnwwwasmn neavaﬁm wv nﬁa nemumm aw Mam .. »m.#»lmnmgnw«»ona wmm as wnnmamwwnma Hams we nwa «mam T '_. _,....%.,.u.m____wm_._$_.m.m_.$.93»: mu cu. mp.m._.Eem. am an % $5 wmwwwnwmn neﬁma. wrwm mﬁra, 1 . e%mww%wxnwwMwm%Hwc awe nsﬁm om mm.»~qp'qq~hhox-

um §.$.q$......m..,$oT 5 $3 _~3mm&mwwnwwm..mnm&HmB..wnﬂGﬁbH~ aﬁwmﬁ omntwwaxu n%m_owﬁwwwvaawnmwmﬁkwwwmw.w%nﬂ%wum on wwmwnmmm am am ﬁﬁi. Ha ﬁhw£a%w+wﬁwamﬁmn3dHuwu& wammmu. «Wm maawnwonma nouw$%.mm¢Em.m% mm Hﬁuwwua ma Hwnwonmwwmwum ww¢ umwmnaﬁzﬁwﬁﬁwiwc;&wﬁMnwxwWm wanna» womwwweﬁ om Ham.mmmmww»mwm.Hwuv»Hwwwmw.

I' 3 IO mawnowa. mu» awn? Euumwnwamn gm amwugwmnmﬂ 6% gm naﬁﬁmaw. $95.3 wé mnnchwnmww ﬁmmmmnnma mmﬁgmmﬂ gm ncaﬁmmmx an mmﬁﬁnm Mum mwmhﬁwamamhm 53%. man. 5.3% hhanﬁwm mmunanam acﬁm mmmnﬁb. .2" umnmmm.m.§_..... as 33.33 nwwm wunsmvombww $5 exwnacnmwsknw. naanwnm 9% nﬁm nemﬁmmw, ﬁwm 3.3.3 an mmnmmoﬁ ommwnm cs. .?E.~n.om mun» Ema wwonwuw nemawmnhwam. ma wan wﬁuwmxzna Q. "pm wmmmmm. max 35 mwaawww Hbwﬁwﬂﬂwﬁﬁs Ewe ﬁmohwaaﬁwwaumm wnemuommw ﬁam wnnﬁunma .

_. ._..3 H5 aw. nonmwawmnwa cwuwnweb. Sum . . ...WHumue.wmm...Hmnmuﬂ.eu. on 3......» Eu 35% mwwua 35 w¢nwl.$.§F.w§a_§ maaosmn om «Wm Genﬁmwun Ewe. ﬂaw e..3.§m am $39» an ﬁam A. _. .%.HM_.u.H.m&.n eﬂm . . «.5 ...ﬁnﬁﬁ_ .

ngﬁmﬂmm wan.

.?..,3.Euw%,%?n D." _.m§.m3".U.w§m nanawéea on wmmnam om §§.%._E.%M%%k. m cm mmnnwoﬁ am m§o3....m_mw... §ﬁ...._.. mmxmawua wnnoaﬁn 8%? uanﬁwnwmnmuawﬁa >3 «-3 uannwﬁb aw" we avvwwea 3% are nesaﬁw ww awe nwnoﬁamwmunmm amnawamam wwahmwﬁ. maanwau ummww on awe run vmoéwamm mama noaﬁmﬁw mwmww wmmsm mmannwnwmm an m mnmawna ﬁwmwwah mow, nwmw an awwmwzwmm. m mna mama» na mum ammnnﬁmnm woman 0% éwwmm em mum vnwawmam Q5 wﬁamm wmnunwnwau awmpw am anmﬁamamuma ﬁﬁ ma wnnenmnw aa um nmwwma saws mmnmwwwwmm wumghuuw annomﬁna awn $5 unadwmweﬁm om «Era man Hmwwnwﬁm. .3 $3 namﬁnwwaﬁ em use waacnwmwmm nmvwmaw on ﬁve aoamaw. mwmww. axnmww mm uuaﬁwmmm. Mm «wwm wmnnwoﬁ. mmumww. an K $5 mmaﬁawwwmw wnmawﬁﬁ. _._. mnnc¢ﬁ.« ﬁmwm ~§E...§ §2ﬁ_.S.,$ nmmuwnmw om Sum f mademoaﬁow H5 wnocwaauimoa 30%. in }¢%§ . mmwa mﬁocbw naczwnw Va §$....&3. . .n.._....m..m swam. «Em mwummwmw wuaﬁwma .. Mumwwﬁmmn men. 53 uwonemwwn Q..wmww_moHm...._ u.n .32. E... wmnoamm .mn_H_ 3%., we mowwas wﬁm umoaamaaww$mﬁ»mma..% §a .mm._m.ua._.$.auH om mmnnnwnus vugdwﬁa wnnosﬁn mm.awwu..nmwu@& manwwoz So Ea H3. am £5 m%%..M W§§..§[w .n§.%wAmw»n_wa§nm ﬁaam Hﬂﬁﬁ nwwm mwvwwnuwwau msamw mmnnwvn gap 9% «Wm yaw mmmwwg mmnawmmwau an "awn nonnw new nmmannwas ow mmnﬁuwnﬁ ﬁnmawma ahnoﬁuw mam uawm an mauwnﬂ mwbua.

m. an au«mHnwwmHmm nﬁwm naanmu% mawMn»ov~ are mmnnnwemmn ﬁwm wmnawnnwa #9 wave own mmvmn. ﬁawwwnwnwos. »w «Va mnawwmw. Umww% nag mwnmmz gm $5 mgwﬁmm mat...» sum»? ..§E..... mmsmuﬁwanm. wmwamwcnm mﬁwwwcam~ nay am wamonm m.w.~omw. Ava mane em ﬁmmawnm saw wsmwaanaa mm ~w.».w¢om. wmwmn wmuwwmawwow cm wwm wonwam.

u._~m.. «vs uawwawon Hm wwaaam wen mannwaa wamHwmm. ma .a.mamn;__. aﬁw Sam mwwaa ovgmnnwau mau aw» wwawawwa ..xﬁnwwa% um «um mwwwwamﬁa.

a wn.¢zmH&3H use mmanmmmwm mwnnmw ww Mm

- _%,._,~,.%§ % 3% magma 9.3 mﬁezaa 3 an u u.wonwwu¢am+%.»wa smu~ae ya mmnwsnmww wmwwnn «Va awwwwﬁw rﬁm w#m mwwﬂwwwuwwwnw om nah noamhw. Mn wmnwmxmvommwwwwmnﬂmmﬁnnmnﬂzwwaxmwnmnnonm om use n0Swm5% ﬁHo%o@#ﬂ..w1 wnﬁm&mKm£5&nmv% wﬁe maonﬁa aw «Wm mmwsmwww mﬁm3ﬂﬁa&wwnn%hmm¢nmwm 50 um unwwwuaa nan aawnwguawm mg maamadwwnam wommaa. .35 ﬁuewamma, Nwnwcnwwom. cm mmannwwwmm magwg bnnanun on ﬁx.» nonﬁmﬁw. £3; non wmmnww W5 maﬁa nwnmﬁnnwéw am Eﬁﬁa mwwnm nﬁwwdmw on vawsmvw na maﬁa mwﬁauwowmwu 0». 5.3. 3.5 mm 393 nwmxﬁnmw .

5.. «km mmonmamﬁgaﬁma. $5 maawoﬁ em Sam nonémﬁw... Mm uvwnadmm "E San waumumw Banana cm as m§$wa,am$ wan 5.9 cum 3%. oﬁﬁammm £5 3.3 mnﬁbu. mmshm. H Ed. 0% $5 dawns nwmn Sub _.,.. _uu..mbwm3_.ew mzwmmma. 5% Eva nﬁﬁwﬂw wm wen $5 . gum $5 ﬁaaﬁmﬁw. Ham mwmmawawamhm aha § sen nawwnwuw. we Ema.

. _m..mr.am «Hm mawwoiwﬁm H ..

omw §..i.....l.¢l.Ila......

T...§mn_u§¢ om ﬁum §n.ﬁ..::..§ mH§M§@L....b.m_mamu.ﬁ . mn_mE...n% mﬁmna awmwwww 0% Sam %-n§e..2.& Q5. gm mmﬂmawma ..m%_m%,w_,.wwm.a"&.ﬁbmmcﬁ 5 aéﬁmnmw Rm¢n..K§. au%HM %_..wk.$__ § mﬁnawnﬁ 33$ wm w arm nmmawﬁwwoﬁ €33.35" wuomnacuw 5.9% Ma mowweﬁwua 33¢ gm m._aE..$"..

.. ".3 nnmnnﬁu an ﬁmwmcmsn nu magma on Sm mama mum. ugﬁﬁ muﬁunnkwwm munoﬂumn gm .. 9% Pa.» ucﬁﬁwuu am an n .. N 3%. aumhmmmmmn mu. hmummhhma no mm ....n§ wand mam Q5 wnnmnmmm mm mmmcnkm 3. an arm Q5 Gcﬁuamw Fan. aummuwaw 3 an arm Pam man .8 m E may momma am unmask nmmnm on. mama Gavan mﬁbhoﬁhua am mm $03 3., mm ﬁmﬂzmwmm mama», gm bu n ., Q5 mcwmnkﬂwumﬁ Psﬁ nmmmmm...

wmuarcﬁ ﬁadu nun ﬁ&..md..H nu.» an E5 naaﬁmsw. Wm Hénmm NHDB mm..?..ﬁLs:..§mx.§ mucuaen ~53 3.23.". S?" 3.5 nw. awﬁﬁmm BM. mmhmxu ; mmﬁw 3 .am...r.§.._§..§¢ awﬁnmm 33 .m._..r.§_..u.X 35,3... mmgﬁmm QM mm.m.E8 mmuzm 353 a man mﬁmnmmn Qua ﬂmwmu Mm. . gm «maﬁa mmnm memm . . . _. }T%#a«aﬁ§wn Cm um? naﬁﬁmwd...

gm ucwmuwan Q _ gm... mukawtﬁ v.._w_.n.m..M um um Emma Eu H3 m.§.ﬁau.k%%%V ..$m.... .,.&mM unvm». mﬁmﬁ R ﬂew» m Muamﬁ an "mam 3...... . pun n ,.

man 33 _wnn__....§_'._.§m .,._..._We."..TM_.«.,...M_,*..,wm_._M«§...:M__.u,.'m_T..

Hg Pam mam aim 3% H.m#Huw.mm.w~?

ﬂaw mmnmwunuam mwmamaﬁ bmaummn We hmmdnma kw 5 man 3% mm.¢%~m&\qu'mm&\; whoa mm.mm~mm~mm~mmux; no .ma.~m~mu\mu\mmmx;} kw. mﬂummnﬁeﬁn mma mmnamwm em nvm mama macﬁan mmmmnmw gm may: 3:53 am Q3 whom? E5 mcmm mnnecmn wmn@H mmumﬁnﬁmbn em mm.m'uH~wu.aamxa 5% mﬁm ﬁanﬂlﬂﬂ mﬂuunw aahwm unwmnmu hﬁﬂatmﬂ use gawk" vﬁmmmab my nam magnum man mama mmmcﬁmw.

nmw awn» awe nﬁsbwww wan mannﬁ gs nag Egan? 5.2.3 §mﬁ$ﬁ¢ 5. wm $53 m§§§a.

any awan 9 nonnwmwma naﬁﬁ an nwwm euaww _m..»ma»ma»um wwa Ewﬁmwew mm aﬁwnaama we uewwéaawa .,;:mm..@ .m%a wWm+.mmmHmaHmH am. ﬁoammwmm £»«wwu_ «Wham . i%$m&%mum#eK.wWn nuns GM Hanmwvn an ﬁ$ﬂ% on nwwm ;sena¢nw..

k »~ awmw.aww«u¢wa¢unmw«w»am «Wm m&mwmanmn»oﬁ ww wmmLwwwwmnnww.dW%nmaﬁmﬁwAw an wwwm Gamma mag. «am mwwa Hwmwwmm_ wm, mcmwwmwma. aw nwa msnwwms wawwa 4am¢_ mwsunm. gag .wwm. mausbnm xxx» "um"

uawww 1G&b%m .¢w5w§ waxmvmwmum. mmwﬁawaum mawnwcwm. wmmﬁam swnwwn Ha mmﬁm om wwa mbmwmanwnwou wmenmmwwm.

q.smWm+ gm»

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court