Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
Vithal N Nandavadekar vs M/O Defence on 17 December, 2019
OANG 3102018
i QA NO. 2892/2018
OA NO.AS9/2018
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
MUMBAI BENCH, MOMBAT
ORIGINAL APPLICATION No. 310/2018
with
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.292/2018
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.459/2018
Date of decision: 17.12.2013
CORAM:~- R. VIJAYRUMAR, MEMBER {A).
fet
NI
ts
R.N. SINGH, MEMBER (J).
OR No. 3110/2018
roe
vies
he
tls
, d. Niraja Ravindrarao
Aged about 2 years,
Wo. J. Ravindraras
R/o F. No.i3, Aman 'D' Lane
No.1, DBDahanukar Colony,
Kothrud, Pune-4ii 0638.
i
¢
.. Applicant.
versus
Union of India, Through Secretary
Ministry of Dertence,
South Block,
New Delhi-1ic OL.
'
The Controller General of
Defence Accounts
Ulan Batar Road,
Palam, New Delhi-1ioola.
The Principal Controller of
Defence Accounts
R & 0, Wesat Block V,
R. K. Puram,
New Debhi-ilic O66.
The Joint Controller of
Defence Accounts
Rg D, Dr. Homi Baba Road,
Pashan, Pune-411 O21.
et
CD
a pt
m >
gt eS
Ob ON
a
OANO.310/2018 |,
OANO,
QOANOA
~..-Respondents.
». Applicant.
.., Respondents.
ran
a
63
». 43
5 :
Cpe 4 ~
x cof gwd th e rr}
a 7 © & o ~ mm
og O.<3 Oy thd ay 3 03
en "a i o * «at ie
> oy 2 3 & C3 Hy Sh, si he wf ig $4
oy ode a ou cd rt us he ford iG @ jt te re
" as cm sp a 3 6 a0) i es as a ' th O os
' = Diet ft 0g Oo $4 oo . Soa At At a Dp ow Mey $0 e
GC ES Ean eed ty bs a wt ag i @ Moot 2 ie O '> 0 G
| eS te) wa tS * cS ot a A WG hu DO wo wm @ ch hg C ns
WM BAe Bt xd @ } Sf cr 3 $S 6G OR thd bt G tes rR
a oe Of WD rd WO WP word oO 8 4 Pea bo G3 ye i MO os 4 Ba ard oe
CG Bo Ta ts cho » 44 a> AAO AA ed ow 8 3G Be sed a ie iy "ed eG
mf O rt i © fob CG pod GG G o> o TO ts. @ i AT
Bid 9-99 ort £3 a Oo 3 Oo @ poo 8 SN cs 6 yom @it~ Gg mis & «
fy 103 * ce) im red ret O 8 mt Chord Me Oo. Guy WM OF « hy our «ff a w
cdo 4d Sy Med Ad ed wl rh Ca a pay oe tn ~
43 OD et bio OP | oO OU MM & Oo 0 4 ke O 4.) = oy 43 "OT is
Woe Mee O ve Moh oS @ Meet EB > OF Or wo bm we A OG
O 44 bx} a ce 4 $3 3 CS spd ve BOB Ori r a O Ort Oo GQ
M SE Sp os O M4 i 4 oo wp Q mt O a BO Om ny @
Ae 1 Dy 43 o Oo OU mM « oy Poort mde WE me LY fe fa 1 OF ea Rane rep
3) Qh eet A oc & flo tp es Mo x o 0 "rd Li go
ve oS Ord 4) Oo @ 2% O SO HO 'COO 1 Pw :
BD Ore oO rd GS DY 1 et PU ty OG woo 6 O me MW Oe O kyr a
G TAN. O fri O @ a Bed da Ut Go "A TRO. bh Red os bes *
ay 6h OG OP Se mf 02 E+ Cf Ou i -- BS mo eh 0 0 0 oR oO eS =
L
be
"
a
2
~
4
ot
mo
&
"y
oe
8
8
OA NOSSH2018
pnd,
4
oa
t
:
he
4
{
'
4
'
10
2U2F20
*
od
a
$
ea
DANO
OANO
ny
cy
be
iG
@
wea ae
i ot 'os wo
LC is] Oo © im
we $4 we. ree ~
43 ved 4 " S m
, mee a rh wt, 2 c
. . SS why a) We <> wy tft
or ~4 wg OO cud * " ci sy my
« $4 Ne 4 TH oa . ee kG 2 *~ oy ~ oe we Fd cored ao
om tn © "et QLD a «3s cs % ~ wh ne} uy Grd th
MoM oo 2 Wan ns) c uy <a ~ 4 ~O A 2m
GU ort mn oo ~~ mC BG a cH og © OQ © @ 42 Ow wo
@ & Boe » i Me & Sy OO aoe c oO oD eos cs OG. CO" £e g
ra te 43 & rd oO my PA oy ig RJ Gort amet) Pret + S Sw 4 S i] dye
Te or| 8 mt 6 AO ad as Jos > prs me & r$ £3 By et ao
"ior EN --~ #) O 09 <P wel SFE ord By ®@in a O wa ord Hh 4 : mo rh orh eI OO
6) KG wi Ss my tp et DO ot ts] oY ONG 4 WD Goon ow wy iy Cab et iy 4 Op
Po os Tom Mert eH red ref A ot ere gy Oe
oo Bae ec CO 8 4 aH ag Oe be <A .2 00 ° S
3 5 BS ' 4 eo et ob ch oy ek oe eS es ee SO) 1g so
oo of 6 'Et 8 O MOM Oo x He MT O PG -4 OM 4 6. RD mM xt 0 Om So Oe 2a oh ett
QA oe z ft tg od OO PG Q CU ord ard ote ty JO he MO Mer gi GO od
MH Os Oh Os fed Se TA th TB bors SS ME Cy fe RM el CS GO UEP a by "5 A We ta "
; OX 6G WOK 6 om GBS a BW Owo" ow * Of ~ §£ Of FS 6BH " GH *
Gd tod oe ct mo « rf 2G $4 > OOO wm «th oS mo FD 4 tt 1 6 4) QO cs i
PH O 4 oe wo pS 45 WY OO oat HOo Go G a @ Oo oc O - >» PO oOmMO RF eg «6
Godt. BO wh Om Oe wmo™ 8 Oo Sm Oo. + Sy ol Om GCmMOon~ OO B&G
Ae wh OM FA eA HN AM MM OO Hea MO MMAR MAAK eA Re
e 4 my 4.
. * x « . . ¢
fs Wo 3 te > oy
OA NO 3102018
GCANO292/2018
OA NOAS9/2018 x
ee
Lokgram Kalyan (2),
TR
Trane.
1G. Mrs. Precila BD, Gonsalves
Aged about 52 years,
wite of Gonsalves,
R/fo+Jamshet Wadi,
'Merces} Vasai, Thane.
Ate a a
Aged about 37 years,
Wife of K. Bhogale,
Rfo 34-686, Adardh Nagar,
Frabhadevi, Mumbai-400 025.
*
2
i2. Wasudeo R. Asal,
Aged about 59 years,
x
Son of R. Asal
Rfo-2/2 Vimal Apt,
Shivram Fatil Wadi
Jimmi Baud,
Kalyan (EB), Thane.
12. Ashok B. Maviankar
Aged about 60 ysars,
Son of B. Mavianlar
R/o B-3/16, Vandan Aban Park
Dhokali, Kolshset Road,
Thane CW 409 oO).
og ee gr Tas *
14, Prasad S. Bagwe
a in a4 "ey ™"
Aged about Ol years,
Son of 8, Bagwe,
R/o A-3 Pratiksha Soc,
. ve a
Manisha Nagar,
Gate No.Ol Kalwa,
. am cnn
Thane 400 605.
15, Mrs. Snehal S$. Sawant
4 Ro canes
Aged about 55 years,
Wife of S. Sawant
my fm, ee vy? Bet Ae teage Bet
B/G Crew hns ; Bubp SEL ae?
% % ra Daria
Choqle Nagar, Savar race,
" * a a
Borivali (El, Mamba .
i6. Prakash A. bad
. ga
ECE TE _-- §®'®bh hhh kl
OA NO310/2018
GA NO.292/2018
OANO.4S89/2618
LPs
Sen of A. Lad,
R/fo C-14-5, Narshan CHS,
Sector-£5,
Sanpacda, Jui Nagar,
Navi Mumbei~400 70S.
Worli, Mumbai 400 918. .. Applicants.
(By Advocate Shri P. J. Prasadrac)
VaXSus
1. Union of India, Through Secretary
Ministry of Defence,
South Block,
- aa
New DBelhi-iic Ol.
2, Flag Officer-in-Chief,
Headquarters Western Naval Command
Ballard Estate, Near Tiger Gate,
Mumbai, Pin 400 O01.
3. RAdmiral Superintendent,
Naval Dockyard,
Near Gateway of India,
Fort, Mumbai,
Pin Code-400 O23.
es
. The Princ Apel c
Defence Account
No.l; Cooperage
Fort, PO Mumbai
fu7 209 O39. .. Respondents.
(By Advocate Shri R. R. Shetty)
ORDER
Per: R.N. SINGH, Member {7} eT} Se wet ey toe wD Test qe Daye F Ya a i. When the case is called cut, SAFL FP. vs 3 ony x = ELAS ~ ot rg " ' "
PEESaALa, learned Counsel ADVERLEG Lor che a "C3 Ld g it @ a t wo ve gi ard re hi $e a ee 44 hd i ig ng ts 8 4A i « a be a BS w a a 3 - a oy g ' 3 % = es, eo, 6B gw 6 ow tg us Ou ® ig ny S. Pee Q Cr a eed ot Oo Q AG) oe
" 4 . 1 & red @
- a Og ce ae a 1 b ao Ew '2 43 te ; @ r ey wy ym ot i 624 py 3 4 an SA a ® v @ wees ed gy it 4 goo OG me om eo OG a "3 tf) tf + Da me gs ry a ~e ay e gi iS ft w ns ed "4 Cy $4 ie y, UG a ee iss s Thee eh y Voy ;
& a aa $ ' 4S my i . Meher aD we De . oo BO ey eA By tS ho 7 @ ca aH is ts 3 Od seo Fe On rtd aa Mi wt et a) 4.4 boa ia "4 : bef ig cei OE Tas or 3 3 CG red oa \ . fed ae . £3 4h i he co 2 og Oe a Bop sO Bo oy am wn 6 6 G 4 a ee ae ry ned a 8 @ » 6 8 ae # gp 8 om 3 a C8 : r gerry a uy. C3 - wy a ea oi} 1 ie 2 vd és 5 od Q @ a 5 a OF a e p. CH Met O sm a ° w . ne sa "4 eo ya & m1 O od &, vod w uy ss id © o) B43 Est ita] U4 ; I om ga eG : . ' oh ed rf 5 ' G * Vv ied O cn, a 3 ng ' " G wt fe 6 «3 a oes © "ret O at 4 et gy & '| "4 a 3} " 4.3 a eG E ae on : PZ c my 5 the 3 an ved ord a wy iG cd a ra 3 i E vs « $4 n "4 cc S & & 5 ~ oe om Nit 4 7 Me u ¢ ord ; £4 'y 7 2 Le im D ¢ Cy ed bef 9 rd c a wy O, o & ; 'a a os M4 f wy 6 : 4 ca ' fen od rs 43 3 i oe "4 ' 4 : ig i 43 ye re " w ie G 3 'e gk Ch, wu Hd YD Lea, os (V4 "4 f, eM iB te fry i bby a) 5 kas 1] see} 4 4 % co ae va q? my O 5 . ey "4 ~ bel rr} ip in SOG | 3 mm w uy g : Bi y Ss 2 Q os eo he Dg m ve % ; ae 4 , fag wh Cy £5 te at got fend t3 sid veri hd hs 3 @ 3 Ww 3.3 ae 88 fa 3a 8) Se os "3 $i ha ~ fe EN + s a "pa " bes 4 Se gerd ka TD ES ae i B Saad 3 wy 3 3 a f+ ch 3 bg @ a "4h a Ke . * Q} bed 54 2 " ' ' : 5 Sim rt vO bf m4 « Ch G eo a # oS aa nh Oy fa ku em Be . po an ¢ " oad ' oS g bs 1 le wo co i) ret B oi Ff ct ' hei J es ced wn whe cs we se 67 '£4 rs ard o tn sed vet hh aw 4 © i 3 ed 4 a) Le) we q) s ort a oe . a * Ee im ae QO iB mel O ag hf ty hed 118) be i ne: ie £3 2 C0 ne &D 2 mo aS Rn gw tw es ed ar . £5 6G z @ ; , 288 : So 2 gg Fey en Oe st B ee ; "s 3 wee cg fe Q i a OOd «a as oC UK ot i ce! ee : an 8 mG mi nt o + Bo re eS a we. 8 4 @ f G cs " c fia a ~ & 8 oc ef & 8 se 8 8 ne ey . in ' , a . i a i ei v4 ae» y 2 a ae a Sg ® « ved fe Or 6 : o ; He @ be 2 ee 8 te aS 3 if © a yo BFR MoU ik a a kg & 4 aa a3 fag . iy fe sy 4 a 3 ies) a o 3 G& oD Ct & Q ° C ag 2 & a ¢ 2 & go & oP Go. ge - G, ae + en o 3} rs Bo i " o ad x Ree ed od $4 05 td a mg wy io " 4 w QD a wt gt wo be 0 OQ OB a a Fo a, ~ » %® 8 on jd S © vee gy eed By 9 6 sg A eo gg we BaP gon & 73 t » ved sys . $3 ~ 3 m Ty orc 63 Re ha 2 > it} 8 q Oo " oS "5 4 4B - rel gt a a in tl 3 C rd rs KE, os ct wy Ge As ge 3 g R S 3p ~ oD eg od : SA . @ 4 a . i th 4 uD a its} O mm He 6 apf a oged o 4 reed * G 6 we 8 ® @ 27 sit 54 wn » OB os oa rH 4 4 : 3 a wooo cd ol p wmf ES on rote 2 s 4 a Ss ' a J 5 Q 4 a a 9 me OS gt ye By EE af te c a ih Go ¢ 4 wy oS ~ 8 * "er Me ay Red re 6 Sor oy " 3 3 ss . . ot in i Oo wy oy te : 53 Be > ved of r4 a By " y 4 4 y vd w £3 » vy B o of fe 4 UF a 4 i 3 py 8 OO we & gy 3 o ae 4 rie O % 3 gq Gry Ub wrt oo a % a o a g 5 a CG. & 22 @ GO rm OT x "re ; ot * . 4 weg oe 4 nowy ¥ a ytd 4 ms 4 @ 6 oO zB # iB e a ey 3 ' Ws o 4 c i @ 4d wet G A 9 ix so, Bow we We wens wf £ "i 2 «g a i noe Oo "ed eI @ _ ' gon Bo Cy te G apt ord 8 ay ~ oO ried 43 Ae ; cA 3 om be wy ve aD . ve " GY ea go ag + a os sc m Gael tt ® ay aod . & - hy et a a 0 wy uo to we ed do 43 be @ . <c @ o 8 4 eo «8 a oo Bom a a ee @ 4 4 fe & a a « 43 id Mi 4 a B 4 2 40 n 7 @ o "4 a gine t Me e at . is j . ef 4 mt "* shat we Eo ob g BP gg & a a Re HO Bee @ 8 8 GO wt eo 3g a) a o aq oo 2 1 oS on} a sy OD ; my rh v4 o wo B ® gi 2 yo RS GS og Fe 8S OG B'S Ho yg OD "4 ha & cw +s B oO o ' art ° do fa oe bx rd cp & is # fa 0 Et es 9 8 ~ go 5 ces fox ro oC BB 0 EN eg a Ay ot a oy ce3] Oo a o w "a vet Gad 3 on iD oy # on oO "j0OM poe pom O, ot Bp BOS fA a © a ed S i Fy " o short Geom Ue wp 36 a dl: ad i 2 ved kg 43 i oe On oe os cs td ork ' O x od 43 ao . a ¢ 7s TP 2 es Ghd Bp 8 rol 4D {me me . 2 & 8 & fi or OD al a wy 3 o o ng i fe oes oF" > a reed €2 'st ca ch 4 ne "4 uy "td ct by 3 gC mF oo oO Bm BO RP od 48 rea Es G oe in @ bt i es, ' y ® cd hel oo vS he nt és © wi AG « +4 } ot aag 5 Fe gp a 8 NS, fe » » 8 & eh 8B & 8 Oo 63 OOD o Oo ™ Db % mn © Fe 8 » ~ 4 FS, ee oe x he rt 4t i Ks © Co wo Wort WD Mee "Ch ey RE Eb om ip Oo in va 3 eg Ch, ted o . 14 4 red Ja ol Booed £0 el 0 Gog Bw 44 a3 c "f a} kK. ef : G 4-4 AS ere] ht tt treed 43° mF ol Ogos "4 ms 6 g a th 4 % we i Sieh ae ® OL ved 4 "saat F £3 et oon 1 e 0} "a o 5 et oe is 4 ay fi 4 ct t Mi OG ut ® gs rhe git fa oO, ty 43 a O got Bay OO sy aH Se Gn an & Mm mo og a fF sy et gg G BU Ay Wert Gy to 3 8 eo & F , eo Se Y 9 EC Be Oo kone i B a bf ag 3 a wg m& moe ced yo re Ay Ath ha {2 rt ne ~ mK. OD 3 43 ! ve; 3 > £3 Q@ fs ay Oy Ua: ee . ff ait sed c ma ° a ny rd 3 "tt é a GQ ar vet a Mog qd 5 Ke 4 Seg Od a Moo 43 a fo A Fe a » " a a o 54 ~ eH "e) & aw ~i @ o Sg a i is i) a... % We io wa 3 * a te Qo wl gy " be SEO ae ey ob a5 i ped ry st _ as aw ho Roche ane A 0 9 9 2g "8 8 uy a Gg BOR CHARS" eB o : "5 e ps ws hal # + ry fo i 4 a gay + QD he 5 % e e oe G 7 eG Fy e * Ps "a oy wi OD a oO -« we OMe 8 BO we opt oy AA peed '. . ted w Ou Rm - a4 Go "ey of * seh Page ' S ms x ri $4 . . hy © nen ' ss ) w@ 2] i ane a a fs D Go. Te oO] M4 2 Age . 9 2 og a ch 7 a ~ ¢ 2 a a\ 2) y is gt & aD es ES ay f i o et 4 Oe by eh Ce GO ge ny PP oy ed Go ip fs w ne ud ° J CO sO Soa fh Ly 4 mt) ap wy MOD FE OB 43 es Me oS - aw p34 kB ow os tA £ ae My a c : es 4G gt bs "py 2 M Ay or "3 ct a oO Ci ey yw HOR Hoa At at mt og 6 an a . we a & a nD wy 4% oy Q 2 Mm fe a 0 Mi ch ' e OO & pe Be ey By " B 7 OG eo 4 ; j cL dah is " eq OF a o et R } o £ @ Re led Shri c.
Of India iQ cee = follea & $s) x u Co a 2 e eS 4 Te ea gp 3, G "e3 i td A oy ; Soa + rt . eS sy 5 ® re ua a 5 oH y cc Sed te thy Q & med @ Boy :
o pe] " i a3 & ~ ce) " wed 4 'A Seg a or mm Pay O q oD 1 -@ i Q be} b © , cs poet ny ae ay ett bey qa , + 3 es ba 4 BF py pS cow Wet CW ee 0 Do sa 0h, mt cd | a a Gos 3 Om OBO 5 o og Da eek & net } oo 8 8 a og Gf oH t ME ge SG C.F En Yep af 8 eos eed GS © @ 2 ve u fos a "rf ey <3 Ba de gy de Bey sy | oy gy ® , wet Ry fay M4 we 2 mga 3 a ni et ne D et Wg Oo eogomawe * vo " ny 4 + nes & 3 QB Dr pow Be Bg a ot 8 s rh eg Bw fs ~ 7 a . 8 Be Me Cet ed WOO GO ad > ey 5 io - 3 . '4 om) 9) fae @ | wort OOO De Gy OA 4 OG 4 YO . gt D a (67 3 id 2 OU OM OD OM 8 HW OMB OW BO rd od ti 4 5 v6 (MO Om Oo Ob So OH Oo MO a a S 3 2 we OS g a 3 - 2 - i UMP OPM Di 6 eM mm hu Oa BO GS @ wp GO og Fog : "
z 3 3 oF EA th 1. ed ce 5S i beg a 5 $4 wy * @ ve be pone > « o 4 > 43 ved . bed wy 43 a G vy 0D oO " ig 4 oO Eo a4 rt rh a Hed o a Bi re ee me Y my oo eS k t :
ay = cm i Bg . wed as ao a tt 0 n 3 cy o a { : Oo oro £4 G a! wi « a" @ pa EN 10% 4 "th Op vg i wet A 1 Oe 4: ng é De fe id Y hd a MOO 4 w ug o weg cy ky fy w : 5 7 . " "7 " ct ad fos fon fos Aah aa ao ci Ess 4) @ 6 " i Kae wo OG 4G Ose "ef BOO '1 5 » a 8 pf oS 0 ® oom & b OR 4 gD goood ~ mo & D wn Y "4 2 a 8 ~ GE # ef - sO mn = we : oy rh on oa gq ° eo @ DO 8 9 a fe G4 kM ae BS ps i wm © a me, ei ° 5 f "rt 2, i Be 4.8 wet a "4 wre OO oy G " ty co Oo 3 u ce) ' x o« ce <4 oe 4 oe a eS An dl a it mM ch, fae os 42 Cs MS 2 a: oO wh ag 4 Gs © gy 2 ei " ' a fo Gy a ey i oO » 9 A eB of & = gf Ck Ch fa 42 fon es 3 3 Ch ® . ai ss be at fo a ve oO = go » nd @ "e ™ w a' 3 OS oe 2 aN sy Be i) Co to a a c gene] ' gm 2 ay ° ' Oo uw er 43 "4 © ny pa Hed fa 7 e mM 43 . 4 cea ore @ he ay Fons, red wD wy te $4 + ° 4 ' 3 a a 5 "5 @ 43 + a hed bed in fi me ee ru a oa wn y * ot g} FEN hy oS KoA om eo ras he at wy wm uP x a red ret ct '. at Me by iB pb e en Ge 43 4 x res "4 j ¢. 2 a esd CO 58) zw Oo Sea Ad % ef it o ° ° aS a 6 ord hy ce mf ied , El (3 th eye OM s _ a GO @ Boe a fF 8 og a = @ we ny a o arf a4 ie pos @ bey, Bes i ai 3 @ tb Sa ae " F D faa Se wy r Doe ¢ syd a] red . roe wd 4 rm Gu + a OT hd _ Re re a 5 ay Mn w Oo ¢ +, I @ e ; @ w mh Ee 12 & oe " QO es ha orf & ig a * bs a B ri Og % W O ws OF we c aye age 4 ape 1 : 4 oy 4 boom Ge gg a ie) ig B serd ' ra %S So Ly a ord @ a) ah HOR At ved a mm @ 3 tS a sd o re ws 3 . a i i we a 3 ce a © is "cA oe ; wy ot @ uy i ; Qi "
ae xt 44 53 oO "3 Q co 3 od * « Q roa w set oe % a ia co a i gc an wt ro fey qy 4 © Gg ob * iw Re 3 <4 nes hee 4.3 fit " rhea + ay a , in oF by ord 43 7 " ot c . ' tee f ra a bs 3 a4 o ¢ Oo
- 3 : me « t ~ we wd 63 eC * ' Fs x & a { Member Singh) i x x N Member (J) (R.