Karnataka High Court
The Managing Director Cum Chairman vs Sri K S Premakumar on 21 April, 2011
Bench: S.Abdul Nazeer, K.Govindarajulu
Sri. EN. Amamath
Ageci 43 years;
Sfo. Sri. BS. Nzmjunda R30
Occ: SDE OCB
O10. Lfiivisionzfxi Engineer Intezmal _
Telephone Exchange Building
B<:IEa:'y
Sit Subramanya
Aged 47 years
S/0. Puttarao
Occ: SDE OFC Mme. .,
Telephone Exchange B"'e;si.'.dVing. ;
Chickmagalur 'V '
Sri. Ram<3sh2.'M_,K.., years}
S/Q. S1'i.K4e:i1pai{a'h " _
OCC: SD33
O/0. DiV*is0_nErI B'TS'J.I_
MQbi'iéVTS'e:;}i5ces '
Bas--:;1vesh'w:A;i"aV:.:::VgarVM ._ __ --
Ba1ng::i0x<é: --- 5.60079 T'
Smt. SL1jé1t~h21"S . V V.
.$§;gédL.;1b0u{ 543 years
S.hanka'19'--- ----------
A ('}:rci"DGM,_{Admn.} Mobiie Services
" Ann'e;§:3"':~ B'u§¥ii*ing.; Haia:~;ur
an'g:fl:>.§<: G08
vff'§221§}'21 R210
Agcéi A:«;1b<Vt>ut S3 yearss D;/0, Eaie [BE Yogcnzfira R210
Oc<::»S"DE
A I Qfix C'GJ;\/E Tsiccarn Quality EXSI\iU1'2mC€ Cimie:
' ~».}_¥;'Fk>(>n Sa:1:;:h::1* C€zmpEe:~§
'Q31' ?v'I2:in, :$~73'§ Crass;
5"' 8I::><:k, 3;2y2:na.g;i:'
B22:§gai<}:*<3 ~ Séié {E41
14.
E6.'
Sri. Ganapathi Samaga K. 41 years
S/0. Eaie K. L,21x1nénz1ra§;:m2: amagzz
Clcc: SDE {Gr0=ups;)
Kaliizmpur, Prabhu Gzmesh Buikiizig
Szmthe Kaiie, Udupi -
Sri. Janardhana Poojary NI, =:12'}:'<:.:trs
S/0. M. Thimmappa Poojary
Occ: SIDE {Marketing}
O/0. Principal Generalfi/Ianager.---- '
LMangaIore 575 001 A ' 3 '
Sri. Harish MR.,
42 years " V 1
3/0. Sri. V. Réiiézggwatfiy A
Occ: SDEC1' "ran.<?;mi*ssi'<>n' Ins$.a1Ia.:'1:;f:v .
2"' F1005, CM';><».L13m::i.i:ig--?i'."v. " --
LBasaVE:.shW:1ré: C:-igfple
BagiVgaEc>f'e.T'<-«ff_ ' '
S. LBVxhas'1<3r,V4i " 'T
S;'c>.N. Ss:__1Vat;1ju' _ V
Qcgz SDE "Ag_/"£11..
L'Divisio'n'2J.. Engineer i--\;'T--§
% %-vT&E;'r3rc:e, 2"" Fiiiér
., N;:g2;:;Tje_}eph0ne Exchange
' _ , B;'mga.ip1'=e 4.
A .__Sri. B,G'."Siaixganieshwariah, 46 yizarss
Sfcvfiri. B13. Guruvaiah
Q::'L:; ?'v'1(}bi§f.2 Se1"vi::<:s D53/eicxpmeili
' HQ/<3; Cene1*a1 Mzxnagez' Telccorn
r Bhavzin
2" Fi<3c>rTz;m:1:' 5?: E33}
Sri Urangol A Y
S10 Yellzzppzz
Aged aboui 41 yczzm
Occn:SDE
Pm: road, S:1nkcshw2§r-59 I 3 I 3
Bclgaum District
Sm: A Shyia
D/0 K Aflfiilfhéliilh
Aged about 38 years
O<:<:n:SDE mz1imenan<:e
Shankaraopuram Telcph-Vcne Ex;;hEi1'ragr:
Bull Trample Road
BangaE0reA56()() I 9
Sm: Shsizela 1 _. , .
D/0 R V Mziik » '
Aged z1b0ut*V4(}"-ységrg
om DE Ss.TP*&. NMS
4"' F1(50;',Nc\5v fI'<?:ie:";:ona~ .}3.ii'i-3,;1'i;2g
Banga1s:>1=$;»56()()(}'1 V' '
Srigs "3./1A R£1m€S1"_i£i V ''
$262. S; R 2':/1_ahab:1I'a' {%':.a.~i3«'
' « é':§>i::;_i years
CIc£'nf'S4DE.V'E{T'E7C, T K Layout
. 3*»2;;¢_§m=es;':?::%<i;()i::x\,?:
Sé'=.i.. S ' i*£;.%VL§<§'*:";x';AE121;3;'/221
S;/0 R'«.?\/1£iVi32£1Iapp£1
.' _ Aged'2:§5<}Lt:44}ic21t*s
_ V {)'C¢_n:SDE
VG;':r:?B%1V'is%<:>n::§ E;":gi:":<::'*::' i1':%;e:°::a;i
gawxxwi Eméédizyg
7 P 8 §¥2<}zi:d. D:1v::n;1g:2:*c
%$< §§§2%¥ \ , {
42.
44.
45,
10
Smt' V. Shack:
Aged 9.b0ut 39 years
D/O. fate K. \/ibhakarar:
Occ; SDE
O/o.Chief General manager T<3iec::>m
Kzxmzitaka Circicx N0. L, SV Road
Halasuru, B3ngaIU1'e f56€}{)O8
Smt. Vcena
D/0. N. Shankar _ ~
Occ: SDE, Rajaginzigzxr CSQ BSNL A
N0.}760/E, Opp: NavzirafggVThca.ter{_ ; u
Rajajixlagar Bangalore -» HI)
Sri. RavikVi1*21n:7\z",'lafinu V
37 years . «
2;/0. Vin.ay:fl< R._ff3.;fii£1''~v.. .
Occ: SDE i\/IBM ?;__ H V --
3" FIgx'Of, "T1 e}e§£hc3né7'EXCh'zL§1'ge
P21HCh3;'fi();1{§E1VI§€3%i1""Ti'E'£3R' 'fljxlk--- ._ '
Gadag 5-82 .103 % T
Sri .C_h21:1<iz*af;-321 V 'iiQ;n§:h2i1*.:1d
39.}»;jearsJ.. ~
0:-<:__: 'S[_>-E CFC Outii<':m:'4if MNTC
, €}[(>. DE.T:*afis--missi0n Mntc
'MicE:*:>\%:'21\51e..§i;z;i{m, Sharavathinagar
" ~SVT3i.¥¥E<>é;i'e;:A < '
Sri}-R. §;é:.i<svi'1't'nz:n;z:2ai
44 y::::*:1:s:";.
= :;f<:x__A.K;"Rangam
<}c::::'~«SDE
"',_<>§i::,~AGE\/E TE', ém Fk)<1>§'
'§"::I<3;>£";9:':<: Eixchzizzgaz Rzzjiahzwzm R«:>:::<i
~ 'S2:23g;§:>:*¢ a fiéi} €f}€}1
48.
49.
11
Sri. K. Naajmzdaiah
Ageci awn: £157 yearg
S/9, late Kashipaihaiaiz
Gee: SDE;
02¢. DE Dam, ééh i'7§(}{}i'
Néw Taiecsm Buiiééng .
Basaveshwara Circle 1
Bangaiare 1
Sri. RN. Harish Kama:
Aged aboui 48 years _
Sic}. Lacie F'. Narasimhfi; Murth;3*"" --. .
ace: SDE'. V ; V .. ' '
om. SGM Transmission }_'_f'<::_§€Tc.¥ 7'
43' F1003 Sanchar Cemplex. '
WMS Comg:-m;n&_ ' V'
§'h Ex/Iain,_."£7m
Sm B1eck}a:y'a,nlagé:f b
Bangalorxa 4 4 3;: V»
Sr}, Mebafi M2ii:f1a1*a - -- '
Agéai about 50 3{afa:*S"
S/0.Pra1ha.daC}3afyé1' _
QCCI SDE. ' ' 7
" 4_;;>x¢. :33 umg? DCRM Cempiex Buikiirzg
._ - ii" E;}yQ{>§.',, RMC
' V. _, Cijiirgfigfga
' iZ%3s*'é;na::da Saga:
' Age;fi'f_3'§:;::}::i 45:» gzsarg
4"' SEO; iazt: "P. Ramanujtfizs
<3£::f:: Af:"?C}E, Cabkz ?s>'I:3£{:
* : 4_Ché§2namma:ma§§€re "?fiie§h4;:«:*:e Exchangs
x __ Efiagzzaisye %
T5
66; Sri S B Kopp
S/0 Bhimshezn R210
Aged about 38 years;
O<:cr1:SDE, Niobiie Sewiccs Banding
3" Floor, Tdttphoiic Exchzinge
Gopi Circie, Shi1m1ga~5772€)E
6?'. Sm: Rézkha M Biradar
Dfo Bhimappa Konnavar
Aged about 39 years
0c<:n:SDE, coznmerciai
0/0 Gm Telecom
BSNL Guibarga
68, Sri Abdar Jamadazi _
5;/0 Haji S21h0(_>, _ I
Aged abcut 55.,V}ie:;'f$' _.
Occn:SDEZ iégroqps; " _ b
Af'21:»:a1pur~5 ES 30 £13.; _. V
69. Sri Kimn Bha{t"I?<';V
S/0 MK Bhat' _ V V .
Aged ab'(:;1t'4() years
occn: * V
O/c3;'I)'GM E'v'I:>t:»3i,A<: Sésrvickzs
.V Kmiuri Telqzhorze Exe--h::n'ge
' .2fm'1F¥O€3E'fA,' Kaiisfi £\/Iangaloré:
73. .Sr-i__E\.<'I Srii':iy21e;.iP:'i§sad Raddy
Sig EVI Pu£I'21LARx<:€idy
z1ES<>'L::v ~«%I€} yezars
_ O<:<:n:~~'§DjE
V A.j¢:31_21hafii<:1 Teiephone Exchzmgsi
2 Yciéihzzrzkzz
._8:§:;g2x£<>r¢
1?
1,
16
Sri. Am} G §\5k>kh21s;E1i
sfo G(:windra<'> M<>khas;hi
Aged about 53 years
o<:cn:SDE gmups
0,30 DE Ruiz}, TeVIeph0ne: Exxhangé:
APMC Gun}? G21ng;wz1ti1i~583227
Kappa} Dis1iris::i
Smi. Radha SL1brz1n1anya
Die A V Ramchandra
Aged about 49 years "
occn: SDE (BLtsi11<:s$ D<3\:'eI<>p131eni}".,V
3"" FE001', Sanchar C<>mV;::»'u>x A
\'\-"i\/IS Compoud, 47$ Cxxgsgf' _ '
9m Main,5'hB10ck T '
Jayanagar, Banga1(>1'e«56€}(}='H
Sm: Vidya Dégyi
D50 Sri H2{rik1"iS--hr.iéi'VL V_ V V
Aged ab£)Ll["~39"f;'€. 'S
Occn':VSI§E"CL::st(}mE=:r"Sémiée Cefifiréf' "
Telephonc: - % W
Udupi ' "
Sn1tVecmi"Méu;igi;'i--. _
Dig} Hzznu1na11'thz; R30 Nialdgiri
;_ab0u.t 40 yéiiilfi -------- ~ "
A ' ;(T')C(;1'!2~SD'E_ A'
'I LN
_ " Shz1n§<mf2ip,iir:;1i'1'--TcIeph0ne
" _ VE.xcE1éi:2g':3.,_}5§.:V§§*Tc:1npE@ R{)E}(i
'§3anga1Qr::~ I._ 7
Sri }**:::%§E; V P
A .;~;{<>. Péii} P B
-- _ V,_Ag$:d2:b<>L1i5E :\;'é5:iiFS
{§::iia:SDE ()L::d<;o:'
Q/<3 DE E~?;::::E, Tcicgahzms Ei><:<:h2::°:§;:c:
CBS (E:;:::§, Gzmg/2::E2§~S§%322?
K:>§_>pz:I E}:s1:'%£§
81.
83.
84.
18
Sri. C. I3211;1kri:;hn21, 41 jgcars
S10. lane Sri KP. Nair
Occ: SDE. C}f0.DE LNMS
Did CMX Bulidng
Near BéiSa\~"%3ShW2if£1 Circle
Bangaiore -- 560 001
Sri. KS. Ravindra Kumzzr
Aged about 40 years;
3/'0.E<..'\/'. Shinivaszzchar'
occz SDE DTC.
Telephone Exchange
Pimo Road
Hubli -- 580 020
Sri. NEK. Anandzxkao .
Aged about 5()..y'c:é:z;1f$'_'. V.
sf0.N.S. Krishna E\5'Eur_§hy% V. V
OCCZ SDE & 13;.Ci'tj§-..TcIe;j*h_<5i1e_ Ex:€hban.g'c3
SR, Nagar ' ~ A'
Baflgakfié35Q{B7"?"
Sri. Gzijendra K:in1af"MfK,.
Aged about 38 yams '
s,/<>. Krushnéimurihy "
Ocgj: SDE _ V
O;'bf:~DE I i'?iI1Sm§ s'.4;i(21:~M:Vce
A f.?"" 'f7?{)( )iT;; T€icphc>ne Exchange
"g/\éf3{),k§{'v.R.{J£}{i',iriifflkiil'
Ag<:d'~:;h€f>:.:1§ 40 years
V us/'};>_f B. C§angya Naik
Oc::3':gSDE
' "'VS:)§:>'.'ADET Qpzicsal E:'i%>c:' PI"{}jCC§
biazzzfbzgé, T:3E:*:ph:3:1c £Ex<:h:«;mg:3 Saséiaiing
*2mF%m;Mwwm4§flRH§
wx' :f§€'2«
E ()0,
EOE.
22
Sri. Jaxjgaraxnzi MS.
Aged about 47 Years
S/0. M. Subba R210
062:2: SDE
O/0. Divisional Engineer City Outdoor
0/0. E 10/8, Krishna C0mp1c><:
Lzilbagh Road
Bangaiore » 560 027
Sri.Krishn21 Kumar P.\f.
Aged about 37 years
5/0.\!'enka{aran1ana Bha: P,'
Occ: SDE RTTC V'
T.K. Layout
Mysore 560 009 _
Smt. Yashc)d;13_V. Iéifiakzzti
Aged abe:>u%' b _
D30. \'i:~upai<.sjI1':=:{:§:::; Inakari .. ' V
Occ: --Stéi.io'1-*.
Sharaismhi '
Shimogs; Q '
Smt. Gayathri M, VSh.arfz<3a
Aggjii 'zibout y<:f::sV_ V
Cl,-.'.'Q[ '13.t;z.=:L T. S. N2zteiVrz:jV:m. *
A '£}€§<,;»; SEE
V'V\7$/'Grki"n.g, ":% Cg>i1:.:ne1'cia1 Officszr East: ii
. €}?_(_,> 1&4 z1:?.iigé:' Easi
8(} ft. VR0z1'<i;f_En€i:ra:1aga:-
Téi-eph.g)'r1£:-E'Xchange Buildizgg
3"? F%~r>e;>rj, HAL 2" Sage:
V A. B»a:ng3E'e:}re # 8
109.
II
1.
24
Smt. Anita S. Paiié
(forznerly Aniia G. Gore)
aged about 41 years
Dfo. Surcndra S. Paiél
QCC: SDE Commerciai
O/0. Teiecom District i'v'Iam:ger ~-
BSNL, Near Nehru Stadium
Bihar«S85 41)!
Sri. Szuigzlznexll B. MuEim2mi
Aged ahoui 39 years
S/0. Basavantappa _
occ: SDE, O/0. Gcznexai
Belguam 590 001 ~ }
Srifihamraj Athadkar --
Aged about 47
S/O. CR. A'th2i:1ka1--,%f
Occ: SIDE} '
Q/O. V _
3" Fifjor, C?"fQmp1€x. "
WMS:VvC<>:11*p<)Li:i:L"47'~'? ._ '
9"' Main, Jayanagzir
Banga!o1'eS6O ()4! 'V
Sm; R2zjé'sh_\§/2.1*i
Agéfd 2'_.b_0LH: 35 years' ****
'd[0. Sh£v¢a1i4fi'gaLp21
'=Q¢;SDE,AxE40§MsU
" _ i'}'E'i:g;~v}"1'Eé3':§§8.If Egichzazzgc Bu Eiding
5 ">3
E'./}anuv2mz1',L' Eiingalore ~ 44)
Sri, B Krishaziz
V n Aged zibaut <18 years;
.5,/<>I"_8f\:' ; Raighzwzm
LQaiSDE
§{);'<>. DE. 1 2:§/21232232212' ffiuidwr
" }2i}'E1iE;2g;'1I', Bzm§;::1<>§<:
A V-'7Fe.I é<:.o1*n-. _
»»§,\
M9.
E21.
26
Sri. S. P. Nzxgeslz
Aged about 39 }j'€2i},'S
Sfo. Papachar
OCCZ SIDE OCB TAX
2" Fioor, Teiszphcmc Exchzmgc
Opp. Kzilamamiir ._
Mzmdya
Sri. Suresh MC.
Aged about 38 years
S/0, Chzznnainlallappzi
Occ: SDE _
C!/'0. 13.13, C-DOT Excm"ng.¢
Ashoka Road, ~ -
Tumkur 572 I0}
Sri. Nzxraxinlha.M1,;1't'I1y SB. 1.
Aged ab0uiye§1i's._V " "L
S/0,Bacha1€ma b
Dec: SDE ;1;.:~ , V '- "
O/0. D}E: S'U--1;);i1fb2lfi;'3iVfiStélflQUQFII V
3"dF1&,=_m~, EKTCC--:.Bgiiaing%'_ _ '
KG. Rbad,..B2ir1gaI0{¢¢~5'3«.. "-...
Sri. i\_/I.L. Kymhéa Sctgy
Aggjd :1b:)ut: 40
SfQ_."Li:j:ga Setty ****
A 'QCC. SEE; Exiarnall
L 'Fé}E:Vph'c>:}<é' E'X::h:mg<: Udayagiri
" ._B'21}gaI'<'::é' u " "
Sti';'-.Su{iiizii<.f/E C. Gour
Aged ~:i:bi:;_*1£ 3?' yeam
= A§¥<3_. Ch'2:r1d1'21shck:3:' Gout'
{)<:C'; .SDE, §'¥'i(}bi},€*» Swizchiizg C€:r:Ez*€:
'_.?;""'§ E'£<><>:*, Te§<--:+phi::n€ Eixchzmgc Buiésciinfg
i?im<.: R<:>2=v:%, Hubii -- 583 {E26
> 1"; 3:v§r:/:;<?:x:;.
48
Apex Court has held than if the promotion of an c111p§{:},I§i'c:
delayed be<::1u:~;<: of the pendcncy of the Court pr(><:ecdi:':g_i$, hc.sVh'a1A1* '
be entitied to :1 e:icen1ec£ data: of p:'(>:'ho€i{>:'1« .;§E2;2 "e¥_a;§c'Ci'
promotion of their wumcr parts. In the pr<.:__sé'nt ca1se.'ihc"Tribu--a;;1§--.V '
has dire<:{<:d {ha pctiiioncrs to grant'c_Qf1é;eqL1en{i;1¥V':3:1€;fi£S;stiCh as
counting of experience 1'<):'..:hc: pu:*pa.& ér Oi'?'promotions; annual
iricremcxns. etc, with effect 1'r'0Vn;_1' 2ZS.L-1, ?.C3()2_, f'i=.h'as c1arified that the
respondents: are ng)t e 'ni.i,_tied§_'t<> a;.i1j€:a:*s;..Qf*'pé;;y from the date of
such notianal t§;1t"'\_Niil be entitled for arrears of pay frQm..._Igi}2;C()§§5iafs,_tha: O_._}?\. oniy an 2.4.2009. We are of t11<:V..Vic3w' VLhai'{bi€..5ai:ib d1<:i_é'r--.d'u+2is not call for interference. _E-7- In thé r:_esu!.:.j' W1" 1Vt pétitions; fail and they are: accordingiy . xii/sm'ivsséd;A'"Nc>"costs. """
S§§% EEEEGE 3%/4 EESEEQE