Shankrappa vs The State Of Karnataka on 4 February, 2009

[Cites 2, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

Shankrappa vs The State Of Karnataka on 4 February, 2009

Bench: V.Jagannathan

C,rI.A.28 3, of 2005 m THE} man COURT 0;'? KARNATAKA CIRCUFZ' BENCH AT QHARWAD DATED '1'HiS THE 4% my 01?' i%E3§p;aRY. £009' BEFORE THE HON'BLE MR.JUs+TIc§:~~3g*..§At;ANNA};j;~1M"

CRIMINAL ZtE?PEA;I§"'I§6;--:*2:8§ii_fQ0O5 BETWEEN:

Shankaxappa,       = :
8/0 Benakappa,vCl:ii}ai,.V I    ' 
Age: 52 years,   b      
Occ: S,D.A. in..T3.h%5i1da1' (';}£ﬁ(*.t~;,.  
Na13g11nd;"R/ j9a3'7  '*"i1'£1ii--,.>   

Tq: NaI%§gu13d, "v.*~V     _ _'

Bist: Gadag.' ' _    " _. ...App€1L:--mt

{By Sri. M.';?;«Shcslﬁva%1t, for Sharanappa Mattur, Adv.) ' Bf; Lekayukta Pgilice, DhagWad,. . " ' ..,Resp01::éent ' ».,(By Sri: gjagadish Patti, Advocate) _ ~"I'}:1,is criminal appea} is ﬁhéd uﬁder Secﬁon 3'?'4 Cr.P.C. " by: the advocate for the appeilantf accused against the , -juégment {ﬁat-mi 25.1.2005 passed by the District 8a Sessions Jucige, Gradag in Sp1.[SVC) CC No.2/O3 convicting {ha a1.)pc11a:1t~a<:cused far the offence yunishablr: under Secﬁcms 7' and 13(I)(<:i) read with Section 13(2) ef the Prevention of Crl.A.281 of 2005 :2: Cerxupﬁon Act, 3988 and sentencing him to u11d::rgQvSg§;«._£_f<.nj 7 months anci to pay a ﬁnd of Rs.3,()O()/- and etc.,_....._ L- This peﬁﬁon coming on for hearm g this made the following:

GREEK) '§'he appellant is agg'1'evc,ei h$s._d{>nvictisi1 fésﬁcgft of the oﬂence punishable under"Se.§'ti9_n 7 éi11d«V'u1icieﬂif:§S¢ctie3n 13(1)(d) mad with seéﬁgn 113(2) the Pzéveiztiozl of Cﬁrruption Act, 1988 and 'iaonths simple impzisonment z;*.z1d;_V§'s3c oﬁbncc under Section af tr) pay the ﬁne amount to undergo simpicvv of 0113 month and further $<=:::11;c:1:ig{:£é of one siniple imprisonment and to pay ﬁne: of oﬁiance punishable under Section i3(1)(d) Aﬁ:a(i .§¥itﬂ :S.:%;ti;5if11""13(2) of the Act and in cittfaulf to pay the V V' _ ﬁnd "23mo:_1'n"t- undergo simple ixnpriwnznent of two msoathss, " 'A 'T haﬁca ;he has prefanrcd this appeal, ' T116 case of the: prosecution, in brief, is that the " $.i§p€:1iant w}::i1e he was Working as a Seéond Division Assistant in Tahasﬂdafs Oﬂﬁce, Nargund, dcmamied.

%» .1 Cri.A.281 (sf 2005 :8: Rs.2,0{)(}]-- ﬁcm the complainant for changing "

from the name of comp1ainam's wife's bmthc:f__i£1'-.xfesj§cct sy.No.2o2;2 situated at Hadali vma;_;ém¢f're«a:¢g1;nc1 'ai:g ﬁnally agreed to receive Rs.},.,'Z'O0/AC:)'n 3O..0 '§'fA.2t3Q2,'V accused acccptcd Rs.1,700/-- aiacibout v.1;{}f). ythc compiainant. A 'map was successful. Bcfom the 4' the usual proccdmc was; Went to the as pct Ex. 13.12 and was conducted anti, witnesses and the *;rap cﬁcials, ccm1§hai:ié.1;i:'*9vcz££."'tc the place of the accused and thcv_»'i§';ci:{§é:nt in from of the hotel of D.W.2. On ccﬁ1p1ct;i_cn "ﬂit investigation, charge sheet was submitted Thc accused denied charge levelled against him and V"--V'_L"%1c '§rcscc11ticn, in order to cstabiish its case, examined P iW.1 to RW. 13 and 18 documents were markcd. £3 the pmsecuﬁon evidence, accused statement was recorded. and thc accused denied the case: of the prosccuﬁcn by examining Cr1.A.281 cf 2005 :4: D.\V.1 and I).W'.2 and himself as D.W.3. The defetlee' V. accused was that the amount was forcibly L"

pocket and as such he did not aét_ the bribe ammmt.

4. The learned l"'t}:._1e on appreciating the evidence' the conclusion that the proseeutlozt guilt of the accused the defects in the investiga--*.ien_ }the evidence placed by the enough to disbelieve the prosecutioiia ease.' the learned Trial Judge _ eonv§;ted~i:he aecused aud sentenced him as afoxesajd, the argument addressed by the learned v_ eo2iif;sel»--._" M.V.Shee1van1; for Sharanappa mattm", "for the appellant and the learned counsel Shri Patll, appearing for the Lokayukta and I have ...perlJ.sed the entire material on reeerel.

% . ;

'lfk :3. '§"'h§: Esamsﬁi C{§i§.Z}S€i'§ Shzé ¥'}§§'§,$E;::*$}a%?:a§:": §€;;.-ﬁzz:

8§3§}€§£iE}¥I 15:11? §Gi"§¥"&}."{§ {mgr maﬁa gyazmés ii} 3::§;::m.§:é %;i.§'a:-$1 guzigzﬁani 0%' iéiiz izfiaé <.'.<;é_:::"%:. €;;1::':::3{ Ex: *::§}.§:2&.§s:i ii: :;:::V{%~--T mzigi gm umirs ihaéi, §'§.";§?: Séiizﬁfiiﬁiﬁ, iZ;?TFZ'{i%f:'3_'_ is %g:'§*£_i;3f£s§.i2;{tif:3::se the ;3€:%:*s@m xzzfm} iéag Séigﬁﬁii {Ezra 5a1:3s£r1:3L{:,{::? ~r3.z"&3e2"_, ,:f1€}é..V":};;é?1.T_' camggaiezzé a.:2E§:a:'i%;§: in Lbs 3€:1':§3E:,"*-7:36: *.,r.;-ﬁg {mt E'§:':%: :»%§:>§;{[:;i:;f.;%§1g azﬁhezity in mspsci 0%' iihﬁ aatqtzgaszfi-.§31:r?Z,._ 3:; '$:'i:xé_ etimi" Elazxii, {ha ﬁzmciéemizzg aa2=§.'*m'::ii;qis . {}::s-gmigq Czxmmissiaaer. '°E'1f1€ref0r€3 the s;5rj; $aE}C3§i_Q'!}, ':i1{'f<f0,'£'{i€("§' 'E3 Eiiggéi 232:1 as {hit §e§§3t§; CamméS$iQ;f;* ":9 h3g3 ;i%VQ""a:1*§;%1§.§i%:;~§~:;= accssré s;z:m<::%;§o:;§ the »3am::'£3;f:é:?;'s.~A Tg<:;%L'gi€:"" *g%%:3e.i§i'- 2:::%(§""'§_::ém.»ssi.. '?%":s::*€f<:>r€:, Eéizs zgusgtimg éraf £35 Eéegttéara §;€3{:%}{a,} aims :29: azégs *£;£{':as..1S€, ﬁg: 1336: viI);s§:%zJ;é§%.._ £;'.2:§$§*--; ass $35 }:§€i§*:;:'i§? {ﬁ@ﬂ'*.a:3;z.é:-:«;$%<':»§:;§.~":1'

- . haci :;3:¥;} aiifézerézgé '*i":sf>V____;aTa:%»<_":€3:':i $a;=:2c%,§.:::::; £iS his was gm: $5:

1uagtsgaizﬁimvg'm::%:?£ié;a:{f3Z€y, {E196 éﬁféct ii: ﬁzz"; Saggiéiiszz crisis? is i.'ai:s:}. is '%}:£@.,.§}§:é$é{:¥.%§§§§i1f £73.36; Ex Ehiﬁ mgaﬁé, ha rﬁrferrsrd {ea $3.15 . avidéﬁaa <21? 12.

, H "Q23 ﬂax? greﬁzzé; zgrgzéé £3 {ﬂat Z335 *§;»-'aﬁ: <3? céxazzggézzgl V' zzazzm in '$316 khaihsg, :§*a$ ngﬁ 'aim §5§'{"3§'k a::%.*:z.f§$€i.§:€¥;. :9 %;'§:.:€ '.&£§?f€3Ei3€3{§ ami this is §:s;'€a§;:.§i$§"::::{§. {ram} the £3"%3'§§%i'.'§§{'3§': {sf ihzz: §E°{?E~§€{T'E,'§f3§{3§}: Wﬁﬁlﬁﬁﬁﬁﬁ .:«m:§. f,'-'iféiié. iéiw. aiasrzsmstifats §f{:1{§;1§€?€{§ §}}3' $.23? §}§'{}*--;'§{f{.'EE§§{§E§, £:(s:':§'§§'::';$ ﬁzég fzzsﬂk 'E"h5§°z::§{}§*€g whazs. {E36 Lb '.n és sa{é{r;':$r:<2'; was :13: e::21fi:"'2.2S'ét:<§ éﬁséiés '£215: :'£'é:"f&§_§}'{}ﬂS§4}§3§'§}«' €12? <>%;a;;:g;_i.%::g mt {game in the ézhaiéza bag 9:; Eh: {}%:§7z,:~:t,r; haégﬁgéi was $12: w-srE<: :33' the Revenue Egsgmcigr, '£316 :;:.2=*.-":ss3?i:~:.-.:"s'_«' "§Z:'}*?: ' ;9i€;'€'é.ES6{§. damanﬁizzg 335%; aarcegiing Elm §:>§*iE:~seM §;ﬁgQ1:j:t%.%:I'~ §0(i§"' €204: arias.

8" '}'.'}::€ éhéré; grmmii urggsié by aha aigggjﬁiéarzi is {km {.116 {rap V:{":::*§;'2:;Vz%}:: 21% tiaat piacs *;x;%;<::":=: €216 érzage 'fgééaezféév mg, £1': €533}? {if "EETEQ §'i@'§3*":§ af %ai§;,;.?;, i_'f§m'z.é, €236 'limp ;3:a§1c'1':.a:1am.a 12%;':-« 'séirawm Ea? oﬁ§€:s::9'_}:2_f Ehkjsé '§'ahasﬁda§ 933$, ihﬂfﬁfﬁifvsi, 3}} is AVI.: €Té'§V" *§§;«'?c}3, w§f;;l?§'.?§:s::. iyvsgtigaiioza {Ef {E16 (33%: Q. T}i§<;3L«.§3§§£:2:t dG:i?§Ei!i§§i zsrgeii 323 1:13:31; €335 i:3s:ﬁ§;%;%g:2:§é;:.g .. _agm::{:;;{: E135 zmi §{E+:_z:1§____ 3:131: izzveséigaéian in 8; fair mamfzéir r_?m--"A*:{::a%§.$€ ;:#*.A1':A:Q%2s4vA:§3?:s:'::"_i:3r:<'<e £316 aemgiaini W33 iescigad on 3§.'?12Q€}'2 53;} {Em §322m:has Eaaii been arragigaé am; '£226 _$21p€z§¢;* »f}ﬁi<;::é:'S cf {he };)8I3Ch3S gym? éﬁfwmeé wsﬁ €33; '~a;{§xza:i;;:s {is Sam: the pancizas. in aééééiszz is éhéaa $15 " Tgﬁiséégzcé can Eﬁarard zgiso désciaseg that the E;Qka;m%«:'£".a pzyéim '€§.'%'.€..§-'ii. and mag '$15 acmzsezi ﬂﬁffﬁiﬁ bafem 33¢ {mg was €:r.0:1.éu{rt::é 3316; {E33 alga gitzss rigs tca é0iE%r§ ms §§3§i"f£§SS 0?' '{;*}§: :§_§2ve:=:s'£éga%iz3m.

% _ J

-ma 3%?» ﬁﬁﬁthﬁf {ia'fe<:'{. p<37::ﬁr€:(§ eat éiﬁ :*:tg;5;r{§s "%,E:@ .§:1ves*§J:igaf:ie:2. ?:;~€i:1g 310:: :?."air is that {he c%z§'i::; 9:' séEipf$..."%i\§_1':22'§.§;?;§z%V" 3 fmsm-';<i 2;.i'{ae:t§:':&é £0 E'v§.{}~sg} ta £4 W635': ai'iac§1e{i""ig; 133:. §§s::%é§.-- §vE.€)sy in $215 '§'9£aasi1{1ar's sfficsi" «_ 1--::«st.y %Jéi",::*:1.=.V "'f:J%2c=: ﬁmtmstﬂgaaf maézazai" was «c{3z1éj:.:{:¥;€:{§a};__ ha§é<:_§,$ {:25 " mid EQ §¥€:E'€ 113% §1¥2?.S§'§E{§, R3f:t§;;r;E%:i::Fg;§'*.7{{> 1'3:3:e*~i~;$_%§'aéf$€ff¥§i:1%§E1€ izzvegéigatéan 321$ the 21dvm;:ssi0;:gV-;;;@§é§€ ﬁgﬁihe €$é*i"'?Lﬁ€ag::e$, if: £3 C{),'¥}§*3§}d€d that ma i*:1ves:{'37;gf%;ﬁz§§g;L._é'§gén%fg~" :$c%§3$§1<)z%;' *Wan"§.:t::E ii") émvpliaéata £116 accféiﬁgtﬁ " éf the aiéegeri aﬁsnce, 11!; it 'is' that ma 125:}? Comﬁiaimani E3§1;rme}f has 30% ':§%_;§:g"x3:§f§{éi'd 313515 pmssﬁcuzimg {;:a,s{-E azizd _. _ m0§€$:i:i{$r,"*§%:z$ paimhgs, iheir ﬁvégisnitﬁ, Rave :26": Si'.{){§{§ ':23; what _V '§:1s'};j *,Ei::t\#6 Sigma in {E15 e:~:amé:':.a§§0.::~§;2m£§:§$'§", '"§"h€:'::*.ib:*$'; 'fizzg ézéfiééazzcé of '$335 pazxzshag aésa WEE}: 31$? 3% :3? _ muCZ%'§u3§:' m*:'§ée §}E'B--;'i%§'CE§.§iQ1'i 3:: §§."§?{}§?'{i £53 ('£238. " Eésfarriizgg is *?z:Ei:z.:~: iiﬁfaazscts ﬁ¥§ﬁ§ﬂCﬁ, ﬂag ésamaé "' c§:;na@i for '£536 apgaﬁazzi aygusﬁ ihaf. ﬁgs aitcusssi has péaeteé ".'¥;h€ €'ii§"§EEE{i'»'3 of BEJJS. }; mad 1% agar': from €.xami:m732g .%:.im$5i§ as §3§éf,3 azzé {kw Ema §.e?§s::c& msiésncﬁ has :30: mag; {§.31S€:'§{§§te{i sir: Su75s€§zQ<::s:: as {2(}u};5; Em 86:31 fmm {she :%m$s~ 2°» 'm $xa1n3Ln,atia::n sf ihﬁgit wiizzﬁgseg zméiﬁ ﬂ'mr€:f<:=2"€, £316 d5;f'{s_:%':vf,fc hag agiabézéxigaé €§};£%E' $23.3 hriérgs azzzsmgzféz "W38 farcibigy-gi:§é;" 'ms §€}tfjf§{€? 0%' the &€3{'i'£iS'sﬁ=L§.w $3 such, 2:3.$k3L:2,g '_E§i;§";§::c"t€_:$§€f;% ti; * --. '2:€m€>:se téza bribe amomﬁ from his ';g:f;o<:k&_§ §;«,uf1€§«_t.3£§€§é__V§§F3:%§§§:§Vg the ixagzég sf ihes a{E{?"§}S€i£§. W133 {mt 'E.-?1fi".':§_E1fy" '2«'iZ€-£3 'iieig '-fi:?3;t":A V pr0$c:::1:'{io:1 :0 prava is case 'b§§?{$':;§§"~:a}§T magénabﬁfz <§?';";ub§.,

13. in guppert cf ja_3gb4«;:jis%.;b33f%.:;§:§;$§Si>:;§I1s, {ha 163211661 <:<:s*:.1a$e1 fax' {ha a;3.§}a}la1§,t'* the 6:€<:i$i0.1;3$ mpm-ted in A.:_§?..':1§§é;%:?+' '§a::::';:&5é;.s§;"VA_{9;§€3é4--$5 :'.?28, mg 1993;

SC 2178 336:}; '.2;{;{::%é:ég:;g}'"§=:§:{f§".9.$'§;A"' Egfeféming is me 23%? laéié (iasxn 1 _=;zz:.é{::3, the }f3€:i§("'i1€§; COuI3.$f:§ argusé "%,'§9as E33 army $2.3. csorzazictézag $316 ac$u.Se%::%--. anﬁ 'ssgltéméiaig kiim B1111, 911 £333 ﬁihfif' Efzzmai, ﬁzhs ':::vAi{££:§2éﬁa;--."L'f£2.E4:"'::: en "*i}ié« §?§:}-.$§n€-3 aughi ta hsava }é:::E 35$ izizaaé e;:07£1;>f§ V %<}_ 'c.§;:tz:'%:f;é_ ﬁts hsﬂeﬁ: 9% deazbi ta} {£13 accusérﬁ, §§s:::a<:s5 mt Eiéyneé' é;t§:2_£:zi:$e§ pmjgeé far aiégzaséaag ibis agpgai 35$ 35% Vzgsiaéa iéy: 33'azé.gme::1§ af this Sig} smart, " €31: She {sfiémr Exazzii, 35$:-11e{3; cmmsei Shgi Jagadiﬁh M V. far {E36 iaiiayzzkta itotztezzéad that 'aha }u{§g.m<:'::1§ 9%" iiﬁe trig? gang? §}fi".if:€§i$ ma mierfﬁrszncs hazsausey iiigﬁ var}-? §.E1i.':-§§§:{":'§}'§. iiseif has ham}. a&m§;§.i€d '§:>§I ﬁns ;«>.:7<*:u;<3eé., wizszz 'mas €iXa};{:i':T3.E3{'§, '})~ K I as §;}.'%§£,,3. Sfi€'.f(}f£§€ﬁf§", '£316 €§%§§3E{:1§;:{§ {::2>:{ﬁE£: §::y E3123 z»a~.:%{r%;:§;$<:i"é3:;[:.:§ {Em aitzéﬁgéiazzaﬁ 9f gzmiiﬁcaiism h}? EEK: a{:°{':t:$s7:{§ .%;;..:é:.:' T' §3I'{}'%3"€€§ iiamugih €226 Eagiimazgjg cf the gamﬁé z>s2?::na§3§§$,. '§'.,1»§'i3 azgd E9 a§::8£i: éfmm €316 svédenssa 0%' 315.3' §)¥r;'f;i:":s3 a'§i€%;ﬁi;* $:;,i 'I;£'2--é:*£ is no gseié raassszz far 133': actting 03:; ?.§1:i:Z'V€i'§u~'?a1§A:ﬁI;3_(,f€ s;T¥,'f 'i1§;.::.:

zaiﬁcﬁr and cgnviztzizzg $.16 acagisvgjé a%1é.__ '§'%.;:°t;{r;.z:7:';,"".m:::i4€};§ be€3*:zs$ aha <?em§§ai:x:a::f£.di€§ 313% _§=:1§'3'g;;a§::rt t}:i€:*g;1*Q:;§:{:z:ti{>'::

case, magi. iisaif iiammé 'g:sf*f<:;.2»:::A:'<%__ ta :'€j$<:¥ €115: Esgtémsny af {£36 'p3:.:%%i<;f6 §ﬁ3;é€érs», ;>Qm1s&§'f<33* iéaau 2é;3§};::_11§g3;:§«:3;i'::__§t:fa_:1§"€:r§22é, 3% is €£§'g"éZ€§T3 "§E::.a'§. iihéi saaéé d;§f3cii;a.:,_a:::'£: 30: §é;§;1%'1'ié ﬁzz: §1*o3::cuE.iea1 €.'t%"%fr3€ 30 'bag as iihgzs: eé%:%.{£t:n{:é' sééiaﬁiighitag the fact <3? éﬁmaﬂii. $1:-«E 'lzacﬁélgééazigzzii: ($17. 231% améééizzi hf; 'ﬂag accugaai, Siaca E315 E1a::;.<§ xﬁizagh eff ae5:€:1;$3é Eﬁﬁiﬁﬂ ggsiféais sand as éha axrammi; was r€C{)'a{;:::*a:%;V.;'f2:Q"zg;1'Ti1%$ §<::{':§«:<%:*:.3 naﬁzigzg mam is E'€§§Ei§}:'E5L an 'p33? of ;:ihf :'§3I'ﬁ$6€"i}$}'.0§i "G3 aﬁtabﬁgh its case smii, as susgrﬁ {East jzzégﬁ sf 131$ trig} £36133"? mas IT§§§"§§3£:a" acgregisé trims " "gm-sastziieii szsiéezzcﬁ 3": Cﬁfiﬁﬁiffiﬂg ﬁgs 3'-zgcuseé azzéé aanésncizzg iximy £3/~/' .9 ii} 36k As; fa}: 233 $36 sa:.:£:'ii0§: <:§{ie::'::* is :":,:m<?€:*:2{::.§,,.._ {E}? s1:bmi$Sim.: mafia is '€§::a'£, 331$ S£a}1{'f{"iOf§i3Eg :<:m:':30z"§§§»%?':%.:§_ii§--._g<} ﬁzrgngh the r:i<3<:.:2.:m33.:£s giacéé befars 22<:<r<3:'{§.;LT;2g s.:a§1::té&i:: :éa§?::£v +- 5961: etu%€:z"<,%:i§;z:§ hf; 'J§§'E'ﬁE af Seq:-:'E;%(:éz: §;'_+3;.{3§{<?} 'iﬁéz-3 ".¥<{_'gZi:3;@€f,' .:'1{; ésfeiéi can E35 §0u11{i in the S337:c:'§é<§n 1;:;x{§§§':'.T .. "if: *31_:§i:3§<3{}§": abagze Szﬁamisgiensg ﬁgs §{ié3.{'I1f"i{i'<.ej_3'v{,",:'i1."{}%'t"..§.'§'.."J"'={V' ig3T§$.§%1§i§<€§: piacsd 3533131122 {£1 1:115: {§:::cisi0L§9zs..,:':::p{>:*is't§ ._ ';%£}Q1 Kamazagm 3535, 3995g:§;:A..._ 3';:{: 1{é3$.§:;.<_2_${;:*;: 3:19 :;:;~;.} 238 £§.f}.£i submiiteé aha? me §g;§éff€:'{%_i2{js for 331$ "Eh: a§3§€3} £26 125' in €:A§:§sTvL§igh€A3V€;f :Ijé'~«Q§n:$nﬁ0n3 urgeé by '$316 éﬁaznséd €C?{}'{,E}.13€§ far' abs éiggjgjsfg-§i2r'::'§'~ ﬁiﬁl 3I*gm:3€33€$ a,éé3:€3sz;=:e:§ ii} <:0'sir},"£¢:',i%1a sé;éJ:1 e iétéﬂztd 091111361 far ¥,£:i<a§Iu}e<:':21 312$ '":';£xE{§i;g" iggfg n3;ca?{311::€""tE1e ziecisiztms {*ié:&:'£, €335 pain? .f<2:" "*:L:0i1s,i£i::ré§£a;:s?1; *é;'§f:€'%:§1€;" {he gyzwaecuiian ca}; Em gaié "ass; E33226 grétsgé i"§.3_§:é;*«:§:; ésyand 33} masgzgaicris ::'ia3'a:'ai so :33 :3 susiaim 'Vfgha }:2&g'm%$;_:1i af c0§wi<':f,iQ.;3 and $€i:Eii::*§£?€ §=ass$::i by {Sim %".r§.aE_ ~. 3 ' '£8, E: ﬁg "£33 zsyscéﬁg sass {:5 ﬁrm aéampiaizzaxzf. as pm" aim ' f<::i>m§:.¥;<:'a§3;;%i §§X.P~ 12 'éiai. Em apymaghsd {ha asczzssgi, '$15 was aézsriéizsg as; Ssirezmd ﬁivigign xiasisfmzi in €116 'E'a3m$é§{§;:2:*'$ ﬁt» .3 affzca, ﬁmaguﬁdg azzii zagmesis;-=::§. Erma $0 changa ms i<.§7:.a.i§i:z2 {mm $3533 game 0?' {E16 <:em§33aj1i:«.2zi:'t'$ w§§@'$ bmiher 37:': r€;fs;;§é2"<::'£. Qf Sﬁéa. 203;' 2 3133 it is in this cezmection that A' is Saki '£0 igava tiemandeé Rs.2,08Q/~ as Tharafmas, it is zxzecésgarjss 8!}. ms: 195.15% 0%"é:E':$'«.§3Iziss.f;¢'z:':i<;:::'1:0 EH31 esfabiish $113': 211$ wark: Whisk éarfmpiaiigfeggiiv 's3".?£ivI'2.'f€.{'§ 'V :9 get (19:16 was the s>s:::;:"k azztrézizgfszd £0 "¥f;?§é acéuséié. siiir, in whey Wmés, it is %:§::;;e :,szm"3.é; afi },1'é"az<ijr;:§;$e.;;§. F§§1iif"'§R7'§'§?1€SSﬁS! '9;?}"1{2% %:a.v£i': been examinasd; '%2'3;iS.m:g3;rér_é{im:*?.§:'JS. 1 aﬂd E9 P,V.Ai;}?j §"~'~12b§:;_3.s}13 S5§.'},éif":$§'§§3.{i:'%E;; cf Naragjimci T ahasi1dar's {_z§€:£:;'L'_':., Ems 3'zt.9;f£::i Eh:-'F2 $3.6 accused was w€.:s1'T§<in iizizégzg Magxtﬁ' ;?;€}€.}';% Eﬁiviaieﬁ 2'is3is#:a:§fé and E15 $'?é§E§ szxirusisé §:h1'a: 7;§7V{;.r§{'--.i:fVE;én{% Tzihmzai maéicrs ami tamgis: m3€€€:_:t§':i;«:. £3V__ﬁ:r§:érvv:§.§§;'s$e§ is £33; him that Eha aiufy sf €335 "g_2"«:ce:,}:z;::é:¢aé ,§,<?::~;.;s'«.§97'w>§'11:°:3#;s§;: thﬁ ca:)§zies 9? {he Lané 'F'yiE'}':_::33};"s ﬁr<i.e1:':'~_:g as? "_§2:='$3E;;"§as {Em R.'§'.*I3; cggias, E3: the {rmgw .€Xam§:a.ﬁ§ﬁ,"§,§£?.§ has siaiefi éhai ﬁg; msgsci af »;%E'2.:«3:§1ge 3%' .§V;T§;3£j_%33, "izgé. §I'QC€€3§Z2§'E 313 {ha éha agyiﬁeaﬁan fzmi gem ':0 '£".:¥3;ﬁ " ,T22§§§;z:EA"$ec:ic;21 arm 'iihﬁﬁ E0 $2.3 Rﬁveggﬁ Ezzggmaior E335" game V E3Q:é1maz3;:13.z;ara 313$; ﬁzmiijg, ":9 {Egg "§"aha$27§cia:* angi 231$ £-%;'é'§:1€$ss has Stated s§»e€éﬁCa§'j; mat {Egg fiiﬁ never gas in §§:*;€ ::':i.{fC'%,1S*5',(§y > ,2 2'2 iii; §'.'5§¥}2 §"mc£st:g3k":.2mar, 2: §'+'§::*3i. §T}*;V';3im,; ;5'§8§I%§S?.E£E}fi zs:erk.i§1§ ii} ?;.he $333' gamﬁ Ta1Z:1as§};<§a:"$ <3ﬁ'%=<;:t& 3%. §€2ar*ag:1.z"2z§, 5330 has {§,€':§§$$€'€§ in séimééar faghéisn émé has a§E_§'a::e{§...%§:-_EE:$ .x4r <:mS§~§Xami:.}a%;i0:1 tééai. the 53:: ;}2::y%;a7:'§3§;;g ti: kE3.at.%;2: ﬁiiiﬁ; the war}: ztmmectcd th€3:$*e.v:1:§:*' «ihc u R2:-2%.;e:n':"£e §nsp:":s::'£m' ané; it is 'i'é7'§{_'{'}.§{§3 i_;'}E§ :E€§'%%}e::--§1:%, ._3;'§3-S'§'3i3{5'Y.§}3""~§';., A' jz,:risdic{.i=::.:: and has aéso giiaiigd Eiaaaiz' hi: , . m§:&.:%A state";/ﬁsni. bafom {ha Qcsiiea that _%§$:~;>:'}: 9£;{s?z$;ﬁg'% kfhzﬁiaa is 1:233 warii sf 'tbs: ac<:as;s:%3;, *~._ Z33. '§'E1€:':2f0z'§, €3.26: §:a:é;:i£?_::{%€ gxf €f§;.:é&éii: é%°i§.m:$s€:%3 {kyﬁi-2 120% mdiésaéﬁ éhsafé a_élé:*.::s§{§, észim was <:';';%;rus'i£é wi%.§'2 {E36 z"€$p{3:zV$;:";§_:§§§%:}=" 932%' §;:§3:':f1§::g Q26 {§;§;::>';zm§§;t. ii} i'€S'§,'%{i£'E. <3? . _ €§}3E}»,§?f: <;§§:'}i:a§"h3" v:<r:;§;" s::gm ii €55; 333$} Ema: €325 .s.:'%;:;z.2%: £'%"af§{.§i€f'.E§{"'€i

5):' ';:,I*:€§s3 :.$3é;'£3§5€*:-'-$55 $332. aha War}: :35' §:ﬁ'€c'%i§2g zﬁiafzgzé 2:32"

§~i:§::§5{§a is __iA':~c§?;"k @§f§"1.§S 3{?§'?Ei£€$I§.. E5 33% actcuamé. 3119?. ma §}{::'&;{}§ ﬁ§i'{;§'1,i§§§f€,§ 2%.:i'£2': {Em . '~;:;€;:'§i'~.,j;a?%;icE1 wag Sﬁughi '£9 be ﬂags ai aha z*$q:2€$*£; 0%" igi:

-- C5'§ﬁ§§&iﬂ331E, *sﬁ;*%r;$'£h.€:° it can ha Said tihai the ::a<*.e;é'a2:~:€:§ cmgéé.

" E':@.:a {§Ei£1}.€i}"i€§{i°{§ g:°a*??a§§ca§"_é:3z; fmm Eh: c»:3:::§§:»7z.éz::§;1'§ ég iézaz :§':}.€$'ié{;z1 $2; E523 cm":$i:§a:"€:§g. Eéézéce; ﬁgs %x;{}:*k af "ihs .:«:7{:2:g§:{§ is 32% im W§:§f €r{}m:€<7:ts§§T zzﬁéiéz {Em azscaﬁt '§;%1§:.%'; 233 $:;:sgE':'f; E23 %:>::i: §,§{:s%?',i:% §"»?* 33 33:: 2'é%q:.iz'f&;';,i:{§ Ex; Ehiié <7::3;::};;.§ai.:;a:;%., 5: eT:}s:é.{:z:s:» £?;2é:§§ ﬁzz: ﬁieégévzt €22: {%€::2z»m'2{§7:::.3g; %:.%zz:: };"}i'}3}€i' m{3:'2§§.,~' L-:at:<:.*§-s:.':;;1g,. ..'_'§".E1.;:.~; §§;§?€:m'-::T3.s::€: cf E::2{:§~: sf' .m:::%.§'% gm £333 E};-Z13"? 6%.' 'aézéi {iaimazziéing 1:215 h:i§f§}{< szmlaazgzﬁ is aési} :%%,:§§_:{s:"j£€'d; "§f:j.; 43%;-*z:'>' "

éimréésiegégg sf 223:3 F295;»: Coaarz.

:23. in 313:: case $1' §ab:;a'g,-;:_;.g gggzggsgg' :r::;. ;}:P{; fﬁgrssféﬁii iii fﬁéié }4'¥}'_i}4 SC 1?:">:38, €52:-'_'MA§::€x {i€;:2.;;€T '§%ﬁ§{w§ §'iI§3.€%§ as :33 biﬁ Sf {ha c<}§:r;§3i&i:3;;a§:§{"'sé0§1'i:'a§7*fi§3*._f;;?é$,§;;<:mi§.:3g *s2a:=~§;'£._T;:

;%<';c::s€{i; thaw {?§:}'1£}é §';:_§_ 'z3.Q . €§.£ma::{§é:::g 0:' 3c(:€~:§3?£i§ig $336 5:'; ii"; "EEK: saga 9? Séaie :;;§'".z'~§?"§{.i%§pa_ Pwzgiagﬁg §*i*=_"%;' E-*'€??,§.z;€és::35;.§;g'iz §=3{:g@, 3:{:'§}€>3:§::{£ 33:1. QR £3{}€i'%?%~ iﬁifft _ E?f3S;,._§:'&§'V§€"~?%;§»ﬁX V"€,"f::::V1;2v:"i5 éffﬁf ap§31*€{:§a€ing *':i";%: mg-'i{%{5;z':<;%€-:§ hziézi i§:ai_"é;ha Cass' iéfvihﬁ §:'{:3€Cu'€3;s:>m zﬁaé. ihﬁf aacgrugezé {if33X§§%E.Ed€3i'§ 31:32:'-%;;~;:;a§;»;?e{§_ gz?{a*;§icat37m: Se} gimw ail e3;§i€:é:»§ fézveuy: $1"; :»7ss;=s;a2*{§ _ i¥G2";%{ "'--2:>:'{§.::é% :_";'Z'% "§§.1;ﬁ :;:<3m§;§9i:1a:1E§ {i€i3}.§}{3'£ ht? éaatgegsisié Ekzéifémsﬁ . éékié saié 'se::a:3lg1t:*:«§cf:. was 833}? m1{Zé?:z* gmtzsiziﬁmigiazi ami %'»¥"é:'i~} Fiﬁ}? _ 'ﬁS1:3§§§?."'aCCE§3'§.ﬁ{§ 311$? §.%:m'*e:fm"€, 321$ qzxﬁséien :3? £35 ﬁﬁiféiﬁﬁii .V 3gf:%€i§'3g ta giva 'Sm §=m:'k <3:{*<i€r 0:3 §}f%1jsf3}Eﬁ§'}.'§ ef '§n'%%}<% {§{}€§§ ;:';{:s'i ~ g::*:Z$a. Thersfgra, in ﬁle i3}.S'€.§§"i}§ gags, {E26 maiivs '€a,{~"§{2:° $3 Eackiag.

3* 'iii 22:?" ibmmg 'is {Em {".§"§_'1C?§3_1 &S§}€C'£l 53? '£§.:<': {E333 Viz" {E16 i§{?{?'§S€§ havézzg ﬁemagzzied zmii §?§_i3'.€,'{f?'}f}£€{§ éize b:*i"§}:":* z-2.:x%1,:>é:::;s?; ﬁom camggiaiﬂant: Ramakrigéma, ms veg; {:am§Ea3.i;2;z;::.é*:_.[';,__€§.;§é::"

$333 'E3661; exammﬁé as ?.§§J.11, £333 :19: _:~:2:;;§_§§:;a:j;I*i§§{i §2°:3S€z:?*a:€1'%Gﬁ C836 ané has has}: t§"t:a%.éd .h{é$:Eée':.._ -§*§é*.__.§'1'a;s.gsf};§1é: is the exisni sf gfating ﬁg: hi$ <:v§,{§5:2c$7Ei1a-i he zigas ':39? R:-269:? V thﬁ ataniaais Q? EiX,?-=12. 33%;"-;g2§""'i:§T:';:£ cs3':-}.rst:V.§§':€ bﬁég <§m§$* étxamyinafiim hf; {M3 ésiégﬁgiég, %:E1€;"€f'G;m:§:a§a.ii*:;3zz§;. ha$"'$':§:§:€{§ "$13"? 'aha aztﬁéggazi was ﬁércibéj-g" mkﬁié, fisrﬁiﬁéi Gf :33: aifzii iém Complaizztaﬁt was i:¥5§{_§ X} a<3':::::E:i;%?§*~.bVL1§;iaI::' §§?{f;:: a_z:§<;"s:a:},%: '€43 éhs 8;€':{TiEjiS€§i aaﬁ ;w*:£C~é<::'rc?§:i::g§}:"--5f:;%:;£_% €Q§23§_}§9i£ia:}t ;>'a11;: {£15 amsmzir. sé §%e::;. .w§,?§{:'fV-iE§?§§ iézsff §z;>i*:}z;s:'*; <:;§'i1h§-1 aatcasﬁzi amzi 33$ E1215; $339 S§"$'§{{€€§ i%£a?.V_ ex;hav:} faféezi is 9331 $3.6 am:3:.':.:"ﬁ. 33125:; 53:36 "§3§?§a§1é, {ha ';9:§:€r2§S§§;"'?¢3§i2ghE imié {:5 E1273; hafid amé Eaizé éfzzit ».é¢..T:§;;ve mm. Eai, 53; 33:39.: {$3365 iéhs L§ka}:'uk*£::«§ '§;.>::;§«; ﬁx: acczgsaﬁg £9 ﬁgs éI.3§§{.'€ gag? gai 27:15 W?%§lQE}Ii:}§;' zzﬁijﬁeved ifsm tbs pgrtkai <3?' €326 éiﬁiitiﬁﬁd 323$ 72? 13:33 '~:§i'£§§ 53'i {ha £a§:v§€. '$23.13, '$135 Viii}? cf;m§:ai::a::t I133 139%. {tame ' "E9 *;;_E:s:- asgégtmaca cf' {he §:'GS€{f"iE€§s.f:3I}, 2%. "$15 Eﬁarnszé sszmgs}; far Lgkafgziéqia argzzed $313': ikﬁizgh {ha §:@m§_2%&:§::az1€ has ﬁat S%}.§}§€9§'i€{§ the §}m$:3<:z§%1is.3m Q'?

grass, 3&1}, the exridezzite §"ia€red $3? Ehé §.:*Q${*.:;?s_.:'§i<;:'1 :'m1':T§'§;?i""»'§:~€: iiiseztartiaié £3111}? :31: that gscsre. '"§"%11€:"{=: £3 rag'; {§;am'§'§.~:~:-§:§i§§€§§':::{':'§".

farm in $315: saici s:3;§m1£2s3L<:s:1 magkz E323: EEK: E€:a§1";§:f_zi "¥C;T{'3?;E51%.3{S»i'i§ '§i>i*-- §..01{aj;"2;k€a. §"af§G§'€{)'5ffﬁ§", ﬁfsis {?€}Z3;E'§; §33ji3::.a §::1;::: 'sf 'I§??ﬁ fﬁ?ﬁ{i?E??iG= ifs Stage gf §;"a3§2£s.§:z§€(; rgzgwozﬁgé, §::§7..E§L;§%?; 2€}{}:f_ ;E{:A;;;'":3:§;E.:§:aV'V 363%, has haiéi mat éasgsiis '£216 €::L:;;':;q'>ia1?::a;:3.t_ t'a;x:i:2in"gp hégtééii, caizvisiéegz C311 §€ cmxﬁjibméé ;>é'::-'ggh E¥»"i§{E1BS?S€?S fuéiy CGZ'rGb03i":C--¥Eﬁ the evééezzm Qf %h:::° ¥§0i;i;%<3«3fﬁ§c§%:', 'SA?§.'.E§§ ?:::«::§ arrangeii {Em '$3. }:,"§§£ §'.3£¥ViVS€ of Tam'? 393$ Siéaie {I}e!§2a')} :v.::'e@g31fA'?1:é:'z'j;%V:i::,_§n§¥l%§€3}i§~« $33, has aim hasizi 21133. 11:; iiafraimiiy 13$ xa':'%';aa:}:€'é;__'. ﬁgs tsgiimtmjg s:3f éhe §;<:z§é<?z% Csfﬁc~.ia3;;3» smereiy ..7:';€ca:::$é- Efiey "aa}<>z:g ':0 iim §"}€.)§_'§:1tf: §s;:2§'e:>ﬁ sang? ::9:'z"'€;%)m;*:é;?s§0i;..E>f; sa:::;é"'i:1é€§§€:.;:%€n%; €V§f§€E'3.€€'. is :29: I3.€3{3{i$Sé2Z'f;' I -*=9%;!§;:.:fT§1V E}§é»--.._&f§~,.s:V§i:ﬁs;;§a§? af $35 §€i§§Cﬁ ﬁﬁicéaia ES fQ'{§_f§=iI§ as Em miiasﬁia. V. E351" "_.'i:f; :fa::s sf {he :e§§}:>1s:3 gwgiiésn 324:: 32%; in Ehér Vsuéisa $16 Eliﬁfﬁ fag? éhaé: aha: camgsﬁaxliaani {§ii{§. E'i{)§Z' $a=,§§%§ﬁ €226 §}§'8§€C?&ﬁﬁ§i ease; iiiﬁfﬁfﬁiﬁg cazzzzat ha 2?: gr-étzszzxé K $9} ivsgséct mg ggmﬁasziiéﬁm $3.5-.€ Emrk, siack am} §§&'E'€i§v :28. '%¥hs'{§"aer fihﬁ smiéézzca piactzii by '£1236 pm$§>;,{:':':$i0;'_2.§ Eéaving h&;'{}1& eviéemcs 0f the C€}}R§§3§fi3_¥;1'{§ Gag: 23$ imki is 92* «g ':5 b5 sufﬁcieni ﬁnzsugﬁ :23 {aka {E26 via? éhai EEK: pm:§¢§:*3;:%i<321 hag ymvaii as 233:: Erzaaymnii aéi rf:aS{:»m.a§3§& giaubé. £3-fiisa igﬁésiimz {:3 be caﬁsiésrﬁé ﬂaw"

12¢}. €3,393-.5 aizii 3.3 am this '§a3€;e:?}': £¥.r:%:{;1§:~:'5£;fé:s,V-_E3*;-"'§3éZ.'I""*§ 7 K Raﬁq Ah;-}mm€& has depeseé £11 'f§"i&<_'C01i1fE§€~'_Of f£f:iis~:.§;%zit%s:;r;:t€'».. Ehai. an 39:;<2ez}2, at abbui }.L.3§ mi; 23;:

Lekayukta eiﬁciais Cama meal' ._tE::.r: '§'ai:'::és1izi_ai*s émi Went insidr: the aﬁice __ 931$ :_I:é:'~v$1ma1_pZai:3}a:2.i'V_askeé Elm: actcimeii 3352511': €115 wa3:}«:;'--. 'fizij téa.:h2ii+Ij;jE;;f {E-E- §si{':z::1ss§ assé-=:ec§ ihﬁ c0mp1ajs:1az3i.whet?;_m" t§;§A.g:§;ﬁ.§'L1Iit. hg;3"?}3a:¢i§7}t}1?:01;g%1£ ami, Q33': Ekaing mid A' ﬁ,Tm€"VC;C?If33}§.§' 8;L§;'1§?e¢*1_'§, ."i'.0§;d the aitczzseii {ﬁat Ehajg gkzaii gas 3? tea' 'é:.%1::f.,z Wen: ta Efiaa iea Shag} aﬂd affgr 22.:-.3; 31353 'gaming Q11: 9? we tea 3:393 ﬁgs V' '=:»§cC"a:%ééci iagksé {ha 15/H*a§{§i::€;§? am}; ﬂit: §.20m§::§3i:1a31i g&¥'%Ef 112 if-ﬁfiéss ¢f"'§€;sL §.ff};{:'«f:;? 12.13 gaclazsi mid ma aatcuseé {:30}; $333 samﬁ aiiei fﬁiit if; righi giiia gfggamﬁ paatkat 332:2 ifizﬁraaﬁez", {ha 'ﬁigzzaﬁ gﬁzéxjﬁ; géﬁgﬁrﬁ. 813.51 'aha Lzjiiajgégiqfzis. Gfficiaés came 311$ 'ﬂap V. Fwsgs' §;e:.;'Q. 3%?» Eowevsag in '£213 C'{3E13"$€ af big cr0$3~€x3mi§::3ti0:2, V' P.'§§~'.5 has sztatad ﬁﬁ'£€1'W}:S€ wiﬁ} regazfcii 1:9 6:16 demand ﬁzgiété by the aC£2"§1S€{§ by gtaiizzg fihai 31?: {mm Q? {"335 'ma shag}; 'i.§'.2i:' _% '*4 E'?

'"'€.?C"{}S€§ déé ms!" {3;{"'32E3a§3§'§ Eh? a§11{m:"s.'§. a,_m§_ :29 Ev'§"ii§:§."E. $2243:-::::"::=:::.1i. Wag gixzezz ':33; Eiim, A1: {he Saiﬁif izizmis has fézas fuzﬂzsr z§sj§:s:_:>$e:§§. in Etrzés c:*<2$s~€xam§§.2a%iG:: ihai. i;:*.<:au$ss: ﬁlm aC<.%u3s{%"'%:;:;;«:§j~§;é;é.§j aimzg Wiﬁ: that c(3mplai:1a:1't:§ §'ﬁ.'i§Z:'§ imagined Ehsaf, :;{f€:'23_:sc;:§""

might E13256: asked $3116 ammirﬁ, 'E:h11$, :%.sf;:

$;§ms:.ss £3 :19': iisgsosing aée;:§:Vi$'m:;t§§;- géezéiiéz £5-:gj;~ra;x7c§ '£9 'ﬂit:

ésmand mad: is}: this aczszzsrsii §E3;.§V."§"'V§h§:§T1V"ih€V"i£%'§;'i3EéSS gilases fzeiai Cazznaéicisrg 3'fatséé3§;..;s£1§' «éiriﬁfé "ii: £}:ie V:naé.§1*§a§ gmﬁicizlam cf the Case, ii; :37. ra§%'1;g:':9 5;1r:g.5;;§§£%fj:{3 '_s_..'r:éE§--" 62:: 3:;,:<:'n 27:. tcstiﬂzeny.

37:» ?,¥¥A.AE;{.:_-V §*J§:é§2:a1:,%.é§*«§§_i:€_ g'f;j§';€:' zgagziﬁz Eviiﬂﬁﬁéfs -a:!1{.¥; thﬁ said Wiit£:€;%;S'%3a£=:' :.§&p§é:::é€ids;:s§;$e€§ in his €'i'%*'}:{§§?f{}{Tf.': ﬁkéii

-z'33;f§',€§f Eh? {iemgﬁaiﬁazfii gavé {ha amgxzizat Ea iha E-iiféliiﬁtfﬁif ﬁiéi ' €%§'}$}:31:3¥i€§.é§§."i€VV"..géﬁfﬁ Vnéigizxai 1:335" cimiiézzg his fazss zvﬁfsa f tﬁémaftez, the iskayukta cfiiciais went, neat:-°f__ {ha .s;::{ft§--§;;::°;?é and caugkt him azzé "$163 the accused; zxéag V:}a§s:sn ts} that giace ssshme he Sim in 7:133 aﬁcs and t%1€.r&3:%"'ie:* Léccusaé aazas agked it} Eaazzd Gﬁfﬁi' the ammmi amé ' aéacoréizzgiy, the asseusaci tgak ms}: E?' ﬁeiscg af E€S."§{}Gg'-- u giagzaminatian. {mm his pjgjaziza pacézsé 2,-mgﬁ iizsis Q18 §":3.r:<§.s Q? {ht accusaé '%>§'{':3."€ égjnmersﬁeti in the smtiiam Cafbﬂfiéiiif se;§:3§3L{3':': azié £315': §;ﬁ§'€2.'€'.'§.<3E"£ %,n.:°zz€{£ izéif} _§}"i§};§§ <.:~<>§:3'2;g.r. $1 'E1325, <'::"{}sa:~"e.~ ﬁx ;

\ 19 <;a:-'h{:mé2S W5 havtt ﬁﬁiifﬁi freiii ﬁgs :%%sé:i:'::";<.tz: 9:)? R'§¥', E6 __:'.i'1;:v;?; :;,€§'{.%3(i:' Pfsév'. 15%} I392' E'i"~?€,f§ {iii Sag; a:1§;'::,%".1i:s1g in <:{';2fu%' wiéh fhif trap psazzgékzamuna.

33* Tfzzs i:vi§{%5:3é:?€ 0%" §3.'%¥S/$3 f;'§ ::':';i"§._ Bi} '.§.'§?§V3 §"':€.3§.' )1 §'.E3§:'. 13;; i:}%:::::«":1g}1 gives; as m::3:3:':;$.s:i<>:.; ';;;f {%{f%¥§3%§{%{§ '::.ééx%:§.2~; éztmandsd 33:6 31%-§7i§E» {ram *:%3€x%::E';5;:::§§e2mi;:>,§§::3 rﬁcsivﬂd the sagas: $5 Sgéii --{;§' '§:;:'::§'<;£:<t':1%.:és:>:§: §%E'§'§i1€fSSf3S xvii} hava ta be 5}'? ﬁat: €vé.{i;'*:§<*{i gkiaezad hf; iha é€.;.%?.::;:;::::*'::-*:_ i'§s{§};£ V ' {.):;.VV.E;%;"-fsgzif €33" :E5ii:%."_'<j£_€5'f€:3$aég, %;§i'm:éé.% wiiriwgésg axzgrye ﬁxamiaééié s3z:{§V {,§:;1 §:I"-3:' ._¥.ﬁ;s§;)E{:a:," 1§:}'\§€5 E. £3E:a:13;2a%3;:,$z~rg:;3a} iagiizzjgiérzzgiziiia;._§5:i%.;1.&:éé;:<; whiz Egg'-:.{§. §>;(::3';€. 1:5; %T:3}.<:<: Egsa, ':%:":::}:«: ::%i:';:e<:';:+:55; 21:1 §1é,s3}.6v§€§~5:§1c€ 'éfixzai he $:3w famz" '}€3§"§§€}I'§.S <33'3'2T<5 a§:;>3:1' axsijiéz {Egg-3 . C ' '. s 2:: , act: «'a33&::!._ a§;a;?;< 3<§:a:::e <33" mam wag ézavéggg zmzsamzé. in 3:31:15; §':22:.:';:i%a «.f'%53'aé' the §":§.{i{I'Eii-';€?§%, is ﬁg: his "W{}I'§{ ezézé iiiif aezztziitﬂi =._§:3i€§;"€ha'£ ':36: 33223 11:3 <?<}::2::.a5:{:'.§sL<}::T Wi'i.'£": :%7:}:*§s: sazsii _i:Vae?:,a§':;*§':§:§§§a;" ésaa 33$ ;2§tg}§'::r:»:<?h§:{§= '§":';€. gywszgzz, :z:%§<2 ' {i':3:°i§%i:g Ehﬁ :E§m@§lEii., ixzmg i£"<>:::::':i:';§ ﬂag: as:;-s:%;:@<:=;i is a<r<7::§';:' 233:? * -»§::sg;éé €i$iG'ii,'§1"§;'. §r"§R{§. {E15 a<:<:§3$€:{'§ §u37§::z:d §§'_'Ef3 szggézié _§):r::'s£.;:.: W§.'§.%'?s his i'i§7€? %:z3:s1d$ anﬁ ihefi gastifaéﬁad {ﬁg} $3231. '€,{}'§}C§{1 {Em z~:z::{>"s.§.:':'£ 311$ me}: the §az"$e':2s name 956:3 :§;§*:%$m3.'£ :§1:%:ai.€::'a€{"': ﬁzz: %/ M . C 3%?

aﬁczzssﬁ 321$ i:%1»::r€z»§f'i€1"_5 E316 gﬁrgezz E35;-"§}Q wgm {",'&}."I'}"§Z?,g Ekm atammé. f€}}"€?§§}}§ pm: ééwr 33:'z<2%..:§2.1:'. ':§:Ji:3 '£316 riigéiaé siés: §}§'"jé1§ZE€% ggcket. cf $16 accuged. am} 13:}; 3.252321%,' {§;f3S§}i§€:' ﬁiﬁ 2§{:::;i¥:s:::§ caliiﬁg '€336 said parsml ii: stag} and ﬁ2.£m53;f§z:::; 'Ei:33i?'''§3s=3?;:f'S§'%"§§:;;_ ' wim wars: S;'{}f§"O?i§1{'§;§_"{§§ {he asgrussai, s:tg1:1gEé.§__E§:2.%d' $.13? accusfsé '$3; 333 righz r:§f:)e:)1x2. Later amuziti 3:38 ';:=.§:t that me gsrgaegzg vé}1o:"Zqa§ fz3ﬁji%.§£jg ' the azaammt. fiitam f§3.ﬁ gasket vibe aa§:i::a€§:§=5 '&§?a"s {Em <:am§§a:nan¥:, The a'§G§:%;%...3€vi:i::;:iét%efA Qezﬁf E. $33 ;:*%:m.ai2is.s{§ 1§E}{T.'h&§§€IEg€{3. 1%: {Em <:r{33s~eX;_ai¥ﬁ3ima'£ia:'>m._ 331$} E}.%¥T;'§%§a£::i;§::$é$;.%_ 1:3»; _tE:v': awnsr 0? 'zéigaﬁ "ma ghétzg} :-::z;{% 13: has 3&5; é'fEpOSf:§ :;?.§:1v.15ii:3:g5"'<%?t£f;E1 ?§:3;€: $'Ji{§;€3E'}{?€ 9? £73,359} .€:::1a"§ {:r:::'t'e3hs:/333163 E5: T§:2ﬁ'%;t:'};"'§5a}h §f:}}"fi{','?.'i§3§'§., '"E'§1.i§ W§t:";€:~;s, 223$ ';3}S$"S§éii;{§ ihgé. s%2h€:*:"":i§t3;é §€i"$0§}. ca;:t':'§='"§31g {ha amgziﬁi aame "=>=i1$:aar_§i"iL, '§%if'¢'ii§${Z{§n and askaﬁ the acztziseé 30 take ':23: aznsuiaa t11€'3;=.:§{t"z:sf5:& 5éif:%:§iI1€{1 is; dz) $3, §)':§"€ €336 §:=::"39.z;1§ Sﬁﬁhzii} wag 'vigaving Efhaé j_3Zﬁ1€}1.1§35£ $3.": big hazgdg thmatmzsd 'ihé éTiC{f'E1S€{§. zmé » Eha' aceragaé "isiiérzg aha 335mm; mat éhﬁ W{§}'§<Z zéannoi ' « 'be g:%{:n€ ':33' :'}iI{:§ yet; the gamma #91:? "$33.23 33391121: f{>r<:=:§%3}§; $13.19 " right gigs pgckeé asf §%;€ §T}§'j§$ﬁ wazrz by $16 ae::1.:se{§ 331:2 ifc;€re3a_*'f€:er, ﬁze {W0 §€r'3@3'3§ Caégzgiit. imid sf iifxé a(:::':%_me€i 3333 his Essie hariés £1531' i.73€ alhewu 'fix é%§'}Q'£:"€ ﬁviﬁfigéétﬁ af this % 21 V5.?§§;i1€,--SS aise hag 1:0': hem: gma€:}}? aézaiezszz in s;'u'bs§;:%;':c;?§: 7én__'i;§2ii cr::»S3--€x€-zmézraatéazl.

36. 3.21253 Shankaragpa is 1102.16 €}£}1tEf'_ :E}3{%%f::V a<tm23e3-xi himasif, He has fIi6§}0S€€3. §?i""}Fi3%S €*as.i££s:V15e'::':;: ;>:.§':.éi':. gm.

:2<;.?.%2m:23 at arauﬂd was a.m., ::1é":4ge:;$s§;p;'sﬁ::*a:z{*Egéga' is his eﬁicc anti §iC1<::::d up qu..éii:f:€i§:._a11{i§:>:f:::a Qf izxiezvezzed 33.16% '{§1sre:aff:.<=:1f, 'aha ;-§;._-:_§<::;s&;:3 was ~ «§"_E}.f§i:C§}1 § as "Eh:-:

'f'ai1aS§3.::ia3:'s chambs? am}. .*~;vasC--_ $33: and than {mgr }:§€i'S{}ﬂS cams: anti .f:{;<3i< }1T%§:1V*€:£:»:'€§1&-- tea ,9:-:;7%%s:>;§""s.é:r;:{3;§ 3§t:--:r ta§«:3;.:3g the tag, '§5,,?§§€T{1§}Z%:§3}? §.5:'é%1:1::V:;1:t;;. ﬁgs 4f2e2':é;<:¥1::"'€:0"§{§ azteimsgi ':9 mks mama}; ff0::;.. shif£.._p0ck>et baa Wham {he ai>:;7'::$ez:§ iéecigizaﬁé to {E9 sci; ._?;".§"'::§;:g.> "<:'s%':1€::" §}2::r$<311 whiz W312; 'w:;€§;: E.'§':.%:

f01'me:;g.t01d t£5"fs:_: rc*iT:>§;§; §3 u'?i::§i16 8f£E€)§1I}i énta: {Em ;3::;(%k€?. <3? ﬁat: é':€3C1;§':3;€fé $.:}{}L"~§§é'§1¥331 i§§:é"'sai{£ §,3€',§'S(}i1 :;:'.%,{%:§ {E3 "pm £115? 33:39:12}: '§"g_;'sf{-f§1%'_3I'}?T.ii:i:QM ':3§V3V;3T_;m:ée:;sct1«::€*£, 'SE15 acarzzsﬁsgi §u§h€d. €126 said _;3tr::"$§3z1 aﬁﬁ' _ké§"iT %:%§%§<:'3.;:=§é}3$ §0ra%?m'é 3:216 ihsmafiez' '$25 acczzstzzi 's%F%1S£ Wfgaaghf ?5}5s'";§2§§ shziri. am} than {mm ba§:}e:$ié£:* mans? "J€§§E§ §3§_§%L " Egg pf;-rjama packs? am}. rimyiie me ac<:=us€§ ::%a§§§::.g éhss "'§é:§se:;. in 3133:): $16 mid gﬁﬁif-':':§8"ﬁ {iid 239?; 31:09 gzmi, ':33; %.§':.:»':'é $315, 315 C-3m€ is kgzow {ﬁat 1:316 §$rse§z.s;} "i.7é?_3£}{} had camghé his hands? were the Laiiayakta effiitziais 3.32% ﬁgs agﬁsrusétd igégi §§"2--:': Lgkayzzigfa gsaiica thaé: €§.ES§3§3i£ isﬁémg gas: ta E'-:.€a§ ihﬁ zamazzgsﬁ. } 1 «-

but in} £3329 fiat': §}{}{'.'E{ﬁ"E, 331% szmmzzxi Wag §?:.>r<:r§Tb}§; gm': iata E1313 §_¥L}C§§€'§. and iizezaaﬁiez', thﬁ accussszi was taiién to €816 '§'a1:a§;é}:§3i1¢f$ Gfﬁate and. was askﬁﬁ ta mmsysse the amaun: fr9m_§iiis< and 3.cc<2:'é§3.:g§3;, tbs a<::<:tus<::é mmaszad {ha a;§13..:.u1;::i'{, _f}*s::':;m.E1i:s?;' " p{}{',§§€§, and §{€§:?, ii: 9:: 'iha iabéa after Lﬁaugﬁizg 'if, "i axamézzatémz af E).W.3 arise baa n.at §§;f§%?n iizgggiv-A. :;3§4;:§{é3£t~ zestimany sf Q.%5J.3 is either iiI}}'éi"i:>%5i§€ 02" a E.--3 }jslTeT H 3?', Thus, if W6 iaﬁzgihe m1 A1;e£A?:G3*{.§, Exam p0ssiE:n?..E15':§z3s cmarge. The aati 123 sgrsupiezi with giasagg :r-231 '§§3§3%':'§';§;.3iiQg§iA cf 'ihﬁ agwzrezseé havésig i_{§&ma_::2;'<§?;i§. V;-:'«;r}"{i'44_'é3.:j;;:£3§3t_{:€i; R3.i,'7i}{},/=« fzfssm tbs e::emp;a1?11a'zi:f:Q' VA': .%f:_7::::. ihe <i€§en,cs: vcimiszé, sp@k€;j:.--%:;:} by 3, giizcm the izzdicaﬁozz fizat 'ﬁgs és;zam'*zz3§i u;':a:4s '"--f§;"s::§';:}'§%V'"§'iz% imia {ﬁe pmikﬁi of $236 :i2xc.c:;.:3€:;%. {3;§Sp§_f;3e' «f';v}§;£:::».afa<:%5';;:_s§§§~ rﬁfusiﬁg $9 accﬁpi thﬁ Same, §'é{W.:, {E25 qiiﬁslééén £3 $3???-gaither {he gymseczaéiars. czar: be Said ii) Eizave '§,'%_f;"$V€d 1&3 €::;:1s€ btsgmzid aﬁ mamﬁabés <:%s:2%:r{.. ' ﬁgs Eaw is Wﬁﬁ sstéfaaé {hat the $ia:;.::iar{i gr pmssf {Q %& piaaed E}? 3116 pmgéczmlen is £333 3 %};37.gh€~:.:* ésgaﬁa A V' the réquiremant 9:: the part. af £215 éafszzatte, The §,}}"{}rSﬁ£":.?;1'§.i$ﬁ W53 haw EC! grave ﬁg saga Eyiijgrozagi 33} masazzaééiﬁ: 3:

Z23 éeubé, whersag, 'aim same £3 3:3: the }--*&'£§X'§S"§§C'f§{ 55:2} 'as a§3é§s§£€{§. 373 regard ':0 the (§;ﬁf€}Ti€€ vamisn ami it 313 snzmgiz defamtte 31$ abiﬁ ta probabiise its Cass. A' yrégagcépia 6%' 13%: t0 {ha saga an haﬁii, ii =1'Z.'%_I}§i£C};§§..§§§w§?§"..g$ﬂ§;{§ {§}c'"'§§§'u ii: {he ézmtani €a$s, aha: §3:'€z3::§:1:?:i0:3[%1a$_:§u$' :§}§:3é$€€i_ §'€n§x.§?é:s§:j_ A' befsend 8}} I'é8S&ﬁ3§:s§;E aéaubi.

89. We havs $661}: $33: uE§;3*;§5%;§u§%1{:>'ﬂ: §;3M§.§£:i 1:5,:

gzfmze '€E3a'%, €136 'W{}I'k waﬁ V:':"}f};i;3§§1jS'€:--§:(§. i§;é'V'v:?.¢%%€1;$€(§ aim}, ii} '£316 absencs 0f mestivﬁ ?::si1"1g :':§15€v---<;§"a:3, r:é.fi<§i{§'ﬁ:'§:f"§§€§3,:az;::z.€§. by $316 accuseé $033 Tﬁaféfggé ' 'gfasecutieiz '§.»'&2'S§:f3£} that ihgsz """ .-- Vérxs éimauni {mm ma <:7a:::np§a%:1%>si'}f§ 4' Ca:::::5t,A:.L:. '{~§§ -.,.,:_:§'~%i7{'>:1i;%:§}i:.€d :33 'mziag ffffffi {ram} ifaﬁﬁﬁzﬁbiﬁ §§zz:.::i§:e.*;¥: afzzvzi méraévﬁr, $3535 sompiaégiiazgi h}1,m.$e:i? E1213 "inf: $:;:g§§<§;*iﬁ%:1..:E1s p:~0 éé<:a;t3;e;;:1 gags, Exstssrpt L135 €.ss;§im:>:":}»* :35 '1§,§_?a€VV _»3€i:ﬁV:9"».§§%:v:i:&s§$g%s aria, §a.n{:%: ¥;:i'€I:€sS€g aﬁd the pgaiim §ﬁiC$i}$5 this 3é'é{i£:i::€§}Cﬁ placﬁé 333: '£E':€ siefﬁnce hag givﬁﬂ 5:36 is ':=T§§'i3}3€ tiaaa }£*Z'QSf':{33;§.'£3:9§1 case' x The ﬁgéex Csuri, in the QEESE sf .5rf..E§,.£a'a:s§'zzm ifs?

"*..._ ,.gt§_a§£e sf §§'£2r°a:§&; mpmea in AIR 1&5 SC 21:23, fmzzzii an 'fa<::5 '$23.: 'aha affifliﬁﬁﬁi had "éakagz ﬁrm péea {hat 211$ taimtﬁé 319363' 23:33 piantﬁd in his zizzawsr xﬁsiiiamzf 31:3 i{I3.f}'E§=_?1€E{1§ gs ami % , D 34 $1135 vergion sf $15 3<::c:1;1se& was ac{::tg;ie:<i as bzzizggg 3 p:*a§é;2::2E:§s> SE16-. in 2313 case an $.12-?z1::;'} 3139, Eéiziz veméeiz _g:>ia{§;$.€§§ ' 3::§,' :%L§';22§%"« accuaeé thmugh £),§:¥3' 1 ':0 3 313:; a'§3p€a3"*s {<3 'i}e'~.a§ §3:*a';'i:%g?$§:3. am': ané mam Sé, Wham {ha :%;:f«:§<2:";<:£"%;»*<'a';."=:=s.3;{;*:;: .%1;.«2s_ ;::;e*;. iéétéfsfi gmaﬁy $}§%1a%-<;;€n £2}. {ha cres$»exa:.niﬁati0;f:;'--._ ix} Q§?{.Iﬁ5€f_I° :a?.G£ds.,: i:}?V "

§>;'€;30:1s;i&z'3::{:e {sf pmi'3ab.i§3'.t:.'£:s:,» 'S§Efié€£?n'V:b}' piacing dafsnce evidence . thai: :"fa:i<=:':'*=«.:.§§:>:': .'a}L9$c~...A<:g;3;::1z'2{3t. be ruled gut. V ' 53%. in the Eigiﬁhef $115 ﬁgs svizisncs an recozﬁ, E :%:;§3f«'i% Q5536 wizsrzt zhs trig} <:e':;u:"€. .'Z§_':v%W1i}€j}:1:§*:fi'i 9? {§.«::nab'€. {Q 1338 acmisegi. "'L,§:;':'"-a:>1:"£4':'z§?:.V;_;3i'%i.:;~§ i'js="--,;b " <:><}"::::'s';, in 3315 r:*<)"::.m::*: 9:?' £3 e2sié£:§1§i*€., ag3§}:;!a:~:.7.3Z$_%ia8§:$ E133" :";{,:«§. %£§l€ﬁ'i1 §.1{§'{€ 0?" §§'§=f: gézifszzcét .é;-*é,2'i{§€',;3{'}§€,'}5.._'"§3'i1'§A. its £§'?b7'§§£::"2?a$§i2§z {E1223 {East iéafsxzitét Evéziaémraz '1::a:ig:r_;:' 3:2:-ix VC<v:¢?:;}:%:7s7{;}; :3 tgﬁzafgﬁg aryvzztavag %;»::c2;':;i:$5, 32%: {§§f€.':'..}.{'fﬁ '=,?€E'S§£T§.ﬁ %:a,;§ '§:j:=3:m& Giiii §§§§€?C€SS§§.2§}' {§i€S§}::§ﬁ': figs iiﬁfﬁééifﬁ §%_?j';?l3€§S€$ Efﬁizlg s;1"0s;$«5e§;3m.é1;$:i $3; $336 ;:rra3:":<2::t§«::::::. 2% ._ ignerijzg iéim dafexaqra vsrsicn and Eakmg note: 0:?' aniy gevétiezzca sf tbs grosecuiian wémessas is iiks 222}3§r:;ac§:;Lng Wfilze '£~'§P'§1€3§ﬁ ease miiy {mm €316 gmsscutéan zazigiﬁ. 'E'h@ €'%?i{§€I'i€€ :33}. me whgia xvii} have is 'as: taken ﬁrm) aczraum zmzi the <:iefen,<:£ '§f6I'$§€).?é}; 313:} requézvrg is 2:36 °§%7€§;§§i3€{3 ii} E313 Samiz (>5

-4 (.11 satafaa 233 333:. sf {Em éivééiezagrét piacéé ":33; 2.32:: pE"GS€{T3.§.i§.€}E'3. '§"h:t tzféai ezrzgmﬁ. déé £10? &"g)_"gJ§f;;" this §;ar:§S§:§g:k in ap§_.):'&{:%a€§::a§.':i}§:

eviiiszxcs 0;: rﬁiéoré ami, £}'1c3:.1'€f<>r€:, fhﬁ '§"1§.1:f§i:1g §tj{%?éf:3Iz§§f{3._:

ﬁgs trig} $93.11, igm;3:i:1g{ 131$ emira iiﬁifiiziffif £3 a ' " pmvergc fméing and. {ha €{}1?:€.':}¥.1Si€I¥fi i"§3£%C§.{I{?{i"-E3.'§7{.51§};§§'é3§:§{f §;;_;_ A' the sviciszzce ea reczszri, £52, £11. viaaw sf 'abs: :'d¥:;::';'2«*:'1v,* VL "'&.?_:*';;€=:\;.'€?'_VV ia;§.%€'2} : ﬁ §:, 22*; is Eilifiﬁéfﬁﬁsaiy' :9 refer K3 g:3:.";§§:«§is 11r§;5:§:Vi E.:>}>' ihﬁf Eeasrned arguiiﬁsé feﬁiiaa i--£5':-s§f;ﬁ§;ié_:5fV "ails: s;::m::i:i<:m Grésr is 1f:{3}f1Ci'i"3':é'¥£';%€i'g',:'73'1é'} €36}-izbig ; 32'-§:3%._.€§&p<:$ﬁ{1 ?if§'§a§: £26 £5; mg Da§'.2,z3::§ {:€§1:E §§1§f§i£§§.i}Ei93§; ﬁgs: apgazgaiéng a'::§;§1a";rﬁ"§g sf ﬁgs: a<:9'§.§.5§:*€}L is 13:5: S-zigaéfizﬁisriéziszzi éingizzesr', }:%:'§§, 9: s::z~i»_r§:%;';..:?: 300%: at-the préssisgsggg céméginsé in Ssciiea §_'£3{I3}{a} wig: maézzé V' <:*.1e"aLf.:' £:.§j::':«2'% €126 fméiﬁgkﬁf '$16 'mai greuﬁ {.7-8.Zi1}€3§; '$3 gig:-::'::g§ <2-z' ';f§s;%':«;:f$€::% !iE_§j5'Ié:':;«'~,_ {#1: 'E116 gmumi af ahsaacé {}f 91" any ﬁrm: Q1" amiﬁgimm {LE §;95#s_.€:g:_1ia1"i*£§r in ma sazzgrﬁan mqaéraii zmsim" gzﬁrr '.€;sex::v?£1?{31ii '~{};}5';s::§ $30303 3% émiaws in $35 Qpézfzimi as? '£336 éfﬁiifi, ' ;{§3~;é}£::'€:~,0f jugiéce Ems; 31% facts' aseasiﬁnsé '§§1iEiT°€§}3', Eﬁ 0&5: *'w9}§:és, swan 'ihﬁ akssazzitsfr Q? Sanciéan 63162' eamzaai ':25: a Seﬁozzs izzfxrmiig' $3 Szasitkg E am :23? $5535 :9 agrﬁe mfgssif wtliig » {ha ésamaﬁ cajzznsai. Eb}: 3:5 .9,§§3€?;§a:1t i11${;far as éhszi. 3a;::a<.~i%<>§: Gréar éixsézig 3:9': vaﬁié is €'{}§}{'f€§"I"§{3{§.

% ,-

2% =33. E\§<:Vé:r€%.;£:}§:$s, 2'3}; '£i€'iéi 0? 'mi: cm:c§1:s*;:>::$ zz321=:rii:§;£i"--?:§§,? me $333': 'aha: {§€§€i"}.{T€ has §}r€3%:ab}§$€:<3. §'s:"«: aéémié by ;_:;;;;«2;:;g* %'E;:<§'~ éﬁfeméta §:vi{i<%::1{:e ziaéé tbs §}€)E§$§§L§§§i'Efg-' :3?" '$115: a:n5::w__m1'€'-7{>zE3?;i:g; . farcibiy pm izriza {ha égjggamzé; ggcket géfézaé'.§:,§t<i;.';:.:z{:€§_§%:%i::g3::2:«% mied ext 833% ﬁgs: i3GE3§§ai'{}é§;EE.{ .h'%::ﬁsé£f_§ia_vén:g Eé:.;f;:€%.,§, §%?:<é:§%f;£%:V' 81351 $315 We §a:1c§1§s raai. s'%£a':§;:V;§.,_%§::5;: :55 caIz.¥,r:ﬁ€3 '§,¥"€§'€': :'€,{:<3z'd<-:é azaigaﬁr "éégiii xgvéasﬁt ihc gaémifhanama xzmss 0§£'?:c:e, i;>é:§,::g {ii;§'£?E::z*5:;t. 2?':*¢:;m iéggfgigce §.:'a:§;§:€{'% ism, mztaz' me E;~Q::a"§ " égfﬁégxca ifif §"§.15v'.2, 3::

§Li1€Z';§itf§%€I1g§ufﬁ.§% "éhﬁ case 0? {E15 agvczzgﬁd émii {hare bsingxgvgc 3;*;x:E:2§::<3§':'A:»;z$;.;§{_i' 'i'i>"}'1}£' ijm: {'f'¥v'§€§;%i31'1€I'€i 9%' 9:3: ~ , ;i:}.§@§;;sE:;:1:1é:a':. 1%:it:{1't--§::sj, Es¢r€3?e«i:'?£aé,_@11 {he whaie, éfézés; £3 :2 cast: 2=yh?:33"::: §'?{};$'«f:1*§é§£'~--.{§<>i;ﬁ" ezgghé :9 have axiandaéi $16 %}i'I};€ﬁ'§: :2? l A3 gmth, the mziings :°::fﬁ::':"s:£§ 'is; $33; tha .i€a;":§§:3{i a: €3uji::2'é€:1 £91" '£35: L<>}s:a§?1z§«:§i3 am :19: a;:;;3E§a:%a§;:x}§ 'sis E.§3ff ,:§z3;$"E::r;g_:1': (51335 as ms f&€';'iIS azzzi {3§E'C%.}1i1SE£%;§}€f€S §'%?§i§} 2=2:§2i<'%§1 122$ _ .:~i:%s"<::z;,2'::';€$:':";.z:<:§ arr: mtaiifg <i'€£'§%::*&3;.:t frsm ﬁgs {}21{°:E'§ '§«"i?,§T§§{'f§'§ w€:'€: " ~~:%:<i 3:_2b_§€:{,'.?£ zﬁaﬁsﬁz' :3? {base :§é3<:i:%ism:§. 4%, £3 tifza }f€."f$'§}.§{, E paw E236 §%>E1z>%%:é§}g :>:*:;'§m": £2 .,.

2'?

'E'%?:é: a'§;3§;:e:§§i its ailaweﬁz 'ﬁgs j':,2§ig::35::::':' :31" t:.'€3§f'i'ifi{T'§.i{}§.1 _:s§;:.i $«s:§';£e::::2e §>as$c::§ 3:3; the Eyéai <:«:>'a:r'E' is 35:? aaézkt "-..§'E:;:7 a§}p€§.§3i1'5i is zaaquiiiad gf 313 '£215 Qﬁencas wéfzfrz :§r%€_ia:tE5:" vwT%:fe::--. chargsgi. 331$ his 'aaﬁ bomi f'f{,Zi§1€'§S {§i${j,2§§3§g&d, _-- " .-- " EMS' aka,' ~

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court