Karnataka High Court
Kere Hanumanth And Ors vs The Registrar & Ors on 28 February, 2020
1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
KALABURAGI BENCH
DATED THIS THE 28TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2020
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
WRIT PETITION NOS.215233/2020 (CS-EL/M)
& NOS. 215603-5702/2020
Between:
1) Kere Hanumanth S/o Somalingappa
39 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
GHPS Roudakunda
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
2) Channabasappa B K S/o Basappa
59 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Indira Nagar
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
3) Ayyappa S/o Manappa Badiger
39 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Meranal R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
4) Shankrayya S/o Siddayya
52 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Meranal R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
5) Shankrappa S/o Sangappa T
49 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Deenasamudra R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
6) Somappa S/o Durugappa
45 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Gudadur R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
7) Abdul Rajakk S/o Iamam Husen
35 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
2
Gudadur R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
8) Basappa Pujar S/o Chandrappa
58 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
S N Camp R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
9) Yankanagouda S/o Shankaragouda
48 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at Parapur
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
10) Devaraj A N S/o Nageshappa
36 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Ramatnal R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
11) Balappa S/o Kanteppa
52 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Jambhunathanahalli
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
12) Basavaraj Desai S/o Shankrappa
40 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at Mahampur
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
13) Rajasab M Tahasildar S/o Maskisab
33 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Karadu Chilume
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
14) Shivashankrappa S/o Timmappa
45 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Karadu Chilume
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
15) Hanumappa S/o Basappa
50 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Hirebergi R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
16) Mahantesh B S/o Bharamappa
40 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Veerapur Camp
3
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
17) Babusab Choudari S/o Mabusab
45 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at Umaluti
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
18) Shekrappa S/o Devappa
45 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at Umaluti
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
19) Sangappa S/o Malkajappa
45 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Mahampur R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
20) Ranganath S/o T Rangappa
38 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Thimmapur R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
21) Rajkumar S/o Mallappa
40 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at Rh No 5
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
22) Sadashivappa S/o Gadilingappa36 Years,
Occ: Govt. Teacher at Haretenur
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
23) Shivaji Nayak S/o Mothinaik
34 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Uppala R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
24) Hifuzinus S/o Dadapeer
32 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Urdu Lakshmi Camp
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
25) Sandya M Jain S/o Manjunatha
33 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Bukkanahatti
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
4
26) Shashikala W/o Balappa
52 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
CPS Sindhanur
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
27) Jayashree Patil W/o Bharamagouda
36 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Urdu Tppu Sultan Colony
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
28) Afreen Saikalgara W/o Naseer Ahmed
33 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Urdu Tppu Sultan Colony
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
29) Kalakanagouda S/o Mallikarjuna Gouda
34 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at Ganesha Nagar
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
30) Manjula Uppar W/o D Ramanjini
39 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Sukalapet Sindhanur
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
31) Sumitra W/o Chandrashekhar
54 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Ambedkar Nagar Sindhanur
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
32) Satyamma W/o Chatrapathi H K
36 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Ambedkar Nagar Sindhanur
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
33) Chennamma Patil W/o Doddabasappa
55 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Ramareddy Camp R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
34) Gajanada Lamani S/o Jemalu
34 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at Huluru
5
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
35) Girija Devi W/o Veerayya Swami
51 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
3 Mile Camp
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
36) Ravikumar M S/o Muddayya
32 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Gobbarakal
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
37) Keshava Murthy S/o Venkateshappa
30 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at Gobbarakal
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
38) Nannesab S/o Khadarsab
35 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Gobbarakal
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
39) Mahantesh Kanchi S/o Yankappa
33 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at Huda
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
40) Salma Khanam W/o Sikandarkhan
30 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at Urdu Huda
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
41) Sharana Basavaraj S/o Gouriswami
36 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at Urdu Huda
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
42) K L Hanumantappa S/o Ramanna K L
39 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at Mukkunda
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
43) Shivananda Madival S/o Nagappa
35 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Mukkunda
6
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
44) Hulugappa M S/o Goneppa
34 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Mukkunda
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
45) Nmardanali Gadad S/o Husainsab
40 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Mukkunda
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
46) Erappa S/o Dyamalappa Pawar
53 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Singapur
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
47) Kusuma B Kallalli W/o Shivappa
44 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Hampanal
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
48) Virupanna S/o Shivappa
51 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Hampanal
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
49) Krishnayya T S/o Timmayya
33 Years,Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Somalapur
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
50) Abdul Rahim S/o Abdul Mahemood
53 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Khadriya Colony Sindhanur
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
51) Savitha Limbikai Math W/o Shankrayya
37 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at Gadratagi
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
7
52) Rekha Arali W/o Gavisiddappa
31 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at Durga Camp
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
53) Geetha W/o Anantarao
57 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher
at Hosalli Camp
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
54) Bharathi W/o Sharanappa
54 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Ambedkar Nagar Sindhanur
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
55) Satyappa S/o Renukavva
34 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Lakshmi Camp
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
56) Shivagangamma W/o Basanagouda Pati
53 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at Bangari Camp
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
57) Naganagouda S/o Yarrappagouda
34 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at Rama Camp
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
58) Mallikarjuna S/o Shivaputrayya Hiremath
37 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at Rama Camp
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
59) Ganesh S/o Janmbannachitragar
36 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Rama Camp R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
60) Nabisab Valikar S/o Mahiboob
52 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Roudakunda R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
8
61) Bheemashen S/o Ramrao
33 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Roudakunda R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
62) Devegouda S/o Mallikarjuna
35 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Roudakunda R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
63) Prabhakar D S/o Durugappa K R
35 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Roudakunda R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
64) Gangappa S/o Yankavva
35 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Roudakunda R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
65) Ashok Reddy S/o Huchhareddy K
34 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Salagunda R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
66) Mallikarjuna S/o Sharanappa
35 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Salagunda R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
67) Ramesh K K S/o Kenchaiah
52 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Salagunda R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
68) Manjunath S S/o Srinivasa M
43 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at Kengal
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
69) Nagaratnamma Madivalar S/o Shivananda
36 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Chennalli R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
70) Dinesh S/o Honnappa
34 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Ganesh Camp R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
9
71) Gangadhara S/o Nataraj
33 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Ganesh Camp R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
72) Siddappa Baradi S/o Hanumantappa
36 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
UGHPS Kurukunda
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
73) Shihipash S/o Ramatulla
33 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
GHPS Urdu Salagunda
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
74) Parushappa S/o Somappa
32 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
GHPS Ghandinagar
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
75) Deepa W/o Veeranna
34 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
GMHPS Gandinagar
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
76) Prakash D S/o Govinda Sa
52 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
GHPS Jalihal
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
77) Ningappa Kamtal S/o Bisalappa
40 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
LPS Tayammacanp
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
78) Mallappa Uppal S/o Halappa
34 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
GLPS Urdu Jalihal
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
10
79) Mallikarjun S/o Nagappa
36 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
GHPS Satyavati Camp
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
80) Timmayya S/o Basappa
32 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
GHPS Jalihal
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
81) Khajasab S/o Rasul Sab
34 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
GHPS Jalihal
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
82) Mahadevamma W/o Sandyappa
36 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
GHPS Jalihal
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
83) Suma H G W/o Basanagouda Pati
34 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
GLPS Tayamma Camp
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
84) Punit R S/o Ramanna K L
30 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
GHPS Jalihal
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
85) Asha S K D/o Krishnamurti
36 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
GHPS Hosalli Camp
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
86) Kotresh S/o Shekharappa
35 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Hanchinal Camp
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
11
87) Ramesha S/o Ayyappa
50 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
HPS Buddinni
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
88) Vijay Kulkarni S/o Krishnamurti
52 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
HPS Turvihal
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
89) Udchalappa S/o Basavaraj
36 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at Udbal U
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
90) Mallikarjun S/o Sangappa T
49 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at Kurukunda
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
91) Kumarswami S/o Lakkappa
34 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Ranrapur Camp
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
92) Vasantkumar S/o Somashekar M B
35 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at Kyatanatti
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
93) Nalini C W/o Chintamani
32 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at Umaluti
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
94) Karibamma W/o Hanumantappa
33 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Srinivasa Camp
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
95) Channanagouda S/o Hanumanagouda
52 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Vigneshwara Camp
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
12
96) Nagaratnamma W/o Javarayappa
38 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at Vilaballari
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
97) Mallappa Hanchi S/o Basanna Hanchi
46 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at Mullur E J
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
98) Timmareddy S/o Narayanareddy
53 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at Channalli
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
99) Shakuntala W/o Bommalingappa
47 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at Hasamkall
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
100) Mahantesha Hori S/o Neelappa
34 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at Huda
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
101) Lakshamana S/o Neelakantappa
36 Years, Occ: Govt. Teacher at
Maldinni Koppal Camp
R/o Sindhanoor Dist: Raichur.
... Petitioners
(By Sri Shivakumar Tengli and
Sri Subhash Mallapur, Advocate)
AND:
1) The Registrar
Of Cooperative Societies
Ali Askar Road, Bangalore-560001
2) The Secretary
Government of Karnataka
Department of Cooperative Societies
Vidhan Soudha, Bangalore-560001
13
3) The Joint Registrar
Cooperative Societies,
Raichur-584101.
4) The Deputy Registrar
Cooperative Society, Raichur-584101.
5) The Voter List Verification Officer
Senior Inspector, Cooperative
Societies Department, Sindhanur
O/o Assistant Registrar of Cooperative Societies
Dist: Raichur-584128.
6) The Secretary
Sindhanur Taluka Prathamika Shala Shikshakara
Pattina Sahakara Sangha Ltd.,
Sindhanur Tq: Sindhanur Dist: Raichur-584128.
7) The Returning Officer
Sindhanur Taluka Prathamika
Shala Shikshakara Pattina
Sahakara Sangha Ltd.,
Head Master, Govt. High School, Ambamatha
Tq: Sindhanur Dist: Raichur-584128.
... Respondents
(By Sri K.M.Ghate, AGA for R1 to R5)
These writ petitions are filed under Articles 226 and
227 of the Constitution of India praying to declare that
Section 20(2) (a-iv) and (a-v) of Karnataka Cooperative
Societies Act, 1959 is ultra vires and unconstitutional and
lacks legislative competency in view of Articles 243 ZI and
243 ZO of the Constitution of India and issue a writ in the
nature of certiorari quashing the lists prepared by the
respondent No.6 and verified by respondent No.5 and
approved by the respondent No.4 as per Annexure-A.
These petitions coming on for orders this day, the
Court made the following:-
14
ORDER
The counsel for petitioners has filed a memo dated 28.02.2020 requesting the Court to dismiss the writ petitions as withdrawn. Memo is placed on record. Accordingly, writ petitions are dismissed as withdrawn.
SD/-
JUDGE *MK