Karnataka High Court
The Karnataka State Co-Operative vs The Director on 27 September, 2010
Author: B.S.Patil
Bench: B.S.Patil
KN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
CKRCUET BENCH AT flHARWAD
mvmv 'THIS THE 2*2*TH DAY OF $EPTEMBER,...2()_1 Q "
BEFORE
"rm; HGEWBLE EvIR.J{ISTI§3I§B;:'§..PA.TEL
WRIT PETITION NO. 6471d;'.2(3:)_§3 eAPiy;<;_'}
"H--»-§;:s: E~iARNA'"§'AKA s::mx'§;%: as(M3P;z::e«:;==¢'3;fj:"aE:"-»
M.A.E%l<;1E:"T'XN<'§i}E%"'E1.DAR:A'EA'i{A)VF=!.._'if'3'{}.~;_ _V " '
R,E§E*R§€;S.'fi2N'E'ED Bw"r:~.:~:
z%:':%&%E$'§'AN'ET' EZXECUTLEVE EZ1§fsl'_<LT§;§N--§3E§32, "
Nma, <;:z,3NNz'N<';§%A,..M_R_<::>_A;}:::, ' "
PETITIONER
gm $R;1.suRi:$H::_afS, ¢rtj'I'¥7'E?¥i[';":'sk3§I£)¥V"§""
M13; ____ _, . , _ _
Eb "'}"'HjE.": ::;r¢§VV::z.;%.«::;<".:--":i'<.f>%e.,.V " ._
A(?%R.§£;1.U1iJ3*LI'"§"'§<<iA§;' :3 £<L'§'fxE{"§'f;T\/§'§3?.}\¥'E' MARKEZTINCE,
.Ea+M B:&~.m.vA'N :2«;:>m:>, '
E3§§I'~§i"§-A§.;{.Z3§€£€ " A-
" ;,2 13$: !x<" §%-§£Ifi:EfJLTU Rm PR(;) DUCZEZ
. L MAR§§g;;:r§fiNg":sw Q'ei::.:v1'Ix/z;*§"':"§3:;.:,
.
3 "£"'§~§;:'?:2T1 E'~3»»".ETT;fJ'?;"1'§?s"fiT>T:*3' E<;ARNA.TAKA. RfE<§'F"f€.§:'*ilE§'.3*?3f\E'Z'}fZ§i[f> BY E"§'E.~§ €:§.E{_'LRETAE?iY " TO THE---§DEPARTM.ENT Ei.'}E"' C(}~(.T}PERAT'I{}N, V. <j;;€;sv.E:,§::NMEN':* <1'; 1%' §<AR.NA'm1<;A ' --,.E??;5?é¥.N.*7;}AE.,(T}REL. RESPONDENTS {RY SMT; SAVXTHA RATIL, HCGP FDR R1 AND R3 SR1" SHIVARAJ Pg MUDHOL FOR R2 ) "E'}Hf:"~i WRIT P§§1TE"Z'f(I}I\l ES F'§'§MEK) UNEDER A§Z'iI'§€'l43;.;£*3:Eis«._¢:§%'L£?'€i3 Ami') :22? <11}? mg: C(')NE:'JI'ETUTE.([}N 53;? ENDI.A,, §v1€aAy:.r\s:t;;%.fétfégzg £;;UAE;§~: N»-113%: RH;s.L~:<.::3:%%,U*m<%:>N mTE:U '2?» L2{}{}§?> WED z\;:*+:i'T}L":*I%<,.t;-:€:_ ' $E<;:RE':j';.rx._;;2\«?gj-..m;*M~::.j _ ' §L§A7E"E?:'"3.Ef} §?,%.2{.}(iE9 ESESUEEF BY '£'§~H."é'3 EBEZL-LARY A"? A.NN'E§}<l'UE€E?i~§ E?TC.., 'm'rs3» 'i*'E'E'}"E'1('I)N <;:<L.>MiN<3« ON E:<*.£f.)R:_'<I}Eé'D'E..R E§.' 'miié1:'-L':f::»A..zx:':;7 '§".HE1 (L1€f}UR'"§" MAZDE THE F(é)1,.L{7)W'fN(3-: __ "§'E:"1€:": '::<}mm"2Lmica'::..;d2-*1._édamti' ';i?j,:j'2.r,_>;09 ;a ss'-ue:écz by am E.§a~:-<.::"@tary, A§"'MC, E3e:=§1a.;:*5: =l :_t1":}'<é' Z;3'fi€§ 1'iE:E"f3§E'§ iia c%mEk:m§g€:d in t§i:i':3"«§,%q1%'i.t 'g';;::i.i';.%.(--:;V1'*2. u 2» _ ____ é,§fnpi;ag§m:.dW_,»5 C0mmm":z_i<:a':ié0n, the Vg7>r:~%:€§1:"'u:;1f?;&:r3;'° f€?1*3<~:ri*;:x..%; :;_rm"i$ 'mf'i;>3f1.m32é:1. 'érhat: as per the reaoiwgicm ::'£a§<-?:<:§ §?';1 E'.;Z{")€)é3; i:.}3c-2 2"" 1'€$p<:mde;:*1':; amt} p:.;z.;t*s'tMM::2m."r. $5.. 335: d.Ai§'.i"fEi3;("L"2§{f.)EW; §s3s1.;1_ec§ by {ha D£:"<.:<:tar, A.g;1"'i{::_:i§%;§:,_§*'ak§V 1'v'§z;a.§*I'«;s:£:§_:_3_r,g;v '£7)a:par€:m::::r1.'E§ B&}jI'1g2':?JO'£"€3, 02 21c:2°€~:.3 mi' }5La~.:;.m:;% ajz1E;<¢zE<i§*C'z--,a1":<'§ 30%;? in fa-wow' <;>{ %:}'2.<-=3 pe*e:i.ti0'r1e::r for t}"zc:
ug A§3~¥¢;rV;:.?a';:>&sj;@v-Q?_é:<>fifx-&;':':*2,:<:t:é.0:'3. 0?" re: gcyciexwia in the AE3§\/KC y:5:z*cI., ' Ba'-":§"§g-::..';fy §:§w:>3ji:§.>mfe%Ci. '£0 be fmrfeited 01'} a(:<:om'1E: of {he aliei:-ged "-'~__ 'xr:iQ1a.*fim§:';.V__téf the Bering and c<_>1':a<;£i'£;i.m"1s of a.1Ec>1immt1't. it is >v" " n g:
$1.:
&"s<3:e;"s {tum Am:m=:x'L1r'e:A--E*{ 'that the 2"" re3;:>0n<:f.e:1E: has; £'.::"2}<:€:n this decisf-sign em fms gmmid t:§;1a1: the };;>e:tit.ic:::t"1e1" haa'T'féi.é§e<:1 m gmi: 1.2;) t}:"2e <:o'r2s;£.ru{:ti012 an the fiarad in (g§L1€S$'i'I;;z=§§3j}i3._S' the mrnm Of" the axE1o%;;n2<~:~m:. in fact, pxzrsuazmisl s_h<:'m.-+' :<:;:m:3e+ n.<';>%;i::e3 iE~3f:§i,3.€d. in 'i:h:§s:; :."€:g,z§21,r<i, ..thjfi4'péé:.§t.§c}n{r:';v___hfitet.' ;'3':,:;"E)r1";Ti'{:t§:'<:i its ;r't=:j;3iy v"§.de: Ema;1exui"c*_s"' E3 a':?;1.'%;'1.'('.ii C'i:.;?a.t€2<:'§ 31.1(}w2{){}§§ amd ?;'?»1.2.2008 ""}E'Eu2:é::{_§,I-1 }1éi}\1<:2 taE<:'c;~:n up mérxwrzsasi CO1"1E1E:"f1%i01"'1S=..?§fT {he ;:ava£c}--.__';-.¢Tp~§3g. But. mom? <3?"
tmraa c::<)2:m:31:'?;'i;T7L<}r'3;5;; zgxm ;7:wa$ssir";g the im§.32.1g'm:d £.)}j<;1§V<*:§--:;I:?§4 $11311 {he leamrxeci
-a:t<2L.m£»:€:E vfQ_V1" v {ha izngizugrmtj omémc" é.'§',£'f'f'€r2}fE,T.-x V'7§;i":fI}'§'}T% .a_§:§§EiCa.t:.iQn <35 mind ta §':.'k":£3 t"@p1%:: St";.'."i'.'§'li£'1,31V:'{'.'§Q}';1§.E~'~Vv :*s;i;'1';);%i'.;.€ ti :aca*E_;»b§,«' the _§:;»€:Vé:1?ti.m*f:<¢:1h C€T.19iy'i'1"iii:'>"~E3§,v__'f_€§j);?'"v "€316 §3etitiQr:.er fufithex' :m}3zz'1ét:3 thzxt:
'-.:{}fCT%V.;€TV.'1-'{3":-.V*Li'3.€?i '.§3}T{;;§;?fi3_}:""{7.:'y' in questicm £.:;'~:. acuid absoimely by <2:§§;e:%.a:i';ti:mg§ z:i j--f§"<::9§;3;i.ss?;&31"c3<:i. e;§a.ie deed, the 2"" 1"espondem: had Cum ps.:m%.:=:i"*..to mdeszw fs)1'"fei%;L11"c: of the I_e:~m<:i cm {the g1"<;>'Lm <1 that V~ 75.nVm€:+--..;>£' the ccxriditicwzs 93%' aliotmem. were: not. compiierd. ~42», Cm,3n:<'5€3§ for tE'1e i",»3m'i re3s};1o§"1dA€2r1t s3ubt;nits___m.a.%:
a<:t'e§<;>n. is '€i»'&§<Z€i'E"k Vin acc.0rda.11.<:c~ xmth Eaw; He f1x1"t}1e::"';<i§>--i_:§i:'£..S {ELK %:§":a't. s3.:£1;i;.<:.e A:f1z*:1e;5<:u1femE-1. does not ciis::§0:~3e: <:.:;}f:sid:§:3z*:§'t:i<§t"2--T " {>5 $31.63 reipyeserztatiansé ssu§an1.ét:e3c§ ~§:>'y*---!;he:7_pe_€§'t'f§{§>né§* Vi<:E%:.. Anné%X":;:_:"m E2 zsmci E', the 12% re:s'p0fédeb1-3._tA'a.ut§?1<:ri*ty ::.ans;%si:i:=321" Ehfif mz:m.e*:2" in me légfité 0? $3316 ':*¢;5§fe3ié;£:15i't:1ii£o:"1$/ :m'£3m.it?;té:€JE Enjy 'aim ;N31:Vit',',im:is.g§r1".
S. in the Eight of made by tin":
<;::mm-.:<:éE 0%" é:.§*1:eg;>é_.':+'a.%.e:g aé;1.¢'£ "§';§i"i 'V'i.~€§\fg'___iC)f the fact ¥f%"_2.a.t .AI."}.1"1€:5~:3.,I}:"éiEw H" <3:':§£'€;~¥* '%§.%fiL.i 6Q?'€§:'.":BA1;1'3C*fff3:T£?53$ « 'fr"a:ztx'3. 1": (me applicaté an of m:im:§ t;.£;'2 t-fmir :*'§"::;;>uy"% g:t..:£f;fi':--i.£:1e<:i bjg,-' me ps3,i'.;%iii::>m-132:' vietie A;:";1"2@x'a,zr@S":Z%T, ::>m.d§*'_ fiVi?€"§:i§§3'L1g11eci Qrciéir cic-zsmwezs 'E0 be Sfit aS1*cfE<=.':.«§.C A<:gtar'tE%h§»;~E§.?v%»§L :53 set aside» "i"'11€«3 2316" wzsspcxncieni is '.'V€I1'?13"E:Er'":'€£§;£*f,'<.i§.,v'CC:*.{fVi'§*vC'£)§"1E$i(3'2€3i' the mzafier in t:'h&:: 'Eight (:2? 1;:}i1@ re:V§.:emsa@;f1_"::e3af;§:Q.::*2{f;s Suigrnitted wide Anmrxures E1 ami Fe ' ,wV V J.' {i Leseanmd €}m*<-wnnient. Header is permitteci ta {flair §'E"Ef:f§"'I.'3.{:} of app<:":am.z":<::e fm" 3"-i wzsponciezmt \'v'i'£Z§"}.}fi,iV"£, ._fl"x1f'€'€i' VA-"€fE'f§'~.';§I~2».
C?" }3%:'.<'£..i";%ic')11. :i;~:: a.<:c;:<>rc§.izf:§;-giy dispc'>:a~:5:d. Q5 ,; ' ' B