Karnataka High Court
Jutoor Sudhakar Setty vs Illur Basavaraja Setty on 21 June, 2012
Author: V.Jagannathan
Bench: V.Jagannathan
EB: TEE Hi§E§ Cfififi? SF Kfigfififfigfi
$§R$E3E'§ EE§'€€H $5? Efififiwég
§AT§§€§fi$?B§:%e?@g¥{x?J§§Eg§g:fY
§§§GR§;
TI-IE Hézsrgzz Magysizaga"§r};5g€§¢A:£:§:é;:::;§i:§
Re alas Secsné A eai
§ETWEE?§:
1.
Jamar $'EiC§.?18;;i{----%3;ff'*§$€§};§--v "
§,fa¢D:;ar§acha1a'3:§i_ ' ' Ageé §£aja_:g §\€emt:_§:5,:3E,, V = RjI§.K§:If§~72.-fi§~-i§%Z§'aE"; igfisaz 3S.3'L:.s€*{;:« V Bamarg»583:G;,i_' 4'."*'~* Gu:':i--.§§'e.::*'fg{a:ésh '- .. I SEE '<3; &§é'%*:ra§:éf§2a{§':;a;'§§aA' %3g€é:.?é€'«'3.;éVG«.f;'«.A « I Rig' G". 3% e 3:' }2'fas;;:§.7ée:_:§?;3. §:::::_ S:2.n'é, "§2::;:g.a§L'§:*€ Eieaég §e}§3;%::€+§:;83_2i}VEH;a..~7
- ._ ~v ~ .HA??£::§§?$ "€33$:*§{;EE§m_a:3€;§3 2% CE:a::é;%§:ggez3§a:3 Srafigaéfzar 3 V' V 3% §sa;<;'<?:::i~} 51; ":33 :3 at % S 9 E R E"'%_§_:3: V"
".'.4""'V'.":E ii "~._S;'@§Ea?,€ Eéééifu Szzégbgmaa $§§'§;'§j; EiE.2.§ér Basavaraja §5:'§:;
Jégsflz ééajfir, ;%g?%Qa,:§%f,:;::"§$%;';g §;'@,E«i?'a::":;¥; E?*<~Ea&§}{§ Eéigjizzpiig §'3:%S§'§€{»*§$33§§§ 2; Cfiriaééaria Seiiréa S/Q.C§8§s8.:za:%1a Gewéa gfiagafi Exzigjay, 2%g:i€L:}::":.2,_:'*%s€, E;'GéBa§ag<3é.h2.,2E:a1 Ssifiaga E%o$§ei»§832$1.
3' £,€§18I11§&§'}. Qeuéa I 8/a.Ce8a$3:i;a::a Gewéa :
figed Eviajszg Agrie::1i:u:isié,_ R,»'0¢baEag@é§*1u%2a§ véiizggs, 7 E%aspe:~i3832§L '
4. C3'sfii*:;§2aksE':ag':3jL::§a,9" * _ Sf9%CzBa$a2:&§:--a:*§G:%7é,;§_». _ égefi Eviajar, Ag§é€.T_2:E:i2.§§§i:,_.A ;R;§.Ba§agadh:;Zx2::.§__ ':z§§E--a;g€; "
39gpag3$32@:»:_§ °Cyx ~ I ?'..R' ":;R£sP@§QEN?$ {By :S:'i,E<Z,Ez"3..€;1:3afi;:g?;;3:§.i ::':1<§'TA§§'.a2f§§'h §es&%., $.§VG{.':&i€S§ E3:
E3. "" "»_: "v%& . ~~ S:"§.B;:;E3:a_::;1€;::§--"_--%._5iis'$::a%;€°:
_,-fair K2 :0 R645:
'§E:is}"--«.E::*:guE_;a&"'._vS«:;%*~éand §;§§aa%. is féésé iifidfi? Sacéigzéi E%3i3 @7§ CEEQ agaifigé: '$26 guégmefii 332$
-*. dafiéasfixfiaé Qggagagé pasgsé §:§&§J§a.2E§2S%é "gu":hef§§e af Ehfi £d§&. aka: Juége §S§£}§¢% .VEi£e§'$§;$":_,"d:Vi:--:~:¢§1--i$3§:3g {Es aggeai and Cézzfirfizéng '£25 "'j.::;<*%g:r:s:"::» a:%i'}€§ éscrea £33352? '?.§;2.2{}GEj§ pgsgaé £3: f5';'§§®; E;¢'"i§'§"5"§'§§§§ mg ihé $36 of gas Fri; Sévii Jzigéga {&§';~$:§..__;:2' §?2«~";§§*é1§¥'C§ Ragga, agggfiai eemifig GE': is? aéméggéga ihég :§;3:j;?';.fi':& =€§>2:::r*': é;e§%::&§eé aha §a§§m2>*é:':g: §'{F§§§£E1§"f Eieard 3:6 Eeafzzsé cezmssé for '£6 ej,§;_>§:r:§é.'Ef§:f:i-3 azxé far' 'file 28*» re3p@::£i€3:::§ 22 The 011%; SiE1§S§3:li;§a§:---('gj{3.{3§§f¥:f:£sfi"i'- ;§'§:'v-»,E"5;"i%¥;--, §%J§'}i€h hgg beset: :'a§seé.'§:g_ 'E3139A,g§;2§3&}§;é;::ji;$'__in} :hé.
appsaé mem/araaéum is ':hé;'E, §b._c3 $e7::.:i'i:3S béiczw age in array in E2§ié;imgV éfiéii 'iiéga;V:§*i§.E"§%V§iE::§ Sz1%ba:1:1a Shetéy wag Eiuéi anéA..v<§.id.§ A' 35 ;E:::"$f«__§§f;'§.,afsivifieié Qafiaiéan Q? Egg}:
§a§s€§VV.----é~:zv.: §:gs?: é;f33§§.ea%?,*.é:he"'E$::zi*:36s:§ €e:)%,22':$$E £9: the aggeiiazzis Q3:1%i:£A:3{%§éa.__:"E':gig in figrlier praaeediags ii: Qz$,§§é«;.._E2:.?§E_§'§?_é'éjiés $31333 wgg aka :*€§e:':°&€§; is; '§};;_":~1':s__uiS% §e§$';2:§_g:z2t ihsreiafi aria £3 'aha péazéiziéff E1?Z%S""'§€$§'é§%i.%L ?E1€:"$fa:*$ Ehe filzzziiggg in éhs 333:; {W2 gzzéi *§:3:°ae%$ as: :*e$~§:;2§§€aEa, 53:': $23328 g:'0z.::ry:i the § M5-«I» "
§a§é5':§f:_€ £3t:',%'i§§E§$§ gégéméééed aha: SE8 guegtészz 35 ~ *3 ' Egg? raiggii; $5; '$235 3;p§}$E&§€S 2332}: éfi Qfifigéfiefifiéi, 45 8:: '£16 eiiasz hazzzi the szsfmzgigsiegg GE fthe CQ'i};:'3.$€§ for the reggagdegt $3 {hat} ix: s:.'§é.§;fc~,_i>§ GM-4 n' {he eariigy juégzrgami zefgzreé. is RJ%..NQ,__ secerié; apgeai was 3353 pzefarrad .'a;:*:-:*¥;:flf:b1é'<:%. ;"~ga:__d s€€er1d, aggsai was 3.339 di3:1':;'iss§3'dA.:a§1=.Z§§§E:2*§?sfC%§?}3 §'S;'§{}3:"6G§F&E"§ in the pre$e:*§:v.__s:;ii"A-tie €~'viT"§.'i."3wA.?.":E.;%_ ?§%_'::::E$'i££7. haaxé Canczlfzfilzéiéy hsicé 323 S"aZ§:'§1.Ef:§€§ Ey ;;givv}:."i:'1:L;f':A:'st_§3.:1s8$ and E336 éauirts were 22%': "§;'l*;':§g:*é".1v».a':.§a;~: the avg}: iitseif fiifféffiffi hanfi Wriiizzggw and 3139 {ha §easai%;'$ -Q.é.";u3"s€ af Eiae jadgmsnt, Ehe C@:ér§.%; ;éb§§§é:§; :%'§%;2:é'é;% is a€CE§'€ 316 €X6$é.IE'£;§@I'i :3? iijiggié"-»;:a:ii§§ $133!?' Saségfiaag $E2§f:':j§a Q? 333% {:§'£,E,.E'"§;$ Efieigzv beéfig s::;:€€;;V'::.§°:*€%:::;_ ii'; aaiufs azazfi $233 e§.rf§§€:' mm géséétg 3 e :°ef§:*:::é§;3_ Ea :33; 3&5 §;§'j£v§§;Ea:E}'€'S é:>3é:;::gsE zzameig uI%f'»:éVf;9i"g%--:§an:2?;wgé gm E2%;'§§%¥5 ass as}: b§€2I:s*§€z1 gas.
W M' 4*« § '£16 game gartées, no guegiian sf arises Ear Q<:::1$:£fi€:ra:é{:::: £3": %:E:§$ apggsai 5% E733' fine abgrve reasmzs ':§:€'.. 'la§sA§.$Va§-3: éigmésseal