A S Krishna Murthy vs C N Revanna on 3 April, 2009

[Cites 0, Cited by 2]

Karnataka High Court

A S Krishna Murthy vs C N Revanna on 3 April, 2009

Equivalent citations: AIR 2009 (NOC) 2692 (KAR)

Bench: K.L.Manjunath, B.V.Nagarathna

:~;;::»%.;»::::.    'a€.;i_.§»:;-. 7»:i€:;.;':{:<.'.;c:

 

_ i

 

ms m;:; HIGH <::.()m<*1' or' i~s'.Ai=£i'«éA'i'A§{A AT am\:<:}aLq:~z;::
BATES TEES THE 03% ms' OF' APRIL, :.z6e:}9 ;
PRESENT W   ].

*rm~: i~;<:.«:~«a';_~5m:; £\r}i<.J£}S'i'1€j%:3 g;:,,.mAp:au--A§§2:<;}H~:::  1'

AND   "  4 

TH if ;-:<;:~m:,1:: MRs.au§;':%;_§;1:: £3;xg.'.';s:A<;;A;<}a'.£jQ£§:}§§V  V

E-:.:«'.A.Nu.3§jgQg29;§ "

in R__,§*.A.Ho.389igm7 -- _  '
BETWEEN:   "

A S :~<;;~e4;:::,zr+.1:*+;g:';'V IS(IUv.i{'f'_H-':f_  
S/U ;;A';'t;"*s1é:r&z=s »fA:2s;§a.:s3"  
AGED A3::>::7jzj 5:; 323- ~
E§;G§'?€.T§:LKIE::?$, Nags; '
smvm: 'z~:.<;:A_u*, B,A§:"a;cM.erw;,_.:.;--::r.§~»:s:: 5; 1

,.,APPELL=z°;i'4'i'

{ 3.: :3.;~;:--. r_;.svisw5's'§w§£eA, ¥:3i~€.(J.(_}Ui'~Ef515}£. mse 5&1.

 _ A z--:.2*».»:_,.a;:133f;r=.2.;Dz»;.xvgI«:,« ...aa::>*»I.}

 'A1ii1!?§ - % " 

1 '  C: NV-E?.E:'§£-';iN'I€A
 :;--:s_<; ':2: NAGAFPA
A339 ABOUT 54 YRS
:  M1: 403 H<::SPI'mL RGALQ
._ E*.ANGAL<;:RE 2 1

S ?i5LZNE SRENIVASAN

WfU i;A'£"i:i S-%é'§f¥§VASA.N
PROPRIETRLY, EELGIN TALKIES
NC} 6, SHIVAJI ROAB

B:"s.N {)rAL{}1r€if3 51



 .  . E 8 '55 .  {E   {,3 .  Er'; .  . .§'=3<::= . 7"  'C3 . ;-if {.3 ii

:3 A. :5 MAR 5;:-5%;
Sm :_,;x'.:'::«;: 5-sizzrwxsazsarsz
:40 2:3; 1, E STREET
CLEVELANQ ']"*C}WN, 3A§»:':}aLa:<<:3

 

4 A S HRREESH

 O i.,A'i'k:3 §5%€.¥f'-§£\fz"a?5:'%J"~I

Ni} 8,*'E33--1, 13 CRQSS   "
JOSEPH L.»5§{{)¥j'"i"' 
LiNG£XRﬁy.s}PUR?s.M

8AE\§(iﬂ;L{;)R

ES A 3 ML::~:;m *
Sjéj L£¥i'hZ 53%-$iNi'§2'A8A§'«é .------  
am 23x1, E s':*RB;§;'<£f f '
€:LEVE;L&NE_) '"i'€')¥A?;"£  '
BA§mAL<;:RE: '-

6 AS$iU'K'f£§g.E{{3'MA§§£ff.  
:-3;%{g £;;5'§}"B'I:%;1_m_N£3?;=2:5AN  
12:10  E  % 
i{jLE;'v'i:";LAE€f)_VT€>SIV1ff€ ._ - -
;3AN<;ALu§::';:::"~.V   .~
 -   ...sc:;~;:::~,'~:;*m:':>&;;'~é';'s

{ﬁg ;S:'"i.=..B.{§,$'i€i_§§¥§§AE€}§?#, s:<.g:a>m~e:s»sc:L zwme SR£r:';iE:HAN€.}+?s
 -  .s1.;<-:.js;é::;s:":;_;.;:§,'r>3:3.fs:»2,, ,m'v;,.....;:?<€}R R1}

   ".i%\'i2';§_'_.%'1§_,«§:'3}.3 via 96; my (.1539. AGAH'-33'"? mg
dU'§3,£Z§EM?§_£'§_T'AND §ECREE DATED 39.11.2905 P3%.SSE§ xxx:
C}§:§_._NO.j.584;;..E'i 2999 cm THE: FELE :;;;:~ '§"HE I>=£XVI ﬁ£"3E}§,.C§T'Y

. <::mL ;=:,:a1:'>"sEs$ic,=za:s JUBGE, sgaavormgg, BAHGALGRE,
 :sEcR':?;,E:mCe THE: 315:? FGR E;.§E£'3'i'ME;I\f'i'.

" if ":31: '§?".«A.!i0.743i 20%:
'§E'f'WE$H:

SR} (3 §"é E¥<TEZV;§§'*§§'é§;

S] *1} £.;A'§'I:il (3.5% i'~iA{}P:i'E'A
AGED ABGUT 62 YEARS

RC} 46, P§if}$PET}§L Eiféﬁf}

EANGﬁ§,;£}i€i:Z Z"i">és(} £30}

,'.f§PP¥:Z LL.:'%.N'§'



 

1 S1'./}'l'§5 Ngumm t§§<£§h;}§*~££'v'ASAN
MA..3<:a§«': IN AGE   -
Mzgi :;L<.;m '1'AL,;<1t-:3, I
SHIVAJZ ROAEI),
snivmi NAGAR, , _
BAN<1.'vAi.(}R}:l 5&0 051 A:~.2_L;2'r._

=2 _ 'i".H§:: :>1s*r§<:<:fr M5<;;3;*§<A%:'-g,~.__ 

ﬁA,NGAi_.£}£€_ti s)i:;':'s«:.:m" '
BANGALQRE       
' 2 .§=;._Rt:§~;.i¥{'D.i'~l£).&iP«2'£'S

{'53: Sm: s:e::;Ta:3.:m~*;;:%é{§,=a .£§:5:~3i;){}.;A*; *,e:;:~§,";££_;w'; :--<'<.:«1< R1)
-"m~iV§:5..xa.«* iéésigf"g>;E--?§3:§A;.{}i1'§;i:;"s¢)--.:.;V[_:§ 4 {W 'ﬂit: iaA§<NA"i'5i§s;A
HEGH ;::(;uR*:f.;Aci:'F v";.i"--='1"~'-:rg»*s.?:;*~1~.:'**,~; TO SET AS138 THE 0R{>ER

PASSEE} 1:7; '"i7HE1.'*"=2JR§f§"'"~:?"f§E;*?I'?Eii}§\E NQQ554?/2005 DATED
2?;03/2336. ' "   

 'f':1;:;s %€E~'Ps§"€.1:fi3§? W}; izaving been beam and msezvcci 1331*

 .,Ju{§'g&§~:2*.n;e::11 511:1 ih_is*--:};:1;é', NAGARATHNF: J, prcnsunced {he

§2:ﬁ.i'0v§;'i31§::-- _ 

s}'UBGﬁ§__E__ 'T

 w;..3=;;§eva':'z49/2005 is ﬂied by pgamaﬁ mot-2 in

.  ::::,;\m:'5>a4;2; 1999 chaigengmg the attic? dated :g?.:;;K:20<3<a

  ' :lzf_. 3.i§::"'E3y 31:: i:3az*31€r.:E smgis éuaiigs 313:: 'e%i,§~'.f\3o,3£:~»<§rEé'?j2£}£§Ei,

2. E€E?ﬁ,f*éc».389f";«3{3U'? is ﬁiaﬁi by ii}-6 Sﬁélfiﬁfid gi:3§€:":<:£a::t :11

£.;K$KNOK 1$8(-":43 1' 1999 i3}? ::%§3.aL£e'z2g;'i1:.:.g 'me d1:::§gmcnt mid

__;:
M,/'



 

U€CI'€>€ dated 39.1 L2i}{)ﬁ, passed by the City fjivii §_3<.:>u;¥:t,

Mayo Hail Limit, Baﬁgaiert.

 F01' the sake 0f ('I3§1V€I1i€§}{§;3i flit? --j§éj§i;:é§s. Sifzaii §}€:" "

ref?e::1'eé ta in terms at 351912' $tatu$ iﬁatfc-gt .fi"i1£:'i;"ie1§ '<f'»:::i:{%:";-...  '

4. 5&<::c:csréi:':g has 131% pi.3,§:s'1_f:§.ﬁ"s  am ,7ii,§.1:<3' ?&b'é:g.§t:t£:"v.

€>§&m6rs 0f the Sui': S(3§1€€i£1V1Jié'  of Ii!I'€§1'£iSﬁS
Eieming §"§0'§)5"L'$;§:§'%.'§§%?1ji £§§ga;£%  :Ba11gai{:re-":31 and
the game ffifxzvgizras who was caiiryiﬁg on
ma E3§1'rséi:5:t:;'~::){':jfg;g1   £31' "fsiigin Taiicies"; that
S1zb$e€§3_;€i}.§"  ﬁt . £$ri3.1ivas, his wifét the: ﬁrs?

dzéilandaxit.€e;:0n.'ii1::.11e{i£_V b ﬁéé Emsiness as pmgziefﬁx 01:: a

~ V.   mat cf }£s,_;;§{_.3£;{}j ~, out 0fw§1iCi1 a sum of his. 1, 3233} --

'  p:§;t§..%i=3AV«fi7.§ ﬁrsi pia:;1tiﬁ' anti sum 0:" E<i$,1,$F§T3f ~ :0 the

'::'-;é<f::§f:1:1vE.V ggspactiveiy. "ii:-3: plaintiffs 'ngitiaiijg had fiiaé

a:14 €:<.§i€€§f3;0:i: pt:t:i!i0:1 in £~i£<":€j:.I'°~&c3,'§?4j 198'? on the $113 of X381

  "'ii:"§i.Srﬁa££ Causss Judge, Baﬂgaiaxﬁ anﬁﬁr Sscﬁozi '3E{}_'§{£§§

 csf t.E::_€: iiarnataica E-Semi éilcmfrrai Act, 19%;. T312 said

V ""ipeii'f:c:>11 wag ciisposeci {::f by was": dateri 3. i2«EQ€§8 as beiilg

:10': mai::1ia::1a§'::£e :irs.c:i tigeraaﬁez" rim piaziiitiﬁs eiﬁtermmaé the

isézazgttéy £33? V'§.f?.'i,1E {sf 3. iegai I}{3i';§{'f?{i ﬁaisﬁ 1Ai>a1'_9'_:?9 331$ §§'$.1"iCf3

i£i;e:": €;§€ff€f'§{§&§'i°iT,$ faiéad E0 C{}'§.11}}§f+; V€§i§1 {Em :;£<:=:§;a3§€%; made ms

1%



 

x. . a H "*4; .. mi; ,. «i LE1} . _; ai is

 

the pia;nt3};f:3,, me suit téx' fmssessigzx as Ta-"a:*ii as f%.3s3'€i:ii1:ag:2S

at {£35 rate sf §<;'s.:'£Ei>,{)€J{,3f -pm was iféiis-oi.

:35. E11 respmrse to {lag Suﬁ s11n3..:::o:'1s--3:11£'1'_'11csi¥:i¢e:~ bigiszzeiéé' £319

the trial <%-sari; Eiﬁftiilliaﬂi N0. .1 {mi Eéet  (x1@?1'iiie3§1'~5;Via:téﬁ,§er:2i;' _

but €315: saecomi {i€§7€:1<ia1:f'».f§j;&:{i irks .__Wz*i;;ii'£2g u"~-S4i:£§'£i::;ﬁ 2e:1t 'V

eozjtendmg that 'the pia§;{1i.ﬁfS.__. Eiagi Q0 1"igh*%_.,,i<§»'§ demarsd
pesgessicm :31' the suit $c=*i:«t:7{izM;i%:  {ﬁe}? were not the
aiasaiute 0\;§7j[},€I'S C*f fha  i:"%§fas s;iati€t€E"'ii1at ziafbngiams

3 to (':2 i3e_2;233::fg :?5:_§1§ , C:hii:£,;:'e::_..--   origizmi t6:3a_:1'£,

S:'i.ﬁz.f*€,-E531"iII1"=E;§iS€.%jE'A:V wctrér-. §;at'tra:§;§'§i as par'i1€s ﬂy way of

ab:m{£a1"1'{. CsiiiT€éca3:s;_  '5;):1i« '£a__ '¥:E1£;: 3i}S€':11€,'€ 0: a gtzziaiical
z'€éaE;é<:::1si:§.§'3,"§£1t:'s.;zit-ﬁsas' "£153, J.i:1ai.:1ta::1ab£-3 as against mam

311:1: mare W33' :10 :*:3as¢3:':: £0 _pa§-* {:£a:11ages ami imﬁce scatigéli

V' "d,;s::';iS1$a§,"of i:%;;e 3:113 """ H

:3. "  Ns:>,.';§= gist: s£:aie:'i that We persons ciaﬂnisgg

   §§}€iﬁ§3€I3i€3.§IA3.-1' ﬁghtg c3€3uis:$ net 133125 3 Siagié 210'£;;ce and ﬁiﬁi

 é *f_£16_ s%1:§.£ 321:1 t,E1€:'€fm'e., iize rsqzliramani of rzoiica uzzcﬁer

 ___' "Sﬁ(V'."i13€'5§1 .E(}<'i> of "£"ra13$}:§2' cf §"}'€ip€I"tj;%°'" Act was {mt eampﬁﬁci

 VW1ﬁ1; that the géiaiziziiﬁs has! 31:0 §OC1_18 gtazldi 13:3 £33113 9: glingiﬁ

301193 03;' ii; iiie am: 31231? 33162 ihmaiicrm sgmgiiii €fiE':ﬂ1iSS€i§ 01*' {ha

sagas, i}c::fsI:z£,£a:':t §'~%<>sx¢§~ E2; 1:.) adspteii figs s¥;r":tt€:1 statézrjzeni





 

ﬁi::'~:€£ by ma mini defendant. 1)é2I€t::::1da11t i'%<).(": ié;i1c3{i ta a;::;}¢::a'r

311:: was piac:s:::£ exgjaﬁﬁ.

?. 021 the basis; of $16 abcsveit piead;i11g:~:;, '€£1¢""t:'?:..'«§?;;£~..

f;-ra_me€i the ftrsiicywiiag issues:

" 13 Wfzetfzer p!a2[r'z£z}j{  g§fé'zIrie7S  _ #25::  2°f:§3._V  'V

535 endanis L',.'9f'{:Z' !F:ea-'r IQROJEE3 z'n_"'r=.:eS* £225: 52*" 52:3}. : 
. , 1.. _ .

3(}z.e(i*7:1fe premisézs beazirgg I¥'O,#';{._ }"f.,_8 azui {in 23 3
mei2Z}2§g; remfézz' of Rs.,3f}U-fifw {i.<i:;., 5?s:-Z£25;{_-->v«--v£q. 
pfa:'nz';'f}"1"*2"a E amtf Rs. I,8?';;'3?f -'*--:fa pI(zir'{5g'ff';'::?e}L.:2? 

L.

.   __ 'p{az'z-2:'g;£§s Ezcfmete pz"operi§
ter?72i:ia£:2_::i'*!E::e iariaizﬁg 5:3" {Egg ééfejéztcfazzts?

" EEH/{zé$fie;r_';g;§§i.;'rz£§j;f,E§"tz:re erzﬁilad £0 arzg;

cia:z:?2z:_2§e:=;,*  3;: :2! :3;-%_:a:1 ream."

'  4.. Wiieifiér :!é_f=:=m:fan:s pre:me tizaz' the Suzi:

af 2326 ";;i:.:inzz_'ff?" 11$; §2zL'::.:'I§ for m=is~jo:}'zd.-Er {sf parfzés
gzmerrgf cczuse ;:g;"ae:€:'<:z;':.>'

 2,:2i':.:2i reiiejls 2352.9 piggiéziggffs e',ZI'£3 §:2"aii€Ea=:5é?
V 1 git. f§3i»'.§;*§'f1i decree 0}" <3rdez:'~""

xi

fix

 8,  :::; V15$.11§:$€;:£"t 015 3133* {raga the pi *r1i:3:'1i€exammz=:{i §~'%;&:',£

';§é::;::;~;;i ﬁ:£E§;E.E13'Iiﬁ:} 311$ gm :33a1'§§eef£ isjxﬁl to P34 wifziis 33:15

. A'..{§;;»€f7:€ﬁbfi€3}«':_?f1?€S ;exa1::::_216(§ i}§&',Z §€£:3i?»<:':::?§a:1i ?€<3.2;'a§3'§}€§§a:1:

~  :i5e:*€:i::} :~m=;"i gs? markszi. §i2x.§,.3.i is £_V}<'ia

9. {E31 aim bagzs of $12723 ;;11ate,:"iaii 0:3. :'@<:r{:2r{i, the 'ma; <%m;1'I

{§{:*<:r€.¢3:§§ f.§:€ ::-:»:,:r§: a'§"s<:§ :§i:'z:e:'i{:<;£ €3.15? €i@f:3.:1::§a1:.t$ £0 izazkgi G'€f€i"



 

vacaiai {.}C3SSES'5§f£{}§}. at tin? 311:1' sei.'u:('1uit3 'pr€:'m:s£s ta: giaizzisii"

§'40.'2, vs;-*1t.£:i_z3 'i§T:I'€':f': :11«;):1'i:§:s ifrom {E16 (tats: (}i'__§11€igI1ii531*i"._é;£T:sf§~v.i!3

gsajg fiafﬁagﬁﬁ at the rz«1t£% of iv{:3.1(},(){}€;¥[--  .

a.gg1':m«'€d §}§;' me 3316: Jutignaezﬁ. a;}£i L}ec';€é¢':;--- ::t;;'v.i»«:% 'vv:s€:a;$;:»V:"2L_-:1'; 

ziefcztzgdailt. oniy has :§_?JI'8if:1'1'1§€i this a;:p&:'_:i.T A. 3

10; We izave kaeard $:~§1*i.C3r,:~§,4\v'1swe':=~jwéa1'a, {3*;:::1m;:5ci §:§¥:z1i<;r 

Cﬂiifzﬁﬁi fax' 811. H, M. Muiaiid :V<":.~t}11_«1113€i' .  ' v€:l1f:.' :§§i§.;}V_}61iﬁI}E
and S11.3:311}.Sttic1i1a1'a1:; "'i€a_11_fi§é%£_   for Mg' S.
?5}"i1'811g£i   §03§': r'i'€'.§ V  1' ' rfavaatel'.

1 1.  t;§:<§V'a§);".%iia1:i that tile tzfisiﬁ
<:%m.1;:*t :'i;Ea:i£:jf§: 1 the iwtics 9:' te.1n;1ma'£:u:3:T: :3:
ie4:1a11c§.?i2?a4S "E1*C3'i.'*s?é1i£t."A§:'  E}: as z::u.1cE1 as piia:t'sﬁ*§}" N0' 1 6:. '2

Wear; ':;::\>?;. <?<;~L<;>w:;:¥:1'"s' 0f *~:;ir1e §;)1"()}"3f31"§}' gmci fJ:i€3reii:;s:*::2, t.§1€}-* zstxghf.

 tags  E:av%3' ':s§<§e:§:{i .z.":«:3%:_1{%€5; in ihéii' ijxdzmciuai zzamgs-A it was

  iE:.:*i:ii€:;t. :z_;:E;§E::i'£f€:{£ that rim s::o:::s:1:;i piamfsiﬁ' was 1:0? fifiﬁ'

Oﬁ:'~33_.€}" zf.-£3   sci?:s:£u§€ jﬁfﬁiiiiiﬁﬁs; thai aﬁier 'aha ﬁimg 9f the

 23:21? !i%:;.s:j_ éfﬁﬁséi §=ia::1£iﬁ7' exscrzifed ﬁfiﬁ 1Yi'.§€f?ﬁS€3 dﬁﬁd in iaisoui' {sf

'£526 :$;<éc¢:r11(i p§a'131.f.:ﬁ'{§.a§f::::i 10, i.k2{3£}:;§ E§,I}.{i *i£1€:"€afi£r fiifxi an

€§.§3pii<?a£',:::::1 8:) get hfif' ﬂame éieietezi, W116 fixzdmg :33' £116 "£1"i&§

c:<:>m"£3; wttiia. rﬁgarti 1:0 :;)w1}€1's§3:1:= zrjsf €316 §3.§a31H:ii:Tfi in the Siiif:

5/

2'



 .   ,  . :3 , ; ig sj . 4 L 

   

$€'f-izﬁdtiiﬁ pI'{}§}€I'§",}Z was :10': in a€{:t3i"tia11Ce: Wiitétz iaw aj:1{§,_ iizjizciei'

U36 Ci.1'{fu}3:1S?iﬁ:{}C£3S the dtzcigmcxu and. Becme is  A' V

1'2. Leaxnezi Scztzlar L1s:;z1:1sei aisscz 3.cive2*E;e:;f"<t{} 366.1193:  V'

of me '§'rf:.1st fie: 13:3 Qﬁlﬁﬁiid that. Iizffié iimsé ﬁ:.Q:1¢{:€iﬁi§;§:a}1-§:'e 

aha said pmvisiotri £11 £116 };nsta:1*£: caéacz zaj;:s__€£. {£13 95;-;:<%s::v1::£i«. §3"1a_& §j1';:ifi'5_V

bang U16 b€11e.ﬁcLar§«' cwf me ~€::ii~.:~";_: did I3Q'"§~,Vh3¥é";Ei3'§,}' si&t*.1,:s 

stanza is ﬁie ths 31,11: §3::?.;*f;.}€!.;ﬁé€;*If'£i,s*-._A in tﬂ§1':;;-.. .r~:_.E'3s&:1c6 GE

Ceznpiiance Witii {ﬁiaﬂéé ' 352  ijieeci' Lsartiﬁsti

Seﬂiar {jaogxﬁé-1é:«§.V  V2'-::};;;eé{g£"*~.*;:1';~g;r3';"s.._V '«Ci3i'{ai;£} £§€CiSiGI}.E':- which

shaii §.3,€- ad Vréitﬁgi  at  .i2§;f.c:r S"s;ags:.' 

iii. E:-?_e1" , <;<3:ifi£'5:z',"V-.. i-3:.-"rizzier Catnmsﬁi for ma f§.£'S'{

I'€8§)O}1€i$E'1-€'§9%7§T}i§§' s€i§%;3c;i*:§.1ig tips =J11££g::t;e11t 331:1 Beams of

?.§1eco:1:f'.§?_:§§$ stégted that. '£116 trtiai Court: has rigi":ﬁy'

"$I§S{§"3'3i"é{i' £3313: R0, 1 5:, 2 in tile aiﬂiirmative E1116 issue 940,4 £31

:i1ie"_ﬁéga?f:t§e  §.}»i-15% €i$c'r€ed the 32;}: in ac:-<:0rda:3.r:>8 *e&::?£:E3.

£a£x§';<«._ '£"f§:€ -§)«f6ViQ11S procsedizxgs bazwéten the 13a3"'€i&s wmzici

'A   "ais;<:> si2;3--;302*é: ﬁle f;.:1{ii:1gS arriveci at E3}! £1216 trig} comm; that

" --ﬁ1:=3. .§i€:i7€:1da:3£s am fi11§€:I'$S"{'.€':€§ 9111}? in squattizgg mg the

.V  ﬁﬁd 'iZ§3€§'ﬁ§f}j$ iiépnvﬁ 331$ gzviaintiff (respca:::{:£e::'i §'é<),}

Eaeiwaizié the ﬁght £0 611jO}_.~" t§";.+.:é §_}1"0§}€1"'i}:2 He iilrtizzfi' sabmyis

ihai" filfi <:rs:w:':f§::'i":(>1';$ :z'€ga;€€i:::g :2::>:1~<:*C;ﬁ:;::£:a1:c€ '€§»"i'{§3 31$

Q/y



 

§:mv1.=s3r::a31s :31' iizti 'i':*us's {3;€T"{. and 'iiiéi iéﬁzmserss of tim '.i':'t:sst §_}:=:E:{i
 '{.ec:i1:1iCai in :'1ai.um Wi1.ici1 in :10 X  cam supper: firm CE-1S§€:'t

03' fizs: ap;::&iia2:x'i: or 'me 9313:' <:i:ﬁ{~::1cim:is. He -- fViT:.f:€_i*&_i%:sV:*e,

ssubmiéits that °£'.§'.t.f:i a:;3p(~:ai 13 aisvozci of 1:1e1ji{---- za.3;§:;'i; v: ;i:aei'ie,é 

res:gui:'a3 ta be {§§.Si3111E5S{<i:i.   ._

Efqu fiaizmg iieani the Cﬁilﬁﬁﬁi cs':§;._b{:é€.§1 Si€i€:fTfg':,. fix =f{i;$.:;E§é»'é?iV1i§3:VV

§!Q'£I1'€S 81';iSi:": for 0111' <:t0{::<sitie:'a€:aQ'ﬁ;--;b

1   1"~-w1§z.ei:"tg::f__' ':§.I'ze*'7' r':«r§'f:'<:§» issued by $118
;.'?czz"2:-:§:j,§"':_'_'£:';_ zhe {§;3fE?f'£.:.'3€23'i'§S :17: in czc.c3:':ia.nae wit}:
   s  V  
_ gag Vi{}fi?:¢é1i;e§*-23:23 sax: jiied by me p:am::;ff" 3'3
?"§?;Qf3"3££2f?'I§g'55§Q' v:r:~":':;: 'l:;:.?=;':3." zsssqis, ::.*E:.:af§2:2:* gaigzirzifﬁ'

f¥"d.L,.§{ 316.2,-:i the §':}a:3'L§.s1:;:£2.nrii :%<:r_f"'i§€: '£316: Su%Z.=~"

 5'51: 3.593252: :'eé:efs {fie izniirmffs are? ezziiiieszd
:_w_ A. .... ..

2 £13,'  %«":9_r;;-:.;1':.}:é :3;":a§:e1°:ai :33: re<:%o:'d, it is wizieiii that '$316 gait

ii{(<3.si EV}? t3s;'.{¥§: p.£a3;1¥;ifi"was t§:";r&}e<:1:mm1t 311:1 <:£a:z1.agﬁs a:i'1::i the

V " gigixifiﬁs f}?{'3'f€€:£§; for uiuiigmeiit agﬁﬁii E}€CI'€i€ céireciizzg me

 €§t:'fe:"1Cia::t.$ its sur:*€:1€§€:;' *sra€a::1i §}Q'3S&$Si{}ﬁ Sf Ehxz amt

Tscizaiuié §;;:€:11;:$6s amfi is ggiajg: giagxagsa at ms mm of

E-és.2i*5,{}€3{}; ~ gym Emu: aim {iﬁfﬁ 01:' the 311%? iii} i":a::3.£img Giffii' of
}_}{§SzS€iS~Sé=i£0§"L 'i".E2€ said suit ix:='as iii;-':<,£ .5311 tits: fseaz' E%§'.~}9 aiiisr ﬂit:

€%'£'€§£i',3' §:a$s§:§§4 £2: §£%€€i,3,?*>é§:a..':3"£"4§ §';}é:§';%'S c:§ai.€<:§ 1%.. 32¢ E.%Z€:§%§g §i:_£:3s:i bf»:

,9'/1



 

me p£ai:1i1}:§f€~: i.'§€3'2'€§;iT£ ageuilai. €316 giei'iz:%m.1a1'1i. i'«i'<:§s.I Ex; 2 ixezﬁm
1.

i11€}.E':§' &§€w;?'£;;<:;11 2£{T£}{E1} £35 {3} 6f .§*=;a1':1ata_%{a Rent, Controi Act, 1953 was ﬂak: to be :10: mamiauzable 111 View 01:"t&'1e C§€3!§.'§§§1;(§11 075 this Stipreme {}<:2m'{' ;€¢3fp01"if:ci. in J!' 1993 {'}r'} €:§{f Suzi. s<::16:(i;t.1i€ '§31'€Z';E.1l1S€§S "IS a 1.1(311--I'€S:c§_€:1t1a1 one iéicia/::igL.':'€:i{:--T ' sf 31:31:: than Rs.;i${}0f~. '5'i1€I"€i{)}'ﬁ,mf§'I.€ e.:{%:it:'1';;:I3:ii_i<Ts3:5'"=::;1:{i€:5' S€+ct::013. 31 of me i<3€:1Ei Clolliroi wais. :'ag§;)§i<:a3f::i_e"' eustssﬁi i;£'1ejmésdi<:§i»::»1: {£11€i€1'V»ifu§": §€€IiZ_C»{3'E'£II'C'--§V}5xﬁ}3f,. '19{3:'§. ii':

féspect Qf thus :":(31:~I'€:S1£i.€:;:1*£::ai pi€:1;i:s€$ 1v£i::1'e:"1::~i}t was 3103?; thatn i-$3. 5:136 in 1':"tfk?l£'3I'v"f'i~T'-'§ :s3:ei;iW0'1fi{i:I' '"iL.%1.$ pre53r511$;"Vsuit was "§i£e(§T a11§':z<.is$i}:f§ig :€s;:;i_i:g&:§.. i191'éiCi.é'zj.a,§;g.«_5i i.ii>'19'_--.§':% E i:l:X,%~'1?'}¢ if). ités :é;i:é+;:; .Qi"'31g1::}ﬁE1?a11e€ to note ihaf. aariier, §3ia:':1iiﬁ' Na. Ti; £*1e1'ég::§§. 8;E'}.{'i' t;i.:fé Vi)ia:11'£:iﬁ" £6-23.1239 S::1.{2.§{.F*%agappa had a ssizii ;«::gai11S i' .h1:.s;i3a:::€£ 253$' tiara: ﬁrssi; £iﬁi%¥};1€§éii1'€ '"'aha.**--<:§::é--.";as:.,észuzaii :;:é""€;:§:§.:~.:<;x:>z~1i 29132 on the me at am: <_:::%:;?' ;}';§§£g¢," §§»'%§.'€§ H31; £.i::i't, ﬁangaiorﬁ Séékiﬁg €;Vi{,"i301Zt 1:}:

€316:.§i§3i£=:13:::§afi:f*§::i*,:3::'0;:11. '$11!': §;{rh€:::§.11§:3 p."i'£)'§3€i'i".ff mid £61' meavmy Kg? z'€€1t."-:f i=€*s-;( 3 3 3100; -- ami feta' iiziuiﬁ mssrstae }"}I'Cif.§'€S, Yxiae sated V" 3:;¥.i_i '€535 s:i€:0:'@:é{£ W'i'EE'1 rétgarci E10 szaizifg" arriiaréé 05 1% :11. £701' ' §<3:'=.1_},'5¥~{}{}f--, §:>?t;:*s was diisiiliﬁﬁéii in $0 far as {$26 Qiéfzei' r€.§.i<:7ef€; %»*;-"€223 {?(}D(Z°.€i§'.£1€id %.r:<?£:,i:{:§'i;3g ihﬁ Z'43§1;§3f{§i§:€ZfV§€f'i';§,€3§'L fzggrievati Egg' gm: gaigi g§m'ig::1{::2§ :§:':«:'§ §}€Z'.".*i'E§'€:':%i s;§.ai€«:,:£ 1-3&3 .'§..1¥T§':«}"L?<§g 3'i/2 i'<i%"é..§"é{;r. ff 1'.;£%YE:s W33 ;;'::'e3':f?{:':""r=:':£'i bif'§;:}§ :: this (#01131, {ji'ii£'i£1§__€i§'1€ §}€'§1{'i§3'i'3.Cfe;' <3? W.i1i{:i§.§, {L§€.§*%aga§33}a ciiﬁti 2131:: E,:>I'*21:1gi:.:g E115 iégai 1'é£"§;I'e';"3£}11'i£?1'iiE'¥€% W35; ﬁi€:€£ E41§}£i€i:' ;i§;)§'C§L%3Vi"'1 hiizia 4 €_.i§»'<_1 aild {mi game was aazﬂ£ia>1:?¢:%%;E;»V%:>_§g ﬁziéjis <:0§{:i;'f '§Z%:§'x{'%:'i'E'§V.¥3§I'.'V {§:?i'iC£:?€I§ 2€;.,'?,19}'E:; . .. . _ V , 1'?' , in E'§7£1'}:}'p{}i"i '.:';§T his casts? ma {'S€fC:{;§'£}(§. pia;::;.i:I:%i£ iz~;*£:e: *%:_:§%'5':- ci6p€;3e£i $13 PW,1 zémd 130$-'i?€'i' €3.f""~§}_.?'I:fi)I'£1€3}7 "§3f£§§{§€~}i-1 v:>fg;3ia331iiﬂ'- {W}. 1 has siiaisztii mat ii:-;..._ ._pia§1':%i§:' §£:'a1"e i'.§'};€ a§3$<';i:1£:6 02ar3r,aéf:é%~s:>§"*~'£.%ii'q:. §s;e?.:j:-r:=::i":;":.,¥,g3"'}.3fei11;r§;es§ 1:18? ﬁrs': pizarésai Ezad ££i;'8;'<"'~--r:;_E"z.%.~;§i*»:::. a:1 é£i::,._b:: i:.gz;i--.::"";3;' ?3'*"*-:r31"é3.t'c; '£213? Z is :"3j8'h SE95': was €33; '%;*;%r'::i2:i*. cf .'i';E"'EJ.€§'{, }.3=e£~.€£ €::>s:e<::'ui€gi Eafg ms fe'1§::.§1€r, §.E3é7 »__;>;iigi11Vai_ {Em-Es:i.. '.."Was ;3z'<}¢:i1;;<.?m§; ai. %:';x.E'2'. <§at€td

14.¢%..4.§A95.':§;., :}1a£'E§;'.§3vU'é {@1313 was pi_1;Z"'C}1a,€:€d by his fatiatrr 0:1 E 3.2125 3;€}A;:?E.~? aﬁgiv $5131? €333 ﬁrs: §}£ai11':ii1'§1&d get 8.16 reznaiizitzg j_8V°'"-?_VV$Ef£2::?év..}3}~ﬁ;" '%.%371'tu€ af an aI'bi'¥€1*aﬁ?G11 awaiﬂ Wizich was :iz3x:*1"§§'-.€*.4:,'£ 'kéariiéir '£0 £161' :1 %}€'i(:r:z1g€:£i {xi} Eiizfxz" gra::<::~3L:&E}:i:3:.', Pafxamiag who: fhaii gzurctaisagéiai 818 3313113 by 835: (13:33 " €§'€3;5.Vi€§i;§."A.2:i§.;3, 3929K '%"§1€: &;:€:.'i1€5iu.§€3 j31'Q;}é%1'f§; '§éi?8;S iaaseii ':10 " §:§§*i:':i¥2:sa:1 am: Eiaa: ﬁzz': r€:'::3: 31:1 }"€iSs}'}f':'{Ei 5): we §::;€=;3§,:~€,-r'*s;t}»* was a§.3;}{>;z"i*.:<:::"3.z3§é §.}€:'§"§§Eﬁ'f.i§"§ ﬁié ;)§.a.::1'£1f§$. .%Cs:'s;:1":ii2:'::g "£3 :*%;£ 1., %:1§~:y E~4'E:e is; %TE.1@ €}1'{'€§6§' e::§z»z:,&<:i 26).'? : }9'iif:: V€§.}.€L'--3'%E,'§f}}? .§'::;:=; was; §3§"<:>1:g1f:€.

{:.2§':. ;'€+::.r:3:'£;§. as; éagai i¥':§.}TE'§§$€££i£'%?§E?i5 <3: §'}_iti":§ $7":-:i£,§::3:" in , uvxel-. awx-e E~M~'.;'£,%é9J?; 19'? 22 2131:: tiiat £:.::§t::2"s wsritten by £iei'€:1€§2:"§i:3 are at i:35<:.i'€> is E'}Jf>, §;i:x:§'1.'f", ﬁegai nsgmce, sziaieazi I§:{.T'>,.'§';'Z;3.';:3:',:»'-"_':;'¥;"v§"c:¥,.'?;i' issued by the gsiaiiziiffs £11121 the pcysiai acK;1ow*i'&;:1g:ﬁen€.sA émf V' at EZXJJEE 13:13 £323 and the ::£€iA€:1{ia::i$Wi'sé};;:i}{_ a'£«£:_§§; E8, in cmsg exazzzmatieia i;:i: '1E:a$ a§i;1"2:i%i:::;ci:'v_;%i1aé2v*:VM;§§i3_:1::t::£f V' i'-30:1 mad he ﬁaare ztaceiﬁzgtzg 1'2:r:1t::i.. $1?}§;'E":;""?.9§i€ify"'. i.é:s"ﬁ:£9:€X{€11t 0:5 {Emir sixazes and that §:'é'7'.a:t:_-;::.:£ ¥.s.?§1*& 3931:: e:aw3:1«:":z"$ ma ffiéli. ;}riQ:' :9?' d:%:§§ii§§gi i€.3J1.2{,?{"3(:§, .§3:=, did 110: ha:v€e'2?2ii:§f'V fV?§"¥s}1ar€: owtzai by E1151' piai:1t1?1f}'..§?%éQ._§iV';..%:}:$1E:;j§§4e =3ﬁ§'...i§1:§e pmgjerty Wag ﬁéfafiiiiiig 1'11 his :i;a1:--x€ ---S',13"'* Silalﬁ and ix': tbs 1131115'. sf :i)l3iI1T_'§ﬁ?"§€':?{ ,1' 833 sham and E113: muzziaipai E:-sxagj xiiezfesi b:33§é:g.._fg:ra:$ :s=s;3ara'é::=;ify', i"'£C¥¥-'v"€iV€E.', Em has €§€3:1:e{i '{.§1.~%"€' 'i§:€ éjixzféﬂgiééxitﬁ are §£~::1a21'£$ s€.:_:>a;:'a£.€£j§ m:z{ie:r £12111 mm L"::i'1{§}:2T §;'>§:3¥§;;:%,t3Li::'§{ 'i"*~§$. 1, but £15: ﬁgs stated fikaezt as j{:si1;1E i3'i3i7--'i'}€fE'§'> i§1e"E§::1a.:i<¥}=was f,€1'm3i;t:at€(: 311$ not :«se§::a;t*ai,€£_V £0 {£16 €X'§.6I1'fi ' -- .. bf igizeair ?:~.;;%'ia.i"€s.

.. 8:1 3 perusai 9:' $316 dc:-zrtimezzigra get ma;;"i<:e(§ E3}? {ha VV ;;}£aiI:':3§§S, i? 113 36:33:} that. £::x.}'T2 :3 {ha '£52135: i§£'":€€i C;iE>T£;Tif€€i E.~<¥A»; fi'§;i32f:g 1131652' Wfp;~::§1 :~3;:2;{,1§w£.Naga;§pa {E36 faihsi' £2?" P925: '1, 1.2313 au'{E2a:;s:' cs? ism: £";msi., grmaieii gs; S€i§;}23_'{'€§EZ€ 9231:: é11{§€*§}€§1€§€f§:I. \ " =z.,= .-'I 7.

,''~.; :1 . 155:: . \.:a.- _.' » ;_ '«w~*'--.,;; L. . H J? .333. . £i<:1- :":\.J . 4.121,; 12 Efiiﬁi". of me 'pmg:>e1*t:i€:s beiengmg to 3:141:31 for U16 bezzeﬁzi and €::}oy":z3e11t. {pf his SEX sons E}.I}.{§. £3115: iiaugiater £3}? a$3:gra,ﬁ;:.g['§.i1€ p:*z:>§3ert§€ Ixzemiczaeci ms {:16 trugt €£E:€€i to 11:16 iZ_E"':_I_S'%f'f'€;'.".3'#'.7.";v,:. . '¥:1*u$1; ::1Ci1:<:i:L3.1g; iiiiﬁ suit. !:3C§1f3€5;'!;I3.€' ;;1:30p$1*t;;;' " i'rt1s_f.€§s 1.473% given 'szajgrgzgszzs §::v€;w-'erg far <%:a:.1*1'<§;::11§j:---<:vj;..ét: 212$ Ei1é"0i53ék:..:s'1A:s3.i' Eh: hug: am: the 'Er"€:sta3e:~:s' -were "air; '*:tta:1sf€"1€_' Q16 _f'm1S'Z:. » }_3E"O§}€.'{'fI€-S E9 the S€€:O;€1{i _{E-"W, 1'} ﬁfiié b§§:m:£ie:a:'_¥ U.1}£iEI' ﬁiﬁ iru-'st aiasoiuigéijé? 01.; 11:iSi '.(x,'?i'§.§31;£L);i€»'§7.'§i"lg 'Q15 age of 21 §='€81'S aim £5.16 E1113: piﬂgygxféiag Wészraf; f3"'§2:1$£5é:3'6<:i to $13.13 as pm' ciause ':2. ..i_€= e:{¢é;;:§",5ja:_1» ;:§. 12¢3.'€~;}€:98 'pa.sss€-z:i in ﬂR{3.§\éQ_.9T?=%'f'V1_§'£§»'é?;,:_§§.7i;a?i§t.__ E:§2:;§?é7;HV_ me: z.§3..1€ig'EE€1"}?f. dafseci ;sa;,11,:'ji.£::z<;~ 1:; 'Ng;3m;}vv:.9':;é, i:";:s:',Pt§ is me: Gztiez' datﬁci "g.<«,~;};€.-22%;: 1_::a5--;s€€i »-- £;é'§;f5£,§'€{:r.?;1Q'fE$ as.:£:e:.~e:;3; 3: Wéas ﬁutfggiitsri 021 E73§;if;é:if 9f'i§1e agzpéiiant in the saga: appmi tiqaég 'i§1.r::V};Qa"§'£i§"§A:&1' %§%?'Tz:"::$ $€€:t.i&(:i out 0?' {mutt am iélﬁffﬁfﬁrﬁ ?.%1<=: appaai ¥:§§:."2':i€f{T{?§'{"iiI1gi}:'. §<:x.%«'E:>ga} is 123.1% 0163:' Ciéitﬁfi 3€3;?.,1'§f?"6 .'§:ié~'i$s€€i Tn: }~i§~"'ﬁ,§'~é0;?f 1':%?ifS §)i'::£1gi§1g £'§'v';1 $151333 K "i'3AAS j%,E:s.€.,Es::sga5. repmgexﬁtativa sf Q23 f?3S§f1£31"3{'§€3i1'§ 5%. 1. in the 533::

gygmgéia }:£»;<;§§:a{"3 :9 9.25 are me £€'s%.e'z's {fated ";é'.5,1<;;="c::§ __2;._5:;;;:9'z';:: zﬁzgsaﬁ 3{}'é§¢.1':}ﬁ"}'1 '£E,&.3.E':§?'§&§, 7Eé},?,¥&, I{}x;«3.E}1, .1€L:>...i~§.9*'i,., E€}x$,';§.i £3}; 'v;'E'::Ci: 1':5:n':s £§?€:I"=E: pram ta %30fé§::

that §}§8_'iI1?iﬁS .§1f:};"€ii{L §:;l:»:,£r'§.';i' :5; 816 {rap}? rjsf the isgai mmce iS:'§"ii€€i an b(=:.§:8Jf Q1 i:s<:)£§1 §,§T§.{"3 péagxzfiﬁi-"s §":é:3i€:ir:. Wixeraéy {.216 iv , :__ '--,. "=_,}w "'5 r= ',, Q .»-( "< ' '"_: ..-:;'~ ':;'---'g,-_ ."<' " 1'1 . A\€s\.') . 3&1 J' . 4 L'':-\«; 2' r_ . 3%? 35 . K"; . ;'e:./' . = as . 5.. 2./x,2 2'

29. £3 -::v3:spe::sea:i to this evizémace, iyvkhi {ﬁe appeﬁiaizi harem has stateezi in his t:v1{:§,e:..11C<é 1313.1: rim 1533139}? ii} itspéct of gfgth Sham ané 3182:: sham 0f the pianxtiifs are separatﬁ; £113: £116 ﬁmt pimiitiif is the OWZIEI' K V' and 1313 second ;}};ai:<1I:i.i}' :15 the ow'::Véi:V<;$i"5,( 8%" s,}1a,i*'t:«;. _:}1é;:"fl1£:

gjiamtjtiis are not <:»::»oW115;rs Qf su1é:..__ :~{<;:i;:e«:;£ui€ _*pr0pr;:%1*t:v=.' 'am:-,' that 3 single Silif fiieci. :3); ti1eI:1: i§_110t V. ma~i:';fai:1a§:sVEé'VVa7s' ttxejg V' have s::i1s.i;mCi xnaiiia az;:--t:.i S11E£IZfi;"' i§'§1a :i'33if.11S'i€6':~"i' '£13-:1v'V¥:<:: ﬂit? {E16 suit in terms of E:i:ss:.,P';Z atiig 3?!.I';f{%;i. §1en<;>e the sun:

filed; in the 42131118 gcii" Vfiazfs .'sse}g:r;§11<i g;:i.a:n1:3ii[ was 119: mamtamabiaii; 'ifiaai; 'ihaé «.1i§?>'€5ia:f:" $330'; was not in aeootriazice \ar:I:i1 gaw, _fi1ég_'-.v _§i:3c€-- é"1?z.:;;. _p§a.111'i;f:'s };'€€?'€iV€d £116 1'r:r1t.s s3€;:§a:'a:€1*j,~j, 4' €116 .f,<:i':r::1,;né£3_€i:': 0:" f€I13I1C}--' ais-:3 had is EM; 3a::';}a:g"33;€ i':je:11er:é's=:3i2gii1: gm dismzssai sf 121328 51111;. 5': mpy 'xof t§?§é 1;s::t::i¢:s.;: :'i£e<:§."i:?«.§'§§§<L:.r~:<;s.9"m»j 1'9£:'>'Ebc:f<:s1"€ I116 iiourt or

-- %i::'£3;f;'1ES£'%Vib'§_ E3:83E"igai€3ifi;'3 pxmr :9: firm 3111si':i.tut:§::s~n Gi' the pf{;$£§i1t §1:'i'z §,:~;és mariszeai as 5:134} .1' EZ:=s:J_)i2 is the fiEjf:{}8Ei10;E1 ._€)f' {\,,':.i'*é',_E~'-h;:.ﬁ}a3' in Hi€l{§.P*5£:}.9'?4/ 1':}c':$'? Wfliié }:f}X,£}3 is fjbé "€§€§§S_3_.'{i30i1 «:3? piamtiif N023 13:1 titw: said case, :i§<:.§}é"§ is 3:6: ' ziéfpggitioztx gi'pi3;t1t13fi¥ N91 312 the said. case.

21., £13 ms <::r0ss~eXa1::::1at:i01.1, UW. 3. has s'{§;€z:{£ ifzai realizes:

i8*':9{} §:;i£g111 '".i;'.¥.1:::atr{: was rm': E3}? E30i{£1;1g {irama s§':c2v$:s§ by his

22. in further <:1*0$s~eXami:1at1€s3:2 he has statad 13131:. he {iii} not rcceivﬁ any iagai notice Sam. by 1:113 <1-ounsei fear the ;::ia:i1t1ﬁ 110;' did 31:: "sec. eive any iﬁtiinaticsxi ups}: tile 6Xc:c?:;'€i«;":_:1 of the miease {£663. £11 E}X.U1 Wkiich is {£16 __';jiét1't:'s__~>--:1: V5:'g_1u H§{(Vi.N<:;.9'?4/198?, the g1'c:»u11c:is Iiar seﬁkittxg. ~€,*?*.%';:1A'C:f"{?].1V§1)VI.';::-V.::i;i;Ii}(;i£f'7':1""

Sectaon ;31éZ1}§i":} ii; {3} of tips: Act 33*; '53't:8,$;t;:(';§.. --_ depesifian. of S;:1;.L,1.N,§<;131nar wizgy is iii»: 3'r:>11119;€£".Ai>vi'0ii:t3:§: '(';'-:3' *' 'ma p.ia1'11tii'f No.3 iZ1€1"€ifl wheiﬁﬁk tile s<::he{£u£e p"i'Cip€3X'iff;»' bei0n§ 't9 H1 case I1€:}}3Lf.€i}f the pia1'11t;1;ﬁ's in ' 23:3. at tiais ajppeai has been filﬁci zylgifg} 1"???" f.:"'§ €:1'c"V§$uit anci that $18 9333:"

(i€:f%3I1€i%§:;§§}.iS" §_e.a.i2e: 21:31:39.1 by €fi1a,E£€1'1gi§"}g 'ﬁle Judgmeni", aéiagi 'L3¢c:j€é'..;;i::«§,'%{1g:1:éc£. it is aims 115%. in (iES}i)"lLi"£1€ ;'~éc:§."i_,V__£_1_a{i 3j8m Shara 3111 the $I_1:i'€, gcrimeziuia 33V§?V03'§:P,1't§§#__é::¢i«.Aﬁiaigztiif ?~é'o.2 33351 5; 855" sham mad that. piaiziniﬁ' ?~ié).1'~§1aS%;%;icci:=fé€i a zﬂaasa fiﬁﬂﬁii in :%:av<:rs.1:* 23f 33£a1i11t:ﬁ¥' §€o.£ j vis:£e '§:'t.;s<§"§:%f25:i;" 313:. after an: Sz8_'i€i fact was braugilt :0 {E35 4,;:ot:£%§ {he 002.111, 9:331:23} §'é0,1 wag dsieteizi :11 iilfj' arrajx; csi

-- ;h::'a1i:3.EéAs by <::3:'s:i€1~ eiaieci 9,E~.}%.2{3{}i;3 and. 111%: suit was cantxnusai V' '"%:§*_<; ;3§a3:1?1ifN0.;£ 0315;. it is 8130 339335 C9111", {fem '£5336: §€<?:3r€£ that the: Siiif $<:§"1€€£'£1i€ p:'<>1_:e€ri:; is aim} a part a:.1r.:1 ;§are:*:%£ of _ ~~;» In 5 _ , "-:-.4 .$'*;'*.__JLé W. : aﬁs ~. » . i_v..._""\.< the '£1'ust.pmpert§: :0 3:: extmit af 5;'8'?i 3113213. Tixat thg"=:"'}::::":$e was Csf5111I}1€1'1Ct€{i from ::%£).:'i>,19.i>1 b€§Vc7f',€f1 1;§1e >V5:§':'**.'f:*-iZ3:§i'1'(Zi giiauzﬁiiﬂa fsztiim' éaild iatjasr €£:31'?en+:ia:'1i';i N(3s.::% to 24* §?9in!:.«i¥9__~§_: I ._ with rsgarxri :0 I318 req11isiteéA--_0!]'éiT ma? i1i:é»._11<:»'_£i~:?éV Sectieii 136 of 'i '1"a11sf"'€:r of P1'9=;3eim':§»-' AC¥;'3?c-éui $¥1i§;ﬁ §3§€Cii*3YD.v; I 1. I -. L 0f't3:1e saiszi fact, notice must be --a:1<:i ii:;ai_3it7:gLi0us and <:iefi:t1ite ti1<.:rug£1f. my ;§21.1'§ic:1£;§1' gxotice has been pmscziheii 1;11{iarf:ect10;:s... .¥,{}_()..crf--.th§: §'§;'C":. '**.1.:i:i}= if3SSO1" has us right {:0 t€i"II1}:;E1;£§"€?Ti1>V.ﬂ}€ i.e_:.1.a§ic9}?'* givézlg nmice to £9.11? 011i}? in respecigof' a the 'ar_€.g:};;2_i,s:-.:*-.:.:£.' pmzmses, if the zerzancji is bmigesx uf;,s.,_ it.1:~3 z:§s.11"E't:AVé;..%_é'z3x~;*bLV{ﬁat 11. must be tﬁmninategi as a Wﬁois.' '' 3°;z1«.3i'i1s2* Ar6qi111'e331e11¥, Fm 1:213: the noticra shauici £25: in w;fii::::;; gm: V"'Si§£€}E3iCi be sigzied £3}? 2:14: 13133011 g1Vmg it or by I ~sé}'ma:bi;»;1 f€~.¢:;*i1i;§0§1s?ered" er €:1¥::'tiec§ ta act 01:: benaif. ft :19t3;c€ giv€'::_ £}§; i}3§:" Q5-<i¥:1s on has death at the féiaﬁzcr is vahd. Where pc1"sié;:__}1as gexzftyai auil:10r1"£y to deai with 1:113 ;;:=1*<3sp$3:*f3; of '§hs_b_;%§§r:1ex*, a zaoﬁce is quit given by" him is also Vajjii. sat V 66331333021 13%? Whﬁfﬁ 21 pézrseiz autimﬁzes aneiixﬁr :9 Sign 323:1' him? the sigxzaium :3? the pe1'sc:::1 S0 sigmng is {ha 5-.1igna%:i,:1'& caf 131$ pﬁrseii autiaozizitzg :1"; 'E'i1t:;:'s a neficr: I9 quit: sggneci by an azztnomzaci agent in £116 ;:+ri11<ripai's I'}€iII1€ Witiwui:

<$ =\- ;::':r,"= '"-':':.r=- -" in 1,; :3 mm '.'n"'::"=r.

_-"'-.:'i-..:'aQ.»>c~.4.;;;,:=us: a,.g\: a*"~e.m.;wii.:. z~.§;:.;a_.~..=<.:

mdiciatgmg that Ema s1g:1af£'z.1re9. appendeci by an agéiﬁ is aéso valid. A 11¢:>i:iC€ {JIICE giv€11 $11 c:0:11piias:1<:.€ with pI'U'%r'i§3~'i0I1 of Section 165 0f'i'.i~'.Acr1: v.'3I"i1133€S '£0 ma banéfsi of suc£fé:~':{§c.ﬁ§ ﬁﬂe of {£35 133301" 01" the ifiﬁfrﬁﬁ as the cam: m;"g§" b~::,Tv"'5.$!13;r:ie there are nzezare £11321 one 133301', 3:319 nczticté to' 'Cg-i§;t {:33 V given by or 0:1 bﬁiiaif 91'' all, i311£':. wf;: é:frCT a/J'eQ;3;jare1" "~gi§é-{#35 notice on b¢haii'0f£1im$eifa'j1<ji"---ighe otimr €:0«€§j.§1a;%¢1*5s,VVs€at£:1g.. that he is acting {Ear mam, the ;;_jz_§t:i<3.:: '§.$ Vai.:L:'::«,-. 23:3. Furﬁler 3 p€I"SOI1 iE.'§1O.'f}€iSVéi?§£'ifé§. into possassion as tenant: caIi;10i«::(i€:n§s'ii:3:::_:{é3i:;:£ic::*e5's iifié or the £5a:1ci'i0r€£»t€:"2a:1t 1*ciaf3{;i3sE§if:;AV 5' i_fi1eV1V':f o~-cgéirzjzétr catiwigszie to a tctnarzt i10'£1C€ to quit 31%;: file a1V1.':%f;r~1*.:;?5'£':'«:fr_::*£" '~S1}i1;. The tenant ($311.11-at object: pa1"u;cu1ari§%'~Vxvhez§;e'v--. té'nai*i'£ himsesif has E38611 pajgzilg ram. to (!§£--£~€--«"198é$ miahabad 3:35}. Wizazré me V iéiitiﬁgrmisé ?::>€£011g 30311;? :0 sevaxai persazxs, a $111: 150 é};s:%é"£T a t€:1 é:1f).'{ 96-211 £313.33? itvii' brougixi aéi the cg--owI1€rs sumg §joi1i'i§§;"as éﬁiasﬁiifis and aid the jmm; ia;11{,£i<:>r::is must gain an " .. g:Vi1;g Vﬁﬂiieﬁ {:3 ma tenant bﬁfﬂfﬁ deteimﬁlmg "i€E18;L£}{?§§', '£0 quit is 91153 0:16 0% 'E115 Blﬁﬁﬁﬁ 3:: whicii f€:E1a}.1C}§ can "£35 d€€€:":31:i:":E;{i, Uiiﬂiéil" §5€<:.~i;e:s13 1}} i;E'1é=: kéassi E".€E'1'ﬂiE3a€€S :31: ihé": expiry at a ﬁﬁfiﬁﬁ to s:i€term:'1:c ﬂit: iaasa mi 112:: quit €131' Sf" iiliﬁliiiﬁii {:3 (gtifﬁw A t€:1a;1<:}-* is ::i8t€:m:1::i::2@€£ by SE16 3er%.11<:€. Of. 9» :1.o':ica:: :11 "£36 mmznex" gsmvxqiad Eiﬂiiﬁl' Sectgian E 13 E g; .._1"€a:'i with 106» 0i['i':*a21:~:1f¢3:' Oi i~"1'9peri:7.»:

25, '1"J:3é: f.€:1a1:1t who is 16%. min p<3s$ss:ss_1;::1 is esiiijxapefi :_i?::v:ii-. {§m1_x;é21g the £a.n{iio1'::£"s mic: anasi %i1€:":saié;§3:ci"111€fi"§Jie..ips appiisitaijie to tanailts, W-'£105 t§:oA£_;g;:;. not: 31%;; E)}»=' {£15 E8.I}€i§t;'}I'd £".Z€3§LZ?'?0i£3§£?£§§Z€€"§ E116 a Cietzﬁ Q1' by pajzizlg ram" 01* 0ti1€§7§%ri's¢. .

;if'?'. in an s_;vé'~--::i:ﬁaV._e'V1;1: £'éi:;1<:i£z:srd me {$21231}: can uni}; s:1::;;~2s§ fﬁié iégzfiiord nag de£a:':r2z';e:ec£§ but he giﬁﬁﬁéﬁ * had 120 t:i'€.Ee :9 grazit the iﬁ:?3;S¢.i' '£?$ 1i€ﬁ;E1 V}}G$Vé%'"g;'?%S}'i}f'§ g-gm} 110$ 5333 M': €£€f€i}{i me suit 23:} the g1"éi:33[::V_1€iVi,£}T:1t £15: hag acgguizﬂi an outﬁiiazzciing iﬁlﬂ ' '%.i:§{ 21::§3i€£*I't.-i~2si*:..;}=;.%sSessitf>:i"'*i»:é the ia;t;1di<:sr<:£, A 21611331: wxhcr has §7:es::} "£6: "z3z.1_t'o. "§;Q3;~:~.;e;3S1021 $811319? (,§€}:1_fsf his ian<1*i::::'{£'s Eitis, iilﬂﬁéécivéf, :£&fére:{Z3v% it may be, 51:! Eoxlg as E16 £:za$ no? 0g;2€:}:2§};' ' :";e$t::>r&€£ .p(§$.s€ss:ie3:: E33' $1:r§*m::€i.€:' is his £a:":{££c:::z'{i. in tim- A €:éi"a ¥x:::1.:=m?: Wﬁéﬁ E3;»:z.g'i :10: £366}: is: 33:33 pri3$S€SS§Ofi bjs; 2:33 "«3§:;m€L§§G:*e:ig he can in azigixtiany Saks me pieas :31'. ignmmzcﬁ, "':i£$'fe<:t~.t, Qf £1136, firazzsfi, mis:*::pz*63e:.1tai1@n 0:' c0--~ers:€:r11, 'I316 'ienéiiztf. znajg; %::::wm:m* SEEQW' mat his §a_::£££:31*d's_; triﬂe $71223 €X§3iI"€{§ <3: s;iei::':'m1L:1e{§ ::%é:§}_t:1* by ac: <3? paﬁieg or §.'I!_"€_-2' €:p€3'at:::;v_€": J, -5 :15 1%? V;-,' ,_;/_1 :_, ,3 4.-._ », '...-'0 BE? i«'}¢f''§ni'€:»,-'n : '3 'Fa :_.' of Eaws. S€C'fl(}IE E. Eff) ?10'§»'K?€?V€i'-Z', {£063 1";0"E t:ést'»3'p ms 'sT;e5:?}::aa1'1't", frem q11eSt;:c-:13 c.i3j11:::i.ng has err;-share of the ia3.1::iiq:f;:_i %'§i'1t: 2 te:1a3;1t who has bra::r:_1g£1t cm {and ?:«}~' the p£aj:11:ﬁ" :af_i1d:i1:ﬁ$£:i§::g,¥' u.n<;ier £5336 granifzsi by him CéiIl£}0fv'$é }?"i31é§f'.'§§1€<ié;[i{f§l" is'-:j?::is ; 39$ iajzciiorti. 'E'ii1€: estogapei 1:£is~a;3g:: éz:a1$*5--._{:3iﬁi§: 1;A£.';<:*.Via§,11L{EL:ié'>:*:ni" 'iiiis is &:v<:i"mgu1is§':::cl at this 1:33:16-Qf "£ge1:1:s"e s;)§}::1§£«z'€;=:s',VV"e{fé:t1' éiiier' figs: termmation 9f the te};.1.'a:1c}-*.

1378. in the inrsfaxit cage': vvsi$"V--'i,i:+.s:{"'i:%;a3e tiaeeti dateci 30.8. 393$} £§:§13%;":=.i:; L*:;eé¢r£y':_:s_fé"é:§s ~..'tﬁ§'i me. father of jgiamtﬁf $330.2 11za(i_V:":$V[8'?'%A Egii1&:;;'_e$ a:ji€2.__t hé ::r_ti}j;":z*5 owner, P.Ha11u1:1a:':'¥:ha }§€€i§}~' i:;_aci--_ ,3 "i:; 'E§1& 'Ii.e:;x.:-setti p2t:ap€1*£}:. ¥»"i11u'::«§13i Pawi 831$. F2 L'g:'.é§'~éa'iV€"::si3 ' gggfamigi. 1331161' 9? iﬁfj a;3g)eﬁa:1€. '<5.-?'€*1rg 2-ne iasseags " ':.2;:1(i$:' "'£;§1_¢V sax: 1:33.36 sieezi. 'E".§1€ iessars w':%:*s3 vﬁimgiébaéi gasjgaiziz €}'ﬁ?i}.*i"3E'S. 233 per h;§{£§«'1'? daigtﬁ i.{3.199?9, %;i"3£"~T£_{:a;s€v Eiag .i§e:2£§i: fsimuzatsii anii the tﬁimﬁxaﬁaiz ncxtzce Ci€§31£**i11€£&{i "€513? me :i€r:7e:::;"ia:1§.s £':za11c:{ Gvér p::>ss€s$1m1 {sf '£116 §:::f;::¢:1;:_f:7£$€*Sw.:4§:2. er iéﬁﬁénsre 3{,}2{T).19§{::39s {j.m1s1€i€m:g tim flzaxri zisai;

T iiiégrsf was 3:1 zzaxdiégided Shara is .31: axial}: of 3} 8&1 ghara ami .. E:_f_é'&'~" E3}-=' {Em g_3§a:i:1¥iﬁ'3 £21 'éitzé: suit scheéuie p:m;3€3*i}r, the ~ VC~m:3m{":n i}€}t§.(Z*(i issued by {£16111 Cajmeist bs iimiii is £345: :;t~e§:?;:'ar§.r E9 i':§e€r't::c_:>31 E{}€"> at '§'rzm$f€:1' ai Pr:::'_;3£*r{_v £471., §;~$:m::?é:r i§':.»:,* iismjslsrzi §3:m_:3t*,:"§i$ 32215 :10: £13661: <'i:v:§'si:3:'i $3}? §§"ii:"{fES §m.::§ £:3<m:'3:i:; ga/A i1EifE}E'€'.- 3115:" {£16 c£1.2~:;z"2»1<:?'£.e1* :32' the 'r:r3:1sa.::?'i10:1 i1'1t51'1{i¢ac:1 by me exézcrtztaxxt. iE'i:u:: }11t€I1€iII16I}.'i GE' the par't;;ees ta the i:1s£1't£ﬁ%*E:::i:, and the: §C!Z11'pO'$€ 011 me ¥;FEi}"1SaC'EZiOI'1 fO1'1'S?i}.1(,'.i1 the _21;::s;'_:17L'i_.:1:5§:=:;:£i._ 1$ %:s1*e:;Vugi11:. mtg existsncs-§ £121-5 I'€Ci'€€:1iS 01' £136; @mp1€:sy¢::£i 1:: ins i,11S'E"1"1"£3}.1€ﬂ'{. s}:10:'é£c1V¢_g;7ee13 .3j§é2m1::;7i)'§1:1€"« <:=o::1s1{ie1*a.f;:o:1s £61' gtzdging :s;i1.ei:i1ez' é'.9ai2f§.1Cuia1* _{Ec4c1.::r=11€:1%f ~~ £1.35"

a ciaed Of rtriease er a ﬁitfsfiii '=3: "s;+Q11v€:ya2;1::%t:, _:ir;_ 3t.{"ié saga ::iee:sio::1 if has E3:=;s;:1 iieici fjzaii '-ziéegi sf %t:i£tz~1::~§(: .515 an 133.33:rum611i 1331 w£11ch €) I..1 €',"0§..13°,'}'i1I:f: cc-.V0'=,$1*§»::;m I'€i€':aS€§S or r€11o'um:€s his §:;;i'I;;:.j:r:si,:':.t1 V' .§3:a:¢::;$::edg.p'i'0pe1'iy and the 'i"€SU.H* cf Suez; zfisase §,v;(,s«i.:£<':1{ §.:€"{fizz} éf.nia.:rgem€::1£. of '£i1€ sizare {}fE§'1t':': :.:::~me1' §A:T$r;'i--7;'.'V~_'m_)_é1i, i--§ i:s ai~30_*weé;1 setiieai £3122: Ehf: dead 13):' reicizasa n€;?:;'£"1:g;:£:13:3gi'afi.Vii1Qii3"'G11i}r§ @3351: if 1: is su§}p01"£€£§ £33,:

{}{3§1S}§;§51'Eifi01'i; s$3.Ei~i'tT @9321 he tmaisd as 3 dead 91' misast: ii «axe 'M;§_'g}{'§T,féi3{:2fiI}:if§§1'€ 9§""i:§ié pajﬂes émzji the p::i1'p~.::s::: of the _':1'é.:3[$;'a€ti:;:..§':A svéiéisfg 'rim :'é:rq1z.ir€m€:1'£$ of a cieezti 0%' mziaage 1:: :2: case; cg" tixgi §}'I?f.é§§¢I'f?' mzrxxeci £3}; 21:6 0:3-:::swT:1m"<s. ' -fiizz. '£313 asgzeiii: <31" 51 m§;§:1quis§1:3;z€:1§1 £3}? 8; <*:s:22-0Wm:r is ' 'i,§::; .;:e}b'is:0:3 0f rm Fzzji ﬁﬁﬁsiifik ef ﬁsiaaiias Higfi €j:3"::r§. :3} the cgséa «:}it"',3@arﬁ aj'Retsze§me Efs, ziﬁurzggesfm repsrﬁeﬁ £3 £3 195$ ﬁadras 5415, u;="i":e1*aiz}. :1: £'1.a:~; hﬁiﬁli .£3.6:§;»:§ that 6a«:t.§1 Com Gwnm" £21 E£':e<>;:}e' is széiziieci '€10 c%:'2;e::s}~=' 2:13: e:1i::1:'s:? ';31*0;3€:*i.}* :3: paﬁ 0:" 31:2 wheﬁe, it is €.§1€1'e§'{>i'€: ;:;y:;'é £1€{?€:SSaI'}E' £431' £31155.-iii' me €;'C?--O"EE:1€1'S to €'€3I1V€f}? his i}1fi3I'E'§'>f. to 'ifiﬁ ::;?:h€.}' can-zyw-:_:.é3:':§';<,i§"s;:: ii is; suﬁ::<::z6:11 if 013:: cat {E18 cm-a"v<::ae1'3 reic:as€:.~?{:i3is,_:5i:f::'r€§.=<3;':: amfi as a rgsauit. of S'{1(i?£§ I'i3i€faS{3 W'0i;,§{§ %.:>_¢ ii}? gtﬁiafgamﬁiii £31?"

the Sham of 'féim csi:_§7:£:" <t{_1-<:s%x:i1e:*,1:'. Lia, s1:,§e:::.1'a xjtrasé _:E1:5:':"t2 *g::é:f€:

be 2:0 c:3::ve}7a11cr: as 32.29%: 7£3}»"c,_=3f1;.=:V 2}: Eizitz c<;--:Q%7s?::eIég:1'§. ..?::ixo11:* = 0f the 013161' <rQ--0w11<:-:'§§, '£'£1e1'e €r:31_1 ape :16 'rt-':viv€a.$:€:,5 :53' 0:16 §)€31'S€*§1 :11 iavmlx' Qt a110z§2_:}i' *a_za7%':_s:s .'£§§' né::*.?--, 2:E:t::z.§:i}=* tsntiﬁsrzi ta 131:3 pzmpertv as the <2'-{A"i -€5'«£%"i1€.',1'.«~~ _

323. 'E"i1t:. S;:%:;»s5'§_.' {i€:e:_1$:{§i:1 £335; iééen ibilowazi in &::.£>'{.%.1e1' s2.1i§Ss:{;§.2€§1§. §9'i: :§v.'vi3r%:;i't:;%3 e;i.§€%'::s;z;31 .of 1:15 i§§a(i::"2':s High {j.{::ur£ :3} *e':.E1e3 case' pf _Cfzi7ef Eevenue Anﬁwrétg Efs.

R.§§'}P;£e£:8;i .3.79J§$ ﬁadrﬂs 15?'. in €118 Sam '"e3asé:9" tiéé-"L 3:eiiL=:a$01" 832:: $3115: raieaesee wr:*:1'::: izmfizers 34:23 L%;z€:}=' I ¥§?¥§1f§§ §1z:%$:i:1_g"e£:{c2£;.£ S~§181'€,'E§ ﬁr; the ;:«mp€:*i"},r as {.'O--::)W1}€}'$. '1'§::se 1'€iéz»3§:;}§' ;'ff§_i§;£.€;:"£i1EiE3€i'§ HES :,:m{i:'«*a::(:i€{i E133 r3i¥1a:"r: a_:":.<;§ if}-E

-_i.11I:e:"x:=.a;§.:?1_"é3~i,§1e éziltire §3I"€.3'§}f3I'§}-'*' in i'l::a:v$ur 0%" his eidaz' £"::'0ti}€::' "--:§;>:i _:§'a:';:: §£:K:E':a3'g::* e:;f Sim §}ii'2I"§g3§_;if3 Qﬁﬁfiy §Vf_';I§€f,E"} i:€::1%m€{§ the " c€;ﬁs3.{§a1*a':1=:>21 :63' 'ifiﬁf i:"€§_€a%, "i'§3.s:: Eﬁzii Bﬁﬂtiiﬁ $9-23k a. vww {$131 me :'€:i€as¢:3:" rsezziii 2'€£1L:1q13:3§1 .i1;:§s i11'ii,€z*e$'£. :1: EQVQIII' of {£15 Gihﬁi' <;?e--Qw:"::3:' {I"6§€€!$€€} £123" C{}11E§i(i€§'é71§}£j3§1. in {E16 321:5} €§€{'i$i+€3§}, ii: wag"; §'}6§{§ 1318:: '2%?%}.€":':I£'1If two §}€ﬂ"§if§S {ifﬁ <7<:s«~<:2w:g1€::'s 4?

-~'. ' <;~f/ 3' ="

-;'~. 1,"1-x4 . .s ¢.e"1._=v . 5.

E¥E'§}$'3I'§ {£165 miss :?a'§"z.1'1£;:~t, ix': i"i€f1'§'l{i3'€3{--3;'£f3"£I§ or ii;-:£:<;£ m."i.:'fs :*€;i€:}:{%m*>€ $9 212:? 'g3:a.':*{.1m:iz«1:* ;<3a,2;"€; 1:22" 'tﬂié §rg}:'}€3:"'§"_\;'., in Ofiiift' '%¥"(}i"€§S,.-"»¥s?E1{'fi'é? tixﬁrts is 2: jzmzi =:;wr1i:1*$§1i_g.3 ami §L)€}§iS€§§S'£(}}1 téiai <:e:.§1_; :;:.3:3Li}<f S€Z"€.?€':i"€'{i bjs; 1:*:ar¥_a3;1~:t>11 w'i1€<re ihffﬁ ES a.i;:fc:ra£i}; a 13:; ms p:'0p€:"'i§; v::3i,<:?~.a:'i .22': i'.§1f:'. £'f:i€iiS€":€:""é',J1£'i i'_%f:€ I'£37£«é}aS€f '>.»§'ii!;E}.§;'€§ €_'}}3£?}'8'§;f3 is {tzliargﬁs $319} 2":g.i":1: :12i;::s"1«:;':};3I_§i:»$s:3ii,i%e '1c,:'i.:»:i enﬁra 3';}1'<:>'}:TI-€'i'E§fJ 35; "far as __iIi:2.$ ;}a:~'f"§:i::s. 3:33 "~¥,f(}1'7£§?€£Z'I:'E,1€3€;{.'~ "§'i:6;rt:*?iGr€, izmiﬁi' .i2:w, ;:':%[email protected]:;i <_é:a3.i' ~%}€=:;_1::a€ie ii5«j2?_{2:3E,j3c'<:s~<:r£E'}:2€1"

Em ilavcstzz' of 3;:1€:rEi1e:;' <§<:3~va.')'s1';%::e:1" ?9%"':%:1.t:':§'«:{V"~ '{1tIi<;? IQ iii-3: §f}3'(Z3§)€E"'§§~'"

ai3'~:%a=::i.}? tirx1sts;? 811:f_§."§1{' :51'. }1;%$i;"."aS 111.E.3?II?:i'i'$§%3Z--€3€1 0:" {he ea-"E'1<::i€ as a i*€:i€as€:r;2 cfszf E1-;:;_;1ﬂs3:3§f'§" ' 3:-3. :3 ma: £~:'g:*=;;.s;.__;;;::gcgiiasgxat Xaur vs, ﬁzme repartea in éiﬁ ,i§3~?-3 was {>{';v§;$m{:z:i a;i'§::.~::r :E1'::*..:"r::2g #1:; ma: i-":.:vi%n£%a:1§?§":. g}é_1::i'g;:1§i:3 i §:sf {E153 Maciiaa High ifr.>"::21"f, 2:15: izéiﬁ 'V " ;gé:':2é_21i;" {;££?"1%:1' a pf::*$<>':1 whezrz mlmg '£316 prcsj§:s<3:'§;}:' C-312 aiss €:»:*_E:?%'3'§.i"§.'ff 'E"?%,: ":':*§"z3..aS€ {§,€€{§ in '?é"£i?0"i13' 6;!' a:30$i'1e;" C-{}~2f}'i?e?'3:€:£' and. W§t:¢:1': S11{~'§§ §:iA{§ti€€§ ifs fiXti"(?{1'£f:i{£ Eilff sifzam 0%' ms. <?e:3-irswzziéz' in Wiiaaé .fa?ix€3't:1' E;E'3.€ g;3r:::§£31*ii}=' :5; i'€§€'E8_'Sf3{i gets azigmsrmgd agmi 1:3. _ ::33_§?§é;a «fast: It': :5 mg? ::'::':::%€:$2§;a3j$~=' fag' {Em €3§<Et3C£If£z'i.1}$. '$.13? €§{€{'.'.ﬁ?f.t:"'. 3 éiéfeii (>3 €'{'3'£"E'§}'if_§-"sf--,i§1{I'f3{ it is Sims {T"§;€.':'aI." iixaz 112 Easa-2 if :8 €;;:>é_=.:i1 ':0 :3 pm':-3(;:': i:e:">§s':.§33:':g '§l}§'£}'p€1"iZ§? as a !:,:*::'121a.1t :32. £".','€)I§BIf£1{)."ﬁ :0 €:.:s<€:«.:'.::'i¢:r ;m.E€::»1§-:6: {§€:€£'£ in §av<;s:3;r :3'? me €:!§.§_1{i§" afrcrwgéwziziz' 3:€,§3"0:1'm::_mg' £135;

;- -, ,2 3' g=_- , r\,:f.!--;.:~¢a...=.Je:'j.,;_x,s=,»-I =r,.:z'e g'\s.,»--;..;-ms. :¢£~;:.;. 9133311 :0 mterest in the t1;1-§3a;.'i;:£iQ11€::: :Z§1'()p€;£"3£f£ aﬁci for {£135 p111'p(}$€ it is 113$. :<'1.€ce3ssz31}-F fa:-I izim in €:XeC.:11:e ea Ciiffftfi 03:' C%i)1§fs3"€}e'EiZ1CE. {I}. Aifé T1953) Mamas £241 sU.p1:a It has a_£$1t5'--i3€eI1 €"_i€Ci3IJE€§ that it. 13 110': ;€iti{'f€S$=31'}? 1291' one of fhﬁ c§2:_Q:wji1a:.z*3 is Canvey £123 1:1¥;(3res°:. ':0 {E153 01:hm:'C::;~:;)W:1ei's as :3; 'iS"St1'i'§75E,€§it3't§_'E V 07:16 {if ins c<3--£}1£z11r::1":s I"E.'§€aS€:?-S .E:3&:» :.:'1"I'i€%:%::.'-:.¥;. am _v1:h;:¥ﬁ::_ Tléﬁfi' irzé:

no CO'f}*&?€if§*"a.ﬁ¢ZZ"€ E35: 0:36 9-1 313 C0--<:rw:i€;rs'--.é:i iavoiur (:45 ifzé .§j%E3;;é:*._ ::'£;'3':Lri%?i1(ii'S.

34. in Aibz' ?;':38f€:; Psi' 4:3 311;}: _§< Izﬁaiiatijtﬁoi &11{£i'11'a £~':;'éz»:£€:SE2 Etiiggil --$:,:§.*;i1'i2'§3;:1§T;%§,£s§§:"'£1it£«:i'géiiai "ii tjzézrtfi am Ewe <30~--

€m?:':5:';:% ' _ of Centraiiing Revenue ﬁutﬁéﬁtg Vs; Patel reperteé in ,;§.1lR 1§63_ 15$, ;a.11€£*~'£::zm gt" the (?€;3~{>'£'Ef1?:f3I'S E'€i{E's<_;%:§S§1€S in iEiw:;--:::" of the othezfg aim msuit Q1: tiixe V £'4fii§;1?1:A1i1!:§>§:§.i?:1_i:??;f€"§;S the €nia1*:g;:=='.::.2.:::1'i: Qf '%:h.e Sf1€£E'€3 cf {£16 otiim' c%a:s--€:iw:1:::1x" £3323-r" sf {£36 :::t::~0WI1€:r W-'E';0 is; {fiat 1'£i'§f33S€}};' m€':°€ij; '. 3:1:€:1§.:>§>s§.«;%; that he :t3i};rzqL1:iSi::€S his siiam 01' his ii1tt3I"€S's€. in ms » §1'{>¥§::+;;t3I"t?§;,, futistsad of ugruig H36 expztssion 'in f7a2:=€:s:.1;:' Q1' {Sim icgiélél' ctéwewxzﬁr' 3133:1633? '£315 €§}_3.8I'g€§}€ﬂ'€ 0:' the 33.1838 ti}: Liza ' €;":C?'6iIx'£?i;7E1€i"., it is :$§Zi3i:€*i£fi*.iE'1E. in 1316 izlsimlif. {T336 ;:+£am'i'iﬁ' 36,} has Itﬁxéquisizxizamt. hm' 3f8"3'* uzxciivigiéd sham in favour sf piasinafﬁ" §'%<>.2 W219 had a 5j8"31 ililéiviiiﬂii 311313 in the 32», pr(:s§_:xe3:"ty 311$ ag £3. :E"€S1i§f 4:116 owzierginp 0% pi3::"mffE §'é_g}.2 111 me Suzi': 1:133 ¥fz€<:0me cczzipiﬁiia 311:1 '§'€§'.'i0i6, £~£€:1<::+:: W6: are ()1: the e:.*011si:;i€re:::i viw;s"""*1:£'§:fa1T._' 5'31__i€~. fioﬂuiﬁﬁiii of 1'€ti€aSf3 deeai rxzarkeé as £::x.§:;»3EiS _:s_';';'1~-..acc.é§rr£_a:1c'e Witt: Law and i;£'1e1'€i:0':'t3 9: vzsiszi €:£§)z:?'i§1:}2t::f'1*§ 5?,,i'i€£ iﬁejazgé' .§:¥,;aif:jﬁjiV' E~i{},;£ had 313 E06113 siangii t.e3_%s:~2;s1£. ﬁg: "1}0f1C€7(?if 1:1}:i':3;21'11':3;'£:i<:s33; am': aigo ﬁie fiat: 32.211", '1'.%1€%:'é;':%";f%t», 'me "';:;1;i§'1::§2ssié:g:1 Gt rm itiarncd 552131102" {.1¢3u:1se§ ':'i.'+:i_1. £"f3&:' *:'zaé1t:ii;£i}:V%}fI_ 11:16: 1'e§éas7é (meg: £5 negafivech Even 111;'.-1:: ;3.£za;:';:.3i1:":ff'§\«*g::;§ i1_;::3:{i'«'i?A1;'é?s?:n:'s_7L1oC6€:deei to the Sm? satfieciiiég %;i€":C:x€i§1igu1S§1311e13.t of the trust, and 3'3 LcitgéiiC';%:*:p:'é$€;3,:é:1:£ve _0-%' his iaihei' he couiti stzii §11ai11t31?1£Vt§'y5: suit. "ﬁg:i§i{i' §'F?"',i1f3I' 0f 3 1'8"? *sim:re £1: fha suit $Ci1€{'§3.1i€ gJ31E:i'};3§i':j2?.,.%3}'§?i1"'iI11a :12: {ha fﬁiﬁfaﬁﬁ cieeﬁti :3:{::*.CL1'zc5:€i bf; ' V' in >t9:§;'?i5'é.':;'31' <:r§ tpi23_mf:'2if Na 2.

363% T :§ias.2§A,T:

if §i?t:¢11ie;1::i€{;i by ﬁlfit Eeazzaﬁgi $561110: éémizisei

3.}}§3€:~:_1i§;ﬁ:g; $01" the apyaﬁatzt £113? silica 5:} 831 "share c«f%f.i1::~: Sziiti §C§i€§§Z2i& pmgrserffg is Ernst ;f:mp€:*f.}:3 ;}:a::1t:ﬁ Egg; wize is / %i'v'"§3;ij;='"a beneficiary :.:11€i»5r '§Zf'}€f fruzei? handbag i:3::.~t1ss sfancii £9 V mﬁai:1"{:::1iE: '5s.§:£ 311$; H6 E'{'3§1{3S 1113011 ?:§6<:%:3;ex1 59 0: £316: 'i'J:"u$%;5 Asst, if}, -:~3z:;3p0:z"¥ 0f his; E1§{}'i}£iéSSiG'ﬂ. Uizdm' §f§€C'E}.€}'i1 iii} «:2? the fax" the €3X€<.'f'1§'£1€¥I}_ 9:' E315: Trust' in 15116 saga case it vs;2'z3_ net.

p:'0v6::i that Lifts executiozz 6f the 'i':"i;zs"£. haezi imgsraeticabie. it was heid that the plaintztf Wa-=:3 :i1Q§._§#:i%:iii<§§§'[ M tics I'€:'if§' cm 5':*§BCti()§1. 139 sf '€115; i:1(i:a1':s: "i":'*s1;sEi :'%.ct- i:{')'" 1:2 3ti::1":_i::t £32.. suit '£13 £131" 118338 $231' the €Iifi3I'{'f3ii1f':3if<'Of"::'%ii£:'§'Z"ﬁCii.;. , :38. in thrit €3.36: cs; ifs, Pazianisamy Gauxgttmi in £23 35338 Maﬁms $623 if: imsv :3e€::i:~- £Ai'é'i§'},S€§Cti¢:5."§3. ms:

sacurﬂﬁz £301; :l';V§?.s'§€. u:i3'C§é}.?;10§ZE. oy {ﬁe sfakﬁ i3e:}i€i€1."wa3 TE! ;=12o1"t.gag¢5:s .i':'<;rm {£18 S'i.'§(.'v;'.&*.§§€?:%""L1_§ E?1c§.;<:.ié=,::' was a.e%3m:ig£:e:i 11139522511:

312$: his :mcI:;aa:):1 by {}ﬁ:<:.iaj£ E-;*€r:r€::'%.:<31', '§',i1é=, :~3;i,::zk»5: §:c2}:':.<::* ' ai-éas€:'i '£13 ;.'>er:1'3"c.xm:2 331:: renzisred inmséit ' §_%1§£3é~'i;}_?§£§§i}i:fi"'€;%§}"§{}€i"fbéZ"£ﬁﬁig Ehiz €i?_1iZi€=S that, €§.€3'%?Q3.V€€i tlpixé} mix: 35' 31. i:':::,-éfsztg ';%:1;_é .§.1enc€ a 311:? E3£§}.€§€i' §56{'f"{}_(3IIi $385 was izeigi Kc: be ::3__.m?:1£a:313§:§.ié bf;-= 'rim bm1ei:c}La::i€s.

' 'ij:2 11:15 case 03* Tﬁarzgachi Kachiai «Ea maths? ifs.

ﬂzggsﬁyg ﬁﬁmuntéar £3 §'!:'?££¥'$ rgpveriseﬁ ﬁg: gm .§§$? Eﬁﬁras 19'? :3 EMS btzﬁn €3'X'§)iEiE'£"1€€;i 'mat ma 'i?;€I:€§ic.ia.:i¥'s rzzgizi: Err: sa{»:*. €3;2:1§§{}€i;i€i{§ Sm 55:30:39}: 5%? of {fig 'E";'usi 530%' 1883 is Efﬁéiﬁifiii an iiiiiﬁf §3:"i:'1s::if;,::£:5 té":€--}Si'. 'Ea '".E":'*::si aizaﬂ 110%: fag} .5, {'2 f-;:.--;.;=a~.>. "-0 4 .. V 'M niix' s='-e.r;,..w:_:. . ~?<.:.A_~.:z« LV ,u.._.._f_.

<§«€;L §~Tu1'ﬁ:§£::1 88611911 2:"? Of '£3113 'irurst. Act. ciéais 'wfi;'E'.1 e:§:'£:i11gt:1s£m;1e11'§ :31' a éiust due :0 (3'€I"i8_"i1). co11ii11ge=.;j;ct:es. Umier §Sec=.'£1':31: 2? :3 txusi; is ex1.u1g;u:si:e€£ xx>:¥1e11 :13 V'j3":fi:°g§€;se 1:3 {T-{iI1I}§}lC?'§.6.§§f iixjiiiicid. if a p1'€§'UiS1Cii'1 is tiaare- i:;1 i§i1€'u:"'i'1*1§st ' Qeeii that the '§'r11s1:, hag C9316 1:9 a11~ find (311 x§;ﬁ'cfs;4 éibfifh 0;' a $03.13 attanlmg CCITEEIEE age wi1.ic.£1€ﬁ{%:~ ii+.3"'ia"f€31T;'~1°.f}L{'"§3; 'thta. its €.:<:':i;:1g11:i$E1€Ci 11}}C3i"3 'ihii {iea'i_1"'aj a WEE?-*5 Gr. aéffiaizjinig ti1e--- agﬁ WE1:ci"1e*m::' is Eater agzd tact but Eiabijity 1:0 ranﬁér a:"~1t;:-%_;{:il*Li_1:"z'a'L'.Vf:*,L Vida {Am 1952 Atzanamza 825 {B3}: % La: Vs. ﬁr.

1%:€;pmse:1€. case, in ciatise 12 of is stated that the tmssiee or t1':1s%f.€e:§«::».£:<§aii me €1'a11$fe1*£'e:e:i prgypermies to S§':i.{;,4 ?¢,;€$va31:3;a.;"€}}€ iirexaﬁiiczaxy Llﬂdﬁil' ma 'l'1*:3$"£ aE}SGi11¥€§'f€ aitﬁiig si\§*;"i_?1V"ea-'=.x&1§,z acczimuiauerm Qiv 23102133', s.i1a1*¢3:::=;, ciivizizincls, 9'£;:_>«:':I.~i".~.~,v,V'ac{;u::3.;€20:1s 0: mgvabie. 91" i311m0vaé::§t3 pm;;::€x"%::st==::-3, ;3i*:;::3§$ ..rm;i4j'..~1*én3;s €10", -:21": the said {,Z:N.§€e:va:111a {§,via;::'2ir11€€ E%é0.£}.'cQ:a'n;:2ieti:1g the age csf ixmxaty 0116 fsaears. AS per ciause 1? the Trust: iiéﬁd, the: Ems? $ME':a§_§ be in ibrcs iii} t.i1z5 Efi€::1ei:<::m"}s' iiiﬁiiiiiﬁilﬁii a§}{3V€.'. C0:1T1'p§€,"£€€i 2} jgsars; aiyzi 3336 31113:: ;}:~<:»§;:€.:"f:§; wsre ira1?::«:»:i=:1':'&§i £0 E11111 as 136:3' C§éEl'£l$E .12, A ' W 41, it is however', €115 Corztantilon of 816 Ceimsﬁi fer the appeiiarzt. £113: in the abse:A1-:5 cf 3 :1%a:1s£'m" E35: {E36 t:1;§;t§:E:$s_ in faveur csf Elm i)€::;3xe.:iic1a3"j£, I116: kattttr had to a;_3'p£}?_ u::1d€2* ii-'wv::<:*i:i0i:: 39 of the .f§€f3i ﬁg;-f me eXe{:ufiJm:;_ :i'}I: ! r;=':[iSi ' and that the i3e11eiic.ia:r§s cssuki nc=tj£1avcAAi§i¢d« __t11'9§=:.

as such. in $up"p0r"i. :3?' ma aaid }3I'¥3';){}'.S.~iY1O}17§(§5%i3f£iEi{'§ §.-;'%;:%13;'m1"=. €,.'m:1"::=;@i 162* the ag>p6i£a11t Eaélgiehed éf';§__3_<'.¥.%;=:? ufi1sé' f<:rii0w1'::3.g ciecisianﬁs

42. in Efzolanath Sen 8:» a:zt:t1z_c§r...rvg§:a::t::§'i:£;.:i§.::'_ géﬁaieutta 118', the facts were ﬁat. 'stiii: premises; appsmizstci 1mc:£e1* Ueeaﬁ O3j¥'ff"i7%§.'3'.f:T i1é£:"§: an téjﬁﬁiﬂlﬁllf, suit for eviction ﬂung;-Q 'giagitf 0f the _g§f.f§IEi$€S mzéti 0bta"i:1€££ 9. (i€CI'E:€w The aﬁscrea vaaé :1ffii4*§;:t:1':jt*;cT:«,.._1:t?: Tim first apgxesai aad whaii a s€:c<:>n£i appsai was ¢p9€';:3;£:i:«::gVV.T'V€iaé E.3a:1eficiar§; fﬂz:-:££. 33.1 ayplmatien auci was added g;Is'aV:%es§:o:1cie1}.t? as E16 was eonsiciexwi desirabie, After 131,3 egaiiiiucéiit giecrcsze was aiﬁimed in the se»::'.o§:{£ appeai, the " Eicfiéiiezazfg saughi. far the @x:3r:.ui;is3+11 czf the ::i,e:=rs:ree bf; fziixxg an M .. ép3;;iicat1011. it was Emieii that am §3f2§1€§Ci&I"}? Back :29 rig.§1t E0 €tX€:Cl:t,€ the ciscrae in piacg csf 01* 30:11:13: wit}: the §:*a$E.:*;:€ azxti Ehsraibzﬁ, aiioxmsd Iihc Ei}3pi1C:'3'€i{'}i§: fiiad by this dzgdgmﬁrat £}e£::€'c:::* under iﬁscticxrx 4'? 0f €J:i~'(i. in 121% said {Ee::?:r~3:9'2:: it was /' 05i";ss3:1v€§£ that the i11'ie11t:i0:t1 01' the $€'£¥:i01' as expressézgi'-.i:: the trust tiaed was that me tI£'11Si£i€ m::s1:£<;i 00112213}? .f.~j;;1}:,i %;":§,:1S'§¥e1' €133 propertjg in qzlsﬁticzfz on his ai'£ai11i:i}g eé'mi.::.a_ " L-:2': --?_§_]i& a%:3sen:::€t egpf 511$-11 C011V6§»*'aZ1Cf3 arr tt'&r:$iTcr«bsy~'_'iEr: fi*u'sf:é€ ins':-. suit. p1*csp<a.r"€;;, the §Js:1«3f1cia1jg: Cauiti :10': €Xéé3.1_:%€_'£i1s"§{::<¢i'v::<{:

uzlder Sectian 14:5 niasi wiﬁ;--_§§'H:;er )A<'..;>~£i i{'=:.,:§é its V was f':,1r'£§::€:1' <3b$e1've::i ;__ﬁ1.at s§:§.c%"%j:€zﬁ xvéé ' 11.9 argssignment, C3'€€:i'£§i{}E1 0:' dﬁvaiuﬁeﬁ .PI'?3'?€T'§3~"'" €i'i1I"i11% Eh'?

pszivziezlcjgr of  gait  Riﬂe 1&3 cf
(3.3%? 1:101"  é    as mentiexaazi in
{.}It£t':r       of the §T}€ﬂ€ﬁCi$£1'}' 1293.3
the rigilt  ~ﬁ"LE.s£ EC! admilzistm' the p3'{I}}}€I'iTjE so
as ':3  g1:§ €:  E113 (£13333 &C£.?€)I'(;i§.Z£1§ E0 {isle

pFGf«§;'§§{}I1S v-1;i1%:?"i'irI.1S'€ uxxtim" Eﬁsciiarz 55:3 of {£113 Tréisi: 30¢: 02"

A _§:3:"a. §}.;§3:'J!f§I7 CEiS€ '(£3 Cezxvajg E316 §:21:3'pc:*'€ies E10 €316 baiisiﬁﬁiaijv émciézi <3? ma ﬁat' :1: the 331% cage {$16 133321 fQ11§:<i fiat ii:m'€' :'_~*x§"';a8 my 2:--ssig:1me3::t,, CE'€:.'£i€i€'}§}; 0:." €'§€:i!€3§'£§§ZiOf£3; gf §I:'i{§Z"'{:t':§i.A ma p:'t:>§3-6;"E;§ aitmiigg {ha §::t,'m;{§€11€y ef Kim Suzi as xje£§j;}«::'&e:§ E3}? €.}:*£ia:' xxgz R2113 ii} at" £i%'{E was' was the e:§;€»::t:*es: 'éiﬁﬁigﬁﬁii as Iﬂﬁﬂiiﬁiiﬁié in *;}:'€3§€r }<i.}<..§. i~<3u.§£- iii) if {j§~3{1. Hitﬁﬁe it was hsiezi {ﬁat {£16 b$§:s.s:§e';a:'j; had 11:) siighii ta £3-(€C't3;,'i€ ms {§€C§.'€€ in §}ié:'§;{.'€ :31" szar j-:s§:':i§§;" E3}: $18 €§€'€f'1"€f3 §m.i::i€=:', Law the §::"us¥:.€:e 3? Size said. irimfi, /, e*f%»:~3. '%"'§'1e 3811:: eii€CiSi()I1 can be tiistéxsguisiaed an facts as in the mstaizi 63338, in the previmzs rmtmi of §3;tig7a._t.i{:r;1 Eéetween 13:26 paﬁiﬁss as far back as £31}.

§'~§§*'}5§.:f*3t3X3f iﬁffiii» €56 gézﬁsﬁizt apﬁﬁiiaxifs fa?';§}€j:"..E5iV£k¥{?.Vv'{'52"€'i}§§ i_£116;, :a33peﬁa11t in the said. appeai had ﬁkfxi a1_?:1 j iﬁrdez' }<;X,!..i iéuiie 5% of C1P{,T. far }.n_~s:1g;'i::'g_=::»':,: r€<:Q: t!:,. E§£":vz} kftgégﬁ I'€§*I'E,'-S€§1'fa§1V€;3 of tim decraaseezi of ;:sEe'¢i3f£_i§;E7'£7"§I\é§V..'L3: ii§:re'§:1 and the $33215 was z:2§.!;<>*.;1é%:*:{§ Vﬁeiﬁém was %:::'c3ugh¥; on rsccsvrd. U13i3{€E:'?;§E_ €' £3'-.13 <::ef&§1da21t.s £?EiI}ﬁff.3§'.. at %:his_-_ '_;_.}§:§*:n"§: 1§ec§ 'i.:::: raise a ::o:1iie::'€:0:: ¥:n§.':ﬁ:""b_?i3.1vf:-V' Ezereizx had :10 iztacuss Siiﬁzaﬁi i<:Vv§:2-aézlfaﬁz '§j}"?::§E*vv:i.i'1':?«.§£s;£}§: s*i£"ii'.V.....E~'i1;:'ii1$:' me 1:a.:::< t.%}a'i: the izis iifasi p§¥:vii:sé13 4}_i§;i§;::¥f:£3é:¥"; iéﬁmvgeziz $16 parfisﬁ, £115 ' :-"a€;<?m';c:i §)§%;"ij:j:'é°"'£"§ @§?a&;.".E3ié:r§.1g§1t can Iﬁcfﬁifi as iegai §'E§}§'€S§§ﬁf3'€i?€ ﬁ',S'£¥.2'I§}i- 'ahr: z:ie§e'::?;da::'§s3 fsrmzzx <:011i:€.§3_r:£:'1:g i:E'::~:§. p.§;a1i:3t:_2;fE' :10 focus :3s%;a:1d¥i to fik: the suit. E03' {E33

3.ftsré:§.;:;:{§":"féi;g:go':?a$,' {£16 aiarcisiozz fﬁiiﬁiti 'upon by the cauzlsal _ far ﬁiit a};--§%é.%.§.3:€1{s is :33: apyﬁcaﬁic. Ea 'Eliza facts af we yrssa-1:: ::'?3:éai* :'%;'E<;~r<: Cﬁiﬁi} clause 3'? 0f 'aim 5£"21:si Ejesid has ci(-35:31:; ""$:§§ﬁ;;f:d €213: tim. arias? '%§F€s"$;.§§:i ha in ﬁegtré iiié 131:2": §"}€:}1€§C'%aE'j«' ",€§}ia§::3;'{.i.§'?{ S*€<':,23 %f;6":'€:§::. <:*.<;~m1)i.€f,zi*<:£ E536 saga {if 2} in '§*s;'§."i§{T'§} /5, m;e;:~'[,...

avatar the trusi: yroperties were to best iransiéned 1:9 him as per clause 12, HEIICEE whrzii §:sia3;111tj.if N02 compieted }--*ears of age, tile purposa offhe 'trust itseif was f1_1i:1"iEesc1 a1:€1f'<«i'_é':xﬁas a case of extixxgttishmeilt of the trust under $5e_a_::":§.0n jthé Pact. A150 the oﬁicrc: of the tnzstees was vacat§42'('i'* 'fi1t~": ':,£e22tii " . ef aii but one of the frustsezs. E3'§'i'<5;n--' oi*1em%ie:-6" "'§...i1e bﬁizeﬁciazjs C0131p£et:i11g :31 {Keats of Vti1e'VV'i1%1;{.;3":€s_V§ wer@_* discixzargegi from tizeir oﬁ"i<':=-:: .911 a.::<:éunt E cf the extmguisiiment of the' %1f§§:"s: 29$ £:::i%isajgs:¥:i'.1:11{£er Sfiﬁfiﬁli 1?'? of the Act. "i'i1€;:¢for€, piailxﬁff ?\3(}.2 compiczeci é.:§Ei:')~~vv'f{'3()f§1}{}i€{6C'£ with the Vtge transfer of trust ciause 32 aisa did not iaxe ﬁ§as::%,<--a$ Wouiti have become necessagy if tiV1e_vt11:ét€eVVVu1'VVt1ﬁstéé:§ had gurvived the be11eﬁcia:ry, in 'V V' _ f::v'€.::xt tE1€é ' ﬁistees would have had to ti"8.'£1SfE':1' the proyerties to the ¥i)€I1€fi{3i»EiI'§? er if the .beiiét3cié1*}§ j_{£ﬁiéd in intestata befime the age of 21 years, to cstizérs Q51' eiatlse 3.3. The act of 'a'an$ferri:1g the trust ' » isfﬁpﬁxﬁas to the bexisﬁeiazjg did zmt happen undsr the tmms :}f° £216 Trust Deed, 531106, in {he absence' of 9.1).}? expmss V V f1"a:'13£§::r of the trust ;31*::spertiss in L136 name of the % ﬁ.?:}1'a.2"'-30.§§?E§9. §f{}i_}7 5;'. iﬁé' '¢"é.i3E.£'\£$.?'z'§{3.L§i{3{E€:} beueiiciazées, the trust p:w:::peI*'£y steed mvezied back to the author cf trust as than was extinguishmeizt of trust,

46. in the instant case: what is of sig11ifi<:éi}.1:ic{:'AT.i§' 1:f:10ug£1t the 'i":*ust Deed Came i:t:1¥:o<e3{:;s.¥;:13€f;e: and 5/ 8*?' share of property of _ the trust in the schedule preizzjées whi{;h__ was V-iezisééi' '*i<:i £113 '' appeﬂazlifs fat.l?z£:r laergitx was... " 't<:s_ 335:: trust,' nézverthtiless ().S.?40.(34vj"1;§7i£ 331501" 91' the trust in his 0ta?n.'31am€,:.*fCi;>.. "e':;11c£ posse$s§o31 aicsng with was stated that piaiﬁtiiis injv joint 0°WIZEf3I'S of the schedtzigé a specific unﬁiviﬁed share am} tE1at ihr:'i%1e :LV'1C~b;1v€::2ie11c£: the tenants Iiamcijv the dcgfandanfs £é"e1€t paying rents separatsijz to each "o;f« ti'1€:& ;:§§é§:it1fiff3. ie:1a11c}~" was terminatad by 8 leg:-ii r:d3t;ig:€ "éV€;2;%,:'3.9?2 caiiing upon the dsfe11d.:au1ts 1:9 hand mere: :01: the éxpﬁy 0f.31.8.19'E'2. After the fziing of 'W:*i€:ten }é.t;i=tement one of the issues raised in the said suit "2s%tas_3:é*ij1e:11er the notiee temzixzating the te:1a11c.§' was good 33:1 additiozzai issue was whether defsndants preve that £.£:1ere £5 waiver :::af3:10ti<.::s. "F13: trial cozzrt answered both ihff: issues in tim affirma1::ive and Reid that the cicfandants were: in arrears Qf 1'e':1t to an extent (if Rs.11,4{){3f-. It was ﬁraﬁher /9» c'i§*?'. in E.§".:.iS {',1£}."£}§€*.}~i§ if §%:<.:::.1§::§ hf: §'{i§€3¥8i'£{".'€ {£3 :'a<i%:.z" 3:3 *:'§.1<*: {i;a<7':3§<:>:': 03' Eéizé. §'az'i_i;::i.z".z3:§ Eé§;.g.i"; {3<.:s:,:::"§ ii: §i"ir:3 Céifitf sf '?3'§:;':iiiv£Zz£ .§%§::;§.a.§isar §'"s.C.}%i;.§§t&p a: ﬁaﬁaiiar VV " in .i§'?2{1} ﬁﬁﬁﬁras Lam JG2£?"3'£ﬁ§ 265 %,%;»'*§':€:'€.i:1 iéiajé V' §h.a3'i' <33': 23:} 3'12: §i':_mi'%:e:§; f:3_iE_é:}.g fig; :é«:i.:;s;:1;::$"£;»:::*. V§:§3.%i'; :':r"':::'st. kt}: ;°€:';::>'a:{iia%;:a1:3; '§:z'21§s"£.. ;}.:*0g;'3€:"'E,j§' r:§§&:'i3f":s_"*;:3 §i:;:_:;§"'%E.g;;e tiza E_;;z:$;?, 2*€;:::--aé£:~i $2.5 EJEESE. "£31; {£15, :,§;§.s§>:;>:f:€:' ass: his i€';g€'V€§~.iii§I}2"€Ei;:5%.§§?;§£'§.i?;€$V"éiﬁiii zifi §."§f: .%.$ {iﬁéﬁii smiﬁ ii}. 8'E.i(3.§f'& £13335 §;§"i€if§"§££T*§:*if:§".§L}f§' a:';§";':o:'€t«.-"2A*;.'?;<<:»1.: 2:52' £295-" 22:: €.:"'?;1S'£€;'€S: £12121" €_%';1£3. §}:i£"§}€}--?-3?...Q{'$;?2t:'§'E3}fi£:iS'i.€i':"i§'§g: '€:§'§é;'% €.3"u§*i,, ii is; r:;::::§fF '§€"§','§f:§'§ 2:35: iiigm:1;:€%§j:s:'€$:é':;i§;i§.§ﬁs'::é .a:"€? V':g;e::~i :':3'i.F:§iEi€3§}§=;*': 9;" {ii} :15}? €;;1§§<:*: ﬁéiafge <§.§"i:§zz': §','1"';'_i§-';v§V.""§:{Jr§".i>§{;¥}3.}.iEi '§'fi8.S{§E}, €'5='§' 'ma s:s'i.§:€;; %.".%":s&1: it vzzéié E36 'é£"mf:?, if-i?§'§'§7§; 115$: -::1E:£*;):'§'7€' $932" {$33 §}i7iI'"§:}€ZiSf3f «Sf z?s§3§s:;s:i_fz?';;'r:'g Qi' §V2'5::'é§%:'~:+£"~:.i;:3'*4:%"i:s§€€$ '§:i;r 't;§3::% ad:::i::§$3:.:"§:%..z{::2 0.'? £31; $1., fﬁgjéé; T. "=;Zf§:':»£%i'::_ Efjniié éiuéét 2 {..T:§'{.,'. §"§.€'"f23;i-'ii wé§§%.';. i§;'a€:§'ﬁ §}€:i;.:2g :39 's:'.;%'§:.«':i§:1:_;%..:'1;7é¢:.:?§ ?:.§;:.€3 $23.22" i.i1§%.':€: Eégiré. $223 s;§1:'%;i%r<-3%, %;§:'{:§£e:'::' .>§}<_E§ §~<?;é,2§<::' 13;. :.:§ a:':::§i =5? i'i:":2.zi "*;%"é'§.§2 ::§s:¥<::§1.a§.i=;:&.:;1 :33: .:,:.§.Em'::S"%: 53%': ﬁééi iiﬁ-$33": V <:§§';;':«a:€.i§%::-z; 'in §Z,§"i€.*- ~;=;:.:é'?£$ 'i%%'§.'z'§§€;':: {..}:';:i:::.';:' l>§}'é§§ §"5_Ei§€i ii} iéegaés WEESE": 2315;'? ; %'§€:"v*"{}§"ia§.i2TLi§.'; {EH5 Z:.§1'£..s::"€é;"€; £2: 25': §T{i'§}§'%?S€,§§§2r§§,§V€3 <i:'i3a§*2i<&%tm'. =-'--"§»<.-"E. {..}§'{'§.{":§' };}'£;§E %<?;:§i:f iii} {;?3'w{.,.\1§'3{fi is §.§»i--'i'i~'~§€,"f€§ 52:2: EEK? §;:':3'2:;:*2p§€, 'iézzzéé 33:5 ?;'§'§§-ii :32" 2} 5;: 123%: <":;2::m':s.':2*:, £323 §'}::'s_>i.:g.§i:i" iii) 23;}: :::1:::§ zgméfﬁiﬁf /iﬁ {?€E£"i%'€:?'§;'éE{§ aés; §}a5::" iii?"-iE2f%€.'; $23 zamzii iiés %é{;:T;T'%;si:~: heE1§'}§'€?'i'E}i.'7 {1::;2'2a:*:*§. b;€§<:. §'.§".§.'§£E $19 :;":§<:<$°€.:<m 0': 2£§}'§}{é§,E"1§§}}€§}'{. -232:' 2: E;:'z;:"~s%:3t: :§i+:;§ .E1€§E, 3:: W £156 4 {£35.}, £31 EEK-3 <:raS:f*. sgsf Chﬁﬁtra Kamaﬁ ﬁevi 53559:.' Eéﬁifﬁﬁl S§m;§: & ﬂﬁzers repergaé in Caiéncii f.i§§ iii: Ezaa iiﬁﬁi}, iéeigi £31325:ﬂag..%j;€"£3_f€§i<::ééi'j;'ca:1::{?:i3&6 EEK: G§»%"-"E36"? <;:§ the §'}E'£}§i}€?.§"§L:i~" '-€{"§S'§£?-ii ii: 23'§;":§1:5s§ i§.;.a;': -§if:£:: is ':fi:2.<3 Gwgaez' (:9: {E7113 i'.m$?; ';3:9€ﬂ;_;€:*:'i§;* ":2;-_::z:§V _§:iiss: VV;§',"..t_§v-,:§i:f?;'E;~ 'zéf '£§'1€* §3i€'§1€'-ﬁC1éiiE"§§ is $0 czaii 1:; gircszz f£1{:.--§;r';:*;f: :E%;:~,, é;?(:=,::*¥€:j+;-- .§§:{:_.;i=:'e3§:}€1'i5}s' '£1; isygm, 511 ggggmg :3 aria; ;:§'§e§1;; ;3*s:;::zg;§:£;;gﬁ sméar reimg its pwtaer mmnwaa§¢£ S§°£.z;a§$s?:s:¢aiT éhyzziig 1 Keﬁﬁzeﬁrbﬁyan $25 §§;£¥§g §aﬁé*f:.':: " 3"j§:_;,_}';ag_' %}§é:;%r§: _§_':@i{g§ $13': '@3251: 21 i::"z1s*£. iﬁ :t~.:«:"**'1gj:;;'é$_i:t:.2;§ i;:§isfI!_'E§,§V§""ﬁéifféféiff-"Eli 7? Eififi cizmse in E316' %'r'u5'£. {§.é3Et€"i §sE?*;::§H::u;%a'::;*'::v§ ti':-af. ':3-"z.:% "1:i"1,;:t':§Y?,."":»'s§'§a§.§ siagissé ie'rm:::z.a'{.€<:i aesiijzs ;'%:'ir:":3: é:.§'m i.;"i::;~%§5{%:::4; :*m3<:§.:>.,tj_ V%;f.:'u€ é«.:~z::'::>u31§ 0% 33;: {Em €:§i{*;.::.§f¥::i11=g:-s a§z:T:*é::g '£315 A «3)£:W:";:é:2:§55" Tag? 'i;:_f::$t.3 ﬁzz': t::*z.:3~%i gai. €;%4I"£.'iBgiEiS§3€d £3112}? $2'; 'aim . :;r{'§_:33§A§;3§.e:f:§:r;;V: =:i%i-'.*;£i'::§§' :3 ﬁﬁi 0:3? in magi {§§23;:::::€:, it wsciss §::2::§E<;§ EEEEEE ﬁikmi :.§:<;:* €.é.1'§'EZ::'S§ 93" Léigea ?;I'i'iS{. aiﬁﬁéi mg. m}: <:@:'1é:.em§::éa'€§: " x 353.3: e::i:+:{5:<'§ :3? tCT'{};€3'eé'£."§f~7§§;§E{"?§"L, 'iris §3€ﬁ€f§{?§€%£'iif'$ {:()s.:.§s;£ 31%. ﬁis: "z=3.*»I:'_{?%{:<;>:': §_}$'£3ﬁ;:::;:.:: iii? '{::"u:<;"i. was :31 {%.§{'_§&§E'§3i}€'-if Eﬁifé €:%x5;c'::§0.i: ;_'}€':§§§s:::°;": gi:<;su£s::35 ix: iﬁééii a"§'§'i§}7 §.72§," §'.§'}.€ i:g'z3=,s;i.::~?c5. En 23$?-E a.;:rg}:%2ai (1935; 23m <:<>3:::€ :s:i'é'i';i;:1 E12: Stﬁfjéf 0.? @1152 €33, i=.,5:1:;3z:-1' {£25 c:::zv;*12ms:a31ces 12:33 {i i_1v3{?:i<>z'2s zsgzaegé §?}}' {E326 §f:Zi1"E'}€:f§- shagiﬁ jgmziigéi 23:: 'gm: ~,:z-$11". §}€%".Ef,:{3§E. imire 119:? §L5€{f0£1"£€ ."é;i:;E?:*::2:¥':2;:.i;us. Eiezzm: {£16 02:39:" s:§.::::r.:-*.«;§; L3'? .:5.£€.§{3% is 853$ asicizi 2:313, a;:='pe:«:aik ._ £3:-3. §-E31' {he aff_"5I'€Sé%§£/f ;z°cas0';§m ;_"'§=?A;~3;%.?ég=.£:589ijés pt"

€,£::ss:1i:'sse{£ *+%2?Li:_§'1 <:::>s*€.$ z>;:1{§;' mi; 25s§}g>%::«:i §:x'{§;'1?T4':{§V,{2{}%§§é: M €:§}.€sW'€{£ 2%-=°i'i§:c:i.1:: any 0:*::£e3.:sh as; ii0.<g:?<;:s;u?;s. {}':?%i<}r€' is zfiér€e:.~'{.s{é 3:0 {ﬂaw up a iiﬁﬁfﬁﬁ':E1{?C€}ET§£i3igi§::, V V _ _ I.' V' ' V. . '''. ''. . 'v.. I j %%%% Sd/'3 §i"'§?$§* ..

Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court