Karnataka High Court
Sri. Rajesh P vs The State Of Karnataka on 24 June, 2010
Bench: Manjula Chellur, B.S.Patil
we 'mas BEG-E-i é:ji'.€;"}U§<':"'i' «;:§> ;a:;A.§€h::A?:*a§;A, PieiN<;:§;>A§;,. iaméta A3'BAN'G£'aL{}§{§{i...._ : '_ "
§L':§£i"E;B TFEES mg 24% my (.2? VV V' 'E'i~%E:Z §i£§§'E' Em: MRS, gs.:S%':':<:§'.:~¢ié.§é§:;:§§:
*3'-1%: ;:§::.::3xzT*'§&z~":.M,§: :~:3R;";;é;;§ is' $1' §>;"{§*:A:;§ w::a:":;* ;»>Er:':§:':{§:€: %;*=a2g.§.-.::'33;2%%;;45:;;::§V::2 {$»:<;;m §€2%§fi§§3§ ii, fiéf 9 P'::,*£'§:~:5§:*;'_;m';}*, :"&ga<§; ?--§;%_};-:i:i2*s;. Z V ' R g'_:>:':'«ifEj§rié"~21};1ya§s:za:2:e2.§:_2;:1i; véiiézgét 33 330$: i'*v'i§;9'i::u';.%:§,s'f&§{§g:':ai:;3Eii, ' %13ha:1ns:p'a.":::a "E'a;E::k, Ra;ma;.:ag:»§z*a VE§§;:,~ir;1a7='I.» r« , .E§§iT§E"Eif:vE"~§ER {§3,;__;'f-3;3?_V_5v'€:§:§Es:9§t&3§: iii Tfiiéagat, fifivjs
2 H ;f;,."::*~;i"§;
;: 'T §'7_€. Siatfi <2? %~';.ar:1a'£a§{a, R€;3re$e::.%:::d E32' 55:3 S§{?.'E'€i£l§"}£' E.§€;§a2.*?.I::€::'i. {sf %i'um1 §3€¥€§33§§;§}€E}%', £1 §"'9V:1(:§*i:a§»-*a3' Rag} Kazzgaiaka '4:}i}"é?Ei"§Tfi11€:i?i§ Sifffffi $3:'ia.i, §'v'§Efi§§S§éZ3i'¥:jy'€3éi Baziééiéitzg, 23:: fi:::§3§:{i.§;<I;z§_;" ""v'€€~':{i'§1§3 ?i"£;21:z::g:sa.E<::'%_?~iSs:'ie{§ {Iii} E9 E3333} Eziahalléiagceuda, {if 0 Shivaaizgmidéa, Maggi', Patjl Maha:ag0'und:9: Pazigzzagmz' €3r0sS, Si:1{}.h,2'3_:1I1.r Reagi, Eiaraigj Past, §}3JC1g3V&ii Taiazkg Q, E%e:111k3z*a{i%1§;a 8.5%,, {fife Halaswaniy R, _ Majez', BM {}8E1g3§ih3."£'é':i.S'W3I§E}-"
iéaiiesizwaza Street? L. Tsziaisbannur, Hazfzzar '"?aiu§<.
1%. ifigvezxdra, {if 0 Lingaggaa fixéybigariy Maggi', }Z}evan:i1*3_§1.:'§.5 _ :::ja SA. I Ejraififiii, b€:%1.;i_n:i §:E'a:':g;a};a Nzzmmg H;;;'mz~'%_,~. _ E:§a;:'éa§3z::* L'«3.S-fi£.._E§f=I:$"§o ' Ti}. §}?.i3;T';;'ff€"i§§ E<i,§'»'§.,, 'A . -. {TEE 'R*§s§§§a:::3:ag<;:¥€:§é;"E%:, §%"§& ? . E} ;.?;\Eog . §€s:;n5a,'§€::»:giI§} _ E3. Séiyazagagsigéa E,a}<i{a:1ag<m+;§ar, Cf <3 Shifianaggada Lakééaxzlageuéiazg 'faflagiaxg $11 33:? E303: Eféamaziagufii, gégzziégéigaé Uttara Kaxémzagiak ' _. ' 3 , §_§s;§ahesE;g®u€§a_, «£3; {E ?x§e&L311ag<m_éa %v§afim:zrz.§gjm:;§a., figt: majgig §¥ia§;€$§:g{;':::t3aa f3fi§E§.Z}agfi'}'é:€,1ié1, ?r£a§;§,anagw's;:€§.a. mi ?s::«$E gmzgpuzs ":*'{":§':m;"g:-*2' '"\M,r'*-m " --.f%:f§"'1, §}a4£i§ Nagazrg i{s::"§3§ai, wk 21%, E§as::«:§}'g3a {Asa};
C ,1 0 ¥%am1.2mzé:.j;;pa Gaaii, figs : m.ajo1', fiafiapya {$33, ARCS Qfiice, Zfija Adaiifa Bhavagtz.
EEE. Siainarzzza Vetiragrga D0€§€'ima11£,V"
CI 0 Vfieragpa Ramanna V€€iF£;1§§.{i, Eagfiz majgr, i"}0(3e;iz3;m;a:1i, 43;' 0 Vearappa. €j3h,a3;2.dL1r, 33;: Gavarai Past?
Efiasabalgmlcilmai, 'Tq. "%:'"€i'E7>urga, E6; Bagavaraj Bac§j.gc~':1*, T -L , Cfio Cfhafldrasiiekhar, " V ' Eigfi: majm, ' Bagayaraj :E~3:':«x1.ig'6r, PG E§&t192,%7xi:?s,:).2sfi; . "
Ti; §<';«:;si1€2;.gi,_ .i}-igt. l?éi«:?sg_}§;:~133;2 " H 1731 V, izlégé-:sz3Tags::'éig§g V:?{?z*é.:§::§:e:'--: §'§i.§'fi§.}_2Zfi,, '{.§g"s3 :f'é--,«+*';=:x$m§f:_g§::»>g fiizzgaéaagazzaia E--§ir€:h22:E, . , <._.§:g:».: m,a;}<;:r,«--._a?; E303? E~ia:;.amaE,, E8. §?ia11_§ui1a€5:°E:f, {Z'..f 0 §§;i§:z31i2'drap§a Savazii, figs: major, _ Eviazzgghfiaih C§"ia;E'i§L§'8§§}& Savaéiy SE32 "=f€é:r$sE1Wa1":»3 Zfiiéajga, §E:$§'{}?€§3E§NT§:.
.V §;;;.2:;. igasmggpa, .a:;;,;% 59;» EM 5%; <2} }§"E:és:a Wm: §}€"EL'§,§i$§§ :3 flied 21:15:61" fia"¥.é<7i::3 2125*} amé {if iifzc-?: {.Ti<>:15;€:;;%:"a:££:::e§z <3? Etcssfigéa ;§:"a};i:";g 'E0 quagéi ihaa :;§Z{£_§}i§.gi1E;'*.{"_§ a3.z':iar 5.3"] f.§Ei.'5{,Ei{§. 37%,-'%'%V;ié}.§.{.3 vzzixé: §i.§.;.3;";.<i:%§:§§.'z?w§§ §,.::3.3&;r:':{§. bf; '£3.15 '§':i":éé;_:_u:§a§ E31 2:§3§;:«Ei<'2:€.%;::"2:i filéix .%{";-3.3,? EX) Eé} émé «:*:::e:1i1:::<.%t:.£t€}; §?;}.é:1§'€€f$v ..;a:~;§f?~:_§.'i1"zi:?§ {Em 2" =;'e$}j}::m%:?::2.E :10? is p1'::m*::3éi 'a¥'§;i§'.t. $316 :~;é:.Ei:c'§im§.. _jg_:3r§3' ésg ..§;ji.E.E 'éihfi £'§isg}<'>§§.2£; <3? ifiéf 3€}.€{T3;iOi1, if.Eli«.3;1.§'1i3f;g5 Effifii; 'ta €§E:g::*_.§:=a;33"g.V§5'i" §?'i1;'*.C._.§ Lu:
;3m's;:.§z:1n': 1:52 {E16 E'~§<'3,Gr§%.1>'a= 1$5»{IS-:3,§~'.:>::1.i"§a3..;3§}iil%3 3:5 jaxéfiiil '£2515' ._§1?a£. 'V*£r; =23;-5;=,is':.'a€ ' €i§}§}Q§3Jiii11€;E:EZ €,}I*C§€Y$ in rézspfigii I of fl:i':j {f:%§IE{§i£'§gi";L.?i€2?§'A. 53%;' ET3:~j~.,i1{g:%l::s:9:: E "aérai Sis; t::~§<;~t, C§1am.a1'a {fizziE2;an:£;ga§u'§1J.§%; '§1'%i.é}§§ fiagséuz, Eéaveri, Eéégjgsézé, ?'via:'§._{§%?a, 'ifililiigigif _ at1ti:? Ei}ava:1gei"t:*. i'iiS{;{'}.{"I.S $313.6: {i::§;3<>$z;:§:_.é;§' '€hi{s a«:;31g2li§*::fif:{}:'1$ yeigiiéiig §€fe:3r& €316: "E':*§mmaE.
':§'}1'i:-§ 11fif.%::ii ir'€"ii§}§:i:;:*_:':;*;§:;2é2:g_ {$392 £532" §"':'£:ii;:2iu3:'jt; Eiézzazalzig 'ziiés {Ea}; §"§{i:??;§§:s§{2 §::>§'-3\'§f§f§T§~f'%§'~':§:;"?;§:§§,(§§:.~'fi'i€ §e:;2E<::v;é::ig:. fififififl ~§,'fi"%§'§jf;f§" aizzéiazié. *§£%.~'§,2i}T;é} _;;§2233az?:%:§ §;§,=* E;E§Ts3 §§a1"2';ai';§E§z: ";%:§::;§3:§$€i%;;?;;%;i1é"§f"E":*:E3mfaaé :13 ;2:$s?3;i&{i £33 Ehis 'WI£"i%, pfi'i'é'§§{}§}. 2;' 83' '£16 iznggizggéfigi axrsiezg SE25? '§"§"i%}::§2:aE E7235; :;2':{;:§;i§§§:§ ':E3;§,> ., §:_:.'::Ea:_'i::: m*{§§*;:"* fiazéiazi" §i'&1'1"§.{i'{5; :31': Eiifikfiififiéii :§:='s":.::$ §§2'§}'if:g '$32.5: A§:2:E§§i{?ai:é:§23 {if ifs: E313; S{;'§{"Z'<?"{f£{}§."; .§.§§3§. £31" i%:§~: 3:a::{?§';a;:'£a%§'3 V "{§§i*»;€:§:;p:.:i;{:*:3;:%' {}§*:E:::i:a§'s, 'E"E;z=. '§':f:§:«":.':3,1:»"si E2223 §3:§;x£§.2?E':?§§.:§. §:."%2:: iz'§%:7::"17m F"
c:s§*£:§a::'?:" :::::«z§{'.é::.g ii <'*.E€:«2:" é'§r:::;%:', @192 2.315? :'3§i".§€l'f{f'§'i<3§§ 3:; 3'36? :;;z2:%{.§.:': Ex 'fizz:
3&3<;€i§Ea::a§;§(>';:...». ,__(i2%§t:{% ' "7?}?.Z;'iZ} {:1 _ ' f_:'\ afiissiaaif }:°f3§§}3Gfi{"§€}EES btiilzszfs if: is $3153: §;:<:;$§. Q3" §'ai:<:7E:a}r:.::§3::
i.}€v€Ez:3p:21e§.1t €;}fi3.«:*.e1"$ shaii E33 S:1§;::j;?€{':§; ii} ihs fizii agsggiiiéatiegzs.
3. Ezifaétfi. at-'; can $6 36311 '.§'m1::1ATf:§?;€ =0i"ai€%'- §3;:é:§s:i:§§;, fifze 'E'1'£b:::1;3.§ was ps:"s':.:a:;E€{§ is §:>:é%:5.§ $3113' 'Z}_ECiCV'71-ffl" @:r:§"t%%g:.V;§;'uE}fi:;iSs:§g:2§::
matifi 7:3}? mg: Em Tfifiiii €;:>u::3ei1i1:>;4 {£16 :§;}'--g:e«3_:i«:fa13I:Sg 'i};3,€fi'1S,€3§'i;?'%'3$. iéaswqivfiag with §m"'£§1<~::'-.._{§§%$&i--%;:»1§';i::V:?i"..j:§a,;«;*;«.A.E1a2?§31g regard is ths maizzsre: <2?' @5226 €f{)?g1_§I0*i€"T§'$}+',_§f€/EifiéfitiE1; tE'i{'*; mz%'i_'{§:r3, ii. 2965213 axpfiafiazxi £11 'i%}.r3"V:§Ii£5T€%£°:;,a:::.. z3f "*i§%:t? :%;ggi'°;,€:2€3éf';::::'§i§:::;;:::e§'$ hfiifiiil ii} giéfcégiié £3235 i;':§S22fi3E§ £:§;'E i'§f;:::'s:&::ii§:és;.%;;.5 _ "
"'§'§"g{?f _ :15:-*::"_m:i:i"i i.I'_Tx;:z§z2$:;%§ agipi-:%2:;"é3:g £52" £213 §;§E"§:§.'§ié;'f}§"i§i1"
A '?%'iE§}FEE§£fi:'ii1é§"£?Vfi§} {'§:a3:é:::g §§"_i§ §3f::1£ie1'2.<:§,.-" <>§"E}1f:: £r'1§}§§E§?£.~"§i€3i"if5:9 112:5 £gs.3.fj%1§%:>:<?é,fi5é$ hiigvfi §:2:'<;:c€€=:ié=:€i Wéiéi afisasééfiréiig fix: s;}E>j{::7*:i{>::;S rai$e§i_E§}; _:§§:z:€ sf E335 a§3§}i<t:«::";'ts mciuéigag £135 p€iitie:;::£:1* §1€1"€§§1 Km '£§.'}€'v§§§:'!§$'iSi{}E§_&.\§ '3€§€{?"£é=i3§: Eigt
3. '@136 am iiai gézicéégzfid Egg; gs mm éétfiafiaai afigfifiifi £3? iigifi maééeg" as :3 'i»%7§§ '$6. @353'; $23 at}: E"i§}§I}§,§(?é§1};§S :5; znjgii Sjmgs grtmsaais §}:::§Ei>rfi iha §=§.2%:°::a%:.€;'E§:a; fiémggisézaiévi? '§'r§t:m11a} 3%; 23:35 £335 zrsf €335 iizmé £¢§§°g3;§.§{i'ifi'§"Ei.i~i~ E"§€:'=fié:§_S its E735 :§3:sa{.=:: égtism" '§;§'}E:§.' §_"§é5If'i§i§'ig §"tf:g:e=§'{§ is £318. :'2:::i::z*e:: 9%" €}'}£Z'f «:*a>§':?;:'<)v:%:*s§* :*:::::~é,:::'E 335% $1163 m*g{:::c§; i:12n:}1v§%£§, ihé: §<;:-}wz";.1:;:E'a§~:an :'%.€im_é1'3.31$i3*a£:vE "§;'r§;§::1:.:2.:;3i $11223} :'§i§5}:::";:s%": :;3§ f§'.§.€ a}:;§3L{i<taEi0:':.;% as: 6x_"pec§:%::<;§u3ly am ;3z:3s:§ii3i:: 251%' .~€;*..E'14'f;;'..§£"'2'i*7;§3' inst b€}:{:a:"1s:1T ihs pt:;*:<>é :3? 2 310112313 fr<>};1:: Ehijt éiiatés 53%;}: '§:§3_f<;=z~;i§;:E "(>5 _.;:fa (mpg; sf '§§'1iS era? 63:', Wi.?;h. {E35336 £2%se:":«*at:?€}:1$, E:_Ei§%:..p§:Ei§i{.;:: {§i:§};£i'r3s_€*:.E's§;"
A d/:_ V' g IUDGE