Karnataka High Court
State Of Karnataka By Circle Inspector ... vs Kurubara Chennappa on 16 December, 2010
Author: V.G.Sabhahit
Bench: V.G.Sabhahit
EN "mg HIGH coum' SF KARNATAKA
C!RCL}¥T BENCH AT BHARWAB % V
BATES "ms THE :57" DAY GF aEcgan3Ea§..2';w§:T$j_
PRESENT _ .
THE HOMBLE MR.JUS"f'¥{_?E ';2f.Gz$f5's.'E!-¥2§%§£7f"'w: V
ANS _ ..
THE Houmg MH.JUS'f§$E~B,V.P¥NTG»V 2 " T'
ca:M1:~1AL APPE1§L.,;fJQS?5-5.52Gi)4{A}
BETWEEN:
SMTE gr: KAQNATA-Kzk
av S§RC:L§ s:x§sPE,.$:?i<:>§% <3? r".' GE_.iE;'_:§ =
§~£OSPE"}} W-RAL:;P.$;, §V4:i«i<'3S1;P'E'§-_ V'
_ _ 4_ % _;_APPELLA§\§'§"
{Qy 3-5; é¥_.~R§":"?"':'Xf§"E%,;'-I?-e--'}E;';%E,fS?%'.}: '
Am: 1111 M "
3:1; R L} $A'R;'é.fi"L'::~%'§.r\»:'ra.;..A'§2% '
3;!) HANu9gz:z:2;;'":f%~:;2§£s;é.V~"
AGE:_37£ §:'E;1%.RS. s';.*~:a'_.;vGL:L";"a3m$?
V. R50 §E\;_'A%.;.§'1~.F'U?4§. 'v'E'i.L.AGE
EN.H%:}SPE"?Z?.&£.,L};?<
~;,,R. -_. ..... ."RES?QN§§N?
{$35 ;:;;i;«--t~{ ;AK$H;f\fl§§<A¥\:*"§' 3533:! £311.:
._ 'L_ . "§'v§~§E;.'7§,_€l",§?%E;'}'fi;, §S FELEE} i§:'$,3?8{§} 3:. {3} {ERRC §'f' THE
$73U5*§TE ?§§'3'; i__§5:{:3Q THE STEQE ?R§{'¥'§E\}G THA?" T%%§S §-%G§\§'ELE
€.}Q7'%.;.§R"Ei__";'i;E;~"T¥m?" ES PLQASEQ YQ GRfi§§'~§'? LEAVE TC! ?§L¥":-I AN
;'%??E£~'%L'~_I3.,§,§'E§'~§ST ?%iE 3%.§?)GEF'u'?E§'\§T §"§'".?5.?.i}5é ?ASSEB B'?
me @§:;Vs.; $5., BELLARY, em $.$;x§:3.93;*§a » fi§.CQL,%§TT§:'\éG THE
QES-§?Q§\§DENT;'§{}GL§SED mg "§2H;§ ®$FE§~m::i% Rfufisa. 332 G?
' mg ;w9EL;Aw?,:$?,é;§E wgyg €"%»§;*--::" "'§°§~«§§ §~i:B€}':£E
iZ}QE§% fiéfiff SE SE? éE':s§§§,
M
THFS CRLAPPEAL {3Gl\4iN{3 FQR FENAL HEARENG ON
YHES BAY, B.\f.P§E'\§TQ§ J. SELEVEQES T?-'EE ?GLiGW§E\3S:
JUBGMENT
This agspegé has been flied by me Siam a%:a§V§_efi;:'§t::; the
jufigmemi dated §6aG'g.2804i gassed by the Fri. 8e;f2;~g:i':":;;:§'%.'3u"»$._L::2L;*.?:?§ié
$e!§ary Er; SE3, Ne.§3fé§96 acqmitiirzg Em :es§0n€i.<%$_t~;3¢:§%§:$€>._d «:%»%'EE7.§
zjsffence unciag' sectioa $332 $38,
23 it is we atase of tf1é§_;§i>'a*Cf.Secuié:;"*": EE7§¥j'5?fiA/"§f3@~v,-SQ.€§§5 e::i
abeui 833 p.{;':., me accused agéazgliezj the.'ds9ge as$§:§ Eviurzéappa,
wééh a sari meg when Ehve*«,d%;\c_efa.sec§_ 'mgafs-_S%fiiE%a~g> if} frzmt :3'? his heusa
Er: Deveiaguz Véilage w§':%f:...3é' §'s<:'{9?:*.2i:;:%r's 'iCd'.cia7'é§;;>;'. ms fieafh am? the
de€@a;3ié ci¥'T':.§':'§>.:ai:ii,@:'2 A§;3";é$;€.§?35 a:i"_":§b'G"ui: 8&6 am. afie: fiiscbagged
fwm "§'34Q$Vp§E3 § '3'i'"%§>"v??éé':T%§.*,*' ii is hem mat the accasetf frag
aemmééiedy:;-fféme':;§:$¥é;%Sé£i££@n 362 EPG.
«' W29: §::2:"egeVz'§ :':5fiE§:':; csmmanced Eis cage as-::2:;§§5i:":g is Wzmé,
'i«.:fE"f:_é'=aufi;$.'va»v§?%e.a§..Cansiabia 5:}? ifm ééaaszgséé fiijgéége fiaiésgz. That? {N1
§2"é'}i,_€:'5£%.1?9§§"?é;"1§;x'%*'%ier: be was fine S83 ai aéaeafz Eéfigii iiéacéa in {me
m§d~n%g§%:A%:;, one éfiufiéyapga game is fire %§i:::se $€a%§aa 353$ gave an
g%3%"~<:am;:;£a.éfi§. "flee aaié campéaém hag mar: resmfied 35; gar Ex"?
K} 352$ iha E><:,?~E€}{3} 23 '{?"%8 aigaaiurg £13? §x;§L;:2E*-;ga_§§:::3, Er; ifzgs
,,, 4
,. , .
M ,/ '-
,2
,«' '
sampiaim; the injured F:/kmiya§pa hag aimed ting': the accuseé has
aasauitergi mm with 2: car: gag am as back: émge and ré;b_.s .a t3b°Q:;i
800 $.37" and me Kugéthimmappa and Sha§%ba$appa ;"?éa§,x.'e;~;:%.¢é"§e:§_v%;§'*:.e
incideni. Cm mceipé Gf the saéé Eréfermaiien, Pwaékv.§e§A.i$:e:e:§ {'i".§:«3;
same as a case in Crime F\Ec._€5G..s*'E§§:§ fa;_*g§ie--z3f?'en1:§eVtgnafgz-EV_SéVg:_%i§;{;
32a and 534 we Smce ihe _En;'urée.:éA:§i;4:1r:%;:a@b@;: Aéé;al=§ €:a'q1'a;s§fea§.%
iireaimemi amd hence; he hag é'e§§:'*%hém 3:9'§<:vé.:.=n:i9ig34rfimfiosgitaf,
Kampfi far Waimeixt a:1d"§?:;_§ Ffii"?a"%;*'»za1.&.*:;. :'::':.§ r'§";,_g.;A; ihé' 3C3@u%E: E><,'P--é'i is
{he FER. fhereaféeri he; V%=z_'eé':t 3:»? €}{3C%J5'E'S?ECE and
reiurnefi bacég :;f§dv..aga;E:':{ went :3 Qevaéapug
'v'iE§ag@ tiw $90?' Ha pgegsared
$28 Sgjééf flEi3'a'E*:é;ii.s*,a5 :;j:§.$encé ?:jf"§W»9~Th%mr:;a;3§a am ?V'sM3~
Ra§::afi';.:¢a: E: gs §?W--€4 ma: ?W--3 sémweé a car: peg
in éfroréi §ha"§<':ou;::e; 9? ii??? txsrfipiaéznani ané {ha sgame was mézeé by
P'§?'vf53 b "T'§:«e.sf_e__af*aer, fie has pregarefi Parzcéwanama E:><,Pw5.
:~gt;g:d;逧»___%he aiaiemsni 3% fisfiaia Thirgémapgag Km
'7§f§*:%%:=sm9;;3;iie§.. 328% Easapga anfi miashmamma arid Gtheg' 2-"§§?L§'E€$7$€3x
' E'-T"'§?"%£~%§ S3 G.§<.Ea$a::aza;§a§pa§ was {he GPE, éjariag tha
.é;eLas' iéi-%?§--§§. E-Ea has giaiieé €533: $53 §<i,i$,E§§5;. he Eek mg'; mg
' %'u:%:?%é: §m:aa=.%=iiga§§:W; Er: Ehés sage érzzm @152?'-*; E» Ga iéie same flay, 'mg
--
végiteé Davaiapura Vifiiage and :;erif%ed the investigaiésn aiready c9s'*:éuc:e<:L He i'€3(:C%t"C§@(3 'me siatemeni 3'? i-ianzmaéah, Hermurapga ané Kariéasappa and aim further statements :3? V.~~rC_"§aEiara Thémmappa, i*<;sr§ Thémmappa, Saii Basagpa a:1d' §\€'é:'y3j;%a£<a Laxmagpa. He secureé the discharge certificatréimv.:;é'$.§§e::§"'*'3f*. Munéyappa as per Ex?-12. Gm.~®$.§1,"i.§§§; '--:%%§;.g% é3¢§as-6-3:5"
surrendared before him wéih an G%i;é.er 15%*éntT%c:%pa§§:;: ::.é'a;:%_"::njc:
iharefareg he has arrested the'}:颀.:~:;.sed éacé :*§Eeé3;;§ed 'i"«s-%srf;";Hr;1r*: baa,' Sr": 233% 'E .1995} he receévgd the F?;:;$f§:4:r:Q:"€§m fig.'-2-'peéffitjf {fie éeceasecé as gee: E><P-6 arm an tE:VeJ"--:=§::im'e'--:ja:§>3' v;*.z e«:1"'--%f'$v«::§:'d_e§ {he atatemert'z§ gm' sen$tabie~Eswara;:x9a, .,:=Q'r*;-2:§».G'€a§§_Q§él?"ééé sent the we3.pGr2 €02" §%1ejé;:é§'r:%'@.:§i;3f ':§"V2':é{iA:c:"§§&{:§ii:.';»:jV§"- He«?1ia*$* ééizefi we mater cycée bearing N0.FvW9';g233, in_{i*x€_%V"';,*3.te::§féa":§';§'? Ehe gpanahas as 9&2' E><,PV§3g On é562.?§9§;~-.hVe-r§¢e%_vé;§é§":é~~1'3pir°z§s:"z fmm the Medicai Q§fiz:e:* ag S8? §§«:;'§3':.~8: 'E_:1 F"'s'§§Vv${.§§'S'§V:Q3.J¥.®'%_'!?.'5'{E'f;;r'; he med me chargewsheei. '.§:3-a;rE'::éi§ vt%:e 'géaéx ma: gragecuiiésn £51 arfies fie gyava "me gage hag axamééfiééj in 33$ 1% '§a!§'§§"E%SS8S am' get ;ss':aré<e§ Exgfivé is "$3 533* 'ah-;,'s.§ pvhéduceé ?\;'E$s»f' iza é». fiafiez' gecssrfiirzg me ataiemeni a? me "'. afi::'€s$§a* UE""%fi€*F Sgciisn 33 C596} in w?§§€:E": bé has denéeé we " a%1a;'§§s, ...... '$5 §§3§'§":€€§ 3§3S§€}E§$ Juéga was §}§é€r§§é§§ is haié 5,// /__ 'ma? the pE"GS€CL€"?iGF'§ has not prayed frhe Case beyané reagerzabie dwbt and tiderefsre, aequittecé éhe accuseé far {he offence charged agairégi him "Fm State inas flied ibis appeaia
5. Heard an A.R?ai§E§ éaamea Aéd'f.E§PP §a:...::2g'e_¢» .§.%'a§§§:*,:Vé:t':fi Sré §.1§.§.Gl,%i"T.d3.Wa逧 Ieameci counaeé fer 'me 3;_:¢'L;s;e:§%%i:f>e*§pa;%r%'<jérj:t'«_ ané gemsed the rrsaieréais' 7' After harem"; boih ':he:§s§.:j.§$? fiia'pe§;'r€5?§*:'ié:%)§=3fi§S¢§..'3f0fM:.;a;%* canséderaiien are:
{E} fie v§V:*.,:c:,¥L'3g':.vi2g::s,fi':'t"';fM§a.t@c§ €5.8"§.2@%4 gassed-I %§'?é Ee':;3;.:r:Tr**':'€§§f,$$$si<:>e'é$ a?Lsdg& V' acQ"aVEi§i%z'g~V:: i?: 9' ::S:€;Cufs8r§ "'3? me Gffefice .. 7.un<ieé"'~eS ecf_i0_'r': 302 EPC ég jugiéfied'?
-{ii} ":.5;;r:;::"e.:d€er?
' Sag? arzgézéé taéfée abzrsve @6913 are as ':?£:E§a3ws:» E} Er: the afféimaiive;
A3 peréhe finai €§E£§8§1 3%? '::§'°:'é foééewéag re3s;;ar:$:--
fi§§SQE'\§S A $4 Pfiiixé"? Ekéfifi: ihe éegeasefi hafi 'saga 11:3 €529 game géaiéan V. ._ ..v:::'2 Em fiaie cf $%f&s':::;% 321$ ?i"=.H£ hacé receréeé Ehg séaésmaafi 3% 'am /' .» /' deceaseé as per E:>«:P-'£0 and regisiereé the saw. ?W»1é has siateé ma? sempéainam, aieceaged bad came aiane ta zine pcaiése ataéicn and 'me séaiemerzi was €@C{j}E'C§eé by him am iherejafier fie wag gem is the hogpiiai aiorng with 3 peiiae Cerzstabia
38. P'v"J=L Nayakara Lakshmapgai has cam that abmasi 8 years baak at I»abe»:1,': $.€;-£1 '1,é:A.'::1:,'*.g,§§j¢éVa:$§::i Mumiyappa was cifiafting W§'i§"i C's€'~!;'2 -- CiQ§.iéiaa Thigh-%::.é;$pf'&. ib a;f:., Eémeg accusefi came on Rajdf:09ééLE»._T%;/Eater ¢§z"::3_e7"A;3..?-'ed Eiire accusefi abused Mi£{":§';;'&§§3§ in f%%Z;:i:1'y..fi§3R§§'L§é§'e-IEgzisfiiéygg tEia"§ §§%Ls'%w%yappa WES masking a': him. The accug-aéfi §%'ss:'as.JE*ir::_:<f§ '?¢i;;:"§§y;ap§a wéiin aafi: gag.
His Siam: 3¥"1§'3«§fzf3L5§fi§@T::_§)§'Q§§'3.é'? 3EQi:{3 ',5f':§.€ff1.&?{%E3C;£i'£ ibis" Thereafter, hémgefi c§§f:%g§.%§un%yap§a is Ehe iviamgié Paiéce S:ia%;%er; "T'1.§",j':é E--%eé€3Z_ $';§::$§_éi:3{;§§':;"Nagappa mcogéefi 'me staiemefit 3% ?2fi:,::;%ye.§;§pa; .V"Fbe%v3a§ier;_"thé mime gem $132: is Gev@mn":e:":'£ Haapiiai A3:E':'%%'3 .a'§§.{,/'kg. igéxaggg an vivééééhctésa, seems' mtg him ta shiét Ffiagnéyapga is; E-1%$iEé:;z. %--%.{§j$pV%Vé:a%iQ Thgreafier, the daceasecé was israughi Ea Eeiéargg %92:::: s§E'§a%.. iézag ifiapaztéent 'En Ehe baawiai far aheué 4% days and éhsan "::.,e *l;s:e;,$ éakgarz *-3:: 'nia vifiage. fiafier aims: 3-é éayag ixfiamiyappa "E§"1e:ea'§i'er? he W%:"'%':{ agaém ta 'gm poiiqte giaiéarz am imigefi a ?i:fii'fl§3§&_§E"%§ 33 pa? E:><_P«€. E:»<.§"»»E{a'} $3 iétfi sgégrsaéura Me 3:33 ifiemtifieé the cieéhes won": by the cfieceased. in the cresm examinaiémm E1: E3 eéiciéed ihai tine distance beiweefz mg viiiage and Kampié police station is abeut 18 Km. arid they had been {Q poiice statéen ai abmfi '$2.03 'Q' flask in we mEz:i~:1%g%*:L E: $3 aé'~3;o{'-«reiiieévieé ma: were were suz'f§<:§en'1: bug §eai!§ty 2':*e::2'r:
Rxrther, sénca may ceuld mi gei the bfggé ?§"f8'§;'.e!'ii"€"'§"i{E'::':[5§§»Ka:m';?§ $5 an Earry, E E3 further eliciteé that éhe é:3:;}mp7'%a%§*:'t 'L/V3.é=.§V§C'[é'{C;?:§;"§.,__3'§: §'};8 Enstarzsre ancé further, he daea? -Sm? ré!T1_ei'i'%b€§:Efi}i"EA§5':ffj_e{ éjge has". meniémed in the cemgiaéni e><,P;L- €=.»t£E"za._tV he'Car}§e' its vknow C3? the Encééarzi from his sésier :3;r._2.:'i1?'V«-t%1e--'_VA§<35§%r;:<;-5' i'.1:;;m{eI" sdeaerdad his siaiemené am the séaéememf cf %*xAu:1§yf;a5;i;;.>;a §%§V"§9"§{}f.§'EC§ v?§j"~V3'IZiGV1y Rzrtherg ii is dem§e{%E'§§i a"§"%:V%};;, b§a :':7§"zérQé%":;e1"decéégséfi was: made: me szzféuence 0% a£<:0%1$E r:sn' the siaéeéfif .§VréT5i.aj'7e*:3?'{;'
-ifi, 4§4»*';,€*£~2;V3555:-,i\$$3,'a§<a€a Lakghmarema, has etaiieé 'mat . = 'd;é£é:3;.S:*§§%:'§ ES hes" bz§€VEé'é% an§ abfiafi a yearg ba.c§< at 836 gm, fierseff :a.::.s3§'§'xi?:g'é:--%V:fag:M::a:?; %.:_"sse§a sétéing 9:1. 'me Kgiéa Er; iyoséé :3? theé hzsuaeu aw"
aéiténg as {ha éiafia $2': the :>§;>;:>£:;<:~:i?e h§ii$8, Régnéylagégsa was 'ieasémg fézimgégapgsa. "Wig amassed came ??%€%'€: 5;: .22 .:':':éé>;j=: Cfiififéu éée 83§§§€§ 'zéée rmtar bike ma: §~«%am:,:2*a§@a*3 image 5 "Q aimgge-3' §'=§L§§':§§g'$.§g£',:§ Ea fiiéhy Eafiggsggg and &$S3:iE'€§C£ him gzréifi a ,, ' /, cart peg OE? bath: the knees arzé back am by the ieft gtfie at ttxa atomactt tpakkat. fwtuniyagpa teit dawn. ttezrseit anti Kati Yhimmappa were grawnt Wham the acctisseé asautwd §v'%t;tt.?§,§appa. Basagpat Kati Tttittttnagpa, Kari Qaaappat Bate Basa;3pé' the Spat attet Ex/tunéyappa tett dawn. They saw etectttcat tight. Tttezeaftetz, they wertt;»ta..ttte t'{ét9rt?;;ti't%A:..'§§u'r::'é3§3Et';:tt f§'OtT"§ there, Munéyappa was taxes to tfiey Bé_!§at§x %'§§%f:§>'€-;~'§p'i"$l'a:Ek t~§e.;V'tt:r'aV'?e:1.t3tt iztpatéettt tr: the Beliary h$sp%tat"t_r_;%'*~t§.ve déyt afid ttttéAr:9{_e:tte:, tte wasit' sttttteé ts: the heme MuV_;ntyappaV_;t:%é:§_att§t tat at the tf3€2td@¥T[. He has idantttted tttésztttvvhfiéasgj-ttéeg by the accuaed to agsauit tafltmtyappa. ta %f}e--;°-c:'§3$$«--<.r:;<atttéttattérttg,"sitte has Stateé tttat aha ttféé %7a1;ES'c2. §;a,:tteFé§~c§' t3't'§z'C*.;b§OWS".'t'¥t"'%V?t§ ttzctdentt Butt she did net tt1fQs'mVVt'tftt$§ to 'tf':8 §3"<;.'.{E%e::::eZ*.4Vt 't'iA:::ttt;.tttter sagtated that the tvtafitcat Qttiser, Kamptt t:é;c:§».ése:Jed_ a§_tfe't«t.t=,¥"r -my admitting Mzmtyagtpa in Bettary tt§."2¥§}"':%t:a_§LA'2::t°}fi tt1é'"3at.;.é.._,§é>::tt%§ was giver: tat: the pottcat Stte was 'zftftitfi ' ;t4ft';;2t%t;<':a:3';f;a"§.:f{"$_etEaty ttcsgaétat tat five $3323. The Bgctet tam that '*::t*:a.ttaeé:' {3.V?k"e'7'.:ai.Q§.§,¢~1"»£';%"\."a§ ara teas Sé they tack §'xfl§it"§t§§3§3§33. te the mum. tt té s§ta?'t§d.'§g; tts: that ta;-ttgtstyagsga; tett t;1¥'t<C.:Qtt$$§€tLt$ ttttttteéiatetgg attar"
2 ".'<§a::_e%astté"g the btaws and tvtuttéyapga ragaitteé his: €:t3*t"3SC§G%.t5-'L attet "V.§té§t:'%:ct§@?t was gévere ta him in ttta §°1i'j§S§3§'?8§. Ftagtt ttzétr aréttage, 'jhfifif "'t%ta:-9% attatgttt away gate ta the tzasgétatt 12' PWG, iélugé Thimrfiapga, E3 anaiher eyawéézness is 'me msident. Ha E133 aésa siaiéd ma: er: the dais G? Gffaacefi he came ?1§Ei¥' 'ma muse Gf §'~JiLmiyap;3a aaé fxiafliyappa & his g'§s'i§%=ws:e géitémg an {ha Katie in frag: cf thew Excuse. The ac:$:Jse§;i**a:é*z;éi}"é__'fiéi;fhe rrzoier cycie near the house 62' §'§('§J¥'1T'%l,ifag'..'3§€:L _.V__.i§Q1~-:;.né-gfaipga was teasing Thémmapga. The accageéé @§{f>::.3ée:%_ :'V§u.:f£y%a ;7;;SézV" arid as;-zauéteeé him with a car? 'megf can héa b::::k,"%._2'ant §®'i':%;0 ;'1~ cf?' S§Q'%'E";;a:{§:§'1;u am on both the kréeeg. §"~iimseifj::3%agl"ze.Bas§a:ppaV, '§<;--is:=§ werié' mesegzi. They gaaciféeé ?sE'is§:.V_quarV:'Vé'i", " %c§e:€t§f§'5e:€§'AE§9§§ MO-é aa the car': gag used by V"_:3 $§'s;=-ggiiéng Miméyagpa.
Theyaafiezn E'x:'Ez_;,.r:«?:§,{:§.p-;3a @213 %§§§:em }f0 L':?1g VE<:::{:'v§'E§ii ifioapétaie Hémsaeéf, PW$--%--._, 2,_ ri, x3%:'%iV-«.§s;§'a=reg:}£%§:*éaf: wen? '[9 Em h:;>3p%%aE( Pram mere; Mun%ya;§$»aL'"v¢Ma$' sh§f'Z§3':i E5-._:S:aE'Ea{y hoggizai. He was Empaééegwt in Eeééygz Eéaspétaé 39.3% ab0 s;=.% fine week" Tmm he was hreught is the \\,§:%:§.§v'é3;§L.§§E" '?gE§fii9j'{' ééui' afier ma? Muniyagpa déefi, Em we crass é:x~ars*:;:2Ta*:.%_¢Q%:[fiigek hag aémétied that %here was a $339 in SC. ?%é€3:.._.5'%§i;,Q~;%_':L"j's:3éé 'me féée sf the aaffi Seagieévs Qaafi ans' amuaeé wag a w%%:"1e§%s he 'aha ssaéé case. Theugh he bag siatefi ihai he cams: say ¢§i':§";*s:sr:zbe:' <3? béaws gxeééed by "ma azscuseé, ;%ma;e%;@:', E: ig eééciieai in 3&3 crQ$S--ex§mér':gi:%@s"2 'ma? mm 'Ehe gmiéce $i§iéO{'3 Em? haé /"'1 LEG:
styaigmaway wen: ':0 the haspéiai. At abaui: $.88 pm, they rgacized the hsspitaix it is further efiicited ihai Muniyappa was izaking iéquszsr. Raweverf he daes mi take Eiquor wiih Murziyagpa; Waugh they was friends. The aceuaefi heips fa:'me{$ in {he viiiage. E? ésj7s2::§;i'§§$«.tfeé ma? he is daposérsg fafseiy at the instance {if PW»? V. V V 13' Pwsfif 9 and 23 have t:1::':'r*vs:j;i3®.,'if"1'<.;As,j E§¥:e"«: '»€$'t§'fé fi:é;§§...§%»1%_fie proseautian.
Ni. FW~5, Eéafl §372+::,$appa;'"§S'*ii%f:<§§E*ia;f wiinéss; wfia has aése siaéed regarding asgauéiflkzfi in-eV'V1"c:i'@€_;efa::;3f:i }i*;.i'Efi 'zheraafiesx we deceamé bei§1,g«~téi<-en ti: K;a%§;_.§i%..%%'C%$_;1§_§aE he aha aisc Stated regagtiifzg __?1ésV s}2'x;a«r3féfia{:{2;2""~Ef2=g .'m<';~a pmiise. Furiher? in the siege ex5:mina.iE«€3rL ih§:s'w%V%:s'2éé$$ ":":«--:>;$"§:ia':ed iézat be game: gay 'aha number 3% bgaws, geéévvaredfiy %§':E3 accuseai {ha incédesfi méghé: 333318 iaken " pivécé *§}::¥%" afiéaagi "£5 E';/'vE'§'§'é§. before assauéi. Wfien {mare was exchange 1 %;§aE§:.$V;'-«.{§§:':§§e:§3f}~%'§a:§ came ihere Excap': ihe iiwree fi€ESG§"'%S whs aémjre 3§':%§rygi_;'..rzA:§n @3363? came 26 We spat 83329;' Eizefiéértg gaésia. fig hag gia:eé:;.,::E%1a§ Kaiiége iéke F:z§C2~<:i wééé be usuaiéy axgaéiahée mg: viééage and v%;s%'{'f:@r fie hag statefi ihai he £3 :13: a cat gag"
iii:
E5' PW»-§, Thémmaiah, is & WEVIQSS fa $2.93 which is 5:
énquegt cgnciuzsiaci an the daad boéy sf tine deceased. Aniirzagpa, is aisa signatcry is the inquest E><.Pm3.
'E8. PW8? P.N.KE'za€aL %§ a witness Pazzehamama fg: seézagre cf MEGS'? is 3,3;vhéc%2 :.>;z1'e'ria2---é§%_<,st§9ié:~.s :33' ?:E:1é'* éeceased at tine %%me 9% his fieam 11?. Pwfifig Dr(G.RamakE%$~Ei'ffi'a.AChahévdayyfiéas sl--§§{té%d Eefazé" V PW-"Jrfi the Sour: that an .2"i.G§.1V9§f5 at ab0'u--%'V%_:EQ'.2iE§_a.m.: ha..%1a§ e>:ar:2%ne@ Mamiyapgga who was bf;'<3L{'g':'1?;T'1:2§2'?i§;'7;3:§'3i§;§:%.V:§<:3.mpE% %Eice siaiian with a Exésiayy 0'? :;é$au§%, $ b'$:fer_;{e§£V~ i%?;é §a§§aev§ng imgizriees an we §;}e§'SC}¥'2 Gf 'zhé;:VV§fi§u_r€:iAV:V '7U E. {£3 A (f";E3iE"':'§§,$S'§€}fi!{')'*~.v'£§i" é"e:«~fi 's%d:§. <33'?---%%§le5.'bac%< ai Ehe Eevef of $8 :3 Réfispérée §a:eraE._ %0?.Vm'sc§*:i§e Ema meaauréng abeaéi 3" X ?/,2': _ _ $:3:n'%=:2sE%§§n aver %é}':;:%;>.<2..A:;eac:'ai area frag: ta: :0 Sacrum ' meiasmiéig gmgsi 2" X 3 V2 ' ,CQmp%a_§?1'£~;n§«.0§'gain in righi; eébmzs jaési me exiérrzai iagugy, ienfiérme's.$ ;.»ré'3.m=;~f:
{§@f"r's;m%a%réé:é"g;--- 3%? $333'? in me $91': §"§}x'SQ€§:§"1{ii§E{'}§E'v Ne axéarmaé ir:;a:;f;z %$,;:5::>_ér%;, bait: teaéefnesg gaegani. $arrs;:}Eai'Ez3§r*:g $1' pain in the 59%': 8}'¥G§.§§§§§' gain?' HQ §><'ie;':&a% v §r':§L:;'§e's.___%:%L2%: *:@:z§e:"ne$3 pregefii, . ',é"m-..jabra3i0r: 3%? me Essfi éaszae ggini ave: iéhéai i§Jb€§G$§€}~' ' '§¥.'}_§:§§b§'2:'% E: §':'%e&$s..%rEr:§ aéiéaui T' X E : E2 :
He has stated mat ihereafteg, on 0<:i.'E§fE9945, a: about 4,08 gamq he has aanducteé 1:303? morte examination on the fieafi bady" G? fiéuniyappa am has; stated mat €553' and 1??" riba were 5 ems away Sam {he Costa: margin shows gaarééai calicus farmatiar: a;1:::%_ %*i3 $13.3 given 513$ opinion fegarééng came 0? death is we io ;';*$é§:-1igi,§x.':a~%:r:%,%':L_:§ asj a resuét of Egwjum-:2 smiaéneé is the cheat abdQm.9rj;~::vc5ns:e*:'gueni"€21 him': force impaci. He has égsuecf pfgst §¥f£:A0E2;'i<':fTéi"i*':__¥"E§§):C)%'ii: S15. 6 am wmsné ceriéficate as per E;:x:._P«--7= 'E~=iAe"§:V;as. ?:;rt%33er'A.e7'><am§':7é5the'L weapon, M04 3% g§ve§'2 o;:>i:'*:i0%'1l"L<?§:1::$'%§f2e: vizvés gtated 'mat éfljuries 3 to 5 can bé~:::ause*é"§y v%.éi.§$V;§iL:;.%._f'ér%g w§i§'z"1"\.ffQ~4, fie has furfifier stated that by as§é§u.§'i'En<j;--->~$}ith jE?;(§'C"3a%:V..v£"?f"z'§re $3 §{3SS§b§§i'£';.i of f;'ac.:?£u:ré'5f ar;:5':§V as"'::£._i7i:'§*'17é:'s"e is gassibéiétgz :31' death by §rac'EL;r:é' Q?" EQ" a_r%:% T}? "i 'iaii,§hV._3eptecen1%a5 . $8.. Eéfig' %§j: e v:rEé}3$%'sx3?'ména%%sn§ be $133; Staiefi iééaii éfljuries 2 is} ' V' 5 <f_aE'§ E§€§,£8;~?.JAS8{§ E? g;é"';:se;:*§0n under me é§z%"2u&;':«::e 9:' aécahaé faiig an 3; V:":"§L;%:.:°§ ';:2€j§.3'j?:;'2§C'?:%§s:éj"-.3s.;:*§a$e. ii: is aim siaied by him izhai he hag gmgééiéirmefi'f%i:':.53:%1e msaunai ::@z:"§%%%ca'¥:@ 'ma: {fie §&§§e%"'ii $33 Eakawz a%cs?::>¥."'«:%éswe1;en he has ?EiE'§§'E€§' fiéaéaé '£331 flee iajuréeg fezgnd an i%é"«--:i,é§caased wéii mi {gauge any flange? $3 we éifg irfimefiiaieéy and ';ia;:%;%'2ar E? éirée éngigrefi éaézeg §Z}!"G$§?' ?,§"ea:2"*;*:e;r*::.= '€§'§€--38€-3* ézaguzieg czsuéé . .
, "£13 have beam <3ur@§K Me hag %L;::i"xer staied féhai if the gaiient discmitérmes Ehe treatmeni, he sustama acmpiécaiisa 3.%"1C§ he has we': received any reps:""% from \fEfa;IS éficspéiaifi 8e§§a§y. $9 PW'H§ §-H\1,€\»'§a§1abagieshwara;3pa, P$--§' ifi 9.8,? during the yeéevani p<':':f§C>fi and..ha~': has Fé'§Di'.L§ %'?V a€'1;;e:% receévirig the repmé 32' death of the ;d;ece2'_'as~:éd {<:;\ 't"r'*=:»=:_~é 'j:z%i:i%ii--ir;fi'ésfia! Magistrate am §4."iQ."§9§5. 'fEf:ér§afEe§','v- %V§g:,ah:§"AéA:;'nd.:gC%séfi énqzsest praceedérég an the éeadpfiéy ;:.{}d aE.$'<:;«..gj§*£§§ar§3d jg/Eahazar E><.P~4.; seizéag M934 fc:>"«3..:é.:%_Qi:;'f;es;_@$f;§ %h§v§;.:ie?s'~3_<;)fi G2' the deceased.
23. '§-3_.\fe§f§§<af{pé$§$5 i.$..i_r;\2e$:%§§ai%ng mffices' xi-vha has Ea§<e{27.;eve_%' .i:fié"v&"m<e:<:"i.§ga':§§';'g_.§;*;::r%': PW-$4 aréd hag fééecé 'me charge séieei 21 @:':';'3§2;r.;J§_3§A.:.3f 'mg eratira rssateréai befere 'tiwe Semi we » ifmffi £?:a:i«.:;=:: "E?:=_e firgi piace :"e§a.rd%r:§ aamgfaénam gsérzg is $935 ' *.??{";$§}§§é3 f?j?'%¥%,_'e"V£§E$a:epa:zC;r Seiweezz 'She 'xf§E"§§{Z}§': 3% §3;ie--va:i':r:e3$ea afihifi 's%:e€§:e's*$§er§ 3? ma centgéaénania Whééa we zjamgéamarzi ma Wk!- n1;:§_ gtaiefi {fiat {fie compiaénarzémzéniyapgia Eiad afiraéghi away {tame ;_V%G* éfie mime siaiéafi E":'z:""§§ §':a§ gévan the mmgaéaéfiami ?%s"%§g--'E is 3 ; E4 :
giate {hat the camplainam éecaaseé wag shifted to {ha hespitai direciiy mam the scene sf {}C€"3L,£§'3'€'F3CE'£'. T ,
22. PWWE fL:r*.:§'zer gtatea tha: at the time decea-$é<,%_fC§é':?.§ {S the gmfice siaiéan as we hag accampaniefi ?r:§.::é--,- :.;xg§I3'§'ev;?{ea<;{"'--«--f<E'Ié.=:", evidence af Pwsé is 3 is ma? 3fter_f:b.€35z'_'\!ve:1_;'"£§héL§§:}%"§:g§ §.sfg},}* » _ had again been is {he pcéice ss'£a§'cm :;i'<:;.s:z:fg 'w£t'%s"~'§fic?'iféaeé¥sgdv ?E"':er"efc;re, ever'; am this point, théraés di ScreV¥;:3ncy'§%§' ;t.if2;"3.V§3fg{£cfér2<ie pjresacuiian wimesses. Therefore,L"%f; e vgerséo%1%'3$ %1arréf§te§ if"? E><.P~ "ESE t§°:e staiemem: <3? ihe"§é;':eas§ed1--£s 'r2':%_:'»f.§,£f'%y _c:o{r9b@;raieé fmm the evidence 92' Exsifiwf ta .ir%_.{h<§ 3-fie.Vhéhéjegzemwiineases fa {he 5n$§fie:':'%_m'F:;s:*i:§};f@r, : Se§:: t§z$'éV"%'F%é somfiéaéfiamé had sugiaineé %:1§L,szr§eé:Qr'§ 2§.'Q6 T§Ea*§:3;:d'E*:é'gfied on 93193995, Le, afier a Eapse 9% 13 day:$"--«§rMasz"2 'the t%a%é?'..d*§ irscidem. Lime: the cércumsfafices, ii: sé;{f:'<%€:>§3aE§""§§i"%a§._.E><.P<%G Es {fig figsmg éeciaraééan fif tbs ' ,&a::gea$§'<.;£¢M 'éiéasé arééy W a siatememi given is 'zha gcéicé am i%: E3 " 'féjfiiaerv"$§é:;e§A[:=.§§r P1f:i«2 that ésrgmeéiaéeiy afief ihe énaicéemé, ihé fie¢'eas§é .E*'2éz§f ism 'mg <:<:m$=::E-Gags 3:73 he regaéma 5§r:3cé§u$ 52%;; 'after %2é5"was«: injected tsy $13 dacéér is $59 ETQSQEEEE. Tiwereferefi aver: °._%§"':':?:':}@:"$%::>:*s faaafi Em §><._P»'§?I.'% and avifierzase sf "P*sfi5--€é am we §:"'§j%J§"87§
--"%:a§":':§r:g ii; the gaiisa Séaééeré 335$ 3 zzamgxiaégéi was 3'£'€:{§f§=?-Efi %%zr@:;§%"s MA /' him is deebtfui eee eiiiwer versier': came? be befieved Er; view of the evieeeee ef Pwei em 3 whe eey {bet tee ma! eiaiemervi ef tee deceased was reeeieee ey me pence. Farmers ii ie seer: i%;'ei'.}?Ws*§ em 33 wee are the witnesses E0 tee recovery ef iwave temee heetiie $0 ihe ease of 'me eyeeeeefien eee r1v<"j>v'*ji'VevV:.l§;;';§fe:'t:e_d 'ihe eeee ef the egeeecetierm in Se fe%AAee':%we '-:ece*s_e'r3}<_e§ '!e'}G«4".ée 7 ceecemed.
23» New. Er: 3:} far ee eefe«§:e:ig';:brepeV':£~i,e 'C-eeee{%':ee';"iEie same has met ieeer: ereeeced Ehe.e-§re.ee.c's,}:%ee. ";F§fi'es'"efe.§eg under me eércereeieneeeg whee we"gea§i?;r§;g¢¥Q}§V::.gee:'jeV::i§ereee: ef 'me 'me? seem we see that the ieareed eeeessekgs Jeége iiaeeeeerved fie eez"agrepf's 23 aeeféd5e:'"A 'A Vfiéereiise. 4E3535;§.}§,,,:»:f§'e'.'.eoeree e? we inveeegefiee me V%f§a3..e;"e:g:5ere'd§. the ezahazer §><,?~4 under which V tee eEe'EV%':ev5a._.e.'?éee eeeeaeefi have been Seized. EXP» Mahezer Lmeer which fee see eeg Lew 5;/EQ4 e%"Eee§.eei fie have been eeézee is': 'fee ereeeece ef fihe .«.%e%ifie;eeee PWAQ Ybéezmeppe eee 2?'-'W-'£3, Qemeeee.' . been iheee ewee eee $3 have Eemecé heeiiée.
. ' They have met eeeeerfeef 'ewe eeee ef éféze ereeeezeéee in zeepecé: ef 'me eeézere ef eéee eéfegee ie have eeen ereeeeee by 935-3 Keré Yeémmeeeee is: 'me ereee-exegeéeeiiee ef ;@¥'xE'e--§ em 33 by 'she Eeemee F-"ub§'r<: Prosecuimz it is suggesied 'Lida: Kari Thimmappa PW»3 showed the piazte of effemce is 'she Qaiice ané pmduced {he cad peg aéleged is have beer: uaed by me accused fag" assauEting: T€§<:§ damaged: Bat bath have denied the S§7:l;.§C;3}v¥%3VE'$§§~€§§7¥,...V"'- Themfare, boih the wiénesséa to the fseeizu;
E><_P«:'5 have turned haatéie Farmer, :35 "
F3W~3; Kijii Thémmappa is 'féeijx 2;uhie3,fz~:~._ir1v E7§'3 evéderme %:here is any w%i%spéf 'i7Q 321035..':;:az~'L_j':*:§"'7 gmefuced ?\:§O«4 at £ha:'é;;>§;>?; beVf'5c>:f;e %zhg p:;s§§t}'a:%_yv;i_ipeVa:7 _t:%*:e K3 grepafed the mahfi2a.§"Ex.P¢S."~._H'i::--V-ev§.{:E§n§e is 8§§8E'%§ in resgegiigyf %i":g* *s':::~%1.%§_}:;-ré"'c':2f. §\~fEQ;4»"E'*;A§,! tiéje E0 E9 She gresenae 0%" P'Q'Js«1§icj. '%'V3.4 "" i¥*%'gAe7's%e.':»§'§c>re3 '£19 $@§Z%l¥'E af me car? gag 8.:3 ,§§§§§49?:,*'»'i3§v5:§':V..¥£;?é"§E'G$8CL§fi{f)§'i is FEST g'sv:*a'v.ea_f
24. ,5«;'?ief givégeg:;é§"z=-L.¢ars3f:;;;é__j§?s<3a,z§?:t is {Em ar:€:%:'e rnaiaréai on recaré 3nd an @325'-;:3p};ec%aZ%_0£'r._:::"f'§§i~§ evidence 3? the gsrawczuiéan and aise %§":vé3'-'.:{a:i{s7{;:11s*f:a€:<:Ve::,,_§?£_$~ are 9*? tée aaagédeied cgizzéen iéwat me ' :rf1a--8san%V:2?gs'«{§§V€:{; $3: the Eeamefi 3$S.§§C}f'iS éuége is pmgges' aaé $3 *f2:'>5:é:3s'é € 3'f"7§".3:'§'"',¥;'c§V§'_("§?;'*.v,+';%"{fI§QT*§C?E;"* an racegfi argfi we fie mi find arggz 53339:: ':3 §§vé:4:;*E %é<§:¥:"i"F9ée seassnérzg and €QflC§§3SE{}i"§ amézed 3% $3: 'She ééarrzasé V' n§:ésséa%%'%:; Jzifige. Em 'aha: View 9? iihe maiiea we frigid 'ma: tine "'._j;;€:£gém&?:% cs? aaégzgéiiai giaaasefi 23;; mg ieaiméé Sasséang wdge E3
--éaseé an sine evidence ma %'€{3®E'{§ 3% $3333: be §!'§'§€*§'§§%'€fi 2ar%i%; :17':
W3 appeaiv T§"'?€-'}%'E3'?0F€;. we held 'ihai fiwés agsgseaé is devoid 0% meriis and the same is; éigmisaeé.
é _ '*.€*§*'*z;'"'*» E1: §.?.5'2:.fi-gé « }§§§S§ F3%<kz'~