Karnataka High Court
The Manager Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd vs K.Babu @ Babu Abdul Rashid on 19 April, 2012
Author: B.Sreenivase Gowda
Bench: B.Sreenivase Gowda
E23? EHQE €fi§5'R'L"§ $5? E'? BA§G.ée.LQRE DATELQ "E'§%§S '"§'§iE: :§':"H gm' GE' g»":?REE,, 2&2 BE?§§€E T '§'HE I-IGZWBLE MR6 JEESTICE M.F.Ae N08 2871.OF..2OC§'§"fii'1"'§*§_'.VV:
M.B:A. NO. 3903 o:«*%2i09:9 IN MFA; 28?}. '2009 BETWEEN 53: ii. BABE} BABz;':%§§§j;L:r;' gggazaryéz' ' SfQ$ABDU§2li*'%v§EEi'E; =: _ 51:63:45 ':f'I~';.s::,R$;";; ' ' » 0cC::a:;:L=:i R/G; {i';'@."€?~;£i1;f<;<¥§f:'£:l'€;é?§?1%'£ "
21% §Z;'RG§$;5,YAE%EAL?§R§}'% _ ;8ANé;ALQ.;Q5' :%.:::>R'§sg ':'1%i,§;§E':; - SAEQQELGQE «».~ 3':<:j _ '__ . ,1%PP§.ZiE..:A£"%E'§ gm. Lé_'£"§;?E€g AEEVE '2, 3&2; .:§fa§§£9R;:
;%,:;;:;a~'§a.?@. 2%, giaygggm BESS'? BéE§i}§'§*§I2a ..%§{£'§~§E,?€£ gaaéfigaza 38"? $3933 £%;3;§*£GAiG§E; ~ E Z*zEA;'f'a§5%€+ER§ {%9R§EE'a3"§Zéé §?§SU§;r%E'=E€E§ Qéfji E533"
:*}.?§§, 3%, ?§{},2E3~2}f?% §x:f;%G;:?E;%B§i4% CEL%§3J§§E§?.§, 2"?' §'i${}R' E':r'EP=£E'xi C?;{};§.§§ Mb Cf§iA;§v:é§{£\.JPEZi§', 8z%E'J£}5%LG§%EZ A: a RES?GE's?,?j}_EE'~EZf'S {B}: Sn, 5%; §£Rgs3§9aAs:ai:a.:=g?a gm}: mg.
5%.} ?x?8'§i€'E mspgasgga E?v'E'l'§§} * ~ 2'*H;3 zvzyzfig FILES 121:3 'i?'3{1f,% $5' Mi?-..gw,{:%:"'~;$<;A:E€§;*:*"-V__ mg SUQGMENT gwa AWARD Qggrgs: 5 2;'21'.;;«::;i:'§:,':G9 §¥'AS:3E§} . ' EN MVC ?I'JGa3225,f2CFG8 ON irH§"?¢§;:__$; §2F._;><2:':.::"AB::L. v 4:33:33, COURT 0? SMALL <:A:§s§5:$.., ;%a£§:::¢;B._§:R," .,:.i:;¢;&jf:f~4. BANGALGRE PARTLY z%LLQ'x3ffl'~£ff} 2:53 cgggizz '~§:«:f1*'m<;s:\:
FGR CO§v'EPENS;%TIiQE'§ AE'£§ -.$EEE{fi:\§§ §E'~.§?i_AflCEE¥§ENT €15?' CGMFENSATEQN , W EN MFA 3908 2G§§._ BETWEEN 3&1: ;ym£Aa3§:§§,'-_-. § 'V QR1ENE:A;V:.Ns;;:'R;'a§*J,€§: £3. :;§::M, , awe. 19,; NG;'f.%E.":342£'?';'ff--_ E\LA.C:APR9s_BH;§a $aA?'¢§:BE:~23«--, _ 2% §:;§:>'@.R; ':.%3% . f;'r<r%i ;:R<,s::s%s% CH9;-§;éA.RAJ?%:?.'V_ -- I §ANGAL@§£: «; 2 8';
NGEV' RE?§ES§§?E£} "B?-~'%'§?"
E55: §:»i»§'%;'A'€f}E§£ 0§:i§£€::x; fi'§§€§?<%_E?€£;§ Ca Lfiia V' . §}:5?';<:£{;'é':'<«EA§?;..{_3E<'E'§€§§ ?€Q,fis<f§;"a;i8§ . 'gm S§§{}§~'??§%E{} cgwpaax, = E~$ESE;'T??EER?£'z"'§%€3A$ egasa ~g;:@§@A;i:§§T:=~ 5&9 azsa ,,; A??EL§;E%§§'f " 5:: 5:. ii :*><:R:§§§§Asa£?;;::@: ; :1 SR1 $2: 3,382: 33283;} 323:}: §«;z::$::~§:a :$;'{}g £38332. Ei:'1':R€E§¥'%i EEQE: ':"'EZ.g%RS;, aw: :>RW§::a E3/G. gig, §'w:'AE€zi:':ié§x?;':?PA, 35% $3333, '::',;§E'v:é;L£ER1i VSANGALQRE mjam '%'ALU§i?
BANGALGRE ~ 32?:
2, 531. S9 szzxagaza AGE: E%«'L4':JGR§ R,::.s:;:: Na £233 tj£YARA%fS REED'? B:3::{;Q;;§«f§, EZGNENAAGRAHARA, 15'i'€g0$s% = BA'€GALif>RE~ 553% 31?.
:33; SR3. gzjggsa M..m.?vR§"A§§i V§*<2jé:7:':«--,,' R2 » S;'i3RVES} 131$ MFA E"EL;¥3_§ UfE§""i«?5§3'{E}"8E<" E:«'R7Z~ai;";'§' 5%G.4%E;\J$'T €33 &U§}G§vEEN'E' A3€:}";:;mgR;:%.@g%3'%::§;% 1:23 2 2&9 933353 EN ?viiVC NO,3225f2SQ8{}'N 3*.H§'::»'€:;;:.§3§";§xm AD§ET'i€)N§L JUDGE, CGEJRT SE' S_E's£éili,L'CE::UE§ES.,""£%gEEZEv§BER$ EvL,%C'§~4, Bgmgaggefig; Aakafggzgimg _ i'f{'}§v§PE;E\?SA'§EGN GE' RS.?69ziz1~G,/:"'S7*£?f%TE'i :N?".:'ER£:$T"@_ 6?/5":a';%" §=R<:x::/f "555 §z%'E'E 0%' ?E"§Z'"§"_§{--,1*?,'*~;'f§E}2§.;;'.DE}?€§}SETE, "fa? Aénéésgiom éhég éay, {Ens {fimzrig :§%;§:2§§2:é€:Ci§ fiéiéswéngz 'ffggfiéfiggy 4;' is/?:i%é€:%:._v3p;Q$a§s 358 ayiaéfig eat :3? sammofi VA ggafizarii pasgeé Thy £329 Tyibaggi 3:33}; am H ~?;S;§;;:s:3::V%§;;'§"_'§€i:'5:€}§25§éfiigfzsiséé %:a3g'€%£%:€§: "$326 ggpsgég ars a§m§*§£:€é aziii mziél 331% ::;§:2§€:':§ sf" Esgynsfi $$i2§ES€f§ §§§€8f§§":f§ €133" §a:"f:'€S, figsjg ;:2r€ éigpgasaéi :35 :":*::3;fiy by ':§:fi$: €fii{};f":"i§f:{}§'; _§:§<f§g»;::":€s:2: 3; 85:6? famis as? $1315 pifiradsd E3': 3326 céaim ggfiiéégrs are:
That 9:3 }9.{§3.2@£:i& when $36 pmsesfiifig :32": 2: bisyfie SE': Ke:nf>'a§u2ja ' 'M ;:*:é_§2::£; Eviurugesha paiya, Bangaieré '8;f§"'E'<iC?L€}" .:€:éEi, ?_.€:f béaring 7. rsgistraiisn Na. KA~O3~VD~?§ }:;_' riggiigergt manna" and resufi kg Sugiiainsd gf:"ieV{>**u.g iésjévéfieg fiviiéaé 3 Siam: peéiiéazi b€fGf'€ §§j':j_.1%§gaEor§, seékiizg {:9mp€nsaf§..a:s:;::L §f Tbs Trfbzgésiai by §zflE3ugn€%':i" airfafé has awarded c:3r§::g3é:?és'3sLf§;§;é:§1 §m<<3r6§f:i: ai §¥/j $3: Aggyiévéd by--i§éLef;;mi<§~Qgégfigmsm: amfi awaad {E36 €:%3§ma,::i hag. _fi§s%§' '§\§§v1%;€§§{2.28?E§2€L'%§§ §€e%:§§1g €::'i§"§3iZ{f€f;?E€EEi {>35 ::'e<;€':§2%;28&'é§9z:. fifégfirégg $36 EEESEJYS? sf 33:6 isffsgzéézzg ':«::g:m5' fged 359% gwggggsg CE33EE€:zg:¥::g sag .3a::é avsaré maés E3}; E3 Tribagaé 3:2 figs V §m1:%:'::Z 'is? Eégééééiyv 5&3 {berg :13 53:3 €i§:$§L§,§Z€ Eegazdézzg Ezzgurias S1l$iEi§§E.{"?{§ éy 3&8 siéaizizazvi E3: 3; mad :i:*3.2'"'§E€: ;:é:€%_5€:3: {..I/W accurréfl 0:": }9.®3.;.fZGff§8 fiéii' 5:53 mgh 333$ §E€§§g€3"iE §§*:':?§z:g sf Qéfénéifig vahicéfi by Es figévszz iha pa::iE~r:ts iihajé £C£'§S€ {Gr $1}; €:c:ns§d€:°a§::?<3§ 2:: ms: appsaé is: V Wheih-3:" 'tbs '?:*§b:1:1aE is fastening Eiabfiity again~sf..:E1€ §n:su.r §j:'f* '{h€: . affenéing Eichsr Canter?
Wheihsr quagiéfttzzié of "'<:0m§,a9::V::$L:i0:::; aw3.:C1€& E3}? the "1f:*;i1:>Vu:3aV§" gs' .'§:1.:3i'-V ai::e::§ zeaggnabie gr dges ii éa1E'fQ:{ enizégiicéisment? 3 Ls8&r:},$& C0ui:1Se%j'f<::i,€E:»ié€ _:i°iz§ii:::j:a;:r:€ szfbmiis that 316 §:"2?VE%r a§ {§i2__e ®§f%'€135:2;:eg.4EZ§'€:§1§: 1;%T2é;:*§€r Vehéitk haéi pes3€$se;:i":'ié:::§:%;€:é%_V mséar '::°ans§ort vrshicie ané ihérefszfie §*iE%§:.;§'>3 é%t::.€:E>iE€<:% 'é'::;""<§i"i'=;,«?6 éihe, affefidingg Eichez"
C:a:;t§€::f. " 4' 7 L'§:$%e§":;¢;?%'?» %_§éz§fT2§£§.r:E§; fa.s§",€:3<:':€§ 33:; $5333 Trébuaai ggaizzsi §:?.3::§€:«._§$"~*§::§§ aéifzé pmpersf agzai fibers £3 32%} ._ §E§_é5%*aE§:€§ 33° §:*;."€"52;:'3;&:?*:':§r :22 333% 'mi ffgzerfi: 9?' $326 'E'::*i§:2z::§3£ . A __€'> ,, A. é tr E ( V ;':}';:v€::"€i?':'3:;{:%"Efa€ gyegyg éar §is§":é:;§§aE $35 $26 8;§§f§€81§ ffléfi E:: '{.§';a:3 _%:éS':_:?;:'5'€:: €::3:2§5%q2;€::¥;iE%; 3:531? '£26 appwfi fiisé 3:3}? $15 céaééézaai far sgghgaseznsgifi gieaznfifi €{'3é§EES€§ gm €236 izzsazsr af ihe Qfisrzéirzgg' Eicééeé' {f:a:::'5:e§ v5:§:i{:E§: gégéméfg 3333.: '£316 §§"i¥€:" £5 Gffsiaééng EECESE" Cflfiifi? siéé HG': §G$$€/SS an €ff€Ci§%?€ gmé araéégi éyiving §3:C§?f':{':€ 3% 03: the aiiaie sf E319 3;£:i:i__e:§€:"1af, €23 dréifsr 'é/he Vehicée is: QEESSEEQIE arzfi {he ?§'§?§€i§:f:£%.§ '--ViT$vv.4fl8%; jusiifigd ii: fasiiéirzizzg iiabiiiéiy agams-§_ "¥:§*7;e V"'§éi;%.:_i':'é:".._ thsrsfisrfi he pays far aEi@w§::g""i§--";:"--% a:,ap€a1:AT;:¥:_:s:f€:*:5€d'*b:gf ihe E:€'§$?;i£'€?€' arid set agidg {has 'E':°§32.;::'2aE E32 as far E§abi.§.itj§ i§' szfiznéis igzzarziurz: $5 CGf}§:}'.x'§§;§::E,"a%;'3t'§G'I3 A§:iéf5a;ré§;?:d by {E8 Tribufiai i5 gag: azfii is :20 saage far €1ehancem§n'é;§_:3fi Léé sf :52,p§£:=5=:E fiéed 3:} jsg £15 ?, eémi;é':* p®ie:5:::i*§ng" E§s.::§2€§ C3336? £333 528*: fiisizé u aV§§é':5£;_ :':§*:z3V§é§*;2g§é::j $336 5:? $336 'E'3:fm;;::3é fa:-gVg:'»:§:'22;g..A§§{:u§§%é::<:€: 5}? 3.C€§{§%E2§E'€ étafi {Q rash agfi 3 {%}r':%::Z§:;;j 3:? {E75 {}f§5z:di::g vshifgzés Egg fig firéifsr. AA 8, '?E35:"fi Ea 32$ €§§$:§§3J§€ '£252: éhs 'gfshisis in {§%i€S§ZE8§"1 £3 _ §';:':-A"Ei<":%i€§ iiazéész' Erghféeis 323$ 35:5 :;m§a_§&€:': :as'€§g%:i $3 Egg xéfizicih is 253:3 {Egg ZSQG Eziéegramg agzé fix §:*é:.«*<~:::*" 23:? {E26 :~:§3;%& :I§E§§:E§ %:2:V§::§.§ §<§S$€'S§'$€§ €336 fiazivézig %' 3:663:66 ta'; {}£E'é§7€ iighz memr V'€3,"}§{i§§ $8 ataétified 1:0 éréve high: meta? *::*a::sp@r%, ¥€E::?::§5 ziizladfier: Weighfi _~:::f Wh§<:h is 26:55 Sham ?5%§3G figs 33 35:33 ?:w:/3:: Eéfid E3}; i§§§$"':f' :€??::}.E3&5,§ if} 326 sagas 0f ifizited India Inszzrancs fig 33$, AS;fiLi:}c2,%;{rz5t and Qthers reporéeé E21 E33" .%:nd ' Natisnal Insurance Ca: Lfiifg"-_:répré.$_gé;:1te:i'V Administrative Qf_}"iser~.,_ "»--:;s Y?,zigz:%iappQ" since éeseased by Ms Vflgs sc:4é*:lé~ ;é§;i§i§o*i'§;e:* §9é?§T@':?4:V*/sé :52 {LR Zifflf} Kai: page 4?33;. AT§i'€;T$fQ.f$ V§:5§§€_?%3 £3 :19 error 9:' X' .
§r;§rm§§y Er; a':2d'é1§Kr~:a:;§ sf fthe Tribunéj E1':
fagtefiéng: §ie_:b.iE§?:f;}'=.:3.§.:i3i§:"?:éi:'--zE§%1eF§:*:su:"€:" 0f the Gfféfidifig is'*3:»§?;§{f}i€ Q "
V. _ ?xEG22:;" _ E '-%:aV €% E0 5&3 %3@§ri:€'£%:€i2:° égzsafiéégzfi 5;? c§,€%:p%%':%§§V§§aa ax%;?éL:*:i£é by 5236 '§'§i7bf:;€;3j E3 352313': 32$ ':t§.aST::::.§:3,b%@ }<':£,?:§@€§ 2*: cg}? for €:{:E1a::<:s§:'2€:2€:'Z? .:'§-$5 psi" Wazvaizé saréiéieafe E}; ? ?, siaimagi faaé ' Végiaiaizzeé szzbiaxaiéagz 9? fight aazamia éfiazfiésuéaz jam: " '' ~a:':€E Qéhar §§}jE§§}:€S aéé {mar {ha bsjdy, Eszjzgrésg augéaézzsé E5? 33:33 32% aésciz aviéfiné {mm ééashafgéé Ex. %"
P 8? 0:3? paiiené: Card 13 MR §€~z*3}2' EEZX. EL e::a:$€ $136635 E3 E2 aad s:,:§g2::22*§§:d by @533 §3i:§<'i€i::::<=: 0? thévcégimaéié 3335 fisciey sxaminsé as PW5 E and 2 :"€S§31$.t'§i3¥iJ§§\'%/'V:é'§f;f;'». ?':F;? 2 $3 8. Rzzjarma in his evifierzcs E333 3§aa:eS€¥_ I:i<;:§-éziairzzazfzt hag Suffered 24% digabiiiijg $3-'figizi. fgggpez' .%§:%::§:a_é;:'3'd 8% T $9 whales bagiy.
E}, €3@3:$駀:€:'z1g' i".":3;'i§.£E"€ _(;_f"'-.:iv::;':.;3'§6§'a:1dA fiigraééafiz ef éfieatmezzi §5A25?Q@§LE$"4 aja:»fv3:*{§%;'&.'"{::::A:ard$ pair}; and suffsréng as .v.aga§:';3"é"'»Vggxsgrdeé 723*' éihe T:*iE3uz::aE._ } E2. '€:ié;i:L::2;f;: ?i§g3349:§.§'aied $3 ;%;n§a3:§e;2§ E0: 5 a?a§g§ in BGW;":':*;§.§ E§Qs§:s§_%aE. E335 325:9; §3m{i':;::::s3§ aggfg §3§§E$ yeggréigzg '4'a§:3é}:a:':: ";%§€::r:: %,@a'r<5ai:'*::i3 mséégaé sxgsngss. ggfilsiéiflifiégi the EEK??? a 3:23:51 xi)? :'§ig'§,,{}€§G;'~ E3 3.:2;g:§§€{§ 5:Ve:sf»¥2é;:::§;?;;'«v.A.:*::§€§.§:EaE arse? éacidsfiéai sxpssngeg 322$}: 3.8 €GB.?¢"€§Z£if:~£"fi'; zsguzésizmeni afié aéiandané: shaggggss 33 K a.g1a2§§$*§;v--«;§$5§;@€§8;"~ awarésfi E93; éhs '§':"i%2/$233.:
E3, {fiaiszzagfz {£3/E323 ':9 hays be/er: sarzsizzgf §.5,§§€3§§,§-- gar mggiziéz $3; dyzkrézég gm 2g:'§:a}:éV<:::$§:3a;§, Qimsifisyégg his % ags, 3593:" sf zscziidsni ami preféggiezz 23$ 213:3 ériaiey his insems saxgifi 88333}? 33%? agsrsisséfi a1: R3é$$§%}§-.--gm; 3% *1 agaisnt Rs.3.,€}GG;'-- par mam}: as§6ss€QZ by §;§i}€i§71;.%1:, Nam/::*€ af ifijzgries suggfests {E1235 ha m':"$*{._i:.a}JeM %:>é€f1£..,, ands: imaiméni ané rest 3;: 363751;' «fgrja ;:;e::ié:;§<§£_ Sfigénihg T. 3121;} ihrsrafsrs, 3 $2211': af Rs' fiZ,{}§_€}';'_~ ES a:%z_':%.:{:3€:é§ égxiéafeig; fess sf §EiCO§f);€ during up '---;:6':*::':2':j "gs against R$g§,{}§@f ~ aWa:*(i€::i Egg' f;it:::;4:'="'E'§ 15;. "?h€ Cfiflfifléififi Eng goat .,_:;«*VL;'§x'g§' %";E'*'1 '€;V3V':'<3f:::'r€ gs.3::44a;:
"i§§§§ia::§dg 303$ caf féfszzrs izzsame is niksgt Qgasifisréfigf Q2? éigafiiéiy giaésfi; §V§'5;ifE::V€ §{:cf.:i}:* agza 333 amguzéi 0? fiiasamfori ané a:§:.§j:a:§;g:2§§:6$s":§i%___§§a§n::a:":i: 333$ i8 'L§E§§€E'§§5."} Ea 3/221% fuézirat ~ E-,_vf<3;'%fif'5'é:3;T5;' .§P:g,2>§.,fi§§§* i€}X?%fa;!¥f:S §%'}8S six? am€::.ii:i€s ag . "§§2?;:§§3s9€ ~ amd E7{&2§§€1f3€};"~ E0E%Fs8£'{§S ééagbéééigg 33 agaiifzgi E» aE--%'&E°f3:€€§ $3? $36 'E":":?bz22§3;E, '§I'§"::':.iS £136: aiaimazzé is érizéiiésfi fa? éitlesa féiiawégig {:<}:§2§}€§:sa§i{§:3:
:'.a_3,¥:92T§;e.i5§é;s~:iaTfa§€3:5:-i" 2w;§;,:"£§sa% E3}; ihég éfgzzzéi iegaéfisa" §?v"§{ ' ééisaseé ii: favoutz $3? $323 {:§a§::%_a:3:. pm W E} ?ai:": azzajé S'iif§€E'iEE§{ fig. 25§§€%::}/- 2} §'«'E€di€aE and irgciaismiai €x;}€::2$€s Rs» 5,-~é3__Gé};'~ 3} ?c>u;a:'és was ef magma during? E336 up psriefl Rs, 'E f§;';-€}§;G;5- é} Tavarfis E038 9f amenities _ 5} "fewardg {iésabflfiy R*s:_§' ;'25.g€E{}A{E;'.' V' T<3tai& & Less campensatior: awardedghyi-,4' 1; Q The Tribunal V R5515 Additional eempensatiafi-._:.
flames £9 35,563/5 «Egg.
E5. Accardészgiljz 'am aiéawsfi if:
part The .z.*§3,i§:§f2:::'é»--§;9 :3§i%"i€:Eé%o§. an addiéiazzgé c0m§ens3..'r§.Qr: wiéh §f1{€§'€S§ a': 8% gs?
3.::z2z;§::§ *;i«1';?::§_ <:E3;€5__V:;f"' @,3.2,§:":i peiiieiezz 3,33% {ES flats <3? r€a;§iV§3;'8ii--:;s::.V V ES?' _ 3 he §:f:.$z2:*a1::{:2é €%}m§a:n§,2' is {§iE"€€'§€€§ {£2 €§€i§§€:S§§ 'E316 ::{;sz::7p5:é':<:;33ii§GE: 223%/3;32V§ée3£§ éj; €326 '§r§'§2;s:%§§ 2s£E:i:%§:§§%:aE i , 52%.
§:§'::$§§§:i':%;§§:'§:§:2 E22259 mazzfzha {mm i326 @3335 of rézssiggé: sf 3 grazpy égvifhég gaségmsézé afié; $236 gams £5 @§§€§'{>,§ iii'; T2138 V é i Q ., gzaf : ; ., r =s E 2. ' ""4 «....,§ "V ' Q 3'' CW9' 2 g; M%% i$~' E8, in "§»'i€?E? 0%" fa.$*?:€:r;§"ag E§ab§i§:}; an {$16 ézxsarsz" aim; aélgwing' N06 28?} ,/2Q§9 §%%§:d by $36 <::£a:m;a_,:_fi ajiid sizhaacingf éhé %ZEGIE}p€EESa€iOI": :a:::va:éeé by £%:<ur:%"7§.' s'%:? b";;J;::a§ EE«E§'§: Ne. 3§G8;'2QC%9 ffieé; by the gnsuéer i§:§és ;;s;: suzrvivs for {:<:sr:$ié$:'a:i{m .e~z?r:<i_ 9ufi?CQ_vEfC§i:?g'3,}V7v--.:'§€ - §:s ' d§S§'3{1iSS€§g 'E136 arzgozzna if arijg, §'€.§CsSVifZ€§..':{Z1}§.A{3"1€fi§f1Si5£Z'€§7 in fiisér agrpeai ES GF€§€;§%E' {: _':Q._b€;_ :§9;'gs;f:5:":ii€d is the Tribuzzaj far <ii§aLu:'se§:~¢:=m: .
G5' Grfigéiaz éfs"----%a '€€i.;s3;t§3;-. 4;;/V