Karnataka High Court
Kuberappa vs T C Gopal on 11 June, 2009
Equivalent citations: 2009 (5) AIR KANT HCR 510, 2009 A I H C 3419, (2010) 1 KANT LJ 109, (2010) 1 ICC 356
Author: H N Nagamohan Das
Bench: H N Nagamohan Das
; %'.P.9663!:')S 2&2 "21-:5 BEG?-é CQURT mi' KARMATAKA, a.ms;,&,;':;;'a>f;»=2'_:»:5L«%I: if fL}A'%"Efi 'ms 'ma :3?" gm' 3? 3%.f?~§E~2$';G§:27.. '*5: -
BEFCIRE 1 ms %~%GN'8LE MR.,,'£é}STEC§5E' 9:_.§\;,.a:;a§.§:5~so§~§.;1'§;'..A:.>::é§k T;
iaiai? pgnnem ;~;c::9ss3;_;{Jao¥a mgm 8E""§'WEE§%3:-= Z §<i.}8ER,&§P§ % -
SIQ mANNA:,:&s'§'~:.h§a§é;$A' _ @ cHAN:s:A?J'FA":;:s:,«»%A "
{;::» Cfifikéé?%§._<i':;§'~;£*?a%A*«§§%'e.*'i:'3;&'_%_" A V A mm A3€Z3_%.3'§?_§8 YE'figRS"*~."_' .% ' axe ":iM,f:s;<::,_ A§:1:~3.:.§w_ .\fELiA'eE*E.,, Huififififiz ;-i"<?;~.a:.;,¢ i?§.f{3=:'§zf§§*«£A;G£\R»5& TALUK S%~§I¥*z§7QG£a' . % _ §;5s§'éG_fix??'r§ " % "
gga, .CHfi.§*€?éfi'§A%§» asssassg <22: J~:":;«:»ws: sssapaag va.:owz:s;a " . {g2éV%<:§-é;xL%e%¢:&;:~sz*a,&e aéiégm, . é'5iGEi:'.,a3s3{§3jTv5§2 ygms k:=;<_5*::§&.;:~;§a;'»J.§s;¥s;:9&:2+:*;--~: vzamgg, E-§£3?=e2Ci~:;a .7i%§©'&'§iI, ééfififia?-iAGARfi. ?'£xi.i}}< S§-§§P¢?G'€:1A_ ' wewszsxéggg 3 $;%34_.C§-E!'s?€N&.Efis§-E aasxma _:@_C§:iAf€?%ifiF'?A mwm «' fig? £'§~§A§'éE*§A§§ éfiéfig $§§?'§Q§x, .5»f£E§ A882}? 52 YEARS ' "RES ?fi§REG;%, §F%'§&i..E'%'§"§ '&f§§_.L&§§,. §--§€.§?'~*'§CHA HGBLI, H§§AF'€fisG£3RA Tifiiiffié SEIMQGA .;..PE'TIT"§Q?~4ERS . ::
3 '=§»='P,9éé3§fl8 mass (same) SAGAR I9; §.S.NQ.2Q3;'2885 ,fi.NX~--C Ts we war? PETKTIGN.
"THEE WRET 927112094 wrvms om ma P.aE%%£_zV:¥?3:L%~;:AgE*<\;{ %*§§AR1!'3@ EN 'E' smug' '2";-as QAY, 'ma c0uRjriLLMAgBELf?;-as FQ§..i...,0WI?\§G:~«» Petétéanerg and %'espe:';de"5:1;?;"'~~..{~3ae.3 '-aV:rs.~2. 'd{={§:eA:*'i;._§;Ea.'.-"«..--..!':?;i':s=;';~3 aéd. ' fespsnéent i\3%.: is the péaintéff b,&.f§é*$ tétzie t.r.§a"%« In this eréer fer cezravenience, thvéfiéarties ?fa zfa'4":'éf9;é'&:;&;d is their status hefsre the 323% {.2e:.3a_"t--. - 1:": V
2. v --?§:a§.€3€E?'§ V:" '9§§§efi~..:"*-Q:'.;E~'3.?s1s.,293,f20%5 against the §$f€fi53§3_§$ feE"'¢=a;'rt%i,E§.n A?a:_r€éi"' fse§ara*l:e pcssessésrz 9? his '?f35'§"
:.f s"§za.m v%:z§"':'t%?;é §~§.a;%r:'€ §n'e'::;iE3§e preperty, Tha ciafenéaats 3. is 3 §§%'cafi"x§§§"§*£:e§:::«._§%é'ta%§f:§§nt érzteméa zanzenéing that an 25.64.1981 a §aé*'i?:i§1<5r§ %_%a?§'3-.a§§*&aéy taken giaca mg therefsre the qagestiaa
-4.T."_j:..«,§§~..a§a§§% gsvafiétémésg aéaéfit xézeéasse grogarties wig rm': arége. ..sO5:{_A'%%2;g;"§b§_3s%$ mi' géeafiéarzgg, the tréaé Qoasri fiameé éasueg am the ' aamgéezeé his evééegsae as ms gide, At the time sf ~.__4 .é%;E§§n€e a? man: fie ifiéfi is greéuse the pattitien éeed dateé 25,$é«.3§8'?, aeaznafi munseé for the giaéntiff abjected fer rj\\:"'~3""' M,-
3 WP.%{;'3.a'i3S registrabie. There may be transactmiés wéween €%2e.&§z.%j%:1iV§é"s;*.T§7r1v..a gartécuiar daed whiah requires campafisory reg§s%§{3ti.s}Af1 é.%i*§c{ei_r fiectieri 37' $2" {ha fiat am %here may 61¢;-E555 be tr"a::$af<.:n§§vt:x_ns} s;a$'g/@§<§§~3 fie mt regime regigtratiers. The'rA5'e1f_o§--a=,A' ah"._a;:s%agE';<:;§i'e:'é*ci~.VV seasment reqaéfe csmauissry reg§.$£i:":ta,fti0ri':.::}c¥e.r $退éi§i':é' i? of we Act ear: be :*eca%veé«_§n ;ev'idé§1s:é'-»L._te pf<)vAe~A"Vic0§%aterai transaiiéasza which de not re qG_§re"re*§E$tr§t§%:';*:., Say fer examp¥e, status sf a party," é§'§e_rei;§t§¢z}_$:%3:§A'fi€.t$J§¢e {ha parties, the native es? pre§g=:*":§¥§;_$, §9s;:'§;g;é§*a4_;:..;:1e~~.:;?' 5§i.3ta:.s amang members of tha faméiyviara. aéi.V%'é'é¥%';-$é1:€§é3§<5§"=§£W&en whéah as not reqaére :*ag%$t§*a:Ear:.
&§;':L--..':§"§°zéL'.wa'%..§'§ 'c'd%"§'37i: e:"aE transactian' mereiierzeé is: the §a*3e'=.:§_§s51§.~:g f'ts 9;? me Regéstratisa Act earns up far ' V"*-~'car2$§dé:s:4;§ati¢.r:.'fiéféye the Supyeme Cmsrt in Rashes Singh am'
--« 1j'jV;;~sff?:'§rs assii; Eéie fiisgh and athers reported in AIR 2933 5:' £3 heié as agnderr "E: is ares'! seifietf that the fiacumefit tbaagé 2_sz%3;f&§f§£'e;e§ gas; fzewezxez" be fmkea' ésia far" 52% iimiéed ;§i.If;§@38 :2?' @s€3$§fss':§'s3§ a gevsrance 3;: 3:35:55, tfzwgh éfiaé 3éif$!°§f§{.'€ zzgaaxiaf aséfimatfely afiea' 55% 3353523 of {he c;"»"V"'""