Lokesha @ Chowdegowda vs State Of Karnataka By Kodihalli Police on 27 January, 2011

[Cites 1, Cited by 3]

Karnataka High Court

Lokesha @ Chowdegowda vs State Of Karnataka By Kodihalli Police on 27 January, 2011

Bench: Manjula Chellur

\W't";5%

 ""}Z'E"EE§ §"EE{::£""i QECELEERZT GF K5§§€NFiT;'~'aKA 3'-333' E3Ai'€(}.:?\§.,{}R§i
§j.)A'"£'EZII} '§"H§E--3 '1'?-ii"? ?;?'W 1:);-Taf" ii}? ¢§5'1NL.§§'s..RE:', 2&1 E g 

PR§%."ZS E.IE'*€'§":

§~§ON'E':3I..E}=1 MRS. JUS'1.'ICI'§ :\;:..;s,:\z..;LJL,:: c:E'-T1£:1:.:;';:'3E~éV;-{i    _

AN E}

B E'E'\?v'" El El.':\E :

§,{)k<2$E'12: @ Ck:<3x.vd<2g§<>*§?{£.:j:g
Aged abasm, 2.8 yearsg "
8/ 0 Chawdeg<>\>vda,

r»4:<)m31,;_1a :\z:§:z§ J1} STICE E3 mxr.2<:e:S':---amsAr§.sx.£§;gFs}<s;::';§ 

CR§E\r'i§NAi.AE3PE§A.1, £x2<:.?e§~.::.« <3r,§%"2C§<3'2».{£t)  '  

Residing: at Ke£r_1p;11neu:.h'"a2'£.i:1'a V

ééodihan: §--1<;1:1:'. ~ _
Kexrmeikptlrgg.T:a1411%:_,._*--'_ "  
Ba_:'1ga1::>r<-;>. Rzzségii». E)is1::'i<i':T;.'- 2 A '

{By Sr:if,€.Eia§:.::,§:',a;§i*a1i;* ' émd
Ad.xr<){:21%£§:;§' _ --- =  

AN  'V _

V " ﬁiiizzgifge. (ii? V"i{zV:"'r>:"_:.2«:i;a.§-£21,,
 ' Keejigﬁhrzxilé 'r"@_1is:*;e,
" £3135'JSt21%;?"~?"E..a?j{1-§.€?"P1'€>§%3EE{f:,3EIé1}fL

E.-EA? ggéfg C:{}¥;.i'3l':'.§.'I:' E'E'?':.'a§§{§ing,,,
B2-'s:2;};21§._;,i':*<::sf38G 99$},

%'<$$=%

. K  . g;  .App€:Ea1:'{:
{Now é:3...,.I.;1d'i::i'z?z1'<CVjL;sé:e::(ig}'* "  

gr; K,S.AR:3£§dy.

1 y ,R£és_~:«pm2 ziermi:

  §.E3g'; S:"i';-3%? .53.E9}am:g>2:1'1;§§r;.:.:na:iah.5 Ei'{3i}}'3i

'E"§':§§; {§':°£§':1%n:':.% 5?'a§,>§3a%a.:§.  €§éé:=,s:.§ :.;:':{'§2%r f§::?=:*.*a.§é3§': 31% E2}

{fTi§:§5*'.{f.T  *§.E'::3% :.:<§s:i:2:<a%§':'é;: <:§;:§s:%:'.E :'f'%{'}J%I}i3',2{E{}'"§' ;'}2?:.:a:»;:%::§{;§

5....»



'7?

'£35; i:.h<:% Eﬁ§isiai':ris::i and Serssiams gJ2.1cigge, E%;1:1g;:1}:>;"e Rzarzzl
i}is;t.ris::2.. §}321:1;__._§:31:>1'e: zzmd Presicii:'1g; Ofi"ic::::", f<'e1ss"L "§f;"2.ut:E«:
E':LCf'I\?a'352/'2005 --

C<>m~t,~V, in <%<3nvi:fri.i:1g  " "E:.h::--:

«E-£pp€3fiEéi:'1i/:£1ti?{IfI_.§.S{%'Ci No. E. £01" the <>€i3s:2'1<%t> pmii:§E":é§'i*§'{é;%.<

504, 3306 (B) S€:2C:'{.ia11 :%,g:«;2 §§f' fP%.3:i1#-.~ -

u1'1{i<3I°' S€{%t,i{>1':$ 324,

and S{'3I1i'.€i1'1(IiI},§.{ him

ada:iii:i.o;'1 to impos:;i;'1g fine of   

i:21p'r'is<):'1mem; 01' 1 year fa): the Offfz-'.17i(',€'.'.pU;i'1iS}: E'gb1{;':'L}.VI':£Zi't1317"

Sc<:*£:ic>1::+; 32%, 5&4, 5063 {B} ${::r.;f:§<}j:1 3G:2.__<?::"   

T11:i.s Appeai <:c::fr:~£.;_1g§_7fo.1*'hs;:ai*i1:f3{ :>'11 ":'f?iise; day,

}'v3'ar'gjz,zf.a t:?I'z.(-slim', J", de1i{:é:fﬁ%c}  

T-.§f1§S5._:;;"};§e::'£';1«V.%l_S§"f§i€,4{§ '§(3}f 'E'h.E3: exppttﬁzazzég. / ac:<?1::<se..d whet;
';?<J.':?i:'.§ array'~s-:{i~as$;"a{:€'i1::s.€:Véi*-._f\3{3'1 b€;',f(}1"€' ftiae iriai Cimré; in

S.C,,3.?%2/2§G€}..5: {>11 ﬁle {ﬁe of f:,Ea<;% '[7}is;i:ric§, and Se3:sssf§<>ns

 »:}L}'£§g€i;.V.Ei2'§L§."}§5§éi~:{}§"€:E E{1,:r21§ E'T)i.s;:;1'§CE;,

 2. T'-*::'j<u_:§§§'1 €:}'22?:rg;;=:z SE'it?'.{:'.E = m.-*'zT:se; fiieﬁ zigzimgé: s.;§.}:.

: A  aCCi.1&E3€',{§. '§"€{,>§4 s>;«-*2=:.s;  §}?"£l"x-"é;%3'§iE€l E5} was; mxi

" "::'.:fi:3€t§~«. £2": ii.§':a=? E§s%s:~:,-téon {.'.':E*§;f%5€3' BsaE'<3r:2 the iriaé C{>u'rE.¥

" 2z§%<"::.:s.-zeégi ?'i::ss;. E. E':;';2 :3? 5 2-m:::§ Q a:a&3.z":z §;2"i::%<'§ £23; §§"i{": <>'fi?E:::f:z:::::s;

= Jm

§}:.:::':£:;;§22:s.?:::»_':€ ':,4::';<:§;:3:' E.'§Ef{"'€.§_{}'§"E-i°9,% 25$:-Si   fE._§.L§«, 323?

to :1;'1ci£?rg(3 §A;iVil"&1: i::1;3I*i'&:£:{11::i€ém:-A ia 



7%

3
E386 2-anti 3(§i«?; Iyfw Ss::<:t:ii;:1': 3% IPC. The '::ri2=2} C<31.:r'{: f<>§1n»:£

2?;<::e::uss;&é<,i No.1 ;:_.._;f1.;i£f'}-I cf <>'ff:=?3'1<?tes p1.z1'1EssE121b1e mxcigi'

S:2%<:i,'i::3:'1.s.:a  504. 5<I}ES{¥3} zmd S%iE{fT"€'i{}Ii1 302 IPC. §%.'<f%<:§.1<sé;r§
N<:>:~:e.f2 zzsanci :3 E-i='¢';'EI'£i? f{>1mc,': g§1,1i£'1.y ezrsf (,>ft"e::1z:::.¢%s3;  *

ur:de.:%r S&%<:t:i<)3;1;<5 323 and 504 EPC,-V '2%»::<[:1.:s€§{i  :l§s.::_:1_ 

   

xvvera £1:m}::1{i r:<:2'£. g.§11i1ty 01" an}; sf   
they umraé z»:<i:q':.:i"i:i;e.a:*§, As  £i" §§:r§._  i;':}'1.V<;>.V  110
zlppeal is; prs.%3'j€r1°r::dv  thé"  a?}1:a.1i§;1'3g3§i;:1g{ the
acquit€.aI af other    puﬁi:-shablrz

EEIICIEF .f§€(":ﬁ{}1§  %%::ii.1z1«:?Rgrv§3§'}j1i:1;j':1<7t{?t:1x:'se;%d persons

  

:::>Iwic:t<-Ed fr): 1_és;sé1"' '<>{'1i"é'ri  V.,I'}.g:w9{i»'2;aV§é5c> 'mm; p:"ef'<:%rred any

app€:21§;'>_ Th£E§'§'f{§:'§'if'5"A, i'x2§{r'£*_t.€> deai wiih €:I"1e (72:55? 0f the

21§3§>ei.§_z::'1§: E, ;'?;<?<jz4'1:;<g;<;:1{i_V  wk) wags; {T?€}E'1X?'§{f'El§:<§ {air i:'E":€

 «.,_(}E°fE..éj;:"i'2::@; ._L§>:2L.;:'1i::--:;héib§.&t....z:;'.n£i{:r §3;<:<:&':.ie:):3 302 ERG :1E:)2::f,g w§t:}1

'  L <;'$'.%§ <3: _ E.1'ee--.,,<;_ §~:§e:51*'%»r_V;f"§'::I1£~:<e:+;.

3,.'E'h::. ;§:m:%:<::m. in zgamts:-:;§,i:>:': <><:<tm':°::7z.E am 2?; E .2i8{7§5

 at g:a%3{i:,;__i'36 pxxtz, 21$ %§c;11p2rdz1a't:}:1a:: viiéazge within. ':;he ﬁzzzii:-$5

"._{§§7._§%§,{:1::§§%1;;2.§.E.§ §?"i,:1Ei§%a':-3: $1;.aE.i<>2":, E7%;?m;§:1i0m E{:.::'2::§ :;Ei§$é.:"'i<;':L

,5é<:€t:i}:"{'i.§:'§;,: 39 §,%:&:% §I§E'f.'E:*§{Eiii.'ifliiiéié9 <::§:%<_T:{:;.:s;se-:{,§ SE':i.2f22::'a::;§<T2w{.§;2

f:éi,}§'} 5;? §.JE':i§.{:.& :E%§E'§.%%;=;z;g:>:m::i:i:. :4s:.:_.ze;':'.2§_E:'u1%d §':efai'21E §:1§"::..'§'jg.;-2 'zzﬁs;-E:'

r_<;§; 2



% [%~»;f""'*L 

suecumbeci "£0 imjuriw and Qthsr wii::1es$es P'fsi'.2e

Fuiétahalagamma and PW.9vMaram.nm su$tain€d,;$i;h_§ip§e

inﬁurééa. Tha pfasécutian reiiéﬁi upcm the e2*§§i:§i:;:5Cé..'_t:f __:;":';:7:V___ _
zvitneagea, 22 exhibitg and 3 };'»{§,;VQsk E€s''''ir:§:1e3:}éncE¢:';: .4 
€§?'i§€I1€6 came to be brs::ug}:1"€. on ':fec<{}I'\:1 ':VfOi1'».E;ET1€ {'§§ff§§.f1f$£31.;_'

Hoax-wafer portion Sf the exfidéﬁag of 'the 1zrit:i:é§:.$c--%. "Ci%:£}.'I1€f -, *

E0 bé markeﬁ as Exsﬂki  'Cfut .5? sgsﬁtnesses
examined by the prsééaggtiéézifv 8 3:13 9 are
   
rushed ts  Vgf£5;};2:3;§e':'1' Eearnt the cause
for  Out of all thesa eye»
W"itne€»;§es;  husband and Wife. P'vV.E

is {£126 éegﬁawy' ~__G§I_ "£§é§ea$€é Shizrangggwda' ?W,.§--

   ﬁs €}*ie'aa:§f¢.vaf deceaseﬁ Shivanegowﬁa. Qther

 €§ré'»:a%i::1és$<5=$" -._a:"€ aka) disiarsji 'E'€§&,§§'§'€S Sf bath ﬁle

§a"e:°€§£1es¢ ' ' "

" gﬁécuseé §'s§@.2+Shivanamma am aceused N0.6»»

« }{:--;§1$§13 i'§:§::3& are the SiS»'{€E'=S 5% P'%ﬁf."£¢ ﬁgésuseé §'%§%$,2

_  'i«§::§:..5§ are $33 {f§':i§§E"€"'i',§}; :3? £315 E:,i:;*€;€=:.§:€:* sf the &€{*:€aS€é
 $%:§%=fa:3@gf@z:'.2'§:aw ﬁﬁgugaﬁ E?€;'s$.Z azzé; 3 are ihé $E'1§,3;§'f€§"E av?



.. V 1«:3««:ig§

S
a::cL1:i-geséci N<>.2~Si1ix£21131m_2:. A{*«:%:.1s<?:d 1'\E€>AE2«I{1.§11:1;:)p221 is the
E1L4'lSh21.I1{i <3? 2'-z<':<.*.1,t.:s<%::§ §"\E<:),{SmK€~1'2<:E'1_21n1ma.. '_§'h{: camsae fer

{the in»Ci<.£<3:'1t: 21<%<:0:*c1%:'1g to Ems: p"I'{i}§§<Ei{?LET.i{)§1  t:.}'i2§'i;'~.P'*ﬁ.7;~1§.,

I1L.:s5;b.2m£i of é1(.'.'C'£.'£:'5€f{i E.\J<>.3 was; not: EHé}..iE"1_ifE:%i1'1.i'E;1§:.Q'"hééf ~
{elczéused Nr;},Z3§§ i*.i'1ere:=.f<>'r:§, an t.}1e;AA»~ci:14t.:% ziif ¥;{}i'efv »izs'1¥§:::?€_'i:<-=;n'é,_V V
Wham pzzdciy f:'<:)m the fic3.i::1s:s of i;i7ie: f{':'_tfKi{.A'3.:ﬁ'j<»_-" T:::f_ ?'X?s5 31 ~

smnaékezd in the E':.<::use sf c:is:=.ij_é'21_:s»::e<i V.-taihiVE'§E1€?_§§i7}S,«'£3€iE?£,'  the "

ae::C::;1s<:d said :10 have .~3.g:11e  .*--:,:3'  §f'iE1;ig,é "G§:' in am
aut.<3~riksh21w, picked    P\V.§ and ar
as;521L31€.&£§ §}{§i';     g,§ri.ew>us
i§1};E1;j~y 11::   .wI1§.<:i1 he uﬁ.i::r1at:e1-5;

$us:é{ta,:ii:1_'béc§ ' {_>:'{ -».,_29g1'T;?.2'{}§ES. Bafbre his dﬁiiﬁig

§.§::::1ed§z:€{éaé§*%% .a§"%f&2.:" §mT:i§ie:":L ssaiéi SE1.§2r;§'z1e;;;{>wd2:

   

{E  :?<{>r:r:§E:='_:i:'1€. 2152.: par EE§«;,P.9 ?£3z1s-395% :52": whiiah. :5: C£i.E3f3

»<§.a:*.r;<-3 ,t:c;=_%3{é"~-rf€;ég§is3i.<é:*e<£ in Crimes: No.33;'2{){}5 bjgg {he

"Eééidihéiéi§'_*-.?<::}.§{:i§. E;-,;X€§'3I ES 15; :".ht:°: §?'E§{ §ej:§i;2:i1'1i11g; E10 Eéza

<:a':':<:;§E2é;_é':":€;,GE" ihe: §:e;1i{:i 8%.';iV21;1cg<m;€i21_,. I'c'::..1i:}:a§=%:;_=a.::=%::'1*{. 11:3 EEES

 =:i<f:;1E;h "s';:"'.*: 24§§.E.2{}€}5$ <>ff%:::'2<i:€: ;:m'z'1§£;E';2i:?:sEe 1.zn<:§e:* $€';{T:'E.i€3E'.'i
  EEC xxx';-.-'sg gimaémigé {<3 %3<:{?E:i§_>;':. 362 §§?£';., ,s'%,§':;er

s::?i_3;1:i§a2é:;§:'3«:":_ <3? 33:'-3 '§'::vé;;:§ 31::-2i'<:;':"{: 3332:: §%%ss:%5;i<:}::'2.s3 {f:}:;.:§"'§';;

2.-:§';,:§'a.z.:.":::.<,':':'§E5; :,x;a7=§'{§ E":«::2::°<§.  E<:::2.:":"";§%{:E é_§a..:€_'.§§_§;'*; £'.E.{i{.'g'i..§§'{§i.{E{f§



(3

21{i:m.::s_-t«€::ci E\§<>$§5 .:1n1(§ E5 in r::?se;pe(éi: ai' ail t'.h<;% <':112:1rge.::e; 213:1

<:::>m>i<':'i;:r;"~:s{i é71(?£'I L.1S§5{Z.'d "N 0.1 11:12» 3 fzitrr iihee off<;=%:'1.<.':es;-2 1'e.f{:"e':'r':'.eg1 t::::>

abm.-'<37. .A;;"g:'ié%xr:2c1 'a::«:; 31:2': said 91 2.1 {1g§:::1en.f:. of ;§{>.i7z§%i<_:#§ii.g§:vz.,

zmci {>rd.er sf ::=;£=r";t:e;:-:;'1.<ts:; 2-::?c:.1:'+;<::<:i Nu] a..1m:1::: §a3'7ii§_é,iZi>r€; Vi::.<.é.= 

5. A{:<7e;32:"cii1'1g_§ ':13 Sri.P£.CiHa;m1:hai.;1i1, 'i1ih:=3_," ':;;.<m:eg:"'«

<t<m.nseE for this: 3.ppe:1121:'i€. if .£1c:<:x1s;@(i"V-E\I<>¢1,,..".;;EA}"€.§'1<;€*.e§2:% '

wi"t.z1€2ss<:s 1:>e-:i_:'1.g,_3; ciiescz 1"€tI21{4i'¢'€;'t§L=V.§{'1{":i}:"  <§é:?'r';:;¢)t be
1311135313' b5ﬁ9'v'"<3*<7i Emd   green.
{"i&"iE'(:? a.:1d ::i:2m*:.i<)_r1.    view {if this
2mim=:3:--3ii;y   '?V1}'i'€}:'P\;V.§ u1'1r:i<§:" the

;;'r:*.E<§;x.-ra;V;'{. <:ifi;:';:%.;::1;§;i'.:E;:::::S';«.__E:  qLiiEi{': p<>$3ibI.«:3 for the

<:?<}mpE2ai:":9;nf: §:»::,e,j:"z:3,51';<u§'~$§§c.;:}e: abzmic: {lag-.*: <:<7:mpEiz:ii;:§; eff the

::1pp£:E_i21:*n:  ..z:<%'<E1,:a=,;::d'N(:~~;- iE., being" the br<>i:h{-3:' cf aaztcusmi

  ;j'ETAE"::-3.:"§:f<>:"<§>:V "=i':§-ié?;§:§§§€f§'&Ei'§'.I§{§E'"§ sf §'"a<:§'::s {?:?e:m<}:: b::=. .::*:zl:=:d

 'm,:?i:;~ _23;':§f&:.:f:'1.2§%',iVe§[y.3 he :::mi',€::1{i:%s thaé, {':Ez'{'?'rE if §E";;<:>; a:*1E:ir<:

Q }I§"{T?,_i~a;{}

{j'f;3;'§€  {if if§'? :: :§Z§1§'<T§E+3€{?':.i'{.§{.)E'1 Vi-'€;'?E°§".'. {:23 E33 E}::%}ie:vs;%{.i, it W<m'£<§
<:sz2_i§.-9 §3{}'i.:3E:'€3§.'1i: an <:='E7f@§":_e:':e p11.:'1i.sE"§z>€:31<: ur1<:§cz* Sz;%{%i;§<m 325

£231}:  ﬁzz? ;;2p§:>s;%E%z;1;.:'1'z X 2:_:;t<%z.z:;~;:?::i ??*<E:,:=:E is-2 {:<.';3'1z:e;%:':':€w:.§,

TE':£é?§f§:§%_>§':fr§ E122:-: ss::%.<:%;sa :§E'}:* ﬁgs? :;;1&.r:é:'£<: §T.h:'-'-: gs; {"§;,;;m'::;-=.=.:'3.1::. :::a§ i:E':§:~





'\f?"a  _

?
c{>L::*§: beimv as we.I..E as 11119 <>z'»:i{3r :3? s<*a'1§:e1'1<%.e §I11§}{}S€t{i on

$19 €:'!.§3§3€'3f1.1£i.I'El'. by aiic:mri:'1g; i':1'1<:? app<::23,L

6. Ass a1§gaii':s{; fhisza, Sri.Sam;323ng;§ran121i}":, "Ef:f521.I:f:I3}:%"C14
Eiigh CoL1ri: G<::v£:r'z';:11e.z1':: PEe21ci<3r :~;submi':'.ss 'i:.11as;.t.."the:.§VI1ii.i:*é§'_'T H
evitimtzzte xmtiici g;<> to Shaw that. :;iiI"V{Zi"1::> t,(}*;

the imitédem. in c;u<:%s3t';i()1'a th<::.,;g§h a.;ti::__:'{:1;1i:.ives:év,_--»_Azééimnzét,paf

see be i:t:r'med as i11t'e'§€:st:c3:d \%:%'é:f1'<3sses '£253  "'p.ré§:%;er1c7.<:
at £:h€-2 reittvazzt t.in1é:'~~..¢<)f" «"¥;*,.E1<:€' i:'2{:i"<:¥._<mi; u%:1s" zaeither

ab1§_0rn1aI E10? ;:s<2c:u}.i21:: 'l"§1e2'é:'i'€3f€-,shé»;ijl::1i:.es T1-e£i.an{:e on

 

the e},?e~wiE.;'1<:=,é§"  vsfi_1<:3g -2:{r<:~f'~ Ae.;',*ji{?;=;~:«'-,~»s:':_§_yj' reiated to the
decsas-geci 21;iéiT5'.§;}1¢7a<:4:--:_;S£3£i. _ 5-3<t<é<>r{1i:1g;s; is him, Eh:-3, very
"fact": t,E121€j ..{h<: a{:s:%_:1§s;%:f':f p_{ii:;<§?:sé viiaﬁ eg"ga:r": of tha €1f3(E€321S€';C£

L8,, ;e.iTt:::i§3::m::':-» giziii pi:-érixﬁci hiss ;:.bci::>rn@;3 with E\«-'§.O:}%a.

 :;-E'a::_?:§ zsaéﬁgicé "§3j:t£3i{:at::% his}? in*;.e:1E:§{>1'2. was; {:2 {E9 £i§%'E'£§;' with

1f,fE::{:it-Eztaéégiesaéci, i'hé3re§:>r<;é, he $€E€kE% fa? £ii$z1':.3§.s5«3aE

{Bf §fh¥:: :3:;..§;.>§:3{:u=;?15:E.

A  '?., W22: }'121::e: §§€.)§"ié.:': £:§::'r:}:.§g:h {E36 wi{iér:'1«::s% sf :2;i§:':<::s$es

£2.§'E{T§ 3%.} zzaissa am: jz.1_{.§;§;;1}£%:':E: €35 H'E€3 {ii{>:,:.:fi i>£%i<'}:,s;.



8
8. in the <':ir':7'z.1:1'1.sss'{.;sé.n»:?e%s$; {)f1::.he <'=.as»;£3.-. E.he.=.=. p{")'ii"1E] 3121?".
w{>':.11c:i 2a:"isse £"<::s:' £31.11' ('G115-3ich:%rat:i<31'1. 315-5.
E} '.?Uh&'€,}:1.€~%1° ilht'. j:,1<igrnE.=§'1E, (315 i'E{'}I'1'v'§£'.fi{}¥1 zfmii 

me afsriier of s'~;<:':m"<;?':1(:c:: c1€?s;e:°w:-2 {,0 
.i:;1i:«:%:"f"e:%z"e£%ci \5Jii.}'1 at" (131.1? h:g~*u;':ads~;'? '

2;} Whai <):'{1e1*'?

9, F'mm ting: e:vici<5:};':1:::e .<f;£'-}_i:_Tr1_et.s¥:fé.§;'£i§30r1::1:'i-1;'.x7s§;it.11ei;ss3ci?;: 

PWss.1 to '32, {he §;€1'1.esis;   u€S{'.i()I'1
{E{)"€,?1§d be gmiiereci.   €%12*;1.1g11t'.<%r 01'
sister af PXV'; %.:§':1§; g,§ivje=:;:<1"$1:j;11'étxj;;Vi§1§€é' eariier ':0 his
mairrieige :.wi§'§.::.§}  P\.?\,?'.}. }f1"§E1I'I"iC*.£i
2l{T(§ElS:t'-ii 2 Ejhgazc §§r;'1<}vs,7}:::*§;;§@ éhagii, :~3}.";:;t was;
$1;'§T€%ri:A:'§;;..V_Lf:':::~m  <:hi1{£h<}£}{i anti ﬂag-3:3; swan

imd;2:~<iA2:2::zg;§1i:3::"'  :'1£:e;.:m~": Sllasshikzilza. 'ﬁ§ET;.<;%'11 ihe: 1epr<:2sy

 - i>€:V?::-:iV:£':";5s,%Lv.2;i':':;.:1e':1£.,« Vé'.*{:'::"<"%i:$c<i §\Ec:n3 wags mm: 2-£3}:-:7: Eé} ;*.{>;:»e up

 _ :;%;;*§?g.E'1 ?.2.i':'2§;'V:>€§_i§e;§ Eiiﬁiii-SE? émégi <:Z"::s:*<:>,:'~;'«::. *:.%2&;"€:E*<:>rst¢ PW. E arvﬂ:

é:§'.;_<;f: pe:':n'i:5.'é;iA<f}:: ("Eff his»; pa'-':.§"ef:',¥';".?;'§Z;'~,'> :;::'3:'§ 2-:::?z:'u$:'-%<'3 N93 ssaizé ':10

 i':2a3.:e" m';;::*z'i§=:{.i E3'VJ.25 i¥*'<>E*' i'£()1'ITi.€;? 'rcz».t.5s{:}:":, ?'x.-Rf zmeri 2

E.E;.§"Ta€§ €53 §f§é;'§§;"§{"}E"é.§.§"'§§$-if '%;.%1a..% :"2':§:"i{.i <3;

V _* *;>=J%:%:'*<:f; §i§%z'i:"i.;;j §:3:~1:";';méE°y* ;2;"é.a-':a}: €;":_3n"§ §'§'1@ f&EE'1i§§;' 2§'I'1{'§

V:.§»<:*:<%::§z*{'§_§:':g2; Ea; '{§'1.§-2% E3'%-'*JIT; ii"  E:;"=@{':a-'::.,.§_:=:;{% <32?" ;.:§?<_%:,.::-§:*r{i E'x1'<.:sé~;e,E}

" §":§:~'~; §:};::.3'=:%:é2§::;. §§'<}am;%2*€:;%:§*,



 

9
smbsseq1.1<,%t'1§:.§jg;: he was}; :z1:«;~sked 1:0 1:30}: af'r,e':%r 21 ;m:7rti<:=1'1 of
£1123: 1_;;1:1dec:§ pr«:>peri£e$ of the fE3.F1'1i..1}-'" while his; }32:1r€;::'1'£,s+;

'.2.-*e;=;:'e §'f;?:'§?i(ii£'Ti.§;'§ at Ba11§,§2s.E:>1'e. In iihcsé gzbzwe (iiirez.:.m.st9;§*:~<:e:s.

hf}: (':2-1.31%? 'i;:::> :f=uE'é;iv3:t.e the 1211165 {>:i"1;.he fékiiiﬂfg'. '1TE3.&:':T£é.'*'€c£;:ré% K
S{}ITif;'.. paz1{:h21j_,I21i:}'1s in the viliagez in i;11<;j__V1§3re::§é_h£~r:2 GE K '
PWss.1{} and 11 wh€e1'ei1'1 ac<r1.:s5c:i:i N<_) .:3g C.1t_Ef',I'I':'i é;'£17}._:d'L"'?§§__fOVv§}Ci 

ggraiinss from PW ,1 zfor he:f:':;::_1f a1":d;_ far E153?-IAda.ug_1F33t;é:*.\ 

A€fC€)i'di£1§,§ :0 PWs.1O and 1  1__ 'had'~a§{re%:t¥.V'€;<> share:
the e::mpss {min the léliiﬁifj'-Vk'ii~'h  *$&ﬁiif§%.'21C?{?'L1S€d N<3.3_

EQ. As: <>17:.vi}1€3, d:ri.z:;»  v§i.i,."5Zj?.1.2005, t'hc:

pe1{idjjsi_ﬁ"0m E}<3:3kis--.Qf~1;.hé::_ f.2:m1?E}; <3?' PR3/Z1 was Stacked
:11': tha §:.{m:<.ec:% <35 €T:Vé_::§3;:-:gé7c1..4Ei~héva11eg(}xvdaL AS: abgut; 8.00

gm. gm   PW} had F€E'{."L§.}i'§'1€d. {mm éihe

 ,._3a::': ";~:1., ;.§§':{?:;a:s{§ E'%§'::»&:....E.v1;',{;> 6 -es:-lid is h;i.1'%.:'€.~if EVi.1Z&Z¥§§v-:-:§L:.¥'i'§. in a, 3'm%;:{§
.r§."i<:;.s;_i"1.a§x;w.. 1-*pé21.r me: i'.§()1_.E§E~;€%:';'5 :3? PW. 1 amd {ieeéezigéd

"'S3}':.Ej:7'2§:':':s%§§é}:}sgig..--*i2é;%;§.<:E2 x>v@;"°§5 z»}._:i}a<:m':%:, {<3 {'fE.1{T'.§": €i>'§i.h.€~::: 2:u':{:i

<;uf:%.:_e%;':i<}:';.é:::iQPW.T:  E0 E1<;>w £?i{TC1}.;'-.}€;':{§ ?\Ea.3 wguizi :~:;1:$i:ai11

 éjia-::.rs:;e:é_"if._.i'§' he w2'::.:~;s :1<><:{ ggés,-»*i_:'1§_:,§ mix" 2121:; f;'.§'{}§}f§ géliér' 'E::;'/2*
" _'z3'2,;:§:jé'§:€;":.::2.:':ca: 'E'?i'3<=;:":3;:s.§T"¥:_<;%'r, ::§2:?},--' é::2?a§{.% 39 E11 ;::§s;2:::.:§?g,€:é{i.

" '§3%%'§7%ii :?J'E.iE'%: '§{.}:*:%I§E%"': 02."; Efaizes Z%T':<%;=§{.*'a ;.7::'1<:§. {]>:'"2 h€;%g§.:"_§:';;;g; ihsi ;,;;a'§;:é_:'.2::§



10
"W}'1(EI'1 P\K-K3 {f£;1..'£"£"£€3 (mi. of the E*:c>:.1;ee. 2-z1'2:"1 i'_:"'iec1 Ex.) pzéwify-Y
'£136 ggaimzx, s.;i1€ wasis e1}.s:;<f; ;1:--se.;§>:1,:Ei.&d E33? the: zzaitilaed
p«:=t§°:;-:.:::;r1Ts»=;~K 1£_',)e(*::;*.a.:<sse»:.i SE3i\?£1.:1€?§§{'}\&'{§21 whc} if-"3 :1<m€-: 

ii

{Exam iihiff jm1i{3:.* 1.:1":«::I<3 (Eff PW': {tame to the S}_3,e;_:_i; .$é1j?'£r1

ti,»

i:11a£', t';E:1<: 21<7<:z:1sr2::1 neeti I101: qE.3£1I'I"{?1 Xwiifl PW v§'c4;»rn E;hi;;.f

trivia} m21i.t<-3r .2:1nd thzzt: they am:  1ifjé;"jf§;'._t.0i'iii? ';a_;>.:_i1"<:3" of

the paddy %}a§§S._ whiciz 'W'€')f7€?_ $i',£:if}.~;€d. in  fh:;:s"a15.'«si;% .'i):\,J

PW.I for wz1.1'1i. of sapaste."}3'i11dir1_g"'-f2:t.;}%§ xkiitia the:

i:1E£:rv€:nt.i<>n of -Shiv21{1'ét«.g=:)\!.;?d23,V "'L}1y:vL"pres£:r1f, appeilatat, ae:ts::used Ne} ~ L{)k€Sh_iL€):C)}i <;;L_:"£.:a. s:Si~ub;1k'i.'r: to firiswoad} and 215-,:sa.L1i'gé._«:i (E1:-5;" _3§.§1§€;"%"21b(i;i)I1'£_§3F§ '{>'i"':3:5;ic£ Shiv21:1eg0wdad En1m€€E'§g1ié3}y'E~3_ii§x§a:i@;;:3w:fi';é__ s§'i'.21rt€::i ysiliimg 0:1': arid feﬂ {§{§Wi'E. ".£'E'§-imggéi ;1<:e:..;:::+;e:.{i3 ?*£{}.1 wa2s.nt:£rd {us %:2r'§;1;g; 5323.? 2:

«--._'<:hr§_f)'p€;:rV i":tg::r11 i:i%t§.::rv---aa:%;,<> riksizaw, he wzasa §3at:§fi<-std by '{h:=3 _ *s;*'i]};z:'1i\;'.§;e5:"-$_ ":.i:4ir"i£Z§ '%i:.I'2.<;°::"<:%aﬁ.e;" 2121 81%: %i(',{?'iiSE€§ wetni: Em-'a3J. §~i'=:,1,j;¥:%"%,:ejs"; {§?:2_:*"*{'._%':_e'-°: next: {$3.}; :12m*:':§.z1gg' $i':iv;'2,:3e:2g{>1>szd2: warm', in i;'4h£': V;P:i~'§m;,::"3: E-§ea2_t'.h {is;%z1€,er. K<}{i§E1a1EL *;A,«*ir:€%';'c;=:i1": P'vV. E';'~ _ E1Z'%:".E¥2,21.3:m':s::«i': €:>;z1.m;§m:%<i §'1§:":.*z and 2-2.{i'v;1:s:s<é{i hiE"E1 to g~,;§0 :0 £313 V Eizm;2Ei;2§;a..::'21 {}<:::':{::°22i §~§<.>s~;;§>§t:2«a§. arm; if:§'::ér<:=. i;»'JE:'if€~3 21 Cziifsiz an '£41m 2:'§i}{§€}E'§'}{;*E'§. {$23. zit-;:j;, Ei2«:.E;>,§} -- é;".{}§'.:."§§'}§2.E§§'§?j, at}? se;2?e.:Z<§ ;?3§?"§_§'a:s:3;:'s.a::§;;~;<;2a?{:§;?:. §E2.§E}."E.€;'i? '£10 bar: §<::a§.i.§;%:2%<E 2;?a§':.<.§ 2:. iii:-'i§'%E;f'. {__::.'s:":"::=: %'.{::: :33 E1 E'€f§§iSi1(i5!"'€:'.{§ a1.g.;.21i§'1si; aI£ 0? 'E1116: a'z,<:::::1.1g;c=n:i p€r:;a*(.§r':é.-3 fat' éizer z72f':i'&?r1<t<:s-;e ;>11:'1§s=;E':2-{E313 LEE'1d€I' S€'?{.","{'ﬁiffJE'3 3:26 2-mci mhesr <::i'fe Eli? g 1* ii. B3,? 4.30 p.31 wh:3I1 ﬁat? -5-30:': of Shix§igi.:14é:g;?§'wd:;z.. V. arriveti, he VS.-'&1E,% ssh'ift'.e.ci {.9 Sg:v,a1k$11§%i.E2:"= .§Si«:3%3p'_§i::;11;VA' Baz'1§g21i<>r<3=. On 't:><:i21g; i1"1fc):'n:.e3e:i "cef E3§§"\;'.€;'.'§."fif..})§:iﬁ»g%i~..A;?{H.: on-*e_r {the ab=:i{::men cjf i:i"1e ,;'_-1v_1'j':.:__re,r;i HE3hi'v';;;rieg:51§$(E21V 'émd " zifier <:1.i11fi.C;-2:1 r3::~<a1'ninat:i.Qn, f,h<;=:-~£7).i}'<:tt:~:rs csgaiiiczii. théai. there was 1123161313.} b1eedi:ag,'A _Tthé.xic§%'i'g3};*<: =E":=;{ 's;,'*;:1sss i.2:1k<3n :0 em€3:rg;e;':e::}r {_).."--§.'¢,' vg{%1¢§E§--.._ €i:":3.«:1i";ed fr<:»m Ehe E3j;p<){?::;;11dz'i_2:§* :*{5giVt>r: '«§3'f".VHE'If£"}E? _* zzbdemege' §~§<:w<:&='e§ by 2Q.'%.2:{}{}f§ " §i'%..i':s:V " "~:_3%3;';'f'?,*£i{)§'1§{127.;+§ sf %;.I'"1$ abdsrzzega, S}1§27a:z2€g:3v;{i21" <ii6':§, Ei:::irr1ec§i2ﬁ:e%Ey§ 22 dezeziith mszazmg 'W213 A' __'é:'E':c, p{'§i€{t:&%V.__;$g%':§{:E"; 'Jv'£ii§;§ in $:,:,§.3;.'::": §§'ﬁ,§m:;1€:é3%d 3:} iihét »<:«§:s?:3<_:<:é;*:":&:=€fE ~§}€,§§.%<_%€-: of E<Z<>:iiE.':.aE§:i. E30531. n1=:>r'£,:3§:': W'€1Erf~ {i<;e§"1<-3 c:>z'": L"'§3j{§';?'iE__)2{i?{%E§..» _T:;s3;{' ;¥'i?;f '20-E}::K.§x.:':::1:'1{£ zimi :.z'<'{}g}5.<-,:}* :"€;';><>z'i4 ﬁg 21%: E;x:.§?;E EZXPIE is éhtiz <3§3m.i{:.:.:': r<:ggaz'{i§:1gg fvE.{},§°

-.§53?%f.2.§131;".{}E':"§(i§T§éi§'" KR $'§'§€;'E1"i(ii2}; 33+; E,.'E":é;;>: {'.§:i}{f§){}§"' §:'<i:m *??36i%::.§;S§2€%:€.3*£:2_ §"§'::';54::s§'}§i;2::E whe:> :::<::%. {mi}? e.:<;;-:.:"::i.§'";é:§{"E %f§':<;i*. <§§:<':&%:'I::eé:::{"§ ':33?' 2,:'s:e=:.<§ %;4:'a:::;:%:<:3i§ "E'§'2:'<:3§,2:_;gE": Ezzlzza §iZx'§3'. E 1?» :'€:p£)}:*I". of fi.§1{? }Z)<)<i-ft.<:>1" almag with :%.21s~:.e. és}_1t:e£.--E1>;.P. 1.4 was; I1'1.':1.1"ki;': Ci .

E2,' Ai'f§.£--r1° §"€rgisi:m"i:1:1g; 21 éféiiéiii zxggzimgt. .23_.{:.:§V:;1s§c::~fi "T pers;<:>:1s, 3<->.w:_~émi 21ti:c:'mpt:ss v.:€:re,-9 r:*1:1'..:i¢ 7,110; 21 f)g3;"e:héI1d"; ihtstm a.11«:i 'L:Ei;i1r121i:€1y 'c1{?i{",'.uS€ffi Na 1:. 2.1;31j:' 9}iem:1€d'*21t:'~ G116 pC:iI1t of iéinra and the: ' "<:sV1;..'i"1»i:'.'1;'s»;a': w"e1f€"A »£5l§)p?f§3}'1€I1CiBd 1a£:€-:21 Aftm' taking i:i_:é'}._ ';;<> _"'ct:1_s§t,t:z;ij;j, "alt the Ai:'i;§t2111é::c:' of :;1::cused N0}, i'_::;>rc.h wfa§~:§' ='DL:.,;<i_11,_<;§'-~ t;¥.1e. ceurse of §nves1;.ig21i.10::;_: ...2%.:\:Ar§121h.E1?i£i'1' as; per El.:»:P.2 :2'. ﬂxrere S€iz<:{:§, inquest.

W215; 'i':V%:i"c;___§i€:21r §VW§§<:»d§i as-; per EXNPE arzd c:Ec)t,hs3$A"e:sf:' S3$€i'A-{Ed afier the pegt ::1Qr§;€-:":'";;.. "'£":25»:=. ..$i:::€.eI:f:er;t: of $e\2'e;'ai wii;z1e$s;-:95; énaéiueiéng , Fwy: 2é§:é;c3 _::;%,Ei:€3r s:y€:w':x;'i%:m%s3ss;*:s; <:ame 2:0 be I"€C':{}E"d§i'.€L Tbs " §:rf{§.-§§e€i%..s37:i::,:1 §=':';é§21:*;.1i:":&:€i §'s%ieév3a:1E: atjgas wi€:2.§r;ss<3s $9 the i:':::1£":.kr2'§"::. f';';:.;'§ e:§:4:@§§i.i€:rx :":1aE'§a:2:a_.;' wii::i:<2tSs£:é$.a and €3§'€'i<7i;?& " '%'~*;?;:.:f:€ta:;éé<-3:$ 13,9 s:<;p£3ak 2?:b«:,::.z"£: E',%1<:~ Efﬁiiifft <?:;:a_s*;{: sf Eize ~.\\£,«w\§ A'gré*;é;€;?<;::,:"i..i§}:.3 2-};.:":{i ::'§ss<i> é.E':<? E12'w-s;;i.i§§a.'::ia>:'": iéitmts by *z.E1::

V' §:'":v€;2$§,§ge:%.§:":gg £i§;'§{;"?§'§%Z;':'%.

E LI:

ef1<:.:<?.'1.:seci <:<m1d take :::01.11e 9f "(.1536-. paciiciy %3agg;se: f1"(}I11 hiss 1:1<3z.1£~i»;e w'E1i(?h were sgtockcd by }"N.1 fur wzaziﬁ. of sspace in £133; h<:;1,:s5<a £r:1n1e<ii.21E,§%1y._ 2:r:<:1.1:'es€:<i1 N53,} i.<><'::1<: a €:1u'i3='1§.?i:1g; 11621.: the h{T)1,'ai€5f3. h::r<3=}«:i:'1§; like a f£r<:i=wc>:>(i 2u:u::§ a't'j;.g1_L:E;§_s* £i.2;aid Shivzxxzegewdea with f(>r(:€ am his £{§')dC)I1E€31'1. -"._[u'.i1<f;'Ls.g'h 3113.'? V' €:}:t,<~3r_I1z11 izijiltfy W218 car.1s_~3e:d, Emwever'S§:,iv;113,é:g;:§wc%;§"falisi to the gi*<:.>1.:z':.d y<3:Iii:'1g out wiﬁji pzxixég "§;'h(>Lzggbfgagérizé of f;:'iv2e£ eye~\vit*.:1@$se>3 wsveal t11a'I:. ﬁifaé' ~:«;{C;(311sec{' ~f_0iu1i:1 fé;.L:}_t with {.116 de{r<3a$<3d .5t,<>c%ki:§g,'1:«z1d.dy Ea} PW .1 in his; i'1o'L3;se§ but PWs3.2 €10 ...9.. Wh{;r._ %itis3s»s~%é..;V --.§'?<31at.iv<3ss of '£'.h.é3 de<:<221--ss'€-.<ii" --si§£+;i:es" ihzé"..§ieg:e2i:s<3.g§'°a<:1",1.za£iy i:1i'.i:11a1T;eci the aC<:L1::eéz;i 1:3 i.~i'f€. '::§:?"}'#»s;'1£:T, {3f._i:'.'i;'z<--3f paddy ﬁeagss from his. houses. The §_§,{'3{1é;'§ET%«iE§§N{}3T §.1§'E§EA§.E§{ft§'§§.€E£EE.; fhzfr £E1{}i§"éE'€ fa}? 'ms: §:2{::i:i<':1:'i., i'1<)¥.x;j 2'-*:X21c€,1y V t'r:.(-3 in«::i§ie:1t', 'ha;pp€:t"1e:r:i emii when 23.$ssaL:Iie{i » €a:£r'h§31;":_V ii;-.Vs;.p¥:}ii&n E0 in the: {;'.*v'idi'f{."i€.f€;E of PWs';. E in 6, and W 3,9"

Zéz'-::j_:"2i:. §'1s:>w ﬁzz»? EE}{7§.{§§T§?£§. {_:aé:;:1.zr:"e<it V'£j;;§11{31.zg_,§§1 diﬁ 35103;; '~,--*=J'iEl3'1€S$ tih:-F, i:"t;ci{§<§::i;., he §1":11*::§*:t'i.§%;1t:.eEy m.SEa«:=:z:§ €10 ﬁ;§1£:: 5-g;3mi', an E162',-2'r'i:1g§ g__§aE.r;3fe:a and "E_'°'E*2<-?:'@§'"=::»§"<é§ {ha '7.{£{§':{.€ii::*.i§':s:% 2:»? 227:5; §;}:%S§::<% 23.§'3p§.§<:ts; hem: zmgi; hisg :=r"vi<i<-Err:{:§:% a§$<; ":,%{}r:"{7:'§::s:.}:°;*s:'é%ss; <_}%"§2s:%':' {s'vi::i:=E:.':<.t:;:: émégi 2'%.EE"§'§{.}:~,%§ se;§:"§";§§;i:.§f is; 3.2%? €:ji?$'§{§€fE":{'.é:3 <3? EEK: .§'E{:"§=3i='%{?f%§« \""'":.z S11iv21.11€g<>wcia ::~;u:+;i.a1ia'1<:{'E i_:'1j11ry gm hiss abd<t:r1"; <-31": wh§.t:*.11 u1t',iIn21i:€£y led to his <1€:at¥:ia.

E6. '1"1'1s:é evi{ie1'1{7:§=: ai' I)€><:%,{,:=:"s; §3'v'\/'s;. 1?. a1'_1;€i; :Z§'}! " relm-'a:'1E. in ardegr in 21rriv<;* at 21:":%c31i:i:h;$Iic::z'1« 25$-3%' «?3{.<t>V 'wi12u':; €X21('Yi',1}? is that :'121f::.,m3 of Q,f:f'<:I1c:t@:$:.. £11211. £16211: 1:::%'~ d1:' 3{\P.§1" 1'~. againgi. ACCL,'iS€(ji N31.

first zesawv the (1€(:€21:~':§d,_ &1f€[ca1--t:IV31 éQ~ﬁ1tFE? at Kodihaiii. A<tc:Q;fdi:1g i/;V=,#Ixi:Ji_a';'-i3<)L11:. 9.00 am}. an 28/ 1 /' Shivamsgowda who aéa}.,1j'1V1<i:-w..'VE':€§:.<_" {ﬁe §'1is'é;<:-Y3; of :«,13S21u§i: wﬁh ;::I.:§'t:€..:;}}:1<:_r1V'HQ': the §3i.'€;',Vi(){i1S availing" On <:X;§;r§)ji:11a§',i0':§; 3 cm X 4. Cm in d§a':ne1;<?.r %1<j:>;§§§a:§ c;E<}'L e:":»fr£' ":§1_3:<§V abC':<>1':1::%:'2 p<):'E',i{)I": <3? €;h<'~: §}f1jE?1§"€3(L 21:2»; the . 'Egg;js.:a;a*:ej::iV.w;;§és--..::<>:"npEa;i;':i:1§ sf grain. '§h~:§;s"*a"él:>r€ Em zzcizfiaed **£.§1r:--?:2:'z.V'ti,<:"_j,<_;':<_._> "Z::§3?'K@'m§3egg<>2ard;::. {§:;é:':.e;"2ﬁ H0$sp§_t:21.T: ssusp@<*,¥;.iz1g iizafzaazgggt i,1:f:§ E12312 im':£=:r'm=1E €'_}1"§.;€i£'1.§5 af ézhe ;1b{§<mf;€%n, Néiiilaer AAEH'-:.rr:_ ilhéf {","Ji{1€3E'1(f?€f €j}f s/:=t,E1er 1f}a:}<:i;<::rs:; 0:' {mm} the: I".i3€t{§i{E8.i §*€?,{T':{§E"t:iE% §:'":'>§':<2 §&év:a:§::s?s.§?€.r2:. §'":::.>sap1i€',::1§ <':::::{=: {'.iE3;§'1 mzeaéie (mi: are;'§i:=:é:;§':e::°' 3.2:? vi:';»§:%.%;:€:;:% éihﬁ Ké':'i"i'é§;&E§g,§€}§¥{§§i iEé:%';:e:°2;:.§_ 'E~£<;~s5~;§3ii:2:E 21$; :-*eT<>§¥§s§{'%{:§., %Zf§§1 iim;-3 <ﬁ,'m=7;: §':2;2;..:":s:.§ {:23 :.'§":@ éifféﬁféii <1}? 55%;}. :3? PW. 1. 7».If{ame$ii" 5' 'tght-': cizrjv,-;<:*m1' who '18 ﬁetiteased vibe 33 examined as PEER 12' he iﬁhiﬁaanegewda) was admittﬁé to Sevakshetra H<:3-apitai.

1?, W212; D1: Giridhar K; Shenoy wﬁo Speaks about the treatméfjﬁg bat j;1'--?:,e .;;'§§?:f$*é_,1:1f1s--<é}'tré;'« hospital to the injureﬁdecéaééé. Sj1f:_i$:¢:'iV:*1z€«g'Va**§§§%ti$i;'~.VV According to Ehis witness, / 3 / pin. V injured Shigrgneg0m>d€%;_.'%?a.g 'Fliésjvcvsital with the history of AaSSa.uIAtV_ with wooden stick at Vexaminatian, he found. ti€r1«s:' 0:71 the injured \ _ .

i} A E<:i'13.rrri{3l$i$""0_ﬁ' "the anterier abdgminal w_a1I gbieééirig on the abﬁemen} _iiE . 'f:ubCu5{a_1":€€:us hasmatema :23. '':hr::

" épigagtria area.

Hé"';3€:?fm'*:§i€é emerggenejg iaparatamy and {wand 9., iargs " "$31: iﬁ ftha ier:ni.na§ ﬁeum~per§;i:9ria1 Cavity fuii sf mmi "ggaéiﬁ m.ai:"é@:*~§ae£a};. Ekuriag the Cff'{}S$ examinaiiang it "wag giigéiaé {ram {$33 égciar ihai wag: if 3. gasrgagz faiig \.'k\\"»N£"m fmzzg a §a.rap9: ':s;a§§.§; gm $35 azmeé $"i.§a:§§ fixed élﬁ gmuizé (g0a¥;a} the injuries as fcsunﬁ an deceased Shixfansgowda ceuhti happen. From thﬁ evidence sf this &::s<:1';0:: Vggi.:§"t.§1€ €§?id€};'iC€ sf ether Past Martem dsctor, it is c}::%§:é§1*" _ acwunt Csf injury is this gmafy i1"1*:€s;»'*:'i~1f':£:--.:::'f;ii '1%3<§_ tﬁé Caiiectian af fluid with :nt;a.rnag£T..::'bie»e1d§,:§tg ultimateiy led to surgery? Sé%;a;}::aIr;€i,:f:1§~+i._'vh.Qs§3i1;a}. Thaugh the pI'OS€CuﬁGﬂ €:e2i1§e:.€fx *E"££7.21'«.3.g h{}Sii1€ witness 011 one parii{;u3.21r-- rte whether the patient was _ C-.{i:23ci<3;L1é" {:ii 1jn§3;1sCi~§iiS, hewever the Gther evi<:1:;éf1:*'g:._ 'bf ~t§;_;iS x§gi'_§.1':a:%:SS' iS _1"i31_f3X73."{1't for the purpoge 0f undezstandrttag \i=§;.«;*E1a"i:':._&XactEy...t1i€ ccsznplaint cf the patieni ir»1§a:$._ and _ %f§éa_tr':1ent was given in the hzﬁsﬁiaif ;'*::$5é§._c§:2;E, 'ra%;§<}srés Wauié ifiﬁiitaié thai he " 'vz;as V- _§9i0s;rg:£ta1ézed 'gr:--«"Se\;aksheEra Hegpitai between "§}3§X 1/2835 and Eater 031., aL1§ZOpS:';Z wag &@1"'1::__éi K€'§ﬁéf.fﬁ$®%?é& General. imspiiai, The: apirzian af ihs PWI2Q~Dr,i{Ana:1é .'-'§;2'§s';%§i#2§§$*8 that the §bEEma:*§;:::g Qparatienai waunés wﬁre Vfﬁéﬁné £21.": £315 éeaé %adf3,=-":

20 {i} P2u'21.medi2:1.;'1 sut:Lu'eci <3'p£3rz21£;i{}:'1 w<>z11'1d {raver riggkzti Side? e:1bdc>112en vertictai 18 an in 1€:',1.'1g§'.i"??' C:{}:'2_m:e2erc1 O'v'(-fi' the areal. in T..hE3 micidﬁe v;'<:su:1d I 1 X 9 {,TI1'1Ei~} bhzisﬁi in <:<>i{mr': .' dra'i11agc=* wm111d {3'J€fI' :f§1g_3§;i1_j€:m»ViE_ia<?::;: {Ems b 'V {iii} I)r21i:3.z1§§e. wound ow::17 _1efi;, H}:,fp_<> Ci 1 €:;3'}f:iriaIn I'€'gi(}'IE of E:1:1€ abdom en ; ~v.i3"'c51fn.

On im:erzr1a1 r3Xam::1:::f.iQ3_1, _"A4i-3?; 5"?» "and. 6"? 'fibs were: fmctured in tile n1id--;11;§{i1ia:9gr 'V7'1.i"s71_(:»:*.V«- Dactor {ﬁpiﬁéid that t;ht:=. deéii:%"1t;""v§1-:3 ':.j1:_1%: "1:.c} 4'S§i§3%,ii1e.1."§aia as 21 restak csf :°'::1pt.1.1.:'e: Q)?"-..§s:';é'zs;';[E 'i1i€.es1iIie._{*i'ue i.§:{'bium. injury {aver t_'t1s3 gabdoizaexa, .

_ SQ, '}'~""-.ﬂz.f{§r:":.V V§;I.'§.71§.5§'~v€;?'<$".§;~{§V€;?i"§{i?f;"f {E338 cam 'i};I'E{§E;?§7Séﬁ'.E3.§'}{§ V.-**.':*;{:':"; f§.jL'£'7:?3 :'€§:§'i.'-;='§T€;*.£:},f:§f;',€i Hm-'a--:;-;--«"ir:p21"i:'.'i<3ni: at 8eve1kss§1€i:ra }1{::sspii'.a1 'tV'§1_{%1iz:3%2.t;%§s, '€;i3f3;£-gaawge sf fluids from H3,-='p<> Chzmdriaé region agiggi z11Vs;«::'Li:i1€: a'z3<i<>m::%:L The §F8.{'.EE.1§:§ Q? :'i§::s:~; zmé §.:";}u:*}:' iii} i.§1e:3__}:e::12?:E§ i§iz€.€;'.§1'.i§1§", xzsmulci :%g:>eak. the {":E:?:E}.S€ {car Such '::?;.z_"'2_1§?;;"::a;;.?_g:=*: <3? 'é:h:'-3 fiuixi.

\\f\ E{{}2.m:év&:;; §.:'1jz.::*y €10 '%L'.E*:@ ss§_7:1a.ﬁ ._T:§:":i.s::s+s$;,§;'§'"::% :'1e::£; ';E1€i prE::3:}2§:r§,? {)f:1.'§,E:'=}§€;? :53" $26 eiszézysthi ;%éég3'§:'E<%a*::*:":§2: wags ﬁzz:-2 {T".2,iE,3E%:€? E63' §:Z%'"s,s: {.£e2:;.a:§E': {sf 'é.E'"::'~? {§&'.{':ii£'3,S§%§{§x '_§'%'::;é:"{:'§'"{_}:"s;% :::":.e:": E'":.;::.s_s '£0 f%%}{?€;'.'. 3,-%«'§"*:E:'§§, :3§<:::s;:'t§;E}; é:E.'_:€: z::§";§%':n{':§;"-_=. i:~%; ««a~v.§'§;_ R.) L14 subsi.21:1tiVe s«s€:1§e1';.«::e wzmlgi km: uradzar S€*.c:i',ir:m 826 af EPC.

23¢ Hazvizggg rezgarci 131:.) that {'.iI°€TLEI1'1Si.8..1'1.{iE§miii' _ t,}":<:3 i':':<:i{£c;%1'1i. in q_u<2:~;'{i<):'1 has; <)c_:m.:1f};f<:d ami' "e:ts:;--;)};2«::§21Eiy_E,£1§3 Ci£"{i'.1,i;}f1"£-8{'.aE1}"it;?:t'. t.1i'1d(;'.'1' wh.'icE3 "tfﬁ-s:: :;'1'(*i£."i.;;':23.S':":if€3£'~ Eé;:1':%a*:f§éa;.ir3f'i;;:iA iI]j'L1I'}-' and 141113': sL1bseqL£_é11.'§ t.o ~ me? §v.I"1AC;'5..£;§fiI1Hfj__..1 naﬁ uni.owarci ir1(:i<:1@1";.{: 366311155 :0 h.§-i:'§-"vZ:'i'h'E§pp{i'E'1€{§,j0€"[.'i¥t1'€I} the i'ami1.i€s»3, t.h:*:3 actual t ;i1'§.§et. "{}f':'»'il:11€V"8;CC:Li»Sf;f(i be"1ng PWW1. and his w'if<3~PW.2_e1n§d as' 1'\l?'-<::rg,'}§,'; emd 3 E-3€€':IE1S to be §1e1vi11g.g;§ ':'1{:¥_««s3(§..;vi€':;:1é;-§;i':_£§g;§1ii:i:":--«'vQxC:3;:s'E. izhe maint<-smzmcﬁ: §'if;iigat,i(§:1';' hvéﬁie c.*"a.1b.1't1'.(:suSEy...i:'i1posc3é1:.h6 5-zentmlce. Ali are <:'E{:as-§;€§iy in:31e¥j;~'.<:::E'e:§. {;> €--.:1§i'1';_ othezp €f"'\:'€§}f".E the appeiiam. / aa:<::;_$e.<§ ii-3: '.;3'éj??E*§=}3;i.€ii§ to Eh-% aéatztaéasaéai Shi'%'££II}i*3'§§§§§-'%.?{§&1 A a1'v£.d°*h:;:.§:3V.,t.he g§$f2:':3--<§"s<3:1 sf Ezisa; eizier bm1:'.1r:6:" amt} fai.'m::;° 'éi>f_5?"%.?i§' » "%7iE_é{: a;p'pe.E§a1":i' / 3.a:t<:::,:.$<3:i E\£'0sfE is; in <:L1ssi0dy* €:iE'J; ziatsz. By 552.2%}: the §;=s:::*i(}{§ ai' c1;2s<~;t.{;2:i§%~1:::<1:§s>§g(:t3.€ by iihasr 21§)p€%Ei.;211";':; w{}L:£c:i be ssaix jg"§3£~11€'S§. \\V""§"y\

22. E*£:~2vi:*:;§ :':1;.§z1§{i is ':.h<;é féfiéiii %:..'z::a*:; ':,E"::»:* é?£ppé;?§i§.é§1E1ii f ;'«j:'§€'?{fi"§,éi4:--{";?--€.§ F'~5<::,§ géizgi zwé: ea-*':':*::": §'12:s2.='e 23:': i2'1€:,é:>:':':;i:7;::1 'sat: a%2ms:;e _;;;:*i§%%:{}%;,:§; §§'Eh'§E..'i§'}? 3:7; »;'§a::':::;%.;r:$z;é{?; ;fi§§T:i%.>2:::'2::%g§<:m:{£g2s_ a.a:'E'2§:%:': Em zirrived at: i;h:'-.* h<,>u;ss3 of PW, 1% we ears: (}'f1,.he {'}_'f}i§"1i{}};"1 E':I%1.a,'i.

{ha-: ;:2€ri0s:1 sf {?L,;$£.<)dy z11::'<;*:2T1d}: L1:'1<1<31_"gg{3.1'1e by 11i:1:V.vy-fsmicl best jusgt, zmﬁ pmguer sez1§:<»:t:<*:<-3% £10 136: in1§3<3_ss§i%{i'--«'f':)tf ":-:,:?:."«A 0i"f<-aracﬁr p13.:'1ishabi<:é L1}'1€.1('3I'" Sa%;:i,i.{>1'1m326 of:Ei3'(3\,:}.S'C:».Vfar ihe 0't:hé3r 0f£'e:1€%es am cm1<:e:":'1eci:-, t1%:1'€%?p€::"iTa;3;:i-Sf"9é%:{i£.£::;"ie::V<:A ixxlposed .13 already S€i'{'\»--'€C1 E}§.:ﬁi;e ac':'c:u5s:;><;1. A 23' A,<:<:e;3rciingiy mi: Ixffakc: 1:119 . ft}! }<>wi1:1g :A "1'E1.c.-ai.;§";}§:é:i1..is"a§1més:ed-.."i:i." ;f;~211*'t'.. 'Ike judgmzsxli; 0f Ci()1'l'v'iCJ{l£(}1"I._x2i3T1d' :{§1T3d€f'£T:{Di Sscs:-taigeriatiz passer} ag;_{21i'ns!;, £11163 g1ppeﬁ'a:1i.4 »~' a5c':{::t;.g§é.3€1 "N_{§;* 1 "far iihﬁif 0ffc:~11»::€. punishabiez u,1':§it*;1° :S&:~::%;,i<m 391% S 'EFLC is: Ezezimbjy 36%. 8.S§{i€:', The 'V ' of <:<.i»'f<:'s.i;::.%4§vcm ;'-.mci e::»1"{i£::':° of sseimémée in msgaéici. i>fi"€;§3:§é3éVS~V :{:_"si':;%.§1isE1gib§e m'1de1' Se:a:1".%<)§1$ 32512' 5943 50f:3»~E3 EPC i8 _g:§.§'§'¥§i%f:1}i:==:c§» T115 21g3;3<:1E2::.'1?: ~ a<:::u3€::i 1'\7<';.i foumzi g:.:§§':ij; GE' the {}ff€f'£"}{Ttf;E p::a'r':i5::;habEe: u:'1<§<:a1* Se:?E':.§i<:=n £328 EPC' :'§;}§}€*':Ez-:.:1%: W Ac2{?:.1$s:<i ?'€z,:+,i 235-; 3E'.€tfE'"ii',€:3§jE{3€§{i §.<} "'§§1'"§§§Z"§!i';i{}E'7éI"iT§.{?f'i'"§'tL. §'3:';:* €;'E'2<;? p:%ri.{>{i :2?:§2*&-.%z?:{i}«" :e;<;%:'v::*:{?'; 33}? E133": i%;.3Z§I ::i:§;§,€: 5/3..:'1{"§ $22') §:::;~:z3; E"§z'::3 <2? ? §.{'L{}{}{}§-- zszmi if} <§€:'§°2?m';s;. E:::?; §§2::},* in.) 'J:

film E1) 1m<.ie1'g,>;<i: t°i;_;;<?:§ous i:1'1pris;<):':1mr11i fax" 3 :"n01'1i,hs fer the €3ffer:c&<:% pL.m_is'}'1abI<:: Lmcler Se:r:ii(m. 532% of 5:;:::p21.r.z11:.e :2;e;"1t.e:':£:<:r. is w222r1*221I1t'eci f<>:f {)'{.§".1€iI" €,)ffE?_§;§;_i'€.\';','fE/'.'T§v.V_'M _iE3 21€TiCE1&':§€d. has; a1E_:"eadj_J ;_:>aid <31' (.§<_-%;):j_>;5itec1 {3:"'1";a'--:»3},xi ;ffi::},)é.:saii;_:s§ 111$ fiz'.1e::: an1<3i.1nt:, he s;~s1'1a-1H, be relésgasjmci ..fi)ri'}'}ui:'ii'§":' 'iff§1c":"*:;Ve; gm': 1"ec;}..:i;"ec1 in a11y €)'E.h€E' {:::.s§_é*;._ JV"%fk%JK%hMJ£ """ §§§§§ 'J

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court