Karnataka High Court
The State By Psi Chikkodi vs Maruthi Ramu Kambara on 20 July, 2009
Bench: Manjula Chellur, B.V.Nagarathna
gmga .%{.!%}é§Ez%._.§;;%, " igtgaggg L "'=?@£.."%;;'::7j'§Eii§'E§€5E"'E4§;%;§; ¥;{éi"};-.'§;ELA§£L?§é, §\%:.;32'§%§.§.§%_-):§:')%Z;%_ §.g;:a:::§ %{:z'f§i§%¥;§§.='%,?*;Z'%.g %%mg: 2% mxaga J Jam; §E§,fi:§»=i§j$,%.
$§°§§Er";'%?P*E'~: §;§§%,»€'§}" §ig%§§§;%.Eg%5, ?:iZ';;rE.§: EQ §'E§§?;iS§ *?§-£3 §§§E%E"*§LE isms' §§S§Eé§; % 3% ;i_§;.r'% 'F' Eu 952:3: S§<§§E%i'E'E%%E<:;§, ma; }§E§AK§§.§§§, as s§+i»z;:'w:~s?,%m, wgs SE?.§,;?v§AR*;,§'§"§-.{§ §<A§~«1§;a§2{%§,'«%« a ;%GE§: 32 *:.%%Q3, ' am: H.G§..,z%Mfi.f€E. 'wi@@;;:<,AkL £52/Q: 23E:iA%<a;¥;,2a§ '"§"Q: amwgz, EEESE": §E.LC'£A{,§?E$.2*§& . §*;§;*$m%z=~s§§a:@~s'§'g gig? $R§%.$;@<:;gA;;~§ E f %%%ké3:J.%3«§g2 @';a%%%9:sr§rz mg SEE."v'§G§'€§V$'§'§-;2*é§_'?3;:%'fS.:?§§fi§§_S'§R§',}%'%;'%3VQCA'T§:S} '}§5§r4%.E§SA""a;'f§:'%%.;?;;;:;.§._.£S. '§EE;;%"i';:"i'1:=V~V«'E:£",/S¢3*',7S {:3 A§\E.§ 53; §.R§?.%f; ;»=3>€ &?¥%:%§;f'k$§>,§'%$m%: ?:i~§'g S'}1%'§'$ ?ma=";§~m ?i~§;%;§' §f'*s1§§$ §~%§5'€';?i%.i§:':{f?;§i}§*T€ MA? 3%; mmggg m $.?l%§;%'€§" La};ax;;s:' Kt: Jsmgg me awmz mmgs? mg "V'~'.V&,§J:§%§§fiAEN? kk1@?;::;2%ga: ?:%$SE§ 33% ?§~§:«:
£§{§*.:§.§.E~'E.,;§3é§'§§";§:"'-fixfifi wigs', s§«:z;<::«:@§: 2% as ;*€:::?§5.$ A{:{§§§":"§"?:"i'€{§ 'E'E.~i'§ s?*<gg%::>€3%s:;%:;::%:«s§*$;iag:§:;3&1: ii 123 4 §*<>§ mega:
éZi§§'§§'.E§'%§{?_§{é":S %:',;:x§;§%.§L§;s§%.;a;3%;s.$ L353 32%, 32s:; 5%, Ejééi? 3&3 Q? 39$:
___a?m&f:;€:.i p;,"zé*:;v....§3A§s:E<e§ up €C§;"i.€&§"'3"'&§ wiiéz ?'%»§z'»~E 'm%:§ J%?::%E;a§, €:£§Eae%.§:'é{; ms mgég mas: .?%€fiR?&L?§_u% s1§--;£m;é2 028-} '°E'§~§E §'QLE;fi"&§I?%§€§:
§SEGfi§§?
Eéearé adagamai $ :mi%%"§3;;'b§;;¢§¢gea:m:« arzaé {E3 E§arz:%& €aunse:§4_.'§;:z t-fie1-;*és;p:;:v§€§$%;I:"€~ac:c:,:gag?'
2. §'§._?fg §§é'V:a__".:.?a:=. '§§;j2r:_;.e: ?'§;§';;:9%:}2:gE2 Ehe fiV§§§fl£€ 3:5:
3;"'8€Q1'"C§__3{i'3;§'x§§'§S 1jE.§_§gfi':$fi?FEE?"-§i§';i€ Cfiiifi baiaws '_§"E':& sage is? '$329 f§:::5f5a_§e?{:?,;%1*:§.§3V:*:._.§:"3 brééf E'2e§b%*e €353 ':2'*'éa§ {;b'a,:fi :ara;$«--.._§;E"":a: :::::ak'_2;§~;iC38,_'§§§§ aammeé pergfizzs 3% 9""?
5 ?'?§'%E3_:;s5g%é:":V"£:§4;:="~.%;§:3:2& between {he iwa Eazzds 323% 3%:
Eééfe V§§.§}:€,'§ _z§::é::*::eZ ihey Said ism have a$s3;;:Ei§& $1?» 2. Ea '?f"%2v'~3 :§%§:j"§': axe azzzé aiming aazgségzg g'3"*:§§§%:,:s injuries €51; f,§?"z;e %::"§5 km '8 '§ gjiz E3.
:'s$§"i;$§i:f:g _§%?§,CA-E éxa 332$ ?i:E.®,-2 is Wag isfifiw mam» fig' ;@:a;~: and m%g3%%;
Ea fiiéfl f;:s3i*$$@Q?;;'5:.%@3:, ?%'».E, ii; .Es'? ';3iJ"~g3 ¥a«::§;~3_€:aT.§:':a_d--:é_';:§L2::'§:%i§ an 3;::cm,:::/72%; Q? awauéi ?}'33;€%& a2":'%:§':£:*:': hf; E $3 5%. §?'i%'~«~<% afzé ?§§§~$ 33% gézzgzfgénfz aéfiifigsgeg zfiflza }2a'%;& ':L2.:*:<:&e'% §":'::;s-.§:":':§Ee. ; 3%, fE"":§w 5';f§V5e %§:~iE3§:='='{§ ._§2"'£--i"a.§»;.3?z:s:§g& %a$&4<:§ an 'aim e:s1E.:§$::.é:;$;_éiéifizsi-;":;g._a.»«:z§%sf;;=;$S:3g...a;é2d as':§':@§' maieziaé 9:": T§'$E3fiE'-Z§» _§32?:-'§{3£¥$'{§»"f*;::€;"§.._"E23_§§;3_$%;:_?:§ {E13 aaaugeaé §8§".:<::{3:i:g 5:: $336: Zfiagig-.::?3a€ &;§E§'€:5é':':3-"»LV.€:"g;7:.z:"e§ p$:*smz3 are ."§"€§a'§i€§ éaizagréimg is §}§i"§."'i, ihg ;':f:"a%sacu*{§@:": av:,:g__%% =i£i{:<.E*:g:;"z:¥e axamémgci £.:z{§&§:::@:%:£§&:':§ :%?%$::%&s:s@§ sag the é'é'f§2§§.{#:.?ES€ §§E€§§€é%§jfiS éfzsaé iirzgre :%:e:'''@; @3323? pmaazzg *"-3&6. :.r5:'%.3a§§a'§3Ea 23:1; 531% sgmt fif iiiisééeizi. {:41/i» ' ' f:7f;;¢:4_a$a§§.:§¥es:'§V V "
we 3, '§'%2s3 .E@£:z°§":@é Cm.;:.:'3.$aE {fir '€{:§"":&%"-.2-_4i&;~¢.-:f§:;;§:*'3a:;?g;«":..%':a ~-- ac:::a2$@{§ %:'a:3g?":_i ta mm :.f'§'§i$iEZ:;"'?_ 3,35% :9 §a:7:3i.::§ as i"}':8 p§:z;&z°$V.Q%'"'-%:%3$ §€';7:€':z:.I': ;%{p§é5§L{;affé'%. 53:23': zizziief $$€'?i§QE'}. 3?8 $3.5." ' §. ,.5;CCQ2'"d§51'?;g_jE§. ihé§:§333*:f:e€i"--.{3é:gr3aeE fa? Qhfi .:'a3panfi82:i$" '_3«€'§f€:l:"¥28::E§§€T1: _€%"£'iE%fi €§.§é§:.:g}z {he firgt fléppaiiaifiv §::Q'::-'§..¥;?.'f§V is 'f%m§§§§i*:$'a:%____vz%?£V%f§: ihfi ;;%mfiJe::§ $2? faw a§§:*é%t:§a?,;%a%:1;'%;::°§'7..é%:'§fi€§i;'ée:?r_,' éihe seifieé Ea:-if £3 £7? %::>2?[a :*&3;safia.bf§€; :*%m/$3 affi' .§§:*:2ss§%:s§a §m:::;:": ?ZE"'§§ safizfi 3%: Q"? _ faczgg {Eta {féuré _____ _§?i:E'm:,:§:§ aaaegé 332%: i€"'$fi,S§;?'§a%E& siiééi-:éVEV2d::é~;§§zt2"«.:§%:%2_ie'_:§2 is %§2";af%fi:°a§ m 33% aaszzgefi, "§'§§v?:»%:3§a3:"eg' §?§;s~2.5:;::@§'3:.;%3g§$.§ :33 is asfifimrz 332% jfidgmafii Tm? a::§?;z%:é;3§,» 2%? '"_?§2& §<3:?..::i ééfzsi E>'=¥G'£};.§§ arisg far am" K " --. «{s:§::;§§&$:*§;.%£a:: £3:
<23: ¥i.:E:':& E&g}§;""§5:s§n&3 and {':}f:€S?Z. Vi.Eé3.;':j 'f;:%:ej»;
-E3£':;:gp2?f:':aEw g?:2§';e':§§a:f:%:
w...n Mums' .;9¥¥'»2 $§:+:§:::§ M Eigzia :*@§3§:'e& fig at :2": egg fIf§§_..'§E.€.7.§':'.".§._§' ".%4;'2f':'§'f*;.;;¢;:': e%;&:a'° €:_§%;;§ju Eiéie Q3: §:,%:$§§* Eazizzzé '?'§2é,;a: agiaggé*-f{.%:<é.:":;.é,2:e:%34:'%;3E 2"
éeizazeaazg 'she *:v;s: Eafizés, figj'é:%'28.$.?"§3};3§_:§%"»::f=.'%;E§::é:::; aazzzmaéi 3335 i5 _%2§fi:.;& @':E282" asczzsgad Ea E2333 5;;§a%;.?"'vA.fE'§'"_2;&:/2 g"§E««r3éf§E":é:¥:f7 aa':$':1$eé 1 S§3,:""i&zf§ a%32:$§z:g; ?'%§:§».~_§':" a;,g'._za=*z,§;z§, .4 i§'i?::»"§% ggeézéii $5 iégiaef Ezaiffi a;$.s;.":s;:_§§f£:#é{'§ §'.§~§?§5_"i'}f":¥E}'§;h§E9'5»§;?' 1-*a?%iE': iéza e:;~E:,:z'"= £3 $$.:§€% :53 mt _ .
922$? @315 * : £i:j;.:'§ iaaéz E2973 axe E?;§"Z§ assa;§§§%:&§_ 5§:?:5:_éE':§f:a?_;*'<::§f: €:§*:'e:»-é}:§a:§. ;%'§i ?;E';:3f{ paémi :3? '§::'::r;e_, ;5?%%*'?.'E fa §§'E"§€E"'%f'%.é'}€§ %2>r:§j_.; ziéé; 229%": Eésfizerz {£2 %§<a@:';"::, '.§5€':.é~¢?f*i:§%=;%f§* £3 saifi 'Sig §?;aa'2;'@ asgauiiesé '?§2&}z' §:,z:"%:§r2e:' aam:;.§;£% nfié §:§ia?8 £5 i_?:&:}; z3a:&3"€ :3 §§°a%:e;_3"é=-*§:?;£3.j }'Z-'fig;-* Eésifi a $3' '"E&§". 3:; ¥;:§":s3§:" Eizgag" §mm&&§aé&.§}4; aézegg afi: 2a2'&2:§'" is §;_%é% §§'§&afE%%?§'§§§.& gaiéae cafiéa aaé §'e{:a§"&a£ 332%:
-1 E22: ma £33333» $25 552% aam ggiaérz fig}:
gagé ..v§3§§%'~2 2 ' é;:é,j::§. §Q:"éz :,:g§;%;i L' 5Xa:"2%:?§':a:i.§22 fizszzgh fieféziaa Etrissfi '°-.:"}A:<: z*ec$2'§.§ fiie €§E'§é&§'}€@, 'éhai aify"':Z%1§-"é;*3:.;:*:.§;;§é{:§ ::a€:f:&V' ézagafiéw? 'bay: fififi S3;.E§;'§@q?i,.§§f1'35:';i'»§§;§_é$%§§é"E- ;c7.§3:'§%§é;é::€"~%f§ég<2.: sfiif: fifiafi éfififiiififié 'sags %;3i;;é';t;e; :n§%"éa3.§§5r._a7_ai:&---.V.§i§?:§:* 0?}; 332% Wan? 333$ Z5:,%:"&:2;gjht {3%§":'&:9VL_:z:3.r:§V{:;:,2;@§. ""§'§*3'5& d&'2f@E3.€.£ furiha? sagggesiaé :9 §?.:%?w3 izfimi tr: 313:: aa;-a¢g:.'£:~:>§3: s:-:ijf;::::>%%: A.§i'§'1§:"T§,=w$}g3;é§3Z'§;g "Sim aacugeé gp8§'S3§f}$ :5ap§;.;é'mé;,5E*',a§2":g'-f.'g:?§*i§;:'::%; :.%,-j:?%}: sfizeagazgs. Cake? 323:2 f:f%:es:;%;~7;:§ $:;sg:v;"}*:§§£L{:aa;:§?_a32.§2éx*a:"3 afiféaiémgf §:§"f;$ saga sf iiim "=%r::e»§a{;'a;.i§:Ai:::':i- "§§ 2'm3; E2? an §*e$5§'& §E"::'m,2. E': g«_ _ % . ,1 g $§'i€Ssf."::~ §af§€::a.+-3A$?a¥§, ' '7§"'.§2:'$ avéziézzca af §"é£~«'§ £3 we "2-**:&§.;ié:._:i. ';i§.,%"'~vv._5g:£:_§::é$.§g§ miszgyzéargiaségfiisag £2? EE 2552?} _ 1§}$?:%3;"'£*:€E"§, "é".§3é éaars *m:.,;, '5, iémg, :2&r€::;§ 33% 2:23:52'? iém §':a§::sp@§"2.e&§ £3 fig? £3': &3{$§:_;:%a§ aézfiasrfiiéiég 31$ '~ 'i:§':;;::§e Qiffifi E«%?§$E_"1&$S€$. fiagre 337% gm £:@:r:§:.?a£§$?';§@;":3, V.§"~5;23 far as; fags? asicused; pia%<.€r3g ap qazarraéy fizere is ::;$r:*$¥b$z*:%:§Q:3, $§:f::§Ea:"Eg £2323" aamagfié gczégtzgi 323$ W .,-,. ' am .. <. .31 .. ., 5.
fizz; ea-srm aéégar 3% m§;_ 2":-,¢e€ §3&:'g;,a;°::.m; 8?
.53?
.. M £7';
fiaé reéaéésséigéééégz 333% a:"§:_:":$.§..§:3:';:a§ ?:::?§' éisizizmggaa, €§'i%§'8 fig §€§<&§}r' §§é;*-;as{%__?;§.§ a}:aLgg&rat§ fiéiéffififfiéjvg flag CC3?;§E"'? iii" "i::"é;t?%':/ a:%:3;_gg@2"&z%é€3?2s; afyaifi $121? 2% "§3"22é' féiaéa {mm égézeir ékfééiffiffififi. 'E_"'E:e C;:+:::ri'v'2'§éa:;%~:sivV'E::.1g~.;%;i1i§§% is remmfa {he ééégééijg a;:2:§«1..%;:}*§a és:x§;gs§e§';5:§:£é;:%§3.._§§:& Sémuéai E3?' in §fi%§::'°£:§}_; iifzs .:j{.:':§i%';" é::'7;"*f%,§~":§" 225%/:&§":_ E323"? are examééfmzai'E'::$:§:;}:4é-»_fiQ%'2£ '£i_é':2:"*€i "E'.2*§& _§:*&:~§€:"::;t:é3 Q? ?:i}"s£~::§& iézzaa réégtiazzé ;:m";:Cw'; :25 '5£§E'E'3;€;, Iiiéfif i_Z*":5::é'a z33§?&a:f§:¢:§.,E§fg £33": éha 336% @§ ':§*:;e323"* E31353 _§%?'::;"%2<:.§.ti§,"§:éEa§:%."§ fig ma': iinzzaiéziai :31?' %:m::*eaE%$"i2{£$ §%':%;§ fiz::m:%f;i:5s€: fag" '%§£G'%."§E&?:?; $3 ii?-"&E"§{ €32; *E:E§":& éiaégig 'A "*:ia;$§§{:§a:=s;E§j.;" 'Ea: aargai $3.25: $23 afigfaiaég azfzé '-¢;'asii':@ {Egg _ §g§::.~§;.; Tfiitaa {§fi£'é.§§"§{'&.'EE«i":fi G'? ésacégéazya '-£3 3}: 33$ $372, ' " -*5:-§'e:":$&} 231$ £§§;§§§::s..§%:§;* 'ix; .§::,%e2'f:€.£:%*:; iége &:":;$"a§$&fi §&§"*§m2$. :5'%:::c::$a:E egg fag? girafiggays $3 iéw i:":;§:.:§"e:% <;%;§%;§";e3a@$( Wu»;
kg':
'?§':e:"e%§%:>re3 §§8?§%§§};" £3 ififii éfgaaakstfzxé i*:§1E?a§§'f"--«€::'*Ea';£ is émyiéaaie §§'i§'§S€8E'E§L gergazgafi ?;§:.e:*e §"£3;$:i§%"§ fa? s'a,€$$:?£:§::":$e £2?
égégzsregé Fgféfl in i§'E%S8 §3$S3§§3§& "§"§S":="°%f fig flag? "7{.§"a&'"é::.j;:{:.'ie';.,2'$a £§V"iézasé €:.':f;:*a$ %:2jé,3:"&§ "via %:§%:&2%;":;
iz2§@§__::e:'2:§e.zzE :":v-1:2';-:°?§& £za,:V::2':§I:z=:»é aazzféfig Ea a§:.,§_g §'::,=2a§:§e:*;:~sh ""E%§&;%gf§':%2<;rézf;gj Ram?- s*;aX;§:f:$::*$ 33 "".:*,':':=;a:s§£§~",§ :"E§:T§'§.T 33$ %:::at&:*a$%:ad %i::::2 agvéiagjggfiigs Cf:§;.%£"':.%§'ifA§'.4€;;?'£ffj'=.E"E$ ésézgég ?:2"sa§:"- :":&2g'E":§:';:::3:.;r>ssx £2: {g"a3i.:§:VV"'§:2§%*;;3éE":%§& '§:::" $3233: §§'EE}? s'%:{:::':z§{.€ :":az%@:* £2/*:§g*»:3-?'i:§$_€::vp@§§}§E:-aa.aae-3* '§'?:§:§ afizémcéa <3? ':E:::;= smaéaijég "::3%;é:;%r€§s é:'§?f:5'z:§ ::r:*?:?3§°:§j iféfza paéézze, €333}? Eéagiiaia ifi QQEEES §§:;::a%:=:§&_ ;:21;*:a;?:;_;3§*"gj:a?v'§ aégéfierma %@:?=$r& "5é:E*;& $G3.,E;E"'%:x ""§'%e},;' W.:%:Gé.,:,§§ mafia? éfig irfzgresgiazz éhaf GE'E2;':9E ":f%*:%}?_ .--':::<':s2"3€ 32:53 gssfiga 3; 3€a%$::":e';::'s Eafare ihg gméézm, V. ééaw Eta s§$:"2:§ Em af igkgze in @Q§:a°':_éz:g ii': C9222": azaaé gméige ::'«:.€a%.:Z§:': E§"z$:*a§a:'§, 'zéwjs Ezfiséézaéa $5; 1'?
35% aiszizza €¥.;»m.?a§:§ 5:5,: gigpparé 'fie *;"';€.~'iS;fi._ »€f2§- j§:.;1S p:*§$a¢:;§€§.az/2, 'E'f§2& avfiéezéama {sf ?E%5E $_§'1f§ E9??? zéérfié, ' indécata a.:=::<; :§.r§.§§%:*a2;2z:e £3": €.'{2£";i§" 'agae:*$.ié?2;2 33"-%e§2%:*;*:_§%.:,%,i§ afiifiaéaii Téafiér &ariéa:::c§,*;%s_ 692:2:-.£_§%a3::': :3';:':';§v§:*a{E%?;:E§e:::;._* Ever: if iizare aw é%§sa§*e§_'§a:*:é'_:?§§a;éa%ii *:%zé:«--:"j$E&"é;;¥;§":§: p<:*;27:r2:?: . 5 5:1? éima %'L:"§. §:Eri;a £;«:»:*2="'*--::?é'a=$;'::~%:>%sia%z*z:f:%?*=ai}:°2:'2 CG?if§?§E1fi firzfi
2.
sage $5 %;:E"':e ;3§f:::s::§ec:2%:§béE"
E;-55:. 1' _'°.?§-f{_;a3%7;Qr"{§};' g§§'@:';é%;fi%E':78;é fiaggfbia is §§}§§§E""§€S 53? ?'%}.>f'~E 3:5?';?3%7;;*§.§%2":%::*é5:.V__fiim Ea assazzéé $2 éhgm gcmzgafii C'; ' '$223 53;-
'E2,§C§%, '~ Ea»%:': §:?é:x;5 *g:;9ma:*;I%: w§.<::m3:sa3 V 5% 332$ i:.é2f'i§§~é ?2a;§*:§§& ii aafmzéri 2:3? figffifii 'Sag sgffifié :12? *§';.,__f:& vf§Z§E":".?;*'€:5E£'§;§§3;é3;??: 23; €:2";e §:*as3&::'a2€;§2:s:"2 3.5;: méggézfagi 5:3":
""«. 'é.i.1§zj;&':%". *&€s"*;£5:'ma 95 &f;& é:~:;é€::.§s$&3' §'.%'-'$83: if ézhgs _' iifiaieiééai afiggzség ?§£E',i3*§; is .?*+é3,G.r§- 2-'i7§.'§"$; rag: _:"@&@¥$:"&:f'§3, 2 éamg 22$? affaezzé 33% saga Q5 fiéfi ;m"*:}§@§::.;z_?.§r:;s?:= '"§'.§£~=; €..§"%.,'ééS€§§§'§ '2«§'$ii§€§ 5% 3226?; £3/23:22'-:?&3 §"e§$:'§*&;:§ '£56 .E§X?.?3 Ea M ; >ww-i M is " 2:'=g"e- §'!,.2 , J ..' <§«~:;u__:;:e~;; JLEQ E.%:.:3§K=>» mzgggg z:2§:::"2= :z_:"s.::%;z" 2:§*:m~ {f&§"&g§£%§":::' g:'*§§i;:3:;$ _ i {:{'s§:':§&f§":":%§5éa?:@£§ :2:z::;'fa:r S&$'§§m'; §%,2*i:% %;%;{mE{f:§. Ea tha %2m:*:_".§3 sf £sE!3:{§§C£§: "=:iff§§V:§$f r:3;fm.:'"& {if Séza .::<";_;':::j=;, it 'E3?-"s_' ??}E Cfiééififiéfl Q? .¥;,;':é:,, 3 8,%;f1'iZ§'-.E§"«§_§é:'.?f'§;",£"~é»"?:.§":§:3;§g' ésifé 33 "§.%3§ %:§t;:°a& %__:2§3:;a'€<§ 22»;:?_f;z:&s$€3§' 2.%>f7é:*z*3:§%';"'-%§. §=§"§_::§§§@ éz2j':::°§§s; g'2_:g'§$;_£.§2&:,%_ %;.:= "=%«§i':4e<:':§, E,'?§::.e.éré§:2%;i3;--i_"&::;;:§g<~3<3; arm ggazfiégr 2:31? W} i::r§a:r':€@3 gézzzg-§S§%fé'§a%::--§& E;§'§:;%;--::;?£é:%..V'Sé::€":>m': 325% E?{:f. 3% J &$~ =32_§53:~{§}T .5? E»-§"$i{:§»."*3 :§3s:;§§.:,;af;3§":g 35.32;; ${'§§f:'f§§"'§€§.E"§x§.'=.§fi£;€.$ §»f;§§g3;{a:%...-7:%..*Et:§.E& géégézzg a2;%s:§§':§::%a §::e§:m:~: %,':3.:r_§"'%;'3£;:;:'i.,%_::aea $":;:'ai:§¢:"$*:§,%a;*':':$.z':€: game is be :";::a"rv:§€ E35? *.{l":a;=~: ' 5"?}':&§*$§*ar:*§§ 9.Cs".:::$@€§ am g":,::7§%}; af figaéiéfifi§T}"i;§n§§;§?}1'»§'E8.§§§ ::z:i§a:* %§:::'£§§:§2. 32% z'*&3;::*E %.%:§%f.E"f: 3%» K "-53:" §'§$.,-._;%$£ta:':§§:'ag.§;§3 we a§.Z:3'2a? %;.?":e a§:2p@'*Eo éafigmfizéé _ §3§"az<;:::§'§,:§?z:€'.;§E 21% SEE". wsiégs, :'%$c:::aa& E ';a 3% ara frigid " ~g;'2_:%§§;i};' fir? as§2%::.c§ §3;:§z_§:<:i:aE§§& uziégr 3§§€'{§{3EE 3257?? 0? WC ;":a=::-aazfi *:2;*;§_§': 35: EPQ 3?. §?:?@a:*é §'€g8;?'§1:E"£§;:S€%'§%?.T:'§§E{:«&. §~§3;E:'§f':g ta 3:339 faai, §§T§C§§%§'E'{ accuweé aémést f:a:f;;'j;i*'5e:a$.3=?:§,_: _ s':.2'asezr;:g@2}€; is the ézscifiazxt :15: ';?."&§}{:%§::':"a:~ '*°«;:'!~$§ 1,s:":%.m%;a§*é inaifiafié ?§%'%;2§;ae3": iz.%".,:& ;j§'i;a:?:§§$_ régarfi fig 'E5129 faité Eéfzai .i;E*:& A:§fi'§"'?;.Ef§_-55?': $333"
Eaaéng G"<fi£"§"§é§"$ 3%" ::&§,giE2§3m;:.$§€éég:--_}':=g;§§, é$e.f:...§:45e 3? §",§'Efi {'Z駧:i'§'§£%§';i "éffiaé Smsiszgéé ;:'::*§ v;{;':,:§{E mag? aaséz :35 '§iE'ée,I'=;§§.é;f:z.:2:,e4:§fl'j'.--éé'-.é:}i;z;§>:;;ga&« in £E&§a%_:§% Ea ;§_@§z;::a§%_:: ':1':-'rm $%§%;.é*:§%e*:%é;'§:€:§?*:i.z;"é""z¥;§:3a's*is& 0? aégéizi zargaéis éézajg $§:'°E;'§ ;::":Z:*§La:»';:§* gggjgiigfiia.7':;:i::p2"§sc:§'3:me§:*; :21? 332% €E;$@:==:, '_ i3:;v_i'~§1:}€ :_E'é§_:;;:3§'€'A 3. sum af ?j3.3_,C%f:%€?,/3 SE13}? Esa '§:.a%{'<§v:§.gé:;:i;¥j§*:_é_f'? ééfié igéjaimé §~'*'§f-E. $9 ?¥§«§, Sd/-~ IUDGE Sd/* JUDGE