State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission
Mahavir Angadia vs Silk Musiaum on 21 August, 2021
1 S[; NFB, YIF TFP&q&qZ_!# S[; O[\;, YIF TFP Z!q(qZ_Z! lGSF,GF lNJ;Mo JQF"v(4 DF;v_Z4lNJ;v!5 U|FCS TSZFZ lGJFZ6 SlDXG4 U]HZFT ZFHI4 VDNFJFNP sSM8" G\P#f V5L, G\P Z_!#q!#)$P V[5[,[g8;o s!f DCFJLZ VF\U0LIF4 $q&q#!_4;]ZH DC,4 VW]ZLIF R[dAZGL ;FD[4 hJ[ZL ;0S4 GJ;FZLP sZf ZD[XEF. AMCZL,F, XDF"4 U|Fpg0 O,MZ4 jIFZF E]JG4 5*4 NFNLX[9 VlUIFZL ,[G4 SF,JF N[JL4 D\]A.v$__ __ZP s#f EJFGLX\SZ AMCZL,F, XDF"4 HLv!#4 :JFDLGFZFI6 SMd%,[1F4DFWJAFU ;FD[4 5F\RS]JF4 VDNFJFNP s$f HUN[J S%TFG;L\U4 HLv(4 VU|[;[G V[5F8"D[g84VFN"X DFS["8GL 5FK/4 ZL\U ZM04 ;}ZTP lJZ]wW ZL:5Mg0g8 o s!f l;,S dI]lhID4 V[ GFDGL EFULNFZL 5[-L4 sZf zL AFA]EF. V,LDC\DN SF50LIFP s#f CGLO V,LDC\DN SF50LIF4 ;J["G\] 9[SF6\]ov **!4 DM8F AHFZ G J ;F ZLP N.R.K. Appeal NO- 2013/1394 Page 1 of 6 2 V[5[,[g8 TZO[ o lJwJFG JSL,zL VFG\N 5ZLBP ZL:5Mg0g8 TZO[ o lJwJFG JSL,zL JLPV[DP5\RM,LP SMZD o zL V[;PV[GPJSL,4 gIFlIS D[dAZP zLDlT H[PJFIPX]S,4 D[dAZP lJJFN o U|FCS ;]Z1FF WFZFGL S,Dv!5 C[9/ 9ZFJ ov zLDlT H[PJFIPX]S,4 D[dAZ DFZOT[4 TFPZ!q(qZ_Z! . CLIZL\U s!f CF,GF V[5[,g8[ GJ;FZL lH<,F U|FCS TSZFZ lGJFZ6 OMZD;D1FGL OlZIFN G\AZo !##qZ_!_ DF\ TFP#_q$qZ_!# GF ZMH YI[,C]SDYL GFZFH Y. V+[ V5L, NFB, SZ[, K[P sZf CJ[ 5KL ;Z/TF BFTZ 51FSFZMG[ T[DGL OlZIFN VZHLDF\GF D}/ :YFG
5|DF6[ ;\AMWG SZJFDF\ VFJX[ V[8,[ S[ OlZIFNL VG[ ;FDFJF/F TZLS[ ;\AMWJFDF\ VFJX[P s#f OlZIFNGL 8}\SDF\ ClSST V[JL K[ S[4 OlZIFNL ;F0L J[RF6 SZJFGM W\WM SZ[ K[P ;NZ ;F0LGM W\WM 5MTFGF S]8\]AGF HLJG lGJF"C DF8[ SZ[ K[P OZLIFNL ;FDFJF/F DCFJLZ VF\U0LIF sEFULNFZL 5[-Lf GL VMlO;[ VJFZGJFZ DF, DMS,TF CTFP 0L;[dAZvZ__) YL H]GvZ_!_ ;]WLDF\ OlZIFNLV[ ;FDFJF/F G\P! DFZOT[ V,U V,U J[5FZLVMG[ DF, DMS,FJ[,P VG\]PG\P TFZLB 5F8L"G\] GFD DCFJLZ ZSDP VF\U0LIF Z;LNP ! !q!qZ_!_ R]GZL S,[SXG4 S,STF )!& !&45__ Z *q!qZ_!_ R]GZL S,[SXG4 S,STFP !_5( ZZ4___ # !#qZqZ_!_ lJG; l5|g8 5|FPl,P #*_* ZZ4___ $ 5qZqZ_!_ VlEQF[S lS|V[XG SM,STF !&Z_ !&4*)_ 5 !*q5qZ_!_ lSXGUL ;FZL4 SM,STF Z!Z& Z$4)_5 & !#qZqZ_!_ VF.SMG O[XG SM,STF #*__ ##4Z__ * !$q$qZ_!_ V[,P5LP;FZL45|FPl,PSM,STF #*$$ $*4!#( ( !_q$qZ_!_ 5,S O[XG4 SM,STF !))# Z)45Z_ ) $q!qZ_!_ lJXF, lS|V[XG4 SM,STF )5_ ($4)5_ !_ !$q$qZ_!_ lJXF, lS|V[XG4 SM,STF #*$& !4#*4$(5 !! Z#q$qZ_!_ lJXF, lS|V[XG4 SM,STF Z_!& #4))5 N.R.K. Appeal NO- 2013/1394 Page 2 of 6 3 !Z 5q&qZ_!_ lJXF, lS|V[XG4 SM,STF #5)) 5#4$)5 !# Z&q&qZ_!_ lJXF, lS|V[XG4 SM,STF ZZ!$ 54#*5 !$ $q!qZ_!_ zL AF,FHL lS|[V[XG )5! )4*__ !5 *q!qZ_!_ zL AF,FHL lS|[V[XG !_5) Z_4$(5 !& Z(q!qZ_!_ zL AF,FHL lS|V[XG !$!& 5!4&)5 !* !q!qZ_!_ VU|JF, ;FZL4 SM,STF )!( #_4#Z_ !( Z(q!qZ_!_ VU|JF, ;FZL4 SM,STF !$!( !54_Z5 !) Z(q!qZ_!_ Z\UM,L lS|V[XG4SM,STF !$_) $(45&5 Z_ Z5q!ZqZ__* ZLUF0"; ;FZL4 SM,STF *5* !54$Z5 Z! Z(q!qZ_!_ ZLUF0"; ;FZL4 SM,STF !$!) 5*4!_5 ZZ !_q$qZ_!_ Z\UM,L ;FZL 4SM,STF !))& !4_$4*!_ Z# !q!qZ_!_ 5ZLWL O[XG4 SM,STF )!5 #$4!__ Z$ !*q5qZ_!_ 5ZL3L O[XG4 SM,STF Z!Z( Z_4$&_ Z5 5q&qZ_!_ 5ZLWL O[XG4 SM,STF Z!)_ $#45&_ Z& 5q&qZ_!_ zLGUZ O[XG4 SM,STF ZZZ_ !$4_#_ S], ZSD ~FP )4&Z45## OlZIFNLVM TZOYL ;FDFJF/F G\P! GJ;FZL VMlO;[ ~FP)4&Z45##qvGM DF, ;]5|T SZJFDF\ VFJ[, H[GL Z;LN 56 ;FDFJF/F TZOYL .:I] SZJFDF\ VFJ[,4 H[ Z;LNDF\ DF,G\] JHG4 ZSD4 .g:IMZg;GL ZSD4 ;lJ"; 8[1FGL ZSD TYF VF\U0LIF RFHL";GL ZSDGL lJUT NXF"JJFDF\ VFJ[,L K[P ;NZ 5F;", ;FDFJF/FVMV[ H[ T[ J[5FZLVMG[ ;]5|T SZJFG\] :JLSFZ[,\]P ;NZ 5F;", ;FDFJF/FVMG[ VF%IF AFN YM0F ;DI 5KL OlZIFNLV[ ;FDFJF/F G\P!GL VMlO;DF\ T5F; SZTF\ 5F;",GL l0,LJZL V\U[ JFINF SZJFDF\ VFJTF CTF4 VG[ VF ZLT[ ;FDFJF/FV[ A[NZSFZL NFBJL OlZIFNL wJFZF VF5JFDF\ VFJ[, DF, OlZIFNLG[ ;]5|T SZ[, GlC\P tIFZAFN ;FDFJF/FV[ 5F;",GF GF6F\GL ZSD 8\]S ;DIDF\ R}SJL VF5X[ T[JL ,[lBT SA},FT VF5[,LP S], ~FP)4&Z45##qv 5F;",GL AHFZ lS\DT YTL CTLP ;FDFJF/FVM V[S ALHFGF D[/F5L56FDF\ OlZIFNLGM DF, ;U[ JU[ SZ[,P VF ZLT[ ;FDFJF/FVMV[ OlZIFNLGM DF, 5CM\RF0[, G CMI4 OlZIFNLVMV[ lJPOMZDDF\ OZLIFN SZ[,P lJPOMZD[ OlZIFNLGL OZLIFN V\XTo D\H}Z SZ[, CMI4 ;FDFJF/FV[ V+[ V5L, SZ[, K[P N.R.K. Appeal NO- 2013/1394 Page 3 of 6 4 s$f V[5[,g8 TZO[ lJwJFG JSL, zL VFG\N 5ZLBG[[ ;F\E?IFPTYF lZ:5Mg0g8 TZO[ lJwJFG JSL, zL JLPV[DP5\RM,LG[ ;F\E?IFP s5f V[5[,g8 TZO[GL N,L, D]HA D]/ OlZIFNL V[S 5[-L K[ T[ jIJ;FIS C[T] Commercial Perpaz DF8[ SFD SZ[ K[ T[YL U|FCSGL jIFbIFDF\ VFJL XS[ GlC\P T[YL lJPOMZDGM C]SD ZN YJFG[ 5F+ K[P ;FDFJF/F G\P! l;JFIGF TDFD ;FDFJF/FVM GFPOMZDGL CNGL ACFZGF CMJFYL SZ[, C]SD ZN YJF 5F+ K[4 T[DH ;NZ OZLIFNG[ GMG HM.g0Z VMO 5F8L"
T[DH lD; HM.g0Z VMO 5F8L"GM AFn G0[ K[P ;FDFJF/F G\PZ YL $ GF\V[ 51FSFZ TZLS[ HM0FJF SM. 5ZJFGUL 56 ,LW[, GYLP V[5[,g8 8=Fg;5M8"
;lJ"; CMJFYL T[DGL ;FD[ U|FCS OZLIFN G Y. XS[ TYF Z;LNGL XZT G\P$ D]HA !5 lNJ; AFN SZJFDF\ VFJ[, S[; 8SJF5F+ GYL4 TYF XZT G\P5 D]HA R[S NL- ~FP!__qvGL HJFANFZL YFIP ;FDFJF/F G\P5PV[ DF, U]D SZ[, K[ H[ G\P5 G[ l0,L8 SZ[, K[ H[ SZL XSFI GlC\ T[GL ;FD[ 56 C]SD SZJM HM.V[P SFINFGM AFn CMI VG[ ,[lBT ZH]VFTDF\ G ,LW[, CMI TM 56 SM8[" wIFG[ ,[J\] HM.V[P s&f lZ:5Mg0g8 TZOGL N,L, D]HA U]0h J[<I] 0LS,[0" SZJFDF\ VFJ[, K[ H U]0h EFULNFZ[ J[RL GF\B[, K[P lJPOMZDGF R}SFNFGF 5[ZFv! DF\ HLJG lGJF"C DF8[ ;NZ W\WM SZTF CTF T[D H6FJJFDF\ VFJ[, K[P 5FGF G\P&! 5Z SA}, SZ[, K[ S[ ;FDFJF/F G\P5 S[ H[ S,STF A|F\RDF\ DF,GL l0,LJZL SZJFG\] SFDSFH SZ[ K[ T[D6[ SM.GL ;FY[ D[/F5L56FDF\ RMZL SZ[, K[P s*f TDFD N,L,M N:TFJ[HM4 lJwJFG OMZDGM JFNU|:T C]SD lJU[Z[ J\RF6[ ,[TF\ GLR[ 5|DF6[ TFZ6 SZJFDF\ VFJ[ K[P s(f ZH} SZ[, 5CM\R 5FGF G\P#Z YL 5$ p5Z K[P lZ;LJZGL 5CM\R 5MTFGF DF8[ GYL Commercial Perpaz DF8[GL K[ T[YL OZLIFNDF\ ,bI] K[ T[ N.R.K. Appeal NO- 2013/1394 Page 4 of 6 5 DFGL XSFI GlC\ ;NZ lZ;L%8 JQF" Z__)vZ_!_ GL K[ HIFZ[ OZLIFN JQF"vZ_!# GL K[P I (2010) CPJ 4 (S.C)GF GFDNFZ ;]l5|D SM8"GF R]SFNFDF\ H6FjIF D]HA Sectiona 2d DF\ Act 62 of 2002 DF\ YI[, ;]WFZF D]HA (Effect from 15/3/2003) SM.56 jIlST SMD"lXI, C[T]YL SM.56 ;lJ"; VF5[ TM T[GM U|FCSGL jIFbIFDF\ ;DFJ[X YTM GYLP HM VF ;lJ"; SM.56 jIlST wJFZF ,[JFDF\ VFJ[, CMI TM T[ jIlST 56 U|FCS AGTM GYLP VFJF S[;DF\ OZLIFN maintainble GYLP JW]DF\ ,[lBT ZH]VFTDF\ G CMI TM 56 SM8"GL ;tTF K[ S[ CS]DTDF\ K[ S[ S[D m ;FDFJF/FVMV[ HFC[Z G SI]" CMI TM 56 SM8" HJFANFZLDF\YL D]ST YFI GlC\P T[ V[5[,g8GL N,L, ;FY[ VD[ ;\DT KLV[P lJPOMZDGM C}SD VIMuI VG[ U[ZjIOFHAL CMI C:T1F[5 SZL GLR[ D]HA C]SD SZJFDF\ VFJ[ K[P vo C]SD ov s!f V5L, G\AZ Z_!#q!#)$ D\H}Z SZJFDF\ VFJ[ K[P sZf GJ;FZL lH<,F U|FCS TSZFZ lGJFZ6 ;D1FGL OlZIFN G\P!##qZ_!_GF SFD[ TFP#_q$qZ_!#GF\ ZMH YI[, C]SD ZN SZJFDF\ VFJ[ K[P s#f VT|[GL SR[ZLG[ VFN[X SZJFDF\ VFJ[ K[ S[4 V5L,GF SFD[ lJJFNLV[ VT|[ SlDXGDF\ H[ SM. ZSD HDF SZFJ[, CMI T[GL p5Z p5H YI[, T[GF jIFH ;lCTGL ZSDGL IMuI RSF;6L VG[ BZF. SZL4 T[ ZSDGM lJJFNLGF N.R.K. Appeal NO- 2013/1394 Page 5 of 6 6 GFDGM V[SFpg8 5[. R[S AGFJL lJJFNLG[ VF5JF ;FZ] T[DGF JSL,zLG[ VF5JM VG[ ;NZ R[S D?IF AN,GL 5FSL 5CM\R D[/JL ,[JLP s$f BR" V\U[ SM. C]SD SZJFDF\ VFJTM GYLP s5f VF R]SFNFGL GS, V5L,GF 51FSFZMG[ lJGF D}<I[ VF5JLP s&f ZHL:8=LG[ V[JL ;}RGF VF5JFDF\ VFJ[ K[ S[4 lH<,F SlDXG ;]ZT GFVMG[ VF C]SDGL GS, 5LP0LPV[OPOMD[8 .vD[.,YL H~ZL SFI"JFCL SZJF DF8[ DMS,L VF5JLP VFH ZMH TFZLB oZ! DL4 DFC[vVMU:84 ;G[ Z_Z! GF ZMH R]SFNM B]<,L VNF,TDF\ ;CL SZL HFC[Z SIM"P VDNFJFNP TFPZ!q(qZ_Z! szLDTL H[PJFIPX]S,f sV[;PV[GPJSL,f D[dAZ D[dAZ N.R.K. Appeal NO- 2013/1394 Page 6 of 6