State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission
United India Ins Co Ltd vs Sushilaben B Shah on 25 October, 2007
C: \WIflDOWS\Deskmp\-10-07\10i2-06 AFL. B.J. 2S--10-O7. .doc - - 6 1
312191 3-*11c1g 113 12111 2:131 EH1 131 11111 E'1cE1 c1111113t1~1'lr111"1v1c-1 1§1.1a1-{'1
H11 1:1<~fl11121 1.13111 111 M1 B1=111=1'1 2?1a21s1g,a1v1 11 3.11 1:31 1s,11$112 21111
..~:1-*-:§'=1~z-_=~r< L11:._J1 {J1 - L L
(113116 219111 °2;«111.--11I§'1 11 ::1T111€111r1 3:11:13, 113a-1 8131 [i12:'L&a111a1o1 0112114
111 11111 1:11-1111 11 1.31311 11L1'1:11c1 113111111 °1re11cz11c:11a 32111121-1 11r:11t:1'1
1161 211111116111. 11t1"1a1e1 =?1s«€1Ie 311161111 [i1f='1a111 111311116112 111111111 613
31211111 =z:11cfl £111 111 2»11c1'1 23°11 219161 $11131 °2r11a1c11 19111 2:1-1 1S°1r1«11
511111 111111111 111111 «-111. 2:E1L1i111r1 .1111c1g I13 111 21-1 fi'.12A.1::§11éI::>1 aécuq
€111 =~11r1c11*1'1 11131 11111121 {-1 1:151 [?1[?1z1=1 11~c1'Ls111 1:191 81 2:131 1111' 311 .%I'1=«'1
1c1'L11:.'l c1<:1'1<:1'l 213111111 31116111, 111111111 131111 32:11:11 21131 91:11 2:12? :1:'1c1'1
21111"; s1'la11€1v1 2131112 v1i'1c1 eS'°1'12:1-31 2:il11ia1~1«1fl F'1s'L'2t c£1=1 éurfl-1
11111. 2:191 ci1111.1£t1ri1>::"1 [i1z?1so$11é1a1°a'1'a1 11'1c111911111=a1 E1[?1z1=1 M13121
011111 111111111 =z:11i'1e1 111 3111121 251 1111311131 [1'12:'11s::§1"1~e'[:>1-'1 c"1c1 31121 €11. EH1
=11-1c11=11 z-1131 Q. <11 1111111 12121131911 °1r1>11cg 11111 1131 1111111121 41111
01112111 1111. 11-1 11111121-1 1112c11v11{l.:111111c11=111r1'l 11113 311321 "
r11 111%£1'1c1v11 2111113 c1'1='-'11;1:1-1 °arIe11c1c11rfl 12°11 11111 21, =1:1:>11(3ri1 11°1":51?1
=1:-11211 111:1c11-'1r1'l 2.111 1101-°"1'1 1111, A w11fl" s:113yfl§1«%::?t-{"1
'*" c1g=11 111%11c11<r11 111191111 11111 3 a1<flu1111 a11a11C2-1'1 11°1?.2'l-T1
11é'1é1.s 211-1:111 s«.21~=1<1Cl 113 2:131 E1 2:15'1vi'1 sc311$°1 <~1eilu1111 111111 1:131
'111111c11<:11-11 *?1«1c-1 11121111313 11°81 11. 111111113. t11c11r112:1<1fi.111v.11'1 °1r1;-1.19':
Q 3; a:11c1'l 11°§-1'1 f111rar11 1~_1'l1111'1°11av.'l 13 31211 1:1'k11e13'1 11°1E1'l 51141 81
K,
1
G€99(&::o1':~ .1 =13.-111w
C:\WiNf)0WS\Desidnp\1fi--(T7'\ifl12--fi6 N'-'i.. 3.1 25-if!-C|?..doc - 7 --
°sg21 6 2191 Etriisé-1sS=1 3323: E1 ccu°2r<»{1 £9. ztnuqttwit 1»i'La'l-fléi sc'-31.25%
ru=+i<g2 saia 2?.
c. auucuvuzrl °emLL3tet€9§ talc-iI2{"[ étsfuz évtvatrt zfiaaacgos aria 9?)
El met-'3'm.'l~tL arm: can eniet Q 3 é.t?S1t2 Eran 22191 2'1é'tI2s relax
zleusgm sia 2}. Gig; mffitwti slmrfléatvt [?t=mcu=1Léc-tt3'4.c-1e'§. an
Zemi 3bl3I.l.(? 2-ml atilc-L 23, {Ian %"9llC{<u"fl °er3e «ml &eL'1I41r=L'let'l silam
X 2:191 m cm, 18 $3.
2:. 2:151 uvilaac-t .=a"t=i 24-1 u.1c«.'1a'l-{L 'bt0'--£Rt sia. utflaec-t mini um
«i. 17: esuiuzédzm vu aim Q. '*3' avid': %LPuCll0l£"il flvta. $1. oflvuoutY
Héeil 1i'L<1.u.vt'l vilu gllet £9 €tru wuiz' 1-Etc-1'l%fhu ewuz Mm 2431 E1'.-11
215454 €131 masgw 53:1 8», :e¢°.s":2.'l mérfi £1.29 0:41»: «nil am:
{M «£1 mi 'fidl ifialsofleélat sei"ws«L1 ch séiatgt °b"§llH 93. mntcumul
cvtauq -1 en? :13 3 :>»t:>uCa~t"i %t°§2'l3t ulziisailzélot atIa1'l5i 1i1<at'l2t'l séllam
3' wt 3.1 gwm fizsmsegs otmq, A1131 aiealua 43 23.
<10. (ma °zr~2u.c'tc~t anti an-zefl M féltcuvt almru. [Sum-I reuéi wit
and 2:62} 611% 3, azlr-ml cu. E-E;"L/(:6 vu 21% Eigvflzlz 21%. 911+
2'1iEm3'ira 2»i'u«i'i-tc-:.1:.~ari1 :z1L:;cu2 uéa 6?: czrasefi ed? 315;, wtatim i.
wstlqli Mum E9 2:151 -'&tL°1lCLlUll'-lt:?!. cfllil zmcfl qua mum ecu. aafl
\ ',
mnqnqaa mm; . »u=.......
f::\WiNiX3W§'\I)eskmp\ifi-é7\L1éii~fi6 SJ. 25-iG~é7..duc. - 3 ~
eéi [?¢2?13:»'Ra10tvt1sl2é'L cfin U:lét'l%fl .§:';12l'--t 'er =z»t~"'t 'o'.--'1. .4L=1°9;2 vita
321 siet 23. ¢2'laaLe,I2:?L mvwils am Wéil uilet £9. szlqtelvfl cam
uL'Lc-fl2fl3t.1ao,ooo]- rfl écfl. mi '{l:'.'t Rticurt $1291 3_l..~9?;,OO ;-- 2:151
WE SW5 =tL-was am frlfitiru nvfl §G€t 3a.co,ooo/--- ailqtélvi
z-amtqqvfi gm 3iaCttHi 3:t£3l.¢'=t 23» I-wig Ei 7€..%"l"ii.. ?g,m'z !s?.ClL*t'l 92:33.
°.:reuq 23. 221-1 Qlac-u gzcil °{°g2 etcu tux "H £9. Iilcflefl 3L.u.o,ooo/--~
rfl ém tI1e1:eflvfl éilam ea wutéi ea ctii u % zs'l%gg,eL'1é1 «Elm atsamt
aIa'laué1-1 2511 3?rt'~lLC{<'«fl °a"1t$=?t «ml zhaat g:>.ct'l wfla viam: alga 32 cu
um ém vflii =_1,°a't»tri'L gm ssaqmi 2M £9.
gm
1.Firllfltét "L'10'l%,:'O§ =:{scm{°g2 saqmi -'ouél E3.
2. ?tllHl€llUl2;l ;qL.uo,ooo/--~-- (till 1i'Les."l%L'l éélam vi. as u=w§t '-L % swgéiélcz om strait-'L séfin cuxmxe/<::c ( sélsh vu=i=ga aiet ) ceztzeil C: 2: -u. 2m cau°.?r gsqeflvfl anal»: ggtfl. aauttcu.
3. &2'1au.aeL3L =uru-its '>I.Rt*ll3L.1tOOOf---- um ¢2'1zu2. vveiru ':11. 3,0003% gaqcu.
K. =wfl<1-tt mi 2451 §12Sgs=1 szctmi mttqcft *t%fl. iv : - U was was (aw: rszxnmm % c:xwIwwwsxmkmpxio-arm124:5 3.1 254 A doc ..
mu fiflk:-« 99 tfi:-£i:~.2; .L::'3r£m't~: 'A ) mm» ! «M Cf§WINDOW5\DesktuD\1D-0?\1D12-06 AH... B.J. 25-1B~07,.d0C mes cl3Q.l?. FiCLl--2E'L stiwrt '»'g°zf2Lcl amt, 7b{"lE.lCl.l'é..
wfla 4.1012/oe =*3?.i1':3'L*ra:--- g,rtL'82$ %3-£1%u iSr2<g.&_J,. efl. 2'L=&1zi'm ulala, ma mm, gv-ts: oilcz-.{Ic>L,vu-13%, W-talcufa. Ham [33-ti1~:sra:~ g2L'leu<»"m rsfl. sue, 23U=t,°i1, Ectam =9ms.é="i«a, an '91 14.1%, «ton €ll$°J,?rt'-lE.1=ltE.. cI..=flc1:---- aituéra (12% sii. :?m.<%.€tc=.q, [iwlrsva cm} ail 2Am..°3.ass2, §m:-- [iRuiS£[a;='1v»L2 ail °ar"l.2?L.=>4,Lg°arL ftm '<*i2cl.<'tt5 °eM (mar 133:4/wm C:\WINDOWS\Daktop\10-07\.1012-06 APL. BJ. 25-1D-07..doc v 2 -- 5iV:t?. 311 <=12cLou2§ °a"n=i1tctm <5QLf{ rll.?;'-lf'lO/?.OO\9
1. [Emu mwqta (sum) °a'1eeu amass d32tE Ftqtaez ¢"'m.ru $21
-L cco/eeni rll. zo,/2/oe ru :§'L°a sic-t gsnefl rum; 212$} 3$it"¢<'='t-a aiiaéi 3, got %m-ucuuuil rules gzat 'run. H1 gem 'W. 8.601 em Guava zzuilet aid 23-.
a. [Emu-1 a1L.<t.Pt.=sh=1, =w1e:qta(auv+) A1 avjlaua vi. cco,ie<: ni 4131 =g,r»L°m1 gsn size; 9.
fitcttxélct gsn " $2'1?.-tI.E.'9H'l $211112 mm: Wye £sQCllHi =»u¢1 23>. =eu=~1LcLw£l c[1=u éurfl?'t wail gm 32<ll?ti 24151 Q 2:, £1241 aflzueet-'1 3L.@a,ooo;'-- ( vi"; 31-am. «aka; e°m 3,21. ) 5t.§13€tsSa mactta 1>L=%{*llrl%tl3L.1l,OOO/--- ( 2:43: gum um é°efl?. gm. ) 'iL'Rfl.': ma =21-3t z+m~1Lr1.L qumz €12 2:1-1 3_l.3,000/-- ( a»i.?s 3vZl=u é.°5'l?. gal. ) aeflzua usi £15 391 mrfl §G€£ 3_L. co,ooo/---- ( 2:13: sum aiiafl emz gm. ) cufils c: % Md <2u°a «ma 2»uvL-'€1 gscugfl em cqigtfl gaqcuvfl gm mm marl £9. "
t 'I
- z rm: vrexaeieac: 4 narmvw @ C:\W"iNDOW§\f)eskmpi1fl-fiiiifiié-G6 B3. i§-10-f17..docL - 3 -
=»u 5mrL'1 aizvtctt btmie. Stftéira 301 zmuqwlt €16 EH41 zmucutrtt cm} W 21z1i'L-sva gut <.-21412.1 gm 831-1 e31 uasfl aa'lzue.'1 ct2'1"é zitvilttcmti '-2»u€1a 23.
an esre'laL1s.vL'l gsui. eslscz ma 2} 5?, uoikam oil. Qua. Litanrit, u<~1'H1, §l.§'-L,OOO/--- vii, =u.--<»mm1 (23.5% 3L.uo,ooo,«'~ H1 i1$13€uSH CM:
amucuvtt Gila: aéuril Iuéiafl m.2o;":r/cu ru vim (3cm81. aahtélaii uulasca. éhivtt §Lc-m ~11. 1:: Hi °5t2u.&<-.L 2) E sileuélvtx Htcyzfl ail:-ufl ggflc-wi'L-1 ail. amt».-1 Cfi*fl é-'tcu ru3;eu '12 max -"«»1:>1':(3 =v{3'«'Btl& szofl «mg i5°zn 2u1Lc~fl 2:431 fltétafira 2»412£'v-etuaag wflui an 3.-ma-L «tau Em-1 eumédatvt <=i1om oatattéial. 2u=u=u<ru2'»'t uletlal aiet Ami mfinaévatrt 24-1 3131 zlétéxs iwizrfl zuacua 2§'L5:asc«gs 35.61. cflitati; zlvgma nfln'lam <*1%et.a2'1e+Lz'1%'t ctl.QB'/'l/(:6 «u my =»1ou(2ru zvitttiat-L z'tc1'12.s afimiam 911% elwlaani am-:1 aim °3~i1 mi 3L.\9~"¢,OOO/- aflqtaléii 2_;,s€Let. 2{l'1lC{lUu cflm .r:ZurL'1%:eme4. =1.£lsé'1tS'-H "-vflét, 'a%ctL3.°.z?L-{1 séfinvfl gsqefl HLE %--'§ 5%. amtqwwfit «Lint/E/ea ru uwtail u'1:231s::fl:¢.fia:rt1 eatatgma -it sijgz sia. $2'1€lLE.'1?3t s121'<;21:ari'L ritélu 2>ui'm °E'r5i 2u=u.cuvLL23't "£81.31 cu szhteai °erIaLLczu u=-wétrft us.
*-L'L=>Lc{l [Emu $19.1: mun $?.'1*iL% sréefl.
V as t i am mm mo! ?_33.'.'fM~: fl C:'\WINDOW'5\Dask'hop\10-07\1012-06 BJ. 25-10'-B7..doc - 4 -
It. %ttHt€ll"LF5{ timm sewti °ari;=L1€'Lc--1 IE9 is a2"laua'l2?'t 2°55, siet sL:>L<Ii1ru W415'. 2wucLL<Im»£'L2A uitcuvu ilrm sisal %1=;.u1. waflum 2»i'L%iii'L$l,2 21%-3» aaoflum Hfa Hkéa Emru wflulq 1.mLé'L wtté Em-'1 c3':$a élwi tS°a*L2Li'+r4'l $1-"i 3.291 '-vimi-*zm smug ula 2:131 élfi-.l:j,
-'e>{1I1iaLv1 2»taLL(3r{l 2S°mriL-I stat;-1 snag, 18¢: E1211 attmtcwruvil s<Zi2SH gsqqwl °.>.<cuc>m.:».'l eufl wail M.-"1 ('tail %lI.HL¢tl"ll'fl ilcmti eacil mil rtzfl.
m"a £=~"a'laL1a'lrfl $2"l?{i?. uni zuéi 22. wit °ar12S2$1.
E. wail %mat erg sic-t a2m€t°a?1 , [?1£cLL-1£~'Lrm-1 gm cflrimvfl $104121 3% E9. ¥l1°ilClLUlLd9.-'sfifl [3£*¢ll*t maLatLM'1 all =<¥'t=t.°'2?.sE'1e.<t ctau &a'lbu<:»."l ctaé [3l5ClL'l *+m2u2~>a1 all =:12¢.°3'r. asszvfl mu :~.et'1ei'L 3:2:-L °Er«i.'L wk rflii °ereu<1et stmtaz znuélat siet iii.
=+3ti1<?Lravu ct.ss'l<-mt 33H gvsca [Emu-1 «'.«'a.aii °6'§l~t3L<':t 2? %, cflwu s;v.r{12?L utima €§l°{Hlri14{ié1cLt£s9§1ttL%.'9L-iwttatfz-1. 1% am uéeu zmvitct em mii §l-':2 éluni voizuiam 3Ql5J~*:l Et cilozcfl °2f'§Ld£ élcu mi cihurti utitaset $'L={=ti ?2t~'1£L(3'1.t aafiuéat-1-1 -2'leflEs zuacuie 9.»i~'3L fimtsegs sia vusfl. °i1 cilm .r--Jur{l231 :bt:>t;1(2vu :»i'u-dam zléés zuaqm Smlaegq semi ruuqél Pm 5'-e=.'%mt;'-.='u"".. "manta ém ch aflqwat c{l=i'L Eacmctrt vtél $13, gem [3l'=Cl1*t is-TR H-3 cgra. m.§:_,;:4.. 215. 39.121 3: ¢l'1'iI.1fl.éfl2{lHi u'l=3t3o§12é13L tS°zn aaizii. we I_ l i_ VGDSC-8% (Bio? - .1 '13:".'J"\Vf~' fl I. c;\wmoows\.oesInnpx1o-o?\1o12-oa APL. 5.3. 25-1U--O?..dinc . 5 --
(aeém {iv Etefl szlauvet-"i Iimahflrmi rflim Qeéfm 32131 °o"§ll€lCLl'fl °x32 «tail. [<'-xtcuvi é'L2="i smrtl anal uurmi amt wail. Iaficllvl s'L:;5'1 aim aataietart sia rtefl. ulalzal éflat-1 X. 'em ante £9 3 %t:>uf3 eulét i§°J|.'1l 5L2.Ié1 etetg=2rimia1-1 5:? 32-ctuti mitla 9. %'L¥'t [\1293:>§l1+é1:>t sécm stats: 3, E1 tL3.c~u-fl 211161 timru sméi sztqg um 23. E121 éllam ri.m °:i1cusé'uS=1 '1UL<'+tl um rtefl M31 fiérl?-Ll.E.El:'I. vltttialvt etiiet El miss wufzrtl aailuiavtii rilétés Q. aafl ulvfisaflzélst avetut M4': 1t"tc-rhilvil §§l9;l*t 3'. wt} m u=~w§'L £s:flaua"t-u séifiu HUB-'ll. um rtaii. 5} ztmtqtourtt '31-1&1 =2rE'L2i1?l£ls we?-irtt *?>'J*il'»I.l'-'Ht wmi sewn -11 =i°g_2 33261 6. \9. 2:191 itfiérag éttifusct saw zcflsticu vteii, met 3; =2>t%ivtL 3'{lQL'1'tl rag aid witaset 3113 cu. 20/K/(:11 «L um <17: 'Hi. ézlqtatfi zaaveutai °zrs2LLEi<e1 Q 3} <12 '*1Rt wufa Mr:-'+u,E't sS'°2n atim. M31 aecsx Hi e"Lut2.'lt€4.ru="1vavfl we?-"z."l. sucil <.'1H°5 é.Li5'+.«'¢ Eva-14: 210:. 2&5; wet. °xeLLElea. cqtzmz. r¢w+c.Lc:Lu1L«u rhea slsai afl. r+l1I=uouiS' uéc-a ut.a2/mu ru ?.'L°c: a=2'1aLL~a.t2L-1 cmml-1 uulaset ¢'w'C 2:1-mm cvfl. 'H-1 -1'. 1+ ni vu °mLc»mi wuélet -"oi-1 a-L12 one 2&1-yaf [clam auiotta amucuatt cL'lHL ,éuv{l2§i qfliii
-wire; «MP1 vikflalai wufzru a°§fl?t 2'lc3{és %ll1P.€{t% mé ailaeisegrt eréaa -viii aw; a:{'nu€:£1 'um-u In-iiasa :.=?Lii=+1i'<»ir»L1E2 wia $3131 221% effixa euacuz ril. C?'é<§t1*l suit-us mat etemi amen »{'mi9.L-1 E1 zS°mL \ K was oe99<sx.oi-,:'.1az~1AvN % K