Karnataka High Court
M/S Ballary Steel Rolling Mills vs The Asst. Director on 18 October, 2010
Author: Aravind Kumar
Bench: Aravind Kumar
EN THE EEEQH €§UR'i' Q? E{ARE'$é.:'}'AKA
CERCUET' BENCH A'? §EEARWAfi
gmgn TEES TEES 136: mg? Q15' Qc'r9BE£.,_*2@:§§7 j" *
BEFGRE _
1?:-:3 EIQEFBLE MR5 JEESTECE A§§RA'$_?gt}E:VE K::'r+::EésE§'" *"
M.§:A. Ne,2:6835;~:§1G{"Eg$f.§,;_
BETWEEN: F' V . T'
R12/S BALLARY 9:33; R(;:,:;:'i%~;<__;' I'§z::;.j;;:~§ " "
SN NO. 8§2*{}&NAN'1f'APUR mm) * ' '
BEALLARY, 913?; %B.ELLAR¥';». f _ ";;;T'AP?ELLAN'Z'
{By 53:; :§;9a;:~.,P;Pi.¢ig $§gé:;3;3A:~§';.Ai>i}.; ;.
f~§ND
THE ASs;:.§"§ANfi*"':::¥.:_--R§<;ii[f{;-g "~«.___ _ _
E1v:1:>L<>°yE::: S*FA.'FEZ_§i§$EjRZ%gN'£iE" i_i€Ii)§3<'?(f)RA'E'§{}N
;':§ARV{}BAY,{L§. 5CiR {":.LE_ ga:-§;e::~§'=sa:,fi; 9:152
HUBLE, DIi*§"E':':Z¥_Ef§£°1.:i?'\?~1'A£};._ " RE$§>{}E'-§D§Z\§'E'
..:';3;,«~ gm :a,z:F':;:'§~«:g$':,':a--*?-.z'g:%;:j:i;§ mv
' .- Ts»:§_&;'v.:>;/EF.é».*{é«: -1.?'-m"~:§3 é}jEE§EjC.é§:2'{2} <_:s§€* 335;: Am; ;%{3«_f-*:EN8'§'
3':$§; '~.T's::sfQ:,'-2§:§%;,, .j_:::._:z;*raD {§Z:1--Eji~2{}é§}€} :'3AE%SE3D IN 3%;
,»aP:v:;.:\¥<}%.§4;:;:{:zé:;%e%;T" €.>.'N '§';P§i€ 9:33: <55' THE DESTRECE' :EUB{2»E
'r,MPL<}%:E_E__f'3' &§'E'A.'E."E3 ;NSuRAN{:E: <":<::a%;;"§*<*:"', HEEBLEF
;;::;M:s359.;;;:«z§:;'._'m§ AP?;a,.:<:_xm<j>r€ §2'1LE::} U/E3§;{3f?"i'§ SE' THE
* --« g.zxxiz">§",.<}:fE;E:s:;' STATE §§\E8UE2f%I\E{fiE;1- ;x_<:'?, iégasés.
"A..é'*ar;:':€% ;%??§i1fz'=xL <:<;:M:'r~;'<.; :1»: §?"€1j}E~?: _:::>:~a§:.:§:%z{::\: '§'.%§_§:'~; 35:3;
..:f:f:'~§E §§3{f}L.TR'";!' §Z;:§E:f_.a'E1':"fE§:;E%E;;§4'} *:*;?»T§:_%:. F{}.§A,{}WIE\?{ii§-:
2 F 'i3£}§%iEfi:Z?'E
Thgmgh 'a'.h.is;; zzippstaé Eisiatai 22.73' z2<im§ss:/K331 'é.':}§:§.V&:::§z,'f, ..1E}:v7
<:<:';r1$<::1t (sf Eérazuflrzd a<:§v¢:3ce:_t.:%s3 aa;>§:€:2;:r§'z3§;_§ f{'}E' {E263 :'%f.;_i$".
é:a%~::@i3 12? fa}? i"§m:1 (:E.~.%.1€;§3{:}E§-;41:x
2. This; appeezi is ziéfsd by'.:hé E"rin€;é_p'é1§ E3éu§'1<>j}%:é:f
quegtianizzg 121$ c::<'sz"rr3a:m<~:s;s e3:;{i"~1.§3g;2:Zé'{'3;=- 05.33;'-':7 <;\§t§[email protected]§aé€<f2--. %
QSJLQGO9 passéssd by __E3:np>'i<)}%€:;é3:s._E%vi_aic3 §ri«:s:.;:;'2m;<3E{: i'.§0u;:"'t;
Er"£°a,§'b1i in ESE appsal Na). E.4}';3?:Vi'}§{},€S;.L ;
'E1*:a:~_.£':=:::E:>,i'-.ir*: [r:L;:: §é{§1«3§.?;A§'e:§::_<3;irig§':€::§ the {fling of this
aqgpeai a;;f:--: as §.J.i'i§jz:?I'.;V
2:} .%;fig3§:E1é§zz:€ 2«; g:<.>:'§%z3d »:*:sz:21_%>Eis;hm€:éE Lm.c:§€::" €336:
.,Em§é;:.:§;--{rs:s':=:-:I~ E~3»%;.3fi;é"Erz$2,::':z>.:":€;:<2 C<>rr;.';§a.2'3é€s; siictfi E948 and was
j§éE?4*'i,%.'2§ cgniyilfiiiifivijzzs par S€::.%1é=:>n amt? 48 {sf ihs: As: 53:? the
-§;p:3¢£f%%::§__ :;:€.§§<%r 2:22:53 %ii€g,{u§2::i<3ns¢ {)2 aa::<:0u:::§ {sf
.21<2:"1~_§;zf;§z;.%3ni.v "%;3§:" <:<.>::%.ribm_:i<}:3::s :"°<?qLz:%:"e<%_ fer 211:5 ;>eri<3<:§ 05
" §Ef€i{f§7';§.&iZ'j§fV'?§{:}'9§?3 35> ?v'§z:1§<:,§: 253045 2: saifzaw <:az_::--3<~: rmiice {teams 3:5; be
"E.3é{3A'{§;Ei'['.{f£% i3E}é$§,':.i2€"}iZ}§ azsgiiirzg azpzm. 1'2-fit: <:%.zr:'§;1s:>§,-"<3: :9 :~.;§3<:;:z:
'C;s:'{,é's:3 2:53 vsfigtajg ihsé s;?<>z?;€.:"é°§;suf;%.:::":s¥; é:st§'E:::£"é'.<':{'; in i,fm:% :s§%2<>w {:.2m5,:e
E
:1<}iEC{§ s§':1GUl{i z":{>§'. bi: d::::<::'mm:::-<2 aizd re<:<;>v:*r:3{§ Em? iiw. Sand
p<3:':::<:§ 9:" {§(3fé%L'§§§.. 5%. §:»€::":«;<:3r2a§ 2-1§}§3€2';3f'§fE§_i; was <::~§f<::'::va:%.
';«f"~.1
I'.
'22.§ET.20€}e'§ at iilagm, {En &i{E€_'T{)i,E.EE'{ ('sf 1.10::~2:pp£:*a.r2::r;%;:e3'z; V
Ef§}f1p§{>}r"€';'1" and aim on a.<tc<311m: 9:" zzzrzy {3'§}j;{,fA(A,>'.i'§€)§"EE:'> §::?:j3'i'*f;s¢é2":g'=fi£€é
.
in the Shaw C:-'iLiS~3€iT :1{>'i.i<:€, ;%.s;8§3%:az*:'§ E3%:°i;:<::'{::;"::a.f-*t:.h'<:. 3"eT:s--3§;r3:'1'<§<3L.;j1*;"=;1TA C<>rp<}z°at%0:1 cieézzrzrsizaitci tbs': c<'}f:%'%:";«1'%3:,z?;i{>f*;;s; pe':j;.-?2:T7{>:i,1:>.A._' v?:~7; tiflaeé appeilant at :§29m2;~ wiéh 212:1E;e'~;$s:, at p{3a. 1513 pmvified undsr the Act, bv:\,?"--:>:fdi;<'31'Ai_Ld3;r.§&"'--3{v3.f®~3QQO6 passed under Section 451% _:}fV:E:e ELSE"?
'§} ;3.ame;" . " §5§9§fiscipaME Empiayer fifiezi an ap-jpea§Abéisarf::V€.'E;S§' C.§'L3;r_€ .a;:V3}id@;." Sectian ?'5 @f the ESE Act ané'CvQ§s{V$:':<iéé~ };:¢€é§igé;E§'i: aha': dssizermrimatierz made 'my the cfgrzagéetem'-.:,f:_u'é:hGri'fé§ is in viaiatéarz sf pzmciplfig Qf '::.a:1§g:*al_ ass-%%?{;:%_,' 'if'; was alga cs§1':€z:d;ed. thaéz the Wages far the Es:§E" ._§§€';::é';<fiae:§ 'vsfizzzmi; be {aka}? E323 mnsiéaraiéan fer da:terr§:§€:a':é§:'z '<3? c@rm;"ib'::fi:§r33z bazléfiii unéér ESE £91, ami 'a§ sz:s::'i%,.4 thé ameé' af €fE§t5§:niz3a§;igr: was agaaéied in this 6» H 4 C} Tééé .2ap§<2E1a.:3'{ s.~%:»{:~2rz§im3:§ {me vzitmzséss 85;:
C':.Br3:sa2=*a2"a;§ as ;%f%}'sf.I and. gm'; mafkeé dmsumenés a3 gags? E;:»;;?;.1 "E0 ASE, Rsspendfizéz gef; €Xa§'I1ifEf;"<C§ {ms \f«Basava:"a§ ass .R."\?v".E_ and got markad Eex:-f:,f§:;;:<~ QE..Ci8.2C%€15 as 'E:>»<:.R.E, G2: app:*z:=c1§a*gV-T§'€,:~1'1"':"«z:*f €'i/'i§.51'EC€ on réazarfig E281 Ceurét C£v.iS1'E1Eg%é'3¢:G;;'-A':iA.}%€ this wdez' w.h1i<:h is quegti0nVe:i::€'a. €;h é 'under Sectiam 82 of _Egé"';a';§[:1,!"ibg i:'i%«'":;«e'VV"'?':*'iv:1':Cipa§. Emgaiayer.
parties:
3 82%; .V % Sédfiafigfgfi 3' an, E6a.:*§:'s.€d achrecaie :_a';;;;;3§ea.ri'1§r:§ {:3 :(:Lp§:2€§V'§a::;i:...v;r<:;z;;'§§:i Cazziené éghaz ems: af ESE {3<§'2;r§' ifs' 3:2"-v:.§§s1;a::e*:2 sf _'§}"i:'§<3§'pEf3S :3? z222..E.:.:_ra.§. gzmtéize in as '*--..=»§:.'n.:€§"': as! Eet?:s%*é_:a;%er:§ 21,1 E,.2§%3:'§ :<;ee'2<::?.1'2g far aaijamrrzmrsm " .,: -§;€fQ,?€ i::E"_g_!é._ Aégéjzzdicating a%,:?,%:.ce§it§? £3 H35: disputeé '$3.;
m§p_Q;3dé:':i 313$ 33': asf;£:£3'1;:2*fi: Q3" i'i{}'E' ggraniéng an a:3pp::»§?;Lmi*:;r ?;§i;§:~_M{~:_:hg:>§:3sf,,--'@:" $386.1': £§€§}E"E:i~"€€;§ sf piacérrg 32:': r;:aé;er§a.§. :9 4fl_fl,., shmzs £33 to whj; 121$ $3:z2pE.:>}*€~2f ::§€&<»":d 11:3': :::afE«.:<~: z:<m?:2*i.b%::':§.::';::;$ ané c<:2:r1$€§:.§.s that in this backgrgyaxtzai {>:"'{:§€-".5" is; U} "@:~j"%:_:c$é<:i5"*. aa in viséaftion sf §:"1in<:f£pE.€s of rzzzmraé ji;§S§{'§C€3( j2£;%§é;,€E.{§ aisa eiabarate his Submissésn 'Q3; r:{)n§;€'1';«:3;é¢ng" :?:a5tT'f7;:.1:" :vhfe purgases of mcéganirig the tc3m,r2Zb:,1%;i,®1fl--._payzifiéiémbji €§'.I1§EO:¢'€I", thfi my Gff periad w3.g€:é'*~.carm'<;é:_ 'be: t:_:k €fi"énst0 cerzsééeraiian fer dfitarminaiierm ;25;;r§;'<:f.=;§;céC:dir;giy;"-hep1'"a_'§;'s for setiing asidfi the mdar téés"$.<%§¥;:d;%§%€,i_'gf:g a;ufi:h@r%':y as Wei} as ES}; Cgurg. i§;A%'VVE€§:VVjx¥;0:3id pray fer remand cf the authority Themfora, _A<:'.eg§§Ev1V95V$r1ds aha: q':.E€S€iO1"'iS of law 'iapptsaé wsuéé arise far comsiderefziezfxf V %':"73§'£i"'c'V-»é»«;,VV""S'19°«31V¥ Vina}; Eéaazfiaiagi apjQ€a:°i:':.g an b@E§éaE§ 'S§;§::.é~E.a"var:t, z%d'i,»'O:';'ai€§ 2x:a':.,:Eé 83%/§pp{)§"§Z Eha A " €:é;§;€§' c;i*'«.,_ad;j;v':2a'fii:§C--'atir3g &;'E,1§§"£O§'§T.jJ as; Wei'; as ESE €92,232: 8_.E"':§ Vvéézgéigéiriéigé; :%:<'3;%:éé:€§2. :32': afgpeééazzi. <2a="<::,:.E.<:§; :23: abés 'Ea "*~:";T;:ss::3V;€3c§-3-Aévsrz if 'ihii msiiier £3 reméiésé; back 2:9 {E26 623/ fi a.<1?}u&i€&tiz2§2; 8.':/E."'U;'§{§Z7i{:;? X-énse i:*~,:5;:.:.e raigaming CG?§€?:"i§3'L§§ii}nS pa.3;a°@Ee by an empiojgss? in E"€*Sp€C§'. {sf Egg; 01?? "perigd bsimg :19 mere mi-s--in§ig§&: by 'aérizzs 975 £316 §uiigm_§:*;3'{ Hezifbie Apsx Csurt in BE-{EL r€§er§€-3.d.E@..':3jgr cemends that the appéai desawesfig ihfiiffi baimg 239 Substantial c;:.;1esV~:;':,'17v;.r§L:'s'*:?s::» 0f E"av_»_;. foe farméfiatsd for Ewing a:z':~::§fer€¢a:E';"' €:az1;';:é§nf;i02:1s faised in me appeal as %z,V2:;:»:s§:f£iQé:;>'V:<';fS ::V<::f'": heard the Tgeamed and after perugzlng gassed by S'<}.%:'t:;§§ 452% sf Ehe Act, as Wei} as i1:_';r1e'gf1::?§3:"«:},f" ~.1ESV§'~..;C':%.'ui§€3 ii: :73 naticeé thaé $hew cause If;'0§;§€,€ e::é;m;e*i:é 'Bk? iss'-suvsd by Cerporatiorrz is the "Pr§:::::.%§'g§ '§I{'<'-;1*§':":j ;§é2:':;_j§;-"e§' '%}i«"%1E:Ch atcardtlng K2 appsliazzé: aim is re<§l::.'§_§'i¥.§§. 913:::'E.V,?,»€'TE;'25.}€3;¥p ii is zzezvi £3': 6:iS§'%;Ei€3 Ehaé haarimg vziaie €%;.3-'as an '22,17§.:2{}€%:§. éppsééanz afifif having '%f§:.:*,$*§z>'e.;_§ ééetéce an E"?CE1.2€}{§5 hag Rep? quite ifié.
-'?;§_ E:7{§:?§f3$5 33:23? 9:: '25} 1 .2§E€[}ES has; da:=;§a:c?:.€{:%, a Eaivtsy is <;¥'f;,SE €@1:°pemé:§<m. :"<3§§_:;€$':%::g; fa? ac%};Gu.r:::m~:::E ihraugh a:,%~,M.. .
sspaegi pagtg §§?f';::}'i7*'»£'§I}§ fz,:§§}> §=":='"€i'§ thaé ihfi dszta {if hfiarmg waa fixsé an 22_,':.§..Z2GQ:"3 at Hxahm. by ':22.-+'h§£'r2 iéme Sa§G?.'21'f§:1f'逧f~w. eguld 219?; haw 'ages': receivezfi bf; ESE. Sarpafatéané' reasarms far :10: de$pa*s:chi:1g t.he.:'*::=$--c1g,:e$i f<;42::*Iiie:*' fig ;2i¥E.3.'28®5 is net farzheaming 'frc>;§:3V :"ét:--r: fd:$, aspsci: has been righfif; takefi the -VV;94:f3:§1};::;'?:;V§Z?C3_"c3Z'fr:g auighariijy ané recénsééeréfifi}-' \.'§>f¢"§'§fi€:§' C:*:»A:3;<si§d€:"ing 'ihe issue regayding 'ari0§;t§G r1 af namzal justice and has ;';:e'+;*a:f.§'i;9:=A;.3:. {hers was :19 such he a,§:€€§::}'E:®fl.t It is not the not have a.1:}-" ether' afficiai 1:0 a;'%;?,;e41:d the' fixed an ';?;.2,E1.2005: It is aégs 310%.; #323: case. 95" "agfiséfam ihai it hsfi ziespatiihed the 7§,e*::$:<_{§f ré§z:c§$;z.__f§3r afijournmenz 'E0 E:E1S'L3;§"€ that it wauéd 'V "'2j€s§ég0§:d€nE {§--a::'p91r°a%;.i®n wzsié in time. in 5:16 sgbgenée sf §::a':€ja§ Ea} demangtrate fig b@:<:.af';d€$ ii
--._ '€%'<s,,::'};«rjéL..g1@§;i'::'§ tha: axgpaizznz has adoégisé éiéaiarg tactéca:
=i:%; i;:;;a"éée <32': 3 gmuizé far :::mt€§:.d§:":g ihaaz %;E2r5m wag *"»-f1:.G'"i3JE::C3§'7; $5 §':8£L'i§."'€£ ;'L:.$':éc€ "mg €~:zs:..§_r'£:§g {ha §€Sf§}atC§1 0? E316 § éeizer previgus (E223: E9 the <:§a.:&: :5? hearing. ?'§r;':..;;3} tsfiniarzticm. Sf E'vErSi«:§€Ea§p2:: Sajjazé that éhéire wag Gf natural jzgsiicfi by {he aC';}"L:a§i<:aEir3g azzitheréty"§;*$f1v::z:s.§ 'b€' accsptefi afifi accerdéngly ii is §"'€_§€'fC"£E;' &,
7. in SD far as, the meritg ':};é¥&*~ '¥g3' e:>§';1:i'£§_ s3 in appeai are carzcerrzeé; it caniention is with regard t%:~¢;V.e«<:§ii'*€i"iE;x.:3;.ti{:i%;AVs'gkafiizgble in respect 3:? wagm far tfié Admitieély, appeilant has n.Qf: Dbc€?;| before aéjudicatitiig £z1_,}f.hf3.3fii}' EiS"t£§"-35f§C5.ai was the lay {Eff peréad.
Efie maéeriafij'wh-a§s<>r:$§s3':f'V1>§;2a§1'g::}acec§ befiom BS3, Cssurt {<2 I demenstzgate ':h 4a§E._TRfE11i"{Eb-péfllging, Labaur Cezxtractcr haé r::'3';vd§ _"C'§§r';€_:°.;3.E3§1{é9:"§7sé«-.,.Q:?7' Eabouzérs E9 31% write 05 €_'._V§2'%};,€>6;?f¥',A §;r:=._f:.he absence 2:»? SG,C§'1 maieniaé $316393? aé,jV';.':§§'V§aj:3. it'i?:v§g<._&?:§{'L7E';:i§;7ity was juééiiféfié 1%: arriving at 23 ' -..__£:md§::.s§é:;2': :ha--§'j_a;':§§:1§a§2%: is Eiablsss 3:} pajg {:{>2?§§'?DL:€iG§S ifs:
H :v%.*:'s.:-._*a:V€':;efi 'z§":;22:..-- '§ss~:%.2€: :"é3ga2r<?§%::§j 39;}; CS"? <::a'3:";%::r§%;»:,:?;':}:>:':s;~,t §;s8;js;'a"%3E€ $63365? 5;? 3:33,»-' {ff wageg gaié is {Z<>3":t:*aCE@z: §3ii:'§}"E€E} £3 £3 in :*es;}e<:: 0%" 'iaj; Gff wagea pgziai 3:} 'abs Cgntraczer baémg :29 mare §'"€s«in1:::*3g:"a_v E': 1-wuici aéago Cé}E"fi€' within {ha éfifinéiéfin 0:" 'wages as déifined 1;m<:?im" $§:::t*7:€:;:: 2&2} <1»? ESE fiat asV?;i»*3i{%;. 'Q3' §-E0:':'bE& Ape}: Caurt Em {he case of 31-{EL Corgaratimz regarteé in QBQ8 LEJE 562». i~§e::;{:s'::,= cantentien is aim"; h€:reb}-A" rejected.
8" GEES arzother gmLmé iiifigéd in §1"if:imé is with. regard E0 {he c0;T§[email protected].'é §:";i§'a_b.7;.€'~.§e an }:"}{;E€f}t sf § 0:2; 0f {he total cEa1}1fr: sf :€,§:3f{*;3.Qr.:%,€é:fV}r1-"£3159;'i};<::~ 7~gr0u:":d that 931%}? 60% f0rr:1s .}:h€§: f%a«:g,é;g c?;:éipé:_:.c::éi"vaé3--d baéamca -'~'%®"/z,» vvsulé be fifzé' 4r::8c§*:§.£1%'::f;sa fi::a'.£:1t@'nanc.e expenses" As per ERR} which "13 & V'En_s;fi?:é::é;§1%1 Rspeyi which <:am€ "ta 'Q6 &€1!3: 1253.3 ffiiiflé that appfifiami E2325};"bgésn ~1;;;;?:ih'ié'*--:9 fu;":*1§sih. %:h<": bmak. 'i;1_'§ vr:Eaim€:§ 8.ITv'§_f§ :§:_1$S§:§d Ehai appaéfiané was Eisfaéss is gay " '§ ;'V'§§:¢:':<:"i':31,:*:§¢:is*;'§1g an {ha ezziérss ame:>z;i.§*:?,, in '~fi{EEf<£ Q? ihéa factuaé ".§%.§i;3.Ai:':.g,_ .-'éaig $<:u°r€:, $3 <3? ihs cazrzaéééirfisé tiréai M:
:s1'§E:;s;%ar:?:ia': £;La€3%:*;{>n$ sf 'Ezra; :a;0z::E<§ arigg in ¥':%:%;$ appaaé for .»""£w being farmzgiatcé and. eéfijaééicgsisd arm: g:<:u3::c%s {urged 'av ./ apgeliani "aei1'":.g:;; fa<:'::,'za§ 2iSp{3.<:i3 the. gzwsaerzt appea'; is dismisgeé 3:1; the siage 0:? E:{§1'§fIi$S§G§": as 'being §E3"»»"Qi%;."3j Gf merits. N0 arder 33 is ceszg.