Karnataka High Court
Shri.Basagouda S/O Balagouda Patil vs The State Of Karnataka on 28 September, 2020
Author: S.R. Krishna Kumar
Bench: S.R. Krishna Kumar
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
DHARWAD BEN CH
DATED THIS THE 28 T H DAY OF SEPTEMBER 2020
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR.J USTICE S .R. KRIS HNA KUMAR
W.P.NOs. 125563- 125717/2020 &
WP N Os.130805- 130810/ 2020( CS-EL/M)
BETWEEN:
1.Shri Basagouda s/o Balagouda Patil
Age: 43 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 770 Sl. no. 385)
2. Shri Shivagouda s/o Iragouda Sannakki
Age: 62 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 480 Sl. no. 230)
3. Shri Basavanni s/o Satteppa Labbi
Age: 52 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 442 Sl. no. 212)
4. Shri Shidagouda s/o Basagouda Hosagouda
Age: 54 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 102 Sl. no. 38)
5. Shri Malagouda s/o Iragouda Malagi
Age: 51 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no.726 Sl. no. 352)
2
6. Shri Kempanna s/o Kadagouda Patil
Age: 60 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 2 Sl. no. 1)
7. Shri Shivalingegouda s/o Ramagouda Patil
Age: 43 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 278 Sl. no. 116)
8. Shri Shashikant s/o Mallappa Bhangi
Age: 32 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 568 Sl. no. 286)
9. Shri Kalagouda s/o Shivagouda Patil
Age: 56 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 466 Sl. no. 224)
10. Shri Kedari s/o Dundappa Kameri
Age: 40 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 627 Sl. no. 306)
11. Smt. Jayashri w/o Malagouda Patil
Age: 40 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no.663 Sl. no. 330)
12. Shri Shivanand s/o Dundappa Chinchani
Age: 57 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 802 Sl. no. 416)
13. Smt.Shivagangavva w/o Kadagouda Patil
Age: 62 years, occupation: Agriculture
3
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 542 Sl. no. 271)
14. Shri Sadashiv s/o Virupaxi Hajam
Age: 35 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 654 Sl. no. 324)
15. Shri Iragouda s/o Chanagouda Patil
Age: 55 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 518 Sl. no. 256)
16. Smt. Limbekka w/o Kadagouda Patil
Age: 60 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 536 Sl. no. 267)
17. Shri Mohan Jyoteppa Survanshi
Age: 60 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 351 Sl. no. 157)
18. Shri Bhimagouda @ Paragouda s/o Kalagouda
Patil
Age: 64 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 42 Sl. no. 15)
19. Shri Sachin s/o. Malagouda Patil
Age: 28 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 841 Sl. no. 428)
4
20. Shri Nagesh s/o Iragouda Patil
Age: 28 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 763 Sl. no. 378)
21. Shri Ashok s/o Malagouda Patil
Age: 30 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 781 Sl. no. 392)
22. Shri Basavanni s/o Shankar Latti
Age: 60 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 644 Sl. no. 315)
23. Shri Dundappa s/o Shankar Latti
Age: 68 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 250 Sl. no.102)
24. Smt.Shakuntala w/o Sharad Deshapande
Age: 45 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 489 Sl. no. 237)
25. Smt.Shobha w/o Suhas Kulkarni
Age: 50 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no.759 Sl. no.375 )
26. Shri Nagappa s/o Basappa Mutnali
Age: 48 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 650 Sl. no. 321)
5
27. Shri Dundappa s/o Basappa Rayagouda
Age: 54 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 646 Sl. no.317)
28. Shri Balagouda s/o Shivagouda Nanjannavar
Age: 57 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no.258 Sl. no. 108)
29. Smt. Putalavva s/o Sadashiv Hipparagi
Age: 44 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 559 Sl. no. 280)
30. Smt. Savitri w/o Sadashiv Sankeshwari
Age: 54 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 492 Sl. no.240)
31. Shri Basavaraj s/o Shivappa Huddar
Age:60 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no.767 Sl. no. 382)
32. Shri Basappa Kallappa Chinchani
Age: 68 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no.376 Sl. no. 170)
33. Smt. Parvati w/o Basappa Chinchani
Age: 56 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 652 Sl. no.322)
6
34. Smt. Laxmibai @ Lagamavva w/o. Ramappa
Karaguppi
Age: 58 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 551 Sl. no. 276)
35. Shri Irappa s/o Kedari Labbi
Age: 51 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no.547 Sl. no.275)
36. Shri Shivagouda s/o Malagouda Shivari
Age: 68 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 253 Sl. no. 104)
37. Shri Annappa s/o Channabasappa Labbi
Age: 43 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 842 Sl. no.429)
38. Shri Appasab s/o Channabasappa Labbi
Age:50 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 613 Sl. no.301)
39. Shri Ravindra s/o Bhopal Hipparagi
Age: 38 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 648 Sl. no. 319)
40.Shri Nagendra s/o Bopal Hipparagi
Age: 40 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 649 Sl. no. 320)
7
41.Shri Sadashiv s/o Bhopal Hipparagi
Age: 56 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 647 Sl. no.318)
42. Shri Babu s/o Bhopal Hipparagi
Age: 54 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 481 Sl. no.231)
43. Shri Kalagouda s/o Iragouda Patil
Age: 48 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no.516 Sl. no.254 )
44. Smt. Shaila w/o Shatigouda Patil
Age: 51 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 537 Sl. no.268)
45. Shri Kallappa s/o Satteppa Chinchani
Age: 74 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 99 Sl. no.36)
46. Smt. Kashavva w/o Annappa Rayagouda
Age: 62 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 645 Sl. no.316)
47. Shri Basappa s/o Mallappa Masti
Age: 54 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 555 Sl. no.279)
48. Shri Shivappa s/o Bhimappa Hosagouda
8
Age: 38 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 490 Sl. no.238)
49. Shri Veerabhadra s/o Kallappa Nagannavar
Age: 54 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 379 Sl. no.171)
50. Shri Basavaraj s/o Mallappa Jarali
Age: 55 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 533 Sl. no. 265)
51. Shri Basavanni s/o Satteppa Labbi
Age: 52 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 442 Sl. no.212)
52. Shri Shankar s/o Mallappa Parit
Age: 34 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 721 Sl. no. 349)
53. Shri Tanaji s/o Basappa Shinde
Age: 62 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 118 Sl. no. 44)
54. Shri Kallappa s/o Krishna Shinde
Age: 64 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 411 Sl. no.194)
9
55. Shri Kempanna s/o Sidram Kotagi
Age: 62 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 658 Sl. no. 327)
56. Shri Alagouda s/o Iragouda Malagi
Age: 42 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 257 Sl. no.107)
57. Shri Shankar Chandrappa Tukkanatti
Age: 34 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 565 Sl. no. 285)
58. Shri Ishwar Basappa Masti
Age: 64 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 146 Sl. no. 55)
59. Shri Balagouda Paragouda Malagi
Age: 54 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 790 Sl. no.398)
60. Shri Adiveppa s/o Veerabhadra Latti
Age: 55 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Mmber no. 493 Sl. no. 241)
61. Shri Iragouda s/o Malagouda Hosagouda
Age: 51 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 629 Sl. no. 308)
62. Smt Sharawwa w/o Malagouda Hosagouda
10
Age: 78 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 828 Sl. no. 420)
63. Shri Iragouda s/o Shetigouda Rayagouda
Age: 38 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 541 Sl. no.270)
64. Shri Shankar s/o Dundappa Hosagoud
Age: 55 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 401 Sl. no.187)
65. Shri Sadashiv s/o Paragouda Yadagouda
Age: 48 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 733 Sl. no. 356)
66. Shri Chidanand s/o Kallappa Yadagouda
Age: 46 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 496 Sl. no. 242)
67. Shri Shivaraj s/o Bhimappa Desai
Age: 32 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no.773 Sl. no. 387)
68.Shri Rajendra s/o Shivagouda Nanjannavar
Age: 45 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member. No. 814 Sl no. 414)
11
69. Shri Raosab Babanna Nanjannavar
Age: 62 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 617 Sl.no.302)
70.Shri Shivagouda Bhimagouda Nanjannavar
Age: 56 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 218 Sl. no. 83)
71.Shri Paragouda s/o Shankargouda Patil
Age: 35 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 449 Sl. no. 217)
72.Shri Ningouda Basappa Hipparagi
Age: 45 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 592 Sl. no. 293)
73.Shri Raosab Bhimappa Kameri
Age: 53 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no.189 Sl. no. 72)
74.Smt. Savitri w/o Mallappa Bhangi
Age: 58 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 254 Sl. no. 105)
75.Shri Shivagouda s/o Mallappa Bhangi
Age: 38 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 475 Sl. no. 228)
12
76.Shri Sadashiv Bhimappa Kameri
Age: 58 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member. No. 447 Sl no. 216)
77.Shri Nagappa s/o Satteppa Parit
Age: 60 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 599 Sl no. 298)
78.Shri Jyoteppa s/o Ramappa Parit
Age: 34 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no 765 Sl no.380)
79.Shri Basavaraj s/o Jyoteppa Kameri
Age: 58 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member. No. 216 Sl no. 81)
80.Shri Basavanni s/o Subrao Mugali
Age: 72 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 13 Sl no. 8)
81.Shri Shivanand Babu Parit @ Kameri
Age: 50 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no.131 Sl no.49)
82. Shri Basappa Jyoteppa Madiwal
Age: 80 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 132 Sl. no. 50)
13
83. Shri Mahantesh Annagouda Hosagouda
Age: 40 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 388 Sl. no. 178)
84. Shri Shivanand Annagouda Hosagouda
Age: 32 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no.483 Sl. no.233)
85. Shri Chandrayya Shivayya Mathapati
Age: 68 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 163 Sl. no. 63)
86. Shri Prabhakar Maruti Parit
Age: 34 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 406 Sl. no.191)
87. Shri Pavadayya Madiwala Mathapati
Age: 60 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 491 Sl. no. 239)
88. Shri Mallappa Jyoteppa Kameri
Age: 68 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 53 Sl. no. 20)
89. Shri Iragouda Malagouda Patil
Age: 40 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 699 Sl. no. 347)
90. Shri Manikchand Adinath Amminbhavi
14
Age: 64 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 325 Sl. no. 141)
91. Shri Annasab Adinath Amminbhavi
Age: 66 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 324 Sl. no. 140)
92. Shri Kallappa s/o Basaling Karoshi
Age: 70 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 38 Sl. no. 14)
93. Shri Sudhakar Avvanna Athani
Age: 71 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 73 Sl. no. 25)
94. Smt. Nirmala w/o Malagouda Patil
Age: 56 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 202 Sl. no. 75)
95. Shri Shashikant Bhimappa Sankeshwari
Age: 34 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no.488 Sl.no.236)
96. Shri Paragouda Balagouda Masarguppi
Age: 50 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 403 Sl. no. 189)
97. Shri Appasab Krishna Navi
Age: 68 years, occupation: Agriculture
15
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 527 Sl. no.262)
98. Shri Basappa Rayappa Kambar
Age: 34 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no.408 Sl. no. 192)
99. Shri Dharmasingh Bahadursingh Rajput
Age: 46 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 560 Sl. no. 281)
100. Shri Ashoksingh Rajasingh Rajput
Age: 61 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 470 Sl. no. 225)
101. Shri Udaysingh Rajasingh Rajput
Age: 59 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 471 Sl. no. 226)
102. Shri Raju Shivagouda Hosagouda
Age: 48 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 772 Sl. no. 386)
103. Shri Shivanand Basavanni Shenduri
Age: 32 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 804 Sl. no. 408)
104. Smt. Jayashri w/o Bhimappa Kattimani
Age: 38 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
16
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 563 Sl. no. 284)
105. Shri Mallappa Basavanni Gundali
Age: 51 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 130 Sl. no. 48)
106. Shri Appasaheb s/o Gireppa Desai
Age: 62 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no.777 Sl. no. 388)
107.. Shri Basavaraj Mallappa Shenduri
Age: 38 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 115 Sl. no. 43)
108. Shri Chandusingh Gopalsingh Rajput
Age: 64 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 458 Sl. no. 220)
109. Smt.Avvakka w/o Satigouda Yadagouda
Age: 71 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 76 Sl. no. 27)
110. Shri Nijalingappa Siddappa Gadavi
Age: 64 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 9 Sl. no. 5)
111. Shri Basaprabhu Basavant Desai
Age: 35 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
17
(Member no. 519 Sl. no. 257)
112. Shri Chidanand s/o Peerappa Sanadi
Age: 61 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 113 Sl. no. 42)
113. Smt Surekha w/o Babugouda Patil
Age: 66 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 190 Sl. no.73)
114. Shri Shivanand s/o Basappa Kattimani
Age: 54 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 803 Sl. no.407)
115. Shri Bhimappa s/o Kallappa Nagannavar
Age: 40 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 657 Sl. no. 326)
116. Shri Bhimagouda s/o Rudragouda Masarguppi
Age: 26 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 789 Sl. no. 397)
117. Shri Sadashiv Basavanni Sheduri
Age: 54 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 676 Sl. no. 346)
118. Shri Nagappa Bhimappa Walaki
Age: 62 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 807 Sl. no. 409)
18
119. Shri Rajashekhar Basavanni Zirali
Age: 57 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 86 Sl. no. 30)
120. Shri Maruti Beerappa Kurabar @ Pujeri
Age: 55 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 632 Sl. no. 309)
121. Shri Shetigouda Satagouda Patil
Age:88 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 5 Sl. no. 3)
122. Smt.Kasturi w/o Basavaraj Madiwal
Age:58 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 800 Sl. no. 404)
123. Shri Basappa Virupaxi Khadaki
Age: 56years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 402 Sl. no.188)
124. Shri Ravindra Dundappa Utture
Age: 68 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 70 Sl. no. 24)
125. Smt. Mahadevi Revappa Belavi
Age:63 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no.704 Sl. no. 348)
19
126. Smt. Meenaxi w/o Satigouda Patil
Age: 52 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no.193 Sl. no. 77)
127. Shri Mahendra Santaram Malagi
Age: 45 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 502 Sl. no.246)
128. Shri Shravankumar Balappa Malagi
Age: 34 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 740 Sl. no.361)
129. Shri Ankush Yashwant Karanji
Age: 50 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 989 Sl. no.431)
130. Shri Irappa Lagamanna Jarali
Age: 48 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 335 Sl. no.146)
131. Smt Kaveri w/o Ramappa Kanthi
Age:50 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 594 Sl. no.295)
132. Shri Ajit Basavanni Bhangi
Age:50 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 562 Sl. no.283)
133. Shri Suresh Basappa Chinchani
20
Age:34 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 655 Sl. no.325)
134. Shri Beerappa Kenchappa Danagar
Age:60 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no.653 Sl. no.323)
135. Shri Bujruk Appasab Mulla
Age: 74 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 47 Sl. no.16)
136. Shri Satappa Dundappa Shendure
Age:62 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 48 Sl. no.17)
137. Smt. Jyoti w/o Balagouda Patil
Age:51 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 198 Sl. no. 74)
138. Smt. Bharati w/o Satish Patil
Age:53 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 255 Sl. no.106)
139. Shri Girish Satish Patil
Age: 28 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 539 Sl. no. 269)
140. Shri Sharadkumar Annappa Rangoli
Age: 58 years, occupation: Agriculture
21
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 534 Sl. no. 266)
141. Smt. Kanchanmala w/o Shashiant Thabaj
Age: 56 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 509 Sl. no. 250)
142. Shri Basagouda Gangadhar Patil
Age:52 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 206 Sl. no. 78)
143. Shri Suchet Shashikant Patil
Age:40 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 221 Sl. no. 84)
144. Shri Sanjay Basavanni Kameri
Age: 38 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 808 Sl. no. 410)
145. Shri Shrikant Gurappa Labbi
Age: 48 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 665 Sl. no. 331)
146. Shri Appasab Govind Suryavanshi
Age: 50 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no.750 Sl. no. 368)
147. Shri Sachin Basaprabhu Desai
Age: 35 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
22
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 757 Sl. no. 374)
148. Shri Ningappa Annappa Kurani
Age: 48 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 1096 Sl. no. 433)
149. Smt.Vijaya w/o Ravindra Patil
Age: 42 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 734 Sl. no. 357)
150. Shri Sanjay Satappa Desai
Age: 38 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 756 Sl. no. 373)
151. Shri Shivagouda Sidagouda Patil
Age:68 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 88 Sl. no. 31)
152. Shri Shivappa Basavant Koshti
Age: 64 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 213 Sl. no. 80)
153. Shri Usman Imam Bagwan
Age: 70 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no.139 Sl. no. 52)
154. Shri Basagouda Shivagouda Raygouda
Age: 50 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
23
(Member no. 229 Sl. no. 85)
155. Shri Shivagouda Babugouda Patil
Age: 58 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 140 Sl. no. 53)
156. Shri Basavaraj s/o Lagamanna Jarali
Age: 52 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 67 Sl. no. 23)
157. Shri Kempanna s/o Mallappa Chichani
Age: 34 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 3 Sl. no. 2)
158. Shri Pratap s/o Ganesh Kadam
Age: 62 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 77 Sl. no. 28)
159. Shri Prasanna s/o Basavaraj Patil
Age: 32 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 425 Sl. no. 203)
160. Shri Basavanni s/o Bhimappa Bukud
Age: 28 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 797 Sl. no. 402)
161. Shri Amruteshwar s/o Balappa Latti
Age: 68 years, occupation: Agriculture
R/O: Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
(Member no. 778 Sl. no. 389)
24
...Petitioners
( BY SMT. SUNANDA P. PATIL, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1. The State of Karnataka
Represented by the principal Secretary
Department of Co-Operation,
6th floor, M. S. Building,
Ambedkar Veedhi, Bengaluru - 560 001
2. Co-Operative Election Commission
Represented by its Commissioner,
3rd Floor, Shanti Nagar,
TTMC 'A' Block, Bengaluru - 560 027
3. The Registrar of Co-Operative Societies,
Government of Karnataka,
No. 1, Ali Asgar Road,
Bengaluru - 560 052
4. District Co-Operative Election Officer,
& Deputy Registrar of Co-Operative Societies
Belagavi, District: Belagavi - 590 001
5. The Returning Officer to the
Prathamik Krushi Pattin Sahakari
Sangh Niyamit, Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
6. Prathamik Krushi Pattin Sahakari
Sangh Niyamit, Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
7. The Executive Officer,
Prathamik Krushi Pattin Sahakari
Sangh Niyamit, Nerli - 591 340
Taluka: Hukkeri, District: Belagavi
...RESPONDENTS
25
(BY SRIS.S. HIREMATH, A GA F OR R- 1 & 3
SRI H.L. HAVA RA GI ADVOCATE F O R2, 4 & 5
RESPONDENT NO. 6 & 7 ACK NYR)
THESE WRIT PET ITIONS ARE FILED UNDER
ARTICLES 226 AND 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF
INDIA PRAYING TO A WRIT OF APPROPRIATE NATURE TO
DECLARE THAT SECTION 20(2)(A-IV) AND (A-V) OF THE
KARNATAKA CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETIES ACT, 1959 IS
ULTRA VIRES THE LEGISLATIVE COMPETENCE AND IN
VIOLATION OF ARTICLE 243Z1 AND 243ZO OF
CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, 1950 & ETC.,
THESE PETITIONS COMING ON FOR ORDERS
THIS DAY, T HE COURT, MADE THE F OLLOWING:
ORDER
Heard the learne d counse l fo r the petitione rs and le arne d co unsel for the respondents.
2. Both counse l submit that the issues in contro versy in the se petitio ns are square ly co vere d by the earlier decisions o f co-ordinate benches of this Co urt in the cases o f
(i) Shekappa s/o Shivappa Saravand and others V/s State of Karnataka, W.P.No .136699/ 2020 and co nne cted matters date d 28.02.2020;
26(ii) Chapparadahalli V ageesh and o the rs V/s State o f Karnataka, W.P. Nos.138960- 139031/2020 date d 11.03.2020;
(iii) Tadakal Wo man Milk Produce rs Co-
operative Society Limite d and othe rs V/s State of K arnataka and others, W.P.Nos.204109- 113/ 2018 and connecte d matters dated 13.03.2020.
3. Unde r these circumstances, these petitio ns are also disposed o ff in terms o f the aforesaid decisions in Shekappa's case, Chappar adahalli Vageesh's case and Tadak al Woman Milk Producers Co-oper ative Society Limited's case supra.
Orde red acco rdingly.
Sd/-
JUDGE CLK