Jharkhand High Court
(Letters Patent Appellate ... vs Rshegsat Poyisdeie Eyed Yay Dkert ... on 26 July, 2021
iN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
(Letters Patent Appellate Jurisdiction)
LPA No. 190 ef 2020
bhuvan Carrier Private Lid. A co any incor ror ated uncer the
ompanies Aet, 1986) having i uhh House, Bariatu
a, RO and PS-Bariaty, MH . District-Ranchi
ah its Director Ash ish Kumar Magan, aged about
Srl Surendra M han Magan, resident of 309,
sartrent, Dangratoli Chowk, PO and Ps-Lower Bazar,
301 . Nstrict-Ranchi . « Appellant
Versus
RShegsat Poyisdeie eyed Yay dkert Shesca york
Bherat Coking Coal Limited, tnrougt
y its Cheirmamn-currn-
ing Director, having is ¢
Wffice at Koyla Bhawan, Koyla Nagar,
eo8005, District-Dhankad.
&. General Mana very: Contr act Man agement. Cell, Bharat
vont Limited, having jts office at Koyla Bhawan, Ko yia Nagar
atid PS-Dhanbad 826005, District-Dhanbad.
ye
:
:
PO and P p -- TYhanbad &
Respondents
With
LEA Na. 197 af 2020
gs, SOPL TCPL BP (Vi (A Joint Venture Entity, having 2 its office
Kumardhubi, PO an ' PS- Dhanbad, District. Dhanbad S2k8eks
ay brane! Authorised Signatory Ajay Singh, aged
S years, san of She Suresh Singh, reside: nt of Flat No. 18A8,
2, The Empire, IGA Gurusaday Road, FO ame
, Dis str ici Kolkata 7OOOLS (West Benge al},
a ov Appellant
ee
Coal Limited, through its Chain ;
iF ng 2 Directe . having its office at Royle Bhawan, Koyla Nagar,
S.Yranbed 826005, District-Dhanbact.
Baer al Manager, Cortract Management Cell, Bharat Coking
Limited, having Nice at Koyla Bhawan, Koyla Nagar, PO
1 PSTyhanbad R&6005, Iistrict-Dhanbad.
wt
> A
Respondents
{Heard through V.C on OS & 14" July 2
on
PRESENT
HOWBLE MR. JUSTICE SHREE CHANDRASHERNAR
HOW BLS MR. JUSTICE RATNARER BHENGRA
he Apoeliantis) «Mr. Sunmet Gadodia, Advocate
iin both cases}
or the Respondents : Mr. incrajit Sinha, Advocate
at x 3 x
THY Pyegd he orsyeeean
fin OLN OSes}
LPS No. LEG af BEAD
WER
LEA Na. LRT af AGRE
JUDGMENT
'A Van 14/07 (208) Pronounced on 26/07 (ec we sy peat ry uf, Tribbuwan Cerrier Private Lid. fin short, TCPE) and Mis. SGPL TCPL BP GV) Rn short, SGPLOIV]) have que stinedk ality and validity of the order of forfeiture of HILO ars debarment for five years from participating in all tenders Reated by Rho Coking Coal Limited fin short, BOOL). A learned Sin wie Judge of sig Court dismissed the writ petitions fled by them holding that ROL acted within the bounds of law ard has taken action against the defaulting bidders under NIT stipulacamns. BACKGROUND PACTS:
wee An e-Tender Notice for the werk of hiring of HEMM for removal of overburden, extraction and tr ansportae on of coal m Seams af AKJ-SIMLA patch of amalgamated East Bhuggatcdih-
Simlabahal Colliery of Bastacolla Area was issued by BOCL on PS PET OPE TR PPh ox eta ey dye sey wk Ey ye WwW oy eyes NE vere:
O86 .O1.O018, The estimated cost for the project Was Ruupees Two Thousand Two Hundred & Lakh, Ninety-one Thousand, Five Hundred and ty}. The bidders were required to upload scantied nopy of the documents and furnish other reqaisi ite informations online in respect of the requiremenis under eligibility criteria, Various clauses in the fender doeurment provided that a bidder unconditionally mast accept all the terms and conditions a including general and special terms and corulitions, Integrity Pact and other conditiens. A bidder was allowed te modify and resibr anh fhe bid befere the deadline for submission of tender and perm ited és withdraw the bid online within the end date of bid submission.
-clanse 2 to clause- 12 of NIT provides that if a bidder withdraws the tid within the end date of bic submission his EMD ned pote:
bebe fee waft weer r anes ween vee ey RL IY adhere the eerie adii be refunded. However, for withdrawal of bid after the onc date af bid submission the bidder is required fo make a request in writing te the employer and the requesi may be ac cepted til issue of work order / LOA, but EMD will he forfeited and the bidder will be enon debarred for one year from participating in all tenders by BCACL
37) 3 } x a of GS 3 iP x ee ef a ma ogee' and o 'hading ar x & .
z Se S & Bs ~ z ee TPR LPA Rs. 2 SB ed ¢ x 3 $ x ders ¥R ates ua aN OLS PS a smtrever be SP as at il i LOWE ke adc '.
aa to all € the bi ¢ cow R i x the of ¢ OF Su x y x CE z PS z d wa DER
- MOTECE INVITING TE = A erred 2 x ¢ inte Bice ' can to k x 8 SOrtrn i 8 vt EY ° < ~y :
a .
' The it eS fear:
& $e, &, 6 as EL FPR CES od : v i of sianie ES 3 <} Le as " a rey i Go fad ed 4 fn US, oy en Me sree pS By Se and < SHE PER phen frit, ?3
AD % CR
--
deter i 5 PERS it FE be '.
CUMENT ce € g lity BR 3 = 3 & "
we oe ae = hee Kenn £ ?
y nee on a > igt oy 5 t periert Sy ong of Documents te be uploaded by & MATOR urine © 5 eS . Werking Captind Neate:
Uieags sed A. Wark Ex fCONFIR 8 *:
, an, a < % es By oth, : 3 & & own ty : : B 8 "a | : : os iM eh : : et t : . ten, " . ' Ka t Me . > SF : 1 ge : ' Be % : : ae ; - he . : ee ge : ' op Se te : : 5 , 2 yt 5 : wee > : * ie : ot : > x, . : . ey * A Re " é £ : : 1 @ : © : e mF : : # 7 : Pe : : a tk : t + : we : : we 8 : : : he : 5 : ' met ; 1 ge ' : hy ee : : : OD + be : a 2 : : + Et 5} : lot "pa : : : > : Me, : oe : : : the > ' oe : :
2 « om, 1 Yee, : 2 *
2 teh : BS : as : -
: : Lown : :
: ; : 8 : XG ee : : ' : _ ' po 76 Bing, z ; : le es : 3 & Se : aed oe * 4 we ey SS ht « : 1 Be B oh tH fe 'he Soe : : s (og ey : We png 4 nh goe. : : a ic ne x ~% ey z a : Be ne 8 Bs : " = fs tg . ® | ee Ge a ' : eh - i Mag f ts ma we 5 . : 2 Se a & we on . Be es ies : wg mh te we Ayn Ne : we : . , ye * ¥; : . $e Lg » rd : Se ye ay Sapa, Sook 5a : at ee nd 1 fe 2 pe , ep by : a er) 1 fe LB 3 i % : : : to ' . St Re foe : ie hye o i Zo : oe note id : < Be : + ee Le : "nd Fran : oS : 4 ' ' * ' wer : * "ae 'nt we , "eh . ¢ ' Be ge 7 7 OS ye 3 Sh te 5 B we 7 he ed : <6 & Ky y : Ke me 1 Lop Q re fe 7 Re: 5 tty ' gtd cee a et oe Se + ed :
Xx + ORS bee * + wen Vine x Pome oed ge ' & : 1 Mes : ¢ + gs Be % bse bea op :
fet cE os + ge ee we eS 1 ' m 7 & > of : te on iy ee a Be BG 7 Me : 2 & z wo. 1 Ba: & : eg 5 gay : - mb x Inet og 2 4 : Ed 7 . «Bp Og omens) ; : mf a : 7 Sin % ee Be Be > : 8 he 3 Pat re me Be : gy * #4 gens ee 4 Bren ay LE * ¢ a ee 1 wt 2 eee 9 & ve . bad t ees os * hy Fton, ' z % 4 2 % vee Ly tae ee ' % * . 's . 3, < Z , a, *) ' +o oy + oak . we we a vo wot Bf Rf BR ee nm ; whe w int Me ys + Be - Me we Le i gy. bene ; int pet won % be oS By egee ay kek 2am & Pet soe oh oy Ss a he wm re pe ag 3 Ly se @ Nod we oo he dB 'nd es Goo. 4 fag oh he a 3 g "es fy hon > na ie % "oot alt 38 ER PDE *.
S. vat LEA Ne, 3 "
e xen SES.
yoo fats avaeyase O BVALUATION OF OF BID AN.8
Pets 4 see rdeteees evens der Stakes EUR é Crue ne ' 3 vyseeae eRe BO "~ OPENING x "
¥ i ~ x SEAT > ° S, GP.
forse-G re
-
Test ve re, 'ne yaa & oa % Eexxe & wee ee eee eee ee eer eee eee wiceve ey y zg Neation and Withdrawal ef Bid we z x a Veaeiiel & > 8 g fase "54 Cau 32 : Mad ids fhefrauoa! af B fae WY a Onl As thefrawal of Bids Wy BLS A } Efe B. Q ey eeyeee Dee eR eee % tes LEASES.
te wees cetee ns > Se ey, 2 iF "3 Tamae-Jt y £ Clause I 6 > Cleuse- IS per raceveeyaned wseevee peeeees + c eS faus aR o ie a ot a a oo gs y i LEA Ra, 180 ¢ idgders & fastructiens Te SY REPOST ~ iS SY AON.
RITY/PARNE ?
7HO SOCL .
s Clouse. Fe yrt MS rep s 3h + 3 SLT 4 ne od + 38 ad x t suit e uring or ef & rey en. Th "
23re hy of * r g 3 of GF MMSE a .
y x b a t & = t y x "> ele ered: wed ost nm cn tt im itn, "e oe & vied "4 BE x, weererevepecceerseges ne % anne 3 : rr a & ceceseneaseconosogees j avon i id && on 'o an % See eed, © a 2k » me Fe oe me " :
oe : t a ae : : * w wa @ it : i fod "Sb : : mm aed BS : Rest a a od a : i 2, mm & y wae 0G nea ey : } eal ot ' mi : : : raeac tent ef we : : : Sat gent ue : : : pny %, we e oe : : : - 4 oo ood wee fd | : i i own % Ses : : a : : ; z % ky : i Ge : ; ~ t wes | t i to i t res 'not ve fot: : i go : i 'end? Lent . we : 3 rs : i a oe, 2 we HG SF | ne a es ' : a | i ts a a fe Be | ~ a " j om ps Oe: Ce ey : : 'ad Oe we sd ee : ot rene fost 'ak woe. : pan he ty he & real $ ae a 4 wen a, ex ; oe ~~ "Ag ne } tn: a5 alae tee et : be 5 ie : ceecetowntedpases ie ae : Se RE ee eeccsteneceeeeed i & re ', : : ro : h tn ws eB ; eh ee Le F : ; pes ot aed en : : % a Pe my & ¢ : : = Eo : 5 fet ' we Som Be rick 'ps yy Sef eProoureme € } mi Bid Qoeaing SY hw 2 eR ,
-
ES x SVQ % on RSS ov PA Ne.
Me, Caeaes € 2° Cause Netic > oS "el oa ae RR LPA Ra. T80 of 3 i With PMaNe, 19 af BORG With RATE x 2 WS 4 "er "ant weed 'nt SUS UPL % % 2 oo w Wek LEA Be, POT of BOER PES EQN fet OY a?
RISE! edie.
as Ks "eee 2 Of > present Hie ¢ % u UNE BID PER BIDDER :
PROWLER E. e Ae of 3 ee fees Ok PRESENT PROCEEDINGS Doe Ee PR ef Ie as ory ar rue 3 RS x > & bor sped Sepert sey, . wee doe arent ; :
ip & ¢ : ; s " feet fs a & ge reg fo tm ge gL fy we vgs , i @ bore wee al yf me "we ot 5 A yen he feos, ot non : Leneet rg "oe na af wy od oo, ee we a ace? ered sbeot ey yo "eet ee se « ot ve Bo 'het iP) fees as im wheat we seers re a freee oni we 7 hp ~ he oe werd abeet of 4 % xe ret '4 4 a % . oe , 'eaeee, , oe aA go a Ke, eee, ss ? "tend ah qeeed ~s ne, as % Inet 4" . 7s fo veers vee, reed otoct "tere z, seed we 6 ; wi eet es ? ; "9 tori seed Son CS ~ ao Yi res aA 5 wef "i lA nd 4 mS net CS we at oe ga eet rei aes o, xn as ry a oe lad home 4 t load ¥ me Dep tee £3 ge os xz as ine wee gee Fa 'hed ad tet ot ° WA oot vee te Ss So fer tee an we oe wepes eteee ver Ly ia Sn ye "4 Gp feren, ws ad we bee Ls oy to os eet ty neon on at wen 4 (te 'res po ee ote fee eet oe " oes Gb shoes cal ow Oe a gn oe tats oon ve end
3 ao ns rr, meee EM Hg ga od red on ree fe tet we nA get aed poe, on, aloes By weet "
z ; Y wes ied 'nid bow 9 fares, a At weet ans fat? im a3 m3 aeeed, eed a. odoei, aed, vo? ors m4 a haved, 'af Mh « we a an wes f ge rt yee rn "et ae Nad "sees one ae Ne Pood gon qeend, 4 yen oe : Cae we vn poe we WE, we a At when " F Se ~~, wat 5 aA ween, seed Lo oe ty ne jee fs af eet ¢ ee pop one et oO iad! " Zhan - a eheet At a oo ts wee oy Seat zy oN + et een ye ped Af we sont wpe we et ae 1, a poo ws 4 oe 2 OL * yo aes hai rs veer ve seen Not vo wei, we "Aes et ae ye cd " nw oo Le aol pa ae * hot we ~ fo pea a x we toe et ee rn. x a IX ae gt chook pie ee tne, oe * a a no dee wt "a mm ge of i ee me ee gy SR or 4 OS " ie oh, % oa reen, Sod, yooh sa Lo bows ot panne . a) 4 Noe ' bot 7 'S ep ae Lb os re nee ™ os mm ate 4 ~~ Saget ree we oy a chpod yen, re Lk wed, ernen 5 oheet ~, yee) "rh om ¢ Aten, Load gs ny bn : os nok io edt 43 ae peed eB rr & wh mo fee we veeey re ne oe rs 'nef pet plosie Bd Ja Ww eos ay deed ot ry ms aoa we 4 « ww, Ww steed " ne ' Freee fy "ee wh . seeet Ch 'ad aad Hee fed, gh a ed % ae perk ae eee a7, a) 'ee wey rn, Z we xt gt xf 4 le "5 ha om raed on net \ ws te cot " wS " 4 seen we sana we "owe 4 ne Segoe os oy: ed Tevet i we it Oe Pal tno he fe eh EG oe, bog ieee ve ws Fast pon met oh ees . x 4, fy tow ye pond oad an g s ae fe 4% GT? ren nested 5 44 aw bag! + 4 oes he a ee on L a tO ped y ao UO on is x" ston gem yo etsy & ma yy 4g 'eo eda pet ot g sane; ' ¢ > ef ny es pe we hoe coma " yond hae 4 , $ co ra . Z Sepei A re " ' ty my Le ted no en Sat x * i oe wet yor wt Be pees ge ve 3 "et og vA ae 5 oe ny Ay het 2 ~ a fort its pate ot oS oe : i bes 5 yer 90) ry ae $ Sot m * < toad, ee Qs beet nar ar, <eN, al faped, nope ' shat wre ~ booms eed ns poles fe yo, sheet S Let wn ' toni, z daw yoon wae wes reed ea vores t Le pee, wwer . Seat 5 ae) * a4 'nag ne Neat t* 4 we ars Me 3 m oo oy er obind ws a Lees gen oS raved ree gS: bows % ae a ~ Bp os fi on dees, ans a fy pet rea we + "pet nny " ah % n 7 "4 % th oe ot Ww lA " py baad * font 3 i, F LD ! oo aS 3 , ns "% a Seas wd ' tft uy aa v7 % fo ¥" om re * a sdood an i we wat soon send ° sped x bad a pen wee 2 ; wet See " vane iy Cae We "sy we % vend os hp " % Oo weet . Ly ae be saad rn ont we ww at ms SS 3 Nat oes Senet ~ oo, peook 4 nee ot we Na it wet ne thee we fy os ~ wh ws ae we, Pea ig Sones ne ot a oo, get oe th we chet vee 'ad tent on L3 esa ae : ° re one ~~ oot rot We teed i ate tn, t be A. ye " nA in ot ret id oe Aart Ponbes og wY m oe ne ves ° ae weed 4 Se oe nw bey : bre, Qe hoe ' Ly ~ 'nat Le poh , 23 ~~ orn Ca et mi net eer y re a we sett we ved job oh wy a > yee om ons cee ad te bass rags we va tee he a Sn with Sows ween ps " we hes few, oy wy nak " pen ws Not pee Gp ane ih A vten toe, Se 7A os food a "rt pat i "5 weed aS Lape rhe set a por 2 yond ai ie : hon " aook 4 pent hs SS ne te > ih s , wa " ws ot B gt o ~ ie eee, seeed, om oa x . oe i a ay ce] 4 steed "ee ia ' 4% nt wr aN st o , ae ~ fad o, bet Fe %, w id ond, on Pia ms fe ne we ot , Neb et Lagoos wo ars we wt tse Ne 0S mn ad ake eed re a + tees ; gy on ne an an wuts Oy eg ie wor ana wy crt " ne dad oe 4 roe an a ws ie we % sped ahs ia ow on, ce a ere g Qo we ", we tet ge A nee) awe sy we Newt snd. 64 . nt a ped, a to ow te "ay £4 ot chet lan ae of 2 wa ne ode mS orn, pot * nt ions wf 44 wet t ah ae now, ee ry ms Dk we Sit 'oll ween 3 yes ne rt oe cael a oft "~ Youd feared ew . te Cet An wid dpa 2 ont Gs et pet ee ES ost ted tote Oo % KS " veo yore steel ve eet ot Ww ret ay "Tr wend o j ft a3 f core, ' oe ys ow 5 . . Tes ea, cee! ' a' oy A wf wo, Cl & oe of ny OB as cet poe ce ares oH ¥ po wn et oh, ws . ons ry re he 1 'vee a etned w as ee we <4 of we ay ~~ tag A bees Ge a ross on rel fey yet park reek ", font ax a - wo yes a me hat we rt BO het on vend £3 ww ~ od re oad : ~ net & et we ns we nt 'od a3 Sd wf eat ww os Y teh eel os SA vat ai Tm C2 pes "OY a Q bees
"4 Ad ; oe Po ae - $a oe von oe feet ¥% a4 ones feat ~ : pos " sent : z Ly Me = ~ seed, be ve fad 4 " Ay vere en ee pk a 'nat the ~ eyes Sad ee 6g .. a3 ny es a a) wt ne a mm oe eneed, eben i. Sad Ae 3 oa a "ad. Sone a shot owt aad we wy on ot pa Oe pa we, med he oe on : pa obec a 4 ' ow, on ~, te gt gn . Sede we "i on, wet Bh 'nal 3 ee pon 'nd ae ae o ot RM ae Lp w oy S on tories gen od ror ~ ~~ me tS ih check ow my os 4 eo a, ' yee tat we "s ed hee ey me Ne AL ry 4, tat At oy ww nt ts , ent * roa a a ot pase oot ~~ Nee? ; Nt $ a, ted re ea ta "a et wm eal me A vthod x hex a3 cr ot mo Ves tA Mie bet ms mK me rae Q Sees t Benet " ' a one! BS ns yee ; cbod ; ee ; « ~ we fe eee ned at or sede, pee me a ar tak Ky my hed x o Levee wy bod 1T oe wey rt res, vate pea x ; Woe wf. we ~ 4 peal, Ps A ed ton : en, Fat m Ly 'nef a nS od eho ety oe hie the ' eat 3 ve te oe Rr, '4 Oo Sf iy ams) ae Ae 4 a a wy ne rs "5 a ebb Sek os. i" pee het ne soon tude we he 1h nae! fae a Looe Sad Mee CoA * % a * 4 o $ Sh eae By a oo Whig we ee ' aed as o, mS mo OR 'ye = ee xo fot ay "3 yen fet ~ i," et as oe we tos red wed ro) ~ ake, 4 bed, yond Co 'nea? seed ie, , ayer 4 Soe rd font I, ane teal : 4 - ot 4 Leo yn om on : wet < 4, ee me Be BOE & & gy ™ G Cow ee mw BE eg * Bo mB pee os orn, of yews et ow ¢ wee Lt NO niet ae Me 2 t yee, reed, fee ge, te 4 Nee ve & 3 : reed, am Laat aa LA ot bes pee as " . ee Aa . a ae aS fon Whoa, i «ped we vee a bet, +e, oypes pA yh od Set ae a where any see Sat ros) Pie * ae s ; CS 07 choad a a aed % % vt oo wk rows 2% Lope oe oad % wer veer oS ne Oo "& os Sood x a es ; oS 4 rt sod vert 2 Y viet ' ded he ot OD oe re ve uA iieed wen - ohoed he OO Se el vor we Te ee ee 7 orn om bes ao wid a oes oe ag A "en ce hei 0S mm wy 3 aA Gp oa oi aw ped ne ted AY + wee! Set Yon sored a 'pat, ta nt oe oo ve an rh nw ~ pont m vanon "ee ni "eae ond wt bw ra KG ay vee dot hod a> oo 5 Ge a C3 * at "ey 'ant a , ve gia ~, had Ah Me iad 43 ees ye on ve o : ot ot re f ot at seed on, At pa pace ob 'nat Gen "Lf Lh Ly be 'or Ferme, * tote, on ot oe atone OO bet ET wh eC Ay chet at pc : os on os a ge os x " a he "nd woe bes ~t . ga Wachee wo ba ey ap om fedod tee Bd ve ede, ried aos ah, a S seer ob oa . eee ie et t3 ee sehee oy ee sed law et ae et om Whe "mt Boo & mB OG 2 a mm "Be Be ce Be Xe Boo 7G Dh ome " fete rome, EE *s "a So bed ee mA on ae ee cet fe GS a Oe o feet Ge a
- 4s we , 5 a, tf wo oy. 24 ty ws we rs we ae ot he ne a Set yeh ne gee ww te Pa nnd? o opted. ': "a tan ys 5 oe u ris . wee + needs, ne ' Ge ' pera Sof yen vn ay v ene ot oe ve 4 of, red ~ eens th Lt we i ene ot ted: ; Be th ene wy, ON i ct g oS led on ° oor ry awed wa ty yes , . vent " ~ ' Peon ted, a) ry RA os wow, mt 4, ~ word ne 63 poeeb we 'ae leet Loot "4 . : pen, yond ae 4 nh in, £7 £4 ne ey ae wt mm 2 oo mw 2» BS 2 me we we stare ped ee . tt '. to. wened, ran Mery eeeet es wee ted all , Soa nt * ~ > ee Parads sed 'fat : . 5 a ze é ae oot po , , , ev) porn te me ft Con, "Ss aS ts nh yt sd o, "3 chook Sat 2 or then wet -- » an wy dew tote te cont apse oe 4 Oh hi we Ee j 'nf We Sno vet ye 5 coe ted a w we o ee ee oy ee as boon bo an wont seed ted oe one ee OS Spek ey ae ES ie xd ae ae . 4 mw RP or, We ke ee wee et ge on Lek EE a eet a, ap oe Dot red reds oo wn omy os 'nana mw ns + eat fed yhoo wood % ee x os Ye a * an 4 weed, a We 'edt oe LNG Neel a7 , 4% AP fs ne, a rh 2 us te. oy oe ween . as gt ~ set edt fog rf z Seer Ly hes Bet ets oe ae vee fey oe Z Bt «, © | £ Ss a an? mom BOS ee pi ¥ cy ws eet ak a3 es veel freed, rs, ge "ee Pd aS a a4 wr e pied shoot aa ~ "ad o & ba re ry yk Ie oa 4 ~ ' Zi a rend th oooh raped ood * oh * aes 2 ° need = tLe wn 2 i neti, oe % Lo we na? ey fore, may : deed ny & 2 anne, fhe oy ae af verd "eet . ps noe ¥ Cee baht we £ ned nee we x; ie 5 a yee OS ye eS A gl et oa be MG gS Oo ae neh i 5 > tree yee auth pon Ay we tee, Soe ' tat wn fot iy yee Nbee ft oh ash pet eee me he ip, ued Ge Ke oS is .0 » a ont % fet eee Gh wed nape hoa rsd a ned vet qeeet feben WL, weed pe a yee OG het pt, Leo LS des fet ve caret et . ae eed, weed, Boed, te, an £4 ey "a ': ve wa vem : Shed . i iy 7 a bap need? Whe hi Uo 3 po ye oo I oe ce, goed: 7 os wood adeed oy, ed ty fea ween oe Sopot vied fhe thon 2 or wv os 23 wee, yer Ale, to pee bes wee Lh bry ape wa oe 4 re ree, n oe ca 4 id vee aed qeoed Sout ~ 4 we : "ae tied rg near a oe gent $ on unt taped, in fee yee " a oe steed t & tent oy ot on oo inde os 6 seed fe "* Se ed wt 4 z age fy ws eo fee, Lx Neel? me ay in ve Bie ay sere x Sf eh 1t4 beat ' Meg 4 5 é ty bewi & L) deed brows yeod, rn fond ¢ g ga ne 4A wer 7 Og eves, ' nape. ; goed, s ws teed uf vert ws Ee feood " res Zs, os. SZ z sere "Ls gees reg a porn at ae' ~ 7 om te oe ot Seog wwe TE Ly yt Jeet ; tort, the ree eyes phd "nt see y Ay tole * --, rm wee on ea nes:
he GA ot OG wanee :
. aoe) ed a3 peed 4 on ns hn vom Geet PS Me eee ° v 5 pout ws Saat Ag ek penn é ¥ as rn ' a weet ce ont ; any gh a yet nt we A+ Ve! ore : ZL ¢ ? ee ag " ay Pane wt om oe ten Neg I Yo a mora ee eT iG Fo YW Sp ~ gees ey we . peed en ms wet, y fm we peed. y 3 Bey "nat eyed eed fh wed "s ns ri , * ns "3 pet xfs ny . ved : i verre " ef Lan a Be rea ao ane beet * vet i "
wy Q roel feat oS tet ree 25 te ym «TER , ™ on * 4% pod GA be 'at nd ~ cn oot "
ww fs £9 ra : Pats eS pn reg wt oes ~, ° Seka Meat oa we te oe ot we mm ; pee, wood sett Loeee wii y qeoed oS + yee os yt , ret vee ~ o at 'ait * Oe nts "Fy & % a be 7 EL we poae pare fa wm EG on ork : bY oo att 4 ga ' at baal we weet Ay ' w4 aes "ws , 4 tenant om a3 ed peers ee rs Pa deat wet n3 ee 'sg ot "emp He) boot f ee wack 3 e es ~~ wy ~ g 'ae Jeo, sheet ree fee a ae +e ¢ tant " we poe ad me ome Lpest ra Sne me + rad ~ ws ~~ eee , ad as ge ont i iw oe ty "
o vow ae a See py ont pe ening ed oy ir a4 nn " Seer hy. a a era aod, neeer ed pe . . ry Ca agate we at "4 ry cea' ony ~~ f ' re ae $ rae Lt see "73 "t mo oy Sh hed fs ts ae He ft
- my oo cnn OS ei wa a * a3 ' 7 Me het Sd Be ne on hee YD ae, cet poe, ee o een a x4 of Set we ye ry a, ~ a, fh oe wn, a See ne oe pee we elon o% % Spore pron ae " fe foe, ane : Lg. or reas 3 on ne we, ww ae Ce Sout rye ed he * aoe, er :
= peek ed ene smpcenet ree ne we bos, $e "
ae ws ge a3 rd een "eel en, we re in wn ~ mae ed in xo ane Me ahee! 63 pene je gn bene ow , ee fi ' aod we ee ators ce pated, aepek * oe nS ge wed 5 oboe nr > St wh) feo Sl ' 5 eyy te A re vot eri m, Zo ees ech GS a Soa we oe we, ww eet on m sock a sped eens os od wi % " wi a re on mS oe : eed bon %& feel os a nm » ; wt ine wd fort te We oy we a ey ry we o3oe WG ped aa Sneit n w eos
4 lag anon, wrt yt % Cat A wed, ptedn, Sepoed ae fn ree a Pat 'anni, ered Ls 4 wet QP er one Sood, ryed poret py Oe, f By 4 a" mo 2 mm me . * ie feet IS enet eee, 375 eee' 4 Mey % 7 We ae rey BE oor 4 chad fh oe : yer ts n fated, % i 4 vy had 2 tote hd f, - ee / eal wee, sewer, mene a on 'eoget es ot woes eort wis Senne vores att bon See meee wy ee, "eed? peed, ws wy :
4 2 o ,, Lo fae. 4 wet 2 me . % Y 'as 4 oad ia eet Koo ep et x a we ft haaas ~ nat rR J joke bebet Ls See eet a men ea ars ree " 'hed veg ret 'ae he thw yor a sored vet bs reds ws yeh 2 be, p ey teri ve "Ay yet et yee 0, Z % te . XZ yf i, eb ee itt oe yrds eh, ots tne apa, on Sh ren % ue ye wed, oo " Z tg .
x 2 of 2D ER! ¥ $ IPR N £ S.No. 2 3 g ref ES orn ne "
OV roth aE n = y < re LM We sh we rs on £ » dds RUIGE~ sh £ ih st i i b Q ~ the 34 { yy < 3 Ae '\ meat 1, 2S er ey penne 4 x fds al se Yr sek slats wk £ a ond a SPLEEROPES oft yas cone ¢ fare & < i Py £ SRB ae LPa Re 287 . rye .
a % x Lh "es ae ay Wy ¢ : j AK GS & 45 tad pod ch vee ges we. tne. he ore % S eapee eee fe He "at Lt seed taps aoa fs oh ie he Ee, hog tp SO a ame we So oy 4 , ye & to a wig eto
3 Kz ae e% ted fe "ne re, ', 3 we & ww " ed we - fees beat 23 o. A ee 4 eee feet a ts w tn ree ny nee hye " Swe 8 ae} a a", Pi oree a * wie ts aed ta Mo pee oe nd ~ "
ane: en he aed e cant Sapnet eee ~~ wel pee ' alt ee pe wom on % mm & a aed ve pet geod we OS Fae yer ' ee re A 3 on t at ; Ot! we, tee ot "ad be vem BY won aN - aed Samed. oe, 'et A LOO Om ete NG. a stot Seat anped oe re reed ms ee eA vet Rene om ot bent on ns at ' yee, on pen fees eee eee denoe Cnet bee ~ & y eee at Bh ged. Sad we aot On: om ' , a6 on hy
4. oy wud, : ae " a 4% oS oe ed oy A Be deed 7% aye wee fe ng ve os we ww . oy caren at hae Sod et Sat ne tee to ne bes ms ~~ L bed a, e ? tele Af frm. v ted, ne bes oe pene enn Ss * 2 cone " Si ee -
a ke tant dl % ms Ewes ae o cone nare TOPE av s "
stiry aks i OY S07 4
3. SRSCEELS at rt a pee ¢ Le en the Rots em on nea! a ue wee Te fo Ze RITES seb anchign y t Q of BONN Pies} % ak XN Me ARS eget y gps mS Re 2 y y & partic of oh dat ay the 3h in iy a ° z x LER eed x S pes X suite ted fro r 4 ia YEE i ° ned fn re nee, we ss XS bat soa er Pr 3 ned % APPT st a Ne <4 3 i Byret Ve, 2 ;
"y i a, hi Yb yhuvan £ rik Ps $ ?
pert ¢ & oth ¥ $f Paty Seth gent Lee op copne, 3 3 dont ns dey vee af ery . anne , Cree, ed OS mt mt yee whe " , oh 4 saat set i Me od cee ow we mmr on Seg ya of hs sg eS te were 8H fa oe ced tan a LG ye gu * een OS a sped rw yee oS a rt fea, pe wet woe BS OT ey fy ar "Bow Rot + teat ye 6 th, Ue.
oh crane oe feed Tones, "ty Qo ee, int pe gt seed hag wy 7, oh chek ged ded ban Pop we 0 vor Gy pe 4G Gt ; at ' pe" on oe wed Bert B ppd et wee beg 075 Bet ES ae wt te atee APR x Tribhuy $ dual PUG Fee AVE > an 34 ik ire iS z hs fet y Be 4% yon, ot COE ws :
A Sup} Bie O ig os we wn t ae bt Ie ; -
cae ¢ 3 z > £38 wt aPh NOTE Sapo, re, Seat eet spe suck ae Mo here x PPR Bee ret rfe ie 3 4 fee % 288 of 2 & a YY of BOND LPA Noa. 22 os ap at ue % FEA POS & ~ rot C ay S € AY ats } he roto uurde te gt a eet ¢ 4 oh on weg oe eet dead ye, + sp £4 te iS bet ¢ ot Ls ww Mo wes a to wm wed é peon, gee ro oA Seal Ty ao ny " 5 Ly oS aly pe tee, bee wae, aoe a wey cad Me 'tet ewes os repre ey we sped % oe, Lo pew wee 'tee 3 ay we t wey ws Sed the oy bend ny rd 'ne ro ree Le Core ro ron et 'ae aebed nee ohn 'net a cogent . 0 at "ot g a o aS weed ree, Lf ok od erk sad shoot iy nee oe hd ee cn on if 'ae a sheet 43 wo Hh nS te a * penn, Ma rym sheet ° t4 Sent ipod eo igs at ae ve oe ih Sed wea oS "
y Be ee "eee " %: a Se vag, et coat Be toh ed bee hes "3 eq ree See? be, rg th fy re oH wr - ce) ee oe OuLt oe vs " Leet 'ced x z on beh ws aed ne ree "apes we , on mom a eyes , ' Le yee on ry z. ere oe Sens a gen we eee oe ' * fs on CO pe eye ee, we ng " weg sea , on rm "
oy a ae Ww Sew? ws $ gS ra Cp is an ore ny be ae yh ore pegs the be bow . wey vot fo ite of ved x we ye get ow + ¢ et ps ee 'ale % reek 4 "4 Ae "eat : By ft, ; ee. @, "ow bees fea hea : vee Co ee ove A Se 65 he te a Bp eed eet hod oe re oA wm 2 peeeh oot nt nt wha mrs ope weet yee bf wm 'nd " rae) vee pe wees, ae see sdeos me on he m Gf ae "eae WwW C3 m m% Lh us "aed, ayes Py 50 novia wot 0 a os, £4 z wm ee -- & ® GA, © hoy Be go Ee on i ES "eg gow 2 be , d Pea 7 é oe v a LP vet Peel ° wpe ot Sed * werd Or we i me by et am @ & mm TS & 3 a4 nan © Sos = ¢ . ht ' ¢ 'Zo é = me, $y . Z me Mm 5 ~ ", Sane ne gee a ne, pane ae in wea Seat x ~~ cyan] we x3 oo, "hoe oes 4 vo 4 pee ps ap ws Seat ie 3 ed wy te a ty reed Be wo wet 5 Nnae we den {ty vee aed ~ + . wt % wo ed os ~ oe, yoo we 7 oA 3 a5 x ¢ ty Fest "son e ne ~ es po a eM on Oo ' s vet tet cae pt yew ~ ms ager! on oe YY Fas aon woe rey yr ead aon ayad pact Mad Newt we at + fee, Niet pee LA on ow ya ora' Y we wes "ar gerne aM pos fy a rn " ~ t 'oe? on x bet pet on oe hind 3 a ' nt be, < e ws ie Ww span v7 re n £ ed r"% ot ad 2 wt epee > Sag es mo we ye fo, . Sit poor, Vs st fee phon : rn pt os Sent ne 05 res owe, ae " z wy . o oa ES ~ oy . Le fe, ' mi sot sa ty Sahn pow, a, on oe OS owt ge Snot een on ek erm, 'ae we, shod a ad ww 2 "& "e Py treed we Eb poet " Be fa Su we oa oer Ons CA m bee ee OE Be ems os aa rt we a ae ot : an & an ~~ on saved ts rN ~ (feed. qo ™ oe aonag sane ; po z > ~ Negwne 4 on an pos ea th wy "we 4 ged ot hd ws oeeet oe 1m neaed hy Ww we ropes 5m dea, sens m wed ge ~ rae nan. piney, een me Sood ne é a wm $ te 4 { Le vs a i Ee Sant he : a fey "= ; ae ~ od te peed. Rat Pag' ene bw, SA an pow, on we 'v t3 No a ae % B pe hee at " 1 oe of epee et oe ~ ° fs g peed, pon Y mf cheat Lael ws ay ores ' AS wet wed, ~ % OO 8 £5 & a * ctr et et OR » ue ' é N Z a fe e ' ; ? $ : A heat oy oe et TY a « CU eo po ee oe tee OG " nape me Le a seek nt "ee La Neb on. od a Bed feet veer apd ~ ws oa ~~ yoo at ' oe "ne re $ " 4 a teat a ¢ es bag! < < ee tt forth ', ay bee, vn Sao vd ft ws ay wor ery Lt . oe re jew yen oft a oh By . os! a he wag w% hg . me f By vat a ry fe vee gS * hat Ve he eet uf : nr ba aw "tent tab ot ve oo hana gM ed wa, na all ~ xr. beet bee, ie ws ws S3 . sone af Soap we A Ke So ~ 4 re ae So y x - " Z GE mm ven ores wh Ne ved ¢ ; Me i o. ry pan aa eet oe Sant i ed ot ae So ~ wh fee o Sod ei x steed ye wing " a vee 4, verte me Mop Mew ve py tee ~~ ; vei set oo we eet oped in re fo me 4 s + L aa f os ad os pe ced heels, em bes Fen me " os ood we st ct a TP a feat nds sow 4 ewe Sand * od ye, agen we foe heed Ps Sad, weed, Lt , yond fod oy Me weed g we - res a fone rene « ay a 4 oe a as £2 tre en an ts greed my a ; wrt oe a mt we 2 ol ran td hs ; ie, Thm eres wm ren st ifs fy ve "So we vee, weed th $ asad ge gz we A 'ae wed het i ee) ger vee ieee Not 2 ike the ~ Lg car Z fed : bone go 7 ne ond ' revs ae ms So x e ¢ hes beni een ny , Ro me oe Cc "od 'oe G2 be on gn m tend, wt . mn pt , * tae 0% the? ve Not + aoe pee jew Pant yond pad, nee " y a det ee oS hoes iy "3 pune wy oath eee 3 at coe 3 om e % ea Ke ve Bo rm ele oS on "4 mo beet iat oo, ww Se a ood a : 1% 3 stent oes te a ~~ s , aw od me aed we oe er ve 7% pot Fad : Ww "~ acai veri boos we mn mm wen Seow ye Cea 3 an "nd feat " ee eres, ~ jell ; _~ ree eo 4 on on, wold, ", ry ie tet z wee oe vase oon Fleer A yee, os pan ae . 3 wee inet Na Sng CS oy 5 w% es oi a pe ry g ae pers , west ged vee ed shed we Z ow i me ° owt e rs pan odend ° ~ reeet 34 wy 4 ¥ Saat tS " ot dees fu phe wi n, phees we ~ 'ne? ry mm 90) det iy a w we oo ty ~~, a ' % 5 ie aed ~, 5, q Tonge Be] a 43 eed ue sent stood, fh 7% sheet "4s ay pene os we 4 ry wes ot ; tA Sd , shoal ae ye os a Soe ns Sone sy ae 'ad oe 4: be Ay * eet rn fort ; Mie et Ye ; 'el soot ; ve eee e mm a3 a yw pee a ao. mm pd : be Net me o a he ' : > ¥ . ' . " deed ; r fant ae st emg ff Sem OU pt pee a ha ee eet i ri ae ie iad me my, ga oy em a a oot cnt ad * ee ~ et oO aed pooei, 4 waes fot oa bet, oa na Sot dee ft be. tees oa ow fe Se "oust Bi o bs oot ay +e wa 'ect wae a my a gare th ba see wt ab oe shed 4 oe we mm mo i ae wd tA ve Soot peony a pees heel va rh ¥ soa ne Sat w " ' % 34 om, ae, ' g 'ee ~ . oe "
fin e ry fone fe tm we en's Me ras aa naa be : pes aA Ca ene wt aw wet OB hee Dep eee r: m ios re Sy ! . red Oe ' - *y " ? . see ee ot wh oe ae toh oe? Boel ot rag yeeei ~ Nee me Lipa boted Me pe rn ryes £4 es 'wd yoo pot oe 2 a rit weed aw 'panes, oa, rt 4 aed vient fi Nh Nat Ly oe e at nf oo ee ted a bed wes ee yet ' no on 9a re, 0G he weet ~ eeteg * ttt go aed ~ fas "7 we "TS neal fy at $ Ly " oy wo Soa ete we bas won teed ed re Qe x oe he une, . z ee ae fs, ves os oped goons wy % Sanne tones wy 7 See : pod, nm bs peed ee oy ; roped aie * ed ne jet A raed er , pod Ls tod Lyd pes gn ae ra a ced wn, pre ree aed: ers oye Ww 43 ns at foe a we red 43 ° we x th ot Mee A fe idee " ape oe x ' 1 fon dow wa By pone or, po weet Ws > aaa fy + gan aad ww ' oe oy "pe ? pebod on A te mS ro spent gent ~ tent ped Sea 'nad o oot Ly "ot ai eet yr feet :
re ag yas hae teeth ~ oe as ae oy tek aden a3 a rs te £3 week ones an im z vend £4 wa ned ween oaks 6S wn Us ow Mank : tt eh 'net aed a Cont ry no Az aeerds Ve a vA Oe ayes mee as v4 Pasi tnt ~ 4 ee ange Le yee ww, nt veer, yond as ares, 24 we en woot tt be 40 an? Bi et re ~o wi 3 a: os, oe ° feel pion, we oes " a4 eo oe al pooee bey ' weed, yee : oe ; uy iw cree ae . rs foe, 43 "ee peees nr, pot ee il Bey bedi a 2 yer werd Bi Tl ge eens te? gon As whe en hod we eg 'net ot Se Kam Nat "ae oe a ne eed aed Nag 5 * ged oN ot oo ore aye by het ern yee we gree ms sf wt Seve sped wee Sapod, dees As nee Peng RG "ee i ts ia ee Peed, AY A naeee, Loot yet ws et eon . Fe iS w om 2 i fee ey e, o r a pes ay ifs gn AY ot tod rr vod any oeud tadiot &j "ot re we we bes Gut xe 4, 'eat 'got ee ved pane 4 res #4 uo Za va 3 a open oni, ee pos Iago bet a vee tn steed Sebes eed, ne £4 vee ooh dyed feet Lt owe A oe Get poh ten eb 5 ye ron ioe ge " BL ;
et cA nt des cee 0% ea a bd , ae rs on aE 'cain? "et om he ' 4 bedne ee oo: z fi 4 ae hed "py . Fete Oe oo "te seed v4, tre a pote weed gg spond ae £5 ;
ee <) LPA Na, 28D of on, ok With & a oS co % pe getior sR fa os font tema, & :
" ba ms tae oe "hy : * aa a a, me x Be mY a pe By ee oA fae, Raed oS ad "eo te, ae os ~ en im we we mee gut -
mt ' ' m = rad cal tA woo we Pow nt mo % ~ By ao So om tes "4: nt thee Gs whe ied oe oo, 4: i , ree we poen, oe ms ae Pa Psd Le ~ vet Naf % ~ ow os, a a ~ rent MA Lf "
he a 4 hoon me ren as ws a re, to os nd oa ged ns bad at ;
& RP ECES > + + 3 t § as Sw ' ~ ae af EVO ar ny => & RRP st aS ent be SEX} N party > 'a the nag TWwe e bb ¢ tat sth 3 { ome if x art W 8 are Ir Hart x © 43 "het 2 ORY e :
A rawn & ne sagwenngie eee ey .
%:
SY RSG of Wi <P Bette reetree, "7 Yt 4 G = gs <Es oy 3 By is 4 ryy Free LPS Na, CW its "y concert TE OY ax th rr AX SUC ch governs the 'Ase Byst ty + & YW al rule wi GFL Very oN aS required ay Ca ~ t & y x "7 te t i ia t at ey mm preg ops Sat gt beet ne whe p pal 2 Por B oe A h & PERRO rE of sw y ;
X y ¥ 3 \ etic z r sponds ny preaneec o x day x fa Oo, ae Anne Von' w a fart therefore STIG 3G Proe 3 g ' Reo a eae ?.
ow "i Ge w Ww er ea fog "4 ap i. Urider ge AVIS.
tT the f Ve 1 procesd i ances would . Phe Ce oS test the tr rew x > a chi ° i wistenc ighing Rot f ar thee x fact really StS OF2 Wo wT ae oh is applied In nee Act o & MAM UN whether Ths t WEL t ~ = z xX an & pod on ee Ry bab OL 3E i 3 g eshion | x a, tL cyt +
-
BC RS ?
BS VEO < rofe ri favo ews £ > Me The tickers POE x o :
wh Lor nue be dig AP pee h degrees 3 at mest 4 Tah x x Jf > a BTL of 3 SAAT v3, RECLEELS MY :
& sublect m by a The loo O SHPO a "yr « ' Mee mss ee yh + ai3 ' Lara hr x x & mS ..
SNS A #32, indicated that there ex BOF kG & :
ie 'ad ul sk Senteras, "afuwrse if wet, i depending & se a x x inhit ths Pea frais gS > t 3 ba abiht 2 N xb nas oheerved as uncer:
"~ 3G.
Paes the ~ ¢ x ' it law or ;
& iY o of he :
TES AA H QF GQ sy et ere: MST xy t The EES wee, R i a x * @ OXpPos ISQUSKE horrnes, we noder % K SOW ryed a ~y
-
as ohse in 223, "
t ourt | Supreme © faced x sys BEEPS 8 ~ x LO os Pode, Soe, an Nat A 4 a ;
$ 3 :
t wy yaad ro ance at te rhea PBey xBaee dex ae THD 4 { AMS ~ PX 3G ae 2 Sat <x ae & Ee gauge wae of mt lnque:
& {7 o gt yaw, 4 <y an ay.
ELS ok dart GB ~ mn i idioator, the adit.
aS self we:
at AR Lh x rH nM ye Inna hee re apes, Ser! a pats nl Red ms pa Lee few, re vee tod in ay wy oe betes aa aa rf x ve ad "ye ue ket we o Fe, ay ue ge wr os ye, 'wot ed, re Ls der poeet, 38 ~ < 4 ie the general rules of fain 3 f applica toe 28 A gen rises, baat QSCIeaNn.
may oy ub proving over witho apt x RR i veh.
RAS nm i TER iy ae a coubiin = = x x & sur NY .
ERS a 3 m2 of 3 as 3 A HH 4 + y x Si for Bx Bees eigen oytyy STRONY ;
tung ben b ds w x & wo b a :
Me ry of Y x x WUSSIO 3 Suber XS "8% at ie worn rt om heat set fy ad 3 x fe 8 3 ;
x thi SIN Se £ x ip itted x x fet At 'aed 3 + x CE OY % > x & bat in n 4 os we word, Ne ye ben, "a ae shad Shin! fr", 'vat gen tae 4 two bic of Sy ek i Pahka MEHL OPES s 2OT8 s for iderifice & elle omiusion. Burt, at this st < :
A oes oO ahian oO % the reason for cary non parlicip he oe be ap 4 s a Fe APU Ne = Ameer oc axe fed sane: price % > Ave uC ' x ~ the appellants h 3 ~ > ARIAL OTECELD ¥
4.
ty, bad ce ae wee Pony SNCTULULY.
Loe ¢ 33 mons) OTe SY de 2 oy i Siok is TERY Rapa gM SMA Yoote £ ry TSH oe Web 2 a a a won ae} OUN x * x x c Ne t.
- r Sah ae gRz I ay ae Y ¥ 3 z hi Q IP t a, the x x PYk t s n SR 3 we open a a fat ores 'nd oy ae "
Nee ~s at LEEPE GE rN oO wn Tt x Mb te re os set vee ey oe ot are net a very al LOR "gt With ww ia wor, Ssekee f2S FR BF ae ju 3 Xs ari Net heed ow bow nee on"
\ cutory oned 2223 :
Rg s t oh + x at th f & bservins é asec ¢ of dee:
OR ec dat ar ok "de ay PPG?
Ui we _ ral ey ie 300 De at the;
x eel th Pever h how $ st SX Ww cat ty pty fdas c ppedianet oy 5 wv Pestoppel "yy Newt ft nciple Pre al 3s at the fe Beg & wee ty "ts "s a Ss ~ a y oo oe S, 7 a / " Fae] ty a ptees hee oe ww som ~ oe os yee, roe oe "eed % So & ~ aN vee a ae we ws fy we ba woos we, Nar ae ry Seat ag ot Bo ne fa fy oo tad | tet
-y wee reef aot oe 'ae rad, os z fo pn, rs i oo Nw aoe il eyed oe on 'nae? aes dens oheet oe ee mm on od net ye seeds k PL seers gt pA reds egy he ox aN et ty <¥ 0 wh 00 a sheet 3 $ e we PROWEE g. PRY of olated the Urcdes :
x LPAR of th led ze bisis XN x ¥ Pays + ahf cay XN tween & corsiy 3 ed. As nmobesc 3 a TWO se aunrrat cet & jc i Ww 3 anetity of inte & THEE > ~y 3 rot be ee y x Ny bees ie and thereby wv vt 2 ¢ x tnd XN Pi SN x SLB .4
ab oollusian bbs r i $ yerned their uric bil p DO Ua 2 a ve a x « merely xeked tha ry Oe < wy Lye BS % i af = RY} raw Y 2 eS ¥ x PL x SLAW SS STR ae \ ¢ oh 3% OLE ~ ect ders contre yi bec th Fe e x arnot b wv om S Pa an infer y 3 ~ OE bnew JY ce tk "a "ae L qeee, wiglatecd and the bis need, ped :
PUES far ide Les iS a owe bic utling ay RR na by sub:
x x OB € "
y x ¢ £ wip S 2 w $ Beye gthy "8 Seven oa < 3 y al OY eve as Lar B Lett .
Ae + here we tial s S y i » ¢ i ed by of free ¢ } 2 rejected stiouietions SOTTO atte & x :
im H 38 Xx = ery biel omy for the sake of he x > wv ed VE € ab:
RTE w N OCs ae + XR i at the ur x uipulal punitive bic 3 & NEY ARSUITED in Ras obsery .
> ~~ ¥ x aIYHLe et cory :
x A Court are Q 4 sé « zt q A lead te the comchuision that :
x sud te subvert the p Y SORE MAA A necessarily has voted by the appe mpett .
wy a 3 q aa ek ape does no ding a x Ha ad ape alifving st " > yy ptt w SYETAS. & x .3
Trey, *% £5. a ore, , Toe, ood WE yo a nape, os "i vyert err, a a o . eo , bee ao vr 'eed 7 weeds 'ae? ae a Co ty vere a weed Seat ty pyeed o oped, , A od hs wn ree Qo on ae no oo as eet 'ea ed 'ted ¢ tape mf Fs Pos veyed not waee "he ebei oe hemes, fn 'eee xr ty seeed eed on pen 4 +n eel at 7 hd Ls t v4 eines " cor "hat res t post yer eae ae * * nee ge * fs hed weer ve, geet oy we te as, ,
2. 4 ot ree werd t ets : pa oe pron £ 5 pte geet oft a Q ed boi Lp fs an roy 'ped sent sheet Lo + geet A . pee, bed, prone feet fen A+ ws read ve ww om 4, ' atene, ; '4 * choos ane ye . wees, 5 fv, 4 os tee " ny "end Seat git t ged Sood eve 4 ee, tre? whe ye tee! aed 3 ated, ree epee 2 wee, mo oe fy geen are eh Ge me hegre mG é re oS oo en Ioooe % yw 4 ' wn ch bed, feet bet cand ees reg " "Arad, we Saot spot Nee eh teen pect hp - trand, ae . beet oo tot yan naeet ay "ny ved . hy vee sere "ye ae bed ' ¥% " ty boot oon " oat Le 3 seb % ot s shed as ve Sat "eed " ° "5 bot weed Seed, Sot " + wry sas mn "9 ant ' ree s pred 'ae! wv deed a ' ¢ vn font 7, bes . Gs Go "a wrens ee at ow, os iba toon vat mo bey "ee rye a4 perrds n jaf yeh ye ed 4 a et fen a fe ae : ¢ dedi, wee wate ms 'ne "age " af a 3 ar "nen wy on "Ss ap shee % non pe pone " 'eee ? ns we nt om o, Dobe, # get * i, pee pre the! es 2 4 + + ' a, * Fed oe O04 is8 haa ve on Be Gb ee Ther wee At ue 'sna? cf ft me LY ~ uy Mer oe we fk ws Sad pines ft 234, eed he Yoni, g 'ne a rated ~ we ~ ar & seeed od ys £ ae nia reg a os 44 ieee ore ec os 'ted foe Lowes ot od, ye, viet r% we pone Ses gn ed ve Qe ws * Aa cot ees an, 7% ne mR rons th ets 'net ~ me ae EE ae bet ms . ied re , oe ne pee whet gt wt Ss oa LA a re th wf ~ te "3 bes Lae? ted Pa ree re os ~ sheet ie oe new oh on, iw w t. 5. 4 Ne, ged Nat % wie 4s ett 'ened "od pe ~s ' seed 3 on v ie oe pet at ye aa rt nhs at sx et Oe i G 5s > 7 a eA SPO eS = wy ED on ee x . a vend 6 a A at "Ss ase we es, ade ge ped mo ae AY "sy vw en "ae Son m2 ia Nad See S sad tht ied oS rien Pant ores wens net wee ted ot an "ae ne ot ¢ aad sone, eed Seawe ae oat * 2 ae ee ; chant a3 i. on "i pe ih és oh gt ~ : + rt tore feat wets ; dee ad : we Che ed ey od ot ie ial we " hoes res ' poy eto em he ge ee ret yew, er vet ~ os ore we Ty yeee a3 ~ hed i ted fener . Pf eet " ay GS ve Me ¢ preere, nm poi # wo hove So a" A dant ps wager ei va eee) fy 4s et ' Qe uM wet bee, oe esi nm So 4 Sanat £3 on oe oped ae mo bed Seo fey fad roee) Ly eae, ran a wee ns ~ Loe >», ned bene pow 'daw fale 7 in ws er % we n os ed ceed ok wh? oe elect Se Saat % a me wen $ mt fn obat 5 ns a t tay on ye . Na pes ae ane os wah ; eneee, towne, Paes wk Ww tan rat "5, + end na oe Neat 9. a pod ant af ey wate geet er ' Sa weed pam . ' , ae we ve, os © toot 5 1 oat Ce Er gee? vy wet , we ' % free ' Bd ih bans eo foot proedt , re fea aon - 4 whe eee hae me ebook ied oe ' me a a ee wpe i oy, ! ae, oa eed hh oS Pi eed i be ~ "ween Le wloet "E4 * a Peal noes By $ A wit : 'na me hed ie in ee ol . bad yee a we ~~ a3 ¢ rot td ~ my fy ws wee woe Saabs pind. wes gs we "a ned £3 oS ns aa 'nih Gt an , ng sont WA EP oe re "
@ ance Mere ee "it Bp ire : Do me ce ms 4 ( oe Ag ae be Das oes we mS ~ eet te pes eh a . oe os nye x wpg ok kd 'ed os aa oe "ped, wy wae Son "5 'nt Senet Ae o gs bee rr, Ae rs we 63 Py or seed ahd te eee, a Seek a fe, % yen 4, eons vee 'at fo med ¥ vl ire, '. "4 My pens ana cl ne ny pate 'a "4 we ners 'ed om Ay ara Saas nu ete . peee, ue ~ te 7" heel tip io age res oS Net ~ et . te oe . red g3 red "ene tat a ond rowld wee ww "nwt ao 7% ret af ot, a * Saat oi Say a % Seni, goer bod, Sent > Ps bet res to beet a Ay a gree ~~ ree ue yee See bad, oe ms wz "tent te ry 5, £3 on 4 deen : . A een yon : ont me aed £4 cored a : ne A bee a, alee i S ow td, - . ton "va % L yee al Mee a red, Leet J wn % on, Pe. ret ' wy * Sat on tee aoe steers Seneet poatt ms ot Se ~~, oe at La ey el oe od * Shane non + sed "th Fa) ood vert doa ow 5 eons? oy wet 'es oe os ° wy om von, et Se "A. wee; tA ren 'at th Nee 4 peed bb 2 so C0 me wo OG wo Fe we yo eLs wee A, ~, pend, go we 5 ™~ ws {% pore ' pot parse ot + os ¥e a i i oe mm | COR eo, ae Godot Saw rot te £3 bag bat ne, i re we baa 83 op bag "ON "ad 2 om a ~*~ ~, jis nA ved 2 oak one 0 ¥Z weed ~ %, anne, yen Ne 4 oe yoy, : 'oe Sa 'nd r% rpeee wend ay w2 y" Lh , $ grt es 4 ; ee "ee om i 3 a, os Go A xo aed ton wh, t fens x " aed See met bot arte "noth spi Swe . ee "C7 ~et ; wz OD os a hed a pa eT Fee is ws Yee ee i Ps ee per oes .S ro lw, Sb a rhend vend ahead . cneee ce : roa ns ee a * oc re + ys my 4 ee a nal bey. owt ok hid "3 ee? et ved ow, n : Z one, ms he, oe Nw wy SA at book "Sy a SS we Oe nm w Stet ee, nd 'ot Me TEE soot ty pao ; wa eet ye Ly me 'ind rh oe * ws a) oy sa? nan Ae os ~~ rend AS oe ws ted ve Ley pdeee fey, ~ wis eee nm pores hee! ~ wheat a ospet a, on " me £0, reas bt ead peo ' peo. ° ar bes tech hey Ve + soot i a 4 a
- aed, x ae - " ws .", 5 . rte "Ret ne ae Mee Ww ere ms Lt nM" me Fe ms fey hoes Sat 'ea oe, woes he on we ONG 1 tos ody ee "o%, ah oe orn wv mm se rot ret te oot, + 7 " im ated we , ow, t pet : a n % feat ee be wages oo " tp hy a on eet on 'ena vv ie zw <n aa ore ms ey, ae 3 bos weed bee ; panes vs * ped 7) vn L "a Bhs edoo nD poe vt ae seed eee ven wy, Se fewe seek : in ft, on rh a, wt oe ; we peer red : new sped a Spee, wh 'sae . q pee is aes awd os 4 wg were eect o ~ . doo 4 a vee! a, 4 ee tt ~ ~ os oa ek : 4 oo shed , ws m a geei La? 'erat 'ad aed ntet g Nea bon £ft wees a , Ww at Chat * f by 2 "pad pe ren rt . 7 ot eve he hes wes tt op Lf . 'ad ie bei Boot is or Foor 2 "rea xe o a3 fos ee Leet ; r oe seed aeoad oy 3 : oe fhe ren, BA yeni ~ hi kw. on, eee % 7 Ne gee on Bi tee te ET Fane Be een ge ped Pal a o bea cont bo 43 ert & Cad ret wee nad ~, ned poloee, ye, eed - ae Sper! wf we < Z tae ant re ro t% "3 jet eect fet ay ' bade beet x bon * my Sa ¢ oh ore, set 4 oo deat net oy " we wy ' ws bodes "6 ot a 43 Oe enon GS bei ; : a te CL rye "" ' Sy nt wert, fot ww tS 2 pant os he ae) Wh red st ge ener, eed we : Saeed vt Oe fe, on wy peter fey a Sood and ans ot oo ot pertn, " nied : Saeed 'sagt? Faacl wenn yy ges ~ os . aan ay iad °. Pe * & ah ge % : o " ond t ww ben, . bey ry 44 need oe es pe pened, eal ' 'a ne ~ mea Sanne ood y oe mn we 3 to f ge 4 eed Let sees a he we ry nm i yt toni if " yk thee tak cha 1) Ce ped yy os Mt a oa Spoon, a3 ps oa 'peed & ak me whe 4: a a ve rs ot Le vondeys seed. an ; we tnd LS poor " oes ree ey choot wd Sawed, oi we wah an ee LA ", $ ad rere "s ae eran, ay a ed i "f; * yee paeet oe a wen xe ved w wie eh bye get fee % a ts " me By Ce TYE , fp tween, baat cons am 4 oe os ap eG 'ant ns vet vee ga eee Ee wt asm ole on tot Le fon fo totee ee ed rm 2 bd g ogee wt wet nt yee ria on ie tod prt tote, G3 sod A gy yo oe wes vet not Sat fee va " rs ws " et ee Ve a 4 . ' _ Niche 7 g ped ' ga t aapee poor, sae 3 ga one Seat 4 ee ts Lop Net oe Mf soped hed and ye pe " te ws ae ot teed oe ty ad ben hs oad td need nee a7 yon waned ge poe, , a RS . wy as Sees we % 4 heen rye '4 as ths cot one rhe chet MS Cy gt oe 24 eg qeeed bod ea . 'eat es oes ve pa vet on ws oe oF Sf eed, cat Mer ga ~ shat ae oe, oe oe pean eae, os erent wr 'ot BA on ad LS oe ret A oe + gee, Sete ie hove ", bod, get ped on " ee ot wn ots a . re ap 7 BP ' ; ne on ca he won ot a : Z Oe , ' 2, "gh mo rm™ wi he EG ay aS feo we Z we Hh So Bo ee oo wo ge ot pat thy oo A fe : 'eh ope on 4 . Lod ¢ % ns eas seed, aeoe, poor % ms oe at re us seed a Sat Get pod, coaae weed Mori. phy ry of, eee, hoe! eer Bed 'a eal the 2g rye oped hayes, o Ce add Ls nd red, e WY om peek wees ~ woe, wees oe 2 wt wn 'nd KR gore %, , ed gy c o ao a ON OS, sped oD nn 7 poe gt rte o oo se ne, sere po nf * ped ; 2 gana, _ S :
: , 2 ne '4, 5 os fog ;
te an i 2 f ot ook, wh as 5 a oS en, oa / ms et ae rw, e & £04 oy "
pny a .
toe OMY he € £ 'tel Nv ISG of RVQG Wr LEA NG. 28 of SOME ¥ HIE a7 Fe NR ¥ HA Be.
t ?
> RUPP Geller e shoul wyarat . ¥ ;
arinot sf on € cae on Nee hay whieh 3 OPUS cy Rhee Ne wh ' t APETICS x .
aS , r x ¢ wm og oa yan ~ mw wn, "na?
fod fy Wie 4s sidders, x NS aNep < ~ te PPQCEEa x , har he ty et * TERR ;3
£ aot PENT the riast exe wks Ww URC ee ¢ deran vy fhh cork x yr Ni oTL O RE a af ad With POF af 8 M7 Rea, E80 RY & LEA Nay ar SN bidde by timent 3 ae YPU2 eh ROY °.
gee 3 by Q ¢ 5 so Q ra ty 'he ' ya yee 0 f td iS 201OUS ~"
Y q a RC
-.
at "eolh 7 ¥ fort Q i, MY > eat ee + OrrUpligs 'der MS ES:
o g WR QE "ERE ory NE £ gs tr
--
Ned "
xo x ss ¢ Lig ANE ~ ahs.
G anid < shed £8 the RY.
SST OW i te SN EVE Pre aoa h IN.
arroed by re x .
wet in ONY :
whe ae \ oy 13.0! i z.
mes x in "1s a) Vv. i, shed a ws ree we at i ad ow bee 2 2 | CR ee 3 "
ae ot ep 2 Be wk reg & yt + x a Ba.
LEA No, 197 af 22h ROSS pts END ie y SX ¥* Te SOTISIC x .
a) eZ EN ale * NY he at goood, Piped a sphere Pree, fe we % ane 2 nes yee youd teed Cs tat a Se * x hades ce x t Pan At to = Set tee a te a we z a a, Me, my ered, ett K a "
as a " xX the show Ov E "e g SSPE oo Pa t 3 Pe ¢ de shaw cause motic Mle PH sent cs > the Te RS f "s * in plote Sut erp x E ~ :
ay x \ ie co Pt i3 ' "
ey bes Y \ zee q it j of J iy by way of h i yee a fe al ral Bas t SCDaTAL ¢ ret ves ae M3 tH crys wich x 2 chore wh oo STE Sl PITT ¢ x ee s ind "
z ?
t aw 4 ZN 3 ey DA iran & met be t XY ta fh s so 8 i § trend, or pa < RYE 3 On oat Ss 2 G ub & red a C323 :
x x WOE Se & MS 2 EN X% BORN sf BSG af GER + R89 s NSN } LPS Ra.
q and taken > g yt to the f€ % :
acd wate RF ich 3 SO.
ae ~ REC i ding Ry xo = y x bi mm partics Eyes Nesary MMe 30 o x Ne Q a 2S ays ven se re an oe xa penne % Tor be < oS cae el on t od gs Bs sp taken > ~ ave EE bade OF x x than as} Sy have ae x A ot ed ead peer rt gk ame s requir aly tae > sath ~ ce would nat at yid SG x % Le any Thal < g OF x AO we WS wa thet
2.
rd yt mm te we g PPE AV ~t g ;
tL EEE $ :
x ~t e 2 x rd x VP sr % ¥ x y a ui ' ~t Sorsedices e@fo. Tru x aur UY gY SP x we ean rig "
OY the Tends a ts bad sar Gecsic £ a > x A et ws 38 LPA Ko, LF af 2080 WEE L¥A Nov PSY of 2te) OF. For the reasons discussed herein above, the order dated 19.02.2020 passed by the learned writ Court canmnat be supported in law and, accordingly, is set aside.
Se. According, LPA No. 156 of 2020 and LFA No. 197 ef 2020 are allowed and consequently, WPIC}) No. 4771 of 2019 and WPIC) No. $218 of 2019 stand allowed, sel (Shree Ch OM, andrashekhar, J} ed (Ratnaher Bhengra, £3 "Dessay t, AEESIOR