Karnataka High Court
The Commissioner Of Income Tax vs M/S Lucent Technologies Hindustan Ltd on 3 April, 2012
Bench: D.V.Shylendra Kumar, K.Govindarajulu
gas mg E%E£%§i {Z%:}{jE'§' Q? E{ARE\§;i,E'AE{A AT BA?\§QA1,0R'§§ ~.
§}A1?'E.E3 mgr; 'E'%E<: Qaw may 0}? §&>R£L 2:3
PRESEN? °
'ma EGNBLE MR é%}$'£'£CE :3 V SE%'§2£_,E§x§.&¥fiR§i;i"EiE§§£é':§;' ' j
ANS
mg EEQNBLE MR J¥;SE'E€E E; @312/?:;2\§§;:.;_RA3u:;;:;5*..;'"'
:TA.NQJf:";;33 0F:25eT$;'
BETWEEN: x
1.THE CGIVEMISSEONEZR ' 0mNQ9M§«'mX, _ . . 1 CENTRAL czgmg {?_LR.§:3' fi::,;:--7:i:*\s'::_:g "
QUEENS RQAB, " ' BANQALQRE.
2% mg Jami?' C:T}'EvE§\e'EEé3f§1{}?§,E<:f¥{,;Q"':" ' :3x:€®M€::g::2§,'~VV " % A $§§%:1;::i,§s1:;\;é{;E°~.4;,% _ . , €f;.E,8U§L§FE'€G§ @U'£E§2E$ gzaggfig B$3§Q§LGEi3E, "
'NAPPELLfi§TS {BY 'SEE; ?E<,;.%"%:s;":f:'!§gé§_" S§:?'€E%R QQUNSEL 333% E3;$A§§E§E;5£§%§E4;§§}'€§ " N é1£j€€§£'E'-i?§€€E§3€G£,G€;§E§ : é:§.::'§?{;~'a§§';i:n2_:$s $3.2 'aw.:'2.§:--e§a,~'a1&§§. £:%gg*§@R Byimérssa, 4 "..a§§'§E::;2;%>;:g,?::}§:g%; 'E"§::€E£ max, j '§E:§a,§,$';a::35€aVi, "i?iff:E;§ §;1€§§"1;E§§§E§'{§ §i3y {Ze:§:23'%: {<3 %:=:>;§.::3::{:e 'WH§'i'EZE'EE:§,§l B;3ExE§ALGRE:~§8§€}é'5§9 ,,.;%.ESP<:%:*§::>.§::xé*:* ' {EY SRESEEQESEE AN?) S.?A§fE'E§sESARA'E'E§}£'»ié}:f§?5S§ _: j" L "FEES .£?PE:AL EE FELEB :3:~;§:iT:¢2_§5<:*:*:;07£=§ 2a@g:~"~%e:%%' %:gg magma asx ACT, :95: Aaisfg-I.s.f5<:;V., GEE'?---.{3§'j 87533733 m::'§3:2:?: éG~i3@G5 PASSED :33 {ya:s;§::{f:::.i~:;<gA:\i§;'2i:;:A@3,'Ema THE: ASSEEESMENT YEA:--~7\ ~ 12%:%§%;:;;;:S;~1.._'»,é>:2g:'ms<; Ti}:
E'0RME}L:'\;E"E EHE SUB$TANE'i;z5'§_L GP' LAW STATED THEREEN A'§\Ei} ETf€:. V THIS Ap?EA;?.1'§C;::x.>H_N:§ F95: :{§A§+:1;<:@, "SEES BAY} SHEENBPA KU1i:A:§"';§;; ' fig §'€3LL{3'§§§NG: Appeaé by §<T€:>*«:%:%::;:.'§:»- :_§:::_i:3e:"".8€c2i2iG:; Qfiifiafi of 'gigs As: digested ;=;g€a:ns i%" .. £%1€ 7' §'rd§% éaigd 2::?.:a,2.@@5 27:: by iha gfiéfeééiii" Tax Ap§é§.§_3}i§. 31 gaéereé c '$1256 féfiiéxfisézzg" féwis qaggiiazzs of §3.'i%:'f . iE7§'1€:h€:' 33:3 '§:§b:i::a§ was c::::*:*&C: 3:2 "f°€:¥€:si:;:g 331$ §fEd;if3§§$ sf Q35: £%,SS€3$S3:§§ig{.§ aw :::§a§::'és:§é§3?€é§2a€;i<':_::géiéader 3€é'_i'i§G§§ 33%} £5: ififmfi :3? €333 Exggifiiéaiiiifi $1} :T::i{ §f€Sp€€'{ 5% She V€§§' iyga G5 €:><:p€f1fiEi§f,z§:'§: 4_s§:';:a:§é1ia§é;A. E356 :*%'a.§:::.r:€{§ ag a ailswaéég §$é%.:_{::1ie>n azadsy V. i::§€€§§{}f§ '-:E=';AZ? sf 323$ AC? 932$ f{hs:"€§<:;:"'€§ emhmiig £323': 231% § gairis i3 as pg: f}afiQfi駧jf a{E€f€§3:€fi §§.€i'?€{)u;r}Eii":g Séandafdsg {vi} whsiher th:%;"""
sjgaiem adagéed '$5; the 38863336 is fair "
yfiasenabis Sr is adapiéd gaff; with a E7i€'S€"ivQi .. rédusmg {he iff§C§d€f1C€ Ca? £a><ati@::*:"".' T sabmiiied thai: the View 3f the had bfisrz affirmed; by {$38 CG::":§:;::i§s;i_0>neA:."V' sf Qfippfialsfi has best: revsrafifi the 'E':*ihu::a£ having :10: §§€§*: examined the qzzfistiszé of gi§c.}x::::::.;:g_ G1'? 316 gaiéelines as S}:§r'§_B:1;:!VVC0urt in $313 judgmsni, 3.:}.(i.V$.';§'~.%:E}Lé<':[;?{7:§:"V%?:'.V Tyibuziai is at variamss zfiih by {he Szxpzrems {30§g:':, E315 <:e:'5é£*.§gV{ '$33313: ha S%,JS§;8.i§"i€ég ?; -S'%:iEé:i:.:"i :;V;1h%:§:§»§Tgi_@n E3 fiat {E13 &S<S€8S{f€ vfiziis 5:31:
83%; «.
««<7%m Qjufigmargt sf {he §Li§§'€f§E€ Caur': in 'é'x9"<;@§:az;3.:d's. V E2 E%SS€S8€€ {Ga '€€f§S iéreégg €;«;{:h2::§ge E:>s§ 0f 2' LE-¢,§s§,22,8§%.2;".{..V Er; ii/he 'ififfifiiéi 55 ggmédsiinés Csfiégainéd in §a:'*;2: 21_;"€:if' " ;_. E5" E:/zsafgr as iihs sesand Cguesiigzi £3131': {E56 '§§i°%b;::::ai pmsesfisé ;A).:;<~:~::*';§'::€ Sgéire sxpéndiiure :3 a re2_gg;./$6 arfié %f1€E"€:fG§'<'":, {ha siané $333: EXp1ana1f, féV::_{};j" '£32 23 :23: gitrasééfi 'E0 1:336 as$€,4.;%{$5<:-:."~:_, 26, We Sinai ézijsié. :%;:?gea2é? :5 :}¥is3 :':'§':béf:r:a} is not at 31% '£€z}a'bi€ éithgr 8%? cf égfia Expia1:ai§<>n {E} is Secéiaa 32 yeaidgmg asv.._é:::z:--§é_é* "$2. , §§2x;3§ai:3:£€3§:" E. '-Vfifiéars 1:333 'fiusmegs Q: prC§f{'.$5§é;a, 0? {he .a__s_§sss$s 3255 Qarriad an in 3 "":%i:;§is:3Vi::§?'A:<:z§%.AQaar:1€& by him %::'§ :5: :'€s§es:i sf
2 'aifiéi€%E =ih§"&:S's§:_SS€€ Easids a bass 2:322' Gihaz
-;*:g§f:%f ' " asfciéapazésjg ané 35:}; ssapiizaé €§:pé:éé:§é:::--4é;j igcégryfisi E35; 5% 85368366 far €h€"'§EEZé1'fj§€33€'."'{}f the busigegg GE" §r:>f€S3iG:{: 9::
'£316 c£;.§:5$:_:°:z€=éia:1 £25 agsy S§E"E§C?:'23§'€ :33" {sf . E:5:§1§: zireiéi ii": 9%' in rsigiiazz Ea ansi *9}? 333%}; of ~[f':*§z:{:2r«aiiGr: gr extaaaiag 0%", Si" EEIE§fG'i£'€§§l€fi§ . ':+:};":§*:€ busiiémgg EEEEEL 'L323 §I'{}'J§.S}:G§'§S 01? ihig cééagsge Shaii apgéy as E? 'S523 said S§E,"'i};C{'%,'1E"€ er " ~~ws§§<; is 3 bzsfidéizg aazfgsé E3}; asseassés".
" '~.<é2 IE 23* *':'§3g;~§{Q;»§3 ::h<:' Gffifif 9? the "§':*?3:m22§ 15-; S6? aséstis :8: ghgg Q},/;j'g§§}"g_ gfigf G21 £31636 {avg 21s;p&€Es§ ihfi remagfifid 3;; {Egg Asgessizzg Authsriijg, 22, The appeai ig E§§O'W€§ in par':
5%: