Karnataka High Court
J Prakash vs Government Of India on 15 June, 2009
Author: Anand Byrareddy
Bench: Anand Byrareddy
fin!'
EN THE HEGH CCEURT if}? K;'?%§'3'~3§»XT,¢:E<::'\i Ki' 3.? '.?\§{"%;%3}_,__{T}§€.Ef{
DATES "ms mg a5"'E'>sw :3?' EUEEEL, zzim j%
BEFORE:
mtg: HGWBLE MR. JUSTICE, ;A3:~:A:-21)'
'WRIT PETITEGN }~30¢39329?'Ai3F:12.i3%32 £5*§j§E$:;«% %
BET'WEEN I
I . Fraizash,
Aged 32 jy'€3i'E§,
{Fix §a}3§3€I';'§<3
ML.:3é,v{3%:f"A§:r5ss;,kkL A
L.}'3.P::gra:1}\:' _ _'
Bangaimje ?§1'f1T1'€}NER
(By Shri.B.§7;amach21ndrd ariii S'$:ri.E'vi.N'amjym::£_= .f';:§v;3ca§e:sj}
A. .....
__. ;(:?0*{V§:7r{1n:t§1zTi_ GE Inciiaf
-- AA"M§n%.sf,%§?*L--c:f'Z§éfence,
'S; £3ui_h~ BHQ,
I'£E¢a:§.*¢"'£}eI'h§ ~ 116* $1}
V !(3~s,wc:§nm<:23£ uifiiamamiaaa,
_ '*l¥{'inistry sf Heme.
E Vidhasz 5§:";ud}1a,
T Banggivrfi M 360 $333
Commandant
MEG and Centre,
Bangalurt: --~ $60 046
14.)
Chief Coziiruiicr mi'
Defence, Acceum {Pensions}
Draupatfi Margy
.J.':a.
A}1ahaba3 (Um _
(By S1r::"i.mvindieumar,Ccntrai C'§e>*g§¥:Vrnn1e:2§'*
fm: Respondent 1819.1} " '~ " 5
a==;='é=as=1=" ' This Vv"r§i Pafiliun 226 and 23? Q?
the C33nstit§;'tic:%n__dE.pfayizzg '.§'> Ql££iS§l the Carder passéci bf; Army 3i1t¥imfit*E:¢:i:»'_ imki-E::i_ }fi{f_ur1_e§i1it*eé'§);" ciatmci 2611538.} 996 and quash fi1&"§:r;§é:' rcj£§¢.&§ng.§i1--s appuzibpasscd by Rash: E 'side their Eettef {nay i'L5'}'+v-i5.;'_'91?3.4,% 3&6), Govermnent of Ezzdia, Mini5tfy&uL{3)c§:fic¢;3=;L.ézgcd E2, '§'.§.999 'aids Anm:xL:r::--H _ "I'hi>:%""{3eiEii;a;: hax?'i;i g bscn htraré ané regenrsd em }€},£};6.iE£'i39 ._c9ming cm for gsrcztzmszecement sf orders this V' ._ da-3;; ':¥_:§}';"C£;?'£IzI'l :.ieIii2<5*':'*I;.*é.§ the fs3i§u~w§§1g:-
0 R 3 E R " x Sim Cmmsei fur ihc pariics, L2. Tilfi §a..<.:i:s (J the cast: 3,21: as §3:.:=§§a3s.n.ss:» The pciiiiuncr was cmroiicd £12 83:: ,é'%.r:31},= on 2$.fEH§'§3€}§. After eumplclism uf' mzinizag? ihc: pciiiiencr is séaiz;-ii is} have {'> 14») bass} pusitsd to 16 Enginear Rizzgimzcni. ii is his e:u:;i<:s1§'i'a3:%;--.§.§:'::egi. he was matdicafiy ami pi*:};:~;i§:a§iy {ii bcsfamz he xagéiafé :«;s;:i-::a.i?£a*{i=§:,'$ V the army. fit: uaniinutzd la; maéniafii.' :z1a§{§i=;:_:z§~.cz:¥:g:§;§;t}%_ '}X;"{E";. which is 311: highest mtzdicaf fiimzss e:«i----:»;§=.i..iz:r:»:sj 'S{ér;;ir;tir;.:'3;=v:29'=. 1995. At. that point of lime:
Mezditsai inspfitciiegn ihcvvificiivviioncr was refcm-sd lejéhe figspi Aficr muiéne itssts, that 9:' "figagi §fl:;g_;§"}1 cf§:ci:; __ is meziimai <:.'a¥.§€gur3;
§§§"£wc§xr¢: weeks WEE}; t:i"f¢:tt;E from 235.1 3 J993,-. vitmtgs Q§_.'}*ms'§cx2:w~"A" in ii}: writ paiéiiua. T§1§:~:
sv:i$"'i.;)g1r$ugni is.i"2;;:....s,:p§niun by fizz: Mcéicsai Bmzsd heid an _ .1 Miiiiary Hespéiai, fignfiaia Canienmmifl Tizig iIA!._'§£.£I"§'1 .w;:%:$' ba:§cd an ihz: mgxizxiun sf 2,: Sgcciaiisi Eésuraa A?h§!s§a:§;_;i"1 ufihe-.2 Army Hmgpéiafé, fieiizi Canienmsm,
-"\
3. It is ihe cunianiiun of £E2e:.: peiikimncr ihai 91::
mediazai auihcyriiicg had nui aiciecimi ezgjg serious a.£En;c:sai_ Yfzcrc 5% was 110 physicai Licfcazis anti EEG was élfismi £0 £3: zmméféfi', 33.2; per 32:: rccummenéaiiun :3? 33¢: Spc£:i:»,:§i:si Nwm pctéziuncr was :::niii.§cg§ E31' zzwnifiifx r¢vi:.:vz:--; if':"'§§E:f£§"~§:.:-€:<§}§IE§i§. Ir: icrms (sf {he £,}}_f)§!§i£>Il £31' the §¥}£L§i§.'-.'«.i.i;"@}£*E.%"!.§"-Efifiiéféii"f§:f§"§.§§£E;T:g Hospiial, fsjnbaia, an 243 i.i9'§§_3;.. 'zafis .~sfpctf§§{"§i;¢:.2"v:sgL;f§<;3§i:3;:zs- VL rzzgexrding tzmphyymcni Q1' the pe::_§i_§§}:;;:3§:1=V_,*§;.,~; @f";5a1rv;;Azjg_V5:C?rét:r 146 {If £977.
4. ii isaih-2: §t2;£§§;§i3*S3€§:§}"':v:§"L'fE27;$i;?' 'é.:~:3::i§'avez1§ié.m <_:s.§ {huge V';;":£:L:(_3I¥2¥'1f!Vi:§'§t;§f:£'iiUIf£S;«.jilvfrt' was amt an 3:: Elzicrcissa: ea:
S:.zra!.gz1f§:V,V vfixés' {7}{}§,5c§fiV¥;.?{i'..%;§§§;';'?é3fi§é(}I}f;§f szzzdsrggfiéng ;§§:;:a:Eé;:e: 33$ ic;::s§:_~;_ fur £311: "§:a»iE.§2.pr%:p2:§?.§(§nt:ss grim tméizz ami §..:>r:maé§m"zs ungier siIsi_;i"§ai;;:Li izaiflrz Qéénicfiiiiyzis. It is an arduuus 15.3% zamicr Whig}:
. §)f:.3§_l(v.1I(2.I}L'»1V' V:?Z$,'z-i giaued. He uughi nut to fiavs beam prescxibgé i&s§{s:.,_t»éé i::'i' he wa:.~: piasczi Tseizms mcdézzai £.?3.§$gL§§"§'*.fiL Thig Vegas 'eggltciaiiy gm vszhezfz ihg: pt:§i.i§£m::::" wax cxpesrsd is; Efic risk mi' :sié*a1i11 and rigour, The wiéiiunes um:-2 again piacmi Eaibra %_a'£<c;§§ca§ Auiixuriiimz an E8.6.§'E>?€?6 an aim Axmj; Eiuspiiai, é Qeihi Caniunnmni. The Spccéaiisi Eiiezzw P}1y:::£t.'iaz': at film Army Huspilal, Dtzihi Canmnmemt, z*c:a:umm<:*-mied i'::r§§:cz"*§.:.f::~:is an the pfliiiiiinfiii" 32363 fmxnd $222: filfc-21: wag. a (ii32g§.3;§§:;né:z:L.i"VT.a3§V 49%, which cuuki not be aiiyibuicé is,» his o;i2.:i,ies_,Hb£:£§.; :::f$;2;7az*§;1.:§§V§§,? an amount 231' Sn: injxxrjg szgsiaiarsczcifl whazun' 's.3{ig:$,'.__£Ti1E,V'§§§:&§1":~f:€§. A' Based an Ehe said r$cemmti:i1;i_aii£3nS,_ E33: E'vE<:t§.§§:t:;:§ Bégzzrti discharged fin: peiiiéuner an 24«$."§,§§'f§; E§"§.2~; {§1i:ut, flwhizsia is: unéasr chaliangs.
_ Thev.j::4.3_£11*:.s::i« E.§§c_'§c£i§i9:mr zlsagagiei 2-mbmii {ital list: peiiiiumgtr §1azi":;u£23§§ azfifizihuai icamz: in Bangaiuxcg xviziciz is {Em"§§6filii3}}t2I"'.$3V"§1¥.Qi!lt:iO\'s='I1 and spent 32:: icsave at Bangaime: 10.4.1995 {:3 29.13.1995. H is aisu :~:§.2iic:d ihat flag; suflbred ii faii while he: xvas gm izzavcs ai and did my! satfibr any Stlfififiiifi izzgury aasi Em E335 V~ *i.gr1:5md the same. Hmwcver, ii is uni}: afier saamgisiien «:3? iezawa A.,}e.:ir1c2"1 he sulkrszi .3 hcadacha, ht: -;_3fi't;:z':::i himself §::;* emminaiityn ms siaictd herein abmva. That §z2j:_:2r'§:, if .%§I'2§.', wigécix £ 3 was fiat: possible cause: for fiat: hem}. a;:%z-2, fer \.&.rir.:i::§:_' cmminad by this Mc<..ii¢.:a§ A{:§i1:;riii::s -:3? i§r;:_r:+:~;g§s?i;a:;€;§:§:§eg and having bccn piaccci ix: Mrsaiissai CaE::g§,2r}.a-C1Ef7" ' the peliiiuncr having been 7¢:f.;a:§0st;(§'-.. £15,» VI'igi,vF'>'i{t$.Igii..V_V¥!!i_E£§3!;"};_ exercises as 9.-:£al¢d hcrciz} a§vv<~:A£o §..1f;!"§,.EA'1€;'§v3i"'A€_§V€A;Vifi';3I"i€,3I'3§.':L'}{i sf. his cundiiiun ané Vizgihc Liiaabiiéiy he harbourezi vs.rI§§.r: i2.q:,_- ' b§g {hat Meéicai A.uihuriiics;' '<_;fiinien exprmsscé ihai Lha "§{3"::*:éi.i1a1"y service and that ii is possibgg. #1:'. he hagi b::_1.§'.'§::r::'(-Li it: the ytzar £995. is i.E1€:I;%i§}7?vr§'E£..'t;l,!!;'{{§i£§€;i:, xvhiuh was mg: 9:: iht: basis efazzy :1'1Véiic:ri;»fl*t:i5'i:.¢§¢::::.;<: r~$z7eihcr iavcsiigaéiung. 'l"hé:a mpinigm E2213 'ha-.'£n«[A :;i§g<,$:r; in having Liischargrzai Q29» pr:-iiiiuzxcr {mm :~:r.:f'%r§<:&!.__'?.:§2s-.2z3.S.3,§96, w§;1ic.:§': is ar§:3§Er:«:r§-3. That uginisgn of ':§:é::.
V n:«s;:2§§1L3ri--i;ées was zzui E-can based en mi}: meéiazai *&E1.':i§f«:.f'S§S. Efizgi ii
-is ¢..§tiI an ihtz basis sf casuai ¥'ue:gs wurk, whiazix 3:213 iwczzrg. aciagi I y 5 upzgn by iha: mcdicai a.::ih::::"ilit:3$ zzazzzarijgi, the: ps:§%:§zsn::r's rnsnmria @ mm Ehai he had 3:si"§::°t:£§ an igzjaztjg wégiirc he xx-'as em §¥:a'~;e: £3 é§é<;: jytzaz' 19%.
6. A1 "the iézmz :3? rcicasc, iige ptziééiumzrr xar;gs----§g;2j:i;3iéig§_'3.& sum «.2? Rs.i6,I6Gi'3- being {Em izzsxaiégiaiiun.....gfax£V;:ié;§§f§}{LR.{3 sanutfirnatci by CC§A{P::m«:iu»n5} P<;éA§ah;:i:r4z£i.. uezmmunicaitxi in the pciiiiumzf i'3}.{ §c:E1:9:::-'..¢ié:eE1;ci fiv5 .é{.E$}§39._.§ T dciiiyemlémns 22%. the séagc of gr;§:i'i-E:;g*..§§1:: $a§::§_amu£:z:§ wuuiei cgiabiisk ihai iht: §:«::Ei£.i:}s1*:#:'r.,w:a;s fgi;:n$'idjz':{éa§--., £722; aiirihzziabéiiégfi pcngiggxsg 3:2;1ii'Tvi§:s:'V $fiz:nxc4V€9s-zgs §t,f§cc£s::£.§, wéiimui 22:~:sigz3§§fi any valid rmasgyriaa. 'E'i'1r:"~g:i«:tb;iiie3;ié£' vssiziic Ring mcciicaéiy buardmi
1.:-u§. §§::».i:~. 32:31 p:'i;;;2!§de;,id £313 magdicai éemuntfinia L21' §§'If3 g,r;_>::n;§s U11 . %.r:<}_;is;:§5; $22.: ;:.2;1iti_ émzision was iakazzx. Tizt: pvcééiimzer Exgywrzrx-'er wag ' giiisn ah £,§_§?_£i{;;f1"QE pmihzténg an apgcai againzéi tin': dccisiesn mi' {hrs u},v.;r1Vé;i§.3£2V éauiixuzéiitzsk Tins: gmiéiitanm éiéeii 13: an apgzeai 5:2 figs " V. Sécrgtaffg, Guvcmmcni sf India Qzruugh 3 mops?' shazaxéei 33 pm' }?;n:':¢:;urc-"G'° is; raconsiécr ifs: ziiscfxargc Q1' fix: pafiiiaancr ami bu enabie the pciiiionssr is cuniérzsss Sm St:!'E--'i§:$, T1%:§:«; agipeai has é .5 nui berm cunsiziared by the iigsmpscé-::§1i Auéizvzéigf. fizsuii in injury, the scmnei ¥m»;puz1é£:ni w§;<.3 2n.»=a:$:~--ap§;fi:«€};c§h}péé.T with a §m,yo.:r is zmmii izim as 2:52»E;>:~Ser\3§;:::1fg1'm~::."s».ié::;._:::§:~ii3 m'e:ci:~:d an the rmumi ihai iirzt: £iii<§rms**--is. mat é:..p«:23:-;i«.:.;::;:§z*;.. i'E:. Pu L_ 1 _ _ is in {his backgruuné {hat fizz: pei§'v§.é£3;1,er ha<i--%;>;$::r.:¢4}_:a VE3"<:gé§.:§ nayiicu fiaieii 23.IZ.2O53i. Ii i:~,:';i:<,;w' fiianiézziéwgf'-?.§1a§ i?x<;?{'A§;'§€:ii§§s3n::r is m¢:1§§«.:a§§}z 13:, zauui is :*:::1zi};"£:__; réfisin ;%"§=;: zzaazaiécai fiincss ccriii'§£§ait:";1j;§'$:5::é&i §£~\;"" 52:6 .§fV£'}'7_;§3'}Z??.*=§a£'.i§§i Exfissaiiégzzzi Q§§.x::-§"
'éiéacfrxezgi +'£{;--..-:5-rs é:::;é2;a¢_§. "§¥§us::i£3§'"é;»:V- v"'§:"<,3a§;:§:--2:.§I f%.§::2cxs..:m»~"i"
::m(§ iizri"ageixzgéiiszéi'zé';:.i§i::s:§E§.r;$ gei izaviygg £:v;'!§'£:Si£§!:¥€:€.§ E225 §2m}~::,::
iim gt:_i§ii;mé:" is §3§;:31;:'§:';._§§iES; Cmazri ami it £5 pyajgcgi iiéas; having :"c:3':1IV'<§ij'z%-:3 fag ahuxzé'"i:£r<.:-:::I:§§a§1c.:<::s' éim , §:§.§m;er°'>: rémsscr Ex:
¢ , E .
I VV§_'L?€¥€!L§:f"v.' " VV .. ?; iizvz giiztrr hzmci, Shri f}%I'di.'§E1£§ Ktsmiagg agpesarizag, fast {$SfiI§§.?fl&€fliS wwuié mzbmié 33 ibiifiws :
Tim geiiéiaygey was grzmiieci in iixez .s='5xm1j+; in ihg Sviaairm Engizzcm ffizmsp anti Cmzire: as 9:: 23.2, 3%??? Afiezr cc2:zz;'::§si£€_;n {,9 of' his Erafinéng, has wa:~: pusisd {ea 16 E?}g§§§$¥ Eiazgimsgzi wig: cffszazti fmm fZ§.u'}.i§'}3. The gxziéfiinngr was a£§miéiw.i'~.§é5«_4_i§2: Exriiihary Huspriiai, Ambaia an Srfiif}. E§§*fi. Hz: . 5' gi a E'\§c:u2'{§ ?§'xy:~.:-ii.:iz3.n and wags f.§agfl§?Sflé§.<S%;?§§E!' £f%1v:--'_22i'E¥;f'i;:3V\'i?:'e:V§3 __<;_ htmé injazry. Hg was piaccd ii; "
ffenipararyj for six: mmitiis z§»if§%;:'L:.§*:'i'ectAhf2'»:3:;g ffififiééfiijber, E9335. {En rcrvicw and E' '%';é2駧~g§§*.;,z§c<.§§;é:'a§ Spszciaiisl L2? the Anny pszééiézgmtr 9.532%.
fuund £13"§iawx'V:§své'iiJpc€i'.s£me13d:;if};?'semaiisaiiam E75:-aizzrcs an account bf {ht §ma':.;ima.y have st.2§§::r€:é£ éuring izis annuai §V<:ave "";5gV(%zs§j.«;-- cckzzsiiiuied fiziszdicai Bgarei rceeznngmngied . ,.-§.ht:V'_;.*32:f{ii§,¢;:nc1' bc §ir;""Lvmav Metiicai Caicgurjs EEK §_::g§'§§.-*3/ii§.§s'¢§:}
--P¢zfmafm:.{2i«._¢ 3:-:=f;i3é.V2';.'?ae~vai£¢.i::Ee:»:£ $231232 {mm scrxrice as im was 3:}: ii: is fa _.sL2'§;§§%:'r . This upizzisgn was apprmfeii by E325 B::§:z;i;}»* = fi:f;:e:iu:"=---§}i' Fvieéiuai $:.;;:w§e;r.~:g an :':,§§.i'}}9é and was; éazfijsx " T._'i'nVé:3i§£§aicd {mi :32? sosrszicrz wiiix ciiibgi {mm 25.3.l§§'§_ Téfi A :1 V' "{::;::';im1iis.2n uifiihc peiiiiensr firm: $34: izisaizegai ;a;u:§2e2"§'zéc:: Emai Exam dciscicd any scriuus afizmmi in ii}: fimi énséanm ix im:m'€£::<:§_ if ii?
$3 2:830 sziaiezgi éhai uggmn fin: pciiiiqmerr bsifig pigs-:5 Lé;_s¥?é9". xi .
Exsissdinai Caiegwry C-EEK {Tc::::g.2<.:~r3.r}s}, as ;.=.¥}__ L} . fix 'xx: » _.
\,*§§lt:i§'I$Z" he had pariiszipaied in tsxerzgisgirs 21$. S£:m£.gé:r§1'*!.:a2::2{,gi f asserlaificd ai this bciakzd giagtr; Exé'-V;::§':_:;* £:s;'v;::i§;._' §3s;rss.:_3§m§:i piaetzd in Tr::mpurar}i igsw Caéeggfig-..Vaz:::_» iwuufigi. £9 §?€:i3"§J3'"{I1 31? ii}: manciakxry dufées uf ?x§i§iian€'--Sr;.:§5vf.icé'.- 'A ~ As adm_ii£c§1§L~V'§r§y 'Q22 ;§*g_::'¥;'§ii¢35fm_1v; i?1't:----ir2V;ze£i sag:-s¥.a:ir2ed at hsaai injury when he; *§.?a*s_ V011' 3n--.éf;i3;:.$}"iéax¥'§ Vfmn": Eff' Aprfi 3*:}':}'5 to 29*" may Lmrs §he._&isa'§3iiity that 2233 Gccagienecé has azorrezuiiy 35t:.:;f: .s:i«:;we(§ as :fl(}E being aEE;?::::€..a§§e: iv: i'~:'§%§é§az°}; " '~ Sari-'Ea: jiifzct £20fi'i§}¥7:£§$;IZi I3cnsi{3n Sanufiimzzéng Au%.§1«;>:"§i§-=. .i§1v2_:f(:»'1{':».;z' paztiiiionsrk ciaim ilsr éézsahiiéiyi gcnséun £2; c:3n{i't:rnt:§<§, "V 3334:: smne has Eaten }"§:'§§é.i?iti€:Z£§, as 333}; saw}: ;§%s_-:e:?i:,'%§§i§.j«;s " cmsnui aiirifiuicd is Miiiiarjx Szmsiazs am} £322: mj;4:s:§.:§z;m is in zigzcurfiancc with ihs R<:g::§;a.¥.iun:~; ami an agagémé fi§:::e§ $22: pcéiiiunczr has Ewan cunsiécmé can iés zzzeréé arzgi has %c¢:Q dismissed. in any swan; the psiéiiematr Eggs bcmz gaaiai gii é H itzrrrzinzfi aiucs am whiciz he: wezrr: sniiéiaai suazé'-; Graiuiiy, Death-«s.:um iiiarzfiirtmzzni £irr.:=.%.:2i.§:~;; h'.é:Li§V§é§'§:.r}g§ §3';;;:_'zA::§:';g,_ «V ixségezr Aatcmmi iiiaianue , Armmi 'i5é;2r:;'<:_s "i'3'e::r:;LF»;';f:1asi. Fund Eaianccfi and Disabiiii}: b«::..;c":"§%:;.= carver isxgier i3'§U£§p ' lnsurafice Fund, it: $512131»; am.Q£'£'£2i§z:1g £{>-E<Z:s.81,¥"§:7>'}'#'¥~ and aims: his is Lmfii {hr M§§i§a3'js.«' S¢mfix:{*,-', §ic §}k_';fifi§}§. r=::insi.2s,!,::Li ink; service. His e§isc§;2crg:: ii; 11;:ii'§'iz:r"i'§if:}gé:§; 31:2,? arbii:"a{}:. _, €3:.§?rt:p§§s;*--.£hs: '*;:i'«;:.L::§:sc§ fur 3&2: pciiéienzzr zamagizi suh-n1ii'--£hai 15¢. g§eg:f§ng'.a;ii:;;,g'tg3£a;2t:c ihai §.§*;£.:: pc§.i§§s.ma:r was msé §::r;:«x=*.§_c§t.=:-d3 v£iVE§: 1nge§iL:a$§_ iicaészzztnis- can {Em Eixaiézzg éémé §:'!t':}=' are «a:i§;'3§ie:,i*31*3ii3§. dtwuhiéfiis wuuizi rcqairc ihai ii}: gimncxums A gr:.x§s.;v2:}é;:4.§. aiangéa-%£h ihs: wrié, pe'£.i§ig.3:: w§§£::h am 11:}: giisguigai E3; 119:2: rcsvgfinéenis are iha uni}; c.§z.:s;am2cz.1i:s :«:a:a%§:§fn§c which veggnaié V n fitzgsiaivti' the peii:%uz1e::':s case. The Ann:::~;ur¢:: 22: Page 43 »¢.'i{2i1:£ain3 tins: Imiings age? the fviiénuiczg 9;? :5: {3;§§§ct: :3? ii}: ilhécf ' Camimiitzr es? Bezifltcnc-Q 2'--'*.<:u:3:.mi3« 23.3 923:' "E\E§3£r:-2 uf fiat: Eviizzigizzg
-:1: Page 43, ii £25 s¥.a§cs.§ as §:.2EE:w:3:=-
8
-mw FWJ ii Mccfiuai 59311? has upizzcai :§:fa,£_}'§£.};
aggravaécii :33: ii; MS" { V Hayes, iiw opinion c:xpre:ss.:;éi~~ 25%: ;§?'t:::;t~:iQ:3 Saézzééiayfiing Auiiéazéiy £323: he was; .c§i-:~2t;11£i§ie:;;"'£"%u:3f:"peizééfin 2;:--:VV§'1'i::'V?;:<:§2g§-ié,§:_>:: maid rm: 5:: zziiribuied is Efviéiéiaazlfi £2: inccsrrzszzsé am? canéfazjy in i§2c:n1:;--:.§.§~:f§a§ G211 r;_::w%i'<iL'«. 'flizx. ;§;C§:e:§ 4;-:32':i1:':E%>e,s§.:§c»z'2 fer such aggrwsir-:i§u;i"'}.A}aé~:'*--Eizéiiirs-1:m's£2::2£i& LEM: §§'2£}£§g§1 Alt: we: £5?
1?
piaccd gknciicr' 3'§;¢T:%x§a Zvfigzeiiazai~.€?ai.{;:g--!.2rjg, EEE €".i?§:1p::raz'y*} i?.:»; 3 pfiréuaf {.29 six :z2s§nV£§i::,"§:\t:4":.2gaT3"ca2mpc*§§r::;§ is ;§:§;§s:.'g,;s: rzgayraazzs rniiiiaryv g:.x;cn3i:«;e::e~:V "£23? 'ba£tiic prepamgigcss, wiziciz imaé icazi to She giésafbifiiy whézsh firm peiiéiazncr $'Ls£}iE:f_s.. J§V§;;'}';'&§.IIL3,;¥{h;€;1'£If3"I,§; began aiczsécsi, ciiixcr in ifézs azizgiézmcm mi' _ <.3b}fc:§;.§"}e2n:': e_3r'§é*£ fim seamzc Qifirgasmcnés 229$ em fiat: uiiza-2: §3::;m§, gsgizéazaiigag xi"; iziabiiiéy £9 prgaézgce rcgurés, is §i€I}:'l€.}§§$§Féi€i? Ehai. Eh: « .[.'.peE.3.}iuner was nué, in fas;:L_ assigngé 323}; 5222?: régzzrmgs exmzcéstzs, =.w§2§s:h aggrwsaiasé §2iss candiééan, Eire: gvciiéion wuagiéi Exam is: be aifgzwed am am: usuui gimme' é '£3 '.3. ii is gist.) signifiezani iixai wen acezawrziizzg EU {E362 siaicmcni «sf :.:tb§t:€:-iiuzzzs at Para ii is é:i(.§§'}fi*:%';E:i_':'..:'.:§f124'§_'>'~¥5'§"I€: tzsnccmcd anihuriiy 1"¥:':Sp<JII$§E'§(:3 193:" rcc;:gmm::nd_£1:_g £;£a.1:é,'g1;--1i5 £13.? . pmnzgiun in the pciiiiuner has tiuifz, ».rq:;.:mnr;:c:i£iea§,':v»iié't: Vés-5.22:-2: V whiciz hmi biifii} reject-:x§ E3}! 32:: 'fi:§£'§;%§2;§V:£:i§'§!V}§,!LV§§§'E§¢'£" géé" ¢§ff;=~:§_§§:r::é=é;§ Accm.:ni.s an an axpiniuzg Whig}: §=?'3 §::2;gnir:&rj§,r E53 @3135 {§t:§f'§$i{¥£i€' tfzéf fin: " Mmiieai Beard and iixcre-figs, i'1$«':§"i~;a:é:{:-'.§£é.:t§--,'£.}'1 in} i,::s:-gmg' The coumsci p§acc$: V!'$'§E.!'I1~£.:i3 gm j:§_;§gxa_cni of the Eeihi High Cuuri. £6' .c§3g;£cn;§'..§i:i:.:£_ fhé Raicfi uugizi 5.2.: be iééttmiiji x-'it:we:d iwvfiiieé (§<~:&:--i4§§2f£g ,a:.éa::~'§;:4sV :2? iii: mmgagggci eff Sm fisxmssi Ffiffélffrfi; LA Sizré fsravimi Kugnar, éi22:ra:a§}i:.z*, gougizi éime :9 mzéiifi 3.' §€_:i'_§°i_§'2?:*;;" efil.'e1'§ £9 azczgm eéezmemfims psrézgézgizzg, §€,'_¥ £24: riéfiazi iwizsn fizz: iiikmcr wag sézzégi :9 Exam E}-::r.::§ i1t,'5I§! wfieai EC: i£§i§3=&.fI"g£3 riguruus miiiiary tsxeruissg avféziciz aggréwaisé §:é:»: aigazzziiiiaan when, in Eaesi, he was {mi asgignaé an}! Suzi: gfizgééss. Ami uiiimaiztijgg ht: has fiiczci :52 a.f§3<§avi§ giaécéi i.e§~2€fi'}£3, mi' Eém § Li Cummanéing €§}§§iccr of iisc pt:§i§éu=:'mr's Rcgimené. w§§2£_r=:;i 2:21};-? szzpgxrriéxgg (iamumcxzis dmyéngg the giaiizz :3? {he §_>c:i§§_i:.2zzs:r.'§'E:aE he: was exmlpetiicci 2:3 tsmiézzrga; iirm saéd cmra:-éstr. Ii. Th: pt-ziiiitancr has fiité .::?;>=j;:<:£&§<.}:é.u$ aflédavii and wouid Eurihcr c:n§hasiz¢A:'.§§1¢§,--._i7é§:i. i}f;3£n " zmzicriai piacezzi an !'§:£:f.3I'£i¢ the ciaini lids ps:ii§iz.}:2%:_:r ?s.a$VVE«tc11 ircaicd in a c-rypiic anti casnzé :z"2zi:1'tii:::', :i"s.f;:xéiL§exé£"§'r:;€m page 11:33.43 and 44 uf the writ pfliéiiigfi. ';*3s;1iit(.%1'?§§§¥}§;2,f~.§€,§_'..:"~§§3E$ :m_'_2 an péigtz R'; -£92: 2-ffesazi ihzzi $6: fxlimiéazai Board wpineii,_E§:cV§z§i23;§§&a.£i2}g-Vaiésgtass '" ii} a§;g§ava%=::»§ aim: Ea ~ :
~.fl'1i§§,%i3"'»*', ;~::,.,-1*~.>1L:6:: '"i'«.>'iS').'". . A22 aéxsiac xalas smzérhé Ehzm $31!: _3. V V ..... as _ «§!§£§f.fit;;:;£.i .13;;3£rés;<3r €'?cn:a:i{;n) -(_1\z§A§"} a1r1<:§R'e.:;£c:-;% rrseurcis iizzzi iii: u§I'ii;.t:r"§}as upifimi' Eifrgai §§ was an afiminigirzgiévc maiiar, Esisiswii cggrpiicaifif igéicaiaaz "ifi 2?-'.':jz::z:.is::::i""'. "§'§'::;rm§i.:r¢:, am '$22: §3.%:.~:§:: ~:,.§' Vii€¢nei'i:r:gs anti £§1:~: finai deeisiun 9? 'gigs: Chief ifionégaéiasr 9,? VA _[)c:fém:c Accounts, {Emacs is cigar desviaééen {mm She: ruféss; ami " ~~ircguiaiiun:; on that aanciiam <31' Liisabiiiijz bcncfié Sines if}: é mm 'urns samziémsing aui§m:"§§y has {mi bascgi iis zit.-é:itsé'a;2'§;« 52%: racumme-nda.Liuns Lzféht: Eksfrszciicai Agixiisor {p::s_z:~;é-am . 'ME
12. Given ihe :2-.5t_>'«-it: Eaazis :;z1fo'.i_ £:§?€§£.{§!$1§£'£X3£:€fiS§-' LIPS'-
pc£i§iu:3cr'3 curxtszltéun ihai "$.12: 122$ ss.»4§wn he was on azmuai §eaw;:,v e.:::§'g sf¢1V';:§:,2:~2;; énézznr ami since; he was diagagfigfi in ?\§-kyziembgr 7:993, afid urzcisrgga sigsgruzes pfxysicai fix: psiiéiunrxr iscizzg pui ihxiézzgh his ueméiiima haténg agg§zwa:.£s:e.§, an flC€L§u¥}i~-- have is 3&5 ai§r§b:§§:a§ iv; Eviifiizzrjss Sergifizé :_;<.2ug'h§.V._i..e,; he zicgaizzci, E}; <i§:nj;éz2g ihesi hr: sasasfl is: fazct »r¢t;:t§rt:ziv E-»'«_xuz1{§:*:_1_'gs.3 any 539?; rigu-rmzs aciizféijx agaizzxi msaiicai aa*§3x2"¢:e§ ai 'i§1 i:;---- §I§§1':'«i£:£1I£:€.'} of the rcspzsngimis. This aimgéai has zmé been guifirgiaxaiiaicd, an fix: uiiixcr ham}, ii $3 :~:§.aiz;:ii in Qhc '~ "::tak:ir'nez2£ of wbjtzciiumg fixai. fizz: mrspmmiani zazaggzigi Imé be in as pgasiiissn ie imsz: maizgzfizi in szggpauri :1-fiizai ::s.2nim2i§mz 3% 3i? Ami ihc: affiéavii 91' flu: Cummanaiing, Gfiiazezr cf £222: §;wi.i%§€.':::c:2"'3 é 'E5 Rsgimsni dated };.é."3'€3<}§, c3i.cg:}r§;:a§§je: séziiingz iizai him was €;:)£C1¥i}3{t:{§ fmzn 1n§§§£az'}: irainigg ané graméc aiming éhrc: r:::TE§:é€:z:z2i parimd and then:-:i2.2m. fiat: §w.::ié£iur:¢2":~,: Liitéafiiiéifif ééggié aiiribuicd £9 nxiiiiargi gcrxiicc is IBJE 3:!§2pa:ri:tL§_.5:,-gr. '§3.1£a§:::é;%§ "
ané ii is moi. 9333: as is izmaz Eirw &§E§§3§71£}?'§§f{:'i§L':5i--i¥§ gtaieggriuaiifg main: iizc :»:i21isr:I2§:.z'2--§'_;V:; in "fizz: ;«g§;§%§2§,\¢'.iE»....:§{§§.§2;>:§i Ittilirfififiéfi ii} rcsurdg. E'1t:r1$§§)rz.:_,__ Qaggnzai E§z:.§2:£s§:§2a§ £12:
pvciiiiuzxssr is m:«.si;§ng ea f¢§>;=££ 3:34;? mg;§:z§e:§,&§t:,.§::§a:é3':t2_. Ffignggrga x§;§;§;;V ...pé:§iiii:n"'-éisrgtsrxscg it: be aiiegwzai amai fig accgsraiingijgaiirgxnzétci- "'2%r2n?;§--:<,u:'e~%'§ is gguasimzci. ii is is» §::=s;:: Egcié Ehai, ij'i:1 .t:'Vpz'."4i2"§.i:_3£3é2"A'..,~_V;V: vdisaibiiiiy is aiiriéuiabic la Eviiiéimgr' Sarviazc »f.iI}{§. _§2::_ i:.~:_ a=§::§;:_a& in diszahiiily gfiszxsiuri {mix} the: am 9:"
e§%s£:§§arg,cj rtspundeni n<3.;'?i sézaifi §uri§1c.:r a:c::§si<§::§ fim pn:,~?.iii-;3:;::'r'.V:~; c-amiégiaizsr-3 fa? may gu§§2:.§_z%r::: azixséfa ::R1§Z?§£3§a§3§€.:}:3§.
", ':'..'§19'.§¥.'..',-':'g§.§1£::' fix-S¥:3!'¥'ié.f3!1'16I} qzmia, }':sms:'i:§m:§ figs pcséiiigazisazf igagaiéiéeg 8 E'! fur szgazh 21 gxgsiiiaazx. 331:: rtgggéumimzé ziifigiii cu;z;_j_§;5_§A'};=-~--.V§z«;i§?§'2~ . L:sr{§;<;*r wéih r:>:v§%mi§.E[§m§1_ ééyé';-,'§' *