Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

- Know your Kanoon - Doc Gen Hub - Counter Argument - Case Predict AI - Talk with IK Doc - ...
Upgrade to Premium
[Cites 0, Cited by 1]

Karnataka High Court

Ms Malini H C vs The New India Assurance Co Ltd on 3 February, 2011

Author: N.Ananda

Bench: N.Ananda

IN 'm1«: H16-E-{ COURT 0:4' KARNA'i.'AKA AT _13ANGA1,0§§::~:

::m:_1'::::3 *rms'm1<: osm-> 1);~:~,{ OF' F'E:ZI3RUA.RY 29:1 E3I%1FOE«3¥: _ " A TE--IE HON'I:3LE :xx1:R.JUsT1<:;;; 3;. M.E¥'.A.N().3483,/2009 {.M\j_'_.'§_' BEIVVEEZN:
M33/£aIi11i.H.€Z D ,1' 0 Eate C.EV£.§*10sa111ar1i Aged about 35 Years N0.1E, G--1. C']'zatL.1n-'e(§a _ Apa;'L11w11¥;s. I 'C' Main Road.__ M11t}1ya1a11agar _ I 2 §3a11g"a}01'e m 560 054. _T ' " , Appellant {By S1ri.(3d:~i(i}'1ar.IAi§ A(iV'O{',£i§§".'}V_ ' ._ I . The Nevv E_r:1(I.3a A5"~:;'S'_1."Jj_1'«';i'i1'(','-f',' C1), Lt:__da :1' . V No.1. Shz§11kzs:'rE_£01.tS'e» ' , ~ V' gm: F'1OQ1i- 1\2Is:%1§:1';«1~;;;CiVn;.1.c_:* _ * " Bat1g'a..1.0re' £3.60 2 ' Rep} by 1*:-: B:*2 *i,:cG1'1 V M --
22.. Mr.Nix:m"

S/0 IJ£12ie,r_. K.K A V {E'v"Ie«:_i ona ESc:{'1Go1} 53 "' E{]§:(Iif"E1-A.C}€1I1(ifi'i glm Main Road 23§F$a;!<213?2:11zaI)1;r2i ' ---------- --« * B3,I1gfl1(3T€? *--,_55() 0 E 6. ...Resp0:1dents '{{:3\/9"Sri.*R.Jz1ipA:'2ii~:as}1. A(}v()(1a£'e for R1. Sri.B.'E'. Pra.sa:'1na Kunuaa =.A(i7a;0c:271L§3 far R23 . V V A V "i"}'1V1'.ss.'2é}';'.":}.V{;r'<~9V,.21} is fiied L:1'1(i€:r sectiori §.7'3{1} of M37. Act. elgainst the j11c'1gmer:i. anti award (ieued 0.1.6 1.2009 pzzssed in MVC §\E0.43?'~'3/2{)O8 on {E16 file of {he XVIIE .»'~\(i(1§t:i<>1121E JL1{;i;§e:. Court GE' V Einfyali 6511,1383. 1\v's'e1I11'Je1', MAC'§¥4, Bar1g_.§a§0z'e. partly 2-Lléowirlg the r:§a§m peé'i.I:i0r.:. for cé()r11§)e:1sse1t;."':o11 and See§s:i1'2gz E?I1.h.E-1.I'§('€I]1ttI1t. of ' :r.:£}r1n3'_2@,:'1saa.£4§cm.

This a}'}pe2a..§. C{3r11i11g,{ on for 11eari11g €:I*.'1is; (fizzy. the: _Co1.zr1 <ie1ivm'e:c1 £h<;' {0§}<>wi.11;_§: ' JU If) G-M13 NT "I'h.;'::; is 2: <;:.1z1ir1'1e1n:.'s appeak for <3n.§:12£:r;(:e,11.1:=;1'i'1. M c>'i"_ (::>n1pe1'1s21t.i(m.,

2. I }:1_a\:e h{:a1"d Sn' Girigihar. >1'C'..f;:1}'1iEfC1 _ fI§{'{I!'T1'S(ff1"=.'Af0I" ' (:Ia1'mar1t.

3. As a r€:s1,:1i'. of 21cc;i:d.§j.31'i, "Y1?Tj§~d 5s2£iI'i"ere:iV3.i"raCt.L1re of left ubial p1a.'{.e:.21u. t.reateci in §VI.S.Ramaiah Mcfiiiatgil Bangalore. The claimant :f(_)1* V§r:'{'ii1<:'1.i()r1 of fraciuré. i,Ii1_c cfiaimarili was aged about 35 years; slic-.VV_\$?21As 'Z{'eaeher in (}ovc:1"n1:1c2.r1i. High :SCh(){)1}ii.f.V?§/izélikéili, }3E;I;l%§Ei1OI'€ ]\§01"i.h 1)ist.1'ic:i.. _"45<f3'\5{2vDE'.E3£1i'i.£ii;fj.i....EELH., on substécguenf: exaI11in21E,i0n of <*1}21in_121i}.,E.'has $i_z3.1:eci 1,1121: c'1aima.m. s'11flE:rs3 from 1'est'.r1'ctTed A "E11{'3v'vf'E'I1:}Ii2}71'{'3} bf :1TI3,fi._v."}{3vv'e:;' limia. Tile ciai 11121131'. has 1.0 suffer 33211.11 2mcl.__ine<>:7.V<,%-r1§cnce during raormai acréivi {.1'e$ of1i.f<:~. _ v_ -V " J/.

5 3? T 'mi «'1». 'E'h@ 'E'1'ib'u1'1.211 has £1\3.r211":?£e.c§ (:0r11pm1:5at.i£>n of Rs. E..;:'3 E £28/~ L1:'1{i<3r 1E)E§()wir1g §'1ea(:1s:--

;_..a Pain. and s31.I.i.ferit1;;;: V.
2. Loss ()§'z1I1'1e.ni4;.ies anci r::1".:}0y1'1'1c?z1i of life:
3. Medical and i1':(,'idf31';te-L} (.>§121I'g€s: "Rs.v5(},OG0}'~.,
4. LOSS of e211':1E.:'}g5 (iraring ]3€71:'i,Qd <)§'J""*'--£{g_';>,2;V_;.:;:'.'3";V'7' 'u'€:am'1e11{,:
5. Disability zmd loss of }11ar';"'i2%.g;Eé a 'Ré;'.73»G,COO;,5s' p1'0spec1.s:
6. £)21:11ag;e to vcrhmler: 1 Totai: . ' ~..R"s.1';:51;'426/-
5. On hearirxg iea'r__:1 €:d C.iZV)11I}S€'1~ §'Of'.CE£1in"lEi1'1i', and after going through eyidcénceH_2};id__i:}i§2 j'L1C1§§II1€I1i, I fincf c.03np(:nsa1.i<):;*' éi'.r;§a:f'dcci=._b3: 3i*ib't:11'a1.V"urldéu" 'the: head "loss of aII1e;1ii::)'e1é:" "j:311j(5j§?;e.11e:'5a€.»bf i§§'e"'*"is§ ra1.he1' inadc:q1.:aé.c:. The 'i7;"iE)L1.nV;-11. has :i'(.{Ej' -~ .;iw;,-1i"d;3{*E'-- COz11}:>ensaLi0n under the head ..' "£'L1{1.11'e :meciMica1"--€$:'p€.:1sE,\.,_' .

Therefore, 1 award ac1c1':t:E<:>'r1a1 coI11p<msati<511.., cji'V"'Rs:-€0,000/~ under the head "loss 01' 2a.ra=iLéi*1.ii;bi-sis »& €':11j<3y1*1*1*c;=.'ni. of §i§h". I a.waa'd C{)I11p€nS€1t§OI1 of 'RS'.-I...5.*Q0'0/Va "£.£J_v.r211'6:s "future 1'1'1cdi.<:a.1 c:xpe:1ses"'. 'I'hu:':';, ' 'e1 2.:1';--11'1aVr 1'L .<éi'1;i'.ViE'::1c{i 1.0 Leia} (:0mpc=.nsai.i()n of RS. 1 ,'?E3/1»26/--. W :':3'>-\,-x. ~--e..'i-':'x'\ g

6. In the 1'€%Su11,. I pass '£116: ib1.I(>wi1'}g:~ CDRDER The 9431363211 is a::ctc.ep1ed in pafri. 'I'm: i1'r1;mg;.1'1.r:d;" e1§%?z:z5:1'VVi':5. :1'1(}c11'fi<--:*c§. Co1"npensa'i.i()n of Rs.':._5i,426/-- "":;17w2:%:L:{.e--"r€i L}? ' 'E'rib'1,31'1a'f:1 is e:}.§r:a11':Cc:>,d E0 Rs..I.7€'ikiA2f5;'--.'_ 'T116? Of' 1h.é. izxlptigxled aw211'd as i?;. 1*<31a£.e$ 1.0 '1'é'i1::e i)f ;'ni.er;-3s't'.».p~€1"1'£2d~~.o'1'~,V a<r(:1'ua} of im:eresi: and 1iabiI.i1y.._Q§7.respo;1dt%113',sV'v_is <§0iifi;rmec%. The paymetlt. and i11v@sfu;.n¢é11i. ,E3§"I"c"1H' 'l3E'.VVT11 {he réiitéovévoived by the T rfi:)u11a1. Pagriies are 6}';1:t<:ii€_(i7't.§) bE§E'i-£"'¥Vh'é':§f COSi'.S. §§§_f* §§$§§