Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

- Know your Kanoon - Doc Gen Hub - Counter Argument - Case Predict AI - Talk with IK Doc - ...
Upgrade to Premium
[Cites 0, Cited by 13]

Karnataka High Court

The Commissioner Of Income Tax vs M/S H.P Global Soft Ltd. on 2 August, 2011

Bench: N.Kumar, Ravi Malimath

; ll $3 M" KN" THE HKGH COURT OF KARNATAIM AT BAN(3rA3;«.(}§RE §)A"E"Ei';_§jI) *;'m$ ms}: 2% DAY 0:? AL;'C2USTL_ j__ A' E3'RIiSE§N:".."i'~»V ._ 'THE E-IGN"BLE ME.~g§;fiSQ%'if.§.%4i*~E;% " V' ' *mE 1mN"3LE .1113 €;;{::%0§% }:m'\7~@3;4;:\L; 1 1 1, "m'{-3 <f;i:<;:>MM1$€5§:<jm§,E::_mi =':'NC3OME.<1--"E'AXa (72% 'BE.3"i§,if}ENG;_ * "-

Q; .5 Ezgaw S' "E2,;_O7A.E§j> }"3;;__w GAL,<3'R1£;._.« ,

-:?;. E'§~'*I._,E'E'"Y CQMM1s$1.0:N§=_«:R_ Oi? :Nc:t:<>1v,: §<::'mx » _j?*'E3l{§TL4'§E.¢;._R2'?x1?\;E{?£'1'§, _ 1%?

u",m©M_ALa_, Eim {f{1éT§g'§Fx/§3'SE3E®E\J'.E§:'{ me" §1\I(Z?{§}1'x/EE-'T};"A:>{;.. '-C_3ER{Ti;E<?, {:3} ms':-3ifm<;>mANA E%UH.E.)INC%.

- N,R'w>;x".{"§--ELENGA Ram), ., " * B;AN€Z%AL()E3%£i ...A§>>§'>§a:.JmN*§"$ A:a;5c2=:;sE.;"2.gg {Z§{'f?z'<:7<;:.*!',, Emz" $?'1C)E.£§0'l Eye ::.a£Zm..;>e:°o§ a5a '"i. K"E?E,7€F'?,E£€;3;' expez"s.$e3 01:3 ii men; ém:z.m"<3u::i'. Nib?" E3'E.£5,i"§1?I'¢i "

gt;mI"g:)as:<;'CF"'
4. L<:*,;;1m'.:t:£;.% ri:(>u:'2eéaeE €02' ilézim-5*. ;."'§'€;:;'éj'§r'€,',"3;:%.1§:%' :1./iiihfi .1§.I}'1:§T3E.§§;§I"it?f£'i§ t;z«.z-"aim :.:<>r1£.c:z':dc><i'% '.:'"e:;.g};V2:.z.n:i :'%;"<$.. i.§EI§§H '§'mvm'Ewir:(;§ afmd the 1'} 9.? mm of \V()sE4'iL:<;;. §%';e§;fc:r 'V%ET}.'pv£fi?{"}'i'fififfléifI11 M} file §€.€:"if€5€'3h()§{I1 _§>2"e;%£'I1ii5»Aa:;9:§V}" x>xf§}t3i.£;--_%a.vL'. . f;*j;:1§h1;"'§Y'1;§ N1. II(".1i.'i§ .'UE'€';T. 'N'w1"eE'{;>r€;x "L§"i€3t .A:aa,.~ :*:sa.<:am;g".. i€) E'i'i.C<:'zf_ *\>s,:;~::»:§ j'2,:ss:3i"E'§{,§t:tf'i in '{Z'€;'.§5:?.§ iI'}§§ 'ii. C'fa;.}:i 1:3,}. E'?j2x:pe;?:'i'1ci : r"r;x. 1 "E"'h<3 'V ¢.:';%:-::<5'1%.;;m§ K-'\,-'ii.h(Tx{,2.14 g;m>pai:.:'iy {:1Eff§i}1"¢E?'<§.E§,§??t'37.-E1}gg K'__"' A .*f"_€::"3%f.:;§'--.o'i'1 :'C%--<;',!..."::..:"C§. mwsti in }3<31.<iin§§ mm. Eijw fizszizi a3\>€}m3:"a.<:%1i.m4€:"§$,,i.n. t:V§':j£:§ V"'I"::>.1i;iu":i*; ca? 'i'"€:':'.'%z,="€'}'T}'X.,1€;'; <';'::>s:;'.:€ér1.{.i2'.iwm."¢;i*: amci ihem.£'€.>:r."a:nfig: Més:,;.bmM::3'.§.§"§:ex£;';'::1 {tam my mtc::"§'m*m1c¢;> Era 2'1'1.a.c§<:~:: <::ui.. P3}. {:m'm:a. the its:-1z"1:1<:d Se:rT1im: Com}:-s€:'E :211;:)}j)e5.1s*§z:1g éc mm:e=:m:i¢3,(:i 14E'1;-M. Té.}'"1e ¢3;3':.i.r<r s;tx'p<:>:1(ii'&Lxr¢:
i1'"1<.';?. ";j'.'.*."§."'€'x'5.i E1': "gk-r::~.:g:}:4:?('r*a" <3? }0.z;u:3e':d g;>1.'e.rms3es~; <1')! which 'the;-2 . g3_<:%*'.__ mg-»;--' <:mr'm:;: "§"'E"1e:'e;<: E?.}siET}€ff2"}C§i'EE,E.E'(';T?:S xx.-"e::'*c;: .£.1:1cm"r€C§ §(;>z" 1"i:3:;1E<i:xg;§ '*%'}é;~: §'¢'72z2:::~'=;<3. §3E'"€'§'1'1§ET+€'ffE:i {ii Fm' <:m."ryi1"1g;§ aim b2zs=,§m':5at.s3. whicih its in WEE? %%%%%% ?:§ m2:m.m:;*. uf {rm} w€.m"E<;.s:~sq <':§<~;~.<':t':"icr2;a§,% xmrk, i:'z*£.::~>2"i.<}:" ¢:i<:%a':0z'a1vf:;§m.;; {>fg,{:.. ii".

a%m':m.a.m..s:s E0 :"mre1:[u.1@ E1X}i)6ffI"1.Ci§i.1iH"€i zxzsd 'K.E'1w'téf0*z'§7;'{m'imfjti :.v__fi<3_z"

inE,::%2*§'é9z"&%:"':<:re: Eiliidfif {.mi..
6. in 5;z,2}}>;'}m'i. m' E:i":é3i33"€ji%m"'i;<:r1Ej.§m;:3,'iéz51t':';§2<'§T <?<>z.z:1He3E. far '¥:)a<1>"z.h. U'1€;'.': pa:'Eic~:s~:» §'"1aw:= .:"eI:is:<4:i 'o_x": 32:c.'Eg;{mé'm:'$:;._ 7*'. '"E"§':<=:> Apt-tx Comm :2::_'£i.h.;e <':e:1:-$6 mi 'ZE'_'r'*&ven,¢'am'2 Cuchirt' iifaaamicais aid. Vs. Commis$iQ_iier_ sf Ine5t3rr:e_AE'q§3c 1."€';'§3€")f'"E4€:E{.§ in [{19"?"?} 106 ITRV ' ; w'iL§i3 L§'".i€3 af<n°<-':.~.:sa.i<;i q_m:s::+&;§at:«"ri Vifék-_:='i:iiifi'§'1a1t';?i 'V"i.§"z€%~;§.'L.aE:?:'::{>1f§V¥;'ié':é:9; 'iamh in E.§"n':~'a c:m..zx.'m°y ;:m(:E in 'E{':/§'"I£55'}£11..I"1< ;§. E": ;£t,'V€i?V -,}{;>'i1';«1:i€:«:?£ ¥T€V;s__1'{"E:.1';'e.. c1§§§°i'.i.e;?a.1§H(--:S;: in ik;>I"§:I1.::§zé:€.ia"1 5 ::1"<:*.(:§:=ss€:s mafia;-5:5; for L<';'§;E;*ss:i.ir'1,g;z.:.§s5i}~_i§1§g~.-- " efizespite-LE €'3X§}C§"idi?.'§.'UTC'. f-I"(T}':"I1 E'"t$V(:E1'H.'i€.% " '~ .. '~'3"?'?~E?'<'j"":="?~€3§§{L1.,;"'ii?» "E'§"E<=V>' ~§_é.:::1.<:.* pi" {ii enzzi-11'<:%a1§<.nA1 Egmszz §.]€:'.'f:?H §'ma:'fst.i 'K0 Em "=wi:;:f*.é*'j;,/-. .'i%1i.};'i;*~ 'SZLQ->E"1E,:«1.i§'1 'mzpaci $53153 havciu hc}w'<:éve-mi. §;;)€:?:€3n E.a§<:§ e:}ow:'2~ £i'£1H:L§5."*ii">f '§TE';.?is'fl-.4-$15? ":5"-' 55'"§s?§§~§€'SE..c:::'§ E33' 'VEs;:s<;;%01z.:z'1Ei C:a:1v:'--:: LS. in j .A.é':i¥+€§z"¥'g*..'>§':.AXE: I'€§;"z'.£.zTsf'2. Ir'2.s2.¢Ecz.&;*c£. f'fs3.£Sff}g; €Tc:2;EJE£*::; £151» {W25} £6} .. 'E{1;t~._{IT€ia${e:; _Ef";E.fi {'3'--EL} ap§_T>@;::Ars :0 have §')¢';':ft'1fl §.e:12"g<~:Ey Ewiiiti-'f§_?1..@C§ in %%%%%%%%% wax' EC} Efzrisrez {:r<'>Lm€...,ajy Exile? {i:w'h* L0;fdshi'psa §"1z<1\4'€~ ¢.::§:+.z<3u>.<:i - Vi:e5<:':eim1:'1'§ C.a-W:';*.?'-.%: .;Fu(:"ign3.m1.€..g '\:v§":i{;:i'1 212°C? as u;'1::.im.': __ "Va/Eézem an m";3ez'm',zf.i.'1:.:reV His» mc"z§3'e'§;;'."_;: _:.£.:§§:'h :c:; :?>z'.c9m so Eyrmgzérzgg {rm} ex2'séé';r1,c:a{., zf2:f; A' c4,:i"a,vc:.r2.Z"<::g;e flu?" the ¢::'tc£z;z"i:?g; Qf AE's*€;:('%'s.=3: V' ?..m'.r'aR" Efzczf. 2"':'1c;.>re is ve;"g,; g};'§"<;{f r'€aSi:"<;~r;; §'§r'gi3f2g~;> é.if:i=;é§'a;rVz=="z<;9:z;* 63;" sgjwziczi m'r<:;.:.rn$zfzgzszcaaa 'E'<:::m;i:fV:'zg.:; {.5 ..¢fz}"§,' {:);jf;::>(3s:fir3 c;*@arN.*E.u.;;<;£011) 'gm .:.?}e:c1'_£.i.z'2g,f"Vg;2 ..&;>,x:;9:3r1v€32f{£.Vés"e ;3rog:2e2r"£g; «:'m'.z';'%?3'a,z§:'caf.,>"ie§ ;fzm'7'm §;:L1.£)':?'-- W m:::g;3!I:'a£
8. "._§.V'§%_;_a=: f_:;~g , 1'11.' §;?'1é u€'}é;~*i.%:§e:+ of Assam Eengal Qeavraerfit Céé} €§fio52r;i_ini;ssio:}ier cf fncame 3'ax r€?_pci)§'1.&:Ci 2:": [(4% ;953€§} :27 2"E'".::¢§L?'V.f? }e§:_»Tf(;E*s';_.f:.V'[}';i'»»«.e2.:XpEa.§:}.iI1g £316. {;:E.'1':e;iT,,ir1{':E':i0n 1">eri.we<*:.z'1 i.he;=: C,_72;_1p.}ii'::>LEa"=E§{;):%?3'i£;§iiAm"é%szmd Re.\»'erm€i 'E%Zx.p¢;?1' t.<7Ei'1.2:rs: IEm.'id ass :.§2.r3 5-3x;)<<.='2"1.€§.iE{ma is rrmrie ft???' :<7£.<::(;u'iring; 0;"

' E}§*£.:€}§,£.¢) €..>..:ri::9z;encc an as;se3{" <3?' ::£0E.s.%ctzs~ufa_c;s;' fm"

:*:§1_'e%.>' e:rnfE:i:.z:*i.rzg; E;;>em;ffz'£ Qf (rim §;m.s;zT.m2.<;;;; E1: is g2z"<3;>e:W§;:; ":,:%.V£:"_::'%*£'E3':.:iaE3E4c=: £4) cagrrz' {£15 czrld is Qf" me? m:;z£zm,-a~ 9}" <%<";_,z'):'{a.£ A I &:')<.fpé?i'7€(L§i{E,.£..'?'€?. ,§'_f['on. {£2.53 whsyr haneci ii. :3; :"z'2zf1z:§e.> noE_;'<::r"

A SE19 ,g'>m"g;><;;.isa5 Q!" b:"i2:g:7;m.g :?n£.0 (2-z'»<2'..~3::£,'e:-ma:.'z;:> (EI'E_E_} $2.5??? .13 9% "3"?'2e-V-3 5:§aq;%r<:zTr2e:2 {j'::7:mf" in zm Asaam Benga3VT~-fiémjnent .. Ltdifs case {supra} ax" E3'ara~5 fms he-21:2'. as :z4z'zc£'é§f:«=- ~ :-

"i'§. ';?"E'u°.52; s;;:'zZ.?'1:i3sf5 c1:Z,§.4arng3z*:'e:*€;i 5);; {.}'I£3'vf;7i..§:§f'~§3€E?'.'?T£.%:?f3 qr' {her} E;.a§'?.(:>r"e3' Hz'.gf'2. Cour! '€;".'F'$.'E:£§'E(.'-f7(;zI§'<,~':.*':.V;<;-',". {.?§€;§' V g.w'i:'2.ct§g9Es:.=s; £..z.s?"z.z'.Ch, e..>rm3r"ge3 jm:7."%,g 2 1 T c':a::'::e-':*:~; mE"2m*e:t} £..he+ <3x;3<;?r1diz..'z.z;j§> (:51; $2 15151;' fm2T* £'§':$:.»3 vé:3..;j§:';c§£3 ();.z§;Ea.g; or for" (;>,:<'£Te'z'1;<;é(>z[u€"' a ?;i:*2..s:'{f"':.z<§§u5; (:1. :'m.§;):~i:zwz,§f(1E r€pEas;::e3=r§f:re:'1z .Qf <;:§i.'g:_:.é;V>n~1efi"§£ ;*£3"'té'§r<3 5:; W1) dam)? Eghrxé. ii zfS"-- a}Q.,.{2€i';'Q2.E4{.;£*.:%.."g§éE:;€§Z§€:'émg, A Cap{€TaE.

assm Q?"{.616_bus$216855 €$-,z32j'fV§'§e§f '€';w* a-'%2<E,<'3z"ze:.fed. or ;<;z.aE_.3s£;'€xrtz'z}Q §¥§; s'§3;9ic;zré§€"i <':z.4;n ('t*z' if2(.fi___§§£.z.{'.£c2.§j §,:.>;":<;z€.<:»*::eer be 2753. <;5»:9>s':..I:_rCAé:3..2;:rE'i£;?§§':;Q%=££T $3' <:.§r'c:z:;::>rz _f'z'c)m £.'§'2<-3 <:c2ag3é£(1E air" £é"u?;%' ~z',ziér_.for3"'z7é:;--{ '<g,f £§':a.5c12 CO;2;!{,".&?I"?'3 £5-2 €T&?I°3"("/Z£".I'2.E§,f ix"; me» £"V2VVé::'gi'§-Ef£:"*£§:p ':.3{'" ~%§':1gjJz'i'E.:LZ "=.g::%;;:»e:2*z1€f.£.E'ur"e:2 3"E:a e:g2.L<35;€'i€)n §'%.:;>a:;ie:¢:2;_>c,%:' V c2:"fL::;e:;e;s; _ }'"c:n' (T'C}}"'1SiC3i€?'€¥£,'iC.>H. :_.z:fVa<»3n»:;* ; '<2%X§f.><2?m".i§£.m*ci?'{S :£n;:c"':zrr°r3d. wi1iE.e i.h.e: §.3:,z.$z';'m5:; £5: g(>€r1Q g:;2=.,a;=¢:(i is ndz'"'€2*':?:.?z.ir2'e?5€ &?§§';'1€??"Mf'§C)i' e;'X{<;?r'r.Si<,m eigf' Ezfzzé §.,--'.;ii$~§?'§;é;?SAE3v .:c;>r_fo:" I'M: :~;'::.b:a*£'om€,2f£;z£ ;="(';'p§C£.(L'€:??'}'i.é1t'?1{ Qf ifs; .sfqgz.:iz§;:;:'22::§§f'1.:';'. Sucrh €3.'.'("_,D€?RC§iI.i"i.(.f"€2 can €39 Ec>c>ic::?z.f (11.5 e:=,>é§'§a-es_:;;fk*<;;'r"r €'§'Et% p<)z'rz.£ qf' uziem Q}. w?:c;a.s" 3;; m'.7q:4:.irc(:£ or j%'c>%;'jr'1. Em: }j)€)iF'Tif Qf £...=2T«:2z.L% €34!' E..1.rIw:£ is :iI"i.z::.* E§{}££l?"(.'."(*'3 _g"'m;'n * 4_ t.U?"a£z:?'z. me w:p9r:cfzTI.:zre is :";'7:.<;:a.zr"md,g gf" 2'.f'2,(a ' »*xpe3r'zc1fi..a.m::? :75? i"{I££.d.eE'.' for a<:*qa.1:'7"z':Azg_;,;z <3!" Z3r":r'z§;Er2g mm ¥ 17 P£;??":5;'§.{Ti2"'i flif. C.?0.2;3.(i. --VVs--«{)c1.i{: fsrupmaj (?2.g:};'r3e3{£. 4.:..;3&i.E3 . }€<>:.,i.?§.a.§.£',, J1, iIhc;I{ by €3F"£CiE,.£?"{?1§; E:')c:32"ze§_fE'£ c;>:mM£u.;**z":Tzg,r in {"316 £.U<ZI.§j z.F1.cz€._}"i,:mcE Cftifiéfaf {;?:''ac2'.*:.e;ré?:é¥.;», "

"Z/M7: a=_?xpe3:"2.cfiE':;are 03"} €££Tt}'E,.E§tf'i1'}3(jjm[E£)€?I.f'i.?"EQ"%:}?¢fi;i;>§£'é;5?;§.. z'.;<;?_ 230$, r2'2..r;>z.ciTe3 is/=z'£.f'a <2 U§.€.'IH;3 5.0 c;;<?qz.:,£ifffz1g kfggf '{3'£'%;§§.élé--?f§?.§;gV' a.::::~s<«:~E.. 3'? 5.5»: m<;'a:rie3 mafia a :.:}z'.e=3u,= iii) ::}z':_':€gr..z.£r"i:'%§ »;m"e ».«_ia::%;;.§<;:1_£f' Ejhm'. E?"2+:.i€;_/J be &'a.£1'z"2<-26$ <i3u<;fr"_ i.i~:._z'f'w (A?.E::£"§:T€i:'.{'2f; §f$'€Ef€§A§{-";?"'E1.é. J2 mi:1;:)c:e.re:1,f'iv<a-331;; s;a51.2'igg da;£c'I * ._ 'T I .Lc:2.?h;(z:r'z;, CM' ,, c;&;>;?c:rz...:g.::ai."'£53 E:%:,.s.z?'z,L. _.?\'m.z.>£;;;>'Cz'pe?:'3 L'z':<fi ésizp A:~;:.~:c3Cia£,er:i N&?z.éffi;~t;ja:}¢§?fs: §7i2'.§§-- .f?"'¢*<1{e;'s"c'z£ Cor'n:"m:
<;}_';"" 7§"(LY€I.£.i(iF'?.V {$£{§1'}?"C1.}.!. ..
.... ..f'.Vy'?'&.:<e_zi E'?':;r3 .v£x>e;;r?:'§?E.§;_ .';}{3?'F'??{i!*ELr;Zi???E" ass' '<3r'zci.u.:'iI'":gj;' are }:s.ss;erC3I. 5:3' v:i'?::['é£~; 7:::'<'m:=<:¢i:Eig>;-=,: 23:" is no: :1wn.n 3: {facts} rm; ada,.v(:m;t<:1ge_'§..i}E:%§::tf'sf:;;.7_£Ei'?::'é? ni7;3If":?»u"m;2ci z..m'.E¥ E5259! fin" swear", '}'f'2.e/3 L':;2'.£s2f'§T?'Teg:£z':(}r'27,z.u§2i:fh is Cirazmz is £:'E'2.a.z. be§Zs...m:;*».<;:*:2 §'r"zm"'<.;9 OF' :£7.£3':?:5 :'ae3c:z.1.V2'":"<'m.E. e»,>x;::s:2r:,5<::s'.: iz'1a,>ei3£:;:<3c2f 15.: 3. mm r'1z°,:1g €}' Em$;zT:';e;*£.;:3r 5321:? an e?xpc*2'zcff§z.m? Vgfim' iffm i:;:e:>=z2<;3_,!"zi:t Qf éf.V.E":.:£? ifiififrégfsg as; 51; u.>ifac>Z@".x*e:'.,g..«--'"«':%r"2£m'gea:'nc:*nE Qf ' Z"E2.{3 {§??jLt;:m§";§m.fizTE.E (?€_N'§'?f}C1E'?y"-Jpt3'Ls'"f'?'2.€iF"E€:?i'Ei ir's'z;Jz'c3:,>9r::'2;cm.5. in 555;'. ;:'r?.t:E.'<:z"2ic2§ ff)?" E.r'mm:ze'.e_.=rz'<:££ 0::-.:;»:<-:€.:+; <32" file: m21<:e3rz":w "

\_f"{.Xe3*<?£; c::apz'i':'a.E4 zm{€.)z,a.<:?1e'3(E), zfw e«.:x';;Je:22'1€fiE:.ire wcmicg TE:-A-'3'T._V_ am. r*<£z;>e23rm.e.* ::4.c(_'.*<:>:.u'2.é', even §h,(;>u.g.;?'2. £:'E'£,r;«? czda.=.£:e1"? ' r'm;"::§.Q; e1:-rr1.e:;'irA,zr'a;? __}'E:3r an :"I1.5i(»,3f£.r'z€§.@ fa,1I;u.m>. ii.<;«':»i:fi H 6-';'I'E,€§F..{.!'i.?"?§§ .?:;M3r'2e;§,'fz'f'. €53' t.P1ez'<;f%2:js;g _rs.m, Q." "{'?"¢:;'¥:'::r'.:_t}'y.E'i:1:."~ W. Cf(JiI'Z€L'é',M;ES'fE,?é;;" {:<~:?5;f' omci "E5. ca:'m(:>{' {'26 c2?{3;{;€£i¢9c;§ 'c;s.';-~15?"

l*?'Zti:?{i'?§"E{l'if'2fE.'€l.5i§j z.uf'E:'E?T(>u£ 2*°e3gc,zrd) z' 0.__i.f':E:§:_ ;gV)CEF"§"i;:if;'v§E§"ii'v'Jf5TZ.{igEffi'"

m1,(:i Czirm zm3m1'2(:eas; Of {if g;i:5¢~;.~:;1. ~:'><:asé2, 'f EL '.F?¥'1<:% Apex'{ib::.m iii}1.§§f'i.€:..V_ifiT.Ef3.§Si'€'f' <3? C0:";"1.2m.::;&;é(mar GE' ftwame Tax V3, Madrjfi Ltd. I"tE§"}€,)§'"§i3{'1 in [ii 998} 333 EEK' (SC); Eiéiés '}':1i3ci'c:.i'r.3xw'iz:2V-- {Em g<:*.s'3::t:"21I. pt".%1'§c:':§;3E(3%s:es a_;">§>§.i¢ta}:3'£t': gig}. _:«:.":'«:§»;:i.é:"x§é:'_2'i:z"1'ii':--§§ a\r;ri.~1e.§E1eéEv::" "pa.1fE..im.;Ear ecxp€:%m3i'£i.Lz'r:t £55; <'2;2.pi£.;:'sii._m": :*€:'a.':e:i"1.w§:3--.;;wxj;»e"m;}i'£.--242 T1'1:% C3(}m:'i} in fl;'1t:+- ;:2%:3()'W €I.,'&-'%.Si€;'f Emrés; 2;pp[3r=:3x%<z*:c;'i §}'1§§?' i..<:=;*:~i~:r£1&'~:v mid e:i<;)W13 31:1 U'1€'i' A!'?zeI'I<'>r'1 E/.'::. f*%rz"i€;§hL' ?.§'Z$1£§Ci§'t?£','§ (im;'2', §~~;E'eEs;.b;j (1%/z.bEs3.~3 Lfizf. {lf$}:Z5} M} 'j!.'(,7 E23???

"1i"«'.Tr:'4:§'"<;§"%f"E"i!i?{';!'i' 1:1': _ss;%;.:.p.2"2;1, w§":i{:'h 'W€;1S S;i.i_H"}.}"§1é?i1'§ZEEd :.zm';'ie2r:~- " €}:'..gsfEs:i§; is a;ic<3r"r'2c(i to £1365? {.'{."Jf]IZ)§§.£fZ'.Z £.£Jf'1€;?F?. if €54; "f'j_n';£c:.<;§e% _{{>r Em-;* i;"zz'f.ia£z'<.:m Q!' (2 ?)i.z$ir'ze?s8. far' .' "r:«3;s<:£i.m"2.:;:{.c:m (3? ca bz..asz',n<;~:~.:.%3% (>z"'f(}r Ci. :~fz£f3s§.c2r'2£'ziai .»""'fl'F .~r-"' mg3E(;:.(:een'm*1.£ cgf €:'Cj'li.£;:ZL??'F"¥{-',"}"'E.f.
ff} 26} Ei7Xg;>er'2dita.sre z':'1aag} he f'.:*e(z£ez"f as; p?'§Z§#Z2#3'xT§é£%§~.,' c"2.£'f:?"ii:mm.f;:E@ E0 {..*apz'.i':aE Lvhmz ii' is _ (mfg; on<?»::> <:m.a? fcvr aii, bat: :;;>z"{}:.
bn".:'?g_';2".ng ir'em <2xa'3£'z:rn.§em >{'£?"€. §:tJ:.§és:}e%(:*':,~: ;c)2;' * :'}_t:=:,V z:s;si§wc:z:'ztj.agc "_fD}" We cirj£cJ£z4:f:i.r'2g;{jv .§_}_€;fI;'£¢;'jfiE. 'é:§,?"'=.__c;: .« E'2"aci€?...n.§j" ézriwzf. §}'(.}f. :'"IT.d_ «?,J}f_ E35; <iE E'_;i.§§2p "s;«;z,:'ajn."< g:>cz;;r'r1.e3;'1.:: is an {:_?i¢'m.aE .§L:if:§F%t.F'?.c;f$f':T: V§£:§{§fEf:"E..§!€ r:§1a::.r5;€(>:E)Ee? agczmsz ?K="',VE:.4?<£:l;*'£_Z..£E:'. .1"? mg: [_ :£'z:.mg§% smm _;}<:agm'ze:3r'1r: f§%:"iiu}J5€£{§. _'&,-';cg';1:§5"1EE§:.g .?:>:€;<'~--_rfeggcrézxfizxéif 52.3"; {TE f;Jz.z3i1'1€:_~'.;s e.*{jgjé;7:{'32':s'§4,L.., $':)z§.}','J' .{§f...§'?';;g§ E:.z.z"n_;:3 gmm
g)(i§_}r;";s;I'2E' %);*£'f2_§;.:s*-- in Va.«;irLCzp:'f(;z.£ . §Lé;'s<:%I4, £"iTz«.:13n {rim} ;,2:.é:'$ 3-»~'E."}"VZ.s'_->.. &P)£i*:~;'i§'2.ess_3; gm z"se.;>z.hm' f'c;1s()i':'z'?§g {1£.£,r3;g;;¢-91$§'é&§.r".b . .

KW ?='§'i*:ff§'~?€1.?'VI"~L_fb!'T_ zV'm.~§ ;'>L£rg;><.>:»i;e cg?" :§'2.c,:» m:;;ce:'1(£i.i'was '- 5112;; _ <:%a::gj£f,Cé£'~:'zi:r:7%,:§ 2.i?iE§'Z(i2'€$i_£.?I¥5 en: fr? <.;>£.F'2<?z"

"«€:£?(;avf"{'i.'&3°,'._ ujz-~§H!1"?.f:iéz' I'M} r>f;}j<3c?E" of' 2'z:tzi*z.az"r"z'2'fL;t_7g Ifzw e-.?.>(;?::>t'3--'?fE.:cji' 1".£'a.r.rc: zvag Io c3'22;:3§c)§;,; iU§"i(§,E. u.>a;S §,c2E<:'@n. :13}. as (.'(ii§;'}§{€IZ Q!' €.}'1.<3 };>e.:.s:£z"ze.;e.<5;;a ,/§_<f;a.s'.z"z. 2' :1 12:»: {'0 Em:
'A . "3s>»z:a:*;r:. wP:ei:!f:e3r {he eXpe3rI.ci.z'§:'s,sn: <ir'ze:?m"rc*d. was; ' -.;;2¢§ri': Q%fVZzL'!G'_f~fX&%C§ <:c&;;vi{,<:4E. aféfw E;,1u.:5"a"rmes;s; arr pcz.rA'f': . v "éigf $5.5; ci*ziz"miazl'zfn.g c:c:pi€:'a%I EL %%%%%%%%%%% mg) (;a1.e;=;1'.'?'c3:1 Qf crcm3i€£cr€ng the? <:_gu..e>:»;£:'i.<>:1 *-.c>'f'._V c1,g3g,'s£é.<;*€IE:2i£'éE.g; f -f:3~e>:c'r£ 210 n 3.52 I; 'H':&-: iffifiihi '1-iigh iffiouiji .i:::'1.,, T Vs. Escorm Finance Lid. r*£%p<::1ji:<_%{§ in "CTR,V»e5; '?4v'v§7§.E1fE§.:';E'1t£'fV§C§ E*'*m';;1»~«?L am m'::e:ier: ~ .

Mfg cor%sz'.§Zic3..2j {4f:'£VA€.":i'3'.""VA!;'?E':'¥c%;'?.' . 'é"J;;a:5:o:.:,;'2£ cm, _,r;2er'<i):.>:'cfi,ngg az.r<:s{;rci',ee:"f:§ VA _,§;)c:.Fi?i{iiE;):;;;. _;g5d:zj'&L:..:{zT.%'a}_:; 413,?' lc<>c::sc>d. ;:2;w:?z3'2.£SeS, .;:a;'r:,r':'§;i:};;gj;" 'Em-!V£f."'& r:cé;2QiI':',z"_;~§ '£0 's';'2.a$<:e:'~? €526 _pz*e:mis@_.é; it}"i:éa;9'é'(;:c1§é;"'§€c4.:;::s}:$ €';'§'fI.'; fzw; an be (:.'(}F'1.Sf:C%(??:%._SC£i.'6g$:.'~._?"€?Z!5§f;?'§'£.'!<f%}' ;%§;,x'g:}§%'r':(1'.€{Lmz. M as _{'3:.M' E5361' 53:4:$i'.?/E/\§%é?«5§'??':Eé;%i:;:, «E0 i'.{')v"§zf.2"'1 z.L.>Fw2,£i. F'??€T1fN?(:.'?' ffm :§(.;.?a""€;*'~,«'_'6.??~:"§A.AV £;'§> §'.'L2I___5;1'-(V3 .maz'm:c:zf.:ze;*cf {'§£"Ed L.uEfu3:z" aim:

E4?A1;e;{ ?'2.€Cf)e'3£¥§f%'g?V(.."ii.}';E;jV' v.f;€%f:I§Ei.i':"9T"" 'w%1.f<.*h. (ma re2zfgm'.z*e?c§ :0 ha) dV<)ria§§."«A.V';»?Vs:? §;'(f)f':ES'Ai:'{i€'3f"~.fffi.(l5. (xii :a::Tzch é?;'q:;u:*ne:iiiz.:.r°s.3s :.;.>§'zi<;?i'2 §.;.:e?r¢* £r":L¥z"s.air§ie.{ e:g:"z. f§}€Ii?'iii?EQ'. _;J(>Ef::;?2mg:; c;3f" fizzy j'E-mm' . g¢3'%'*§y:a£:"C§:f2;1g; az.>E.%f>de2r'z g;>amI':*£Emg e--;rIe;*. is; Fé?mCfz'":m;? _ o:z':.d. $1515: nc.zt'.m'<:3 :3,' z's3p<"ufz"5s rise; m:}£ Q? an ' {2}zt:€--{.£};j§.z'i:%§fV§i;'§'za.1'ac?E.'e?r so (.'L'§ :0 {1'fZ.€f1?'(£{Ti.Ef?'§;'i§&f as c'.*€,z;J£E.<z£.
g3;;i<;m3: rjéii§.zz.z"€ -
29 i>uz'£c§£ng;;, zflaarz, ma-3 pr<zz.:iséa;"2s Q!' ('Ems <:Z<:uz.se.:mg:EE,_ appigjg ms; gt' z"'i'3€ said. :~.::'n.zci'z,zm or §_,£3€.)f"}'£T is ca.¢.~i=2.:.:{;1 ftiii' gzwzeaf £35} SE19 ass<2sseae2,"
Q3": 0E" V 4: iéts. " L'%,.'f.'*.":V;'>"§?;.:S*;~ft".S{;:.f?ti'-'. is j a E'? W"E1e%1"::*. b'U8i1'}t'iSET~} 0:1" pmfz.
(:2H"z'ie'::£i em in a §:>uiEc§i:1:}g moi. c:\I»7'1}s::::§<i1'¥&V':3_§f TE'i.§Vn:;2..;TT'tag}£,..'ivr1&.VV§'<£_L;§._.~ ': ' v.YE"1.%{'.E': me: &:'i.'t'SS€§€€~":-";a.'.~i%t'.'.€', Ii"ma1de:t~: 21 :33' A(:)V'E.}%:!;'.'1"' "{Bv€f.'.C;§] ;':>e=~a:'1L:'h§} E,'a.'l'M.'3 aifimzy <:.2..1pii.a§ a=:xp<:r11d§ in re is;_:II;;E}A'a:1sf1"t:{jLA E)}f §.}Tti?- ..'-;_a':::71;~;,;V;;3*:Es,=;;.%is<'T::e:, fin" T:,h:»3 1:3s_.11"§J?»(:>.:~;ess of mes: E-.:')§.'!..:S:|g;§E:'}~V€:'-b";G\:.3".'g"v:'A' $1" _IL,§1&:: <;t<2z1r:;§V,rm:£'i<3;A2 0%' 2:my :%aU"m:i'1,.m':% e:>2:*.+:'1Q§nggiisiéfisxhzxfgré \r§.r{).:f;E~: ;'<i*'Ea1§..i.::>';"1 E0 zmd by way {if ?('i'}i]€I§'$$f§fif%;viO'%%""€§J iV.zl;'ra';::fs§r*':*j*é.19<:rz?;"1_<3nEV of tin: ?:mii<:ii;<':;,j.{; {Ema} :'~:-shzsili. a.j;:)p§y as-; if the 5:-3::-xici i'?sH'"'E'E(3Tf'%..%WTVV' <;*e.;fV "'M.3iic§%:3g Q\aI'1.'1€:cE by (in: arsssgcissssczca. "'£"}.1.r;~:tx"(;:fQrt}, V E'§':€3..'1.;1L§.1'T[}{)§?3€3 of S€?f("'Ti_§O}'i 332;? w.hi<::h p:;"<:>vic::%.<:%sa ?;'m"

V' _ (7%atp.§:"%;%e;&:ig1_§".i0:1; ii" t.E1:§"'€i{)§i'.1ciiI'km N0. 1 is s»:aa1.:éa:£"£::%{'i by 22:. icing-.§21§ fie;;.r€.:':*<;n'L L igjhtgé ' e §"§€%.é'3<.:»'::3:1ae:s fhra 0w2"2e:" of (her. :a'i.r:V,:c:£u.'m {:<.ms;Em::<?'E<:%(:1 cm. §é;:~..;:1 'tr p.a'a~::1"%.f '"§'E"1ere£"m"e any c3:*~:pend:£{L1':*e in<:u1**re{:i Em" <::§\«'iE &,\Ia:2;:".'§s; 'b};hg-2 in ;"es3;3eci. of the §(';',£?L'.~'5€3 pz"c'm%:¥;a:§s, wiihrmi zzmy " H _£'m.*E.he:' "pm€:>.E" e::::ar'1..nm'. be 2es21i{1 Em be 231 (:22-v.;j:;i'1;i§ £",.X'}T}(?1"LC.§i'1.ll'i"€:E {inf 32 :s"mé:'i€:%&::. Th£':i'i. wzmizfi .m<::e1:' {.3163 +3:':d.~;'; m.fN§1.:s1i<:e:n "E--i:;n'1<::e;'-33-*e.V_paws §"'E"1»t=3 f{.)H€>'W'i'E"k.g 02'€_'1<;';E'.

E8" "'E'."§1st {)r€T§{:'.:* g3;-mssaci. by the 4O£"'i'1'e:'*=::L A§}}j}€'TfHE1'€"€ {mm :1'§i:=;:a;ic:}i1<3t" mid. '§i§"'} 'F.:9'i§.3:A;n:'a.E -i'V2V:'--:::go'£7:1«:'.,V"aim 7'L'.i'1t'~:» I &3x§>mMi§'i'.:,2;."e Emirxwreci by me, R$.fi;';2,33.05'?/V .2723 hiareiay "":%%_é5i.;~.zx$id<:*:"._ii:1.fi .=E"Eitj £fi2}:'i;i<;::f 1?:~:+ m:rm:mie:<:% to €..he: ;:;.e'3:ae%s5::a.i:'.1< r? ;:zu'E.'§':c7;1fi"i'.\r '"i;«..3 <::<tu:1r:3iVCi'e?;"'w§A1€E;'.i":€:z' t':'§'3<=;~r V 3:79 . V ._ raazéti f:??:>aip€t:'i{'{§E'E.7§1"€ii is 2i*&*.'vm/11,1.::_--?§'e>9;pn:3§1{§E€._1,a.i?'a x.;3.:"" z;:,:1pi€,aE <i%,>§.T§)€:?I'3.C§it{zI't*:

zmd i..§'1.<'m g;"zi1':£ :§m:E"1 zfeiéei; "a ::3 . §t"%1Lés:--.._z1:'+;'ssé;ss:éet¢: iii) whicth his .335»; é:t";%:.i.'iZ¢s€§"E':€§".£::r":.}'€;f=.v. 'if%;'z"'x.Ii.<9_%w €::£" i.i'":<--3:Wé§':;*: u?:r;%. me: ::S'{.2b5.§E'&12"i€.,'iE,il C§1i%';'.S§§'.i(TH_'1 mi" km' '$éi;'21:im*.cié iii ~é.1h«.i.:3'T':*a,}<3T;;r:=:zi§.. '£201: 21.1"1sn-w:1"cr<i. T136 })é':'z1'{}k'§ffn' in b®E'ii" fiizgséz" €.m.§'n '(?()§£'~:i.':§§. ' fid/W Nfififlfifil ;'?§&,/W "' EUEEGE .V . V &~ "-19' V' "
'A 4 / E3'; ' ta " :é*s..1:m "mi"