Karnataka High Court
Smt Meenakshi K R W/O Manjunath K.S. vs Sri Manjunatha A S S/O Late Sheshappa on 2 June, 2010
.w1_ Efi THE EXQK Sfifififi fifi fllwfl A?fiKA &@ akaafixaax mawgm Tnxg wam fm may aw amma fifilfl EE?QEE @HE fiamvaym fiRn§fl3TIfiE &R&LX aaeaaaa j "
smxmxaam aavzszcx pmwzwxaw $0 253 aw 295$. 5 BE?WE$$ mt.$m&nak$h1 Egg.
W?¢.manjunath.E;£. _';
Agm& wheat 3a ywarg % '.
Rmaiflang at ahwgmika Vaahien fi¢u$g_x Kaafii fiittlu ,*.V =""* ' Bazahaik, xanehaay --' Eangalmwa §n.K,) _ »V: _ 2;. ;
.w,_x '.», Qfiatihianar (my ari R.v&dmanaEEg:$ §x:€gf?&§a§§ra§§, Aflvs.) _ < V_. .._ .
firi fimnjunatha"A;$. { 8im.Lata B§aa&ap§a,«,* Agafi abaut'3? ywarm*JkV"u w_;
Kasfiding at Ehmmmika fiausfig Kafiji Hittlu } a V g V.'»"
Baremax1;'£&naha§y "' §anga1¢r&.§m»K«§ ' ...... H mRm%$an§@at (fi¢%ifi§ §mfi$3fi§ a } ¢x1;a9_£§ £ilmd unflar aamkiam 33? CE&§§flI fly the amréizazmizg "Em: the 9a'titimnm* pxayang tea set .._ '_-«ggida tin" mmar datafi 1?.a3.Eéfi9 pmmaa by mm 4 ?a£t nTtaak" Gmurt, n.x. mangmlora in flrimxmal * Agyga1 %m.3fiflfQ8 in am fiat aw aatting aaida the ._ "*33:L's2!i$IZ' ¥"'t..»'.':@".&«& m.aa.2ma pasmeé in $§.C..Hm,.&'?;"2a{17 '1%&y"'tfi§ Caurt afi the &H$Q~E1£, Mangalmwa 3.5. _ 'rhgarfiang thm raliat ma.& pawtainimg ta tun [*,Ar@3idanm$ owdar my alxawing thiy reviaiun ". petitimn.
e-v--.'*-'fi'_""""--\"
-3-
whim §$tit$$m wmmiag an fiat admmfimian thia dayy thu Gaurt mafia thg fifillwwingz fiflfifi &mvx$;wn Qatitiwnar is wifia mfi théW , tasyanfi&nt fiarain. fiha iixafi mm §¢fi5?ffia3? fia£§t§ff*"
tam» f}..aa::e:*na6 mm (EEK cam:*k;.§,__ :;gagai:%¢:%ak,%% Bakshiima Kannafia Qiatract against ~%&£* kfibahfig_*a' under tha praviaxwnw ef fiamfifimg 1fiw§£ Erafiagfifiani ; "fin fawn flnmmstiw V$azefié$ fiat fhfifiainafitax refiarxraad 'mm as {aim *z':s¢ "';,%!;x::~h_¥*AV ;3;¥';:§r::§£*:«._'_:*=z:;!fii::a:g:t§ fiéékinag auvurai rmlimflm inmluaimg'thm %fii1gfiffr§&tra&ning har huaaana §€fiémf- §&1gfi@fiin§ *t§§f prmparmy, paratxng the V§&m§T§£fi&@$§fia,F§§fi ,tha relief afi saparata a¢fiémm$§at£§fi f@%'%a£ &é§ifi&a¢e.
2. wag 1aa£ngfi &E€£khéxeina£tax $a£%rrad ta aa the ?¥r;ai*¢fiwr£"A£§£"ahwwt?, by wrdr dmtea ,ifi;$.fi$§%,¢:a&;aw#fi"'aka """ said appkiwatien aha g%afit&$~1fifi& *§a1fi reliafis almng with athar *,h_ra11飧; &§gfiiQvmd my tha gaid arfiar at tha °._rr;a1 ¢¢a£t, 'tnw hufibanfi. £$&$d fiximinal ayyaax
-fx§g3$@§guu§ unagr $$ut$wa 23 a: tha my &mt mexmxa "" _tfieR$§§é1l&te Ewart" y fitw juégmfint anfi mrfiar T aguga 17.2a2&c§, tha fipymllata fimurt alimwad tfia *_3§§i& ppaal in gart ané? whiim manfirming aha ¢........_$"_~3""'\.---vs,
-3"
9rdar mfi tha wrial fimuzt in am fiat as it welataa ta tha gamting mf raliafla 1,3 anfi fig sat amiég tha aaifi mrdmr $5 ta raiiat ma.2 prwv1d$fig_ , xeaiflenae rm tna wifia anfi mmfiifiaa thfi wwm$§"§§f_ »"
tn the quantum uf maintfinafimm payable wfij_fi§¢. huabaad ta the wifia and 3 mhilaw§%. fig§fiéfiefi'by4 , tha maid jufigmmnt afid mrdar_ at wfifia &p§éiisfi¢°} Cmumt, fiha pxafimmt rmvfifliafi i$*£i1afl hyt$hgf§ifg.W 3" fha raapanfiantvkfifihgfid1$§fiafi%E_gkasan ta agpaar in fihia r$vi5i¢flm §¥§$a@ i§ :§$k3an nr thrmuqh kin fiaufifiéiflgmggifig"%a§ai§%*$§Anatiaa 3! this meviaxm§% %§§§§é§a§§} § 'fi§%# haard haw argummnts fii thén;e%%$®§"fi%um$§i fer tha revxaian §$titi$fier;¥;§% Va§§DflPgr#§$§ ~§9th fiha ardara ufi thm Trial c¢ufit anm zfifig#$§®11ata Smart. = '" 4, gag méagx caggt has aaraatea the huaband tn §m&vi&m@£ir§§lfXna£ par%$mm wf afia rasifianaa afifiumnaa fig him fia his wfifa my gwttimg tha iaasaa . fav;@§afi th§$%£rmm in anawraamae with law: whie {(§grfiiafi @£ tfie erdwr @f the wrial flaunt has baen '3ag£'as;aw my the Agpexxate aware an the greuna ' *-_tfiat" winww tha fiirat ilamr pmrtimn ag the < ragi$amaa baa bamm in mwfiupatimm afi a Eaaaaa, it f""(-y'?--' N4"
aaula zmt bfi wwaszabia mm mm hugbazm ta mmawar pcsaaasaiam $3 mm asaifi pm:-warty mm than tum hanfimvm: um: mama ta fiwig vim" Thmugh this raas;.a:V:;':¢'-. ~. is amwafitablaf the Ayweilata cmurt amght tgjfia%§g W,"
qiremtea the aypwLlmnt*hu&mand ta prav;aa%a¢: ¢g% alt-atx*nat:;.Ve aaaammmzfiatian my tak:;,%z1e@ _§ny rasitimstial ggraesmzmm em rang. _i2m?:'a+ay$&v. at Ttfiifiiiy dapmving the sum asf hm: rig§:a.§"~.ta r?a£§Vw&€§aQ°v_t<§.§V has prmrwad har %1s.mba:2ss:i_.
a . mxrthax, tam (vita;
has filafi tnda:y:_ "1;€'.}'1&% max:
huafiamtfi, d:i»§x'5e'a;.:t3?.€::: by the wrial fiw3j"t' mndmtuxrbafi my tne Apwe11%&§:m¢u§£{fg&@gf§% gnaix mat alianata hm asmtfi mat apmrafia mm mmk 4§;::a§§zmtf3";'«:. §taVfwm;"%:§m_...ag2~m§.raas ramdamtiml pammism 2?,z:2"._1fs:'23fi?5@;,§x;' piié a::;:é"§.._ Emtmfiushga amiar a 2;*%g'mtm*%§ 'n sale"-¢ged"'fia3a§"s5.a,3m$a'w1th tam intent ta v1'_deg::*:i.*sm'.4"'.iw;:?,3_ 'z:'ig?m We reaxfianae 3:: the aaifi aim Ema @1m$u_ama alzmg with ma as glwtmmat mm mt' 'mm gain aaacfi :i'§§*:.;vm:';-«T1:-'§m&,.mfi9 ssasmsmxtesfi by mm mmmxnd in fmrmar " 'FEW mgtxmam gm mm maid aale iififid ¢__§"""/' W5."
xwveai that the gumwhasam haw Qwwm put in pasaasaimm mi tfia maid grmgarmy. $, mama tfiim ammw fiawtwg. it W glee.»-:
thaugh tag vita im mnaitiafi ta rms£damme; §a§ husnanfi smlfi tbs antirm rmaidafihfigi-1p§§$i$$§ T.H dnfififita tfiara &aifi§ an mrdar fly fihé T%i@i C§3§tfi A reetrainiwg him firmm aliefiafiiag Athav'§£9§%rfiy' whiah xemainafi mnfiiatuwfiafi _§y. age hfigpglgétfi flamrfi. Tmmrafiara, X am» fig :tfia'i&afia§d¢rad v£aw tfiat aha xfigai righfi ta Hiasifiafigfi "ggfifimfi ta aha vita umfiax aka 3? &@% mafinfi§"ba fl$f%£t&fla ?# fii§gg t%$'%gg§%$@U§&£-xwéakvafi frmm tag gurefiafimr @£ t§$ £g§@"§?&§&rfiy; aa wwulfi ba a&an firmm tha x&¢it§i$ in t§@i§§§§:aa;$ fiwaa, a sum af Eflufigfififqfififf §é§§§ .§a$ai$&xmt¢mm amvunt in r%%§%$tfi%£1§gfi$_§E f$é«aai@ pwagerty, he is way in i&$_§®tfié3 §$#&t£mn ta wamura a auitabla 1 zam¢amm&$§tian :§n xanfi tar fiha. raaifianma afi figs
-- . ;fi*~'-~* 4 '?§r~;tha rsaaans agarasaifi, E gasa tha Vfiéazwwimg, (.:""*-*"
ug...
fififlfifig Tha raviminn gatitian 15 allevafi in, part. wha gufigmant and fixfiar ma tha figpailata $auxt ifi, , so fax aa it ralataw ta weziaf $0.3 grantg§"§yfl_ s"
tfie Txiai Smart is harewv fiat a$;a&a §h%»§$;iéfi. $a.2 grantfid my tha Twial §§uxfi '@§1'§w#éhy w;_? mmmma ta tam gamma mm: mm ra§;'g:_a;£§rgaamt_'"V.;;m§:fa£n fir: mamjunatha A.a, tha musbaafirmf t§§ rfivifigafi patitimnar $mt.Maamaksh$.EwR:§haii firviflfi ha? a amitahla reaifiantial p$%ai$é5.7$yfl t%E3$g° it an rent amd awmammafiaté ha: in fih%_§§;§.g£wmi$e&m %he rmat§Q£i£§é.im§fi§m§fi~jm§gant and arfiax af the figpfiii%teE§Q#§§'x$ai§ mafiéim mmmiaturhed. Kw mrfifik aw ta fl@§t5}z.