National Company Law Appellate Tribunal
Anup Kumar Agarwal & Anr vs Crystal Thermotech Ltd. & Others on 24 January, 2017
IN THE SATIONAL COMPANY LAW APPELLATS TRIBUNAL COMPARY APPELLATE JURISDICTION Company Appesnl (AT) Ne. 17 of 2036 jarising out af Order dated &¢ Octeber 2015 passed by NCLT, Kalkata Beach in €.A.Ne. 331 of 2015 in O.PNe. 41 of S016). Anup Kumar Agarwal & Agr. a. Appellants ¥a. Crystal Thermotech Lid. & Others ooo ROR HOS ES For Apoollant > Mr. Akhiles Advac x we ra wL trois me % eee rege ot th me, ee ry ot aA Pe, oe or foot a oe fae, gee re Ls Ma, Subita Mukhopeadhay, POS r Adve yoate with Mr. Batite. p Malick, Arivocates for FPorBespondent 2 Sey gk seygeet Pos dues ey ~ Sse PH oe ¥ This appeal has been preferred by the Apnellants the National Company Law Tribunal, Kolkata Seach Gherematter referred to as "Tribunal! for shart) bn C.A.No. S3i af 2018 ai ¥ % g in CP. No. 4b af SG18 whereby ancl whereunder the aoplication preferred by fs S a respondent <p a gt an oe Cp -
a a gions, Ae wane, Saget rat & st tamed ¢ Ss Was ente RS ie es Art 18 pani sac < *, Oy F 4 Sass t detailed and pla x z & SES o.
"
a rel & tL s The rereina er & (thers fh tied 2 «Ee ZY i &.
2) % :
& OTC Fy ae fon bet fy ms under the aul:
ae.
ser See ok oratedd an SEs e car A FP OWARS th SE "t EEE Oo a x ats terre rek Nat withaut ary me SB i 8 eHants IR sppellar x8 os x Re 128 ert t oe The furth Sees aoe "3 wis March ' x EM YE3 oh i Be ~ x S OF othe et 4 Seep f x s 'S qyracte ir y x WS) lant ae] a we 8 2 X OtrHeri i & al x a 'ab Sek, eg anes at St ug orines, ne a 'ney S, oe x Set riche. ae! ;
" Ye £3 ye aed ' , "i ik me of Sek Ly pied eae rh gf gon Sw £6 ant % oh B "fy "es Ty oes oo opt pes oy Be oe ee a 'eon a eid ed rt ea oe a) on z = o~, Ri Bia mA tet yy _ m gas ov - ea ay eet aheet em Bos see Bee ae ben a fae re went ti pnt ie wa, roe ° wey we get a ay "Eh ce 6 e & oe re Se at 2 th 'ed. Be pv Tt $ am 5 oe bs + oh a - * of ae ' pe tet a a a a ped On ct wy ne, ; as ve eee 'eh Boe re mm sept i ten, roy Se a cane x shat ov. me bad? ad. a) a a pd aes aoe. rite waa ra * n % 'th , :
ie ¥ tra 5 ey, on, & 'ee thet Bo oe ben oe a Sua oo coe ome 'weet Les pet ay fet ged 4A reek at * & Be ee es mp o, wy, ee "oe Sant met Nw? Se vet ae bed 'hee fn yp a . . po f 3 fed af a3 re: * ny , ot bet, ne hey ee Ay wre, es ae * tee neg rent nee on. oy Be het uA Sed 4 bas es vent * wm web " ou ve z sed eh ot ee nee od oe An Pod yee it * ae Aes a oh » . we. - ne ' 4 £3
" 2 tad ad SF ore ys re 04 ve hee oe ow we ae) ee wh Seat a td , et os pee ee eed ee ty seh, ine het nf whe Re om ; a ot % : iad ye a teed ret ped, ges Sa rere ete, we ons "ah oe eet if we a; og we hee if ne es ao oe Snel et tee, Senet, et Ke wa ae wend Opes be a oe oe eee AS re fa ge om ou ae at sy y ve "ae pa ~ re ae aS Fendt sa es ne " feat pee ore gt one, a ae o, es oe pe wen 'eae St pred ee Pa hehe os ae an re es % aid ek. RY es ees anh ere, Senne: " % om «Meat Bets, A nee oy ' ry x wept 4 a weed woo a: yore ae me te mo tS te he ad " tes one S nna, eee wr Saer oo my ee tes 3 ned a ae ws wn Ae a, aa nie feet 23 ' io 'ae ot hob : a a ind :
bos Ss we pe "eg " wed be we a oe ey anaes ae Aqeet se ~ 2 , a ee ° ee ga S % % oo ad ore, te woe, eg set ope peri, ae Neg oy £5. res 'ha at. * ee wate ae 'ha Wh " p% ee we 4% rs ge "Ot ar » By iy apes Ped Nk ne fe w nee vot ( #6 Me pen ee ok ne rea et as ie a ad ey ee ven Pa ian ee oat oe Sng ree: a a 4 KS Se. oho "
4 my, Wat ont re 2 'sr oe 4 a tr, a ne we oO toy % nape pee, fn ae %, Pa Y bop on, a i ge "hed A's ee ors, a, all ? * a nee a Keel, ; ae Nae! Sel oA GE seeet 7H ey oy eg at Als a" aed, 4 ae "4 a 'bof ak on, vent as y eee hn " St af but ta Ss 'eee ane Jin fet a Spek we fos ws " wee sr, yee * fg " 4 te * Whe re eet wert na a gee ue 1 on hat ee * "ted es -- an ~ od ore, . 4 toe e re 4 : 2 et 'a % poe SB gen . ' Sei Seat a poids bee ' Oe st a 7 . a #F : a ve aes ss te, '. oe rr t bs vee vet swged, od we ae fob robe ay 'ae! as A le iq 23 ve ee * rf se, on . aa iz 4 " 3 Re got Le te by ant oft ey +3 on oa, et ee res "bunk Ky BE ee fo, ve mens bee th vr, ee eet No pn, Aaa at of a get pe oo ae pre ye ¢ ee ret, oF omg aft aro fee, Eas $a ae oe poate Thay ia r, gen serer, pee ry nnpen So ad me 6 ho towed Z oS oe e oat ns oe yee "
aE sort yen ae gS § teed " 4 Me ped ety TO, Cae seek 4 bo <G oe ns eo ay SS ir red oe ie ae aft 4 Saf we hoot aS ee en we Seat Sada: oe ps fet bs ed vs ony feat wd a ne he a % tahe Gok. eet 'eae geen frat Be a ee " * Wee enees win me "73 pes 'ita ae Fee, ork 2% me ape "dt wre wat sf ed nine os et fy een Sees 4 rag sere, g he hs a sheet oe ena ee pee oe net oe * eee er : ret oh. nes aad sneer nd wees fet eet Son ® * 3 ore eed Sod
5 Tne! wos wt we Le "ia en a bee a tes 5 he tps fa Ea o ze fe ti Eee re eo wn 3 pa ry af tet 5 on or : pie ze A we et gt , io ent pe Me vee : 32 ee a ie : ay o Se Bo Oe fe ae Be ae WG Pa inn " ys 2 cea "
a a bes ie a4 x ad . Sesewe oA ee 2 6 8 rm he & a i ane as oe m on, aed wee ee ae 4 23 , nm 4. ee we . panel 2 ge Sint Z , j na 1% gee fs :
a aM atees a4 ge ce ae pe spew dees be Ka om Eset viet "ae pend 7s) , Fag ree ised bs Le * , Regt a =, er * ( sons aes oa ed tet ne 'et yee a we tub Ke ee ae He oe 'iad bes, eS oe et wen we ts ogo ay tee i wok AM * Fa rt i om of ae oe a ? +. toh oo} a 6, aeeet, i: a i, a on "4 oy a3 oe Fe i ' at 'ae rs a ay aa gs oe ts ces oF vt 4 yea" pean ees boy, ong cde ner bes. 'ths es es % oa rr ¥4 rae me , we ao oe pe a es we ai inet ee . Sat a seort a Ee hed $e Be
-: te pe fn Fed deed 2% then get Bo te "fo 3 os ye 'gt BS a Sad Le on 2% to Es ee i "ea : got ae ets * me wae Soi wa ; Sak ae zs, a tt 3 > " 'cad pen + whe ht 'one es cs ie he eS z 5 we ee en.
x e ee o Fp ifs f i iogal remove x AP ORL oe ES aerut the a uy So aye od eee é, and w WS ISG x APPOTEeS TN Boke & PLIPSiant to 8 Schon < a ue 4 x.
r eS tw EERE ps Cen steal f rnes Ac
a) Corp Syypyed BGs a SATE ye Bas Ce Pe Lk ement by ay x Tigers hat at ee re "an oe @ oe eyes OMe a fy Seat Son:
+n x ae gest hee me, "hae! eet a Sees ms, :
het Gt SPP a Pare.
ms tt ERY sere:
> THe ee oon oe eg oe pane sen, 'engl?
' z ye nt bag aid ey.
wy vy hy of ees MH x ' 3 giaime s x
8.
PREG f LER ee Q SeChign: J oo we s ays Re > a of Ss CSUDSRY Wal DoF te respondents HO Oe the O, Re a he o a3 25 "at .ne or TOR me pee 4 yore #e on :
go ae See ce , ee ae ay >was Rs vi XM hy eas, = ory the ds me wee Peg] ae wan os tas oy sf7 ' es s a Pas aeons 3 pent 's me " 2 5 OS oy Sal o % ye, Re 18, py Mw » : x hh is ba mo : nd ne ge en os, ' Re at ne ae fc ee 5 1m ee Pe, me 3 ee, te! 8 ; on tae "tape, ryt os sheds 43 lent tp. ' By ran % . kent So oe ee as cnt, " et = a ped, Sent of weet a Bi Ba * a a ap Lee sy eee, a Gh & in, io £% te dena res. we * a "tS ei wee ceed me "
. deed 4 te oe % ~~ awed, a sf peed : 4 jit, ben ay oy ay fy vA ee woe te 3 4 os igh rt ns wet mee es + bad £% snow, et tent eh wv eS AG $ x y Sone ns 3 od ce hed < oe a: a f oe ae ae ft ot a ern Boat a anes wok < re er Son, te ed 'ta aoe Bay eek {3 ce weet woes ps aD Sa nen ens bp, ones fy a3 Be pes Tat rack 4 oh. ie Sec ofr, if ree 2 ted oe 4, eda ', ne "
oA A mh Ley ba "4 oe Se sn ne ee 4 a stots £3 , het ae hy we Ry A Le q ape, cae ae 6 a wend. ae get nee ye fo ae a, pe hat th a oe ore Be Lhe noes oie we BE we eed ~ $e re fee, D4 poe : f See ape me Y Pcl yas: aren Wg any, Fae) A Nah iain, gels oo oA 'ne a me oo * oS ' ee * "ee ay Ve a oo cs Sa o sf Ser ve bs peek, we : oe LS, 'nat Sty . net ft im ophag oO ? et at eet, betes Shed ey teh gt oe re Lh, Ge . "aa pA eas ns oe * ae bee 3 oi a pees 3 ee ae yon end 'ut a, * we ; ee pees "Soot ay ay" 2 Sage: ae oot apm we aoe ho * BA "et ed, ed "a oh fs : i het 5 we et ot ee pet Be fs os nd ~ Gen en, x, any Ses ee "ena? Se. 'Spat " seine ge Ry 'ee es os may Y 3 4 ' ete fi ERE ot ee , uw wg hens a oe " te "et ha be bey a "A 4 cao ven tal nt 4 aed ts o yer whoo! pea *, hy 'iad? "at wed s n vhok, & se peed z as * "trina saat:
bey ay Be pork ' ony et 4 re i lotend wy is aed " eas Lite tite PR EeTES Aw su beaquen :3
e th 'hed bee Soo 2 ae bee ue oot elapers Private Limited' where ~ & n "Bhagwati Dew i 3 + £ deeisio:3
cee per. ¥ fet aes tes Ae fe i cS e £ gg © wy pk & pn ~, ge Fed et #% % ge rt re hot ms Seat Cyt i a 4 % hen, weet raent bee. 'teh 'vat oa cas 5 te me reed. on, Coe Pad we sete, "ek Ga on t en se 7 me 5 a ; "ee , BS aa ; 4 4a * ee Pett He 5 # # aS 6B 4 af . fei ig : bo gg be. on Zk $s adoet m pat 0b he al £3 ie rpee os ty ie whe ee ae 'es aeery ES gat & om ah oy "4 eg ae Bs seed vs om ae a wh we Soe 4 ad 'heen been ie +8 ee ae 23 % Fron. a af i ne fA i ee ee OW oe 6 one ae 8 By a oo IG as ve & es tere ~n oe a ", :
ge Subs ay pe ies eet cnet rs Foe a ea d he ; i ma 2 Em im 85 fs ue eg SO steing Pa) @ Fed Be oo : og ¥7 Cl fed Be we es Ae . Shows, i ars wee ee Ts HS te "os 'net nes ® ek pis $4 6 oy 2 Se i 3 oe a in Sa) BS ba GB ah 4 on ee Ess) oe ed 2 oft ae a oe. en ~ at eo s ¥ Foxy a hee 4, re oor oe wo eet BY x z thee i bs a = eg oe Gh rs Z * oe a " nt ay as, nes oo i) 2 "et Fe ao ae we dag weet pt ae a ee, fin, we is L If ets ge hee 33 a ss : 4 wm , oe Se ee] x he 4 wn . oot ae oe % a, are, " fg sron is F be ey gra Fadd rh 'ew rede ry et ine nt A a 2, et . oy . oe we pon i oe ys om aS reed et "-- 'oot "a Soe . tens Be "od £5 ne ;
Lh Gs By at Soot os ap Pn ge ; 5 4 , po a % 8 6 * ws ; ge OR & io we Bs et in "a : 4 eet Me "3 & xg ; fy hE é , oe f te :
ee 7 2g & & E ¢ & & ws ae ea @ se 'ig ig Le me ns me, oe ny : ', z ie ue vey vet "et " ; no ea ane op Be eA we " ' os . . ; s "e 9p & Fa joud : hed fe be 4 ES 4 : : Cy vy od By See re ee ; 5 & be 2 Ba wo ao bot 7 % Be ss oa" eet £ oF m, Oh
- bad ni 'ae oe i "he a oO oS be vet be ining og eS Aaa "eG cee & ae a fe a Raed o i om g oe a the : oe ie a . fe a " zs, re we ; % ' J eden Ros, yore asa : ye need ya, fe : 2 mE ca te "Oe i thet * . ts wk ae - rn e 'dent as fe net Ye oe By * oe ba xr a iG we é % PA : oe : F sot "ps ft = "pe a ae = 2 #8 > a % 6 s re Le Sa wy oe ke oe Se . ay ist be ot aye Ry ay wha fo £3 Pt ES ae ton avi gre a3 het fee oye on 2 ood ; , ae 53 ome cA 3 Le fe i rs bade oe Ga se en "so oo! ed ee we 1 be Be Se Be oa oR ops oe oa mo ES : Be be o mee g x a ae be, $ oro os ' ; fa ye a nae rs we oS ws ge wet Y ron aE oer oe 2 ae fe a oy ie beg ta 4 ee oe oe aon "
oh, i fe ht ee vet os e ae ei $45 1 wei deci ee a eee 3 oe a5 3 " * ede, Sa 3 ber a E ai Z ad, ae ; "ee, , a ey os a ty EA s = ra | es ms, is ye ms taal tone re son Je ye re4 5 ; ws 7 ra] chest ye Fa : " = oo AS "ey Pa oo PS Be 3 oes : i toed oy a ey" wy Por ee we sia ee fe oa we we tg ~ on i oe Py, Nonna fe ie weed a gS. i # wy oe oad het eS 5 ae vaeatt vee fete spas ay see tat ant * be ; Gy ot oe if , Se wy es oH - 8 & & o . oe nm OS : 8 Ios tt ' ' a i me Bs & Manat Fed rot Le Be tet fi o : Spe ay st - oe, A at 'he fewer 0G fy ae 4 'nest fy, <3 oS eee Sen ae 2 a ae ot Ay gt Ia See? re ; week Fa ae SS. ; ; CE, ie eo ey £4 ; in rc! im te cs é af 3 ee $y reining St, teed bt yaa a" be 'cad 05 oe Man ae wh Ba Sk, ws mp Qe Be a fag OS & ie oS : , tgpce wh "ote ee ra ' x Sew! a % lew. itty, we, Men, ne: tg 8 6% OE oS es 'a Be oe he a Net fo ae ae { e it eS 2 ee eh & ' we ft wnt oo te fe + ' a ° rs ' ade 'et % 4 ae 'aes io ae ' oe ag bee 5 a mt " A % ike Ch os Pe S & nw oe %, ne ft oy ae pre aS ' Be aA f wy oes be co Ch her a as Treo a 4 w ASS fe " ay om on & Se fs a wae ben were 'oat & sent ee ss me " an AG a, xe %4 Pa "ee ape ve Be £% deg ore - a wn, ke Me aes et pet, oy "oe gs a phe wa 'etd e wh fea re Ieee Font %, og s roe nt ny as ions ca a my ron : BS ee we wd "i bs Ay og ae? uy Be ti Y Ch Bs , ro a ae 'nah et om ps = ed Aa a ceed x hex be & me pe my oe oe be i & so ee 2 my oe ee Ye ae gs 4 e 7 $ ¥ 'ep % rs, ined fre ge et hed rae! xe ad se % : te Shed inf we fe "x weet , seed peat ek hm CL pa "hand cae] seas i a) pet or) fe Ga fe seed hod CPEE Tita bee eon Sewn LS ayo three ye FEN tration 4 a% of s iv wy ad fo an pes oa rn EN <<. £33 38 £ = wi * & "% ¥.
* Pho and the pe x Oi 2 February s wre oe wes vgn nedy Aha teva ER ve feaitt Spon Pee Y 2 wheres 3 x ee 33 etian x SE os ov WA etHian p on.
setat is winder SOER Sth se any "ye of TERE R eet an e maunt art in "Bhagwati Developers Private Limited Vs. ved COTPRIC (S019) 5 SCC Pare 455, g e levestment Company"
Peerless Goneral Minane fea ee te wet eae poe ty 2 .
Bag Ee 2 ot » thes wn, ; os, "bed 'se ge aw.
re gs von rye Pinal Sagat ome "Sa a ws st % = Be 3 Phen, Pa Vi oo ee e anes pee é Z oe "
casi we gg, Fi oe fs ts Ce 7 ny Se "ne - 4 2, - ory ws ae " y £4 he Ss Be ~ me Y te "rm a ; ae i ded aS ee se sat ad 7 a rh TNE wae rns at ' iy ° toe " fos teow tay "
ne et it ' $5 os 4 aad * a oy why won, weet tee ae nae gee, ' oy ts ~*~ <r " Be a ~ tele teed ay 3 fe . % eA bie os "e oe wy od eee, ee ee seed can § ' : 5 3 ts ee , nes ;
"ieee be, rs A oe 2 net oe tes "ee me ee a ies ce aD gs a sy Spee " ngs od on bee ca' . eee, 'waa "eat a om oh ot Ea . A one eg :
Ft Sb ag oe: Meee ie . a SS a se we pee eo ed at ] as ae get . aa zy we whet, a x, i" ee oe Fm ws al a See ed LP het oe oe By te ra fee i 2 w fe bo ohen 7s % ~ tee phon co bye or sg ft % 2 é 2 p ws oe oo ope li ne fee Bs gs ae ted ae a 2 ¥ poets 2 tend ., a : m b ca ne Wor. Sy 1a "ad? 4 x ise fea a wy a 3 we has ort *. oS bes ae' mn . we ; S a wei t % yen &. we . " oer tet we oy ny Get ie ea re wh a ; Hf % x tt, i ae bod fp. Ch, feet eee A eee ay fe , a me fel ve pee % th we » vr ped wa thr : ay Fae. okt we or Sars, , woes tg te on oe a xe os rot th a we be "Seat Soa ee * oe Fy en ee 'tess 4 e ttt 7 hes hed ; oy * Goce ve wo nat Sot hes pee be, ow ie rag * os taped wt oy fa Ope ; ny ee E 1 "y ny ie hae ts 4 2 a Set Sens 'ne 44 bea ie ; Beery ; Me edewt & eg t rae o me os we Lo nr S @ & ie w ge ey gem s in te of ey ws y a: te he gee: eed, a ot ee fe & Sot Be se . ah an gent on yen wee "at? rt 4 bb? hy 2 ed bs, oe, BE ot oe ot a oa bon oe : ad : wh we ad : qa 4 mS fa ae wh 3 bea tee $y 2 gy «7: bon fet om i my he 3 sm a, sce ne Ee) "nett a vet 43 Je ea 'ait & t uo Ka ob on as % wore oes * aE ne eget fee atnet %, ra ae, ree a z % oot eo a rm "ee ~ od ; nd Ma ho, 0% shel igh * tea Se poe rn red pent, oe eat fen ven res ea, we 3 a, z on %s, ifs " : ty * xs ay stews
-< lame, om 4 of ee on by ' a 3 ay : wee wat sd se poe pe 'eid, ening 2s aes a4 oc. needy % 4 a he a ee oe bat ay '¢ tae park 5h, se a weed phot $ fs be pte. 23 % re my Ses 2 ' Dna, we: MS "Bs et gt 'ne! oe Ld " ea ey gs x $04 au Lhe sh ae FA A "Se aa 4 ft a a 3 % p a ne Sng ba re "a oh het ms bes ; were :
% Pd a wo a a te my 3 % i be te a bet fy fs rg s ces om ae on ie ap ae et we nots 4 wba s os oe < ee Oy red » ; s we oe vee % z hen gh " "s m % ney Aa bos see ae SE yong ay to , t wet wy we "3 Fyn x er "anet we "on of be on re te go is ; ae an re he a br ont a oe Z ry Pd 5 ete hoesy ay Set a eek fen ae weed bean ' Lome ee neice he ae BY ra "¢ 43 ns e £ 2b ci " hace oh, on, a ak a ut 24 . het to re. ¢ ~ $ Heol nee ' " eb . nm at ne ves oe ;
' a eae te ne 3 ree ot * me aot * gy Bee Se a co) ad of oS Pe he Mp ' z % g 25 x i, ca ae tom a ie F to rs ri tos a m= Soa Piet x oe : x oe on , : oe ? oS k oe ht ry ig go hah are @ ord dood Sh bat Rew % we w that ihe baw lad dows
- <2 wa NPs gs BS y x ¢ hae 4 tetees 3 PAR z ted* x ISR 2 ce Pet.
Developare "Bhagwati DSUPPOMe ne by wer.
a a ae a ea ae Sha ee rhs bn atawemenk tr gy ofthe Tribun are. pecardes CASE FR x yr the G N spheant ¥ y x without restic at foto deter 2 = reholdl Shy SS acs at the the round ~ am the 9 's SS HOT, ary Bete amp C % is a se ene SET ibis a dil ta be RE ES Tet QHRALE ee wy ae ee ee a Naf "peg 'net arial rit ve x Gf on uA "heed ne ae Be ia 6i om e one, oy Sood pe » TF y h SQ.
Le srt Mieintanuable cd Pay at x aves Act "C3 ge es wn be wk om SX oy 2 cer Sec RD int wee Sere.
ye 'tee ae f a ata pres nd gen % ee ~ Ke wee va : 2 "7 cs none cy vegas May Lo 'od SS 'st "edt : Vo! wy Yeni Sek a on es a ee Fa weet be % a ro cs a Ee 3 6 S i 'at fees wie "ee we ee 4 ; oe , : a) , i ta be oe: ed MS be # oe WO od Be ho aA eS ng me 4 wn bee. es " . ra oe fee ee race Catt 2 oer e ng we S : boot gen oe me LE os fore i oS res ~ seni pot, pd ster' $ fe a tot "ge eh, aphen, oes oS chat oe 2 & - >, eee ! oe om, SS 7a Aeee epee ee a5 we Spike:
a #5 ae ae ed. vr phen been om as 'nad ay int Sree 9 vee pee fen he re int wpa wet oe is ny PE ae 'elie z a dont wh arene, Be £ £3 'rn ae Fipas vg S ene hy oe 'ad Spee eee rg gre a Soe x eee wen yor pigee ae tb ve Set eek cae 2 bad pts ba 5 eed js i, : , Z 3 re ; bet yn v4 ap ee % i ti bod 0A wa Peet ' wns wee % igs por a ot great eat : es % ee
3 - j ee oe Bee lb t, om % 3? eo o :
by a ag B se be es, : wanes ed ae & oA 4 eek we a ae Ka 5 i ey 3g he ha ie alee pote, hae he A 3 5 aiee ; he tp nee oat g oe tet Es ? 8 ne were feewn hey res ood o arog gh % gS feet es be E 3 om <e4 ' a "ee er fa < 3 beg yea BD S54 fos f 2 a z von me BEE a, ee E me A es oS fea woe. hed tot fat sine - aE "
£; we : 2 é a aS eee, a we g , " ae Se ey
4 ' pen on te * a 9 we a - pre 4 = et an! Mire, he bs ' 2g 2 :
: ae or eee ie : > ais th oe"
"t & aun