Karnataka High Court
Divisional Manager National Insurance ... vs Shankaragouda Puttanagouda Marigouda on 6 January, 2011
Author: Aravind Kumar
Bench: Aravind Kumar
1.. ;'3:pp€:§__i_2:::$ {B}; Sréi E5¢E'i,§{2:},?z{;<::3ai:?§, fade-*<:}<:2.:t:<::} iv» 3 C1 %'a1z<;E«:i:"23zi«::a":3 Eézigearaisgzzgb Nzgaizif", fige §if';¥aj:>:r, ('.}C<r.: Piaaznzaié? .R,5c3.Kagi:*1eHi, Tq.ig}?E2zf§&'i§§'§. - W.» 2' Bheernzippea ':}g§a.ppa H<>s~:ama:r:i, Agfi §'x:'§21js:';:', {}<5:;:{::" :3??? "£31312", T R;'@._H'5ddég<ms:i213 Tqx; Bygacizagi. " _ . ._ . 1?v3$p;}:1d€nts {By Srflgaxmem '"E'.1'vEa:m_2:zg2:r:i, fidi'. far ' ' * 5 R~2 SE' 2-"srecéi ' This; §'€§§Z*'5¥ is; fékicé wider S<::¢:.i:-3:2 <3'fLTE3§'_CV;%g:i againgt the judgment 212253 mafia"? dalssti i}"§.v§}E3,_ié1'£§()5éA =;§ai:::«é'ed NQWCA/NR
23.§;'2Q€}4 an Ehe file »:>:P.Ej.b':*_ §,,a[b<}:,jtr_:§7}§§7i§:%E:*'_'2%_nsi% ¥Z€2mr:1;is$£0n€:' far "Jxf0rE<:m6r:'$ C{3IEEj;*€nSé1fiG$":§';" _,§."§Ei"§"€'3'3i, 3,wz_az"difig§'2a;"'Ce:}mp6n$a€:iG§: Crf R3f?'3,30é,«'~ wiih %§§€€n?"kZ%S'€.'-"£'§';Ed "{f:£:'§~{'€f3(f.'{.V";'[;ij'§.§Eifipfiflafli herein 1:5:
degxsit the samzz. f_ " ' '§'1'1tié»;e 3.f;:pr:e1_E:% :;'<>v::f3§2j:g%,'9:3'._{5:..._a.:§mésésskm E;§1iS C121}; {Em Ccéuréi aieiivered {he '§<:>§E;w{ri'ng:: _ V "
k 'F§1€s;€._§ §§¢s;;eea£3 é:*<:?f-_fi§€dVb}=* the i}'§SE.;E§"€:f" centezziiizzg that ii EEEQEES :i§:,$;fi':£$:?fi{§:§f:f§"«:_E2€ insured 312$ pay '$38 a::'m':z:":'{ awaféeé bf; Ehé,!i:'i.b'a::1$;fz=.._g:3";éé'=ih§:3 §.§§'{';»";,§.i'}{§ ihai {3§5<;§T§E&1"1§S aarem Ceafiss ::;~:;:;aiEé1zg A 3&2 a iz*'a ;E'_;i£$é*~:ra%Eer azzd 35 smch Ehe <::§a_ime:z':é:s am 20;: {T231/'€§"€C§ .:,é:<:§;€:" ths éizsuraiacs §§}}§C}-' égsussé. in rsgpsst §§§"€:*i;§.:'f;g§ Vfisshéiiie 3:25}. am Ehese grasuzzais Ezéazzrsé haw saazghi; fer ':€%2i;a;e<%':7.:'%:g«»,j..iE'g:5 :~;L2,%3:§:2«m€é:5:§ €gi,E;.€E~;%"§{}":'2 23:? Esgazar £23 §e2v<:s:,'a:"' Q? {E36 §':'"3§i5E;3;;«E{}j.':€§" afimé éigééiffifii 2%: :":§a:':":'§E::'";%&¥ i%Ww L% 1 -4-
2. Thig {Z:3u.:*t iiad Qrdered fa? ésszgamte Gf rzetslce '£6 z"e$;pa::d€z*:f:.s._ iakiaag 352:0 cam.si.d€ra'zian {he questiazz Q? Eava mriseé in 'Ema a§pe::«.=:§ was sszémiiar 2% {ha aguegiian 'L12'-'izéer cezzszéderaimzt 'befme Bivigion Eemsh Q? this C@':,:ri_3L_:".;. §§ef'{E~'Ze§"~ Naséaaézgagg,a§57;2o§9,555a;2@09 and @5§§g2@§§ §y fL its Grder §ated 27.i2.20}..{}h ';'€'0*a..&;=' it 13 b::fb»ii g§i£ .j'i:3;_?i;}'-':6 1{'§§:i§<:v€' §;*>f this Cam': that Said quasiian has beéfl £;'£._Z"1.S's/'£7€11f€;Ac'§T""L'2:«' i;-%«1'5<:vA 'V Qivigian Bench of this (2011:: in a§3oi%é.%7&:ferrec:§" ; fiegéasagzagg,é5$7;2a09[%§5s;駧§_$fid.@55é;20@9 by its §E°§€I" dateé §g,;gg;.;%g;'_".\'.ig éiabie ta %.n&€mnii'§;' iiiés §'§A'1"S3';iAff€§ 7'§ a:i:é=, ' p&jj'. {$1.6 <:s:>mpe§::.$a:ésn ta c§aima_ntss, Sa§:';§Si;2'"?3i§"€}'§SVSii"fi's~_§»§§~§E'&€"*€§ 3:2 recerd. 36 S23" €}§8€V1'.°ir'v':'f'}Ci;"fi€}f€E1'1EibG"v'$, in {big appsal aim éhe §r*:s7'z.;a_:'2e:*' :3 5q';:1.e§é';"':j;§<a;/'2§.2j:;.g £33 Eéabiéézgy {<2 inéerrzzzify {ha i.n;sm"e& 12;': ._:"€s§*3e3<:f:'j€:=§'__ ;é.Ez;3§f".r.:;s; éf::?i'$§n_§.;; s'u;_?. :3? a mafi trafiéc aCC§§€f'§E "¢*}ca:'u:*2"&a:E 2?é"%:éE€__"éa:?"§§*'§ng csggiées in 3. é::'acE{>?wi:;"a%ie:i:f. Saié égsue ge§:~:g :%::.aré""rs:sw£:2:egr3, and aanéa? havirgg %3€€?f1 hzsésj. by {ha V".."_'Ef§%:;"%§é~{;:*§,._ Bézrzciz sf zéiég iiauri in 2{t}€}1'€ rééferrizati afipsaésj I V 'ihaii: é:i:s;z,.:r<sr ss;<mE::%§ :;:«:% Eéaéfiés is"; {he ézgzmrsé z:2§ $°}L§%.Z"§"E {:§.;:.i":1t3.s; €}":,':?; $3: rzyzscé azssééeni WW"
c. "
5. 3 \-
'v':'":'_;3*' pe:"*::a.imZ:":g :0 ":r*actar--{:"a§.1€r <:23r:°j¢i11g; its Caolies, s'ubsia:_;1£:ia§ quegtisza sf law 1"E§iS£1'{'I in this; appeai vantéuid be ::a;»v'=:>re:'§.'i;w§§"<i_}f:%:
judgmsni 5:? maféséezé gfiiéfih 0% ihis Cami: a:n:.fE' ' questiazz G? Eaw £3 answerséd agai.r:s"§ E2:::éu=::«€%:f arid. :'v:é"?f'amx'u:9 @fL'._ re3;3e:>n&ez1%;S and a{:C0z'd.ir2gi}=* apgeala $16 é?._§s;:;:2ésTS:3_§i,--.{3;:fn{;f{§.:f;i'= in deposit is ardezed {Q he trar:Sfe_:%€7_d is" 11515 .3u~:éé"§iV§€ii:':e:%;.aE Commiasiansz' by Ehfi Rggéségrg' f£>r:%::i.'éfi*: Ekaz" being-v..d%.8bursed in accordance wifiz the erd%?<s5r;"a§;.rj."i'* ;:w5::*é1?'».V gfiassefi by the Cemmissianeézx