Karnataka High Court
M/S Shriram Chits (Bangalore) Ltd vs The Joint Commissioner Of Income Tax on 15 February, 2010
Bench: K.L.Manjunath, B.V.Nagarathna
'_&$S§C§%§E$§ TEQX § Zfi ffifi gzag §9m§% Q? KAR§%EAK&\%? 2Am§gs§g§_ aaiga Tfiig $32 E5fi3fi§E $? Egaafigygg é$§% f» §RE$EE?_m.
wag E$§*ELE gas§§s§ficEfKiL[§A§3§§£§§f?f gfig A . T _ v 1 V $33 g§gfELE as;yfgt:c§*3 v §$Q&§A§§§A :°?.&,aea23§7a§*2§@§'* $§T%EK§: ' 2 fiffi sxgzggfi ggifsfligéfigzfiafié L?§ {m2@%fiA$s$amm§fifi3{mfimmm :§};$§;gy%gg§, gE_xwsgaxacuwxva mzggcyaa §§Re§AL§?§*$$wzA; """
3&5;-g¢3§'$:»§E$E$g*a aQ§A§Ar§@,25§;31 :3?.?LO0Rg:§§§ @§¢$s,§:§$ofi Qfififififig S%$%$R$M§§fi.%3?, %§§E$%§?
_ {§§ §Ei:$'$§§§§§§E, SR, €$¥§$§L Kfiffi ,K§$§EM§§§ ¥3LB$§g F§§ Q 33%} ggfiggy Qgggg §§§ :
1 "ffifi §@E§? Sfififigfiififififi $3 EEQQEE ?%X S§§€§%% §§§SE"§, " ._ ;§&§§&L§§E. §ES?Q§§E§?
" {E§ 32:; K §péR£§E§E; C§§fiSEL yga 32:. g V SE§§A§fl£;E§ &§V& Ffifi fiE$§@§§E§T} Th:$ Z.Taé fiiefi mfg: Eéfik sf tha Efifififi ?ax &ct; :§§i a§ig;mgT gut af Qrfiax dataé /' €&v/ S5'?
231.23% passeé 31.2; :m }<%'¢$. §18_fEa.:.?:§";'2$G2' :f::r the &$S@$$mRt yea: 19$8~§§ praying thai"fifi$$u §aa'%le Senzt my be ylaasafi ta:
a} imcmzate the gzsbgtamtial qz2as't._3'.:it'a;:Vf::z;s=.Vv §_3.%é:{"
fitated thexain.
b} allaw the a§§ea§ ané $at{a$i§e;%§é ¢r§$£ $£Tf the Zncoma ?ax épgellata Tribunal begging i?§% Rag. 2§8;'E;:z1§f2$§2 éated 23;.:;;,2:2s4 J:s.--s.sa $792? as it xeiates treating't§e.fiivifien§ i§a¢&"i$ iaxabia and is net exempt gfifiar the"Ea&@a Tax émt fitc.
_ mzs Ayymg Cfii=§3«. §~§S' _€§§§:. ;é*a§:§..»"ez«;?#__$;;Rz:i:{; 213:3 my, zamggmagwa J; $22:-zgggggaf T§--§.?;. ';:%';?;:::2*_;:;a:&::xm:
Qéwfiava.§e§ré.t&§"1%a$ned acunsai 5%? the §art:&s§V .$e '?h@ Vafiggggae hag fiiefi tfiig g§§§a; §&§§: §&$£$§g_ 2§$A. 3f the Emcama §ax fiat; 1§§§grxhé:fi§; agg§i$vafi b? aha aensuzrafit
-fiiadfiggé 5% the axégr paggaé by éhe égaesgimg . *k§§§is§: swhiah has %&ea cagfirmad by thfi
-jfifigiggianeg afi Eficama ?ax {e #3315} agfi ' §é$ther affirmafi by t&@ Efififimfi ?ax figgaiiaéé ?§i%§fi&l, Eafigaiaxeg ifi EE$ Ea Eigjggmgffifi é§.2$w39 fifié. ' 'mi
2., *§'33e fiastzs iaaéizzgf ';:a this hazaumfierz Z *:'T::e aypeiéliazxt -s-= Ezzasi fiazzwazzyfi Tha §;i$§:a;*§:e assegszmrzé: yaazr 1§§$m§§'IL»::*T§1& fl$'.2:_E.ed :.3f::$ xafiurn cf i::d§:*:e~& vL**v'{.';:':;V_$:;"et%.$SesV$é::é:".at yaar :§§$m§§ as :§Q11,;g§a_&g¢:ar$a§ gn amount cf %:eé:2"31:*:*:::" *:é'as...%;5ra§:&sse<fi unfiar R§.2a,??,533;:
geatian and erdaredg far ;%&f:;:'§;%§; c.=.:€1 iimfiiufiing iiztgresi $§ »--V t%2& &'¥'i*$i§E§.€. was aégjugtafi 'i:.mgz§;:§;az 31%-:%~ ..V_ $.}2'.f.::'gV:s§2.*s gf tax gafgabla by aha the aaziier aggaggazzamfi §'€&:°§¢. A A ':a§*£§i§:§ :§;:;+%¢;§;§,é' gggt:§:3 :é3{§} wag ififiuadfl, &fta:: §1eé§r::":%;§§ ,' :a:: axfiarzr wag ygagaé ézizacting éém gfiaagéée is gay the §%§.,&E"i@% af §.$,"?§f§§§3;§§;"-=, §.?§1i$5 mxégfiz? wag fifififiéé an 2§."é,¢2§§:,§ a :::c;'%;+;;';,:*;$ tggzfier fififiiiflfz
3. Subaaquazztiyg 323% was iggizaaé :3 ézfizfi agsagsag by iziwm ;3'§:;::t €S/ ,:%452_§.:§?;;:2§.¢.:.:§€sf; téza gaéggant $5 522% Eiazéfbia ..g'm*m Cammigsaianez far §;Z"";$QE'f%fi Tax an the ~ the grder mf assesfizzaazért. gégggaé _-{$:':"" V Ezas ta ha restifzed as: time ;"i:,_;.*:i'?<:>2:h._fi"* izétexest Qaysbié u2°2de2_r' s;.§st§.l¢,!:*; 23$§".,3{ za;9x:§,':°z.Qt"
been laevzad wéfizige §g;LS;sfé;;f2a§_»_ mi &$$€§$E'£$§"'i'%';;. Rf; 3% sf the Ermerga "fax A3: wsasg §gf?.3"é%1..%X2'€"E éfi . 28 . at s 2f'§.£*§%;'. :3::_:: tha Agswaélng' Qffi a&i;.%§_ wag garrgléataé fiha Encarm Tm Emi far aha ma Em 'haé. mt $21a:';§':a:%.%a'?;. :E:e:V"§;;::*:e:.?a:a%: pagraaé . zzizéax sasxtiara 23% ";f:gmr:;:'::j=x @223 2:x§§ case arid '%:§2$..%; the ardaz =.§c:§*"".;:*%§::;.§;é.$9;%;i@§z '£€§,S rafiizeé, 'ta baa by him if; 2r:z?.&%-9»: gf téaa szzhseqziezzt; .' :i§%c5;:*§$§e:;':i:3;.=a;§ azztzazzfizzeaé, 3%' gaatimrs 23% 3 cf 'tT§"2.a E*:'..::&:m@ Act 2€;§':;§ Aaamzfigimgly azz @:'§@:* wag pasgefi aaiiing awn ma agzseggee :3 $33 3 3222:; Qf R$,§,,§5;%%g2?.§.;'~=~. Baglng aggzggavefi fig? <Q7/ 5 the ardfix Qf xefitifiiaatiang the asSe$s¢,£;E§é gfi. appaai. bfare kiha €$cmmi$s1anez' $§"Efi@§g$ . Tax iégpagla}, Bangaiara. E35 £amm:s$;§§er_c€"' inflame ?afi {%§§fial$} after heaxifi§V§h§°§é£%;§s éigmigséé tag agpgai §§u§enfii%m3n§ §§a,§$de:. af raafiifiaation $3: fiifiifiédgg §&a§%.%§.2QGl§ fihile flsmiasingVtéfi.afi§g§§; §fie Camm:s$i9mer Qf Xmaame $33, :§§§§§g1g§ fi§é§$é$ agam the 512 men: __ 4' sgmzzr ma.
233 »$E::I:'??E."€". V CG%fifiR$:&.'I.; ?3§:.}«iE$ §a3$e§.i% §;§§§§$;§§$§£ ta :§8§§§1§§3a Beimg aggriaéfi by ;t&§',¢Qna§rre§t fiifidimgg, iaa &s$é$$a% §i§§@ gavgyyeai bafaxe tga Emaame ?ax fl"%§§@ii§té.&?§§§§%a:, Eaagaéaza Eaaahg whiah V_§g§eai3é3§¢"¢am§ ta kg éigmgssefi reiyiag ugaa €:.3f:é»7 i:E;2%3:{.:i:;:§':%,§i$ 23,22 EEESEE $E2sm:~:?:* :;:2«z:*§§;§ arg. §E§<~"'E.§T'?.:2.'f_ -fi'§§2%§»§§$£:$§'»§ER $3? Cs3>§§§§:m ',.;?;',§£E£., r_3g:mgv3ggr:%veé %§ thaga Gréergg thg §§g$&fit ' ;§§p§ais:$ filgdé (lb;
é, ?h& a§§aal was afimiitafi ;mfi; $§%V. Septembez 2334 is asnsidex fiheH[£gii§w:S§ _ g gubstaatial qfiasticms sf lag: _« fietfier the §p§a1ia§é* ?r:§g§g§ was xigfit in hm1$i§§ thai't%& §§§§§V mi rectifimatigfi §a$sé§ufim§e:ASeati§n 15% gfi the éafifi_f@:{*%§&f:33sessment yaar :§§ge§§ ;ag§;gg iété$駧 far tha firfit :im@ und§: $éa;23§gg gs vaiid?
5. $3 3? é§%a§§£$Q*i&§:fiéd fiemiar csangal 3§§&a@:m§ §§:%§3§afi&ma$t£y gafimitg t&at $13 tag a§fih@:iti@$7 éi£. mat asggzdgz that the _ fiaggméaa ififlg§§$Q§E §Efi§§? gfifiaf L?$£ §E§§?§ A*,.§$fifii$$:@§gR Q? ixx %CEAL féxgfif has X3 駧ii:éE;$n€"ft@ the factj Gf this saggy _ gcéézfifig :9 big, t&a Eamgfile sfiprama Smart in j §3a§:$§:@§§E G? zgaggg ygx $3. Egg Efifiié :;.::§:§g§ rapaztfié ix {2$§?; gga :?R 252 ififi} u"§a§ takan g View at thfi zgzavagt §@:mi fif iia whax tag vaawa-wara §£5i§§&; if tha §$$§§$i§§ Gfifigaz hag taxam fiflfi §:&w§ but $3 §a$§§§t Q? <"/' suhgaqzmnt azzwnérgmnt, the view czzmnsmt mu i%':gf;%..g ta be imvazid and 'aka same has ta valid. Eaiyimg uyan thig z}'udgmz:t,--~V§*;m ::jg§2:2ié%:i--'jts'4 fihat the 3'udgmem€:; zeiiéfi .fb<j; "' t§_:%;1VTA« Cazztzgzigsiezzar Qf Ezzamzw.' ':s..$'" wa3.:i" tizeé Ezibunal was met rendered 4%,;;«z';;éa;z* t?§:e::._§z9Qv:§:.s:i.er;s $15 the 231662226 Tax 5233:, %,<;:*{fi":§_;i:»..é mg prwvisians at' the Eiazfnatajga. Ssaifié'-..T'a.:;v._.%;%.i;§:,,v"'=$;\':'§c:ez*di3;22§* to him, c¢z:5.::de%:'3;:§§g? §;§é. a§;:g9:z::$$:::§'¢L""'fe§ thig azasa, thfi "33-:V'i°§'.'3?1&fl~g§§i3¢:i': §*::a71sv..__;*?.m5 appiicatiazz 2% the faatg $§fi'=..§t:i2§,$"V-;:é;$e§ ""--._ '§5he::&f§3:*ag he §:eq.,z.ests :h:s4;jcf:cm.:: «£:§::_ '§m:-gsggiaez tha gfazestima Qf iaw §§:a;s.;s{lég;~:. 223:3 light fig the guagmna $5' aha $®z%£v§ES$I%:>¥ER §F Zfifléksfi TAX 2%. V V' éaifiéé ";:2x:§::;a; -§,;::«:z:%E§,. .. *§er aazztzag My. gxamaég iizéza Eaazfneeé _' '.f:3$§§§%'§$16§:i §.§§&a.ring far the xwyfimue szfimsits that aréer gaggaa mafia: aacgifié Q5 fifié imam "'E?a:; Ag: was just; 333% yrapar, ma Eevy fif irztgregz iifiéfififif ;~:v;$@a23%§ :3 marzfiatazy araé <"~/ W) gsgessiag fiffgiamf had left saw:
zntazagt umfiaz se§.23éE. Ea xgéiifgféthé"
migtake mamittaé. by aha; @§§i¢&x§ g;t;_%§$} lways span fa: him gfia §aS§~ a§,3$x§e::}¢f \* rectificatian. ?§%ref¢§$; ha nréqaesig the fifiart ta éism;ssv:§he a§§ag: ¥3nd, 3% mainly Kélififi Eupn tha amefi§mefit "f§$@§§ht imta Eaatian-23éE 3§£:$$§a¢§§v%:y§u__f ?L "§av$mg§a§§§§d. ifié saunsei fax tma a§:i§§¢ w%a§'tfi fié kw: caagidgzeé :y*'a$ in _ . 3 $§i$ %§§ééiVi$_%h%§§%f tfia Qzdar sf ggsagamaat ' <§a$fiéd¢b§3:%§'§$$é$s:ng Qffiaax at axe firgt ";§$§&fi§$V%&§ §as$eé relying apan ifie Qfigmant 3f,t%& $&§$&m Qauzfig Z5 Ems §a$ yagsa the \ar§§rW§€ afisesfiment bagaé an aha éfifigmant Gf 7§u§$me Cbuxtf ig ii agxfiz far 3% éfififigfiiflg RwVV$f§ice§ ta zaafiifg tha srdar relyifig upfia the } V'$u%$&q§§at amnfimgni ta tfia praigiafig fif Sacififiéfi?
&, 'Ex
8.' it 23.3 329%; in éiaguta;-;, V' assasgxzmgzt "é»2'3..% passad, byw .._i'.%::'3 '}.%is;;*.V:%:$e§$$_:;;A:z*':§'».. Czffiaezf. as peg An:1§xw*nr§w§%;3a§;%f'_'eT2'§,§;:§§fl.§:§,., prmfzisian af fiéafigéfi I_33$G@z%£ ":?:'é.':z;" iégat '' was gfit amgzzézeé with .....:"9é'!.::_z*§$§ec'€if.§;"%.§%% ../Eefféat zzrméeg: tém Finance gffacfi: frazzg :.,é.1§§§g _ ';?__z*Q:;:: cider sf assas$:m§zj;:*.~ §'31na;*:a@ Act wag, a;{:.,._;:_g§. ::§V'::;; that as $3': tégg fiafia af 3$$essz::&nf; this améaz':§§::2.ez:%I'._§3g$ ::=;§':'Aé:E:$§:.+%, By xaa-ding the erfiar 3&7' 2:§:j~j:§€:;':;;f§.£;a;?§':r;;-::§§.:;____§:g,3s$fi afiéer $$$.1§§ af tha §.c§i.;, f.:$r:m$ss:@:°;e:* mi' Egmmgzza 'EQX has sézatéé timt: while paasizzgr tézé «firdafi '$5 a$s@$§;§:@§:t far time asgagsgamt ygar .ii,,§'§5«.=.--_§§; fiailawimg the §?§fi @ Qf the EEaz°;*'b1'm .fj.:g?::;;:%e:fi& Smzift in aggaaz 333$ E.-,gE§§§§'% Em gm mmag imfiaxegt uaéaz saagsgzg 3.2: ha has zeaggzmé. "aha a&$e bageé; mt: wig afifimfixmrzt fif $%::.23§§ by Fimazzaa fiat, ESGE» Frag: xéafizlzig 31/ §t.12.1 Rasfiaetivaiy, £$11$win§' the CQ§§>'.§§$SE%§%§E SE' :1»-zcam max vg. "
the qgastism cg iaw in favm§§:®£§t§e.§s$e$$eg_' and against thfi ra¥%n§&f'.
1§§ %§$axfi3mg:y; th;§ ;g§ga§'i$:a§§$wads Thg agar §asse§;*§§_:$h@ uA$$é$$ing Gfficer mafia: $aa,1EéEvfit,2§;€}2$$E fig §é:"&a3exa:amB whiah h&g-$ee§Lcm§§§:mafiV&§uifié Cammissianer mf Zn§§§g\m$gg&V§%§§é§:§§ $3 per knnexurawc i:§..32$7a:= _ am. -'2%;z~;_é:.%:~:e'z:%.1""-a§gwt:';;~me:§ %y we Encamfi ax %§§ai;at$ fzibgméiiéfiagaisxe Eamaé 33 §@r Eggaxézawfi §,§$.:;2§$% 33$ fierebg £3:
a$i§$§."
$%S§'fiw_Efi.\