Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Integrated with over 4 crore judgments and laws — designed for legal practitioners, researchers, students and institutions

- Know your Kanoon - Doc Gen Hub - Counter Argument - Case Predict AI - Talk with IK Doc - ...
Upgrade to Premium
[Cites 0, Cited by 1]

Karnataka High Court

The State Of Karnataka By Its Secy vs Puttaswamy S/O Late Kempaiah on 29 April, 2011

Equivalent citations: 2011 (3) AIR KAR R 490

Bench: V.G.Sabhahit, B.Manohar

  E§5I':?;S{}R.;E', »» 5% Q05

xx: mg HIGH e:i«:>uR'r or KARNA'I_'AI"{A M' BANGA.I,--QRE
I§)A."1'E£i) mrs mg :29'??? 135:3' OF' APRIL 20 :4: j _

PRESENT

THE: E-~E<i)N'BL-E ME€.e,§US'FE(f.F3~'J.G'S4?§§ifi:5§§'§'i°   k V'

AN 1}

'mg I~1ON"BLE ;'»11éz.L:i:Mf:~m.,<3EA:3.Ma:%§T@H;2gR'%% 

WRIT AE'EfE5%.1,..:'~iG' . 2g:%i%y~;i:2o0';?' ' 

VVRIT .APPEA.I,,   209  f":":i_ Ef,S)

BETWEZEN;     
  2-'xE_';?EAIx NO;--23 -1;":::'<30*?

2. THE 5i1fAi<1':::,0F 'KARN~;x';*A:<'A
BY"'11*:~.. §€$ECi§:E'FAiRY',  '
}*iEGE{EiR'~}?§I3}{5{1§':*£fIC3--3§€; J
R/I';G.I3Ui£.,_[)E%_\f{}';'  
8ATNQALO'E2E'::{, . 

2' EV 'T'1~E.E  JGENT EDERECTEER,

" "'*cg}§,L.E,G:ATE:---:mUcA*:f10N §)EPARTMEN'i'.,
 AP?EL,mN*:'3

 §E§€:.j:$:%:':§%:.§§§i::'$:;;r~s;sg. ASA}

V -V A1*~.2%)  

  3; =  4_ PVE§§"'§'§'ASWAMYz

V  AEEELEE ,a«"§[§%{} {ET $8 ':"§:g%.F{S,
Sr,/{E E,r1'¥'£'E<Z EEEQM PA§;f'i.H
E-§?{}E4?;Ei§I'§'{} HES PE*§§'"E3E{L%f§__. E~:E§}E.§{f;X'§'§{}T*~E



If}IRELCTO¥Z (S. G ' L) .

PBS CCEL-E:LC':E» OF SCEENCE.
MANf)'.:"A DIS'i'RIC'E',
RESIDING AT NCLL284,

gm) CRQSS, BANIDEGOWIDA LAY€}U'§",__ '  f '7   

MANDYA -- 571 401...
EVTA§'€E)YA DIE5'I'REC'E'_.   

2* THE PRINCEPAL   *
P,E.S.COL-LEIGH or: S€3I.ENCE,_ 
MANIDYA W 5?: 401., '  "
MANDYA 3I')ISTRiC'.I'.

3' "ma SEcRETAR*:?"=;'o    
GOVERNMENT 0}?' ?:E\"if)I.§¥; ::v1_1~_1'_§»2_:3  .
}§;>EPA¥Z'1'MEN'{' OE Aggy CjAT£'I<f)N,   

NEW £i>E:LIfi£E.._« 1.30 Qgfi. 

4. THE ;C'?§2'E.IV¥éE'y€}_XF€;5§E.E€.Ri%'i'i"}§E2Y'
i'jNIVEf;R$_i'§f'Y GR,AN~TS_ CC}°1X»{f;MISSIOF\E,
NEW .%£1)':*;: 1.,;«i'11::;a E :0 Q0 1 ; ~  V   ... RESPGNIDENTS

{BY SE1Mg_S§PAR;§'3E§AS.;§,E%Q§f.'£'HE. ADV FOR R1,
SR1fiSHRI3E{A?~E'§H'; ADV ma R1.
SR:.p,s._:):N§3}~1.KL5MA§2';'Am; ma R41

 R2  R;3».:§RE u;f3AE§RV'EIf}}

- "W..;%:r:n*»;%..§>§>§:A':;':4":L§:3 {}/S 4 0;? -mg E{ARNA'I'AKA

 :'é:?<;:.~§A  AC'? PRAYENEE m ;§§::r ;%SE§_>E':"3 THE
Qfgigfiék E%s%"=;;53<SE§1> EN mg: mag'? pmmgm

N{>(':4.99:{:G,:'f3é:}{:5 I,}A'}'E*:§fi} EGXG?/2396.

,..
2 ?'3/"'"

MW



.'  V ,

1.

W'RI'I' APPEZAL.NC>.Q4/ 2()O7{S--i4{E§S}

B E-"I"'\?'v":

'I'}*~EE; S'i'ATE OF KARNA'I'A.E{A
BY {TS SECRETARY
HIGHER EE)UCAT1'{)N'.
'M.S.BUILDING
I*3ANC:A.LORE -- O1 .

THE REGEONAL JOiI\E'I;V'17).:i._R.EC'1'C§f"i.. T 
COLLE1C}IA.'i'E E1{}UCA'15E-Qi\fv--I)£_-?a?'£'., %  
MYSORE M 5m Q1325. : T' .. A1DPE;LLz-xN'rS

(BY SR1..I3{.KRISHNA, ;§;Q;;a,.;__  'V

AND:

E.

SR1 i~1.:'Ff§;駣E.NiEZ' <';:'tif§i\'3v"'_:j;zix'; 5

;<:=5;'()'1,,/9;:1,*E  141333 s3:3w':>iA§

;E§.G§_Z'£} ,:%.E;§f.}.LI"§7 &*',§;;aR:s,

W0 RKIN.C§ 'ASE _£»IB;E,C'§'OR OF PHYSECAL
E1>1;%'CAT1<3;\J *{.S.{3;L.)$

_ SHRELADECHUNCHANAGIRE
3  AR'i'S &_R;3.QMME_RCE carmseag
 1's§AG;5;MAN(}'§:i;A M 5?: 432.

m1Aj:--s.r3":?A 1:~1s"m1<:'1:

  T. E3;§_S'2<3*fi:>£T?s_\:"g:f: AT "SRII\"§ZE)H§"L
~.  E§'§ii'J_E;§}.I*C3;%XE\1;'a'ifELE RGAIL
 '§',E3'EZ§?<I'£'E:N$f{}E\§¥

Ngié-g%,MAN{}AIA W 5?}. 432'
"i%a§£'1N{i}YA E'}ES'}'REC'fI

 'i'HE SEZCREi"'E'AR":"1
532%: §a§',)Es'j§{E_§§'€C?E~i_A_?€A{§§E{}; g:.§z*':*$

;'%I'*£ E} €I{}?%:'E'?y'§ EZEECEZ {"i€}i,Ei*Z{}EL

xi
j%/§'/k/~~
3' 5.



NE'iC3AB£'1ANC}fXI,J*X ~ 5?} 482
EEJLEXN If)':/z~X [3 I STRI CT.

mg SEZCEEEETARY To
GGVI:?;RE5\EM}E<:'NT arr :N:;:2IA.
:xz:;+~11<e.£>§

Ef)EI3'T.€3F E}i)UCA'E'IC)N   
.NEW I>£:£,:-11+: 10 001, '

THE CHAIRMAN/SEc;2.I;"rA:%Y   X _
UNIVE1R_SI'I"_;i' Gmms €:C3.EyiMISS£QN;   M
NEW 13mm 410 001..   REi;'}.I?i3?<II)E;'fNTS

{BY SR1.}VI.S.PAR'I'HASARA'f"HI§. 'Z§'£§._f€~".'»:E'O\R C /$423,?
SRI.R.,S.I}ENESH KUMAR, 'A_E)_Vf.I?OR k

SRI.SHR}}E<IANT* A1"::v FQR R1  j'
R2 AM) R3 ARE: ':'3}ERj'~{'E£3} - 

\;aRi**:é 9;1%pé2£;;;;-- Efimiu LE;/3%; 0%" THE KARNATAKA
E~i§G-H7i;'G§}IR'i4:"§;CfiE'»[.P1'%,éfi{§EJC: TO SET AEIDE THE
ORIDEER '*--__PASSEZ_If) ' --  r:$3 THE

'v¥RE'E'

N84 §§%?;/$6 /2:CG5V'£}§fi{_£';?§;'_£)  1 Q /9? /2095.

KB

_ 'L  ":'}}:_§:;":e.€f'%~.V$5/*§z:":;' APPEALS A_E2E Hgwims BE.EE'*x§
. a{,§%E;%§§:T31i"j'~;;;j»*:§%V+.fR}«:SE§2vE:1> Arm cgrvmg; ON gm»:
?EéQ§\LJ€}:§I§E:€i'EiEiiz'iE:3E?'§' 0? JUE5GExzEE:?_N"i' '§§~HS mix:
MA$?®E£AR J., §1}EE.§'v'E';F€§%2E}'.E'E-EE? F{}EJE.£f}'%?'k/'E?*JCv:

PET§'TIGE\F



'...€\

JUDGMENT

Appcriiaritié; are :*e3pe:::3d<:m.ss E ar":{i' '2 ._ i;r.1 W.P'N::*19§30/2005 and w.p.Nu.18346/zofia, -.j1§g%mg zzgg:ri€"~;.r<::d by fht;-% €_'3}:'d€',i' €i£iT.€f{.i }(}?i?5~':2;x'}V&_ §3:;::»9;.;é3t'iu:§_ ",b§2' =i:h<?*;a 1€:e1:*r1e3.ci Single J1.1dg_-:6. a1I<3wi;":g i:11céV__Wt'iVi. p<;éi:.i':.i_:;fis; fik-%{i '~by"« file firsi: res:-;pe1':d€é:_1i. in ;1_p£)e%z:{S,"A i:h_€~_=t CrC}V€3'1"E1I"I1€I3"f. Cir:71;;1:21a:&_ and G0ve1:"nm€I1t. 0;~<1m:. 2e3~5~2005 p€£.SS€'§d by f:.h;_;% the appééilants ':0 refund 55116{:_2:;£3.11£)'Li'i?.'f,_E%i1id ;tL>AAr€%i':;ei's£& the benefit: arising; 011:: 051.195-)6 -.p5z1§;:":s:;:i1--e' tic: %:h€: p<5£'.E'::i01':<-31*s5 preferred theses: wriii §.e2i"i:5. 7 2" ;';?»i§1<':e ::%1¢V{%<§:nI"i::3r1 e:;u<';és.-:E',§<::r; czzf Ezars.-V and f'5:<:*£iS 212?:

'é§":'§JE>E§:éE_E? _%:9.z'=_::'t;&2 \>s.-'rE'£; zippszaissé. bz:)':§1 ihéf :;§.p§;§¢3ais am ::Et:'§;%>e't§ :%;~.:§,g§s:«%.'§'1Vt%'r and (ii:-2;p<>$e;3£i 9? by ilhifi {'.€}E}'1E}"I%.{}X"} (}Zi'"C§€iIE'. E':
3, Th('?. p€:tii:i(3I1E-rs' in W.P.N£>&19930/2005 __. Was .'w appoéniied 21$ 22 Pb}--'s;ic:ai Cu1.'t.ur€: I:"3.ssi1*1.::7i;<}:* {BI} 55% in 3:6: 5?" re:,~;pc::1de::1trCe:>fiegg¢:: azaci he repc>riéi;i fT<§r"=s:?£1;i','§%-T " am ?--8--397Vi1~. His ssaiarjg x:~s:e1.5; fi};fi'*fd"&1S yer _fi.h¥:-,~'Ci.i:<:1}:.£2ii<. déitfid 1~E--"E9'i".f>. Thfi: 2=1L1i'h<>1'i{ieé;;<:i:--ni:er.11€::E €,()1?:fir;*m:3iti'._ hiss servictesw In \%'i€\2£='* of {%0;11.£fig__§» intoV.£§:£r*::e:*_of'1f,1'i%:' UGC V pay 5963.18 x.v.€.£". 1--1~§9E§A'6, §f,;:a££tA 61" F%;g;.30OG W 5000 was extiended was 21130 ext.eI1{ic3d_ £1*<3§r:{:'::{1L:§--I~ geiection Grade Sr;':&"£}E'. <31' @213 éixiiendfid {mm ' at R$.r-'L325/-- as; on E--8-- 32$' é3--9~1995 in Ehéi pay ss::a«1E(;*:---.:,>£'"? RS,uS'?T_ s 'fh':'3 pet.:%:1';iVr.>:j;_{;$_;j. in WgP,'NO.18346f28Q5 Eiexvizig '13.:-':,? T3<'§§§3,}:':§.§'{$13£EE§fiiTt2};.'iji(}§'"§ was 2?app<::§.m:6<£ 27:55 21 Pélygécafi {f§_z]é"§:{;m:% A §T--;%*:}j:as:i,§?1'-L:<:*i;<}2" <::e:'1 '?«€%~ .i9?"3 21?: Lexi i:%a1%1a.CE:i'2.2:' Arféa S{:i{4:z';§::5}A..2md S,§§.$<.?E_ab;m:':a S\€'3Hi}' {i:3m_:":'1é::r::€ C:}§§a%gE=,, " f§'§'2i:%'1:;:g;a i}is_»'~;i':'§{:t'§., '_§'§':<%:"::%2«1;f'§.<>:':: Em gait. 'E',:°a'3.§f;se;E7<1::"':"€{i; xiéw' is t..Ir:_e 5"? respc:t::ie.z'1i'--Cf0£1<3ge with $1116: 1'§mi;',u21E {1?.{)11S€?:E'1{, of bcsiih the Ins;*::ii.1::t.i<>:'1:--:1;. K388 UGC pay Rs3.§3Q€3O~:"§{)C}€3 W215; :3:>§:%f:e'n<:7is::€1 to him W.ewi°. . his; pay w:;1se; :f.ix<:c:1 at Rs:s.3,1GO/7E5h{%ré21fi':%r;jV»$€§;fa,i'<:s'r scizzdszt of pay W313 €?X'§,(:".1:1(i€?d and S€E4[£f{f?A_Ai{}'Jfi of scale <3? RS.37OO~5'?'O{) w'21§.~: (St: mfiis pay was; fixed at RS.3C?;UC'./~ E-.71;£I'i2..3'I€E*g as 035.'; 1~9--1£339E> his; pay vu*;1 s;,'i'E:?;::3<:*f§" at. 4;,4;?D/ 45 The Univer:f~Ai.y Cr:f:2;1.i. j'<fQms11i5é;i(§'1i* {:'%:3:1:»31:it:ute~d 23, Pay Rc:y'iséi'{§::T. Cf{}I11§,T':1t';iV'if,é€3. f{}T t:3fi@"' :9evisi<>.r1 of pay, The C<>n1mi'U;,§:t--é3. €::~:2i£11in'e€i.t1*;f:E'a;i:J§.€r" and submi'{:t.e3c§ ex re'p01'§' $16 the {3"x<?i_&?<::f:33i{§,9'=_ v{;§:"a11i. Cammisgizm. 011 V' r<;::<t{§m.f123 <33}-:§tc::.E::.E<>1': m:~3;'e:i'EiV by i',f:t;3 UGC, thezt Ct<>v<3r'r1me11{. of "§1i;€E%:21'V'd§%::%.§{Eei§A.._ije;;2 r<-3:vi:'--3e 'ézhe pay Sifziifif ti}? "§_"'e2:c§2e:'s;3 Li'i';»:*§,;v°£2:::'::_:e:. zifgfsci PE::;$iat21.E E€Z§'L?z€;fé1{.i():1 §}i§T%1%(,',?,{}.E"E3 in {he " "~.__Viff::}¥§ér::é33\.§%i2i: amzi A§d<i=:d C<éE§c;;;é:%$ §§:.'zbj@<:t; {:3 va_ri<;us-2 T ';;3:f<imf.$Aié:2:1$ st.ip1.zEz§%e:%§§ 33:; ii: gmzi §.§'i<3 E."€';":gLii.%1i"{.iO1:1 €r2m':.€:d if};-'__ flhéf-r U{}{iE. 'E.""'::e>. S"::2=,aE.e {}e:>v<3:_":"::1§;;%2'1':4 ::%é}:':s:si',i*f,:.2t'€j a z:;%%/M Cemmittee ti) Suggest the maclaiitieg of Scheme ':0 Extend {ha ravised UGC $63165. Based mcammenéatimn af 1:133 CGZ'}11'§ii'{'iiEi€, V' QG'£f€I'E'§I'I1&?;}i has aecideé ts ad6gi: a1':;d _:.%,'i*::E"i:r:§€-.i'%.:ii':3A HQYIEIS anci ui&€:}'ir1€s' and Starzrfiiéaréii A. reséz-'.ib€.ri:
Univfirsity Grant (:OIHIF1iSSi£}I}:"-.» A<::c:0rdir1g_ij;2_, State V' Gm-farnment by its orsiegj' daiiiéti' Véxtéfidad the re'1ri$€d pay Scalea fig: $ L'V'f§<=::529Lc:,.:'*':;._<::5V;}L-§r<sg.;V'. L{ibrar'£ans and Physical §ir%i'.f§ré.fii%€ "-E2%_¢:VVf'é0vernmamt and Aided Qf Department of C9i}egiL9HQt »3V ' '..."vv§fi§'{>;v1;1Suita1{i011 xvith thfi §O"1..«'6FI'zi'f£"i%I"1"€V sf Human Ressurces Be3xrf;i»:71;:§::1e':'*':n., A De'fpa::*trr£e:1t Of Educa_ti01';, Haw I3€:1h.i. réi§i8§%a:=<:§A_ {EC{CWEpaf§? Scaie WEE} be retmspestivaiy ;é f§1e:fi§6§¥? "V..ff&?::. "E44998 and Efiihfif berzafiis axriii be §ra$§'fspe§:1t:e.€:E:£ effectéd 1.6.. fmm the éaie Qf Gavernmemi 3r§€: '€ié;:ed :5»~nm:§§9. Caéuirii'; ':"~l0.@ @f the tabis in ";-'_.§§":*e Said G€3v€r7{1m.€ni:. Qffiifii" mafia §;§J1'2d€E£"':
£9-5;?"
L;
C321i.eg(§ry 'E',xi:2.%i;i:1;g S{?Z11€S of pay ReviS£%d_._${:a1€S of 13211;? 5 Librarian 3?o0A125m;95oA150M }2OGQ4:§2Q>.183OQ {S€I€c:€iG1': §Z?GQ L" 5 .

€}z'ad<::} E)iI"E?{.'.iltI)1' sf E3hy&3i(:a1 Educaf.i(>r:

(Se3ec:t:i01.1 Cr'ra.d€-3}
5. The revisegci S{'.2}AI_€s:. of pay?"a:2<:vL"i:1::i:1sive of Basic Pay, DA, Ini'.eri'm Relief aild. IZ>§:21:*'n§:ss Aiimvance admissible: as _:;3r3_ 1«~1;9'}'£§9§§. " E;z};._1i?;1e ...:§5j.id Governmeznt Grder, the ;:=.1"'{)C"~f?*'(i;Li'E'€ _f(}€1"' "a§<?1é:?:::Vt;Vi::>'r';:..:)§-- £,m::'i:ur€;* fin" the Se:1i<:rzfi C_§:f23..A:i5<é.* .,a ;<;, 'mfé-':'§,__ Sat:-fie.'-;r::€'io:1 Gracie, iihfi qL121iificaf::2i_(>i1. f('.II""=I"E§(':i'LEi'fi'¥f1€3f1*[.% p1":)bati0n§ t.ea<:hing days, EVOFEQ é:;:.2,1{i e%.'<:..V_g'Vx.¥z1S p£'€3E3{ZI"ib€d, 'E'h:3 pay :»3{:3.1s:3 sf §3£.:fjéa7?;{i:'. <>;f"~._;PhySi<:a§ EiTi'aI;C32"i.iZ.1§{))T1§ whizfh wa$ fixed 21$:
ixfag :"§;?'vi§f;€?c§ E~{:=;-;.1;2€3S{)~42G9283@§' ¥'%£%1i"§é': Eiéxitzg i:'§1<~3 pay :=3<:a§<:>., am-: bassieit Z.'€i"££§S€3§ £9-iiéliéf <31? » RS;,7§2Qf)Cf«« haS 11:} bis takesm §.:';.{:e:§ <:{3§1$iciemt..§.<,>:}_. Simws; *€.'}:é:"{*: .§$ S.-E-{'3Z"£E€f <£§.:e;;:=:,:"é.::=, 2*e:gj§22::*:ii:1g §iXE':ii'§€>E": :3? pay zmfi m'é§;§§€}E£?飧E€_3€i? in <::%:m:~%;€: €}€§3;} 5'}? €.Ef:s:r {}i}'€.f€?§"§§§§E§{°?I'";§i {}r{E:;=s:" {i;$1§'.&"f{i ; ,-
')/,: '"'§?*...r"
154 1-- 1999' the Kzar'r1211.aka1 U1'1ix?é2z'sif.y S(3L.1gE1{;_ fair {:1a1':ifi<:21§i:?r:'2 .2153 to whethssr ET)i1'€:(7{.m' of .F"I=":;é_';~:;_i{?::-?;I EciL1:721t'_i{3:1, i}£:%p::1i:y I_3ir&%<:f,r;>I', ;'£s3&;:%$t'21mi: Ii)i:'c%:j¥<}'r .E§{:~*:.h ' S<;%I:3.m':i{)n C}'1'ad£% as varzii as S€I"iiC}I*"'f;7=~{'1E-Elf'.~ if}Mi§'1{f"{7fii'§H.€g§€:$..

\?Vh{} x.=ve:r£:: e:x,:t,e:_1:1c;ieci UGC pay seam: xvere e:1'1t:it1ec.£ far E'1>:e1f,.i0:1_ Cr?fApay"ea: Rs: f~¥ an<i "

(iathis-:1' b€~:'fi{:"?fi{'.S.1 'E'11<~3,€§'<:»x$&r':i'me:r1i; »';?L" (7ii1'(E'Li££1I' deified 23~ 1. @200 1 <:i.21:*:i..'fiVe:*_a_;i' as.,iiI?;(i€_'i'i' . » "IE: }1er(;~by {ii§1:'ifi'e:§i_ t:i'£a*€::. fizey hexve b€:<:n._ "<3: .= __1<:'§1iy._'«« :j£;.§"1'<: "'VVi"£3\;'isi(>r3 0? %f;?C§C ,7 » f:é'<7ahf '":*éf.'fc)sp€2<:ti:?€:Iy fmm aili ather ber1<2fi£s, on '{'h€VV':*§;fi(fé:}f1"if12§£'1fl&i3f.é.C{E':4 of G{}V(3I'I'i.}".T}.€'Z"1{'. of India ':;':";c§i1.:€§.:3ZIV;:-gi_Vfi:§'21"£;i%i>:: 9&7 pay at Rs.E-£940,/~ an {'c:{}'1<::p*Z€;t;:<2'r1 yeara in the =::adr<;: asf '*_SQ:}f%'§?;§%€1{--i:fi§I',/z5XSSiS'{Eifii I)i:'e{tt:<>r a Umii the «h " Cr'{>"«;u£%*';.<.:'3V.::.":.%§:;";'£, mi? Endia <:E€:a§i"s:s €;*i;7~iE',€":.'i.'7:;'E§i{}§} <31"

<::*;.E*:2§:::*"§3z;>:'1@:f§':::s, i:_h.::*;}.--* WEE} mist: be :-:n':::Z%.iIa='":{i ta} t:h.<::

L %13::%.:¢Ai<;%£'i.i; 0? afi:3't*<:%$a§{§ i§;;x:ai',E<m sf E321}; 33. H E 4?§}4{};' ~ Pr<m1<}%;i:3:':;'I3'Ea.(%<3<zn@;1é. 2.m{i<»'::"
C2'-ES, §.E":€ ;idv2H':{?.:.:?:" §§'1{3:°(=.:3:{tm€. ifiiéii? as Eaiii {i§£f}'~fiJI'§ 1:"; {Edi}. {i;'7:t?'.{?%{§ 'E3~ E E» T§§%§§§}§ {Ta}, :.i;3..::{%{§ A. 15--E1»--i9'39 anti i€3w6--20{)O anci s:.1bss:3q:,1<-3:1i._ }€3ve1*;1:11@:11i, {3z'::i«:%r:--i~3 Wh.i(:I"i do iiloi, }:.21v:2 r'0E3$.._ * far {.119 P11}-""§§i('.21i E-C1'L.i£?€.iiZi(}1'1 Elild Egibrairy ::-:-s.'£:»:1..ff; L- V Umii f'm:thé:r orders; <3fj}E1e3 < <;:x'€:e11ding_§ orszieér bez1e:fii:s :,£;1?:_31:>2i_'1._§Q§3._: rm-*isi<}:1 of UGC pay $<72i1e '.§s.r.1c":1'2 " »i:¥z<:5 :+;1i'0:re.sait:i physicai %;éc§.§gj£{:2;~tiotiV' .__2m<§ persscmxzei dra\m;__:1g; UGVC_VVVp%}§9"'~_§:5C£1.ié ~:'«;?r:1;_1I3 V3101: be granted <}t;hr3.1.f :"*::£:éfi€i"i;iSH L?§§:fii;';1i:1e:i in the Goxrerramrsnt Orcigjaf 85:31.16 2153 "revise-:<<'1fr'-c3'r:":iii~E:--1:99-6A;"7.%"_-.._V ' '
8. ff wh i'}'é"'exter1ding the UGC pay ;ss<:a1<3 are '§:)(>Lm;<i"vf,}:;._fi2s!.ij3'w ..'£'.11<": G<>vem.m<3r:t Qrciizz" dated E5~§.E_;iE39'§ ;§r1<:§'.é:h{::%*.CiI1;§:1,1E21r dated 23--1Q--2®S"i. $11 the gas-€;2i._:":?%_i'L:=.::a;3e, t:hé"":ééC(md ms;p:>11<:§<3':1E', C(liH€:3g€;% farm-*a1*ded 1 V'{.h;€ 2f;e§;%¢:;g}:;.iim:%_3.3{%223i:i(>§1 of '{h.<:% iérsf: :'s::s:;p<m{££%m. for f;':}{'ii?,§";'I"§E§§_§i}'Z';_ ':53? UCECJ pay' Siiéfléff in iihscé pr<}f<>rma §}1'e3:e'«;<:ri':3€d. f_§'ii:£: .§;§:é::§:1{i r@:':»;;3<}2'1<%€:'ai: in a:<;}i§1.:s-;i<3:'f:. :z:'E%;%*2 i',I"2;ar firgi ' ;:='<72_:":£§€~::'?i. x.m"{>:'*:§§E3r ::'1<:'::i1i;:§.:>::c::<§ me': §'€;?i«"'iS€i'?{i Exzzagaiéi: pa}? 21$ .--§}'3:&::* iiifzii §:22':_j; ss::t.2§§2é as TE€%:-;.E4,§é{}f« *;§13t:éa5i (3? A34 R:~3-12Q4-28/--, 'f{'he: C}o2:<:%:':'1:11<;é1"1i: of india wi"1.ik~::. eximgdiizg UGC pay s:~3<:aIe <::I£321z'1y ::1e;'1':'i£.>1'1<:éci that. {1"f?.iI"'§£"..4_ "ii:'{_1€'f €}(}*«';e=:1*:'1.:11<3:*:t. <31" Ezilaiiia r;:ie21rs €Xf;€I"I-S3i{}I"t Sf f"'{I':E1€"I V'~.{}3,M%l.§?'f'*. b<;én{:fii.:;, t.E1ejg are net, <-3.11s';.i'i:I«::~d to any ' afr::res2~x.i::i fixéktiiffill 0f the pay of R$....I44¢94f)}"§'_"'* uf the: sarne. the sseccmd resp<3:1d<§:=;at. E';-:sc_{:7d '§3gis3;i'c:-LL___p=3§_.rA scale sf fimt r<3::~i;p(>11den'i, as:Rss.14é',--94(II/-- 211f;fi'i.£i::a19wa1'i%d"c:~:'I the same to t'.E",:e; second in {.he'sa'§_;d 'p'r{>i'é;)1'm21, {hey haxsss-3 c.1<-sarly :11e:1;:i<3.1';<«3d V1:.1zé}é;v._ii"'th€1'e "is; .;,my'3misf.21ke Q1' {EXCESS ciaém, thsy aifé; _r€;zci3gic§ '=15€:'.v.fiIi1i'1*1f} the S&i.£'17l€. 01'; the bE?§€§iSH€5i(: _i:'V:3§i£€2r€£L?}§ii"ig;§ the second appeilant ac:c:e'pf;éd. the sa1;j};e%j_L'aV1:id.ftsvizsed basic pay of £4,940/~ was 1":LI996. Whiie zmdiiiing the "'v..z1c€;@i::':,£;:a: ">i'2f €,h.e:""§é2{:<3:.1d ms:=;p::}1r1.der2i.~c<:«}E€ge:. it was :*§<';_E.,E<%e=:{ifl'?€§},?"Sis:.33c:{t:<>z;1:miis {}€;%p21§'i',i"E1€'Ifi1 th.21i; £313 ssaflzzrjsg was w'§':::s.:_1gEj§,z~ ~fi}:'<:::i in §"av<?:«m' GE' 'she §'3.:'s;'i. .:"s=:$p<}:':de:.':§: zmd ""{§ire:£:E'.e:5€.§;. "%':he; £::{;Ei:3:;g:3: ta re<:m.=m* t:'}":e sziiéé amaum. {mm {hes ' -.s':':z::';.3:':.{E ;"€;:s.e;p<:>:'1:§e.:.3."i. a.:":r:£ :"<3Em§:>urssu:::2 Elze :,=sam::*«: is "éhsaa S§:.af,<: V. ..._{f§s;}w:%§"':'::m2:2% by $25; c<::m:2'::.::2iz%a§é<m ("Ea-:E:.<-353% :Z5»2«2G85R »-3"./x,/' s' .
Bsssizxg; 2Tig§,§1"§€E':'€'€CI by §'i1{fi S&1.ITI1f:"i, ziirxe pr;%t.if;;i{31"1_::--2r fiirzéci ax.-rm. 'pé:%i:it'.iii>I"; c::ha}.}.€:.1'1gi:'1§; 'éI:"1_e =::i:"C:L.:EzH' da1t.€ci 23~l0~»2€f}Q ardear <:ii:*eCt',i:'1g;g '?th:'-5% S;i{;"':{'.{)I"1d r:°e:~.3p<}:1{.i€rr";t <::::1§ege:_--{§g) ré"%c:'{}'*x:;ér'.__. i;:E'1:~': €X{',(;':E3S p21§;':11€:':i. made TI} thcz p<:é.i'i_t_i«:)mf::{é"trefo1'£§= {his Cr::u'1*"[, A' '".?Z The p<;éi;°1t:i{::n€r in W $116 erder <:i:;1i:ed 26*5~2005 petséegi' by Jami E)ir<-zcrmr, Coiiegiats Ecvit1;c;e}.1i;i'c>'&;<f1_, 22333:} '{,hf;"; Circuiar daiied 23--1_Q»2GQ3*; 21116335353}e;0ugk1:: §:Es:€:e'i:s;i0m af UGC 11133? S<:2?,'i£%VEi£§"R$:;.

3%. 'f§'1.§% "1§éa1:*':é.é( :{""Jiibige afteg" <:<}nsai:i:3ring the :.7a1am:%:' iii _V§ie:v?:z;Vi;§-__ e..§.E"<3x:§%.~&;é<:§ KRz".P'1'§{}. 19930/2005 arid §§«i'3?~»,;A*€-:.:ri*§iie_:'v:1em. €ir<?uEa_:' daziifiéii 23~E.G--2OG1 _:21*;»:'d; ':::é;Se::::_é)V:{éi&{§'$--.{§.2:.é;.e3:£§ 2§~2--2€I}OE§ agéci 2§--5-2{}@5 ;3a§s%:d by f:;Eé£=: $s::§€:'<§:':<§ e§.p;3z;%'§E2:s':':. ?'u.r"{:i.1<:":':* dir§>:cf:t'.<::d '{§.w 5@<:<>m:i V.,;3p;}:t:%1'§z:V;':'£;. €15} 're€L::'1{§ the': :;::12<>m'1i: :°<:<::>v<5::':~:s:§ 5mm. 2'i'.h.«:=:

--v'§,>éT%"%'.i.'iij§§é'i§="i'ECE':':%§ zmd aE.$<'§ §':{%E{§ i3'E'1z::i; i::§1s;t ;'}€§.iE;i<T::':a*::"s; em:-% a:':':t:§€.§{,%{i U73 21.1.': {he be:3m:é§iE;ss; 21$ pert UGCI péljf s5<;:2,aE<=: W.s:"%.t'I 1--'iw19*336, The i_:;%21rm:t{i Sixxgie Juc1§__>;<:~:~ helci '§:'i1at. ever: if fh€.t':I't'3 is Wraixg fiX21"§i(>';'1 91:' peg" Siféiiiig it :3 afmi: at: 3.1:: ir1s;'§,ar:~::é:"*.{3i' the p<':§it,i011t3z'$ or {H} 11r1is};*<:%p1"£:%ss;eni:,213;:.i0:1g~~'i--::9gV._ _t:E§':3 ' pef;ii:.iom:1"s_a§ he~I1C::'x fzhe same-3: CT&1I1.E.'1{}'i'. brsé iTi~';'7~'."§V1Eff%§"T'3Vv'Zfvi"-V.:jEV..{)'_§_5€? 1"€{.'.€)"v"€;"f1'f3'd in \fi€i"W of iihtfi Eaw laid 1:13;: Hv0;1'b71€§ §:'aLi§2i}f{iLf1'3'}.§*§_7 f Cauri. in P.H,REE)f{')Y AM) G"1"i.~1;a£e;S' «;,k's; N :f*e:E3VVA.§:¢-g5a{4:,eé in 2002(6) SL1p1'€'1'1'1€ 3-H8. Jlidgfi 'further heid that the Grade) in five y€:e1r$ :::<-21%-'i<:<~: d1'a.wi.1:1g__.§A"'pa:§E" s5€::3J:r; 2':i:_ 6"? Stage at "i[1§:Lfi.hé Sarah: vs-*'21s {<3 be fixed at. Rs,} ii.,94.0}¥-- ,:evis5s:":<i ;<3Ca1e sf Rs.i2.;'§»28+ }_8,3C*--'"} wit§:i'(>§ii.»§é;:kié';g "i'i1':ei> a':<3r1:=sidera£'.i9n the gtirctxaiar "e:¥_at{'c:--d:' :53.E'Gf2£§G§.""'é3;:*£d {E26 ::(;:1dii;i€;1:1 imgsossesd by 'éihéz A -G2:13:é:i:"::é:«$z.*;i:.V s;_i" E.:;1d%a whim {3::§i.e3:1dmg§ the {EGG §}£:i}" Scaie. Fi:i"§§_}E€Eif»; * €"<3£E<:swiz:g ihéi <':s'2"a:i:;*::* made: in K 2G<§5$ thifi iearneii Singée Qfazége aEii3we{i " }_E;%34«5,!'2G{}E':s éiilii d.i§"<:£:'§:€;ci {he r&=:$§3{fzne:ie:1:1i5 €10 ' " -»v--:_{%§2.:§:{§ '€315 2:m:z3:,1:':%Tsea :*s;%<:{';¥<5:'rs?:i. 'f§<}r:': a§2::'1z.:a§"y 2.{}G§§ {mm ,» z:;§~«'~"
the: $3.131}-' of §';.1'1<:é p&?iii1i0:'1cr.$ Btéizzgg £1§_§F.§'I'i.f;?R'&?C1 by '£,1'1€:__<.>1"cIer passed by ihe 1<:ar:'1<:%e:i Sir1gg.I€: Jzzcige. '£:}":£r"V.. C}<3ve?:"1"1mer"1i. 2.-uizd Elic?ggi<}:1211 Joini; If)§.rc3ci'_{):r _=;': appeai I"3:éi'<:2re: this Cmxrta V °t:'p~ *
9. Si"i,K.K3'iE":'i'}11&L }_ea'1rz1ec:Ii ggrfi/Cijit-\':'\E§éI':§?u€§'4'-,1': ':if}mf<*:r1*,::i€:,;r1::A' AdV€3C£i1'.€*. algbpeszxriragg 11):" {.1185 ;_ip;3eii;1'2a'i'ss c:c.%an'ii<;11:cit3ci ihat {he {)I'd€t3' passeti by the '1:%21rnéE!. is g::o:m.rary {:0 iaw. Ir} the GoV*erfi1,_£_if;A-311$"-'_VA 15«11~i9Q9§ it is <:E<3a.r1y mc:1A£ic>':1€:(iA,...t}Tia;€:. 'i'.-_'.r.1e_ iiii:'c€{'i--=*:::i:;%2*'és {if Physical Ed1:::3't1i{iii '(S¢Ee(:t:E3Q'i1V (3~:fi§i'ci€3} h'é1K2'i:1g :3x:isi;ing..§ pzay s-scale Qf Rs«V3?GO~5?"OU- rev'ise<:i sacaiess of pay Gf Rs'_§_2QOG«%§;2§%}8i%GC2v_ V""{§rii4i1 Ezffect fI"'(}I11 §.1.1996. :;'2*i;E'2e%§:. ihcég: {3;<)m'§:'f*£'i.inE%:";i'. <:3:ariflc:>d in its Circuiar dated ,_2:3;.1Q,;?;'i};GE. V§':1r:.:§:;', ihir: E)1':*€:<*:1;.€>1°:~3 of E3hy'E-3i(?8;i Ed"L?i{Tf£i§',i{)I1 are n«:§'i;,_3232:?-E;~E{:{j..-- €39 any {}'{h«:':r ?{3e:é.:1<;é§E"?i'.:e;. C32?-mass: Qég} cf ::h«:>. "Ct{}'é2"E?§'EiE..{E£€E'1{Z {}i""{ii'i*.§' W{}"LlE{§. 'me appii<::.21bE<;= {')E'}E§?' to {the
7.E.;{:--::=€'_:;i:"€:":&a {;":$¢:§{i?::t'ié(;2':'fz €};"23.::}e§ w§.'t:.%'1 5 3;;-*z:a:.:'s; :35 S€?:""sJ§{Tf€ 4' _,,_éif;§2ar§:'2;g 'i§'}a=: gm}; 23$: é:'E1%:: {$332 a.§':{i §".§i':e ':}¢;%:'2::.~ti'iE' oi 332:2: K i .
.s=;ce1.Ee <31? R$,':~*-1~§94U/ ~ was; z;%~.xt,en:;ié3ci ta them. '.F'3'1€;_ gzaid bezu-3fi't. W21$ msi f;?}<Zi.('3I'"idE'.C§ to fhfi E}i':*::%(:i01'&;,_ .I}e:;;§:,:_ty*
f)§:°:'3:(::i{3:*s::,fAs$i$§:;mt £}i.3:*£;%::zf:.0r:":3 caf Ph3.-*s;ic:aI :}';"?;éiI_1§>;;§.i?L;;ji}w.A On s::1.e11":ifi{:.21i:i0:1 sazgghi; far by the? Ka1r'1'1at.ak:2:.__U:':iK?.é1'SA1E_'yf "

the: St:a,t.e <Z}<}ve1*:1m€1':t by -_:'1c}i;i_i?i(:;§;iTiz;iz: :i'_g;{e:f§V 2;3-10»2.00"l ciarifit-ad that '"t.13'1.fl'i3 f1:;'rt}§iefT.§§zrfi£%r£é"ii§::.v;;& C:0v€:=:r11111<311i'. ezxiending <>t.h_e:r be:1¥:fit.s jip'E:.;x>;5"'1;§>; 'frkfavrrf mv'isi0:1 of IJGC pay sc:211'6,["'~AS1.z<:h 'V":afdi*éS21idV Physical E::1uc:.aiii<:>1"z 21:_1d 1,ib'rV;11'r§%'~P€:is§0111'1£3'i'dfawing UGC pay e34:::211e: 53112111 11¢)? be ;:_{{I;1I1.{1£,';C1*€)fi"2{5'§T 'b€::z1efits: <;tor1t,aine<:i in thc'VVC}7é:é"s:"}1mefgt{'O':'d€%:"s-; eSit','é§:1d£11g UGC pay~s<:a1e as F€§7iS€C%'~.§:%{}fi} -- ,.~'E'he iearned Single Judge wi%.i1mzE; i::i§€:i'f1.g. ,3iI:?:.{} {':'fi31s'id::'raticm the c:<3:':di1:,i.<3n of ex'H2%:d.i':1g"%'.he U(f£C"'pa§;' sgtale £¥..If}.d Gavemrnsznt Circuéair <'"i:¢f::.%1;%:*i E. zmci 211530 An:1<:x::re~HI tie the {§<2r§f§3:'z;3?ga§§_%z€§.i= G:"e:Ee:' {iaissd 5»: "i--199§ §3:;15~;sse:d the <>'r££&':'. E'::riT.E§e3§j«:' tile ja.:dg:§"2€:'1E, z*:3i.Eed. :.1;3<}'3";. by Effie }3é3i§'{.i?{'2E:éE§'

--,,:'faé;3€§::*'{.e::€§ in 2G€}2{8} 8upre:fn<*: 4&8 is 32:32, 2~';pg}§.i~.;"rz:E::i<-3 {<12 V. .%'§*§2=: §'a&.::'£$ =22"? ~:m zraxsés, 'E.'E':::% Ema; §;;z§::i {'£<>m«-":1 E3}; 'igitwé '£<}n*i3Ee %_. -

Suprem.e €30ur't. w3;)<)1~i.e€1 in AER 1991 SC ..27'}'§ {V.C}ANGARA.M V/55 REGEONAL JOINT I}£REC'1'QEx?S{":.4f$I:E}T) OT}-EERS) is 2;1ppEic:*.21':)Ie 11:7; the f}':1{ff.$ {Bf ~

5.-s<3t.1gi"1{, for 3e:t4t.i:1g asicie U16 5-aa;:.11_:: 'mi 2éLiT<>'%g.*irVi,j;;;_'AVf;,i'1:L<-3V V' aappezxis.

10, Sri.Sr_iE«:3.rzt:h, 16:3.rr1e£i9<:¢;)u1::st:1V ei};)pe:11*i§:1;{-.}f__ {big ti*1:;=. "; first resp::>r1de11t argued in szipporfil of tf'h:_: c};'deV;' gmssed by 1:,h€-3 Iearneci Sir1gIe._§M."7'1i1d'ge ;_a11f(i.._'a1é;<#s_ bmught, to the n<;~%::i::e of file C.f.'i11.1't :°§»~:g;::.r{i'i:1'g::VEae§. .i:}:*§1't3I;a-- 'paased by the Unive:'S'i£y"'T. '{3.r§{:3:.tmié;'.é§1:)fi cizlted 1§A1€)~2OO8 whz:31'<3ix:';' f"h€:V in its §€'r'{'.*£i<f'.I" ciated 22""

Sep:ez:1be§ '~w §i:_1:s ""'21pp:f0v€d the. revised Career V' _, Ad:veiné,:€:%n':G§3.§; A V"$'€:h(2me= fczr the Asfistzzni L:_§31?é:?:"§§£§}S»v,'V}'~%i§S§;.&si.a;:"1€; £T)i;"ex:':i:0rs rzzf Physicai Educa"£30'n. F:.:»3fjf§:h£;>I:. ;:tE21¥;1:~:r;«e 2{¥i} sf iihéi sssaid f,}i"{it';',E' §}£:<pu{'.y V §3i:*e£:%i£::_'%; {>5 Pizgssiczai EL:f§u<:ai:£(}.r: {S€:E€r<:%'.i<>:1 " .AA{?z«:f.:z{%'«:>:};"€fia7;EEs;%§§e: §}£§e=:»::§::i>:'s-; 11:'? Ph3rssE<?g'sz.E. §EZ{.'::_::::fs{:.i<m .. __{_S{:"fE§'E{?.'§.§.{T§§'E fire'-sgiss} wi"z':}': 5 5-e:22:.r.s: 23:21; 9:": Zeb 'i§{~}€i :§E':21E§ be eligibie far piaceizaent at the minimum of Rs. };é3¢,9££O _,_/3 as dana in {ha Case Gf Readers and cerztendeed ihat.=.i__5 I10 iiifirmity is": the {}rd€:r passsed by thé 2ea3:"i=aed_T ~ Judge' F'u:*the1*. the USS itself _::1gr€_€d G-f ' the pay scaié Gf Rs.14§94G/M xx,ae;.'.f7, the said Grder passed by ?f§.;f黣:,:1'3:.,;%.:§§';'5'<>r;§eI1t " L' in bath the appeals are er1Vi:i-;f§{§:§i:1--.f€i»1rL'*s1r1e éairi .§:;aw.j,~r scale and writ appeais havek'bt§C'ofr3§3'fii1fiffi§:i::§<j11s. There is :30 infirlfility In th.e'2 ':3rée:;fA §:fis$€d:: Single Judge 3:101 sought?-L 'é%{:*2:_ appeals' E1. = --- {:o1n$ide1'ed the arguments adfires5eé».jb fy_€i;ie i&:>'ai"zr£§d< ceunsei for the partieg and p€ZfL1i$é§{'?If1€ T0tée1f$__««impugned passeé by tha learned 'S§;r;gI;e it: the above Writ appeal E?£-.i:$._ na:if£~..§*§1 difigute 'aha? refigamflfini $30'; in bat}:
ihé"~._wr§_': ';,{I;§'§eaE$ Wfiffi imtiafiy agp0.i:1*¥:,€§ 33 Ph.§;'SiCa§ V "{T:'2s§§:3rsEV--* "E::$3:.:";1€m:"sk As £36? £215: '~:}QV€E'1.'.1E'3€E€EE? Grdar //{W I -i.
1%;
fiaééfzfi ?'=~11~iQ9'? 1;.}::.ey wars {zansigiered :13 washers. They have been exiended EEOC' pa}? Sfitaie. Thfi réigv-ésed USS pay Sfiaie éatsci 1~1~19§6 was accepted':'%:sj§} '~:}*:::-§~ State Geverzzmem and igsueci GG'£?€E'f1f1'1€°£TE 15-1 1~199§k Tbs pay Scaie af PhysicVa}_ '~-E§d*::};:afti0f1* ._ Directors was reviged from Rs.37-{)0-'§;?(}€? tc;Rs;-». 12:{}{1f2} 18390. The said pay SCEEQE xgvazaz ?€Xf,$:'zd€d"

I.»-1~19Q8k Vvhiiéz €x:ter1d:E"ng 'f.}{1e UtZ}Ci"--pay tit 'ya ciearly mentioned that unti1"--vL.;ii":--i3 Gr£.}1'€§f1fI?éflf.'1.{;f Wii1dia Ciears extension Of Otijgei' be};f1ef:{t's., "i:}:1€y 3f€.1fi{}§'§€Dtifl€£?1 far ?1:h§:é" af§=féSa:id fixation of pay at Rs.§4,9x?~'--!~.0',.s'«.-.V -'fF}'%éV_'Gqi%'efr;ment aisa ciarified in fig circuiar d3.7t«?é: ?.3 ~«3C}=:2i3$ 1. on the Clarification sought '-afar £{a.}.'f§3;t'3ka Uriiversifgjg holding that the .§E},}'Si€€:€.T}:'»,E«i1§;i,;£f33§;Ci(1'i{1 Birestars 33% H0': eniiflfid :0 any afi?i»r<»':f:' bsfiééfiis' Ersspiifi 0:" the same, the Secené ~'~._ *:'€$§0;*:a:i§§:1i»C{%§.iaeg<a withgui <:<3:1$ié&r*i:"1g the Cxmrernmemi VA and {E26 Cireufiar, sxifizzégfi {E16 basic pay 6?

_E%T:;;."§»<"E~E%4G/w afifi: f%>:°*~;K;&:'éed the §E"Q§i}{}83§ if; 31% geefififi /' 30 ap}3e-%3_.I21:'1t_ 'flat: sse{:<3:1d ap;::e1'E.2mi: '{;ae,1_i<:vi:ag ighe pmpr;'3sa11 S6111". by the :~:3e%c<3:1::1 I"€Sp(}I"E.d€3I'1i'I as f..rue £1§3pFC)K?'€§ f_f'{.h€ seganle. On iihii E'}£":1Si:'<§ of the ssaid E1pp'I'()V£i.L 1j;I7f::¢'.S3'%;'%L":{;~r1V1c*Ex I'€:$p():3dt:I'3i1 E'.X'i'€"IEd€d £;hz3 Egemsfii, of G"1": V' Rs.I4*940;'-- wm". 1.1.1996. _....mfme1--'":;::<§:'i:;:,::f£g _'_A:h:=:_V aCcou.'r:'t'.s of 8€:e::0nd r&%sp<)r3denE.¥£c)Ifi€g¢:X, iiwafés: :§.:5'£i3.;:€a%.i' by i',h.{:3 Az::c<>ur1tis S€CT,i{}£1 thzii; -jihe E5';-3:;_g?'s<:a1{5:&3::{;€aj.vr<3_j:1gg1y' _ fixed in févgyzzr cf the first". resj3{)f1d{3:1i;. " '.-.?\§;{f€)':E"{iiVi§§§Iy, the Sf3(.'.{}'I"id rigspondezztmcjziiiggcé Wéis L. {.1i:"é-:::ted 't.b7" t'é~f1x the' salary 21;1;1a:i :19 1'<-2(:{:sve:'r ?;f£'i_e' '€;:§é;<§€§i:sjs3 pé'£f;'I¥1t31?ii m21d€ to the first. :*es'§::6'11d;éi:*:t;, «'7E'E1e' s.z;§é::«:):1d 'fféspatadem étcfliege issuefi E1Cif,i£f€ {:41} the' 3?"i.rs,;i« ':*:§S'pQf;ri'e:r::_t. The first resépozadent by his ie_t;_t;e:" {i'&?'e;£§ .2~'é~€i./;';_{){}';'3 _re;3§ie:~<:§ ihat. he is in fi:1a_m:}1aI 'V"«..'{:ris:§;S' £21:-1:}. ES '::'*c£ifi'r1g {>11 4--4~»20€}6 and ithé excess _p:>qgz;§':e:§é.._a£*zzéieiéir; .may bi} :°€:<:<;ve:*:;%(i from $1213 Reé:ir<3:1r:e:--;ti1t E"§a=>:.2.{E§'i'£:sf.. '§"1';3;épii:a*é of fiiha sszima 'Wm: ;3e:E':'é:i€21r1 'izasg %§:5e:é'n WfEE.:::{i s:i:;1§§3§:::'1§§i:1g? éézéé <:i:'<:':.%:E_22r" {'§é':3.E€{§ 23» §.Q~2QC£'§ amé fthzé K A ' c:i2?;£:e-id 2 §'>~ 2~2{}{}5.

>1

13. "I'h.e r<3sp<::r'1c1<;t:'1i.:~3 in 'iihe s@:<:on<:i writ' appeal c.:.he111er:g;t>d tzhe cszrdm' ciamci 26-§«~2€)Q5 isswrci ses€:~<:a::sx'2d appeléemf: direc%i:i:1g the 2% :'e$p€>z'1v.:ie_:1f,"'i,<:§"r%;fiX3 the pay sc:z?:.I£;=. 0%" t.Jr1e firsst. resp<>:1€i<'-mi and f.() ';'iT§:*,(;Z"§'3:i:"'€'.§' i:F1::--« _ ' e:~:<:es3s:s pa}--*ment', fmm the se1E2a=;rj,2' caif i;hé'i':rS'f; rés-p:€}:3d{:fit':f.V: _ 14" The Univ€:rsit.y Gram. {?g:§i11mi$sVi'012""1:? its order dated 19«1C$~2006, or». '<;:~f f1}§.§f..i€i4i.€F"1R;'1'i'if€f£ by the .Mir:_ist.ry of Human REJVSQ:1~§:es:'*~.£)eié@?.1€>pm€nt: dated 22+9-200(:S .a15--g3ré}v'éd .V_'VE:E:1'é95'v--«--vrsxiisézd Career ACfVa§}f§€i"ff'1 €£}fV iiS{7}1E§§rf1c:_ ' the _}§ésSist:21.ni: Libreirians and

i)i3"£3:<:'{0;rV4s 0? --Ph'}?§5i§fé11.__ 'E'.,Ci£iCaf.iO1L subject to the fulfiilmemz iii' r;:£;%:'tgi£:r1 £::oi"iditi<>ns, The Said Qrder detixad "=_'£9-- §§12i,GG6v%« is pi"é:§£§:'i{%{§iiE'€ in :z'1eH".'ur{-3:. In ztizmge 2{vi} G? §_;_h'€a T;:s5'2i2ri§:"x::::*ci%f%:*T._ ".E}€'.'§3'1H",:«,-7 I}ire3ct<3:'ss 0%' Pfzjgssiqtai Educ21t.1?_o:3 {S€?i€:§:t:.i<}1i1 ~{"_':-%:f':/,.2.£:§&,>.§ with 5 j;;€:ar53 <::2E' S€§"Vi{:i': as an 3;» E AE.E~3*§6 " ':-:.%2a£E §3;E%v.§j'%§§§§§bEff féir p.Ea<:<:m€n'é: at mi::i.mu:3.'1 §{i8.}€f :3? pay T iii" 'Eg..éa._E4/.§§4{}/-- {ii'§=§1€;? in the: <:2':sa€: 03" gm: ??L€fZ:id€'3§"5:%P It :15 V. ?r;1aE;S£<i: ;3r:}$pa%::iEs;€ 21:"; {§§}{'fE"€§§.§€I}E.'E.. 'E_'hs:3s;c wiizz} éifé': ii': ssésrwxictaé 21$ {:11 19~1.0--2G{)6 E1E°€'. a1»:3:r'1e e11fii:1e{i f*<.:'::' f§"1€7 s§2;»1i?<i beraeffi. E<':.1rt'h<:%r, in <tE2m::s<-3 3 :31?' '£316 s_'s3.i«:1 Uifiii Orvziex". me {EGG §"1é?Lé%=3 <:'te3a1"1}; Z"£1f;%I":'[i€j}I"}€{1 that ifiareexr EXER723...I1iL7€:§'?}€?fE'}i' ScE1e3'me wili be efik-3r::.ti'.ive 5:31" ihiit pz'e:'+3<3.:11:. frcarzi :':_'*.;?"'='7/7'.%'_'1 Let. t.'m% c§at:<3: f:'c::m 'whir:'I:": ihc:-1 Ciemzer :":',-€§fié'i;1ff:V(?i6_'.Vi:"§"1£;=:I';fii'"

Sitheme for T'r3a£:h€:<5s ifs appEi<?afl'j._E_:=: u:1c;13é3.:f--.i:1'1.¢"----e:%<;ié5*:§r1;;g_Tf grdezr vidfiz i\fIi11ist:ry iefiiftér <ie'«'i,<-3:1. ;'Z"?-- '**;'{*39E§.:'"Ef';;2,:fii1€§§" if vs,-*a$ made: Ckrar théif. the aboVL%___é§'u:Ef1<:,--I1_1e v.-*'(;u.1_t£ (7€}§'I1€' into f:}E'{Ef3 with im1'ne<:1iaT;e é:"ff"%:§-.<:f;..7 'E.ji»I":r:-s§€. wfiii be mmified ass :":3g;u121%.i{}:'1:a $}1<:11f{'.}.y. 'E7.7fi€%" i..,'§§"zi*¢':3'r':*::_ii.ir;é:§; a2é;":7Aé¥:? req'ues:st.€c§ is bring *a}':is?§ t:::» fl:-;i1€ :i}:'2i::i<:7<:~.g:'f 2.131 'ii};':s'"<:o11e;:,§€rs affifiaied to it {hr m§3::{;%:::;ssa1j; a1c:ti:>fz:. ~«_He.:r:g:.e:, it is C:i€ar that ail other beixssfifgge fK>iia'i:::_{g fz'i":§;;'--./t:_E5::;€' UGC 3,321}; sétafie {tam be drawn "-§zf<::":} 23f"~T'7~"'£;E3QE:~f~ {:fi;i;;"b}; §}€'1j'5?,«{}}'1S wirio are in s3:::rvi::<& as; "{}V§g:1.'_'}uEV}'; UGC in its E<3€:{.<::** Ciéclfjfifd 1§--1.i}~2QQ£5 atéaézgrigg :::e:7:i.~ié.n'1é:{i °é',1:1a%: ":.h§: :r1e;°:{:<3:$;<ssa2.1"§,r m;;§:.:§21ii<}nes wifi E36 "§'21f2::z:§zci _i%1 fE,E§ZiI:iiT{;?. ¥'u':"{.E1&::; an ihe i321-3&5; aé' ihff: <.m:ie:>:.:* " ':§:?:'1?:.--:*.§}é« §._iE§--E{}--2{}{"§€:§ :§::as;s3€:<% 33:; {he €}€':._ 'aha: (j}<>:r@r:1.:"::_:=:m. ' 'V is:-a:;.':_z::<E za €T:w:':=a-*'«:?:mmezgzé: £}:*::.iez* aw; é§w?--2{1%€}§,i-% Ebi' 5:/-:#§"'""& <-3:>:'t:e1_1ssi<;}:<'1 of C-&11"E;'.€1" AdVa11e::eme:'1i. S£)h€3II}¢i'3 to ._ ihff Phjg;:'~3icta.E E:Cii1£32",i'i',iO'I': Di§'€f(.',f()I"f5 and LiE3ra:'i2ms3 S1,: j:;*§:'i.t.<§ iuhe c:m::1ii;i<::'1:~; me:1't.i<):'1<-3:1 i',ht','I'E?iIi'1. Re21€i§.:'1§§_€_;£" fl4<Z?§C~V c::"<:i<-Er Ciélfffid 19~E_O~2C)O6 r11a1~:es;< it V€;'.I'}' £11851? V' firsi: respon<:i<3r2t, in bath the 21ppc%;1»lA:s»:¢uf<;% ',*-,";.'r':3'I;i"e.'i1'{',ii.'§'e:d'ibzti c:>t;he::r b(:11€fii:~; except UGC pe1y}§s£:2;..3.§.:: fvé;--£:.ff;_ H€:3.I1f3€f, the: ()'Fd€:'I1' passsed by the learnésd Si:1'g§;{JL:dg€'is V c::<)r1t.3:a1*y to Eaw. Furt.h<-31" thi:%~~._Vpet.:ii.i<1_1'1£:::§5 have L1nd€rta1«;en to r£:_fLu:1d U'}_v_E:u'é1I1':f)_1£E1'£ if £3 any excessa paymez1*E:. §~1::*r15.»;:e"§t, r1e;:»f', '1c;s«;.":;::*.zj;'"to t,}:1<;% _pet,ii;i0ne'r$ ta <:():1§;V«::9':i€i"§;%1};1f. re'v:f}§ed p'é:y"s<:a:e was €Xi'€3i'id€'d to {hem nést, mi: t:h::i:"v':_En§;f,a1i*1.::§:.::s or on misreprese::3t,e1ti.0:1s. §':1ri.1f;e_r, §ri *t§f:I<:V.Q.o\§'E:rffiii€I1t. Ckder ciargcd 2,3-'10_2OQ} "-'£'h<§'- .L._G::>'2f'<'3;"1'1:i§1e::';t: §*i":éid made it ct-iiiar thai: u:r1t:fi flifiihéf .¢;)i*£,';€;%'i'é;~s $f}(}ve:':3r§3€::1i., €x'{,e:'1{i§:1;g Othééi' hem-ifiiis E1<m:%;_nggj .i'r<:§%j§:.-Q USS pa}; saf£;:1e%. ;<a:.::th sf §h€;": a.i'<:z:"<:es;ai::E 'A "'i?E":j;s;§{:.2':5i.Elsiuétéiziizign and 'Liiyyary §--'*e:;%:"s:;:§:::'1<:%i draw.ri:';g UQC 9:13'. xésreéziaé $%:.a.E§ rzaét: he ;;;:°2:.m:cé:¥; <:}':§'":s;2' §i;e~z1efi't,é=; 31% Cam:ai1.1<-3d in 11110 C}<)v€:r':1n1:3;T1.t, C¥3'<ie1" Le. «:*:x:tm1ci:i,r1.§,§ __U{,}C pay scale: as; rm->*isse.ci f:"<::n'1 1«l«199E3'
15. in vierw sf the gubsequerzi, order pzass;§§Ei'4-i3:;._l:1::h_€:
UGC dated 39-} ($2006, the 1'£:&:xar11i:1e ELM: matitel" for (,'X'{.{:7f15§Ii'Of'1--, "E',';a":._1fe3'e--;? Adv21:1<:e1'r1em. Sctkzenle a};":1:iv.__ £)i:}1é:j 2 be'11Te:2Vi'i'if:§;___ Théz exf,e:t1s.i():{1 of pay males of Ra A &&?;t;f :i~1§i996 ES cc':'m.ra:'y ta {;he:*. G0w?é:=:rzfi:1<:r'Aa_t. {::i':«;1f:_.€d 1.5~1. @1999 and 23,1U,201i..< Fz,2ri:2':ve'1f;V £311:'=§}€§€}*§33fifi,%I:é§nt has pcswfsr' £20 QLi'éié;hi:1g the Government Nc)i:if1<:.2£1;.i§§i§. is Comirary is Eaw.

A(:(:<};aii1'3gi§};" iiftz V;::Vzé'--s3s.A§ '.nf{)1E<)wi11;§:

. . . . . . .
3 are aH<m,re:::'£. Théss Qriier éiated E L' H'§21{3ié% in 3??' , Ri"«;?m5 E Q93% /' 2865 zm;<:i "' § §' '«.__VV"»%'§.P..N.t;,_fé%348f2835 is i".§%3§.'i 3:3;-Siififf and the :":12:IE.é:<3§° £3 T " §'{::7rz;a.:'2{iaés,i iii} ihz? sas3::<>r1{i ap;3s3£§.21..z1§: iii} 'z'z3<:(}z3$i<§:;%r Eihfi u_,$.:§s:":1§;% Eb? §"i;x:;»:=E,§<:3:':: aéf E3233; fig': ihe Eigiaé; :3? €.h{=;= s2;.:'{3:se{;;:.:€:%:2i:
éw 2:3 UGC t:)I'€,if31" dated 19~?.G--2£}06 aneti 21.15%: Gc>ve'r':1:71e1"1f'. O1'(.'1€i' CiE£i'»'£,'£'1 4§«'£"--2GOE§ in ac«::0rdan<:€: with 12m?, wjiVt,Ii1;.£:f1_Va perieti oi' tixzm mcmtlzss :i_":*<:>m ¥:,h<~3: (13113 of retteipzfwtjfj::{§";::}{_ _ of {.1113 étrrcirzi'.