State Of Karnataka By Pa Hapalya Police vs Chikkavenkatarayappa on 17 February, 2009

[Cites 1, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

State Of Karnataka By Pa Hapalya Police vs Chikkavenkatarayappa on 17 February, 2009

Bench: Manjula Chellur, B.Sreenivase Gowda

 

IN TI----H-i I»--Iaml C.'()1ER'I" (>19 1w'«:N.»\'1u-\rm M 1a..w<_ ;,x\;.,<..>121~:
I)/\"I'E+1I"') "]"I-----HS '1'1---11+: 171%] 1%');-xv oar 1«'1_a:.1a3R_L w-~:Y. SEi:{"){').<1'}
PRESENT "*°'

1WﬁEPH3NTMJEA4RS.J1N¥HCHC mLANJ1nJ\nﬁiE£;Lﬁ4jt

AND

THEHONBLEMRdR$ﬂCEByQ@£Nﬂ%§ﬁ@QWDK

(.1:'§n'1_i1_'T2aI Appml 1\'2(>."*l7'é§. t3'ii2(}'{}f2:" _ A ~ 
Between:     VV '
Sim £1' of K2.11"1'1.2'1.te11<21
By Pe.1iI'12:1p.2.1.lyz:1 P()1i(2L'.  

   "    "}\1)1.3c-.lla;'11'1t:
['I*3y Sri. G. I'%I':a\='zi:111i S§.'ir};§gE 7.E3f7'{_i"}  

An d: "" .  ' '

1 . (72 1'1 i'I<._.1<z'1'.r.CV: 1A1.'{':~:.! 211 ;-:-,1'y.e=; pp 2'51 .
S / '(.9 \="~r.'1'1l'\"2-3 I z-5'1':fz:'1;:fe'1"1':3pm . 4 () },-'<%z11's.

2. V. ._i T211211': I"{z-.1._1_V1é z::1p1.3e1..
"  ()».'\f'e:;'1'1.}<;21t":j1'myappz;1, -<1.'3 '\-'C.'E1I'H.

   '  -- _e.1"1'j.21:11;11)}.>z=1.

   

' /f5'_~¥{éxm2:1.1Jp;1. 2"?» yo;-;11's_

4. " . 'i';}.1é1i'i \7er}1<2:1t'z1;:31:):'1.
/0 Ve1""akaLa1'3.m2;1.p1:)21.. »-iE{) }.»'c;.111s.

   ..I:1.1Ei I"ap211'm;'1.

S/0 (}£'L1'1;1jz.'1}:)pz1, 138 _\_='(?;-11'."~'s



{:5 .

10.

I1.

12.

 my

Ski" 'A_"f»»:.]. =$'1*Vi1'1i\-'e1sa11'1. Adv. §"(")1* R I.

E'J

R21 1?} mdi C 1 1 in 11 :1 ma ra  :11 1'1 :1 1') 3 )2}
(z'1E::>2'-1i.L"('1 ~ .'-}i1'1(T(".' c1e;?z;u:i)

KL11'1.lIEl}.')E1I31] (f'r211'1;.§t11a1..>;..)21.
S/ (:1) a1'2:>..saa}.>}.)21.
32 y(:a11s.

Na1'z1si1nk121[)}_:)a.

S/ 0 Jalii Iimppzr.

M21121 1.) 1 1 1' L}. '\:'o 1 1 km 1 22: 1''2=1_ve.1 ; )pe'¥
S/0 Nz1rz1:.sa}T)})2.'1. £30 ycm'.~__s_ '

Nzxgzlppza Cr}? Naggz-Haj. _v _
S/0 R2m1app2=1.. 22 yez11's_'~.._ '

C}a11'1gj1T:1z1})])z1. _ M _ 3. .V   M
8/0 CI'1i11nz1\-'c111<a13,_i"2":y;:1,p'13~11. _  
20 yeews.   _  ' ' "

;'111:£j:;}3};)é31§fi.;  »
ZS / 0 Chm:;'12'1V<:ﬁ111<.g;:t}u';1y;j1}.);)2;1 .
20 yt;%a1':;_. 2    '

_ All z'1i';.r r£"+si:c:ig'I'1An.--.._s 0:"
' gj fxei i 1:} 21 1';-51'5a2';_11-1e"1 33 U m.

.:}--;-1go%.';A);-111:; '1':-'a:i'1*1'i'<§._ K(.)}2_1r Edi.

1'{c.::.s;.:)<'') : 1 (:'1<*.1'1 1. rs .

 R 9, .R 1. 1T 2.1IT1c;E R 12.

 S'.'ShemI<a1'2:>:.1313221. As.s<)<.'iz.1I0s. Ac.i\rs. Em' R 2

 'ro"5,_ 'R 7. R 8 zmti R 10.
 AA ' Ap})ea1 21gz1i1T:.st' R 6 a'b21'i:c.c}.)

' "I"1'1is (3r%mi1'1z'1i .A§3}')t*211 fiicxi 1.1I"1dt.'.l' E'.3(T('.'{i()I'] 378(1) 

 a .._.{5'3) C',1".P.(I by tzm.' State pr'21_x_»-*i11f.'{ in ;;"1'211'11 f("E£1\='(' to £110 em

5

sf'



\\.-'1't§"1 P.W'.2 \=~'<'nI<z1Izlppu wI"1<-?11 hp \\-'ass }')11:.sy in ;)Ic')1.1§_;_'}'1iz'1;_g
fhv Ie.111c:'is. A1. tlmt. point 01° tzinlth /\---E 2--and mhc1' é1.(.'.(..'!.l.'I~.3("(.]

322111;} 1.0 h21.\I<_é e1s5sa-11.1l'te(T.1 not <_mIa\,--' I'.W.2 but alsn §"1i>; xvii?

P.'\-V4" with (_'I1.1':')S._ 'SI.()I'1('..s zmd hz11'1(.'Is 1't?\.s:1.1I'éi j1' Ij.:'__f in

_gg1*ie\s'c.)11s inj111'ics i.L.'... fr221.c':1.1_.11"<* of 1013 112.11%] ig.».__11(_3

Smlplc i2'1_j1_1}'iC'?S In P.W.é} 2:u.1c.I P.W.5. (T)aT1_.1~h»::_:{'::)11'3'~}'§ia«1iz2! hi7.b 'V

P.W.2 as })(':.1* Ex.I~"'~2 21 (.'2T1sc;' (':2-11110 t.o.A1)A.(§ l"C{Lf,i\'¢5.1.V('.'-}'L_"('.'I.V f<.1_:_1*:--'{;Tj'2;c=;~.

file of PatI"1z1p21I::_1.ya pc')Ii.;?V<-r-..__ s1z1t"i';.}_11' {ma t'I..13:.__(>1"I:}L-'11(9c=sV ~

p1m';shz-eble tmcicrl' Secs.  (32.4 £1I"Id

326 1'/W E49 IPC.

  I.V_)V1"VI.iV'§'~1__1"§",A" é'}~1_{i'-...."(_m--_)1irsc oi" iz1\»*<'sii;__;':11,i<..m11 z-1I't":c;?z*
:'(.*g;'i:tsI"z*21f'i<)1'1~ of V(V".2---1.':;V(A' E..':;'}16%»-.S('*I"1('I§lIQ F.I.R. in the (mmL'.':-=*1'11<-r('i
.7\/f§"'.'_z§.§J'.."i31'I'~I«'31.f"'(i'. ii1_'j111'n.%<'.1 \f.rz_'1s s'a(>1'1t for 1l"('&11_l'1'E('.IIf ¥)(*i'<n*(;" P.V\-'.3

»  M.St(';1.I'}éu'1_(:11"z1m0i"1.z.i1121. \.vI"1<"> E12-1d c><an'1i1'1c(..1 E'.\.-V5.2. <11

}E1'1.1'('I75VE:1}--'§'EI3. i's::sV.<.%11cc1 w(.)1.n'1c:1 c'*(':1"t':if'i<"'z:11c' at I?lx.I"A3. -41: sand 33

1'L*s1)£§(€':'.iyéIy. Thc spot m2..1I'1.;'-1.;r..:':11" \-ms (I':'a\=\-'11 and

 $iT:u.'e-r1I'1<:1'T1t of f:3('\7('i'E1] wit.1'1c-asses imfI:a<Iz'1"1;§ 1.I'1c;r 1<;H.1'1 2-¥l'I(1

 1;~;in ofi11_j111*<*L':i (331110. 10 !._)<.% 1'occ.)1'(.ic:r(1. ;'\ﬁ.e~%.1' ('*<'nz'm.)§vté<_m of



£"i.(".('L1E~,'.('¥(.i in rcs1)C('1 01" all i'§1c.* ('.'1'11:IE1'f_{(:'S. A;.1j;j1"ic~\*('¢1 by 1.11::

5%:-11110 the p1'es?enI appeal is I'iEc<"i by t.}'1c Smtc--'.  V.

6. A<"(t()1'di11g to H10 }<:zs'11"11(*_cE~----.,A'(.i(.iE--;.: ..S:21 1°u..

P1"().*5e(':1.H'c)1'. the-' cvidmlce of IT'.\?\/'és_.2.;<1».T21iv1(.i:;"3 c:i'5'1-1f.'j}f'*61__ \'s:t'}I§'t

11'1(i' ev1'c,i_emre of P.W.6 ("yer-:.wi11T1(}:as(?:'4 t.<;.~3 tzf-ﬁnk.__j1'1(:§idc=91'1t'_ »

would (?S1a}')1is1'1. 1.119 n10fiv('~ I"()V'I"-.1.}1--'V.?_ éT1}1<T'}'_,_",%'.(['_1 im.'i%(.1(%1"11. e;1::'1d

evici(:11ce of Dr.MS.C31131'1c'}_re1:j10}:11'aj-lg;4'RVV.3 p1'<>\-'05 1.11:?

1'12-11u1'(: of i1'1_§1[11*ii;%s s;1..1.$:1j.'a-1i'i':<E}fz:.i. 1:33;' "~i,.]"1c V1'_11;j.1V'1"x9'c(i, tI'1c1'CE.'<.)t'<_~ the

cvi<:1cn(.:e of i-:1'}'1.::_rf¢_:;f v.{i*a_1T1c:sse.s <[:'(..)11p1c'('1 w.it"}"1 the-' <*vi(.k71"1('é(=-'
<31" dc'>c'11{"n'-._V\r?(T)11}'KiiA: '*c'.S§i.;1'E:~1i55}'i"""'Eh? ('t1'1e11";g;ctS agairlsst t..hC

ac'('.usé:_(«i ';;)cr:5()i1éi"~.;1'1"1(;:1 '*-.1:1:1}: fi1:'1('ii11__g of the t.:'E;.1l CIom'1

cic-.*sc:_1'\rc=~s {.0 E30.Vs§ét_A*--:;1si~clc?, 1'11 'x.-%'1'c=r\=x-' of the-* I";-am E12211 {ho

 ex?-i(1'(:1'1,._t-é.g: of i11_}u'1*'('c'i"wi.1:.m?ss%c:>s w(')1.1l(.E poim 01.1: gguilt of

  é1_1i(i1 A~1. 1. 80 £112' as l}'1c==;t i1"1j1.11'ic'S; oi' P.W.2. 4

e'm_.§I 5 are L'(j:,u'1[1(.>(}:'r11e(1.

»--.«

 As e1gai1"1s5t'_ this }("%e=511'1:t-'(.1 <'m11:sev1 for flu-.

'2vi_'c:rs'ag3'c)1'1cie?11tea e-1<:c1..:sc>.(1 s1.zbrnE1 {hat in t'}"1(_.' aE')s5c='11('rc:r of



'c"1(.'Cl.1SCC1 1:)c1'$<.01'1Ss or the 1*C2'1.1 21532.-1.§.1;-1:'1:.s 211.5 they 2-1.11% well

e1(tq1.:a.i1'1'1..c(1 with A--1 zlnczi <)Ihc.=1's. '}'h('_~ i11c%i(1_rs~1:1_:t'-.._'t[n_<")1<

plelm in day1ig1'1t:.. It is not v\.='(':1": 111:' <"a.1s<:' ()_1"'iii1Hf"(}§.f'i'Cli'}1?--&:"*-

film injzlrcd had sc1'.\rc1'211 0I'}'1(.'1' (21.1e1_=n.i._(j.s in {.1'i"c'=x}fi11é1'g1(:r;11'1g'1 VV

cspC(:i2.111y ()\VI"1L.'1'S of 11eig1113(_)1:1'"i1ig2; 1}::1j:'(:is x\?E'1_( > 301,11.c'1_"h;i'VEj

found f211.1}t' wi.i:}'1 the P101}g1Tiv1f'i'§._()i' I1.'ic.__1ziI11§i "E;)}3"~.;1:.1"1jL:*' ;~§jo1"1 M" V

the (:(_)1I1p1z1i1'1a1'1t. O13.' t.11Lj.<tj'I_'m:j1' 1"':-»:I:1.1'1c§. i"i'1'L*»pms5ec1.11i(')1'1

11215.5 p1'm-'ec.i that t§'1e1*@ \.-aiféis't':0i"23<,i31.6:-11$....:i'ig1'12. E')ct:\=v<ée11 tihe

two g_;1'o1.1p$ §)V€«]_f "Ihe %:ii\rissiﬁ'31'1=(J«f*§jrq)},5(':aj'i',y and A--1 1'i1":di1'3g

fa1.11't wilﬁ. .%1,i"1'z2:.1 :1.V(*1;*,Qf= iE.1<*.t. the very 1€T1"1()!' of

Crosa}c><21§'i'1A§ii:;v1iicjh' w'(:s_¢i'ici §I.1di("'..'('I1.f'(.' <i11:'*§1'1;,§ ;)211'1(":1'121ya1§'1

t'11c*1*e\-*v:;1s'*:.'z 11'x.)_t@}' i.*;(?§_;{E}1;I'§i .i'I31f*._;" tlic pmp(-1-K y (tie.-spL12'.e l:)('1\--vc,e?1T1

E11161'1Lb211'1.i<'2§.._ "I'v}1"c:"c*"t'(>1*'L-' s:.1.:<%1'1 <"'1f(.)ss~cxz_.11ninatit");1 \v011}d

V' .1f2ii',E'1Ci'* ST'i*eng{}1cr1 t'_hc' (I.'.&I1SC of %2'.11(: p1'c)[email protected]_io11 §'€"§§z*.t1'(iiI"1}J;

"' . t:h._-3 &i1V1-c)f':"iTy'Ve;*.  - . . 

  So far' as 11'1c)ti\=-*c-2 for t.i'1c=. E:l.('.(..'.L1S€"(I.1 to ;1Ssa.u11'

"t'::'m~ i1 ij1..:1'ec:§. we are (.3? [.1'l{"' 0p1'1'1i011 t11c')1.1g;{}'3 i1'1j1.11'<=i*{1

"--V\\.?it'A1'1esssess Me? inlc-=1*<':sE"c?c1 \xrit.1"1L*ss.aL*s 2==:m"i re1211i\4'c->5; \'\='("



113. Ac(":<'>1'(1E11;2; 10 E'.\'\:'.2--(to11'1pi;-1111;-1111. AA-1
E§F3SE1i1HL.'d him with (:l1.1I::1 1.111 1.111": loft. 1'1z.111d: }11'.=~1 w1'i"¢'=

P.W.4-P;:::.;.).221'1'111'1:-2 st.2':11'.cs 1.11.211" /\--§ ;:ss;111}I.('('§ 11.01' 1'111s5E:);-111d

wiih 21 (*.11...1b on 1119 k'E"1. 1'1e11'1('1 2=-1g.1;==1i11 ss111)1)('>1'Ies 

also P.\?V.E3 s11pp<')1"1"S t'1'1(> cvi(§(:%r1("e oi' P.W.2 21-1'1'1--{'% IA5?«.'W';»'--5.-T  *

.s2?1\.='iI'1<f 'i.1'1;11. A-1 2-1s.=:.;;11111..c(11 his 1'e.1<'£"m>.2iwit.1'1 21"(H111}')"1">1'1*.1.}"1.é'

( F'

loft' l'1a.11d. The-r cvic:1(:1"1ce of ¥':'\3\' 51.2". 4 ";1_1A'11--i_;') "'.i§*'::11..1"i?(.1.

1'1'1cii<:211'e A/1.0.} is 1101: me <*.--1..j;1'r;>._w1i.iV31 'W11-i..(_'1'"1:  was"

z:1.$:.~:3a1,11t.ed. In 1'.1'1cV=:11)s(r111:'t§' =<.1_f' (*?;<;.t.£1b1is1'1'i1'1g.{A"V1.1121} 1111-~

we2.1.p01'1 tlsed by A4 to 2.1Ss;'1i:.1i:1':'}f'.W".'Qf_' V1V1':r1.1i('1 <ro1111c* 1.11"'1(ie1'

the (T§E'i.fI'ﬁiJf(.3f7}f;T(')1" c'I'i--iiré}1<11'y~.§%g::;r21pf31'1'sVV1.0 21111'£1<.*1. {.110 pmvisi(>1'1s

of S(.*('i..32«b'. ('1-1.3;'<t"}'1i£§~..C'c'>.1.11?I" lms E0 ("(j11'1('.l1.:(.Eo {$1221 1.h(-'

1.

)1"<)s£?_C,111.1011 _tV':"t'1:1.11'g11'*.\vé'5ié s11<'(..'cssf11'§ 1'11 C51;-.1I)1is111'1'1;g, 11119511 'F-'."W.2?--.";=211S1:;;':1i1'1t?<'iV"§1'i'c\r(>11s i1.1_§121"1'(-H. 11"1.o_\.»' \vcr1"c=== 1.:1'1a%1)1(' 1'0 V:-:.;$-t'e1'£';1i};1j11 "1Vh=;»'31.t':_}~ s.~:'.11c1"1 gzric-.~v<'>11s i11~§111"_\;' xx.-'<.>11i(1 2..11.i'.I'21(.'1 the p1*'0__v1sv_i;0;'1_s.¥()1' Sec..? 26. "'i"111e1"<>i'(">1'c~* thc (">§'fc1'1<.f.c 2-1g1'£2i1"1s'i A~I ° .13 (rs1..2'{b}is1'1cLi 0111}! 121'1dc?1' E5c?1.i.I.325 e':.111d 1101 1..111dv1' '3_St:<--?i32{3. ¥{cfe1"c->1:1(':e is 1'11adt-1 1'1') 21 1*e11(>1"t'.ed ("<.iS(.' i11 2{.'}{'}5 SC'.C pz:1f_'r;c-* E395. pz.11'21;___§1'z11')1'1ss M. '15 2;_mr_'1 16 w};i<"h :'0z"1.(..i 2.1.&s 11n(i(tr:

14. "'}1'ic\»-'()1..1s llnrt" i'm.=.s 1:)c%c=m c.§(*E'ine(1 in SCCUO11 I320 IPC. whi(*}"1 rezxds fc":I§m.vs:

"32O C}1'i€'\-'()t.1S 111.11'? ~ T110 fc)ii<:)\vi11g;' 1<.i1"1c1ssj"nt.' '-- h1_.1r1T only 2111? (.1€?sign21t(==*(:i as "g:'ic->v(")1_.1%"_:.--1 Fi1:<st.-- I':31'nasc?:,1l21t ion Secrm (Hy. -- Pcrm 211118111, :p1"i\.'e1t':io11' '<">t' 1 lm . i.g1'"1 i' ' (3? . cith&*1' eye.

{Th}rcIIy}_:Pg"1";?211a.t1E_:«;.1t pr.ivat'i01'1 <>t.'1'2c='r }'1(rz'11*i1:g_§' cfaf (."i{§1t'.I'- c-'.'2'.V1':, ' " I? <.n.1r111=1y'.?'¥3i'iv£=i1_i01'] 01' 2=11"1}»* 1m'.n1l..>(-'I' m"j<'>i1"11".

'if?i1,1§"..~_I')<:ssE.1'11(:E"ion 01' 1.)c:'1'm21;"1c?1'11 i11';;')z:1i1'i;'1g "'<",f '{¢.1'.1(Aiv.i)f'}V\?CI'E5 of 2111_v 1'11<'1nb<*1' nrj("n'11i.. . Sixtjlﬂy.--Per1Tne--11'1(:nt €Iis"af'i§_§;1.1ra1.i<")1"1 of the §'1<.>ad or 'fate.

SW<:11t.111y.--¥'1'a('i.11_1*n:: or ci1'.<e:1o<-,ati<')11 oi" ex §'mn:;_*. or 1"()0t1'1.

I6 I%Zig1[11111_\.=.~;.'\.1'1_\;' 1'1u1'E' w1"1.i('l1 011d:-.11'1§__§(=-1*s life «:)1i__ whirl') ('E'1l1S("£"w' tho Sl.1fT(?l'(':'l' to he (.i1.11"i1"1§',__{ 41.1.14'-.a_

51.);-1n':e: <31" t:wo11€.y days in sc~\-'(:1'c:_~ 1'f>0c'Ei1y 1')2'2=1;i"1*r._« .f(._n: . A' t1:'1.2.a.1t)1e 10 fc')11ow his (>1"c1ir1211'y }?>1,1:'s1.1i1.s;"'-

15. Some 1'mr1s \V1'1i('h zi_1_'(> :1'.1r,)A1} }'U>{(':'.._ ﬁ.1£.!)':£('~.._ 1'11.ufts w11ic1T1 e-z1"c_: 1nc11*,;i('_)1'10<"1. 'i-1:1 "1*hc=*. i"i1's51j.AA s:C'\-'t~11 ' 0321113633. arc obvi<:>L_1s.1y--._wdiss,1ing1.1i--s1"i::(} _l"1'(3n1'" £1. s1ighi huri. Inezty 1':1Vr;>--'.«-'¢V:1.1"v'.«}'1'(:»1.§=rss "E";--c._ 1'13§(:)1'('- SC:'1'(')1;1S. 'I'1'ms.sV ":--=-1 Ta.-fg.)t.:::'1(21p' : 1'1'£i-: (fT'E:.'t.1.b.bl.'.v"{' i1:tcr11.~_sc pe:1i1'1.. prqionged'_.£1i:Se;1$t§ ry To The vie':i'1'i1:.. f51.1!1'::_g:}L.1;;§1--;i;~': V fail within any £51"

_"§.}'fC:""31}1'S1. --..s('*J("ﬁ_ '('.1£111:;~3(%s. Bcl"cm~ 21 VCbﬁv"i<':f.ii,<')1'1 f3:.i:' 17I'1§*"-sca1{£é'1':'({t) 01 g1'ic>\-'o1.1s 111.111' :c=:2.:n be ;jé1E.§}~:.g:Vci=.. E'3--1:1_C?"-r')'1" ihc iI]_§1.l}'§L'.'.-Li d<:rfincd 1' r1 SC€_i=§i()a'1 i3V2O."i'1 111shf'*bb st1'i(*'i1y p1"(>\s'c(1. and E"1](':' "ve1:g;11E1:1 V-:T'*}ai.1:1'S(: is 1'10 cx(':CpEio11 to the g.__{v1'1(*1"z='11 m1c* ()l" 12-1\«V""£.'}5i211 2-1 }.:)on211 s1.2.1t"t1't'c' 111113: be 3 _ "<;:g)i'1§i;.ajV{.1e.(i 1*ic1:}y.

'I. _T':1*1<=:*. €Xp1'(i'SSi(')1'1. "any ins'é.r1.1111<>'111 w1'1i.<:1'1. x {jL3€r(i as 211 wee:-tpcm of r)fi'e1"1oL\ is Iilmly 10 b."é11.:s:.;<.' ('}cat1":" has to 'on'-T g.;_':'1.1.1gc(i 1.2iz§<ir1g n0M-- of 1'h<: 11Cz1c.1i1'1g{ o{ the S('("'.U(.)1'1. \»%'\.«-'E:'1z1i" vm1.1i<'1 <_:(:)1'1st:imte 2:1 '"<:ie11'1g"c.1'L>11s wcap011" would Z (E('})C1'1(E zlpon the fe1.('1.<'. <)i"('t2'1.<"'1'1 ('zisv 2-:u1(1 11:) f_{&'I."1(.'1'21}iS£E1'§.i(I)I"I mm be-* n.12'1<1v."

14. "I"hc11 c"'()111i1Ta;_;' to 1.1"1_(: iHj1}1'i("S s,1.1s$.;;1i1"i._v"(»1. by P.\F\/.4 F-'a.}:)e'111'm12;1. Ex. P45 i11(ii("a.t':.(*s; 2.11] flu: 11_2j'('-'cfj'1s'jL':

are simple. in 1'1z'1i.1.11'e and it is 1110 .«spe==*<:i'f_'".i<V'---»£.'.f_ a1'1d P.V\/.4 lid:-11. A~- E. e_15~'.sa1.:1£.c=:("i v3;aﬁ_V1('.1';"t-'.-'i.1":'1"1"-5}'S5i.(}-:'1f" (')1'i €311':

raj!' I?.w'.2. ' 211"1k}<=:. }**I()u.rc\.~'e1' we notioc.":m;1'(.: £11-2.1:': <.)1.'1L.~ s§'iAz}1}4)l- iji;4_§1.i1'"j'?VVVL» on the 1')<:>1<.s(m of P.\'\/T4. E_>_;_(_.4iépt.~..1_»}T1c: i)wc_1't_-z=1<.§t% of A-11 1'crg211"(.'1i11g in-.'.1' i1'1_§1:1'iu.?§'.~ ~€.§T'1t:*yLc'Eij,)V1:101j};;:gi'1'2,I 0111 z'1g'e:i:'1sI 21.1'1},_-Y (,)1'.}'1('31' accL1s.scd .__Sc> :;1IS't_T5 '*.}'j:r.'> é:A\fi.<_Ev11("t(: :t:*i'1; other \\.-'i111('.h'.'.~'.€:S C1()€SV'I'V1H(")"1:I'Vi'111.}f)1i('TEﬁ:'IC'f.)'fIhC'1" 2'1c*Et'i':'sC"(i for 11'1<: i1Tgj1.11"i<>s on the?

1)C1"s(>f1-- .<>'f'«_P.V\»'v7.V4'; » ~

15. 'I.' '1'1e.111 ('0I l1ii'1§_§_ to the i1'1_}:_.11'i(='s of F3'.\?V xxx:

~ _}'*iax.iL*..t..11«:;'wfm_1'1c1 (.'('1'ii1'i('re"11c-2 2:1" E$x.f-133 emd :=211.$o wi11'mss of *P..W.I3V '(«§(';:.'?iV'.AkT:aV19. '1'h(m;;§1'1 P.\-V.2 did 1'1c>?i. 5:".}')<:<%iI"i<":e'11ly (.iis<:1.(>VSs;r the' (>vc1'1A;-mt of 2:111}; of 1.110. z.1("m1.<s<."d 1'c';j21.1"<ii11;g' V1'Y1"(:'. i':1_ju1'ic%s cm }'1is_s son P.W.5 but I'.Ws.F3 and 4 2i1ge;1i1'1 f1'cfC1" '£10 the O\"(:',I'1"--2'1(I3T' of /-\~ '1 I zmd tin" ('.'a.1_.1sc for i11_§1,:1'y on I') ;:)c1'\.-'c:'s~:(' t.1'1(T>1..1g1'1 .su(?h (.1i;%c't11R.s".;i('m \.m:.11d _j1:;~atif_\_«' 1110 z1cq_1:i1.1.a1 of c)i.hc-£1" z.1('('E1S€(1 L.'X(T(']')1. AA} and A-1 1. Eb. In t1"1a1 View 0ftl'1c ma-11.1.m'. wo :13?"=r§'f._i'11<--' o1'3inio1'1 111211 1.11:.' ..J11(.1§.'>_;1n('*:1£ 2.1.116 r..)1*('1cr of z-u1{q'11i:-t.;=ii*-ii1 fat' as A4 and A-- 1 1 cic:sc1'\--'<35 1t.) i")"(5 s<;~: z1'.:~;i(1_:;¥. ir§._ea(> '1--'a:1'.1' €313 (.)iTc11ce. pt11'1is]"1:=11)}(' u1':c:i<*r SL.~(:.i32,e'__£ 1:-.m(i 3213. " »Sz.') V':--":;1'1"'-~.%a:=1'..'s.'~.VV 1.11011' 2-1('.quH'tz11 in 1*ospCL.tt "t*vaf "'a111 oi£101""«f."1":2-1.:';§(~.9;W ST"¢11"]C'1V (wmfirmt-3d. S0 1'211*."a~.~.=..;' ej1(?'t;i1if.iL.;1;} v('5'P._(")t'.1'1c--:9° 2=>;t"'*(':11s:sc1(i in 1'cspe("':". of all (.'.l'§.21]'§___{(?S E111'_.}:.iC1V;g:1nc:--r::1{'vc::§i". ;_'.11'1<-~ t:1*i;-1.1 c::o11r£ is (éon!"ir1Tm-:d.

E7." _ 'fm:u:..1(..'i __§a;1.1iit._v of t)ff<..r1u~v ;:)::::Ls'1"z;»:1E>ic 'V V' A ()'i3T(_T:'1':1(?{g?.. _p1..1_:1is1']éi b}'t':-----«'.':'11('fe1* Sec.-.324-. 1 " 'i'c')V.}1&?2-11* :'<:§12"1.:f('Ii1":.g: >e(r1ato11(>(:=.:

}_:'i'€.7_*»'-'v.i'I:""i3';A§ rc?ge1.;"(:1 to 1.116. {am t'h2"11. A 1 2-1.:."1(.'l ¥'.W.2 ;«-um'? .' ..('?10sae I":§}2.1E:i\.;'<1s zmd {ht-.*. s('*.t'1"1€:a1u.>.1'11. bf _p1'()p<:1"1y ('1iS§.')1.11'.E'§ in 'pi:nt'1'1.e;1y;.1$1": S1.1b--s0q1u:-':"1E to I"hc-= inc:i(im1I in q:u;:.s;1.io;'1 £111'1d "'{?sp(t('*,i:».111_\; in the ztE:)se:"1(*@ of ;»11'1.y' fﬁilhf.-§(.'(;_1i()1'}1 :.1111c)wz'11*(:i uncicr s<.szi';:32vA,V;.u_1d'~.;:=11's;.o' 325:3 I.P(..I. A41 x"nmu.1 _:_gf1.;i}1"_\_.=' of i11L*idL'1'11.. we ;II'(' of HIE.' <>pi11im1 I'"'.('"). ,:'\v% M25 10 hv cxi.c11('fcé(1 to A-1 and Pr] 1..

I9. H(_.)\\'(.'\'€.'1' A-1 :;u'1c:§ A1 I z;m--.= (1iI_"t:""("T'%"{\,'(ui~.,§:(.)':. pzly (*(.)1'11.p@:'1szi'11ion. E11 \-'i(3\-V <')1'Ef1oi1' nvc1'I41¢?««'§\.'1"i'i~("lI*~.1}L*st11L{.:'L:iV.' 'V in tho i11_j1..I1'E'S s11s1.2.:i3"1(-?<'i by I-'V=.A_\-'v'.¢~:»-.22,'3»"1 2;1éV1{:l"'-5.'" *~A--=%; is di1'<:(..:t"cd '('0 pay cc)11:q3@1'1s2113'.im13 of A.:{t>..VI-?.\7\33..'3 VI(_'.~.1f ' 0eu.1si1'1g simple i1'1_ju1'cs. A- ('1.1:I'('(',I ('.('~1.12:0 }.);z;?_v 2.000/-- 10 P.V\7.4 for ("£1LISiI1£g"'--'*1~{I11}..31(" If)" I1i11'1. Am-I 2--111d 1] are (1i1'eL.:I',<.*.<'i in pay"'(%(.21ﬁpc-51';.$:1_1.iU1'1., <'l1'1"('<*I'c-('E 2-1!')r)\.-'<* wilhi1'1 $i.>_<.--V'.w---:'( j__*--! 1'0I1_i __1'1'1.gj ('.--._a1.!}n£' z'0<'ci1_)1. 0'!' c'0}.')_y 0!' 1l'1is ()1'(icf,_ in;('f(€i"éZ1;.'tl_1 ':1»§"("~1.;S'a>._c.i1-1- and 11 wiil 1101' 1'12--1\'(= Ihv E)e3'1c1'i{ <'31"'4_P.O. V}'\<'i;at1d"_;z1'12':111.01' 5112.111 1'._)c 1i..s'-I"e=*d }.>(*f01"(' this (3<.:«1fg1'1' .ikw1* l'1c¢2f11'~i.11g._§ 1'c.js.;a11'(:fi11;.:; sc='1'11v1'1<~('.

Sdh JUDGE Sd/-3 IUDGE

Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court

State Of Karnataka By Pa Hapalya Police vs Chikkavenkatarayappa on 17 February, 2009

Bench: Manjula Chellur, B.Sreenivase Gowda