Karnataka High Court
T Venkateshan S/O Thirumalappa vs Karnataka State Transport Authority on 10 February, 2011
Bench: V.G.Sabhahit, B.Manohar
' ' V . , 13R. AM SE31") KAE:<;_ \.fE:E§ii)1--E 1, . 4:-33/V yrs 313:0 R3§Z'I'ARY.
if: §K:f«;R::¥J;;*I"gs;2:A S'I_'A'{7£§ ROAD a " '§?:AI'sEC§-,£a.£,OE{E4j -- 550 G21 BY ITS r¢m?sJ'A<3::E:~:{; :::>:§«::T»A:(:-"2€'<>:-2. EN 'E'I--Hi E---HG}--1 g:<:>m<a';' (>1: £:Ara:_NA':'zx2§AH .£§A:\;<;A_:J<>.;:;:{:'J"
_i')A'I"EI.} TE--IIS "1'z---:5: 20%? {MY :11}? ¥?I%:BI{L,L=X£€Y. A' rims EfZN"1' H L. 'mfg. :«~10m;3I.:a: MR, JU STE (3 1%: 1§11»:.,A§?~:A1f'I.':..: 2 X AND :_ ' ' '.
'I*I~1E: Ii-:ION'£3L.I£E1 Mr2.JUS'f:':fi§'ia._MgxN~®11;'§§£ V WA NO. (>§<" fi:0;::§v}:93'§ §:3E'I'WE<:E;.E\I; " 'A ' V AA '1'. vL«:NKArrE:S£~-m.;\i; ' V -- .
S/O. TE1II2UMA.1;£\P¥%_A§._._ . ' AGED 43 YEARS..."---.
N06, 171% cRQsS.:":._?fw 3:/L' ~-- V' E'>.'1'.MK LAYC3"U-'1',V 1; -
EBANGAIJDRES .-- 5e3v<;;é_o_7~a, .. . APPELLANT [BY SR1 M.R.V. A€L:§-Ema, ;n1,,1.>'\';;I.fA) E1 2 . 'E§A1?§E'€.54;ff'x'AP§?%:5"3"ii£¥*E£i '1"RANsPQR-T A':3'1'1J.£Ox"aJf:":: b 5'ri%+£§I,00R, MU"LT:ST€3Rf£T;D '§3UI£.E3H'\.FGS, i3ANGAi;..OR.{§ 4 ~ 560 001 ,3 ":*E§A-:'§f$z:><3R*1' CO§{1?3ORAT£O?\L '~ _ "~:3N'1'j§aA:, ()I4'FZCiI.'.<ZS., fk;§§;%s;(;A:, 1.-4-mm LiM;:;\é'r:-»-Igimi--i Rom}, SE1§AN'I'§--£I?\1AGAR§
3. I3.zX1\iEE3§a.ND~EA, i\r'Ef&1r-i.,:='~&_i.)£+:T\.:': E\:'£G'_1_'()R SEZREJECEZ-, CHA'{.»I',AK_£ZIvQE§.
E¥?.E%ZE:-EEON§§é1§§J}f'§_ * "
{BY SR1 ma VISE~IWANAfE'E-i',AGA £~'0.§2~;€<:' SR1 NAGAKAJA, ADV. FOR R2, 1 SR! 1»-1.13. NAGARAJA AQV. FOR R_3"«€sz T SE{IASP1'OiE€ E-~1ARANA_:--iA1,1,:, Az)'_v'. E~7'0£?; R2; '1"E-~IIS WRIT ATPPEA1; i'«*»1,;;1;i:> U';/~s 4 0,5' THEE §{z--\E{NA"FAKA MIG}-1 COURT ACT_'PF_%j5xYENG "E'Q...SE7f ASIIJE', 'rm: ORDER I?'A.SSEI)~~., IN '1';-1'3 .w1""<-1.i1:' PETITION NO. .1581 1/2005 DA"1'I€:D 23.,/:08./2%0<;15;.
THIS AP.PEAL cQ3«:i'm"<jN,1:?Qré£*_o.1§;t)'IiRs mis DAY SABHAI-i£'E' J 5 . :3 :«.:1;,;I.W:;e_2;::1j: fiat}-1 I;?3«.P"().1;I,,{)_f'\_§.i'1I\fG:
*1' vii; VVUI r) Thi'E>"~- a-zppé'-at " £1i1'€d by £1131? 1.)eijti<)nez° in \U"P'.4?}r(J'L1-A58l.1 / daéted 234842005 wh<3:'e1°n the ieaastaed 'Singic JJ_cigef'2.has ésrclined 'to interibre with the order 01"
' §'(j".E11T} {j.'zI1€i"'f%§§LS§§f:C';'ii}? '£:hé3 S£,r5:i<3 Ti"£1I1Sp(3Z€"{. z"~'1pp€§L?3_E,{*: 'i'ri'::»:ma§ (h€::*?{;=*.i1":.a§"t3<é:°-.«:€t.2:z11<:{i ihe '"Fr'zTE:>L1I"12;1i."j? in R.I3,No,?33/2001 '*.. ';i:{;s;{>jE'21:* '=21'§<-.2 pr:%;:i1,ic>.11€::"s pem'1i1. b<.%a:"ing N'(}.9,='G£~{}2 is " _ 'e::.<§::';<%s:':*:'1<~7:§.
2. 'f'§:<'e Wm. Pz:%:.1?£..£<>:3 N0. Efifféii X21005 was §3J(':C§ by {$26 ;*::%v2's~:é<>:'1 prr..=:':::*€.§.§}:;.a;t:" §¥";' i'%%1E7-1 N<:>:'e.?33 ii: ?4£-35266: Eysizigg 3,, 21 H1.'iex.»'s3s:i b F {Em =$f(,}H"IIE1UI1 e:3:'de:r )zzss:=;:;%::§ E3 é..hc ..&3i,:t;21i<:% 33%: E ..
'I'r2111s5}3€>1'i, .A1f);3Ezi1z:1i'.c? "§r§buI'1ai. In t':§'":<:%. ssaicl .1'<;év§si_<§'i"i.' i and {)1.E"1e1' c<>1'1:1e<:tet:i ;feVisiv:)n pemicarlss, I':§}<~3 "ITr.;b1j.i';1V2i1".hg1$ 59.6%." aside the order passseci by the S:§.aE'eb_f§'i"23__1i3pE§3:1,=.A1--:.I:Zz?;0i9i§'y f {h€rei1'121f{'.{%1' Litaiieci the 'S"i'1'\')c_):: i'h€f' g>;I'"'<';'L1E'Ed,i;}4ié.1€ I"1Q ;9{§;L1"i:c Sm*vey waxg haid arid STA wa1é:%.Vdi:'e::{:ec1"€:)u}::::jss @112 Order élfiél" {:<>r1d1:{:i.iI1g§ t;he §_0i;1:.i. 2f50L1i<é "'§$:L1}."T\;'i;~'§f a:1dA3fc::C0rdi.x1giy :"eI11i':,1.et:i the maiéer to S'£T7"/$5. 'l€--aj;f1Vz-K1. Singifi Judge of this Court: c7Q:iE'i«171V:%:-ed ¥_1.}1cf r.3~£*d€é«1'"p--é_3;3s_edf'by the 'I'rEbL1na}. Beixigg agg1'.9'c:ve_d; this appeale H-e21r(E V"c.}_}'é< »1'€:£L_r.i«:cE* -COLEIISCI appearing fer the a.p13e1}az":it;.V.L r"r:s})V(:r1d'c*:'i1t. ""N'O.2 and the learneci HCGP ap pg§é1i"i:1g for f<3s;5(5ndéni.-- 1.
4.uTE--1;e'"~E.ear;1ed c0L1r1seI ap3j.3earing for the appellant.
" :s1;i'i;>1j?:1it{f:<:*f3_,"_~».';.h;§3:. 'the if-aarxiesd. Si:1g1e: Jucige has moi, 311 all {:Q:i':2:ic§e-ifecziv {he maE.i..e'r oz} me2"'i.t,s and has; pr0«::c:*<-rdéréfi to pass T:;?1:>.__ 0;*dE%1f :'8;1121.:1{Ii:1g {he 11121'£','{',er {.0 {§'}€'. 'i'ri.b:,.m21§ for l.i.11":i£.ed "';}1ir;>'c}s€: of c{)n£iu(:t'.§13g;§ 'ms: jaim, s»:4zr"ve3:~; in Eémew as tic} ' v4;he1':%1€::_° f:hsa;"e is 2121}: <:)<,»-*5;>1°}e1pp1'n;;§ of me m1.:E,€s-3. fie: §imi}f1<:r:* 552:?) z*;i§';'£.{t:E §.E':e:€T Ehe €'§€,3§'EE',C%iT{'.§(}E";S 0? {EEC 2';2§;;}€}§.2m'§'4 ?:av:: fi"lG§'j. ¥?,i'~':"'§ E.'-4,»-'1*i,E": {ht-5 S'§}*§§ 1":§':e $arz1.c? is not. p:'0cI2.:<:e(i Eli)!' ii. is "£1:-'f,;{U.§;f€i b€f{'JE'€ 'i.1'1:;* '.I.'ri.bu1'1a.1, 110:' it. p1.'0z:1L.1{'r.e(i b¢3f=::»1'&%_;"t'fE'1'i':--'-"Q~C_§)ai;:jt also. In any View c>{"1E1:3 n1at.1,c<1: the €31"df;"1' ()f:_'§',h:'r;".=, $I*1c}i,v~ that jeim su':rve3: repml. has .<z"1"<;s'i,«--. «be-39:1 M <51;-2'1,':3iC1<'::fé:d:~.. This appeal pez1<:ii.ng f':mn'1 2005 ;12"_:{iA~ 'T3;.hée'._{)?:fr§é:' V<;»§;L"--~€::bl€.T '"E'ribL.u:1.a} 1'e11'1it.t§:3§g; the :11att.e:i' -210 £:hVé:A.;S3:'fE';'~'a. is;'i.i:j;2§;§a1i1é:'£31é 3211:? the $211119 weulcf not V' in j'i,1risdiCi,i.011 of this COLz;I:_ "i3y 1":héfl iearneci Single Judge, .3-X£?CZ()I'C¥,§}}%§i'_j,f_"AX'é3E:~.v;f1C§}d__'%{'Q}£?§§'i..i,§'}'§E ortital' of the learned Single -_j'u.dg<*: ;dE)é"s' »if1<>': f3i<¥1:r1 any erroz" or i1I6g;21ii?3§"'sx $TVas..E:é ::21l}i:'fVI3E);"i.:.1:..ériErer1Véé' in this appeal. 'Fh<? e1p.peal-- is' 'd:'1's:i'ii.<s_SE:d, *s3p