Karnataka High Court
Sri. Mallikarjun S/O Veerbhadrappa ... vs The Ministry For Home Affairs on 20 April, 2012
Author: B.Manohar
Bench: B.Manohar
' =:;f;§3
£1 E' m'E'§{§'€:'X'E"g'::Vi:%.
7 Ci' {EU ;§§;'E%€%:}5'%_
'§'EEE; §i§@A~;*§:::4§: was, 3U.:aa:;z:a:{}é--§;i;%;:.
\fx7£€§'i' £I>::'§§':'s<>;'x: 2.
%:1§§+:*m5z::;:§;: V "
SR1.Ev§§:§,§4§K§a§{JEE?%i .
Sm.'2§§:§;§2:E33:;x:}32;;/i:,3>;>§; §\x:5*:.?§"§'% --
ggcga: 'r'§:;'-':E%,S§ <>é:»:: Eéi;iS_:§\IEi;?§$.;V-- . "
E%;'G.§*§.?§{>«é%;§a%8§3a ::}:s:v; C%L <}E'$-XL' _ " .
§>E1'§§'£"éTf{_}E\EE;1E%
::i3'g' SEE}.SEEE':i';*a§%'E;"{§2,}4'§E";
} W} , §
$22: "
"2 " xx" '<."< '~
2 §~v§ 1;;
32 533.5 EEEEEEE f'éf?§i§ E} §*§§£T {E35 E1} iég
QT
WM
'w.../
Qvww-Q
w W"
M"
9"?
Wm
mm
W
i M
E} ;¥%i;K§} ,
{I} 9 E} §%§"<J E
23: §%éiii:V§{>:V': 3:5 iékiscié
»i§:f2. %§--:a2,:
:;2:;> <fT=:>2:&si§:::i:%@:VV'2 {sf E;:,<i%2::,V §32':f:};§ _%:":":%':<*> '2=j:z;zé;s§:"@..
of IEEZ'i§EiEéE§E'3%.,i§§. «:%§:*:':%a1'V' §:i}"!§ZiE{?{,i§2,fi é'f'
s;az:"j; §.i€;'§§€,>§E 33:»;
:::a+::2'i::x::%:':~:Vs zzmsi ézésa; §:;>a1:%; "3E1ai% {,"§i,§§,,i"i§"i€;'?i%; <3? <:>::<;>
é%";zi1,a§<:::32.21:" E53;/:<i§;<;?3¢' 21::':{€ E}%é;:z§' ;
"'fa£;'7'§'ii2,i} §,i,}3.'°iE,E§°{,* "L,E§'i{E{"3I
:12;s:é_ $2.? :25
55> :' zzmz :;i:{é § 5.; as {E
1".)
E'Ef3,zI?%3S$21}'}' 22€_é!ii::;:': E3}; 3€{:;::*i:':g the §}€*':;":§ane:1 his
§E::gz1§E}; §3"1{'jZ"£E§i':f*3I'E§ anai 31:13 b%,I$iiE€SS SEES? ifrggzzs
{%E:,:é::%§r:z:%§; S? 0:33 §?'3'a1§3:§ %{:,:::::§:* Eizzzadey azzé DE2a;i':*3__§"'--«
:V2i%2~:} Ezavszi éiiegaziéfg <}::C:1g3ié:c§ %1is %3usi::é3$e:~; Sifiéégs é:'1<? '
;.;i:r§:1g iéfs iésmszzi ':0 ggéve ii :8
<;t<}:':ssi{Es;>:*22i;,i<;::": <35 z'3;,§1fi€X'&;§""S :_::2fi'= V'
:E3s:t:*:=é:%}3; gzzvizzég éiéi-3
:";:£::31a% i<;::"%L::'°<i+ :V1i'as:§m'Tg@§:3§f__ en V9;':::.C,E;%.,::";i :é§ '
32%;? azzziazvfzzi 3.{:%. cf ihe a§<§':::S;s:i§ §*:>i'ss3_::'s, 5
2. §}€'{,§E,§{}§3€3? hag ':§V:>T;1'i5::3_e:%iE:{5; --.w.:/3.23 fLE?:Ii§§3f,§ *;§:1€
éjzisézziésg w%::5i s§2_.:3p €35: é%:€~;::;7;r'::.§3*.;3z:yw 9:' i"\2E;'s.§é6:mE+<a
'fix/"§:'3é:3 Shag} ;:;é;' ,'¥.Z'*.¢v5;--....{f-A3§'C>:f{§;; VU_6.;3,1-32:" Biifias" for {ha East 2%
_':*'{"<:1§'E% 2:é'":'<':>2%t._;>'Eiv:;;:§:'i§ ,_:;§:;:i<;.;:?s;;é:*§gJgciéfisfi §m:";1 the Csn":;3{:%%.,;€:2é.
'.£€":::t%,;?és .. -é%%:,:€1':sé3 was 23330 3"€3C!€';i7€{§ £83' £253
3i:3;2:" 2CiE%?'tZ;2g." V'§E;_$ iéfis §}§§§€§0E'i€§ Ehajé; he was
:«a:,A:i'§E::,27,;§.:2;;§ §;2:>§3': %3é:{':?:;&2:i%':";€% 212;" $36 E5.se:L j€£%E'E§ szmii hi? iszxi ::::Er~:_{%::
;.?..:":§cfs"_:é;::f:'i E§~::i:%:s;:" 251$? 332$ Bazcécgé' baa? him {G 33236
airgfgaeiéé «:T%_.::-.35 Sgéasiaiégy ?£::;g§i%:2::§, fifésy éhergugh ;'{w:";:§:
_ $2 §*{:22;§23ci'v€%:23.§; §:§2:::» §aé;§":%::>:§§:° azsag $2,:§§s§§::2g {ram sg%;£~<a§§;€z::Za
.,:4§:;;:§:VT §'::«.§E"aVz"»:>/{:2 Z:}:>3'§'.f:'§"§iT3§ V'%§%§$§g% ~€3:3§§:§:*6s~;aez%:::§ §I'a%f:E§;£1,"f3 ii
§::::;2§};. ?'Z":€ §i"}C§";{%1i'° $3.3 aiiaséaszi E23331: Ea: azgzisrge
2
$2.24: %::§::2':§é£3:2é, $223.3 ':9 éakfi S1355 saéé; §§"€Ei§;§"'§'}§f§§'i',
<1}
<1
5. i
2 is:
, V
>33
.§;;2§ Egg
E}
3; '
\v,r , .
*3' x%.~"22:~; :?<>:":':;
,.i.¥::.:::<;%
2' E':
\,'
A:
E
K
, S,
E
,/L
val .
1.4 .
. C .1
:2, xi.
£1 2...
3
«
2: .s.\
1;. , 3
:5. ,2 ,1
1
2.2 ..§ 1;
if Q32 , L
.2. ,3;
.3, :52,
E 5;. g
E. 32 ax
.3; ii ,\ »
'EEK
ii
. »1.:\
22.
2 i
. .
'<.%_:~,4s.x::§: "
.&Ep§}I'{E2:':,%;'§E 292:? {T/W25? {H/:';»(','r'iE_§TT§'..f_K€_§'}7 §;{',,
,V {%<;:,:<;ft:1EE:,a
.3
,3...
f ..z '
S1; 2} < ;
v\ . E. 2 ,
_.§, ,3 {L
:2 5 ,91=..vL
5:; .,$.,., .. E;
3: $2.
22.. ,4
45!!» Y;
,., A, x; :3
4: «C 52,
x J 33,
V 331 2» .~
::,w:":V::<%::1va; ::::.z::§
{rm iii'
E
42E,
3.2.,
_, . _, rt:
as S A
K 2 r
a , . 2.
E i 2 a
: . EC '£3; a
§i>;:,%fss;:x ééééz
_.,.K
E 3%
2&§2
222':
'
cszxfi
Sf
31 §&55@Q
Qfifiéj E
30
Y:
.. .4.»
is
V
U;
2
t
3
5
1»
2%
éi
51 xi,'
8, E
2 ,2...
_} ,{
{ > W
w.!€9.L it
XE ,1;
:3
g A 1
'i E 53
22
ii
akra
fa:
W:,£§éf:1<Ei?§";&; E ;7w.
N; H
22; E)
5
3; E
E E V
, 2 R
_.z\ L
Kl» Xvi . 6,
.,1..,,
3 0 5:? <1 A; {E
5».
Z'
3
ézé.
was
9.;
§9'%.:riE;.:3s* :3:
Egg: &5E§:<::>;;:$,
_ 2,; > ,,
E {X ,§\
{$21 ,3» Q3
.1; .
if, :3.
mi _,.:x,
. . u xx.
,2}. M, «aw. A 4
z 1 :2 ,. W
3 E1; :1
2. ,}
.3; mm... X»... 1
1 { rii, ix
. .3 _ xx,
«ex \ M 1:2,»,
N} A {E
,3:
Ta
2..
:1
3...,
2 N. 'L
6",
,\§H
.;s...¢\.
) .
5,
$532313;
3,.
/sx. _,
:2 E
,3}. as 42,
,2. xi
5 >
Wu 0 g._
:4. 3;,
a E;
2 E
E
.5
1 'E; 2%.
2.1 E.
5.; VI} \
xi vtsl
2; ,3
% E Ha;
/VX5:\
1.,
{K
,1;
3;.
25.
22
¢ é
<,;>:Eu<,:
.1...»
vii
.
K; W ,, ( 9.5 . w 5; 12. 3:
. ye: st. ,§.
.. ,3 :2...
iii'?
2§<§§<,\if'>f?> fl ,/hm Efifl z3:é:§{> as {E at :1 ::2<:::': 1:5 3% E 2: «:;'t<:% 3:, :9' * ,1:
25., ii.
(2,, ,_il . 2% ,2 .,, ...,..\ SE, >$..\z\ xi . ,2;
I; :5
3., _. . £2, , 1 ,5: , !s\ , E. . si { 9,, 2; >35. , , Eu. 1 ,. c , \ A.,\... an av 1 w\... I, E .. , 5:
,. a 3; ,3; W013
2 3. ,, E {K 5: 3.' 5, ; ,3 :3 WW; 3: C 2,. :7: 5 11 . 3 . 3 , x } i E I z \, Vfi. ,r\ 2...», IE" 3} 2 : 2.. W} _ . ,, * xi, $2 3 3 X N _, .t\ {Eh .2 33, :94 rik A .2;
xi... ,,..%\ ii xi ./IX,' wé, L i .5 E2. 3, , Kkf
5. 5;
.11 Ky ,, X V2,; >2. , M i 3 ; K 7/ Na... will , (XE sh: ; 3...; 2,1. :..§/ 3;, H , ,2;
5}:
M \ f EV :2 2? ,,,:
,;, ,, i. 3: i5\ ,4: . , < X ,, Li
5....' . 37..
C, Q ~ 21 2.11 1}.
ii':
mi.
. 1} g>::Ei:[i<::::<,%2" :x»'a.E; :31 §,§x_ ~sé::<':1' C 2:
5.} E} ai::é;.v.';1'i:':':+% E' 9:: 5 §_é'*<;'*;;::
2: :éa:> :1 ( éé :3 ,2:
x ,8 x, ,, Wax vi;
\,f , L. C E5} S§i?{ii§V{}§'3 { 2;
3, ,, ,1 :3.
xi ,2:
:2 Ex. ,3, vii . ,, , .21 .5 .( 2:
%,'f* 2.? :5: {Té . xi , , ii {:2 .
mi y :1... .. ms... '\ . xvi , ii , As: i , .5 vii .11 x ,, «E; 5.2.
3. .
.3.» ?,,,.E,. $1 N .2, Q » 45 ..§.
i.vvA ,, 1;, 2:
,\.;J, < E .11 V!) E ,} /§\ 3, ,2:
,,,,, ,, .5 R. xx , 3 2., E ,2 .2, 45,, «U .8 xi mt, f a K 2 S . nu V,/.
5/2%§«.%2??/eééézzééfziz 6 2; ,, 2 , . {ex .s.\ E (S E; 3 22: , 21, §,,_..... .2 .. ,_ y, 3 R, . M 1;, K {\ ,;,z\ 3 ,, ,\ , §\ :0 xi ye. 5; ii 1;, ._ ,
5..., (O vi 3.
waf», ,3; my it ,2; fmz 3...; 3,3, ,3: sé in .
:3 ii i g , Li, 6» iév: 2:1,: §E'":{3§' :,;,§<g:::: 0:
,2 = E' 3,3 x}.
2 ii) 2; _,, \ ,..§. {, E as 1 .2 ,5 13:. was. SK :2 _ . 3 V A is Egé E... , { 5 .
E, 1 { E E xi, ai ; E __ ; Q S ,', 7/ . L, ,3 W42."
1;.
5,2;
2;
A» a » , :3 4:
,3;
3;
§ i § § é § 3 § § 'F '3 i.§:::: €7<f:2":§;:'::;::V§V>;V%:2§T z';::éE':<V3:'§i%<%::e§ :'+:;%:"':<%c> 233:? £%§:«:;g:sa2iz.:%<:§ :§:::;a~5«:§§s):2 :%;E':af*iE: " ":::> g':=<:éz€i:>:::;%:" E5 EEK? VE'3::.:%gi:é *§'3'::2:«V:.}»:':§-é;:%__:V":": <3: ;
§'::;T!,f~3 c::>;.<*%<'%a:%;V:.?€E as': 2,':,j.§:i'€§.'{,Z"%E'§':{?E'1?§ <;§s;1i{: ii": fees:/'s:,'2;2:" 9?: H 3:; Ex: :ia%:;%:'<L%s:%=:'V§ EL}? Céarié £i<>:z:°z_' rgxt :3 if'? 3 <3? 3332;?
{>5 ":~.7§:1<>':ea§3<:>;i2 é:'<i>:§::.éE/'2<2% A§5?l_ §'<éés§:.{}r§§§;C:";2 ::<;a:m.:2;":®;:%i 3325:: §}é'_'"i§iE§{T}}'E{'7§7. ;i2.213.[__ V_,_--_'_~< 'V ' %._éE1:£3_'' iZ§;1{,'i,{'%E" E}€f£:s:"a% 331:? Civié €.jTf€}%..E§"{,.
If:%i;":<%e:V:% :"éar;*> 53>" _aii:2%;%'::y__:_j:{;:fifzzivé 2;::2j; vazéisgi §:£<1%:%::.<~:<> {ES mi; i :'<>«iE 2:: 3:-5:? <7?
§éi::§;%s~; ii: {:31 ; Eises é3':~::*':":"':<} " ix,/mié §::}%,§i 2, $153 :3' f'?,{} E §s.::s:"
M 3...
E'i1§l}§ 5e2::':?i:/'::V{t §1:(;::' <ts:;:2si{f§é;%--:';?:§£02: ;;::"2:;': 353%? .<s;::::s::% {§i:'*%§E E§f.'+}f'~§{'{'§¢ gig;