Karnataka High Court
B Nanjundaiah S/O Bettegowda vs The Commissioner Bangalore ... on 3 February, 2009
Author: Ajit J Gunjal
Bench: Ajit J Gunjal
\%r'
V V. V' rDL¥)_ MAiEivALA,EANGALoEE.
PAPA REDDY
VA .._AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS,
IN THE HIGH comm' OF KARNATAKA AT
DATED THIS THE 3rd DAY OF' FEBRUAR_Y..§(_f::{}9 355.; A T 4 E,
BEFORE V . A
THE HONBLE MR.
WRIT PETITION NOS.
BETWEEN : X
1 ENANJUNDMAH. '
S/O BEWEGQWDA, , ~ V:
AGED ABOUT
R/AT NO. 1,/':," .- .
201%! MAINRAQD, _ A'
RAGHAVENDRA Liayoufzf, '
BTM F,;AYOUT,E5IS'I' s;°;rAr3E,._' .
EANG,aLQRE.V'v~" '
:2 SMT GOVJREMMA. _
W /0 RANC'i2%_N£aRA8{Mi.{AIAH
A<3EE..AEom* 58 'EEAEE,
R/..Afi'}' No.43, " ,
' ' ._ Bi5.NAS.'r-EANVBLARI 3RD STAGE,
, m'AMAE.u,,BENGALoRE-as.
3 J'VEN§é';$¥'i'A_ REEEY
Sm-ENARAeE=__.EEDEY
AGED AEOIE' 56 YEARS,
-- R/AT N'o,5o,
JAIEHEEMA NAGARA
S10 K.N.OBALAREDDY
R'/AT NO.4?, KOODLU,
HOSUR MAIN RAGE,
BANGALORE ~ 68.
Em' AMEENABAL
W/0 MAHAMD RAMAULLA
AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS,
R/AT NO.6,
RICHMOND ROAO,
BANGALORE 25.
APPAJI GOWDA
S/O NARASEGOWDA,
AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS,
R/AT NOB25/9,
mm 'c' CROSS ROAD,
VYAIJKAVEL, A&ALLEs_HwARA,Aq,°j ~ ._ '
BANGALORE -- 3, . '
KRESHNE GOWDA ._
s/0 SiDDEGOW_DA, .
AGED ABOUT .5svYEA2jg2s, '~
R/AT NO.2O_'s, < ='
:31' CRO$S,'EvF3"f1?gI1fig}I\¥'}§}1",)fi':3,, In
RUPENA L*\GE€A'I_~;IARP: .
MAE1VALA~
N.G:R. L;'a¥Om', ":1:
BANGALORE 5:3. " « , =
N.R.LA:<;sH1vE KU'1T1'*§Ah'£.MA "
W/O K.NA_RAYAN.A N_AIR.,_.*
AGED ABOEIT '70 YEARS,
R,{A'I' RO.722,-- A ,
v£s'1* GROSS, 6m Mfliii,
A . BTM 'LA'{.0'uT,2nD STAGE,
' (E;§v".s__.)', EAVNOALORE 75.
* . . '':a'zE'E''Ai§i"{A',',:= V'
wf/O _E3.~S.N:AZEER,
AGEBNABOUT so YEARS,
R/A? R034, mm MAIN,
V A RATTAEIRAMANAOARA,
' _ JAYANAGAR WEST,
'EANGALORE
NAGARXYFH NA
W/0. THAMMANNA GOWDA
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS,
R/'AT NO286, Tm CROSS,
2713 MAIN, BTM 21'" STAGE,
BANGALORE 76.
£1
12
13
14
MARIGOWDA
S/ 0 CRIKKARANGEGOWDA
AGED ABOUT 70 YEARS,
R/AT NOJ319, 1211* CROSS,
6'39 MAIN, BTM LAYOUT,
BANGALORE -- 76.
SHIVARAJU
s/0 KARIGOWDA
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS
R/AT NC) 819, 2!!» FLOOR,
12m (moss, 1611* MAIN,
BTM 21¢» STAGE, EWS
BANGALOREJ76
GOWRAMMA. K. *
W/O LATE RAMAKRISHNA "
AGED ABOUT 55*YEARS'" ' '
R/AT NO 151,- *=%'i'1,
4m CROSS, .S'R1N§3/ASA Ngégéé 7- . "
BSKIST S'?FA(}3§---. V
BANGALORE -=50;
RAJANNA; " ' ~ 97
s/oxgmz 1<E.MP:::t::<jjxa.a::>'Af"'--%% % %
AGED Agom 42 YEARS'-.__ "
R/AT 292V,L2m> MA1N,", "
BR1NDAvAI\'..LA?oU.T,
ARI§{£*3RE, M160 LAYOUT,
BAré:NERQHA1*rA"RQ_A_Dv
. .E3AE%iGAL'OR'E.-«76
15'
~W','-Q. SRENIVAS;
ACEED A_80i}T"7O YEARS,
R/AT NO 156/2,
2"" Ni.AII\5_ ROAD, 13.K.NAGAR,
AYASHAEFANTHAPURA
" V. BANGALORE
MAYAMMA
iv/0 SIDIDAIAH,
" " 'AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS
R/AT NO 925/9, 11TH C CROSS
VYAYALIKAVAL EXTN. ,
MALLESHWARAM
BANGALORE--03
17
I8
19
20
, A B53-n:;A;;<3RE
21»
4: 22.
THIMMANANJAIAH
s/0 MOODJELAIAH
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS
R/AT NO 20, am Mam
BYRASANDRA
JAYANAGAR EST STAGE
BANGALORE
K K DASAPPA
s/0 KARIYAPAP
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS,
R/ATNO.'7I4, am A MAIN',
SRINAGARA
BANGALORE 50.
ADILAKSHMIKANTH
s/0 SHAMBUGOWDA
AGED ABOUT 53.YEARs,-H . '
R/ATNO. 13, 217m «cre«:)ss~;:;,
MuNEsHwAR;xNA§.;ARA,, 1 i "V.
KAD:RENA§iALLz._V ~
BANGALOREQ6
LMAN3tii€A;'I*E~§A_ "
s/o 14#;;<sEiM1VNA:'%AYA_:§1A_éésx.. M %
AGED ABOUT 51 YE'é;RS,~,_
R/AT No.2. YELAC--HENHA1;£,I
KANAKAPURA RVOAD,
BAS.P{v'A.RAJA LAYOUT, '
_ .A R' «RA1~.1:«iSH ' .
_ s,£<_:>' :~1.RuVI):.°;.sx;§E;)DY
" AGED A'i3(;}EJ_T VESSVYEAEES,
RIATQ No.29':1,a:;
I4TH._A moss,
BSK :2?'D STAGE,
BANGALQRE - 70.
"'f"'z3..y';"YoGEsH,
"S/O."VY§{UN'i'AVASAREDDY
AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS,
-«R/AT No.44/A, um MAIN,
VENKATESHWARA NILAYA,
BANDAPPA GARDEN,
MUTHYALANAGARA,
BANGALORE -- 64.
42
43
44
45
43
CHIKKAIDAEAH
' _s;xO.LA'1*E:'c:}--IALtJvA1A}~£,
' :§GEU...A='3;U!'}'F _5_':"; YEARS
~.R',*A*r NO_942~,{F, 131* CROSS,
.3.
BP. RATHAN KUMAR Pm
S/O. 2.13. RAGHUNATH PA},
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS,
I?/A'I' NO 421, B.T.M.LAYOU'i',
gem MAXN ROAD, Sm CROSS,
E.W.S., }Z3AN(}ALORE--76
RJAYAMMA,
W/O. S.M.CHANDRAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS
R/AT. NO.21,R.zv1.H. COLONY;
ESATTARAHALLI VILLAGE,
EGRONAGAR POST,
BANGALORE49
GURUDEV,
S/O. SIDDLINGAPPA,
AGEE3 ABOUT 51'--srEARs'" "
R/AT NO 133,» s::mj'MAIN ROAD,
J.P.NAGAR,'.63ffi .%?;'AO1:., 1 _
BANGALORE-78.' '- "
K.N.P:2mcASH. ' . .
S/O.K.N.NAZ-2A1?ANP;PPA,
AGEDTAB-OUT 5; 'Y..:§ARs'~--__ .
R/AT No.51, 21%: MAIN ROAO,,.--~
22¢» Lavoufr,-ask: IS'I',s'£'A'c.'}E
wugvaxanzaczzazey ~
BA;srOAO;.ORE-:20' '
41? MAIN 1<'c;j_»AO, rm LAYOUT,
BSK srsn STAGE, BANGALORE--85
.. RAMAKKA,
W)'-O.IA'FE CHENNAMAREDDY,
' }':.GEéD ABOUT 70 yams,
"R/AT NO 289, "rm CROSS,
Exam MAIN ROAD, BTM LAYOUT
*' 22*» STAGE, BANGAL.ORE--'76
RAMCHANDRA DA.
3/ OASWATH NARAYAN,
AGED ABOUT' 52 YEARS,
49
51
52
-9,
R/A N024/1, 2"" CROSS,
2?"? LAYOUT, JAYANAGAR,
BANGALORE.
KRISHNAPPA RV.
S/O. RVEERABADRAPPA
AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS
R/AT NO 33/4,
CAMBRIL ROAD,
DODDAMALAVAHALL1
BANGALORE~--O4
PADMA. K.,
W /0. ANANFHARMU,
AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS, '=-
R/AT 140.223, am MAIN RCA-D;
GURURAJ EXTENSEON, 12,f:'.3s;Aa;n;r~j,
BANGALORE.
SONABAL'H ;N :uy
wio. vm-«LL R.':»e:Am:<.;»1),'--..jJ--«~._
AGED ABOUT'6£"{YEARS, ..
R/A'I'.NO.85/'L5. "I:;, ~ V
Bs§<a3nn _
BAGNALORE * '-
LINGAMVMA," V , » V
w/0, cHzKKAGo'w.m-,_ "
AGED ABOUT' YEARS,
yzj/'r-..T3rs1o.:33/4, _____
«VPAFPAIAE-I moss,
' . BODDAMAZJWAHALLI,
' BANGA'LQ'REf.~.__}~
+53
'MU 12A:.5H.%___
mo RAMCHANDRA SETFY,
AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS,
' .. R/AT":ao.98/1,30% CROSS,
7T5I&LAYOUT, JAYANAGAR,
V V' BAN GALORE.
H JAYARAMMA
S/QGURAPPA REDDY
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS,
R/AT 510.9311, 30%: CROSS,
'?'?B LAYOUT, JAYANAGAR,
BANGALORE.
55
57
59
-19..
(3.3. S. GUFTHA,
S/ORAJAFFA SE'I"§'Y
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS,
R/A'? J. RNAGAR,
JARGANAHALLI,
BANGALORE.
SHANKAR REED?
s/0. PAPANNA,
AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS, V
R/AT No.47, 131' MAIN ROAD'
:33' csaoss, VIVEKANANDA Ex*rxy§;';..%»
BSK KANAKAPURA ROAD,
BANGA LOR E~78
GOVENDHA REDDY
S/CLGANGA REDDY, V
AGED ABOUT s<,3.Y'EARs~-- .
am (moss, 3r..mMA-2N,
c;owDANPA:_1YA,;1:TwL»i' _ . '-
BANGALORE-£1 V. .- 1;~
SUBRAMANYA RF;{)_DY' ' ' '
S/o.sEENA% REDDE.'
AGED AB_oU':' 59xY_VEARS' ._
R/AT S13 CROSS,'3K'?«MAIN,¢
MANJUNATH. NAGAR' , '
GOWDANPALYA _ A v
BANGALORE-51 ' ~ *
RE'fHi§k1MPJA
. 'W/0'_vL.vRAMAKRIsHNA,
_ ;A.,EO{I1f 5; YEARS
" ._R-,(A.'i' 'N<:)" YALCHANAHALLI,
KANAKAFU mg ROAD,
B§§:NG1§.'LO§3.E-78
Bxsmfifia
g A3;-.0. LATE CHAIAIVAIAH,
* _ ;A>GE'D ABOUT 52 YEARS,
RIAT NO 942/F, IST CROSS,
Wm MAIN RGAD, BSK 339 STAGE,
-- " BANGALORE-85
NBABU
3/0, NARAYANA,
AGED ABOUT so YEARS
68 ASWATHNARAYANA
s/0. JANARDHANA REEDY,
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS,
R/AT NO 1406,
K.i~I.EXTN.,4,1,3
JAYANAGAR NORTH, ~
BANGALOREQ 1
69 THIMMA ARASAMMA
w/0. NARISHIMAYA,
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS,
R/AT N0 3:29, 32» STAGE,
4m BLOCK, JRNAGAR,
BANGALORE. f E
(By SI'i.D.L.Jagadi$h.&..:._'-.
AND: . Q , _ 1
THE COMMivSSI'Ci\!ER, "ii: '-
BANGALORE DEVE LQPMENT ' « -
AU'I'HORITY,': * V
KUMARA PAREVWEST; ' "
BANGALORE-2o'*.__ ' _ . " ...RESPONDEN'I'
_ (}33{Sjji;*BasaEra1*a§___\{..Sabarad, Adv.)
o o
~<IffiEst\EEi*;?v»%;?E'A*:£':*i*1<3r~:s1s FILED UNDER ARTICLES 1226 AND
09' "«EfHEV___v'CQP:fSTITUTION OF INDEA WITH A PRAYER TO
_ _f-«.1$sL:E A WR{'I'":OF MANDAMUS TO THE RESPONDENT HERBHN
_ .: '1s'O1;r_ EGESIEERING THE REPRESENTATION vim; ANN-C,
DT,.29..4.os;-'in so FAR AS THE PETITIONER is CONCERNED.
""*r*1--1§sE WRIT ?E'I'IT1OI'~I$COrv§ING on FOR PEELEEMAEY
'HEAREVG, THIS DAY, THE coum MADE THE FOLLOWING:
-13-
ORDER
Mr.Basavaraj V. Sabarad, learned 3 directed to take notice for respondentm
2. Learned counsel appearing fen 'petitioner; serve a set of papers on him.
3. Even though theVm.s;'tte£?_ hearing, with consent, it isA'taken "disposal.
4. The proceedings of the constituted for re.co1}:11:11eI1dizfigw~to the displaced persons of on 29.03.1973. It is thett "i'g w3.'s'i*esolved in the said meeting that 904 entitled for sites as per the of the Advisory Committee. It appears ~ jsgr_epresenta,tion is gven on 16.09.2006 for allotment of It is aiso submitted that there are 92 and out of them 23 beneficiaries have «jflaiready been allotted sites.
5. Having regani to the fact ma; representation is given on 16.09.2006, the <2 is directed to consider the same_, " V' respondents shall also consider dis this regard in accordance witls. " V' A ' % Petitions stand % 6. Mr.Basavaraj counsel appearm g for to file his power in thei Sdfg:
judge