Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

- Know your Kanoon - Doc Gen Hub - Counter Argument - Case Predict AI - Talk with IK Doc - ...
Upgrade to Premium
[Cites 2, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

Wajid Ahmed S/O Syed Amir Ahmed vs Rehana Fatima W/O Wajid Ahmed on 18 March, 2011

EN "i"'HE§ Piifiéfi COBB'? GP' §§ExRE'=3fi;'TAK.z§
CIRCUIT Z-"EEEKSCH 23:?" GUM-3z%.R€'iz%_
§):;«zt:ec§ ii.E":.i§»:: "E,§T§.€*? 18¢ dag-* €_:::£'?v'Ia1:'{?E3, 3%} E
E%EF'{}RE

mg E-EGWBLE E's«'ERJi}S'E'ICE: .ARAE..E NgG;xR,m  :  ' 

R.P.§?.C. N<>,54~2 OF' 2020

C/W    ._
§€.P.E'.C, N{>,513 95520::-A1-.Ti' 4'
:2»: RPFC NO.542;'201G V %

BE'F\¥'EEZNi

Wajid Ahmed S/0 S}-'€;'{§ &::r:i§'~~,r{%E1§:Iied A
Ag§é3::38 ytsarg, C){:£t:811s§mzS5§"'--~ -  
RA} in the hi)u:~;€3 05 E£€u1:afP0Ei*€:¢  '
C{3ns«smb}e Payan €h€:=:'.3_v R0221."  -- 
Gu§b2f:rga~585 103;   I 

£$K$ '?%:E:§§.i0:::€:"

{By Sri. L-iyaqai =.1'?%'ar€<w;~€:- U55: §i.2:d..," "A.{i?aa{:e1€.e}

AN?) . .     

" 2 '_.E€&:h_21:§«2aE'af:§:'2":21 'i?i'£<)___%1721§£{i A31 §1'3.<:=.<§

 Ag,§e:L'3:E f:z_:§£::;::"3_ Gait: Ha:>z§s4:éh:>i{i
*  §{,.:'7 s3:¢§.;e::5:%.{§'  §§«f2:;~":_8 E<m SE?

%?:;::%:::::;:::'§1j??-"§;:§;zé;:%*.;i;§E5E J::%:,a222;:*'g§ Eéaisad
S} L£§§}éj};I"gf2i- 5E;€fi_:*'_é. 'E SE

 --V S§1;i§£5;_§?:1:§A'§%:;z"€:;'z1§ E}/'<22 Wzggiéi &%3'§_':r2€s:i

 _ 'gig: §}  {7}{:<?:: $€,2:z{§€»::';€.
' ji3:":{:'$_:° §§;.§2if{§§E§EE <3?  §§"i€'3'§'E7§€f1E" E-'<2§:£'€«:2a E
' * 5  §{€E§§}{}I'E{§;{E'§}'{.S

( ""'"'*--M

WM M39 \....--x.»'



 Egggté; 3?} §;Iéi%..:;':3"sss;'{7;¥::%_:

tx-.2

{B}; Srifi S Sédhexpzzrkzzzr, Acix.-*. ff)?' R1}

"£"E2§s-,: EESPFC is; {£36.-35% 2.:/-S §§}{4} {Ef Fifi Ad: agggazismi ashe Orciez'

{iii 3iE<ii<3g28{"3E3} p21s~3§a.€=:i in €:."ExM£ss:{t;f\é0.8§j2©®? €21': 1f..E1::%_;§§i€ sf

%.%:e iT}§&;?;::'37_<:=£, Juaiggge-in E'zm1§E3; C<:»1.zri:.. Gizibgzrgaa pe1.:'ily' Ei§§,{T§€'§?iI1§§;
'é.E:a:"% §::ei:ii:_i<3:.': fiierd 12/43 1.2?" 2:3? C§§i'P.C, §'1:}r maiI1i.::%11a3'1%E::?.""ffiizge

pei,i£,j<3::1e§' is dirs::<?':.<=:{§ :10 pa}; %"2,C}8fif» per m{m;f:'.E:.;--¢ "%.;ije': 
E¥{es§}<3:1£i&;':%': neixé 2m{i 31,501!)/~ per m{}nt.h to'1.E€€%:rsj§e{}:3.<ii:3»z1j£; *

:m>.2, :f%*<>m itha <:£a;t,<;=: {}fi'§"1{% p&2E:i2'i.«;::n 'iii: sshfgfr g.§<;%t.€.: .E'£1§:iI'~E'"::Z:i;?§§';*.,_ 
IN R1-"'FC K351322011
BE'i'V'€EEN

E. Reflema. §<":.:1t:§_:r;2a1 W,/<3 Efifajid AhIf3"€='fi§ V
Ag§£3:3<§ ya-:a1rs;, QCC: E~%Io1:z--:%§: Hzslfi" --  V
R/:3 Javici Mijfiazllss H0{.s3€€j-- 1 1 V ..  
§€€:§:n1:3.E,i1 §'é2;§ga.;1 Gk? Jexv21f'gi'§%eiad   
Gz,1§bargfa~585 E02   .. 

3, S§f:e1.rr2.:f2f:lz%;E§z':':.1.::}5§ :>;';;km1;§«;:% A:m}§e?:§
Age: 1 O  E\z'E'.E.§:-:..>_:5' '€:)f{ '£?;7 '§'f"_"%~'é;u:<§z:n'i:
'¥jr*:d€r:° {§':;21:*a§§a.:':: {::E;§7 §'::@*:':*'«2::15Tl{;§:<Ef:--::%z' ?e'é, Na}. 1
 *   = V   P{'%%fi.ia2";e:'$
{E3}; ',3-Eré, "R :':'~} _vS_i{§.hézp_i.::"§»§.;é;r, ,34'»;.x:ié,:*"€>e::.2>;'£'T<T:%}

  I   "  ..... .. "

§?s,?g1_§i:§__ §%':§j2.:'§:<;={E"'S,§'=:3V '£_;,.:§ ;4w:1i:'" 5%}: EZ"'i§3,C§

:;E.9§:..2;<-3§;2es:;;s'~s

 

 "'~iE{g':: in ?;.}':,{;>; §1{}?:,:=%;:%'j's:}§; .§%/Emu'? P0311253 {'i{}:2£%%':abEa>
 _ §321'§:-- gm Chilfi? 3. E§<3;é:a

" ~ :3 Egg}

 'EE§j.;T;'i§:::§;' .E._,§'j.3i-ragga-*;£. §32;2:"e<;%<§ {_E's»;E:2:2{§§ 525%,:-'{3{:;2§:e:§

35$ E%?..:;%3§}<§:2{2:;*:§"::'

: ......... Mk WWW



".E'hi§:; RPFC f§It2':{.i 22/5. 19%} of PC Act, ag§ai3'1s5E. the
J1.1Ci§§€;?§11i"'I'}f. amci Qrdérzr aimed 3i.§2.Q{}O9 §}::"iSS&€i in Cr}, MESEE.
Ni}. 89/200'? an the {£13 sf £.§*"1e §}:i.ss"trict Ju<ig§<2, Famfiy if-{::L:r£: at

'?~z:1}':32irg;g:., whé:%:"<?i:2 pariiiy aiiam-*i§1g Tijhéf p@i;i'%:1'::3:"1 {Kati 'Q3? {E16
§3~€i?fI§"£.i{}§}t"'fI°:?9 11 ,2' SN 12?' (>17 €3;'.P.€. Arid it is E"1€°I{i Ezhai: §}<5:i;§-i}i'c3j:1<:»r
Ef*«§<},,E is e:":ii.i'.E<%ci fer m.2.m1*é,e.:.3am<:eé caf ?2,(}QG;'~ per :'1":<:f:i§'.i'2_"L:§i:f{§::1

Ehézé dam <>f pet.ii.ior: and 'i]}"1€ ?<3:i'it4i<3*:1é:*r f*€:::a.2   E{_;r« _
I}"iEi§.§}"{i€;'.I1E1I1{?€:? of 2": 586;' » pair i"¥1€}I1'li}"k fycjxn {ha :iaié:_ {}f'§}§?f'i?'ii}E_1;. "

{iii Shé-E gets m;e1:':"i:=3:{i.

'£'hesr;*. RPFC {:<:)r11in§;" 0:1 for 21ti:I1is-aigizi, =.§.his§' d'2;§;..__ 

Ciéasrt §€iS§:§€{£ the f°:3E1_0wi::;g:
ORDER:

> RPFCE NGS42 af 2a:}§@,_A_ is; me a2i'¥:§éfp{§1:1{ieI1t' in C§*E.M:is:s<:.Na.§§9/BGG?' on i:§"1{;2'V:'§%:fLé'{§AV_;<>"§ E:_%.;§;f§£;¢%:§'_§}i$i.ri(:t. Judge', Fzxniiiy flow': at. G;:1'§'E:;.z?;_%g21 :§_E1E'f§§'{?i§E2iff.§§I' .i'£3f€i§T;E"'€(i {G 315% "Famiiy Smart" iior ss '§::<:§'«E,;ié £:;§'Vé?{'iEE:i::~§'{1V'i3;°'E§'aE3;fi~ §%1<i: inapzxgrifzd Jzzdggmem mad C}r{i€z* {tame is 32%;?' fpzsgsséeicfi 33* Fzimiig Clmari: d:?2f~:--:z:"i"3Zr1;:g him is ::::«__ ?a:i::.§§:§<3i3¢;*:'r N63,: 213161 2 theréfiiz ggav . zr:a.;2:3-;3;4=e:i':7s I": 9% 3:32§'f:'é.»E:'::§.::;:";<:@_ 1*'et:S}:>;<%'::§._i:?2%E}r 23:; {E16 222:6 sf ?2;Q€}G/~ mad 3 5&3/--

" _ E' §3i}i.}1§T£'i"j§":L " E'~I{":z.§E.3 <2»? 29% ééé fiisiii E12}? .P€:~:'§'.:T'i;§<:»m;=,§* Nsmgi 2%? fiisl?' s»a:":'":.€~: {:§"§.§¥'§§S%iff'§i},8§j'2§§? :'~;<;=:é;%ki:";.;,: §"a.:;°§:E":é::~:"

£311212:r3(:ez2':e=:m. £22 rim ma.iz1i'<;%1":a:1<é{% 2?g§"§}.{}Li§'1§S pa}g'abI<:% :0 {harm by 'iilhiif :'@s;;>{>§::{§€*:1L 3, '§'§2{>1:g§h €.hzé5;:> iW<f: rz:s.ri5_'s:i<31":sa 212%? E13166 £"<:>§ié3§«-' .fGr 21<.imi55$:{>.:1, hziving :€:g21.:*d E0 E1121? zzziiure 05 the _ {Ewe}: E.E';;e {3()F}"°"€Cf,§"l{3i-:"$-ES {sf *a:hie:?:%f: 1.9; <::%E'13.E%enged.-..§§;3{'f2,'{.h&s,§% £*€3ViS3i£}I'iS. iihtsry are i:akr3:'1 for final :i.i5pQsz1.-iia§1(i'=.;irg§"£:'m€af:i_s'xzgyf Sri. R, S. Sic§hap'u_:."§.»:2::1 Ieearned {:0i1;3_s3ei f{)<;.t}:£: xx-*:f":é' :§:'1:<i_;r1me:>:' -. L axhiici and Sri. Lxfyaqat Fafaed iéégzxéjffzd fi§i?{§'L1f1S€§ §°€pre:s;enf;,::1§§ "Else §'€:§«;p€}r§d€:":1t1-« ;RE5'jF€; 2m 1 zamii the p:5~E.i%;:§::}.:1e:' in RPFC Nsfiréfi 0f'2{Z? ,?i}§. V " "

4' E;:*.ar:'2€{% <f{§;f::';"2.§»§£3=§. .p€ii'?;'i{}{1€E' in RPFC N{>,5:-£2 of 201%, mm is §v::;S§:§21:';:§ €}.§:V'vR§TSE3(}2'1€§€3f1E, N0. E arid faéhe;/* <35 §::§:;{;_;" §%_€>Ls§%:§3:j:;jf§{§r:§_:1"£: A.A?$':';:.;".'?.1;'..,;..<s§:..2'{3miEs; thzat 'ihimgh i.h_<;*; :'~§5:§€§ revigé-;1;:§::.. £9f§E:;:<;§;"z;«;f1~§ai>::?s3§'aE g:*::2:z3cE:§, 3'26 f'{':S§',I'iCES {E18 SEEHEEE imiy E1563 g§;.§*;§':;'.:.:2{§ '::'I€'.:»;g:'§__';'7é':2;§ss::a§:;z'E3.£§:% :3g3p{}:"i:1:::§i:y 329213 :'1<>'§: §§§§i'{'?§E '{1} ';°;::v§.s.§e:;§':~ v§§$ti::;'i}I:1s:* Eli} ziiiiizsatez €fi?'i€§€;?§1{f€f {H} §Ei:% bs3hz?:§§' "{._\,V'V%V7.'I§};t'§%,'4{2.*'f'fV7;3i:§~§:'1' §;}s?§:i£'i:';:': E"%2.;2.i: E£J§;%;E:% §E.§:§:{§ 'arty £135 '$3j§ft';f £i.§'§{§ :§':;a;§--..:;§;E:.%::;=:§1 €f§'§.E'EE'§;E"§{'i'€?f'§"f3i?§'"§'§i Em §;E3<3 m£:.2?:1§',::%:?::3.::{f:{:--:, 27:%£-7£Ti,'E'{§§€;':'{§ Lil in t'.E"1.€%i1' fax-*<:1.zr in €i:'E.Mi:~§.;::t.?.\§<>.55 <3? 2085. He furfi";€:r :?.::mi:e::1ds~3 i;ha"i. ::-:;i:m:::--:- Z"€?EiS£}}f1éi§3E{i'; €,3pp::3:":' z,.1:_1it.y E1255 not: 'i'::€:':€n giarééiz is this :'e;'-:x:%.:e;::}:": p€'f'§iifi§i'}'I}€§' is 22d{7Eu<7.e evidaxxie 02': his; b:%§:g£f_,7§:%1s3 r:r121.i.':.€rr f°v"3€§j.ii§"€E?5 {:0 be 'r€:nE§;i.ed ti} ihg Fzinzilfg <'3e;>';:3'*éi"§2i3::_"

{§§$§}{)S(:i§ in £§i'Tf§3*(}3'd:£iI1£L?€:": witih Law, ai"t:e3;r §§§vi:a:g-*:3;g3§§§;¢::*'ifi'.:.i1ity gifi gm; :'€1.,:isi():'1 pe:'£':itis:>':':e:§' {<3 21.£§t:i;I.:z(:<;"% t:é:\;i~ci€%.:";.gt:::{:-"<§;§é' E153'be9E:z11f7f-.,__ : A

5. Per Ce:m'i:r21. Sr: R. S;.,__4'Si;dh21§L.i;"ka;flx_i:§:.§é"'§éaai§*fiefi"

<:<>m;1-:~sé3:1 repreaéznting 92:3 vssife. anal" :7dji.r1é*:i da1:g;§?z':»i;e1::;' sf,';:':)Hg13:
€i<::::€;.ez:d$ iha'i. €i€Spfi€;'i .22,-*2:iiVi§_:g 'L:%£iE£i::*:ié:';{».v.€3;::n;3£}1"':.:1z:i%;}z the :*<:~.x»-'§:«;§«:>:': p<:¢;'.ii:i:3:1€'r_ E :1 : §;%P_E'C§;N<}_,? Sfeéz E G 3"<§5«par1:i€nt'. %3t3;fi}r€- the E'amiEy ?:,_"<>m'--"£:} {§'£yi--«~;:_;4{3'£ :t':'::e_{§z::.sg£: ':0 €tC1{§1i{E€f 21:1}? «:=.vi&t3:2<:<% 2:325}; £:h€:r{éf0re, 'ac: '*<§§}€+$ ":'":i,?éi'. e"3;e;%%%;'2:;é:°¥Je 2111}? {}p§3G§""{iLiI1i"i.}' H} isgid éfvgéifiéiiiééj ._§: V
--. _ 2: pe%r:2.3€r:§ t.E':::é =i)Zfi§§i§':--::fi 'ré3:<:{3r{iS in {,>%)é;2-2;i:':$<§ i?:f:;=::z': {Em E'a.m§E'j;; C<;2,:ri, "E'E:€ §é1<;;'§:5 wi"::é:§'; %1:si;;:2'§;:£ be :'m%:',i<"t€;t»{i zfmrzz fizrzgfi {:n:'{§€:z* gheééitsss. in 'i:I%_:{*: 5:-mid iii.
6 Iifivéiiexaitii of PW.i3 am behalf {sf §}%?-?fifi()E1{£tI'E-S iiizamirx c3.r1.":e:% in ':36 re€:::2r<:Ee:<:i an G3,C':2.2>O{)§ éifid t:if1ai; €.§1e?
E1.02.2GG§ for re<:cm:ii:'1§; =m:§d€m:a% an b€,~':":f.g::..EV§5"~-.a_'"._ emf this I'f3:?3p{§ZTi{i°&%.1'}.'{.. On {that <:i21%x3 {Ef {he respa:1€%é:::1E. emit} big €.".(}'tEI1f-f's€iE were anii %:%::%€:%ib:°s%. E4125: F21n1i1yv.C'<32.«:.ri £¥_4§0:'-§}.{}:'%:iT {':'Vi€I€ff§{',-3 fez' ms resp(>11def}i: 2."«._»i:"1a:§:' z{€1j§:r*u:}9r1e3'iiV {ha case: :23"; I?,€I2.j?;£C}.G9 f{}Ifv.fE€E3.Fi§?;'§§'V.V;€:l§1:€.3 a2'gume::t:s 8:": {ha n1air:"p§;%1;it,ii>r:. .
Gm E"£7.0252OO9;----. }*h€é ré;s§;5<;.§1j<i;%§'nt: iherem {fled EA N0,3 'j1§§e:~n';.;_s's§';;n_f; of the F'21.mi§.y _{i'::::,:§%. for ae;fl§i:'§;::_a:.i.;ji'g 'aigidézmite on his-s " Came :10 bfi' 2§Ix?:--<}*;%;€;%e:iV '<:¥»:f3;§v:%1'«_;<f_'i::,,f,{::d 21$ "E2039 gmd ?;h€ §"€;%S§{}"--If§{§<3?3{i ._ £i§1£5zzr:;ff;:: W325: pawmitiesi Est) 2:~s:?£::§u<:::: é'-;éa=*§_{§;é%:1{:<: an Ezig bz:éha.Z.§ zmd tbs: {tame 1?s,,§%;%é}s--; §isc;§§_;:.::*.{i 233 2:53: LZQQQ {<3}? ;*€%:<gps:;2:3d€r::"f:.';<; V ' Ts€*§§*'§sfVi{r::":A{.'v€:.'' '_.
§i.__v'{te3:zf;'E{i bs': SE:€?f§.'} §'m"%:E:{%:' an éthai. {'i$;'i?,{'f an #§V.:.§;}:_:'§.§":§:>;§ ms: :*:%s:~;§<}:3§§€::€. aiiarsagzieti :23: 'i<:a:5s;,<§ his; "'~«.é*::;:'i_d<%:1{7€:, 'E'he:°€%§'"§.}:*:";*:, it ztzamaz in §}{:':. a{§j{mm.::":£§ A :19 $8. E21.2;§{%§,, 9:"; zz:§1§£:itE": s;i;§;:¢1. '£133: §'€;?§§§{}EE{'§{EE'2§'. ,2-:m£§ :3s«:;a~:%:§ m:%:'£? 23%.}: §3':"€:s&:-mi; .::.:_:'2::§ (f£iE%§€f§ <iéa.m::% :10 be p{>s;i:€tc:£ iii} m-*ic§a%;1{?:;? an b<%E22:1éf0f°i;41"xe :*e$pe:m:i:=,m. {',Ei.§'§"ifi iii} bi'. iiififfifid.
:2: {En E{}.'i2.2GGE~3 {E29 resspazzdezzi. fi§€{§ emf'---
a1ppii<:':a"E;2'a:;:'1 Elsi' §3<:':°:niss:§;<>:2 ti'; a<idL:§:5é3 ".

€'*V§dE::"£C€',. Tbs: ieazrrled. »jud%g€ 0f the 'V' C<3u.r'=T: :"é3€€:§v€:d this $ame3 a1::zd {E3153 ':0 :ZI.E2,2009 for <:{)1§'sicib:§fA:'i;j;githg. appéiitaticm. {}.'§" far arg§Lzm{§i%_1§é"--_§§f' 'vf".I?1.€-if asides on €f}.fi1""i'EZE§.

in an 2:.§2.2a@§'~..;.he .~:%ésg,:sc;ndem. a:*:&"§?1iS <t0'Lm3E:§ Ygv€':E"€i' zzéizi. Th;'::§ E€E3;:'H€'& <:{>u:1s»3e§ £70: iihfi"'g3étiii':3;fi~as;:"s§ fikvfi' writéerz 2ja:'ig'i1rz1V:¢'f:ii;tss:': :39: ';Xf§§~?,; §§1er:'fé§""* "bf the Eeamszd <;§:3'uz-'1S<;:§ v§;i{:~:5':':if::e.,1f&%:s§£:nai€:3i4 came {5} be mkstn 2153;' 'é';'%5:g:::'€E.'"-- the F'am2iiy C<}'L2z"{ p:2;_sse§:§ "§';§'3%;*: §§:I'):§i;E§§}§1€:':{§_ Eflfiifii" eiiaié-id ::°3:§,1Z.x2GG§"*;2¢§if1?2<}1:€, §1&%211*'§:":g_2; ihe argzimemis €i3§_§'}"E€é~E€'§£i7Ef'7EE.€3€i :::{::un:~s;&E fliyr '§.%.1€-: re§:ap:3r:de'r:':'..

"Ff %5':f::>.:§:*'é1§*2:€a zzbzéve fa<;ti:& ii; £5 ztiear €;E:2;: iééazrzziézi ' " "-1{;:»;:«a§:':-».§s%E §'%f;.:' ::'a--3::s;3:mdani'. ':3a'-é§E§:'é§:% '§Z}E€';? Fganiiiy Caazrt. iiiié 329?':
"*Vs._:E::::';:':?:;:§% .._€:;j:3 §°:%;§§*<:3:%;§:::'.1*£:: i:§§:3 E"€S§}{}§§E{§€f§.1SEi. £:};§§;i§ is} sssazbzzziaéi: 3573::-3 . Z§§f§:;Ei_§}'§_§§§'.1€2.55; =33: an 2z_;3';_3E22.s:s.2::é'..§{3§1 §_%;:s§f _§_3<:-m"2.i§;§;.§a:2§:'; €153: é?§{§€§?;.E{Ti€:"? .r""'""»-~w~,.w..
sz:"~>~-- 'I €';'3'Ji(T§€1":{","f;'": arm 211% an the mafia ;3€:ti:;§m'L Thiir rn22.§m':»:%:221n<:e3 itzmm ix} be €EFih.21I":{:~:'3'd f:*'<:zr:: ?.'E.§3{30/~ H) ?2;GOGj-- pm' E"E1(31"1.'é'ET; in {EEK-"€'.}L'£E' :3? P'aéi:§£'i<m.i=::' §'{f€.:uE--wif7::-? 213:1 f§'€}I'£'1 ?L.C3GG,/~ in %ii,1i§:.§QO/~ ;:>é:?:' msmth in favémr Qf Pe€,ii:i:3:2e;° N:,:.2§ the mi:z<::""'ci.:?;mg'I:i-5:5. and E:_E:::;% said a11".:ozmi:,2; am or'd<>:r€:::i is be: §3e1.id fez..€:.'§i'<:i:i1=.§}3r_ zhé yrisperzderiti fi.'{)I§'i the daiie Gf iihffiii" pet:ii2,,i_{>n:.f0:i€:3}V£3.:;*1:::<5'x'1<i::1j1§..52?' :::121i:1E€3§1;a1:1<7€. This; C(}S€.S €T:{)1'1$i.(.'§f<'3fI'E1~E;):1.§'3V_ "§m;:"€:é::';._§3:1 2141:: _ r€sp<>nder1.i:.
'£'here:f"{m;: 3 am 'é}'3f' '§§;§.'}'€._ ;%:§piz1'i:1z:'1.. ':i£3at. théé arzciis-3* Bf s»-.f§é"5i. «~5_ _ »_ V ju55'E.i.C{;': <22-'011Ed be 1n'é::%%.,_ii" the 'r<2§s;3fi{>;:":_:"i.:§:m- ';}§¥f£>re: ihe' F':,:1m.fly C{)E.'i3T"i. is; givézfxé 3:": féé}:§§%:1;;?*{:1V:':':'§vf?;.3§-IQ -aiiicéaxéie ésviaiemre in s."~au.ppe:}ri;. {sf ihes, ::::)m§:11E,§:2:§;:s-* '§Z;':§;§;fi'37E1:"'ifI1E.- §:?:"i)j<:c€.i9rz5; '£53 %':,h€ p<3€§€.£{}r1 :fi.E<2d '£333 Eéfzzis ;r;_%;*si'.£<;.§<3:1e:" :;.:..;1de:~ v§€€?{1§{}§1 12? G5 C1".P,{i. :a:ss;%:s}e::£:1g §?Ei:'£&1I1{3€??§1i&'.E§{T, é:';--.';h~s? 2::im1g3€::*:sai'£<}§:, Sézzcéz {E162 r::a.'?zi§€:§" :°equi§°e$ €151: '$6: '-;'ii'1T§'2§'§.;§.€t<'i§"-ii}: ELhf;': 'E'a§:.":i§_j; C{>u:*i. :E<::r <?<>21Sié:ér§ng§ "Ska? '7[._2:§3§:§.§<:aE,E{}é"2. {:5 §}éé%,i%.i€3§3:;é§"'s; €;%1z:*:=z°e£§: :E<:x2" €§§§}E2;§1€¥.';*:§Z2§3E1§'. 5}? {he ,j w:fséj2§§.:1ia2%:'::s;:j;:;"réi:Q RPFC Na:>:§i.;"§ {éf ?;€}H fi§.<s3<i 'aj; %,h{:=:m setssiééizigg'
-§z_.:2*%..E=:::i~%g iI"3E'E.E'E2if"§{fT%:E§E§?i?§"f;§j E2': i:h:7: §m';§§2'{.§s2:.2;:':{:§--;% <3*=s@:" 2-ii'1{§ £§§}{}E?€§ 9 ?*29{)€}€%;'w :;211":.»:i ?1.?3Qii};'-- per rr1<):'1i.§1 as; e:t'I2}":2iI":{?.€:ci by t:§'§<*=. F:»'.2m.§Ej; Cam Z"€;ff£§TE€€?§ii'%£€§'}' 31:3 fz1vo:.1:' of P§=:'aé'{.i<32%1_é_~":r E'\Ec>s~:q§ and 2 ::i0<;=:s mg)!' $"%..i'F'§?'§'V€' far <;.7<):2$id€:r21?£.§<>:':. The E'2a::1i1jy' {.T<,>uz"i; aha}: E§.Ef%.'é;'i*, §,€:'E;',§"£'fw det:<:>r'mi.:1€ 331$: :I1.24;.iz1%i:e:'321§1c:§ }:2a1v'iI1g :'e;g;:«3.:'d is all; i:E1.§%"§2:{?:V:;5§__é§:}_;:§2 ::ir{:z.zm$i.21:'1.::@$ and in {fizz Eight': «:3? £1116 €;T&'iC};€i"}(f£3----ii.}ffé1.7;i' 'aizay bégzé' ;e1e:i€iu:te:ci by the :'e$p::t>mieI1{' i:he1*eiz14 Hf;'§I}€f€~,,{.35162§~€i§E7i{"}V's2'fi.I:i§g};Z.__ coMMo2g_g:§%1m§:1;§"

i. "ffhe impmgnézd :.2dgm§:.z3V{.A"v Q1."'<:'i'1'.=-:1'*.v'A;<i+'cf;.1";:5<";>.d 3 1 .3 12.2009 ;:;{_ cg;*:.:ig;§;Ng§§sg/209?' by the }.i"ff:fi'}'1€:(i Efi)§§;V'_:'r:£e::E'. §§1,2?;1g§'e:%';~. E':a§§:1;_§E:v C{Zi"ii'F€'... Gu§be1.:°g§.2a"i$ hx;ér€2_by; 8.6%. 21;~§i'd.€_ The ma.i'."i:<=:r §§é§,}iéiE}? Court '%'s3i'%'h £1 d§7;:<%{%*;§{;:':.. $3. oppormmty 110 the r{%ss§'<;«:::V1C1<3:":iV,' f;:EV1A::_§f%:~*.:§;.";:::i{L"E;<*; azkiucez his; §?V'i€i€3fi_€:EE, .E:{€3'i3i;*3§{}'E"iE-2:Eis1§..€f;EV: %;>;>}§s;:'r€,:1z1i{jg shaii 3&5-<; be ggfiwzrz .1E.<i:i f:;h§:~.;;a%%,£i.i:%é'{érs Eh:-:é:"ei:2 E10 zzséiiuétai §UI'fi'}€;'%f' j;.§ a:";;g5 "E'h:-3 Fzzzxléifg Cf_".§'L§E'"'E', §9.%1aE§ 'z"§%~ "' <i9ié:§5:*::§.§:e Iihéié :a.r:::::m:1€, <3? ::1ai:"2*:.€:1a::{:<:2 :0 be ' §:%:':h2i:?:<?:{;?::i in :£"m:*{>z.:r 8§;3s;%é;i€.i§2:1:*:r5 %i.E'1:;%r€:§:'§, '§'he a,m<m:'.:€i, d€;%p{}:ie.3?3;.é:%{§ bf; {E36 §@v;1s3':::2::

_§}F.;':§i§?;'Z§€I}§"§:E3E' €22 REEFC ?%E<:§,:'§%?; af Eéffiflé "\ §§"€::§§3i:s§':éé:;::é. E';<*:$Z?zs2"€: '::§::.§3 F:::.§'§:_§_E3; i;,{}s,::":§ f+"é§'E2:%§E iii, E C?
be acij:..2$£:€:d f:<}a»=va:'e:§,s~3 Ehe arrs;:*;»1r.s sf Z?'IEi,iI"§i§3§EEiI1{fé'f a.r:<i 3.180 futurc<3 mai:1§.m'1zm{:<3, ggafgzzbkf by him :0 FEES wife and his; :":1i:1<:+;j aizzughfer in t=:%rm-S 1:}? ihézé E31121} ardevg"
gagged by the §<'ami_§§r {Zr:>u:*¥:; af':'er c0n$icier'§_:f§gi'_L' "

the €nié;:*€: rI12r'£:s3riaI 0:": re{:::>:'d inCiL:d'i'I§g .f{;1*3.:é €V.i€§€i'1{',€ 91" {.133 I'€E?§§3€}E}.dé;?1'E? »*:@-I_:§«€ a'dd{:'tf@':E hims '"E'he ;f<<3$p:>§1de§1i b€.%£§;7_3t£r- th€~:A"~4F='fa;"s*:_iif,=..V <'f:fT.__;:§1:V:%i shaii go an €i€rp()si%.ing %.ia:'.§f£'.}7.2.V:h:-3 'Saki '{§<:{i§1rt, {>11 er bf3f{}I"€f 5%-?i1i_z'1?';:2,_*gI :>_§'e%ef§§:E:..._E:1§;?i:sh. Caiefzdar msmth, pegiding : {ii§p«5:~3':1E nthe main p€'E;:i'§EiO2i.'£§ ' 3 ' :e:__um :t:i5 _ V:.<.:$v:::ri:is m:on'i',h1y ,:f:1a£zé'f&:1:3.r1<:€§< <>f.4b'9t}h. §)m';.i1:i{>ners tagathez' araci ii}??? ' ;3aVm.€§ '«.:s§%13;E§._.§1~§s{;:. be aéijtisted i;.£:=ward$ fziifgréi z1z'ré::1:*:*§. :3?" §32.;_:.§';1€€nan£:s: and §I1.2:1?§::€:€a1z:{ti€. in '{".€*,§'§"§}f§ 0f the f§§'EEi§ Gram" is be p3;é':2%%éd.& E1": §§':eE: E-Eéiiéi {'i£,iE:"5-Q 'Ea' {<;_e»3.**_;di:-."=:é"'é:~:.<:; U} {%a::2::%»;%;=5; in %:><:§%;E3 i,%zi:s$ §"€'€;"§~E;-'si€}§"B.$. Ei{._j<f;'{.E:,«--:*e:<;§5s.i€;:*: p€3i'§"i:i<3§:S Sijgazzd {iisggegéaai sf fig':

§::_;?% &E§3{}'%f%;",' E{%'E"§ZES., ?,.,%.:""*=«»»»»»w«~T S2'?
E} {3'§'§gi2"iE1§ (35 E13115 {>I"£i§i:' Shalfi E326 pkxcéfi in RPFC M0542 {sf 2818 and a <:<;py 'fthereaf Iii": RPRC N<:r.5£3 {:5 2011. Reflards sshaik bfi rei::.::T2e=:<i__ {:9 {ha Fzzmiigr C<}m'E: Earth with alangf w§i:.I'f;_ <%(_>pjg 0%' 'i:}':3Z$ é.}§{ie:%:'. Siam ilhii? pa.rti€:$ "
Ei§}p€§EiI" §>{%§}:":r€ {has F-'zznéiiy Cezmri. wi,ih<j;-"=3; éiP;§£' ' fm"i:,h€r E1éC}'{;§{?€:? am 3€}.(33.20I.lA.~ mi: % W % ,. < 4,: ' M .' .- V «' R}