Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

- Know your Kanoon - Doc Gen Hub - Counter Argument - Case Predict AI - Talk with IK Doc - ...
Upgrade to Premium
[Cites 1, Cited by 0]

Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai

Naval Kishore Gupta And Others vs M/O Textiles on 21 December, 2022

CENTS AL ADMINI STRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
MUSTRAT BEN ii, MEUM SAY,
Original Annlication Noa, : aS (S016

Dated this Monday, the gi day of December, aqss,

Hon'ble Shri. Justice MG, Sewlikar, Member (9
Ston'ble Dr, Bhacwan Sahai, Member CA}

(1) NAVAL KISHORE GUPTA,

{san of Jageshwar Prasad Gupta) Date of Birth: 20.06.1971, Age
-44 yrs, Grrionths, working a § Deputy Director (NT) (Group °4"
Post) under Office of Textile Commissionor, New CGO
Building,48 , New Marine Lines, Nistha bhavan , Vitthaldes
Thakashi marg, Mumbai 400020, and residing at : 601, 6th Floor,
NC-2 Navchetana Building, bcmiee Sector-3 , Kane Nagar, CGS
Colony, Antop HIN, Murnba , State Maharashtra, Pin Code :
400037.

(2) PRANAV PARASHAR

ison of Late Ramansnd Prasad Sinha}, Date of
25.12.1965 , Age 50 yrs , wor king as Assistant Director Grade-!
iGroug nm "ones in Regional Office of Texts Cornmissi:

_ Office of Textitle Carnmissionar Co 'porate Block, RMG Co STIOhEN,
Pardeshipura, Indore - sz and residing et : House No.O?
Ground Floor, CPWO, Colony, Officers Residentis

MADS NYAS PRSDESH-8S3 OO4,

Hs

PRA aye dk Pax Tee Mi
page ~st ss ¥
{ay GQYYTa Sayan §



ie)

~ WE eO fags
OA, No. 58/2006

(daughter of Yashwant Anant Lagu}, Date of Birth 227.05 1983,
Age-52 yrs, 7 manths, working as: Assistant {Group "B" Post) in
CMfice of Textile Cammissioner, New CGO Sullding, 48 | New
Nishta Bhavan, Vitthaldas Thakarsi Mars
Murnibal 400020 and residing at : A-S/501 CHS Ltd, JE Gram
Post Office, District : Thane, State of Maharashtra &Obgos,

Ne

(4) Prasad Prabhakar Pati]

4
\of$

{son of Prabhakar G. Pati), Date of Birth: 10.01.1962, Age-54 yrs,
working asAssistant (Group "B" Post} in Office offextile

Commissioner, New GO Bullding,48, New Marine Lines, Nishtha

Bhavan, Vitthaldas Thakars! Marg, Mumbal 400020and residing
at: 5-303, 3rd FloorChandranagar CHS itd. LBS Marg,
OppDreams Mall, Bhandup (West), Mumbal400078, State of

Maharashtra,
3) Mrs. Priyanka Hemant Sawant,

(wife of Mr. Hemant Bhikali Sawant) Date of Birth 519.908.1986,
Age -43 yrs, working asAssistant, (Group "C" Fost) under Office
af Textile Commissioner, New GO Bullding. 48, New Marine
Lines, Nishtha Bhavan Vitthaldas

AO0020,and residing at: Flax No.6, Znd Floor

ae} '

Mnakers! Marg, Mumbai

MulundChitralekha

ATR my S i RArdeomed flees BAL, at
Mithagar Road, Mulund (Fest), Mumbai

(6) Mes. Malpana Pradeep Patil,

e Pad Loy bw Tin ve f he a a eS oA Peet Poko %
wwite oF Mir Pradeep 0. Path) Date of Birth 14.99 1862, Age -53
paige - hy wn bey a ee tee weds FO Ma3 Riss J ey gn nates
yrs, 4 months working as Assistant, (Grou "8" Post} under Office
£ Teytiia fx t eae ~ POPS Shae = 3 Asset
oF Textile Commissioner, New GO Buncing, $5, New Marine

i lene febns Na] ee 4 § Flaw oy bad on Tha Lee y Ass Rx bye} :
wings, Nishtna Shavan, Vitthaidas Thakars! Mare. Mumbai



ha

(7} Mrs. Sulata Dhananfay Jadhav,

(wie oof | Shri Onananjay Sabali Jadhav} Dete of
RSirth :08,06.1965, Age -SO yrs, 7? months, working as Assistant
(Group'8"Post) under Office of Textile Co ommissioner New CGO
Bulging, 48, New Marine Lines,Nishtha Bhavan, Vitthaldas
Thakarsi Marg,Mumbal 400020, and r esiding at: " and
Floor, RNA Hills, Malpa Dongrl No.3, Andheri{& i
§O0083, Stat te Maharashtra, Pin Code ; 400 098.

'a ¢
ee
ra
Ce
oy

(8) Mudalier Kartikeyan Arunachalam

(A. Arunachslarn) Dete of Birth -17.22.1973 Age -Al yrs 11
Months, working as (UDC) Upper Division Clerk, (Group "Cc"
Post} under Office of Textile Comrn! issioner, Government of
india, Ministry of Textiles, Nishta Bhavan, 48-New Marine Lines,
Mumbai 490020, and residing at - 4-201, 24 Floor, Lodha Park,
Village-Sandap, PostManpada, Taluka- "Kalyan, District- Thane,
State Maharashtra, Pin Code-424 204.

(9) Ravindra Sitaram Durgawall,

e tararn Ratnaji Durgawall) Date of Birth:09.01.1972.Age-43 yrs

i Months, working as (UDC) Upper Division Cle rk {Group "C
Post) under Office of Textile Commissioner, Government of
india, Ministry of Textiles, Nishta Bhavan,48 Ne Ww Marine Lines,
Murodal 400020, and residing at : T-B/Spl., Flat No.268, Badge

NO.24, 15 Floor, CGS Colony, LBS Marg, whathene (Wast
tate

Murnbal 400086, State Maharashtra.

(10) Shrawankumar Narsagga Khads

aye

Moet tT? ee
renthe Corruvissio



Be

india Ministry of Texth es, Nishta Bhavan, New Marine Lines
Mumbal "00008 and residing at: House No.i917/3, Nave Par
Road, Dosti Colony, Near Sankeshwar Grain Centre, Ambernath
(West), Taluka-Amber nath, DistriesThane, State Maharashtra

Pin Code - 427 505,

"

.

(11) Anant Babafi Kapale

{Babali Gosal Xk aoaie) Date of Birth:03..05,
Months, working as (UOC) Up
under Office of Textile Commissioner,
Ministry of Textiles, Nishts ni
400020, and residing at : Flat t Nog,
sewrl, TL. Road, Mumbai 400015, Meharashtra,

CG
CS
cB
er
z
if
Oo
Q
ay ey

{12} Mrs. Neha Sumant Khavile,

{son of Mr Sumant Radhakrishne Khavie} Date of
Birth :30.05.1973, Age -42 yrs, months, working as Upper
Division Clerk (Group "Cc" Post} under Office of Textile
Commissioner, New CG Bull iding, 48, New Marine Lines, Nishtha
Bhavan, Vitthaldas Nie Marg, Mumbal 400020, and
residing at : 42, 8-304, 3RD Floor, Nehru Negar, Kurla {East},
Mumbal State vvahoracers Fin Code : 400 024.

patden, ra

(13) Surekha Shashikant Ramugade,

ison of Shashikant 8h} Ku Ramugads)}, Dete of Birth 16.06.1971,
Age-44 yrs, Grnanths, working as Usper Division Clerk (Grous
fC" Post} under Office of Textile Cammissioner, New Go

S33 edie es tT Dis - elke Baa oy ~
Bullding, 48, New Marins Lines, Nisntha Bhavan. vitthaldas



Leste,

mr fs
j ff 2

ist

DA. No. 58/s018
(14) Shakuntala Subhash Safian
Wife of Subhe ash Salla nl Date of Birth: OF 03.1956, Ape -59 yrs 7
Fy? Hy

under Regional rextile Commissioner in the office of Regional
Yexthe Commissioner, Kendriya Sadan, 5t* Foor, sector-10,
Ninmala Devi Marg, CBD Belsour, Navi Mumbai

siding at : Flat No.4, 2nd Floor Shubha Laxmi OHS, PR?
Bui ve ing, Rabod! Koliwada, Thane {West}, Maharashtra, Pin
Code 400601.

ry

(15) Smt. Mangala NMiadhay Warkhandker,

(w/o fate Madhav  Eknath Werkhanckar}, Oate of
Birth:01 10.1957, Age -58 yrs, working as {UDC} Upper Division
Clerk, (Group "C" Past) under Textile Commissioner, in the office
of Textile CommissionerNew CG Bullding, 48, New Marine
Lines, Mumbai 400020, and residing at: Flat No.93, 4° Floor,
Sanjivan Society, Ganesh Nagar, Lalbaug, Mumbai, State of
Maharashtra, Pin Code -400012.

(1$} Deepali Dilip Datar,

wife of Dilip Dattetray Datar) Date of Birth :18.07.4957, Age -

§
\ }

38, working as(JDC} Upper Division Clerk, (Group "C" Post}

under Regional Textile Cornmmissioner, in the office of Regional
Office of the Textile Commissioner, Kendriya Sadan, Sv Floor,
m10, Nirmais Devi Marg, CBD Selanur Nav Mumbe 31 408
esiding at : Flat No.55, SS3 Type, Sector No.3, Near

SAE ee VEE} face aye coy Sam § = la ay had
CIDCO Office, Vashi, New Mumbai. State of Maharashtra, p

gaat
ts
"3
oh.
ot



58/ao18

aan
ANG,

A
he

as

¢
'.

=} Date of B
n
i

nd "C5 smell ef ny, a" mos Se tee ay cs et ny
seed péossie C ac bey LY vs rb Sha 5 tet
Ge 2 Zs $@ 38S g is Be x 3 g
oO O © bh 7 O -- 6 om we Fo Ee eg ab i
os Ze be Go Ch Se ee m. Ty G Be a
bx a FF ee Petey a ID me a Sh ee tg oe OE wrod
rn rn, "ee. D8 Sw se FB SS us oxy ;
Rud oye pepe "A Fy sh ET AS '. 6 2 7 an,
sO pe Se oe goo be ° "
ee Ee f° yi x ria Paarl oe.
2S Gy Pm py O ig a oe a oe
2 im ff mH Pe wy OB & i 4 2 oe any i SS
A cm a G@ OB Oo a Gort Tow Of 4 v4 So fon
Oe OS a a rn | jm (J 2 6 4K SS x " Mine Soe
2G SS 28 Pe Br m Om ew x . 2
» $2 AP ty whe DB SF a De be oO fe 4 et
ie Sn, ca o tp oe ~ OS fee eee 6 rg i '
fee Acree es en ee a i ne 4 as
28s 2 BY co'@ f > oe & a) Go . ., 8 OG ' wo Be
oe ah yt 35 C1 s "Fo 3 iv) ers oe 2 nm ce BE a KG
poe ma cans.) os Oh, ae O te mp ma Pm
od a 4 i 2 2 ny eek x seme Se * son fe ote
O BS ao Me ee ~ mo be 44 ve ,
brews W fest oe % t bean rad a ad no Ione: 4 -- ¢ iad G
Bg a 5 © 6 w o ssc a en oS ere
Scene > SE O os Gt Ob ow Eom 4 tN a o
2 OB eB a © 6 & = ; 5 OM on
Ce we £2 US Bs aan ao om et ew
oe % 'z " C Bed By B
@® woe
ped <
ed
aa) TOE
cS
ts
cy
cst
[2
©

¥
Agra Road, Lal Chowky, District : Thay '€,, State Maharashtra, Pin

re
See
o
tA
&
2
Se ut
Rd >
Z a
wi
fe bee
. ; RTS prmee a vere « i 5
$e ry bog oO em < a hs B "J es a
5 BOS 7 8 Se 8B ee Pe os Se F B
iy <-- 3 Ext we , 7 i f " = wo cy S 5 4, i
if at whe, es aa ij i sy w = nn as a ce FO oy wm Pe
peanee Os Jem OF we ty Sen int Sy ies m m on rei cer)
as) a Se ea GS , a 6 & & nn ane
% iy be & sy £4 5 Ross ; . a 6 ee pe "af
mma} a} - Oo sa a Ee 2) 'ss aw ag O & & 3 we wt
Wa gee gee ke Fed i: ns cy 3 re 9 fF GO a + OS :
Vis 3 8S & £ Beak » = B e Se cw Bo. be & oe
bn G "Be ee TR Exe cp 8 Ne gy oe OE . a ore ee ead am <5 CR are *ee wh am G
: CR Fi 4 © © ot Q O Gm £ Tt a an
be 4 23 a 7 +, soem bg ; wT ny Q em A ah [on SS ie
y z onl eS: ord boo freee 3 Gt A ii oS pan > a Se en ye es mg 7 on £05
Coe oe oO ee © £ 1 = 2 ee CG a Ee we wb ret G Ss
eg wa it SG = SS iW + ay OES
S35 2 i 5 & 2 he 5 3 6 a 8 £S2€f2 4, & ts
Ba "a " 6 = Om la a ye ag o
ye @ £€ EE ££ BES w#SG E+ BB SES FB > os 'S 'e
a SE ae gy wo ~ @ J of @ 1) OS mm ZS ghar & #£ . fe
tog # & BB or OS os a = @ ae wot c 8 Sen e wore 2B ~ fe
we Pa & BP A Ss F € BE g Oo ff Oo 2 Og GS 'S #7,
ty mB Se Oe PF Senet ce Os a Oe A us att ate LOY OPS ae Lb, he Moe ie wm on th

AS ge,


and residing at ; 8-205, 2nd Floor, Narhar Shuven, Tlak Chowk,
Kalyan, District 'Thang, State Maharashtra. Pin Code- 424301.

(21) Mrs. /Sent. Anisha Sanjay Nawani,

(wife oof Shri Sanjay Jamnedas Nawanl) ODete of
Birth 15.08.1872, Age -43 yrs, 3 months, working as Unser

(IDC), iGroup "¢ "C" Post) under Office of Textile
Commissioner, New GO Bul ding, 48, New Marine Lines, Nishtha
Ehavan, Vitthaidas Thakars! Marg, Mumbal 400020, and
residing at: D-11,402, 4% Figor, Mohan Puram Hous sing Camplex,
Near Gautam Jatale Hospital, Ambarmnath, District : Thane, State
Manarashtra, Pin Code : 424 501.

(22) Smit. Sreekals Ravindran,

(wife of Shri Ravindran K.) Date of Birth 01.16. 1968. Age -47
years 2 months, working as Upper Division Clerk (UDC), (Group
"C™ Post) under Office of Textile Commi issioner, New CG
Bullding, 48, New Marine Lines, Nishtha Bhavan, Vitthaldas
Thakarsi Marg, Mumbai 400020, and residing at : Flat No.A-102,

ist Floor, Sarvoday Srusht} Building No.2, Nandivall Road, Sunil
Nagar, Dombivall (East), District Thane, State Maharashtra, Fin
Code : 424 201. |

{23} Mrs. oamidhea Sandesh Jadhav,

(wife of Sandesh Padmakar a Date of Birth :
. Age ~80 yrs, months, warkin

[Group "C" Post} under Office

, 48, New Marine Un



(24) Smt. Nemilata Sautam Mandviker,

le
oe

ay,

ah ° oe yk Qieeh cae ¢ aioe ae

| iwife of Shri Gautam po. Mandvikar) Date of Sirth :24.04.1969 Age -dé yrs,
md & months, working as spper b Division Clerk (UBC), (Group "C* Past} under

av Marine Lines,

es

Office of Textile Commissio oner, New GO Bae, 48, Ne
Nishtha Bhavan, Vitthaldas Th akarsi Marg, Mumba) 400020, and residing
at: #8-F, 25 Floor, Amball Nivas, Worl Village ¢, Worl, Mumbai 45g030,
State Maharashtra,

(25) AIR Vasudey Mar Bay

(Vasudev Vishnu Margal} Oats of Birth 123,08, 1986 Age-49 yrs 02 Month Sy

x £

working as (A LOC 0 Lower Oivdsion Clerk ee up "C" Past) under Office of
Bhavan, | New Marin eines Mumbei soos Qvends irasiving at; A/4, Ground

Oistrict-Palshar, State M sharashtra, eh Pin n Code ~ 603 203,
{26} Nandkumar Bhau Dabhotkar

(Shau Babu Dabholkar) Date of Birth 20.05. 1970, Age -45 yrs O6 Months,
working as (LDC) Lower Division Clerk, (Group "C" Post} under Office of
Textile Commissioner Government of india Ministry of Textiles, Nishte
Bhavan, New Marine Lines, Mumbai 400020, and residing at: Flat No.205,
2nd floor, Satva Vilay CHS Utd. Worli Sea Face Post OFF ice, Hatiskar Marg,
Prabhadevi, Mumbai, State Maharashtra, Pin Code - 400005,

{27} Uday Mahadeo Martul

Cornmissioner, Government of india, Ministry of Textiles, Nishts Bhavan,
Ne

aw Marines Lines, Mambal, 400020, anc eiding a: Hat No. G-7,



1

me
"3
os
oy
Be
a3
Co
am)
ud
Lae
iy
23

and residing at: Filet No. 22, 3* Floor, Sector

r.

Re * wy xxi eae Sie os RA any ey SAE i
No.3, Antoo HIN Nene N ager, Mumbel 400037, State
ry

no
Oo
"G
<%
"a
3
inte
us
ie
od
mee
$3
aes
ist
a
wt

(Shankar snes Shinde) Date of Birth:035.04.1960, Age -55 yrs
hs, ; .

€ of Textile Commissioner, 'Government o
india Ministry of Textiles, Nishta Bhavan, New Marine Lings,
Mumbai 400020, and residing at < Flat No.163, Indira Nagar,
Goregaan (West), link Road, Near Goregaan Depot, District -
Mumbai State Maharashtra, Pin Code- 400104

20) Ganesh Madhusudan Kerkar_

anton,
Lhd

_ (Madhusudan Keshav Kerkar) Date of Birth :22.04,1970, Age -45
yrs Q8 Months, working as Hind! Typist Upper Division Clerk,
(Group "C" Post} under Office of Textile Commissioner, New GO
Building, 48, New Marine Lines, Nishtha Bhavan, Mumbai
400020, and residing at : 28/9, Ground Floar, Shantinagar, Sane
Guruli Marg, Mumbai 400011, Stete Maharashtra,

in

(31) Shivali Sonu Warishe,

(son of Sonu Yeshwant Werishe} Dete of Sirth 16.04.1960, Age
"22 yrs, 7 months, working as LOC (Lower Dhdsion Clerk} (Group
"C" Past} under Office of Textile Commissioner New CG

' & ~ $ j t o to gw deb deg = Ss lint ays
Bulging, 48, New Marine lines, Nishtha Bhavan, Vithaldas
Thakarsi Marg, Mumba! 400020, and residing at: A-1d,

Stet adi wets as ae N wm PA ww ten wo BS an ee

Sldchivinayak Chawl, Chawl No,G/A, Jack! Nagar, Malwa (West)
bee "Pn, Soaks At wy ae es the pen PX ook ea AESOP

Oistrich: Thane, State Maharashtra, Pin Codie 4n06os



10

XK

OA. No. 58 fa0is

ek:

+o So Ag

(son of Babruwhan Anant Gade) Date of Birth 01.08.1959. , 2

"56 yrs, 7 months, workin nga 8 MTS ONT) (Group °C" Post) under

Office of Textile Commissioner, New CGO Suliding, 48, New

Marine Lines, Nishtha Bhaven Vitthaidas Thekarsi Mare,

Mumbai 400020, and residing at : 2/2, OM Sal Leela

Ca.aperative Housing Society, Milind Nagar Birla Colle ege Road,
a?

Kalyan (West), District Thane, Maharashtra, Pin Code:
(33} Vijay Vishram Tambe,

{son of Vishram Manaji Tambe) Date of Birth 17.07.1962, Age -
33 yrs, 4 months, working as MTS {NT} (Group "C° Post) under
Office of Textile Cornmissiones New CGO Buliding, 48, New
Marine Lines, Nishthe Bhavan, Vitthaldas Thakarsi Mare,
Mumbal 400020, end residing at : 103, ist Floor Abhidarshan
Garden, Titwala, Post Titwala, Ganesh Mandir Road, Taluka -

Kalyan, District - Thana, State Maharashtra, Pin Code: 421605,
(34) Mityvaiest Balaram More

(Sen of Balararn Pandurang More), Date of Birth (OL.O1. 1966,
Age-50 yrs, working as MTS (NT) (Group "C" Post) in Office of
Textile Commissioner New GO Pug, 48, New Marine Lines,
Nishtha Bhavan, Vitthaldas Thakars! Marg, Mumbai 400020 an
residing at : 1798, 2ND Floor, 186, CGS Colony, Sector-S, Kane
Nagar, Antop Hil, Mumbai 409037, State of Maharashtra.

(35) Sanjay Balu Malussars, .

fe . oor 4 Daryll ~ x Pa. Sek, GEO A a wey SS
(son of Balu Ravji Melusare), Gate of Birth 02.01.1966, Age-50

ssc RATS PALT eters: MYR Shay wed Py SE} - ee ,
yrs, Working as MTS {NT} {Group "C* Post} In Office of Textile

tis Ni SM Bastfkiag am Nie
Commissioner New GO Bullding, 48, New Maring Lings, 7 Nisntts

2
aes APR Sed Classy Celkear Wael Sheela Nie Mi a hee Lint
*! P. ~ XN. ard bath eee ss ert Ys? oa wy
gil iY, ga Floor, Kelkar Wael wnena, Negr Maun. Sec RO, Sai

Moga RAaesevedie gases mire RAGS he. SESE YP I
bade Manciy Cremour, Mumba: dong: i



* open. hes
@ Ga &
& re Tw

ae & SG
ws " woes
Go <-- fn
on ~ C3 Ut
oh a
cad a So
ois i UO
LO tv 5
Ch be
Shane we te LF
potbtoeetian

Pagar Os,
"4 megpane?

Shavan, Vi

o

Mumbai 400081, State of Mah

rs, working

Age-36 ¥

co

© Building, 48, New M

didas Thakar

"
Bey

-
AS

Ld

uy

th

:
H

Bhavan, ¥

Maharasntra-400 O86.

e

Ate oF

= ee
i, SE
i, ae

ay
2 3

Mumb

shau Salunkhs,

*

ari

(37) Dattaram 4

& yrs,

x
oe

fson of Haribhau 8. Salunkhe}, Date of Birth:01.06.1960, Age-!

working as MTS {NT} (Group "C" Post} in Office of Textile Commissioner,

New CGO Building, 48, New Marine Lines, Nishtha, Bhavan, Vitthaldas

Thakarsi Marg, Mumbal 400020 and residing at: Flat No. 21/226, 1" Floor,

, Mumbai, State of Maharashtra-

q)

par {East

3S Quarter, Ghatke

TBS, CG

07.03.1964, A

FRirth:

OF

Gat

huvaneswaran}, |

al oo
NE

oe pe
Say

wil

f
;
\

red Pos

dink
SZOTES

my
Se

'SS Ng Gs

iat
me)

'hi Nager 8

2 zs
ody Sake

eNo

Hous

iSfaNe

Assi

a
3.

S62 OO,

~

:

3

HY}

wt
wet

pS

ary}

Red
ie

Stee
Mas



bos

OA. No. 36/2016

o

Nagar, Conmbatore-641085, Colrbatore- 641035, Tarrinady,

?

(40) §V, Subraman!

(daughter of late KS. Velayutham MJ, Date of
Birth :29.05.1962, Age-53 yrs, 7? months, working as Upper
Division Clerk (UDC) {Group "C" Past} in Powerioam Service

Centre, Ministry of Textiles, OM ice of the Textiie Commissioner,
Jeganstnapuram Colony, Surampattl Erode-G38009, Tami
Nadu, and residing st : D.No.68 Periya Kondalemoattl, Jari

Xondalampattl, Sslem 636010, Tamil Nadu.

(41) K. GENESH

(son of Late Shri namblaruveettil Karthikeyan Menon), Date of
Birth :03.06.1962, Age-53 yrs, ? months, working es Upper
Division Clerk (UBC) (Group °C" Post) in Government of Indie,
Ministry of Textiles, Office of the Textile Commissioner,
Powerloom Service Centre, Municipal Mini industrial Estate,
Marakkarkandy, City RO, Kannur 670 003 and residing at Arya
sree, Near Ration Shop, Palakkal-Anakkallu Road, palissery-680
O27 Thrissur District : Kerala State,

(42) N. RAMASUBRAMANIAN

(son of &. Nagarajan}, Date of Birth 08.04.2958, Age-5d yrs,
working as Upper Division Clerk (Group "C" Post) in Regional
Office of the Textile Commissioner, Ministry of Textiles,
Chintaman! Cooperative Super Market Complex, 2nd Floor B.S,
Puram, Coimbatore ~ 641002, Tamilnadu, and residing at : 47,
Laksniy Puram, Shiva Nagar, Goo. TVS Nagar, Coimbatore SA

O25, Tamiineda,



g as Upper Division Clerk
sgional Office of Textile Commissioner, Ministry of

e
Chinthamanl Super Market Complex, 2nd Floor, B.S. Puram,

AN. Neat, Parasakthi Nagar, Ganapathy-Colmbstore-64100s,
Tamlinadu.

($4) SANTOSH KUIMIAR M,

fson af KR. MAN, Date of Birth 80.05.1970, Age-45 yrs, 7
months working as Upper Division Clerk (Group "C" Post} In
Regional Office of Textile Commissioner, Ministry of Textiles,

2 loor, RLS. Puram,

"'4

Chinthaman! Suger Market Coriplex, gnc |
Colrnbatore-641 O02, Tarnilnadu, and residing at: House No.63,
Ammasal Xoner Street, Ke Pudur, Colmbetors-

641038 Tamilnadu,
{45} B. Ganesan,

{daughter of Late P Palaniappan)}, Date of Birth :10.05.1956,
Age-59 yrs, 7 months, working as Upper Division Clerk (UDC)
{Group "C" Post} in Powerloom Service Centre, Ministry of
extiles, Office of the Textile Commissioner, Jaganathapuram
i, Erode-638009, Tamil Nadu, and residing at:

<

129, Mein Road, Arachalur, Erode District, Pin 888 20%,

cs
Oo
is)
me)
2)
on
a3
sy
"
aS)
yt}
ct
eT
sy
mi
CB.
143)

"oa
x.
a
4
Q
ath
uss
ty

oe
oO
us
a
Ww
ae
3
93
oy
=
ad

eT Par
Vesaehy faye Pee fod 3 {
SENUIESS, A HUMANS
Ths yess es aan wots en
PUTER PY, CONTIN ST Orem

NoGS Arcariasa: &
PSS Se, SSPE TSG fF



1a

Tamilnadu,

iwife of & Girsesan}, Date of Birth 28.05.1987, Age-48 yrs, ?
months, working as Upper Division Clerk (UDC) (Group "C" Past}

x

im Regional Office of Text!
Chinthaman! Super Market. Complex, 2nd Beer S. Puram,
Colmbastore-641 002, Tamilnadu, and residing at : House No.5,
Divya Garden, PAT Colony Road, avundampaleyarn

NAT wT awd ye oxgabe: enti ne
le Commissioner, Ministry of Textiles,

Coimbators-641030 Tamilnadu.
{48} Purushottam Arhin Salve,

(Son of Arjun Marut! Ssive}, Date of Birth 24.08.1961, Aged - 54

years and 4 months, working as MTS IND {Group °C' Post) in

Office of Textile Commissioner, New GO Building, 48, New

Marine Lines, Nishtha Bhavan, Vitthaldas Thakarsi Marg,

Mumbai 400020 and residing at House No. 302, 3rd Floor, jai

Ganga Nagar Apartment, Rameshwadi Kulgaon, Badlaour Ow,
District Thane, State Maharashtra.

(49) Manol TiMakwana,

(Son of Tribhuvan S.Makwana}l, Date of Sirth: 08.02.2976, aged
¥

45 years 11 months, working as MTS (NT)

CNfice of Textile Commissioner, New GO Bullding, 48, New
Viarine Lines, Nishtha Shavan, Vitthaldas Thakersi Mare
Viumbar 400020 and Sesiding at : Flat No. 882, 2nd Floor
Sullcing No. 91, Sector-!, CGS Colony, Kane Nagar, Antoo HU,

: qe. ~ x o z
Pmeyy Sasa Seam etione Meus otis
fOU) SAYA SUNS SANISY

f Ne a Xt deh § ota Deve afin sh Paws 3} dy os eyes ek

< oss WERE PRENSA S S 3 oe. is oy g Yat Real

AaSPED AVE GAN whe GQ MSR, AG ber & STD PAs Repo acre)
s 3 >



OA. No. 98 so1h

nes, 'Nishtha "phavan, Vitthatdas "Thakars Marg,
Miumba! 400020 and residing at Bullding No.1, Room No. 2,
Sector - 3, Kanenegar, Antop Hil, Mumbal- State of
Maherashtra-400 037,

TH
bs
ree
S

handrakant Nivrutti Pati

Office of Texte Cammissio
Marine Lines, Nishtha shaven Vitthaides hake
Mumbel 400020 and residing at: Mumbai, state of
Viaharashtra.

{52) Ajay Dharamil Raskar

{Son of Dharam]i Sadashiv Raskar}, Date of Birth: 17.04.1970,
aged 45 years, 8 months, working as MTS (NT) (Group "C* Post)
in Office of Textiie Cammissioner, New CGO Building, 45, New
Marine Lines, Nishtha Shavan,. Vitthaldas Thakarsi Marg,
Murnbal 400020 and residing at 596/BD/27, Mehar Pada,
ALM A.toshi Marg, Byculla {West}, Mumbal 400027, State:

{53} Harish Sakharam Naravane,

(Son of Sakhararn Hart Naravane), Date of Birth: 27 O01. 1964,
aged- 52 years, working as MTS (NT) (Group "C" Post) in Office
of Textiie Commissioner, New CGO Bullding, 48, New Marin
Lines, Nishine



>} Whey ot
GA, No. s8/eoud

(54) Vinayak Tukaram Nakhwe,

iSon of Tukaram Nekhwa) Date of Birth: 19.08.1889, aged 46
9 months, working as MTS (NT) (Group PC° P

tie Commissioner, New CGO Building, 48, New Marine
Unes, Nishtha Shavan, Vittheldes Thaxarsi Marg, | Miurnoa i
400020 and residing at Buliding No. A-7, Room No. 134, Sector

Post) in Office

Vi, CGS Colony, Artog Hill State: Meharashtra - 400037

(55) Laxman Shagull Ghige,

é

on of Bhaguil Dhodu Ghige}, date of birth: 26.42.1959, aged
37 years, working as MTS (NT) (Group "C" Post) in Office of
Textile Co mmissiones, New CGO Building, 48, New Marine Lines,
Nishtha Bhavan, Vitthaldas Thakars! Marg, Murnbal 400020 and
residing at Building No.26, Room No. 815, Sectors VIL, CGS
Colony, Antop HHL, State: Maharashtra - 400037,

(56) Sumatinarayan Amarnath Yadav,

Ot
mad

[Sen of Amarnath Vi adev), Dete of Birth: 05.07.2959, aged |
years 6 months, working as MTS (NT) (Group "C" Post) in Office
of Textile Cormmissioner, New GO Suilding, 48, New Marine
Lines, Nishtha Bhavan, Vitthaidas Thakarsl Marg, Mumbai

400020 and rasiding at Rajiv Gancdh! Awas Yojna, Room No. S10,

Opp: Hari Om Electronics, Anandwadi, Durga Mats : Marncir
Road, Kalyan (£), District: Thang, State: Maharashtra State - 422



ae,
JAS

a ReN RS,

cas: Ma

OA. Ne gS /eor

opp: Building N No, 178, kannarnvar Nagar No.2, Vikhroli (6),
Mumbai- 400083, State: Maharashtra.

(58) Narinder Gamodar Singh

{Son of Damodar K.Singh} Date nu

years and LL months working as MTS (NT} {Grows "C" Past) in
Office of Textile Cornmissioner, New GO Building, 48, New
Marine Lines, Nishtha Shavan, Vitthaidas Thakars! Marg,
Mumbal 400020 and residing at Shri Datta Tower, Wing-A,
Ground Floor, Roorn No. 4, Sai Nagar, Jai Bal School, Shani
Mandir, Vithalvadi (E), District: Thane - 421 306, State:
Maharashtra.

(59) Laxman R.Rathod

(Son of Ruda Rathod}, Date of Birth: 05.09.1969, aged 46
years and4 manths, working as MTS (NT} (Group "C" Past) in
Office of Textile Commissioner, New GO Bullding, 48, New
Marine Lines, Nishtha Bhavan, Vitthaldas Thakarsi Marg,
Adurnbal 400020 and residing at -House No. 1682, Building No.
178 Sector-V, CGS Colony, Kane Nagas Antop HIN, Murmbai -
£0037, State: Maharashtra.

$0) Deena N.Anjara

CMfice of Textile Corapalssicnet, New CGO Sulding, 48, New
wa . .



we
te)

($1) Leela Khocidas Boricha

(wo. Nathalal Jerarn Solanki}, Date af Birth: 1O.09.2972, aged

AR yy pos or ~ y SON ~ OF De ro
44 years and § months, working as MTS (NT) (Group "C" Post} in

QOMice of Textile Commissioner, New CG Building, 48, New
ine Lines, Nishtha Bhavan, Vitthaldas Thekarsi Marg,

Mumbai 400020 and residing at 'T-39/408, Prat

Koll Wada, Transit Camo, Mumbsi40002: 2 State: Maharashtra.

{62} Ratan dinesh Baria

'W/o. Dinesh Ducidas Baria}, Date of Birth: 07.02.1956, aged 59
years, working as MTS (NT) (Group °C" Post) In ONice of Textile
Commissioner, New CGO Building, 48, New Marine Lines,
Nishthe Bhavan, Vitthaldas Thakersi Marg, Mumbai 400020 and
residing at Building No. Al, Room No. 312, 3rd Floor, Ashok
Samrat Housing Society,Ambedkar Nagar, Mahalaxmi, Mumbai
400027, State: Maharashtra.

-Applicant.
Cv. RAG. Walia, Advocate)
L. Union of India," Vhrou he The Secretary, Ministry af

»
-

Textiles, Udyog Bhavan, New Delhi-1100u1.

2. The Secretary, Government of Ind
Public Grievances & Pensions, Dept.

'Training, N North Block, New Dicihi-viac

Kd



Senna SS

(Mr. NK. Rafpurohit, Advocate)

%

Per: Hon'ble Shri. Justice MUG. SewRkar, M ermber C33
ORDER(ORAL)

Wir, R.G. Wala, learned counsel for the applicants suoratts that in view of the judgement of the Hon'ble Supreme Court int case of Union of India and Others Vs. M.V. Mohana nm Nair, f2aeo) Supreme Court Cases GL L&S)} i, this application does not survive. He, therefore, seeks leave to withdraw this OA. Leave is granted, OA Na. 58/2016 is dismissed as withdrawn.

(ne. Bidgwar'Sakaly "(dastigg VLG. Sewlikar) Member (A} Member (3) fac}