Karnataka High Court
Sri Ninan Chacko vs The Deputy Commissioner Bangalore ... on 2 August, 2011
Equivalent citations: 2011 (4) AIR KAR R 557
Author: D.V.Shylendra Kumar
Bench: D.V.Shylendra Kumar
V':v<r)\( 'Mr' .
EP§ rag mm: CQEIRT Q? KA.R§€A5'E2&,E§2§ $3: Bmamgaé"
}3.§;E'E§ *m:s 3:33 23% wry' GE' agagsy. 2%: 3 __ gamag: ' Tfifi §i$N'BLE MR... &E}S'E'E€E RV. $§~r¥LE:%§B&é;..§§§:%:g§§A;é"A« V. Writ E3'5f.i€:'0n f'°Jc:.E E 8.32 0f2{}Oi5} {SC Bmwmmg .. V are: NENAN e:::~»L»:x<:§~:<} Sm m;:'g z<;11T1mMK;a':*§--{ARA :\%EN'AE'$ AGEED AE{}E§'i' 84 afgzms * R/A'? AHVEANAM V§LE.AGEZ KERAL-A s':::m:e $233525? E--i§.;'E-3 {gm H€3§J{}E€R . SM': Ema: M ALEX W'/O SEEAJE M AL§C,Z'>< AGED ABOUT-41;8 Y'EAf{S§ V N035, 2ND CROSS;
r,:*C0;9':;z\, SQUzi&RE; .
CGOKES 1_'0w:$;. . . 1 V BANGALORE ;; 5e:;;--.§;5s2;;'.,__ _ ' ' ?£i1'E'E'Ff{}E'.\EEZR _ , {Bk Szi.;~E.I?'i1&-'aEaé£:";'Adv for V ':'311°i'E§ Szgrnatl, Adv} AND:
:1 "Em: :)éP:;;*:'a2* <:Qm2::S:%::{>NE§z E%_éa.?Jf}AE.{} ARUEEAE; '§'.}E8'E'RiC'i' ;::i;.;>;';~.:G;:.a:_,.s:>Ez:%:,' . ..... <4 .
2.. ' = ..'z'§::2: AAS$fg§§~i/X?€'§' C€}?J§EV§SS£®NE§€ " V _:§{>sj)?;:;:§A:.,:_g:?:1§a E%UE3~§§§VES§(}I\i '. .
3' ":':?»:RE :5' ;:<:E~:;~s}«£ 45%;} %;;5%,':":<:: .é%§\EJé'::. €E§%{AI.>?A » :x»:AJ€::E.% EF3 AGE:
., " * '1'-*{g§§.£,E}E€ V'£LLA{}E v _ {Z§:'£z":?€E'~E;'%E€;§:'{:4aE}5%'E"%z7*; E~£<;>§;i3:,:
Ei}E§'*€§aNAE"L%LE,,§ '§:saI,.é;§:§«;
323AN€;;a:'.,<}}'zE'; é"~::.:§eA.L E}ES'§E~?.EsZf'E". ';«;2~s%'%§§;§§a.%:;%: a§<th§:d:£.::'é:d Caste & Scheduéed 'E'1";:'be :f.V%:V§."v~',":}"?'?::*22:;I':§5§'<'::' ef Ceriairz Lanfigi Asia, E§'?8 {far ' _ sh0;:*'ir._'€£hv.§:é and 53:79:: in iezrms of ${31'}:'3(i eiésitidfid C:'c1S€£% sf .444'" §§iiS,§"?<>;,i':~~fi; Ems <*:ams~3€éd {3{}1'1E~3'§f§€3F-.':Eb§f;' <:{3:1.fu$3ZC>1': abaut thisa :3§jm;}:§:;%¥.. ;3§'ic;: and %.§:€r€<'§'{§r:3 Eris §}§'£%?&1§ii&i:', 3%-f2€§"£";§."3§ ~ €:<}'m1:seE {Gr Ehé.-2 §@'£::';'::_@E:er Whifi E9; £:h<% §_3E,i§"{T3h&1.Es§f§' af ggragaizefi SM'? VAN: .?§;%§%A'x'AN?a W/@ 5. N.z'§£%£¥'.{;:.NA E?4E.z%J{}R EN g<2<::v§:
£'e,;;%,*:' :'\?<},4 3.. ES'? <:§4e{}:'»3s3 J{f{}'E3 ':)£)L{3NY VEVE3KANz.'%.?€§"J2'§ Nxaézzaia J;'%.IBH;§R;'§'EE§ NA{}AR * V. 1 E3ANGAmRE:. -- 56$ (':33 }.'§3}§SE'{3E§E)§¥iE'¥é'ETS
-4'.'.,>.
{By Sr: E3; Or:1k;:.;mar. .£\.G£x §E>;j*' E'{};;; E2i3,'.;R4_; 5»; Rféf V 7 TE-{ES .§3§£'.E'§'§"§*C>?'-2' ES §7I§.Ef;§} EENEEESEQ }'71§{'§7§C.L{*355 §}iL'?;€='E§N§} {}?'7 E';-§E:: {:<)NS"m':;'He:>N <3?' '§?~I§E}EA._ E'R.AYEN{§' rm g;>iJA_ia.§~1mf;~»§E:: O;RD::;R* , I}T.2;'3~f?.O'?'. PEXSEEEZD BY '.1V'i"§E3'"~».. D§'3§'7;§'§'¥'w ' {LvQRé'M"§f3SIONER;" E3AN{}}'i§JO§~\{§: RURJKL EEEEYF, §3.A§'\E"G.£3;§.,5(:)'F3f§ ,7 Rig. _i.Vé'3:;; ':AN §§§EXURE~A, AS ARE%§TRARY XLLECEAL ANE3 §JNJ'AN'§}_ ETC, " ' .
m:g§>§:'1"m€.>m €OfvEIE\i{}_{};?€ Psgsiz ::=Ria:;ir.r§:NARY E§§2£:R§Z'€€} *3' {}R{}U§>, mzs mg: mg: cgum' MA§E*':?_{E;-F©1,:.;)w:Nc;;-- The: €"£:"I1{:_'€p i1"' 3:.:g.f" "a.:.j'T:|_.:fa:$"€3',,__ "i31*£v{:e.V. 'C<3*i13i;itL1£é3S the: fufi m3r}§€f,:v'VVé?2§::&AV:i:§::du;fhE§*€§f§re a;:'V1.:'§i1i'§1c%:i:2g§ tha proxzisians Of Sectaian "cf 05 Pmperty Am; 1882 anfi Ehere3:f;j;.. 2w0i(§i::g2;wV%:hé'- gfifatrigiozzg sf S«9:C:t.;10:": ti 0f 1316 u-
« 21% 2» S:.1bm§::%;;<,3§<'2:": {if S1'; .E}ia-v€:k;'1.:r§ §ea:':":é2:i f3{}iiE}Si";'E Em' ETEK'; §"x;%Ei§:ier:e:" f.E*:eu: i'h.<3 prségeiaé: Ezarzaiié ems: §;*r:a:r:£é;%1:ii an {:{>E§€x::~t.§ng Lipsei: p':*i{:e 9? $53!» in 2'<::§§3s2<:?; Qf 4} 'i;:;€r§:.§ zmzi !:.§";€r€~f0:*€ flags': pr<>vis«;i:ms {if 'me As: i_&§..Ijié;>??; :':{1.§:ra:;%5é%'a"?;:.AVV ' 'a:ha'{: the grzzxitee dams net' bé3E<:>I1g' %;.€;~_'*:'h;€& "s3§:'P:§'{i.LéEeL§.__éégséés cammmziiy and at any $213.9 :1a:34_:na1§€&:fia'E 2v2:,=:»'gé%:V.:1§:€d 'z§;ef{::;"e . 'a.h£.=: aut'h.<:s'r':'{.3,: ti) this effwsi. etc. Gr: the other C~n_ffi««:um&r§ learned Addiiiena} G0vernn1Ve11'€;~. . if AdvQdéfit.f3 'éppeexrirlg far respanfienfg s11:b:I£:§§s t_;h.«f3_.~'t 'thémicendiéiian is 0f :10 C0r1S€q1_i<~:r:é:é' SéV':§tir3:i»...}§2} Qffhe ACE aperates in the grggeni :;«21se a:'1=ri; %.§1e_9$e;Eé:«.'§'1"a'nSa_ci.i0'1'1S hazing admiiiediy after fizszé Aciéamingégf §1;}3f{§.:f0f{f%3 afid being met accompanieé "F5333 pf?0I'E"'¥§%s'i'fE;f.}:71f.SS§;GE§; 0? ihif Sé.a.'{.@ €r{§'3f€E"i"3E'}71€ZTC; tiégsig §nSs:)f3.,:" 22% figs:€:v£§I':.{:ép:_§:2§" definition of gramizfisi iané ?;.§.2i"id€1" $16 As: :53 {§G«§E{f6_}f'fi${§*; ii"; {£898 émsizzéew mi-"en {the 2am"? gfaritsé an H V{::;ai§§:5{:t,§n'g ":,:p5:ss»:t §3z'§€€; Ehzzt assssmninggg than aézctéan 3% Q? figs _' »._';EQ'§"?'2V';'§"':-f:*'EiE*E° {if Pr{}p€§"é'.}? gkéttég £2882 <§p<::'m*'{.€:S aiax :.¥z1::&;ea{':é§{;z1 " E;-';%3vii'.22§3E§ *v':}§;<E€{§ in via}; 5}? Ehéi' §}'£"'€}V§Si€}§1;'E; {if $é;é{fi:i<3:'2 'E'?an$f§:<.,Qf '§334%:.s§.-3:€:f§';fg?V Act, 3882 can nevar bi? Said is be 'TT._&'£a::s:8;¢:,'*£ez:;?:'§" z 5 M of 'aha Transfler af' ?mpaer¥;y East, $882 as {he mamenéz {hem ES vigiatiizn Sf the Caiifitiafi, "the grevisiefis affgghegtien E 1 3f the 'E':'ansfe:* af Pmperty Act 1882 cemg afid 31} Qther €81'1S€q11€E'iCf3'S have is yi€1d5'_t:};,'!{_'§'f;;e: af section 1 1 of the Trangfar af P:°i;§@:f7§§§«.§'¥,.c':,p _ T
4. The éecisians referreéi» Sri."
Biwakar, Eearned c0u:::~3:?:§ §Oi7vA'E'i1'i?ié.';;¥:31:§i*1'Efi?:§7'..£;f>I"}.€'}#«fi£1f§i'§$§C be said to be goafi law any megéé Judgment Gf the Supre:§1e§~vC'z;§§.§§*t céwxzéé _"€zf§.___f§SiD§E§QWEA :25, ASSISTAN'L' é§?I#1ifi'SSi"é1;?£§R. :%;3..QTIMRS' reported in AIR 2003 upset grice is very giaafiy men'§ 0£3.§d it is proved that the upfiefi: pricié wag <::T:1"pé;§ $16 actuai market price at the ifififi . G'E'7.,€_:he §§a,:é':..,v Ehfi prmzigiens Qf sectioaa IQ Q? the 5 3 "E'h9s9 2i&;;::€é{t*g;s% zigbzzri, in fezgfrtg §:ai§e<:':§»:>n sf §5@;'~-- far 4 EiC§"€§% and beizzg ail ihs :"a£;<3 sf 315/~ pm' tazatre is; :V':%:':a?"E, am?
54).; ' part of {the ups;:e{ ;;=:°'i<:e bué. is 312$}? g3I?:<)&:;52g _i%;;..:* Eléééifiiiffifiiiééiilf. and sub-::§iVidi:":gg the ssL1rve§I..,{i;'{§:r:'£:{{<ér$; ;md:_ ' ihai: :5 mat, Qvezz am}? upafif, prim: 2;; f;EV:{:AA;3§ry3s*£::"1?€;A f 5 Sri. §*z.f:1jE18hi3KE';3.I", i6arr:c.(i c0#;*a_:f:§s§a=a.T£ f<;r'Vf;}_'§T_e f§j3:::*E1"_: '; r€s§}{>':":_d£:m; Subnlits that S0 '1;{_}m§;{V as~:/'*~7T%~§I'ii pgsttiiion is di3rr:is;s::»:é$ hfi is {7ani%€::1iM'*an:§ he ?:i.r_3fé3s7'~r:e:>t. press for any fufaher reiief.
2?'. i?§T}1e%ihe_§3._.:f0i;%jT§i}h :9€:$gi{;fide§i§_ §1*é':s"='5€S 50:' any reiief 0:"
Qthemrise, '-this; "is.'j":>;i)'i;._éix§r&;1{éz::%2dingf whercsin reiief' can be extenéed " Ejhieé _ reapazzdem, but the fourth r€tSp«:::';='--}.dei1f. 2%}: the .'§> _¢$ti aziam mzaskéi use af his pri-zgenca aznly "'__fga>v.Vs§*:2.pps;;':*>:~%€.§<::é'>sg:'de:' and far dismisaai 0f the writ'. gxetiéion :.,z..?"§['t:§.";"w?:1§a%§'iV-- f§:é:§T%e:.i?;i_<>:3 Sris R.a§2155h%3ka.:: Eearriegi 3011:2393 €92"
Cfehe §Qi,;.}."f?E3;. respandésné has 33:} quarmi, is; éibfiéiiééilfii}? 21:} EE'i%';?Z'§.'§'. in $35: 3*a,:bz:}i$sé:m$ .. ;fj:_1::*§<"§:;': an h€§'::;:Ef £3? '§'h.f.E p€»{.i:§{}:z":£%r, Na zzzzssrii: in the writ '1?
§3€i.ié;§<}::. Na izgted £02" £:%':£.€r£?c=::*'€:m%a% wix:4E*: fihe <>:"=(E€::° passssggi by {:E1s;=: §3€:g;>:.1i:jg' C{>:§m:_is$i{3:::€::f.
9. A<:{:.<}2"d§ng;i},,-2, wrii: peéii:':{m ij§S§§}i:E*§S€{ig A%N/'