Karnataka High Court
The Commissioner Of Income Tax vs Sri Parasamal Babulal Jain on 14 September, 2011
Bench: N.Kumar, Ravi Malimath
IN THE HIQH CGURT OF K§NA'§'fiI{A. AT
§f}.:&§':3{i '£.?§§:e-:« 2,11%: E45" dag}; 0?$::ig.)i,e:'1'1E3{:?. §. '
Ei'I%.1iS.i43EF€Té* _ V
THE I~1or~e"BLE MR, JUsi=:c'1i:_é§ Kfir;mR;V «. "
V
'mm rsxoxwgm MR. JUSTICE mahgmgéra
;_';.i;'s; é\£m ::§};_;:fv2é'c%é_; _ §3E§'FY§xfE*1E-§E'~E: V -- V ' 'V " V E. '§.'h€ C:2:1i:.§;1i:§§§g§:s_:.'3<:3'i zaf E1§}€I(}§fi'££{'1.€:?;XV €34 E{"§*3a1fi%j§Vi:1 :f:,: "
g;f;z.zm~zss .R2:::;-11.3 " < . M §'f1i5<".?\,1'1§;§:'i§€)'E'€';*_ V ' Titan": u§'.:'1..§?'{§£"F1{¥fimgilgi' .i:};§'i7§ 552:1' Vi'§£;3:°<§ 5%}; "
.. <2 :2: B:..§i§{§:iIt:g.§ V _ Q?:;:;?«:'-?1":':;fs E7%<}2::{E " """ "
ix':
' * .. _ §§1§;1:%:;§;3a.§4V{§1*%;é . ,,.A§3g;:&i§21.:':%.§»5; . _ {.E:3":5 3:': {E K:e.:'::.2:§z':::§§}.;f:.:: ,5-'3s.{§i='i_§£'i2E§_€;%} g'aN§£f}_: T Shri §"é1§'ETi.ff§€.1E"i'lEi§ E;§2T{E:}":.:§';~:aE 323:":
-. '§}?;'<:;§}; E'«'I'f-$5 Mimi E:':2:';.1"e:%c f,%{:E§:<7"§j:"3§'::~; 4 "I"sE{>§:%é€%;"'E§}*I 31.2%; <:;;:.T:-2-gaigsx " _ ' E;%§:4fis=":§;e~;r;2';;§:>§'e*:% ;.,E¥ié;%s;§3{t2:}{§£::§':é {By Sari E3 E"-331'?%";22s;21z'z.:i..§'::ie ;'§::£:><}<:'::m;%} 'Z"m::; ET;~'% fifiinzi :.1::{§e%:' Set<"ié<31'"1 iZE'iC¥é'a of s:ri5:;i:[:§.3;' {REE of <}:'s:.i&?r dai'.<::{§ €)8~{}'?--2é3{}:"§_...p ,fEf§;1z'2§2;g'2C§{}f39 ibz" '€.}'1<% ;"&5'~:«ss~:=:-=3éé;::'e:<;=:»:'1.%_yfirzai' 2&0 32:; {E} f{;2*;':1u§z2fi.i3 '§,h€ SL1bSi.&':1£'1{§€-11 £§}..1<:?1g€'.ié:}z:§; £3" rm. ' {iii} 2:}k:>w ':E"t<3 2~.':,pp€a§ a:.I.1{i 2;1::;i.€ié:*. E.i;~§:; :i3;i£,§<:1 pa:
n1E?A.N&88G§Bangj2Q§3 dwsd ®8{fl%20®5 <';r{i€I" (3? {E19, §m:<3::'1£3 '.'2§x Cifffizer, '~;1-'{§'1:"ci~5'{"E}e E%z3.2':;;§;21§'<::_:*<2;V. * fi1ag§%§ €}:{}1V.j E33121}-3*i E22 51.":
'E'h§s; E31'-X, <::m.:1i.n;,_;; <31': ii:-2' §f;';?§;E£*§\E1';;§_V.'{.hif3 §\?_.5 §€E.?E§§:3R J £§€§:§.x»'e;§.'<;%{i E':§1e. i?1:3§§<>wéuggf:. ' v A V Jfi$§fiEmff V-:'12=zsa=2:3-.;'}:ni:§s5;':~':*e:té ii":-;5:;'v--2::.g3§>::%z3;§ ciméfiextagirzg i.?{:.<3 T§{}t';'. :"€vé:i:'::.é§:;
m.'«:i<:%:* p22..s-;;si~,:é':£ ':33;-' i_'1~i2%:: "E'r<éb':Lé:§;L;%_§'%s1?E<;§<:i*; Efmss .<:3s::i. zwiéa i;:§1€ p<;%n33'{.3-* ':r:1p0s3:;?d by é.;i:T:;z:I';:z$;3;é; EEi'3'E.f4.,f;>7€.3*'§T§'?.{'{f%§"'i.E§E{3t:?'i' S£3€Ei{}1'1 2?} {E} {(7.} 9%" E316: §:2<:<:3"3'"z€% 'E':4;;{'z5';:?é.; E E§{?+§ §'. {fa-.Yf_ ué3'E':j1<§§1, I§:%:%§«:%i:::»:§°£:fi':* :':';%fs:*:":'<%{i €10» 2:5; '$16: §%.c:é'}._ .
J '-._,.
;3:»--. is; 2: v;:§'2::Es:saa.§& cieaéziz" in si-,:§§E~<.' ::«;>.2.2.:'=e:%:<r;D E~§:;é ._§?2::§?,. fi~:%i';"'»§T§E<=s§ "--.7~;':fg.'T;-" z"{4:E;z..:':*:'3.s§' A s;:.::*2,~*{:y v;a:<; <':<3z1e:'§:.:§:'ii,€.£% in ihéfi 7"2Z¥f::é-::"*2_ia;:.§?": {:{Z§€i}§'}t:". 'z.a:':.§s;:% Béiiéié. jglaé Ef}u§':§:zT:;_: :su<':';'1 $:_3m:::j; '§.h:':},--" §{>a.:.:':d 'é;.h:1§. "i.<:% 33.2353 ':3:-33:: <72 '3<?mé.iz'1<.f 2:: §.::;.2:':E«; 5:<;:s':{?:-um ZKEG. .E'?§32 :2"; 5'57» 3 9«-«_we 9%. E3§{§e:§2;:.ie2:§': §'€{iZ22"%.,{.1§§ §?§2m;;§2:E<}:*€:iu in ,1)"/_.
<3: i_:?1 E"§'§¥, . .-z.::":;':§i:m'1i2:1g ' ~ iii is L I