Karnataka High Court
The Commissioner Of Income Tax vs M/S Gemini Distilleries on 2 November, 2011
Bench: N.Kumar, Ravi Malimath
3?? TEE EIEQE C€}§}R;'"§" Q?'
§j}2:z'§:~:'f€% ihiss; §§'1£;', 2"'-E ::§a§.:' £3? E"~§{_>'e«-*'€:T"E'§;'é'§f}€:'tZ"§ E. '
:I3:a§%:.ss§;§§%;:V'g*
YHE §%;@§§§g:,.a mg, J§S'§"E_§E,_?€ Eggjggggfg '~ V' .
.
€33 E-§§E'§"§L£ ,::;:=§& ggrg*§::§; éfigrgs:
{£2-%; .
§%§*I"§'§¥'\./' EEYEZ-N ;
3 '".?f}.?:::? {L{JXE}Eff};§;§EZ.§'{§VE'§..§f.§EV"{'}j§;V'E§.'1{i{3I'§"}E? '.§'2z>;
{is:%n_E.:"za.Z {i.§:i€:.§%;=: ._ "
C :12 ':?3;g@r§;::;;;; "
V @u€a=%;":éss §9{<)::s §%a2i::gai<>:°é~ V V 'E7'%:::3; ;§f§%;«:-3;';-':.':§.j».,' Q£32323§'1".%.i5:%f5§{}'1'3t*:.3" Q? T " ' ?€zé%:>.:_>.:'z"sé€' iF22z;'<'.
giZ§:::':,;:;::_f§ ff' ""{':E.<=-*:-E ' _ 3-FA:;i'ii.1'1g §}:.,_;:'{":é:'m~:i~é E-T{<:s;'.:{§' :=I%:-;.i§;2;2I2.IEa§:"§% _ 9 . M5%§};.}&%E§22:§': 3 :13 {I§j:§jg -..f':§:';£. 3"'::'Ef E§E%§;§L>E;:Ei{.:%.VE.2.§..E;F§«R ;72<,*§:Ia}{'r2=:aE:i-r} /,/ gr fimx RE"! <;}<::m§:%'2:? §,}%.s»:'£.;%EEs~3:*§a=:5;
i§€}3§ E\§<.>:f§}'1 §i§E:':z{"§<;
§\£§2?:m"p21E €iTi{i::%;I'€ _ 4?? Ei}§{'r§«:c%:1:é>;<):": {'%i<:;2*:.fi. ' Ef.%2%.:'2.§aE<:r{é "éfé'é;§..=a §"'E"f'§ féiza'-%{§ if <32'; .§ffa§*t§.;. iiééfié ;z:"§;~;;§':'zg§ 912:": :3? {}I'{.§i'.?I§' §:§;'z§'€:<:§ i§{§--§2~i£i{}{}i"3 §:}i-:§:;sS:?€'§..V§.§':g§'§Z{'§"E'%§\ {§E%)2_§E§a::;.§j2f§}GE ft}? €335 3%-':23.:' §€}'£?i£*}»§37 §i:*»§';zz§"§1§;{. ~'f::<> xii} .. §3:.>":"':'?£m Q ':--A!:.'" 'SE39 $:z.b5§i.;3;3}§:.i21§ ::§_e.2e:*:§;-*,'§.:'<::n.=5s: §:.§£" §.Ei2i-*'.:$"§v2i§.€£§ "§.E':€i§€-E12,, :f:*::?V,:-.;;-:.1:_?a.<:m;« Ems: 2.i§,}:{i}€':é1§ amt? zisiaisi 8:5: <>re:";_fet?;::z-.é}L.;;§asSl;%<i €53/' éisei-:_. "?'i"'z'~";.i"--E*'; §%3a2":g§a§{m3. in E'£"f':
E\Ea;;»@§§:%;'E§a':'1g;';':*;i§{§E.dé:;'i,€§é:;E.:_§%Q~»E2i-=2€j:{}5V_r:%<>;';fim1i:':g {ha <;rd=s:' <3»? {Em f§§}§)€'EE.2if:k1?V {3::;_i}m:I'2is:3i<}:"i'€%;*A2;£'1{§'{::51j7E'i:":z3 flié': émféfir" ;:;:%..:~':;S€d. by *:E":& E}€'3§'2LZ§-,:»,«7 _ €:§€}Ei'}1%"§'§:i§;§?%5§;§'{,;:':ZTi%?§f__K}? '§1.::.{.;:3:}§€3 'E':_.:x, V,€;~:":?;2t'2:1§ {fiE:°a:i€-- 1, §$a1::,éfi¥1iéV%:"§, "
T%;'§5:; E'E"1!': :f{§zé'.:i.:3Q; K31': ibz" :}fT§€i£'1Ei"§§'"£§_3,: iE";§s':; aiazgég ' «-2}?' :i'€:':E3?.i;««"€-:':»§:'€:":::?.--. E',%1'é;:"§bfi<}wi2':;};:
§§§§fi§§?
is; '{3}? 'iE':i:t= T.§?;ev»:=2::::.z.:;s ::§':;:ziEs:'2;;§§2':;g; §l§Eé':? e:::"<;:§§;é§"
§;25:s3s%s§:*i:i£ i':'?:%f<;;, ".3'5"L."i%::z.::":2?s.E;
2»/If '§.'E.'3{: mi? %_42:':={ :t§'"%'m'i' 2A*E'2§:;*';'2 'éE'2é$ :»s1:§:g}?z:=<.':%L"*:':'é§é:.%;Efa::"' Q?
é..his.% ;2§p§::':z?i ?.}é;>E€::.i; §'{s;<,. E.{L'a{}Ci*.€§{§%{E;' E22 *a.»*i:;*,%.,>af_--'=i:s§ §§"z":;.i,js"*u;::"é.
1253:;
:\Ez:393/20$? :R;E':i€E: i>;"a:}I'.":§3r>';?%,:s; 35:22:? ? <35»;-2:": 2-z§';:'f>':%;1'§--:'_":':.> ":%2€:;, E"§.i,I§§15'» {7f{.>:T:§.'"£.? w%"i€,s"é;: mi: "é.z--::x: {:'ff§"?<if%' §'f:";§EiE'}_ E'ZS'L .§.{EQQ4{:é§}{.};5E;"'ifiE';f§.§"'ii'?
zyimfa-I $3" é'.E'2z:% {.ii€:«:'%i:~2q'<.}:': 02" éhisg {:{E-'{.3:'€.\._§§'}; §'§'A §:3.g'%§ §'iAv.§;.'.€3§;Q5.=§§3 $323' £','.2'if:'§{'? 9:' rgggg {:Q§rf£§{§1'SS§§Eé'ER ':3? §::r$§%:s:azM¢:!9gX,jg "$39 mfg;
& ggwxgg f *:§:z":1. ii; '§:=éa5::e'<.7E"§%:rn5;:,§' 3122?'. E:":§5;'E.z':.::"§.§<.}r1.
2.KRi>:f%fiZ{§.§.i ;ééass;1,:s:7j::§ {:23 {E3}-.{:'2~..2{}.§A
-s ';{;,2E:§}§€E' ac: ggegzéiizzgg _§}r0<:s:<:--»;Ei:3§;§s-3 a1§¥§s{';a ;-:}§;.>;}€:g:'i" p:"§4§1:~:':":"a:*é*Ei"Egg? iizxé §¥Z;<ixs*é;'~.;rme mat.
rrakaim:ai:mbk:> -i:__