Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
T N Sing vs M/O Communications on 28 November, 2019
i Od No f62013
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
MUMBAT BENCH, MOMBAT
ORIGINAL APPLICATION No. 46/2013
oh |
Dated this Thuudaythe Qs Qo November, 2019
CORAM: R. VIJAYKUMAR, MEMBER {A)
RAVINDER KAUR, MEMBER (J)
of
a
T.N. Singh, aged 55 years
Working as Assistant Engineer
26537, DOarpan Talephone
Exchange, Chakalia, Andheri
Bast, bhamba and residing act
E/LIS, Shiv Shakti Apartment,
Opp. Triveni Nagar, Kurar
Village, Maiad East,
Mumbai ~- 400 Q97. sc ... Applicant
( By Advocate Shri Ramesh Ramamurthy)
VERSUS
1. Chairman and Managing
tor, Mahan
rec a
. 4% Tee pu} >
Telephone Excnangs
Jeevan Bharati, Tower I,
i24, Connaught Circle,
a
New Delhi ~- i110 Oo1.
2. General Manager West-il
Ma ahan nagar Telephone
Buchan nge Limited,
Goregzon Telephone
Exchange Building, 37° £1.
S.V¥. Roa Garegaon West,
Mumbai o- 400 O62. ... Respondents
(By Advocate Shri Vishal Shirke, proxy counsel
for Shri $.V. Marne}
ORDER
Per: Ravinder Kaur, MEMBER (J)
2 O4 Node 20i3 ribuneals AC, 1885 seeking the following relilefs:-
"S(a} That this Hon'ble Tribunal he pleased io quash and sei aside the impugned order dated 18.09.2012 (Annexure A-i, passed by the Respondent No.l and the order dated 26.03.2008 (Annexure A-2) passed by the respondent No.2.
() That this Hon'ble Tribunal be pleased ta direct the respondents to restore the applicant back ta his original position prior to passing of the order dated 09.04.2009 by the respondent No.l and also post "him in the same post which he was holding prior to the date ie. SDE and pay him the emoluments attached to the said pest of SDE for the niire period and also fix his pay in the said post of SDE for the entire period and pay him the arrears arising aut of dijference in the emolument between the said post of SDE and the current post held by the applicant.
fe} That such ather and fiether order or orders be passed as the facts and circumstances of the case may require.
(d) That cost of this original application be provided for.
7 on whe x *~ awh No? a. IMG OAcrs are that while the applicant ¥ wit ~ ut a RITA se WAS WOrKing as SDE in MINE, Mumbai, Gorecqaon Rea laxrkans Soe mores Re Yee Se ey eee, + apa LELQEOonSs SAC OSN OS » ne fas Served Wht oh x Ye wer 3 *~ & oe ot my mt nN * ~ a. cnargeshser dated 14.08.2007 (Annexure A-3} alongwith statement at imputationa ot tne allegations sqainst the applicant are to ~ reg + oe nen the following effect:
"2. WHILE functioning ax such an 27.02.07 some cables were expased by Ad [MRDA near Patel Aluminum Company on OA No $6/2013 wad the Western Express Highway. Ten Primary cables of different sixes, 1200 to 2400 pairs, averaging a length from 12 to 15 meters were exposed, Gn seeing this, the Area DE, Mr. Koshy requested the MMRDA contractor not to alow anybody to touch MINL cables and if anyone tries to do so the matter may be informed to Mr. Sharma, SDE of the Area on phone No.20350007, At about 11.45 am. Qn 28.02.2007 Atv. Sharma got a call from the contractor that about eight number of MINL Staff were cutting the cables. Mr. Sharyn, SDE, along with his staff reached the spot and found that eahles were already cut and loaded on a private truck. Mr. Sharma escorted them to the Telephone Exchange Building, Goregaon. Then the ANC staff dumped the cable mm the yard maintained by them, In the meantime the Area DE spoke to ANC (W-2). He told that he was not aware of the incident but will confirm the availability of estimate for recovery and other details. After getting the clarification that estimate was not available for this work from DE(ANC) (W2) the same matter was reported to DGM(GGN) and also, through DGA to GM(W2) on 02.03.2007. Since the whole episode has taken place with malafide intention by the same unit staff, which delayed authorized recovery in S.V. Road, and in this case with absence of proper authority to recover the materials.
3. WHILE fmetioning as such during the above period, said Shri TN. Singh concealed the facts and gave wrong and misguiding information regarding his absence from Hea Quarters, (Le. Mumbai) while on leave from 23.02.2007 to 01.03.2007 and stated that he was not mowing Shyam Bihari Singh and Chhatelal Mama and never spoke with them on phone. The CDR of his Garuda Mobile No 20538444 astablishes that he was very much in Mumbai and has spoken with the above people several tmes, He fiether stated that even affer his refusal, these people along with cable construction staff recovered the cable but were caught by the DE and SDE concerned which shows his malafides intention in unquthorised cable recovery."
In response to the apove, the applicant vice latter dated 06.10.2007 (Annes A-5}; demanded eartain documents. The comntentior of the ¥ NHSkULS if res 2 rd es wed we ee Sn $F « ef et Ds
8) a} a AgY eh @ & 4 ht m3 oi Ma ca XG 43 th $3 7 "ed ot £3 Fe] '9 fon $3 ved $4 xe;
mF OH WAR? .
2 PS eds ' i * ha i a Cod oo Ow Cs ageeg ged Qs ort iS seed £23 ah oe 4.3 ud Oo gp 3 itt G ww ca 4 nod i vend nautho ra get v Aa 43 GY $f o24 ord io} "3 3 "rd td ep G83 im it notice Rm FY RF} ANNeGXure et dated uy m3 43 qi 84 fet tes O ey iy @ "4 BQ @ seed 13 "rd S oH ay "tS M4 ped O 6 0 Gs wm w "geod cmt os > OS aon sod ae of @ i 173] w sa Ad iB B 4 * As ws 3 43 iy w) yg w ii . . j ~ u Y a 3 ° i > OC au tt i a et aH ce 6 & 4 8 & & B Co rf OS Oo C@ 4 0 SS 3 5 wy ip fed as "ef a 43 ry ce 3 rn 4 od 0 By t it 3 & bd * baa - 4 ey Ad he Ug GO Se 3 ® wo 4g © wok cy id Sed C3 o pan oO a) @ wv i vee EH Shard . ° Oo th Oo a nm # me mt OM Pa v4 3 4 . O & Ww gg 8 %&§ W © ex 3 Ho Oo A , "rd * on 6 os § s rm w 8B @ Soop Bo 8B OOH Gt fg th c ey $3 Q * aed it ay Zs orf 4d os @ "rl ct a a 3 oa wef g @ De cf ch o ft uy ry Gy cf Q us Gi a Py 4 4 p *@ oO in a) 43 f wn 4 ee SF BU wlUlUmlU UO "i O® Go ow @ -& we wg ED a fy oe Behe eo yw ch oo ae of as Oo Bo en iS od | ge BR YM mt Oo wy : of od oof Oo reas is di 3 4 "tr 44 4 ah by oO ae a ea . oat % Oy ond - ® ee ad wo my it a e ors "4 oO oO 8 a wD Oy re cs it ut 13 . 3 x os OE MO > : he ey fa cy . hy us a mc 4 hy oo. 4 es a "3 Oo. | fe O j : 2 OG as et ¢ bos } 3 e oF 4 ot a ees: 4p ge Ge xo C3 5 w 4 ws ¥ 0 ee c wo GB OO 4 by , Gq © BF q @ o ord * td " ved Yad "3 cd C%} a 4 ded yy G © 8 ES ws 8 yo bp 8 8 6 BM & a a ; Soe om # i on fe, : 4 . ond Aen ah -¢ : wo & oes va & ts 3 wo & goo a a £3 O FS GH Fo H 5 8 Oo & A 9 é 8 DD wu 4 og eB FF op ot OO £ BG x Bo Oo TF ff go 8 4 ' wm A * 48) rs ret te 4a £3 & ct rm rm 4 Cy 5-4} ey bed fo a , he x ma Wy ' oa ay 7 <A ad Te, ct a r. 4) i 4 }3 i.e, ~ @ 3 & Oo % 8 0 0 =f § BY Go 3 3° OR wo pina go g © mB wo Fm ee &® GO 8 mo t eg Sf se o CG ~ Cot 6g © o , ey ct Gh wb 3 QV Cy So * weet S ai % Seq wa 3 . + "a rs Oy £4 4 © toy o 4 4 Os a 2 ba re @ v4 Sires Qn Do a wes Qe 4 we ~ ba a 0 4 oh , w ! 43 ) 4 G :s) , es 5 rho gn v4 « 7 UE Yo a "hE " 4 op fF OB we 5 3 ¢ c¢ % & og & a » @ 86 & @ SS 4 . rt - ra 1 ® na % : Ba Ped «5 4 © Q 2 me , 4 ce: o ay on a E © a o a , os a a oF boy v F eo 8 m Borel x wo 2 & 3 es hy cw | og 2 a P Hom G2 8 6G cp n Oo @ "ft vl vn 4 5 0 * . it #§ G & "3 Oo © Ad CS @ _ iG "3 el r ° 4 Oo co Yo 2 rl bod st ° - {3 ba t . : ws x i 4 C3 v4 a mo fo oe Bd Om OR mM Om BH front v io his absenc i di > Mionbai while on feave er concealed the facts and gave ormation rege Qf inje » c L@., to 01,03.2087. Ff ° Tag ad Quarter, x eon = ?
3.02.2007 :
"i) The Charged O) com He.
vrong and mislea ;
3 f "
*, 6 | Od No. 46/2013 fii) As per statement of Shri Krishnaraj Yadav, Mobile No. 9869356180. supervisor of C.R.Traders approved company in Wil area for supply fo labour that on 27,02 2007 at 20.00 hrs., charged afficer had phoned him and asked for lahours to recover cables mear Patel Aiuminum Company, but he refused to give labours because it was not his site. This has been confirmed from CDR of charged officer's Mobile No. 20558444.
(fii) The Charged Officer has accepted in his statement that on 27.02.2007 evening Shri Chhotelal (Krishnaraj Yadav), shri Shyam Bihari Singh and Shri Phool chand, telephoned him several times regarding recovery of cables near Patel Aluminum and Cable construction staff (ANC-GGN) came in night at site but went back and on 28.02.2007 morning (The day of incidence) phoned again him and even after his refusal, these people recavered the cables.
(iy The charged officer has failed ta intimate the incident to his superiors. He should have given the telephonic intimation to his superioxs for unauthorised recavery of cables. This act of Charged Officer clearly shaws that his intention was Hot genuine, "
Pant ih = x " ay gh . be wy 3 GR ae = AOLSONaray Yadav and two statements of the Hindi language and one in English Language.
v } : Seti 5 mith F-hoaen FARES ' ' ' the Memorandum ALONGWLth CNese Three statements Od No 462013 ee, "~ a © $4 a in ' ' & - ) 3 My Soy Sed wy a es 4 a 3 e 8 -- SY o ££ & 6 B® & o 6 & eos oS w a) , ' n m3 6 ¢§ @ @ Bo 4 owt 3 «Dp o 4 %o - 9 haf us 2 , - hs 44 wn "eS a M4 cs Oy . eed a Acs oe e wy OR wy c 3 o Mo @ a @ me "ef a cS a x1 mS G "cd cy & & vol 6 g} s gs g 2 as 6 c ria} % a " jet oo = cH 3 & aged 4A wy m me GO GF BD ag & 3 oc Bog a m G °°
4 ct a {3 ar} 163 43 rt ' eH @ a 42 @ n 3h aa » Sot og @ « Mot FB POR an ge =O a ~ O 4 e e 'S ce a 3 ue 8 et iD 5 & 8 e, i $4 z ot oa ged . "yd : :
Co ® eo tm 8 © B® HO wt ay om 4 a 2 hy M "8 & oe 33D . a & " wo 8 cP oD eo «gg % us un p Oo eo © m = @ a g of Sa q Os B ey TE cg CG 3 43 44 a ; ve * oy se 3 bed rd aR o o ® ae) "4 fa 3 43 we mM 4 oO rt gy BR " 43 4b Wy oO . w a 18 a iD BS o e Ch Q : Q @ G wf 4 ry ee ca ae @ * ei Oo C4 43 o ES 4 wee a 44° So rt ~ OH ue o a Qh A " i G : i . * oO ' zs , : rs a "5 4 ' is ap aa ef 2 o 8 G ke i} 4 s nes 3 on wet ' & art @ es a ae ca ans ved a @ * a, o 9 ft gad in 4 ' od by iy ' a € as : Pe ey @ g@ £8 8 ote HB B ee = ay nm 44 ies ™ @ 5 be Oo BP 9 a a o a bs 4 bs {i oD Ba er ina @ a 4 a ~t B® Gort ook OR yt 3 oo cG 8 4 4g x io SB.
} rt 0 cs } ih G 9 mm o Ms gst ae 5 8 op HH # yw # fr tH @ ow § m9 G B UO we Get Bet GB U4 gt re ca oO GO, tf sey 6 7s . & @ 8 ® w © 5 p , 8 & "4 m Po 4 oo 9 me oO ¢ Hy tH oO 4 mn Be Dy ®o oOo @ Oo % Go GUM Re do« 7@ 6b my » OH SS st :
mo oH O '6 a OE 3s ot € 8 t& # Co Oo, 5 iH Dg yy wy 3 gg © Qi a4 Boe 4 8 2 a fe oh a God G@ GC HR EF Gxt : an So . - a va a a end od Q wo 4 ' % bas ee ery wremen 9 i me Q ch = te Grd ie "d wh OO 3 tm OM Sa OQ 6 @ wm Ww 3 rf j. 3 es 7 4 ow o Q OG rt ed ® ----- 3 i) o 4 Oo Ra ved co fo nef 5 ry mn A © 2 G bs i # ' O gi a Dy 43 448 a Go ~~ @ wer ned u a OG oO ® Bo -ri 0 = © rt re 6 led a @ / ie chy i o 2 2: Cy co wef e) met pd rs % & t+ © a wy g @ ih g ;
v i q ct 4 q3 @ : "
Qo Coo ok ed BOE 2G oOo D9 © GC a O 3 8 Q byt oS : pe fa oD 4 Hg oo
- 4 ad 45 gerog 2 i 3 Jay ap Ct :
i £ Q be © oO a GS cy Ld 3 e od fs : . ch Mm Gd '3 4 ' a i ai oe . OM as 1D ud mr ' " 4.3 @ cA et "gr a oy Neng ™ 3 nit 43 hed "3 ait * . od = ft 2 oS " 63 fet a oy a 5 a % 4 vad 2 5 * 43 o ¢ rd Go 4 th 0 3 . os en Oo eg Q ny " et ae 5 Q y '. re re t3 wee oped cs oy %% ig 3 w SB rn "4 o Hoop @ "4 vr oh a a G . 'a : i s "4 . ' w a fe 5 O p ¥ Z mY fa C's . 4 ee i t B = ef a ed ve a mS $5 a wD v eS "eo a B sks 55 . et Ow p ry 4 Qf, 6 a 1G v £5 3 D L '<3 z4 ie 3 ce "c4 43 4 O a § m 2 RP mw eg a - 6 So rf 4D 6 FO & 5 6 6 8B & y By o @ * 2 Bow . tha @ ut 4 3 Ei) fol 3 3 it i 4 a & ot G "4 O hy A 4) % a o ip o) co os a cy hs ' a BE wes ce! mo eg, OB Es fe : { MH YF GO fg
43) 4 on 4.3 té ut Cc Lon itt i 4 hy i} © od cer) G3 5 re fm 0 gy ~ & Gg SQ 4 ved rd cs ' 5 Os a a £} wn a ay ot os ot G ih = 43 en Uy & 3 "3 3 te a Go og # mt @ foc @ - gy = og G M% to Go w o » & & 2 nm Bo UM Sh om SG gov G o @ 4 a oe 3 & re wd ry ag je 43 43 vf iy yp © Oo § 6 & ch eo wv 8 AO rt eS wD i - a na GQ tt eet gent " 43 Oy 4 r et om .
9 moor mg m a "§ § © & ge = om BG & c 4.3 Oot 3 WKS o o as aa es hk w wn oe CP 6 Ht ga "e wi Bog OOM yw ek "
oO & m mm %© § ¢ a 9 * oop 8 gg & e 8 & Q} J 43 aed 4 i 0B 43 wy " 43 . Q Wop rt eg eo om & ® C 54 4 tS 6 a 4.3 gS moog qe 'i be ge O mm Fook a " o go 6 Ow © se by ge BO a SS So £ ®& & ® 4» 8 * 4 8 God" g ey * Oo » o FB g F g 9 8G oO Bs Gb om @ & 0 ; es og BS . ww PP & 4 Ss "rt 1) sy + 4 " . . : oo -m Gg f ved BC * Bl ogg @ oa & & aS op 6 7 te ow a @ 8 ££ FF & ww & 2 oa bs on Ga @ oO mm oo @ ef 5 « £ 2 Mowe ~~ OO @ fe pO 0 OD ® py BB wr & " DOU a HB re] Cy é ft 4 4 a iy a 4 a a @ 03 4 "4 ort Goo" YB G 8h A ob we 3 Od No. 62 Y ¥ e a oS » received * wed "
OL of period cond Ler © et OM x £ Y MOnNTAS £3 3 as ' is es = Beh Sam iX> xy BS + Xe ~¥s + LQ vent Pp VSvVaence Ea ae a 43 4
i) tr be te 2 oN 2 emanating aus Se ke fa sp u, aw Lee argeshee * + c gS ved 45 43 5 wt SE $3
a) $% ved oh that % 43 fv CS oy a ey omy ne the on at
-e4 .
ie Lak :
ak th, ib V oie SN iv} 01.0 on 4 | aa od ~ we ised A unauther No. F62013 Ge Q my ed pan z Fad BA Nace. Sw Lea wD ~ wie mn the 4 « ab ad ¥ Se ad exoos:
red wef a3 i od '3 a8} ihe
3) £4 £3 wm ea ot A a ge tend ot = O pt 43 wee ged.
apd a mp a 4 3 od vet doouinei Sak tf 4 3 bef O And KS co god CO eed .
hes HS i 5]
- rf a and B C3 ae Fay ANALLE q Oran:
em M 2 ors:
aS = es ved ce) "3 a ~ 4 ed $43 a G 9 «y-4 LA po oa Se present "Ch hg «mf a eh LY Ly Nef te be
a) aa > ord 44 a on ah mc r x mne ng ' + wn 3 rae:
ee hak, Rega ii.
No "
a 43 wK ts ih cod Loy ate aR 1g ~ a oe a $4 its i3 g ik OA No. $62 a4 8 "a need ag ced dated
a) EA 43 y ry se?
of ?
a 3 Ss rod uments. a:
Rac e of ao he & .
BR stated <& LS hd tf La.44
and y e ee a ri he, whe ee cho an \ Au q3 45 4.5 re te "| Oy wD ved 4 avd oo ty of ee Q penal 8 G 4 for cale = Gd aq 43 oO be, "
oy Ca dated iB + $A Gh rf » P 4 43 te S As gy 9 a { cr oi 4 u oo a wy aw 6 i} ip 43 4 @ oh, ws ity v rl s<y-f tt 43 a o bf + week of the vt ate ke pa a yreg td iG xf, ved o ri af ..
Qf oe GAA a Tribune "3 the trate e-ag ~.
A q & rr fa
23. a o> 4-3 Ran the state od aw oS g oot tw.
B oe SRT Ne as me ' s ve etek 7 Ni, I 3 iT ¢ % e ony £3 vee ted Cy of weed ty bf 4
a) A @ hee £4 w@ Mi Bed 13 (3 AG 4 4 Ke ua hea 3 bo Od No 46/2013 wy ord pha ron wf $4 say re od aes et ealed Q con BS res:
a a oped et @ MM te rec ement av A 4 2 Sa wD SS 43 as) Lte .02.2007 » CORA on cA "5 @ rd a 1 o rd 4 a AG oO hy mot go recove Fa @ he a wi .200 uy f avd 3 on 6 wy = '.
.
ne ai hey ~ hw e ect bu = os = Qh t m4 ret ue oes i fie Ld, uy a pad is.
ord he "tf i 5 i} * rd cd &S tf ip pa teog es rea red.
eco Sad ae 3 Oo 6 nd @ x Et dings SLO u} if weed "a ard a 4a wr tS a 43 th QD bd ee o eo Gj in ies: 43 et wn iy B a) 43 9] a ie Jes "4 37 a itt gS av ot mD ard 4 6 uy Y Moa qh tn a <3 4 oy Be é "ed ® a G3 i Oo €A © % cs BY 43 Q oO $y 4 wy G Pe bed Cel 6 4 Py ved ON wy @ Q (J ved ns) Q G3 cS wo 6) 0 as 43 $3 ' ay 4 ea Wy x o 43 © cl rd TS 4 Gy 3 oot aed Gey by @G wo oS Md et 'es Qe 4 Bo gd rh Et Oy eo Gh w ™ OO Gy wv "S w uy sed Ct oo ed a 64 . BD z ce) ord o : be Me iS uy OQ. < i € ce a wa as on 4) iD os) wt 4 by rs Tt a cs vg wy a gh ad wh Mg ee SED Oo 7p & & 4 Gd BO woe oD ts ced sd u 4) @ Qs rs 6 4 @ cS "to, oO A , : i », & a v a SC 'A OF G G & Ben my 8 bk oe AO ca v Ss o 4 & O@ Bb OD Hog Mop * 44 ot % M4 G ho ey ; a gs es 4 ce % ny tn a ot ed Set gy get e £4 4 ta foc 5 ew ie a Th kt $4 Po gp FS gE ga i -_ © oo DB v4 nord a Sag mt 63 "A id wes . ; rt i wo hs Rea ci '3 bo o ty " ' ' et c Ad 3 me) 3} oe od @ hes 2 . 5 neat we + "4 ey aS ode + k iS 3 4) cd rnd a oO $5 42 <d ey . 4 . Sea . ip yA "4 Q nD Td "4 ve G 2 > cD a j 43 m " , 4) m " - : re © as Ct : wy A am a on is oh 5 4 vo © 42 ue) . 'eed ke , a a vem 44 %h £3 " a iB % io tye at hy i id : t3 re 1 a '4 La % i oof Ly oy 2 O ee Sax 4 Q en eg . oe nf a . os 3 44 - i597 ry4 4 if og oO st sed : NS O 4 oO cf sas +o ad fe t {4 . ca go wy + @©@ & Go wy & mM iS OC 2 he a th o. om 49 U a cf i a Mo & tt ¢ a vp * fly OO rd orgs O o V2 Ly <4 3 ' @ aed od a, (3 re Sat at Dy @ uy "3 a aa art 4 : ~ art 5 by Me re] ad ard mw ic i AD a Bs a 4) re a as a ' go = be ' 3. tb er QB "ts is! ui ey 54 ek, 5 3 eget eet 1 cys at CH Zt on oa 4-1 Fy ek wc rr + Seat whee 21 et <4 : veed 3 Sh Cx fa RD cs t a ocd is i 0 iH £3 4 ed : aS a . } 4 ae HY . i} "v4 4 tn & q@ wy at O mS + x ea y ah . o 4 ' s ot ae) 4 4 a ~ sy fs 4 . oO 4 ht $4 ¥ w Cd 5 e OG «8 ae 5 od 2 OAM aS rho gh MD eh kn 4} r o4 ee 4.3 4 CM 57) 4 fd 4 cod 4 Pe . Ay etek og ahd uw 4 ae rol % " at rat C3 @ od &, sd G ae ie w aa » qo et sa " sf .) " 03 wh eed « rey ba oO "3 - wed a oe bs ih Sq tt 4 wy De « wz oA bt «4 O aA ' 2 GO PF GO gi UY GB Hg Syed fo 0 8 a4 es fh ce Sy oS @ gm at a oa G, + @ ws ep ted B® a - 4 co a mp Oy, oC 5 DU 6 BG o M UG yok a, 4 Om wt ed UG A HG w mo oe rt ®t got ot ~ 43 TE my Gd ot £ pp og rn B © Fh 4 vy 4 Ds om bb © i a ao ort rs ay 4} gs a) i oe i So "rt } 5 O wh Bt © red aa w oO FI c ced cy ' AG a wh of t med ow wo 0, Oo 3S mt 43 "4 Ch at a ri & a O 43 Y 43 w ih te: $3 at on a % Oy a a we oe} ws 4 ts ch 4d ' a "4 43 be z3 s oO "et 3 ef iy ic adi 5 a 4h 3 us wh @ thd ved m a 44 et vr be, A 2 pes am gS £0 «S, $e he <4 4s z GO © tt My i mh © oC Z O.40°20 Od N Sef AD ty we x or et * oresaid sme few aw he sta e A 4d rd wyef
a) 3 am i @ ot bos oy uda Gar 4 hi ES wd 'O ist oy MH §O oH oH
(s) ea rd "
& ae @ zt $3 tn ID ao ce xa 4 foods responden eed at Soy Gl 43 Oo ci) Ly a = ~ x tk ing ' 3 aur or 4 AG vl x no Pacrar cnt = Nat ne ad ke Co QB 3 ~ 4 pa} M4 Ets] 4 1G et ard G ~ ! oD bed © O 3] &4 a x placed o 4 a 4 ved Le fi) 3 O or} ¥ e ana wah ROU a of X oh "A a] ef 3 wp u i aod ard BS be L ¥ * yr tea Give s '2013 Od No. $6:
Z we 16 uf gh * oF 3 hed "H 6 cc w ce ws i os 4d a wy . 43 hd yy ud wy os . a oO ¢ ww 8 @&@ Oo @ @ GC ch & oo coy a a > © os es 53 a) nas o 4s 4 th) QO rf wy 43 4a Bd Th 63D $ tp se B cS w 3 ts ao of Ag a #3 " ty Db het Os Nog ip MN mo ny a @ 6 ws a th , 8 uy Ea my ~ @ a o ae My SO go8 & Pa HOP a EO wm OB eo se a 3 ey me oD do : MoO LF 3 y 9 OG mM Mm gy ; toe 4 ae red i "se rt ' eS; C3 eH] ~ (3 ae + M O eng Cy ¢ § 8 8 2» Bo EB 8 m oo» § © 6 gs GS wm G& & 4 a. 7 cA nt 4 & Me ro Lf 63) a ihe " L" 2 $ ) " " S : apd " % 3 "4 re se oO a ied 3 at an LB a3 hed a 3 6 ca + co ® 43 Oo us ref ® ef rk et OD lg Bag ts Bie ed : ; o sé a as oy CS oe $3 q rf os , an D as a ¥ 5 G 4 5 EB wy 03; @ ot 4 hd Th a @ e O @ v " ahi we 3 3 '4 xo ig wo ° - oe Ms 43 © 5 ; ord . As "3 ma £5 % ih @B G iw, .
re os "a + rot wd @D 3 3 > r en oe a) @ Dp a im 7 va od . . gn . ~ a Sot - ig vee ba 43 uF ued t2 * co itt q@ ty hd ord @ . Ad wire 4.3 it 53] : 44 ae . 0 @ a a t ta a ew 8 6 #& @ Be Go et 9 @ fe og § @ i eB | < 5 a 3 ie anf t2 et te, c $4 QD im A AS eS 0 Ret GC Pp GC SC G@ § 2 2 6 B oy 8 OF G6 Go Mg Bg ed om ® rd os 5 w oh 4 3 0 Bo Eg 4 gp tgs ay @ ts he bs Oo, ot i. m3 > 8 © : i t a OQ 4 i YH. mo ort og FO ed pane Se GR at a3 a ry ws i oC Dp aa wn TS 53 ' Kf Pe vcd ee) w 1D £4 if ht 43 a 2 0 BO O sp BB me Bo OES PB ow Ge OG 8 B8 Yy © '7 ei $4 e ce © 4 43 4 4 yA 4 oo a gt ' a iD 4 i ns) Be gO Og 4 ) rea 64 Qe gg a ® os ms A a a) ~ q Wo G 4 1» OU ted @ 43
4) ~ co g Uo og ry wy sy CS " tt mS wt * got 4 o . a i & A MO ae bea qed cS me we SC ge 8 Bot & BB og 4 oo gg ® cho hy ch OBO So gp Be ee ag oF & a Got gO O ve mw & ce a 4 - 3 e "> ms ths * © oa my is be a ra io pe o G 43 wn 4 oo HS ow © & GC go & fhe" sD >
5) 4A 4s ; + 4 'J ord @ ae 4 a x Guy 2 KG aw "4 uF dt ony 4) ba oO cf ry © 3 @ 2 $a rel 3 a 5 as ry O BB 3 & 8 oS Se we og og g a tS ri UG 6 @ Se OK "aaa hs aC A * ce Cy ord 45 O ol * . My 45 * @ th as ved 5 5 3 a 43 { f oi i y DB fe :
- = ar oe - ~~ i 4 ved - " 4 4 wd OA , Boop Bb @ 4 oe 8 BG «a & %$ ow ~ 2@ Mee ma Wy rs) w co ~ os a fy mt oo Oo a i ag ff ay - "tS ord
6 a td by a e w a we ™ ty ord Q ' « @ 43 tye i i wt 0 8 o @ 8 HB Bo om gs - - 'OG & Oo 8 OO & 8 8 % go a wet ard be be 4 cs o =P rep cy Ss re +e w "ed o 43 8) Bs & &s m | v4 wo C3 fd 3 be wed my C3, Ad ved hed sot w 44 k4 3 A i} © O 8 = my Red ag * ms * a By ' "3 Sy a Be 43 hd oe a 0, Ke my 7 CO ra a qG? 43 mSY Oo {-~ iM a @ Oo O Oy O oD 4 5 sed orf & oa reat re rae) sy Ma iS 43 ce: nD aa) x} a Qh 3 fe ys OD ag 4 $4 oy ny te e % {4 mf oO ' i oe @ "C 43 © 43 tH ay ry het go AS ss Bt OS Et i 6a, a 54 w gS Se @ ms S 2 a O bea 4h ord Wy vat © 3 & ga i et ea Ad 3 ri) Do i] ris Y a 44 sed ues 43 ved Ss oy bo i © ae & i a a 0 5 rt G fe £3 ng ed _ bed es CO Wm a « OO ow a) 2 D » uw BP a a Gg tS SR og 6 g Boo w § 6 2 @ 8 re m4 A % Ad O ilk 43 rn ug it Ch wy in G 1 @ Py x f3 . a) * CG ; 7 43 0 nas 4.5 a oq % ci By hy 5 ' A co Oo 8m em om ey Bt He Ug BO » 9 & ¢ a ; 3 $3 gn 4 co tt. o Ch 3 o "dl 4 S t} v eo "4 eH mc 9 re : : ; 6 t 3 aa ts ed + * co ot of BB Be © Bo 8 BM oy BOS ®t oy O24 ef iw ' at ord a us e oa 4 ' ren wy - vpf O Pes ef a 4 a $3 3 @ " o we ba @ Fog es $s Cc ow cs wn ws wy "Bo i } 3 @ 43 & / o eon ~ oF dt i t . 4 oO as 4 ct Sg a OB ° Y » Fo op GO gg & G ff £=- ge & OB so Ge Hoo Es om 4 GH OG gO w % © & 8 se © G& 8 8 4 * a © @ 13 reed Ji Cs a 4 al O C4 " w na , @ & wo a G eo o b FT Bom Sg 3 Wo ge @ ~ A oe By 8 Be ow 2 oO eG Sg, 3 ™ ot cis - " wy e oD ty 43 wf bd &4 - he my et Os ap jn oe 2 & 8 S&S 6 ®@ @ Bb Oo 9 mm mm 8B wm f is se A ES o ® po iy é A a a] ai 4 B = 6 Co a ; Ps et by tt @ ced ~ 3 a rr Sa ha ae 4 '% a uy § ' p a OM 6 rn a} ay 43 eed O i. set td in Ay te 5 "3 or} i~ pan ch St Q a v 43 eo RAR 4 3 wm , a » om : 'eC ~ 1 a ~4 ry Aa eat is o id cht a3 44 ® a ard 1x3 © a st 2 er ES i M4 ve g c ; ; ify Oo 4 ryt wo ie c ¢ as to yt Qe: 43 4 * a w . 3) eG ted 42 o Q Ht " oe mn g @ be 4 "yt 44 D . i & oO ti © 4 $4 'g Ae ® vg c Oo 3 we 44 ne os , 3 en 4 a . & O Sy $3 "a ° , Bo 8B Q O 4 6 £ 6 SB Y & @ yoo v i G4 ® o 8 8 ti Hoo P 5 go Qo. & mood ig , 8 8 BG te gy A Se gg B > © & ad 42 a a) th & A g 4 ' tit a 3 en or} aa a by n Mi m Ses tj Ag OO o SG a ot L Oo a @ o i m3 4 a Be x 13 @ fe 43 43 a my fo 3 ref & 2 @ w ry Fea] "a cp + + if Q «ss x3 45 Mt uo w 3 #2 rc mM 4 o 2 ea m™ 4 cS 3 xg at Cot 2 co ns Hoes Om Be et gem BR gop ow OO # pD @ BY OG M SS TR ch @ , * oO pp & oe wv th we Oo G WwW O f * wy G M4 g 3 & i 3 ef on M4 if o w@ aed mM od si) aa n wv 3 . i) @ @ cf © 6 ce) fy 4d Oy A 43 a oot o AS a tn ao ©) 4 hy * ie rt iS im ved ved q 3 wy ta ity nam} : G St "rd iy O a 's) m ord % ord a uy @ o eG Oo aw w DB Ka M cr} i oF is 'ot sa Oo © mS ) m4 oH Sef 63 bef im wy a 4) Ye} m Me 4 2 Cod my 18 tr Li read a nr the bef «3 oss @ $4 wy rod rf ny u a g rs As Oh 4.3 rn hes sr oO 0S
8) Med
3) M 3 a 6H
3) 4 ved 0-4 4 43 Ee bd ri hee se} Cy Ry pea id by uy Oo 1D Md , ~ C cy 83 2 > ved ed chy "ed See at th $4 ote fe cy wf of aoeut Formed GO ih c being Pe A wv i %
9)
2. G i} xed i vy i
i) S bt Es $f ee ea hod Ry ms ed afd RRR 6/2013 ¥ @.
OA N 19 3 m y a at ot See sor ds 44 @ ua :#) Os ped 4 g Ad ey a + wh bicant bbs ott i Os} uo t te, aN} fa O eed et Y & "s rhe x x called wy i "poy a ree
a) 2 ved CAD asked to recover "4 a ef a3 J rs aed at Ba eB;
4 oa Ks So wy @ $4 @ is ryt af
a) if} of theg 4a 5a t3 eed rod % ty G} ae $3 B fs fs effect % to cs o Oey oF 2 of ae) vge4 6 en F6/2013 Ld 20 ip "a in op ry G Cy wn ved ot hs fe aed 3 vt <t 5 uy Q ren} ¥o a3 3 m aA a on x «x3 rd 3 D $2 $4 yy tc erg mess + c & a rt co i oy
a) xy cM Nn te ONS 4.3 a ty $4 024 % or "t weed ct weed $3 itt aoe @ i} a ig q} vet my @ a rf Oy End yet mt Od te Cog 5 oY =e} ard £53 ce et Bile Tp Pa SS *~ A wy ve set it ont ty we Ne ere a ot ag irs Haat Nt gare mo eg re uy ered t case 5 i Sh % i ip oe £8 Ly G Ta Le arf Aa .
5tee eee a at chet ro a 5 @ Q, 43 ud i ool oO %, 4 wo or an tt) qQ £3 reg Ct tf} wy v3 @ G we oot 4 aN ve} 8} G QD XS ™ £3 ae 5 Ad 40 bt if w #43 SSS G13 oy Nod cad rm + oer "rl "oe ae Bea BA 38} Gy 43 tt es :
4
Rak sim wd of ag {) "ed $4 in a 4 1G "+ fa "
ct z vo) 423 th * ¢ =e we Ls ny {3
x) tua:
x Lijay:
(BR. V (Ravinder Kaur) K oa Me@ier {A} Member (7} REE EEE oo seceeneuen ceca ean ganaauecaeacaeaseanesassessuse