Karnataka High Court
Sri Indu B Srivastava , Ifs vs Sri Avani Kumar Varma Ifs on 1 July, 2011
Bench: K.L.Manjunath, H.S.Kempanna
eo THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE K.in AND | THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE F 8 LS KEMPANNA, hoot uw ae Jowell Gone a a ve Fan | : . + es S/O LATE RAM SHANKAR SR AGED 5OYEARS = PRINCIPAL CHIEF CONSERVATOR OF FORESTS (HEAD OF FOREST-FORCES) - KARNATAKA, ARANYA BHAVAN, 18TH CKOSS, MALLESHWARAM ©. a) SRLAVANI KUMAR VARMA IFS y & AGED 58 YEA S/O LATE HC VARMA, PRINCIPAL CHEIF . CONSERVATOR OF FORESTS (PCCF) & "MANAGING DIRECTOR, STATE FOREST INDUSTRIES CORPORATION,VAN VIKAS, 18TH CROSS, MALLESWARAM, BANGALORE 560 003 2 ae east LLIZY Je ' 7 & te : UL. Py a a & S =
ead % A a z ch Ba ae :
a peg Pod » nag FS fA:
os 3 LL ey? ee PN. eit - ae) en AR OO Ec = | Oo fw ae oe a me "roe De ge ult '.
Le re ig ode weo Pa OGEE WS? ot: JO i Zim "224 ne Foe <b ws i Fé Woe UO bef ib :. . " en " pace a -- e) ine a wen ee ny a < mg S622 e¢2 a u) + 2+ age. <n ee GO uee Heezgs Sas | fe. «eth EeterO OVE aoe (oO yp ame. oe ue"
Wei WWO Fpugec « e i >- Ooaez wot F-mnoae so wero ms $ uy ast es vu 109 HOI WVLYNYYN AO DINO MO wlewiwAnrery WA Dries Lamia writers Gm niece peeeue Dy Wuncursuun vuuesas can Wena mae wemuree aes reo ages £ dil! ages "oll Stuns ce sans foal Sans = -
sal :
< a i Sol ahi ot & i
--
ie g sh )
-
stool . ae cn oe ge a & @ oe a gis i< e @) a) ass 'vr sa . e . ss ' re & - ff OS f& we F c
2 om se ae :
"a sis : Shease edlssos 7 frome , senugee Rood ey ~ we. @ S o ry oO o f£ Bud a el end os i fn 7 oD an . acint <* % SOS % a ' ASG, ed ¢ wales e- ' ein . oe Socw i « . iy : ana 2 4 sae ge "
Pan 'odin : 8 om a) A) "en wa id say ae oe sone a " "a - a Ban apse . od mu a" = . Cp o ey a 4 i) sgl 7: . 7 Q. a "oe = © whom :
soos A tins.
"age ye sontess
3) Sinn a 2 a 2 ey 4 2B Awa a) seine ' Joong ey Baal one ; en
- °° wa «+X -
g @ 2 ui e sf ag + "adbeadl e
- YU o 2 a 7 ra » + to 4 é "
cn " -- a a e = - 4 as ce ene ' : oy, ; ~ ey a a od oe "dial ¢ " £ os Aes & é i) JHDIH WIVLIVNUV dO LUNOD HOI VWIVLVNEVN JO LYNOD HOIN woIVreNNYY an piAAs wal wuwiesieu A DURA pines ek ih Ou nnn ecw ee oe = " Bs ra) 8 'am hud = RS i % > on wi a Ss - Fi . oh @ 6 v) 6 oS "eo _ Salon Mo spay Hs, sllnies gp _ = =) Pa oO c "
wanes "
ee 8] a ws ue mr ?
is SN Boos oN om GR st a t ea wood a ; eal cx Koa! ' Ls) : as Soe heat uy -- @ . ' om rs) Pal c oe 109 HDIH WIVLYNAVN JO LUNOD HDIH VVLVYNUV) JO LUNOD HOIH VIVLIVNUVN JO LUND HOI VYVIWNVY 40 Iwan MAL WW IWR AO TM Ley D ' = cntosess sous! ro ' » Blow! ns ie) - ca "yo Sate :
id i agponnel vo oy pry ' ory ~ ragaige Sey sie Gu. TH 2 is 4 © .
oO sg .7f GES i ce © a: ae : con G & ie rN Toke
-_.
Wi As) = x =-~@ 6 >» © @ " oe hoa" . na 5 " & c a G o th 3 6 £3 g20 "Be.
, > Bb bf So ee eee a ee, abvadl Caine aysong bso heh, some Aeagat™ 2 HDIH WAVLVNAV JO LUNOD HOIH VYVLVNUVY dO LUNOD HOI WIVLVNEV 40 DINAH werennn A INARA ties wantin nee cn cee n kaw 94 % 5 ompletion of sevacor of Forests Adan ' é Mae urteen years of zg ad a A oe ines regarding if d tre 'of the Service in = Ow.
wo Co Ps © g 6 © a c q © ore Ke ae dso 109 HSIH WIVLIVNYVY JO LUNOD HDIH WIVLYNYVN JO LUNOD HOIH WIVIVNYEVA JO LUNOD HOIH VIVIVNUVH JO Larios HOIBVIVIVNYYN JO LNOS HS =-- 4 w . a a sessceane gM ue val cl re a Bie a aR gun y -- seems soos % Soong a ey a oe L.) .
ses % 4 a aa Cal j . ' % we c fe a o ce _- be PS x, as o8 2° see HSI VIVLVNYVH JO LYNOD HOIH VYVLVNYV) JO LUND HOIH WIVIVNUVY 40 DINAT EI Wrenn aA Adc cemete Coeeeec cee. ¥% wah | Vanoat tonal
--
took Sad 5, {2 '] hail =
--
2uw ned S wath a a a ee -- OW Ose sol . wot fon Boos sates od " oom a Mh oy ae @ io . oe ty, ae «f oauaats ales sais gig, Risen --_ BO sees Those Sq Meewan wos ES sss anoreatoe
-
ares dud 103 HOU VAVIN NYY a LYEAOs MEI YNVIVNINYY 1 IMAM LECLa WAP Eerarwrer wr Gr. DEER PK LORE ESD otek PRED Ham MM ee om om Bo Rom uw wasn we oan me cuon ema as te of Boe Gove ta & & esi addaung - =) <4 Ge .& yi, Bosco ba pnd Rinsenaeel 4 or ~ " we ® a Boas sa Anew a fa nd Me i] te 2 a ree Lc aod a5 te Go nw o geen uae x x a if iP Joe a uy AU S = Pa = @ @ a M gosteee ' olsen rw 4 Brow one er eg, oo, w i re) _~ oa ha mS ab ee , a cdiosk ee ne goaty ™ = (te oO 2 HOI WIVLVNAVY 40 LUNOD HDIH WIVLYNYVY) JO LUNOD HOIH WIVLVNNYY 40 PHN Hel wrorenpren aA wah usw PRR RUE ENE Om ome Sa ee 3 3 9 thant ey ia ae 'oe nd al 7 mm sahondl @ oS © * te Aloe aed & " Ne oO 6 A " ie ' _ c 2 5 o = = Go eo SS -- _ al ™ Gj a "i ©O 4 'y" % I 109 HSIH WIVLYNYVY JO LUNOD HOIH WIVLYNUVH JO LYNOD HOIH WIVLVNUVN JO LYNOD HOI WIVLVNUY™ 40 Lund. HOIHNDIVEVNAVY dO LYNOD HO Ag a cc ' . . oa ~ w 6 os © 8 ad ct sas «) ona cr Was not al Ae oF alent s 4 eS a %® 7 Go ¢ 6 ee seins wise ' cee eh & x a 6 GP eons * hood shee - ce < g at the mo 40 on, "i, = G a i % a & 9g se e oy pr, t is 3 : ¥ = ~-- oa -- ue Foe wa a @ om sees ' ss % " ie ce £ -- ~ hog a Co vs hod AER ona G o oz . wi 2 G s » BL a = = safe ey soso a) ia oo Neg ay Rosse Cs oo 2 8 os . .
oa Mow kad )HOIH WIVLVNYVN dO LUNOD HOIH VNVLVNUVY JO LUNOD HOIH WIVEWNNVY do DNAS Wan were; aan PURAA tina eal Wate WEAN Woe we am am ea ae ~ § 7 aa EA aS por Bead) POM ol Savas ws ue sans one fee me 5 poe asses Rod poset on be seo mg shu WON Se, S O39 HOI VIVLYNYVH AO atNOO HOI VOIWLYNNYO AO INAMS Lm wewiernrwerd GA Erm caeesey Krcuenumneaenme cm ne wee ae eo Saoatl pas 'Esoass Sey) deal 4 VY @ a a £ ee s 3 i c 's ae san sdb Av] Shes ¥ a £ easasvase Baal Lo) ng eas hod "
. & mS . '3 ey Bom _-- a A .- ood © ae or] ons ' 4 es on wine :
| hand ws son " ee = ' o . Sos lho Neca wos F. Ke oo : Le) AS te : . ey oe a i?
= () ih = s oS Side " Tacs " a Sood "ee dig ee .) ~ Ad shoot mS . foe 4 "3 '*) ee som bet he = iw " : i i «3 oe i sos o @ coayate .) Sgt © i ate ae = a . :
@ 5 5 a on ts ee i ay o a ae gg rashes ae an © z 7 i en Co ase ; e : 4 . a ew Pa Pi ic ~s os 8 Xiwos x a on ©. € a =) . 2) eo £ § @ Bove alos! JHSIH WIVIVNYVH JO LUNOD HOIH WIVLYNYVH JO LYNOD HSIN WIVIVNNVY JO DNA wan ewer; aA Una LOANU A WOKTHT TR ERO Gum a ew oma woum oe als & ws Be yous ee Boyes w dd on Pr a sen spy 8 Skene GPK, 'Seg Pa Mec eo oo © uw Wo oh agence .
ae Bs we eo to
-
a tho Bouse AI ~ % .) _ . = Aes o€ B Te) § Goce a icathon woh fot shes a Sethe ssc Ay a 8 soe You ee .
x * Wag agin ' . toe sgn sSonei No! whens agus 1OD HOH YNVLYNAV JO LYNOS HOI WIVEIVNYY AO DAMA UM ween GR UR RA Die nen ms nae oe ee 8 hall Ronee Oo 2 w ) > w ow oe Ty ans 3 2 % @ § cs oo 5 oh °e@ é per : se sliee ees. PAS . Sow . on "
dual ee, y . ey -- y % _ % & ay 4 oO o fs) z low i i ~~ G & we o = c . ri G ra = oy ays 3 C Toca woe wlio ayy | sa :
adoell wn JHDIH WIVLVNYV JO LUNOD HDIH VIVLVNYVN JO LYNOD HOIH VYIVEVNIVY In DAA uA wiwiwaniwe oA DUAAA press Shh Od edn Ree ew we ' ob shod"
sqm ssSdhonys @r@s oso C sez @ slid =
--
a a Seal Sin = on sos vl srl Weevesn w Ne ge 7 ' sabe.
si = wo oH ee =~ apse Py i Rosse a og sng 109 HOI WIVLVN YY 40 LYNOD HOIH VOAVIVNYYY JO UNAM WO ww wren we ae AAR comnts cae ee eS a ae a & baal nS Ne ow _ ge S900 a . sine hol we eet, gece a dog - uO PH one -, & YEAg 4 0 gee ave. + w 5 heae Sam ey us shai . seat ; a a = oe me . s -- X& ae duo a ; ie) Suh ve coo ; J a fone es vo Oss a _ if Ha Sup sven see aM a we oo Q Se ses ey : % i. ae { se a. a a on c bush pe ol ee Rey oe ) ae on =
-- : " ho St cc , i "es gramell = nT X rw) : oe - -- Se Sosant fat "a coon Bod (O es a ag " ne yo a Ssollos & ' is soos yn, vag « sag ie sling! rs a io . . ; 'oss co ASheols is alles AO a'. 2 per OE 48 hed Gad oo ane 4 § " & a : . 7 a i. * ee q hl @ @ & yore Le wp ro alts mr sbiecee caring "a sel ey ¢ _ :
a s ts fs ~~ . a a - _ <
a) oe od ha Athena gpoey « , o « i) ry 0G @ oe % one a a ond ns a co soa! ee = thea veg . + = he tl Aa Sasa 'pss Oy ae og iy a , F ae co Ss a a3 OR allo alheadl J HOI WIVLYNYV) dO LYNOD HOIH WIVLVNUVy JO LUNODS HOI VWIVLYNNYY AO DNAs ue wuiwiiniens ca bere ee a? ne heal by & Soon oo a a a i 5 "
: " " g r we _ = cn a. o gy Se we w a hos e RO A. Re Saed) , 3 ; a Hone Row & vy @ i @ se vet re) ee etnge Nis aoe 109 HOIH WIVLYNYVN JO LYN ns OD HDIH WIVLVNUVN JO LYNOD HDIH VAVLVNYVd JO LUNO? HSIH WIVLYNUVH dO ino HOIKVAIVIVNAVS JO LUNOD HE cr eee £D on wo .) © @ + 7 ie "
Bea ve pom f= ae ve Seve . ™ a, ee Raw = cy " ip ass Da é 15 - (~? 2 3 8 a a " = Le eS, ae £ 's) cc ee Nowe a x £ im ¢ Ss ee "pai 4 ;
a m "Gy rd ; a = in ~ . ar a Ae at yo B 8 th oc a bk 3 c c U Q 5 sa 2 HSIH VOIVIVNUVA JO LYNOD HDIH WIVLVNYV>! dO LYNOD HDIH WIVLVNYYY 40 DINAD WAT wiwiwannens aA DURA sintes Cane eee o- eos a pee ost Kew ae 3 RR os «3 = _ ' ONE e | : o 'Sioa : on a = : ee : Gro g rose ~ aati % ie) .
ra) x ' :
: , Reise rae * :
= ed ~ * abun : fot we oe & 103 HOIH YOV.LVN UVR SO LANOD HOM in WOrVLv YV>l JO LUNOD HOIH VHVLIVNUVY JO DINOD HOM wawrwnwe 4 : .
: 4 PSA VAL Peers ae a Lome oe : © es uy ke oe . Ge fol a2) -- WI ¢ '5 ro id os P tr ude < 4 =~ Qe stheew! "y 68099 'get y oveos apes agen eg idea ll oh .
hese hoo © : nn ss one . et rc 2 oom eh sete ve i.) on as ed Sse sey AGO . AGREE ue oe Eee ce a : 7 Soon os gy 2 mS alec aw aha egos 9 HSIH WIVLVNYV) JO LYNOD HDIH VYVLVNYVY 4O LINOD HOIH VAVINNAVH JO LYNOD HOIH WIVLVYNYVN JO LuNn95 HOH WILVYNEVY 40 PHONO Ue Ew aS o swesees a .
103 HDIH WIVIVNYYY JO LYNOD HOI WyiviwNNYY an se A ;
qi bins ey .
shecal sons lino Sea ee agg :
Aes 6 se % e BOS pre to 7 Bre) Soon see Reaves acca LJCRI Le We ee GU Py 8 cee e slew abel ses Oe ee Ra ie) Whee Reeg <e > xt CA.
ce oe ox es oom cn a) 4 .*) ¥ & fs - c a = fs 3 = ane oc age - hens ee Fa] , wll © D @ g eh "
Koo! Basen ~ i 5 _» OS 'Snes ; BGs ove govm : Boos ees Dace & & 4 s & ces ~~ 3 0 © 2 ~~ we at ae ge wy a oH a a i tee @ , = ao & S rn os : oF ig om _ & c Fat v = oa , GG & © , = ] 2 2 & ®
a) ra) ba = ® 3 ~ oe 2 = "th es we : :
hol Se to . ee ese © we 9 HSIH WIVLVNAVH JO LYNOD HOIH WIVLVNYVY JO LUNOD HOIH WIVLVNUV 40 LYUNOD HOIH VNVLVNYVN JO Luno? HDI WIVIWNUY 40 LUNOD HO 4 'wed ne c uo fates thes ante on Boon " .
wey --
esE ahyn iy eo:
vem eine 5 a er .) iS @ Sooke uf "y eet ooo dad Moone Sategy an) om | hid} Cm a 8 £ :
as a Soon be) comes See a WOOD HTH VOIVIY NU 19 LeTVOD HOI YYVLVNNVY JO O89 LE wenwrwarese Ge aren omom eens Gumanene ween we a wa ce shod se © a sss ay dead?
ed Bassline obesil a dest pote sd pane sgt a * Spaond:
oS e oe wa @ pis :
1 Sag F t abhoat eae goon adBoasss @ pone uy _ Mecow oo As, alin o aed WBE Was banc sad) Sage vail 8 ARES one ong Ch re 9 HOIH VIVLVNYVN JO LUNOD HOIH VIVIVNUVY JO LYNOD HOI WIVIWNOIWN dO DiAAT Lat wieiwanws oA udind PORE Loken ens wees or wt gab Be cv oy alow APA wena my @ apex scale i 2 a a 2%, 809A, g spate, gre Te :
nso hres Boat yg 8% . fs i 2 . "= ; erg 8 venl ; Sie? aisosl gions see - re eet Awe ce i 0 8 2 tl 1d HOI WOrVIVNY YD 40 LNOOS HOM YW hw 42 DESO LE were Ge me Deer Werke ee URN Fo He moe Gum wn un onan sue we neon me
--
aston Moons shad?
i e's | ine 'scaioe Soe oO py 4 a8
a) hud ageoall spe py ra want Sooner fia) oc = oo ww al ie 'hol eo cc whe ey ted as .
heal ed @ a é % .
RAD . --_ "=~ ogy Ros ee ~ wa, ae ec Eevee , sebennee J uo Na cosas be oo oa L*) ea aaioaiKs. = oi head a wo aL 3 oC @ 3 : "ke aR * pe 7 S Le "5 Ln bed sehen Hori?
Moon oo swingin Asse .
3 = @ -- Sad a im ae x = Wow 2 GS LS w +3 -- olin or aw w id Swe ae J HSIH WIVIVNAVY 40 LYNOD HDIH VIVLVNYY 4O LYNOD HOIH VIIVIWNNY do INnjas uate wavieniins iA cunlnn cenece coe.
"09 & Si, pa ble gon hewn 4 Aecthone LO WO Www JA INA LE WOU A EA LI SR RR I TVA Ue Weer ew 2 OWA LOILEWw YW DRI 2 PMO Lat a Vreo Pa id «© 3g hens 3 sa a 'add e 294
- wy oo a hoc x oud IB o = eo) ey omy hea ay . eet, .
Sa oe "nga as ae Docs 1a fo Mista sett Wage re --
ue --
a psa se gS, . ' Segeagi ~ te ' s aw "envi " es etn a 5 & Rg, wes Aa al x Bonug ae sth ae ~ cd 9 HOIH WIVLVNYY dO LUNOD HOIH WIVLVNYVy 40 LUINOD HDIH VIVEVNYVYY SO DINAH wean GA DUAAA tines cance cee | fe ae © ou . # , eg re : ee of *, escnons " ae one a avail Nee eh aN 44
- 2 8 dues wil ER me a a
i) es "i "om «he * ae _ & cr & > ie a Mbsadlos oe £ ey rl o A ops * oer hee a es a rs re © 'len VOD HOU VOVLYN YN Le) LE NOD HOM VV LINNY AQ TNA LAL Wawi www 4 PAs OE Keren women om aa me oS = . wy? a 'sso ea we ns oI cg a "
, a i 6 a Al me or Ss es ae ° " 2) a < ~ afb Rg 4 hued "
eB ae PR Peg ie .
Tosh & -
seo ass aselese ~ 7 Pe averment ~ ue ' sine 'Ss Si od ® ] } sos a , So 'a Aye 2 ye sso sBhece Quast 2 HSIH VIVIVNAVY JO LYNOD HOIH VWIVLVNYVY 4O LYNOD HDIH WIVIVNAWN JO DIMA Limi wnrieanins GA scien tumeee Gaeceec nee. ssed LE wilt . a cs Pe, & %q ote eos fo Fw) i A ac ee .o a ce : 8 Ne bene oe oO ha ay & Bona) Le) oe is eat {HO LO Wwe ANN 2M EMA LE wri 2 PO LE WWE WRI OO IMA RL We Pew OM DAO LEEW ln UU TR Le the wd wv - < « % r sous agg . ; o m= =e «= &® o£ vie "
ssc: Banat i eS ae ee eo = £& is Tet "
a _ 3 _ ee teow y co & a] te e se > & A ¢ i % ss sant F 5 ns pe eo Ps me £ oO - @ os © ioe a = . eo aust ep as es { S & & sesystes ig z a & be Se.
Raw o dat i Booces, 6 wm Hoos =~ st &s ad ond?
aBusil os ony cd ssa Qos ~~ a ae _ ded f i decal hei = 5 ideas st 'Me _ nad rv .
® choad ° ® F w £ 8 rg Q _ " x ves g Siseas = 3 a DO HOIH VWIVLVNYV JO LYNOD HOIH VIVLVNYV 4O LYNOD HDIH VoIVIWNYY 40 INNA WEI wiwnennnwe aA DURA tenses Caen eee g ww 4 © c
--
Sd & a aa a os siete . ee IRN cn. & -, id
--< aoe
-- iow oo) ne ig, Nay ga Povsptond oun & © ony c 2 a a bs 8 ws es &d aoe Doves oe
-
oineente = oe @ owe ale! ~~ as oie es ao 3 anor A Ww = -_ . ape 8 2 = CG CG om on 7 tow % a = o @ 8 E a 5 x i Lawes Sat adios ay ook 1° HOM WWW ONIN JO PVA LID www ZF TIVO LEA WWI ROW 2 EMO LL PRAWN GR IATA LEO ere ee ren Tem ae