Central Administrative Tribunal - Cuttack
Srikant Chandra Sundar Ray vs D/O Post on 23 August, 2023
. ~ ~ > por arenig x haw we pe dood i a Oe ea oad tot a pong tovies tA aa rt, a wee oan a, v4 ft cad wet: pew' ben waka drodt oe * a3 oe ee on Sani wha 4 fen hes on ' ", » nat = we ss Le ae a ss cme Loe re fate, a a for p os fee A ry cen mm Rane ' bad ft vet pecs we ty famed Pete wa sea ratie wd soot oo fay Ne, is > ;
oe ee be, Le pee The « gee ' ae, cos) mo a fee Ms % ke enn, el peas Pigs' a . ww es vanee ba "er oe * Pod Ho ihe fy:
wyee, 4 Fan] rye ere, A ; a 4a 2 i a3 perm ee arene 5 iad pone Clb My * :
we pat a: as et on oF 'at oa Snowe pas Vt ne Saaiew woore ae ~ poles eee (oa oe fe oe, Ae
2 oe a o ve ~ hoc re pee Real + dene = a, Poe hee pos oe 'seo nent! oe onl, % we to. eos pe ae oO we om m mes beste aa pees 'nade 42 ee ee, xt 6g a poor & aid bd on, fpeeeee, meen had peaurs yee cae ~ * oe tea 'nore apy eee . ee < 'ee, 2 os Laie, Lea yn we AY 0% 1d Cf wee awl nat vr ged "~ Vt na? La ws aot Dy se, a;
capeed ry herb gem OS an t 3 AL pon brine . nett sos ' peers ie meenees tart. pny wight pra ones 7 a an at = a 2 Caste" nen, a ed "tat po os, ge Leena) 4 wn yore on ayo Nema rd, * wwre,, oS cll tes me ¥ nnndk noes ret ae or, a Ms eed ben, Ly £ oe a mee "5 fe Se a por ee 7 4 a 8 a: fi aed ae ed er:
4, . fen, ee i Vote Fae; ait ates a wy ant pe ae we es rs:
oat ees ead pes anes ury Poal freee 'nt os ier ng foe or gh oo ' Need a we ot OF ; Py facah Soe Faas Fines 4 Set be ped 2 basal oe Ls _ anid ee whew Ey #3 pn} ae * ee eo] ee vat oy 4 we ht apt vate Newel i:
oa, wheal nee Sond pity pars wi ak see ne, hs Bred Nenad Eat Se ane foned, ote oe ' Fates Poh cae' t "Ne, Les wea nine, oy om " Pe Bag on ae as oot ed Tish wt Vee aan oe Renee, wes a, Nor tant pet. nore, Me poe 0:
io wrens con e Si ee % . ' ne ne on 2 ne aman Po "s ees pn, 0f9 one, Son oy, fee, 5 n4 . pen " Sond * fed feet Z 4 ;
won CAs ee, oe baad ae) hy sos ; oy "ny, St Eo ay ut pa ve ay ae ine) 2 5 re a ie Cy ~ bn revee ment e 4 oa = 'of Sy ie sad bes et eed ay ay eves, pouers wey need pated 'sa yon, Lo oe ee 4 ete, ast Dee wet foe pnd, r ome dood sped nee yor boon) ona é < a, ae - + we Ms ane cat bee TP hg eres a padre.
pened, ~ =e ress , ae og sees Boe a 3 me "
Frage?
host we Fae) Foo} ye L cast poe CORAM:
en Hey Py se os, Fest eds Stee en. in, rene we a npn, a ez) Om ih po oat ine aed Sad 'el a Teed tl Sea yaeor el oe bes f a ead ie &: nee bac ae ne Gp cad Vor "ek Sab Ake duoth coon z ee os, il sae 3 a 4 So a iy os : neerit 3 th ' + bees La Ree * fer oy Sad C4 ea on wee Noe wet Pied ot, cand we wa aoe, ee on, LX age eed pete, ow ta igh 3 Fe pee St ih, ay yaw oo, tee tad bas a Fame x Caneel' iol Dhewe. Sa? oat os ae ee. ares Ot. the bon Be £4 ee, tones taal $5, 4. "seit. : x ak at % ead ed ~~ on, ras . .
gd $78 joa ida MY wteet ~ as ise] ied panes eres, vA Seat poe os we tr ms Oud WM yrs wen "eres. Pees i ron yee 2 be ite lace eed: pitas gee. oe, pac ae) heed a, ye eon eon ae ree: Lg ced ty 0, fh oe Sox aakad og * wy S et yon take
-- ¢ P . :
a og wien on ~ a, a es ~ ---- ceed Pel : inaee decker fon ope, vane & aie thd seed der oA a ae Goer wt a sink ve ane is rte ae Pact New. oboe pr, ag fy gee on ye pains ork tee ane. nn rand sige, pan yet spr, y f siped ¢ rapes, ae set we ab ot ne oot noe we eo x mn a re we pas oe sno oF ond ap i 3 ood fee ne wenn > x 6h: : bok Bf Ceaaeel % oy, Sek Ease coed 'he sy ee es Eooed heck Sa oe '4 pon cree panaad SR.
er pork bane Bs, at AY ge. : eres a tht wpe ~~ my eo tae pe Fates Tya 5% pen £ a aot ; wie 7 sees Ne "at A cues e vend pcoaed : : go . e 4 any pe, -
thy Saree ee Pea pas ees eed Exes 3 %o Paras 5 ae st 4 ' ee tad mo ae Se be ha Ce Kye - So me » bane} oped nae eee ; ge ay Eo , Esaad ae, past yen Dcaiend nn, bo ant Sout ¥ oo rad ined an Sa hed pee pe I. ae Pad nee anes pane + Si pee : "or seen - z noes. Feel Ste re woh Klee wor ol Cine whos poem fe i caer aot 'het an v ra "f uA cca) alt ot nat bas ar dent beh saan $ feos io fox te 4 * pe, neers yes Tha aa] oy a4 me am Le 4 we a, ynaes aa Fans : co ty " faa yen fee, pss bey posts se pen os fa) ben ws By on on ie Soak werd: ween ten sat ae ay on uy toot cod gen on oe a oo ; Sec ? eeeee ee we gre fet fee. pa . ager ares, yan te, tts eet 'as 'phd os wine soy a At fn 'et ee, "at faga pee Pad wee ip fates bed footie Pty, pes pa ve Bt pers aap = oe fs he aes ¥ wn poead peal i see ; _ a font ant yer pa baa wy ween ae Paarl beh rece, eee pars wo aye ms coeand tif ard 4 rapt pes, as pee 'wnat aaner pee, Fond we ae) és pe ieee me, aa:
pen vot tip fon x 4 em) a"
ra conead per Pies * at oe thea 'sed "haat F ed foe ne, 4 Sane Oe , oe sy eet Hanns Sree ae eg aoe gen pene pees 'heat: yen fesad word: od poe yan saa ; ro ween sh ~, Dead Pos eee. Mae pee 'at ts Cee 8 are, : deed x £3 - pe, we Eases gee pea Fase a ae Rt painted, oes en wn pon fa seietts cae So seeee "~ wey ed ond 'sa 3 font Le Lt z Co set aye Z ay ee, 23 i ey et one aes wAee, , ' . & . 4 Sorke a gat £5 2 Tact tree, bred oo hee Fy ane poe ; <, een ad a rns ager ott et LS Senn base wees oe Saat ea pe fae eet " aad ee ae "me ye. yt Behe See ee . it con aaa a "hat 03 Pas a ot oar coal 4 ee Fey ae wat mm ay fag te ra, fog Pa a , ny ee poet wd ic nw oe a at bead z tae Teel one = Fnaes eotrd oan panes oe A gos we nad on cm fee "nee? pad: tad ee 1S woe baw $f Re. bok Pa ' :
aire Le cA % se _ 7 my £3 tes wer ye, ies " Anat , eet pa Pon. oot i open wine rie bos "nie pea pe seers £5, ars hea ed pee a3 ie dad ott * Pree a3 oa week a ae bao} 3 pen ret eed we, oar ae ae) ee fn ee perc Ga co Sin ayon yee , ad "oo ia ots bond hes ad ae poner Son poe ro ren, "* tt 4 pon, nr BL, paw} oN oer ow Ee: ween od ead' res, weittel 'eat Set oo, tad Cent Moe aoe oh eet pan ~~. sears: aah hy, he eed ™. epee : tere hn Fash wa os, ", neon: wn een, pee gee bre i * 4 Ze Ss Lae pons 2 ot, we, - ead teh geal wey wes, FT ered pre ayerd om aod ete a3 "at g wen oh ped mm pee 5 are pad 'eee re * a 4 pes Pad vik aaae ES heared ney , ifs re ae a ws, aes of oe Sa re ay oo eo ne wet om Soe as Lad m os os oNA uw "~ ¢ ane ents > " memes Lt ti "ak oy nt ; pea ves we soon a comet oo f " ad bet ine 3 pes we Lo whoo, 0H ~ * ' tg wy wrere nA oe eos ed faint we tof tod if os wy wes se pak " ity po dd Soot tt ' Peed bese eae ' pee P "g Ge es son ae om o , "ES faa as: . we fen, "4 "we "age we pad $e, en Seed Seder Ay ww sna gern fue on ipod we ee) a3 irons re ae, <<" 3 om % tm, phase) pend pas whos a3 'at 4 se Lop, 3 an 4 pes fae aa 's Sind, heed teed ee rn Babs vot swetne yen as rt: ¢ ms , ¥ be os sth we ob ee ee ee, to ae oe at as: oe a 4 a % os ee ; yor ayer. : t, z 7 2 boog be pen trot dood Fa fore hed Ls : bese fog gS 4 nee es ne a 0S yo coeds vpeet om wo 4 fad Dino, eed ¢ et om ge cael bong ye Sead: an 'eat fore "ee en, Lo pe rae, ee ro" Fay, pe yen Sea yore pon pexs a raed rr a Fem! ° ey A sre sss pow : 4 att waa £% wt vate heat Son bode tad eed en ay oad pee a3 ei? weet ~ ies ayere Tow wey ove, ea ot Ee a] oe i on nent a3 oud 23 Ft lod fae se tthe - wed hae eae "ak necen She Me ae 4 pa tht yea 1th ye ara fae we, eck thea ia 'ats rs 1 Soot et wy ona weet "eat x joss ad bet : oe A pa po ued san 3 & 74 deed > se pad apes Fags' Lone " aot Aree, ay x ty ree, 'at ye Sat pon om, bees! 'eee, pete, "~ oe we stent wh oo Pe po o ye oa onl x : "eae gees ed en vee jd oe oS ooo Be oyna ty we re we ae ion Oy ae ee heed cand aaa fee herd x roel a nent fort 43 tS id a ba Open faad on es 'greet, cal iaaad pen [an shed hd H ¥ Chet o, z a pel tee _ Ese Cal ves i ead ao Ls rhieed ue o~ te be, ber? leben arood . ft wees Fas mo om sath nA ' +e weet me feon wt Bes] oe ee if: ers bed fe, oe eed o% z 4 q ;
4 "% nee es ¥ pS Sent pe me By ae: 3 ' © pee 'e we od oh aa Pad pans nal as wes ote my cod bgt gee ree Noeeed Pa ew 2 F Sens , wm far wie sae rs FS nn, Lt oones ree deed me ry beck a ees ane aaa rf Deedes cong nod on ewe, nae ee tel pool anes Nowe pes roees were . ee, "net ee, wi - Fog * vena ae anh . "ss wn ~ Sot ee a, when ne "os "i ~*~ Sat , ot an oe fs ive ot tpn Fosani aed ead 2 oon Sad face 23 ie ego ay pot . ' : es on ro oe xt ' H i ; , see pas wre. ; ea ' "ad pee _ refs foo WS pons 23 ia [ae 7 a wee 'ex? spot wy Sees yoree Food ed, aw wane Fa i '. = wn a4 panne eee ben mee ? renga wt fat ee ~~ to or) ft oes i se x es food On heres fant 'oad m 'site wren we on ares, baa a. anere ioe bed Z ox] 'eet £4 yee Dea amg anion 5 sen a Arowt Laoaia Lt on oA ie ay bon wer ok 'ned. pe Koad eed ae peers oo" er Fees ben vert ba ~ paacy eee ; on es hae : 2 ae 5 wiped: Nat fy » oes the e gone an oe face on, we Poa Cah : po aren a Koad pee) pan were a3 a on iow o 43 eee a a pees a pee one pan aed te "a . pyres KG et: seat ee aot * y Sel we vee " 3 ew Loe peer ores Jon, weet we deny acd whens ci ere ieaat dt wlooes bane "sn wt book in rg. it oh, a oo few te eet , ool % hood war pan Sal oo LAs : pater 4 oe : pied * bead cheat fies Gees pon set st ard * yee wot On arr, peel a vet 27 tat pean Cee? the ran ie Pa ~~ an wt sehen hae Sok ey we, caer oes aa Cay yen, tA aan bere o9h won, > om we ne wert: ween on Pa ct omnes, es awit 'AS ee: ee, oe a3 Seiden gee oe Lot ot ord " pa ont - *, a an a4 oe om eal ah ee vA . sheaf wa IN fhe 29 whos ca "Sy os eat wy we aid * , " lated vt enrer im fare bens ie ees nee pes aad Cee pete, aan OS woe "ee mh e 7 ~ Soe hea weore po pens . on, as Sri piers how, tad dove ies wy het oop ied Bae TF al "nad tr} teed ot, Fed x vin, ues os, net " fond is Poaad wry b, , "eS as) nent , ad 0B a * paee seen 5 ta an . at eas om, Seal ed were Sop ew xae ig wt, abe! Bo ws tf "sasipsd % Ay on nae a et ws et Pane ~ ss igs od on, bes oe fe "oo sed % +n eae o ee od nel heck ms crowed poe ie vee pred, as anand, Ese oot tn pan an aa Seance a oe on tJ aad an ccd pea Sing ane yer ee ae "* ; an pak ween . on en bey, wry hed eee on od G el en, on ae 4y hae "TS "hi pa if a5 5 os . ~ ~ , i ae -
sant a3 as Si ve we " + TO Soe pean a Chee 24 Ai we Lent of, Yt oo 1 rt een fom ae os, A "ad nn = ws "re as on we ines YP " ae ae vice 'vt toot lacond Son ia wm, 'et eal ; the Coe bate: cael % na cage oe reed eke me eee nee, "A fe ant inl -_ ai aed oh va pe os at ie on me Sod aes ass sent ht ' et Ke, land woes an Pres cod Pan eee 5 pune, "% ot oe read ows, Sana Sons ao pees eee see fey oe an Apa ton gre, ae? Basen Beck ae fh ewe, L ' ' Ce. Gy Far oes oe : aes wn, Sua wren, a eaet ned eneee., ta ; rn, . at - 4 af pen "meet a3 voy, ey 4 re wee me "a ia! wt tat Ge "fy 4 ey od "ne Se whe fevk, on, ay a ah " ag 'fs % eg : io, a neees bee, Laer oo a a , eel wn oe bb oe "po Paes Ss Oo] bet oo pan pos fs Lane paneee ban en ~~ rr, ' {. vee, gre wn None ane, oe M$ ~ ee ae pang Pas paeen feee eltety we. ae pone eed oo we Md pay Bs 3 re, oe, need pai rr shee' ws 7 teh net oe * =~ aepeh rd Sneit 'a? Cet Ban hed wee o~," Sabine at ia raped 4 of Ln "SS rv 4 ~ fae 'od we oer 6 a 'anit tt "ad pen oe ht os yo col Ge ae "ey vapor sae pate ~ x Sh a ft bead evo cae /: we ae * pet, 4 ee er Faas ° ge3 any a, _ net seo. on a a3 toed janes eos feet good thd a 4 oS "pes "noe cen ¥ nt 2 ~~ cane : rit eee J 15 ' " ae: pas bee ts eet aes 'nad feed. ES pe, hon , "ant & "ers ye 'apt td food . at pons 44 breead payed et! Le? Deel pees ne ; - pee' ee tft nee pe 3 Ss 03 iw ye Eo a 43 tf anes mn aot 7 La ba oS on , at vad tf ye . aed eke os ad 'de re Spee & ben a ta aes Boot a ms 4 oe act on, 4 t we ; 2 ron a th an os en Sod _, fooe om om, pee wine, ar Sh aoe Y%, es we, a Fa ae? ae 'nil! peed os pepe wee Le, oad " Paar' on 4 % ve ees 5 .. 7 es . aby Seeks eee. aa tne? oe wane ween f3 sa St me oe tee os bond wy eae vere nap) enh hd bod ' gery ee fey parks x a ed y Se el ~~ Nee, , fron. ae newt ws ', ft Po fone wesc =~ ae my a3 bee oe, peed vie ~ a we fee pace, rant nai? fant vee ree Sone ie oe, Nerere, eee, oy wy eet 5 ae cad vee ot Oo ai bs ren omy ent nat CP incon en ven werd " Kane fort on SA ae 'goed ios agen my geet *, ad voor vai om : z : om tas fone hove eA as "3 er a a G3 oe bee [on Seen poae an nd gore "Anis 7 "he On wn jw. 7 aan oo ie -- Na. & ee at deat eek 'ced Tika gee an pede a ES £r8. as "ok ead hess bas) ro ih a eee ray, a3 f fea van re vee nw: ae fers ae plant . Nt ¥ C3 ont peed ees vo ye nad "F oe se bea od coe fey ~ 3 fewe ot evi, pon ped thock ess ee a4 % G3 Oy ae ae ent am eres ms ee tone od oO sneer, ne rr, Danan teen ana at cbs acene ve fee. Lebrab Leaaal ~. Baad nodes pe aie OS iad _ lout, 'neath "
oad ¥ r accardance w * <2 itted that the y 2 yee ~~ eee ts) yaeet Ae wwe P< eed oad ity ¥ RY the mes ey RX Jat i IHSS, oer de SRN:
x i ry ne the appl , "
~ fence of theo .
ar contumittins FY * fi pa and of ing HIS st i terat y Fey yall Ae HY 3 a Cj Wer 3 ¥ ».
iH t yer x x y Tey x <.
A No. § cafarder dated 14.09, 2076 in g St Bpd eSTHE sat d tred fh} i OA has subm cen in » 3 8 > ta benefits wi 2 2 SOPV ICE og] 'onferr CTC * 641 /2011 he has nat he 3 ood.
hk with th y ¥ TE he Inquiry. The ae _ ot £9 o the applica xe wide | regar \, had speci moran of or "OVEL ro eh oweven, the applicant hority imposed the ShmMen y ide e arder dated SAGO £ age, His important to note that the "punishne ent tot dismissal from service ought not to have been Gmposed had there been Rule 16 inquiry, which was initiated ag ainst the applicant vide charge sheet dated 21.12.2004. The Appellate Authority in his arder dated Q812.2005 (Annesure Af) remitted the matter back to the Disciplinary Autherity with specific direction for de nave groceeding for oral hearing starting the process from beginning. Therefore, prima facie, the Appellate Authority has set aside the punishment imposed on the applicant under Rule s yet going by the order af the Appellate Authority if cannot re q concluded that the earlier cha herefore, the ee nlinary Authority ought not to "have mati ated anoter) Yule 14 proceeding for the self same Incident and allegatia vithout deciding the fate of the earlier ch a ee sheet. Hence, we are In agreement with the arguimer advanced by Pid. Counse! for the annlicant that maitiotion "of another Ru le i4 inguiry while the Rule 1G inquiry Was OD, | iS Brel in Law.
ome hd wy ened fie teens bat ated sand bags SF fs see bon ha 0 ae he he py ' oy, 3 wy Eee wots me ee rr "3 en Ets wD pes er Fog pe eva pon te awa pa pee pee pe) 5 eens anoks ats GR eet ee ba ees meee, i ised bey, 4 et nae eck iaieaal it oe frye, Sius) aA oe ce WED. "ern Faces par Bnd. pied, feed, sy no trea eens ie or) rash -- ee an Par ent 3 pod acd wrens, anand on Espne Lk St ee, 7% oe yes net bach oe Seat erener ane cid ee py on ie en pied Sey Ds ery ay a neers boas Snel ad ee We io. Road a3 betas ers Feed 2 ted Coad pot "ea ont * Log Pag ny cid ", hey yee Epps feey ws i we send we coed ies) ea oa "net one Cs "et my oy ree on pad ee Sant bok Sees ak mS a oon ye > oe £ oe ees tf i nen, or iy Conrad Somes aed a LS us "nad pao bagel foe e on re aang aay ie ud ors ge 3 ot wren . ae ef
- i tg, oa noes Net on wn fobs j tome wy ek hed teen ape 23 pad g "eps moe ween pa np aa St Ge ah bes Ta ye woe; a boa ae At ve a3 i} Sern Lb ? am Ww Sad atone Bent ae 6 00a Ba i heoe et or ae a z Fy Ay xy pas eee a ane' aA Naat pene, eed ¥ if bet aid 4 3 . ny, oo ee a Si vere 'ed " ~ aes heed ae hood Loot Be ae. , whe ved baa 4 oat 'tm tek eo wt yen Atte Sept boas , Sx to ; J ; me 5 at oo ton "ad oo @ a = "ey "3 ay porees re, Paeen were Pep 4 po Mee ps ot pas eee oe a whe verve ee Senin 4 pans a oa ve we esa a a, LES on ad was ceo, Bee. AS wanes ; ot et hobo pana ~ vee. oe
-_ pa sad won, ye pps is As Po pees npn eon, on roped, Pa nts vie a ase? 3 fot Fened bas ea tbe a if may 3 ore e bee Pond bx abot: gon pad cae oraad negara aL Mee " Fass' 5%) poeees o Bek ab aboed die Lo bd sf a ween 2 ie ' F w 2 a a a genet it id ve 4 Gi oe ot pan a te ie id ee Ke en Ps pose pm pee ad Pag oe my "eh F oo oh gS Bee fy Col a on GA we £ ed 3 ps os a) ban] ao ere 4 tat SS my fr npr £ vee ed ~~, "ne an ae?
wines Sania oe 'ca 'eet 4 boned Fen Sovk a a Go & a Monee Pah lan rio rg etal aoa pet raed Vet per # see asd adh bapead oe wink we Lh hes, el gts, Li coe onen Pea bead ra a pol Sad ; FS Boy "3 i a : : 2 Bn "eee Song, gs nad ; Boat Nees en yn, a3 thot oa :
ci ig ead ; on At wo pas pee ¢ ore, ioe et &3 3 3 "gon seed gad ¥ Spat Uam fee, ao 5 ves ra, pa) ony ° aes ts Sao Bs ad A, a bg mA eat Bx oe ti son fw. ae feet wy Ret isat or Res Bs bane sy Set x "ont Py aby wine wey an acl Sone a essa] re oe ae oan ine een ee re A oo Gs an got iS ? Beak : heb sacl nee. pe pods : prone om yen S dew ey oS 4 ex ots heen in on od ge ek z re, Z Bed we ad pond ' fad nd tne vey bes ; pers Pas Loy hea 2, Se Pass me eel ee hi ie aad sagen $83 paar he ican ge + ane, Sat ptooe 'oad 'real ent Soe heat os ine: "
fed As on one feo tat ped eo _ hid : nas sarees, panel os * ey poe wars, poe 2% Bs F onc ead ms Kael ete! eh Re 7 ae ae teva 4 = ¢ 3 tethy Sos pos cae) gon spies, pm ty ~ bey 4 pas y Ee £ sow a, oo ran wh Qe ™ wee Sod anes Be pal ai pao Nw Paes 3 oo oe . Saat ayn pant 2 ces oe od vA De tony So aloe "4 : ey en sol Senet oe Seid at pon xe] " ~-- oanet re *s rent ae % eee pee apaeny aa) fy foes ban i. ned peed t z a Sf Es intent were Roe wy poe fs had pas Saxe ' 4 oy % 7 al poe e jena F ts Z Ls Sy ; £ : co Rice pet Enaat he te ont « iA aan pore "
"nar eae bd erased Pond deed ify es Th vee om GG te ae ac' Fat Py im Qo re) we eed : eon ed cM a wns ; peed . awed, ; @ ine ae eel ween oye "pees Z en -- a Snead "heed yet ; sae a a % 23 . Ay gor a on a0 yon Waa ape aon a) oy ¢ on, Bees sho Saeed 7 ae te ; A ied fen te iy sern cod 4 iad eee 4. te ay am wes see ~ plow, oe a lh, wen a Vo neon . int om on root ye oor) Sano sooo ones net ed + os "os on my Faas pana wee ao + evan Ean Pond Ty he ne 2 "re a a oa "A o oe a ee = fae ge Sore ve Saft bow Kod wee hs ones Wt yt a iw nocd