Karnataka High Court
Sri Haridas Naik S/O Chandranaik vs Hanchinamane Gadriyappa S/O ... on 30 March, 2010
Equivalent citations: 2010 CRI. L. J. 3634, 2010 (3) AIR KANT HCR 416, (2011) 1 KANT LJ 340, (2011) 3 CRIMES 633
IN W12; mcm <':<,)L;m' ()1? KAR_NA'I'AKA
I:>at-ecl 'I'I"1is'1'}'1e sow .1)ayV<,>:" }\/I;r:i'('rh=] ()
§ BEFOI;-'~Z,E A. 3
'I'H£:', H('_')_N'81_.,E 1'\/I_P%.Ji_.;"';'i}TVI.'I (.213 *M:m.1,,1" ':$IA{1;ARAJ
CRIM:NA:;T;J1:'1'1'1'1igg;i§;§?Q;;_; 49. o';:;gQ
BC3t"W(':('3I1
1..
r'~>
Ln"
' "L/2' "
Sri Harid Na iii" :3" C 11 3113. _cIr3.n.:g1i
Agcad A~'{)i')'nf .' 47 :3.'/Vf_'.'.-{:'?_I'.'f:':3§".' F't.;1fe%sii.' "JVa.i"c~.}*1e1*
H053 .15' E':..¢'fL'. _("'{'.1"I'{'31':j . 'J 21g.g22..I' L1-:7' V Ra :1 ge ,
J'cigé.1I1.1If-']';1h.1Eg; . '
T111 £1*1m.;f::;;>p2{;. < S ,1.' 'r i' 51f}'1_.i p pa .1' 3-11
E-*.(i' Ai3(_31{i' -» 5?1.T.Y{12:;1"$; .
R 2'2 n CR) 1} 011%' a £1';-.2 1: "(Bf I*'c)1'<;'..<;*: .
J";-1g'z:2I_'1.t1" Ra 1"_1c<_[;'(-':': , {J 11.: 1' Ta} 11 k
. « .P-'."1V_[ ah c's}}2".~ _Q . l.'v';>:aa_m1"11_a
Ab<>1.:t" 27 Yc2;1;"s._
F_()V1"~fj;}:':S1"'V C~L.;211'ci, .K¢:1z1g;{)f'E:c-' Bella
V 'JL; .¥$3v2;: F} g,-{ca J2:g'z:1.I111* "§'a11,:I«:
K v"v' M»21A}'1eS}1, S /'(.3 Vee.1*abac1r'appa
" Agzéti A'§3»(;»1.1t" (32 Yea1's.
Ned L1 $111. apes W2.-1§:<.::1'1 ('$2,
A «.,.;.J2=2g2;111,x.1" E{e:1'T:,g._1'e< ..TJ2;1;_:{fe2:E1T.1_1"{'aI1,1.k
K V BE'1S2'J,VéL-lijfl S-3/0 'v"c:€1.'2;1ba<:irappa
Aged A?)(>1.:I. $35 ':1--ar'.<.:a.
i\f<w:.i1,: I' I"1:")p2.1 We-': I'1c'..'?1{*I".
gr."-=~w».$fM""""*"'s_.---.«
6.
8.
9.
" . '~é'§_}'i*5}2"--Af*€'Sa'i EX}-----1'zi'1 :":::_211_;'1;:.i. E-i'C§1};\'.§€1:-in ./Riv}
Si--i_K<>tEz't*g,;<>\v<'i;.i. 5'-3/O I-"E 1I.f)<.)(E(i12-1z'1a;.g<)wd.21
/\;'__§cc.i .«'~\}:)0m 25'} 'z-"e;.':ez1'.~:a,
E*'(>1'<.é:.s1§_;.._{11a;"(i . K;1.y:.1.ss-'1'1z111aEli Brsta
J e.1g211'1 i 3' §Ke:'L1'1.§_'{c
T P T131i.;.)p<;:?swz;-1.;'11y. /0 i"3;:;1a1::=ii;\}Ve.i"«.
{TX}-'i(>.ci Aizxmt. 373:3 '*1'(>;.11'&:;«
F<)1"c.sE C}1Iz.11.'("'l. {..Jz'1.;§:1'=1.l.1.1.1" B6112: '
.[}z1;;'a11.11"§';1§1..:.k ' '
§'_\/Ia1:'1_;e.11:);)a. -E3/0 T\/§;1j,«'z1}.)}.)e1' 'V.'
Agni A1f)(.)1,.1{' Z30 't"Y(_,_.'&.il1".'-.§. 3
N C('i1,1f,}'1opz.1 Wait (:11 in 921'}?
Je:5;_{;_1E1.11" R21-1;. 1,_a§ce. {T} ;.:;§;;;J1' :1: 1* T i
li " %
I )E:1ddpt? CE' , E3 /' 0 K}").':?51'('}21$" .'4£sé.1§'.)1;;! _
3 r.
I-x.;;'t-:*(.:1 r'\}i)3f')1If€~. V V; > 'z-"i-1%e;::'§~s.--w
e":f'£..*(.i L.1f"1'°1{;"f.»>'a : ''v''%"f2:?; : j-§"i.i:i}.{% :1
=\,3:3--.;'!._'!;,-1"} {21'.'§-'§§';1.:'i;;2a."M _
, E3 ii <<')__< >3. }'1V;2;z_}..5;.=:, V35 /' t >. A m &sl'1i 121 :11.) pa
. -*"\,5§Qc:'1 :;\'%,,~r;} L: 'i' » Y-<;'e.1'i"se .
.«.gI"(.'>1L' C.:}1.l"2.1-E"{. 1_' ('3;'a¥'1<.'sl';\v22a." Bciiiiizix
' ' = J 2§:.;'.";"Aeil{'.i .1'j RE,%1E'$__-it"
_ f\'£.y'}-21:'a}:§;');1}; E715',/0 'iTi%;=s'::=:;;;L}.;>;;)ei=s
A;;_§t.4cE
N{f{fE1$_I.}T§i.)},)l1 'Jv';zIc?§121'1z:11
C') i .1 i 5:; 2, 'Y' we-1 rs .
a__§e.1'g}.:1}i.:.i" [:{c':'1.l'1'_._'..'__:(::', :};;g;;.1E1::"E';1,%'1,1i<,;
. .1 R31. i E",i.om-r11.<;
€»~...,{"'"'sr'\.._,_'_
AE\/1é::';;.1(-H}. i
. . :2»
1%.)<.."£i££<n.':. :4.11'c e"'2.:<s tm(:.ic--:3":
:24.1<).2<)o93 ;'.)z_1sscc.l in c%.<:.No.:3'7:a/gma}
Nc>.19/i2()()9} }_:)y t"i"1<-> ie='e;11"11vc.1 Ci\»'iI Jm
=
._}MI'*'C. Je[>,k9,';;;-aI1.11' ff":(?1't;>i1'1a1ft.c'1" 1'(V'=,Af_"(1".1'If{*.-CE'. j}i.<>7,e'1$;-_ "'Tri'a 1 -}J._C6:1.1rt"
{O1 s1'm1"t}. 1's'~.:sL2:'.1:__L: ;.:m:'<')c'<':;%%;-.;__1;gj2:.i1'£E+%_ 't:'}'1c".~;u'V'p(.f£'i2i,1g)1'1.é:.1's 11.1.1 1:119 c..>',€"f"c'-*,:'1(__*o.~"»' u.a1{l(:1' ink-'<'1i<:)1':;¥"-.§.:4Z'3; 14?».[_jfv%L8.v «II$2£3, 324, 504 amd 50¢; R/W st.-g'£j:--,i_;;1:'._ 1.
(;if--m*:~.%
2. "1"}.2 :3: I ' .;g'_i'1 I119 ....'i'1'1221.§ft-:1f"--.. Iismd mcizzy for z1ci1T1i$si o"r1__ 17¢-=9'<_,§'.j'1..:A<i."1:.r)_«f':I.'1'(j 1'1z;1f,L11'e of ti'):-* i1T1}'j)L1g}'1t?Ci
c)1"(..i c-31" 2-1.z1ti"w[I'lf1v '1i7g--'In: ;
c1is1'.)c')s'2-:1 2"' £*:~;<):[:§_>;1"3:I' fen'. E1 l_::..1i;u>1'z fin" f1'1"ie:1I ..;'1{ §'?1f1{5.*~.§é'i--'§;fi":-«:,11§l:1_.'1'éJ'iS <'>I"S1'1' I---I;-211:11112111i'1"1z:1pp2':1, the }<ru;'--:'z<t(_i {"i<}11..;.;:~:'<i:'l§<)2 Lin: p(1tl'1ii.i<)11<'1'S ;»;:1.1<.'i S311' Vi};;1.yz:11<L11'12ar V' 'inf Z<)n1"x".::"(l H(]T(fi1" 2--u"v in:-:2.1'z"d. '1'E'1c=--* imp1.:g1'1eci (;'I'"{'Llxfg':I"v-.é"'{1'Id eézfi HM ;.::.vc1"m<-'I1{::~:, 1:1 £1110 ('.()I.E"1p}é,;i.i.I']¥. filcrd by £.1"1'e:'.é z'<a3}:')n,.1i'i:§«:?:1: :\E<ss~;.E za-:1'1('£ L2 §'1{,'1'(_Ii.1i em-;> p<;'n..1..5cc'I,
3. f51_z:'1.:.<:(% 321 §:',>1':'c;=;~£*1}."sc;=r I2u."'is'+.: Ic22;1('1i1'1g 110 $110 p1*(:>s'3<=r1'1i:
(a) R{__'f51_)('}]'1('I€:.'IH E'~5:>>;(% z.-md 2 I"1:::1'€*1'11 f1'.I<-mil 81011' _j<';i1'1i" ('c>1'1'11.j)§;-11:1? :.11"}{.im s.3(.'(?ti<')z'1 Z2{i}(',) ("I11P.CT ~
4. :(§,";"':'£'._I:)AVI}.,} 8:
E.;>crt'or(.* i.l"1.('r 'l'1'i;-1} C..Tc.>z..11"'i. Thtr .s5z._>.ic:i :'bump.1_,z1':.1;.~.V1 <~2.11nc=* 1:0 be 1'<':i'<*1"1"ec'1 :0 1;l'1cr }'j)(Z)_H'( "§'A:""'={.TV(,§1 iff(?1fI'1Eéd"
§ u:'1<"1:;'1' f~S<;'t<"'I.i(>1'1 15€3:" {f3}"'«rq_£' c"r011'1pict_101": of éfllw :sub1'"[1i11'.c;rc1 '1--:3' -S:.1'1:1 1'n.1_a ry '.R.f:t1u)()1'1" £5fi':'i.(1.:z§}3.(,tmF4.£iI3}é? was p1"()[t":t>'1.('IT€'1 1:1}: 1.I:i'«;:_timnpiaing.1f1'1:'E5 {f';§E:1"€?ti1']. _ r up
(b) '1"}1(i'1'I Hit .!"1'_i;;1'1_ ({§(.)v1..I.4I"§ 1'fCf('T.g'iV'(,?(1 z'1.['fi(;1:'»1xIi1.sa :'sw(:')1"1V1 to by'.'_lV1,'ij(-«.,F'n>i1'1151.2.2"ii1*1VE1:'1~f',§2--. *i'1"1m'(;*i.11. in Kim.) <'4>_i']t.i'iL: Ea-\v(.).if1'1 §st.;.'{%p'1'?:1é;%'n r _I'j:5fé15ed 011 t:h@ said
1.-(_»131"fi'cii_{1:v.i-ifs; V 4;-._: ;' (:1"~~_ Vé':h(f.=. _2;-2.'\«'c::1'r1'1€1'11s in t1"1(--?
""" '<'r,Q'f:i1,1;.:)¥}-ifE:m."'1_~ljé(-i;' V§'i"i'.£'-'IV§'"'{,:()l.§i'"f', by iis i.111p1.:g1'1Lrd * '('.I)1"'(§('I!V'..:V:.'2'I{.;_]k;;'.(.'."'i::t'--',§';§H'"€ §'1<'* '13' $2.11:a1:'1'1a1'y 1'c"p(.>1'1. 2-EIIC1 '= i$:<:1c=-id jij}:ft>;.ré§-.§I%s.; .;1;_.:,;.11'1'{1.*~._»*I 1':1"2c>sc':r pc£i1.i.().:1c=;=.1's for 111:: Aszi-:i't;'1 <_j'f£'L_r1'1<"'c~s. '}'11c=;: ('O1'I't,,'.(.'.1T1053 cyf this . 'Q1"(::£c=t1' i'.$V§V"'(".":l"'1'2':1.}(..'llgjgfi-T(.1 £11 %}"11'.:~3 pc':r1,it.1'o1T:. . -'91.."Hal'!I1211;-11'}U}:-ipgiéi. lihc-r le;:a1*1'](;v:.1 (]'.<T>u1"1st:.l ;¥'()r _ 't"i:_1_.<,-> §j'<:i.i'_;~%':i'<>:.i'1:'c;.'%s;. pia.(__*§.1":;;;' rt-.*Iia1'1(r<;r on 'i:1'1c;=. dc:<ki.=..si<.)n of this .' . Sri Katferao :"<'.~1.::r'>r:<.>c.i in 2908(1) KCCR 354 5-';l.1'o1':giy '* _ (:'--<>-;'i1,<:?1'1<"§s; {i"§'d§. z'L.><'(:i.\*z':'1;;{ oi" 2.-1I§1(.i;':\*z'1'&~s 111 1191.: of 2.11:? sworn _<':,1a1t~;'.1[:1c'1"11" :"')£'1_%'1.(.: (.'{)1'1'1plaiiilli-1.:if £02' is.ss1.1i1:;;{ p1"t..J<'c:se.<'a ;"1§5:-=1i1'1s£ t§."1ct ('1i«:j)1.1 1"V1_g'i'1'T:Vtf*1'1<* c't;:..sc of Sri Venkataramaiah and Others Vs. rm s;t.211c3.>.111v1'11. 1)vi'o1*:-=-* f\f%.z'1§.{i..=sI1'2.1.i(é. '1'.1--xvi: '$x*1»i'(S~1r111:"»--.--_1 5s1j.a.t"'<=i-'1:I(*11f ("l<)c*.~.: 110!' (111.1 11()I".""1.>.,{'I'1::'~_("'Ifl()SS"V ('.'X&.l1'"1'I1I"12:l1i(..)I"] of 11w (fit51I'I1p1.£'1i}i.t231111"'11i1_1':1{1 ~._1'1;1'(;j_1' w1'1.1'1L.*..~::s.=;c--.':~;. 11' is m'11\-1' l:1"f'<i-'V 1\~'T.._a1.gisl;.19:.j:.1..c'* »\-'&~*'1'1(11':_\1'l':3.' 1' 1111'11A''1':'..r~-v5fr1fV _ a.b<é':._i':"' 1"1"1c:
1'(:*.L;1.1i1"c?(.i 1;. ('2 :5;-'1 1.11% sE":atc1'1'1e1'11 (>1 1.1"1c=:.> 11'i(..)_I1]pv1E11I'1£3iI'ii._ a-'11"1é%1 E110 with ..1'LiI":[1I§'.1"" --«':}L1,1.'1A)'1"".ff1l'§'.ICC1 than 1.110 "_j1..:(1g1'11(:111. 1'v1ic-mi <:~I.r"I' 1'11\1x~E"1':11c;* _.1C1'§UA'1.1:'i.fj-3(1)C()L.i11St?1 for 1'1'I.c.> pc.*:'.'i_111c')f_:101"/i1§1'iI1~i':1:L'*«.jf3'1;21I[.'e1",:}1' Sc('fj0111 1.45 Of" N4..11.:'\<?§°w1."I1i*i1.'1= _:i.1"z(.%'1.-'<f;i.:=L; age' .$},')c3:('ti1'i('% pI"()\2'iSi(f)I"I in 15.'-_L.11i;":"_',¢"".'{'11111111.121"'.'§-'.1.:]11'("1'I1§['.)I'€Z)\»'1("1€3$ for fi1i1'1g of '1112'i1E1:1'1(::1...a.§;?,iI'. z.1.'i1':1V<11§' i_111'1§$11'i'J'1 111135 1"ctge--11"(1, I':1'1i..~'s Co1,1r11 111 1'~.£.§'1i-'1 r-A;.51..>{j'11.a§a~.V4_§'u__;1g;;1-.:c-=:11: 112315; ;;1<*<'<'pi'<*c.'1 1.110 e§f1i'7i.(4_'1'¢1'.fi1.1"1-11-:.;.1'1.&sA{15_.*1v&e111)111ii1£(.%C'1 1'l1'I2-L1. 111111" .s2:1'(:1 ('a1s.sc==> ' * wzzas 1.:1*ag:'1t€i5I.1'1<:" p1"0\zi.s'1'<"m.<s c)1"Sc%r%1..j<)1': J45 of t:1."1c--'
5.._,§'-.;1(?3i'_§'1'."}.1'II'é11i)1(3'.11'W1I'If?§T,I'1.l1'"!'I.€"I"I1S ACE: a1."1('l not a 1' _ " vgj(1)'1'111'}_31:'ii*m' 101" <..)f.'1"c::1":(1<;> :..11'}(11m" 1,P.C.."' £3"); _1?.c*sJ1<.:1A.=§z1;; %...'z."1<--'- E':1'J(.1\r'C cubse1'v21'i.i(>1"1s in £1119 said A<:'t2-1561-.1.";.m1 of 1:.1"1c=% <};.,>i;"1i<>1: mat 111a: i(:e:.1"1'1<'d 1\/1a::gisL1"a1:<;% 1(':(').1.2"11]}.1§'I1',E?(1 ii .sc1'ic.>1..z.s LI'I'I'(')}" in 2:-'1<'c.t<.~.'}3[';1':1;;' 1..1'1cr e.11:'"'11'(i2:vi1:.s§a'
--f§\vc'>:'11 {"0 193* 111:: c'%();11p12.1:'1':21111' is] 116%.] of 11'I.t:' sworn .%;£.;-11.m1"1c1'2'( w1'1ir;"11 is; In be 1'<:'("('>1'<'1c%(.1 1i)_\:' 1'I:1I'1'1 (mi)/*. '1"1'1cr1"c==-'1"<>1'«:-', 1111.' §.13::)1W1'%c-?(§ c:>;'<'.1r.'=:' i.'a..<.i;1.11'1'11=>" ")§'"f.)(.'.<'\S.'-'~; a,>"2..:1'111.'~sE fix 1 L» »w é'I'1<* 1:Jc'%i1.i()zw1'_.'~:s 1'01" thc' $2-'1.ic:i <')I'£b11(_'c=='s (":2-n111(:.)i"' bc SL1f;'a'i--';1iI'1(3(i in 1;': w.
7. A5 to 1h(.:r (){I1c1' c'7011t.cnt:1'()1'1 (Sf,1c:ai*1'1«»3ci' (:'('}L.1I"1S('.I fol' 1.h<:é pt-;%£.i1.i011('~1's 1.l'1z§.I 2:21 Njiiim"g~(_;_§j'1_p_1:ai3jH__ ?_':\:::.r() or 1"1'1()rc pE'1'..=s0r1s is 1101 »;<T>;'1.vis2;igctE~ L,112d(;1-i'..C1*.'P.C. a11.C1 U'}E)1't:'.f(')1't' 1']"}c:.> c:m11;').ia.1.:'.1'1t. in %i::1¢<§:" i11si.e1i1§.. def-:;~;:e fficéd by two pwssoxls s1'1<mlc"l 11<")'1A__ E":-;:vc----1"E-')c=ic1i' ~f-Qi_3,fE'?1T§&1i1'i('I(] 1:)};' H10 '.I'1'ial C(_:)u1'1 and 1'16'-f..m:v 1.1H11 "0£.?1'r1vi\)E§1i13??Viii'?'?E----i'"' <1<:.se.1'\»'es to be V Hig_;'1'1 qtlz-1::sl1r;..:('i. 1"'5').11_a£"V}v":V1ss-.g{r5~«;:'}§'::tc'f__' :.l1<*1*(=* is 9: d<:("'i.si()1'2 0'! {.'(')1:1'1"f.V>i:' Ma--§c:!.z_':i:'-: (."£.'1St':' 0? Narayanaswami and Others Reddi and Others rt:rp(')1'IjCci in AIR ._1 .<'3s2;" i\;1;a_xb¢t:;as 443 m 1962 {2) Cri.L.J. 616. In 1:116? 52-1i('l {*7é:;_1_:e~;.L-r."'»:iI':.r,'_ E'VXl:;-2-:81";-1&5 E"--{i;;{E': <'i{...n:1"L {4h<.k>1_1;;1'1 Iurlci H22:-11. 21_joi1'1E. ctt'i)'--2'1<'1.;';~-ivz.-.1..i:3ifby £'_\,-m my ,mo1"r;* 1'.)<;~1's_'~:c::':..s' is ;:.10E. <-(>111'mm)lat:eci 11;)}_~' %'.}:1 {* C...T1"i.1':'1§1'1;'13 }"')1'{'}{',L'{_'§11.1'(.'? {'Tod(-'._ 11::ai[.<>;.1(1 of q1.1:-[1.5:'~:h1';r'1g I_'};1t%A <;'0m1.)1ai1'1I'._ it 1'<:mii.Imi f:'E":c In;;.tt',i":.c-=é.1'" ¥.)z1<:fK to the " (".(,)1'1(..'.(::'1'1ltitd Ma-=;Q__'is£;1'e:1.c'* with 5-1 <:ii1'<:<"{:1'o1":. Io irate.-1*; the ('<,>1'}'1.pl2.:.ir1£ J}l:=:?<§ in iiné s'~:z--xid <.*z.'2:&;(-_' :15»; 21. <':(':)n1p1;.1i11i. by Olli' of g....,M:-"-3..-v**g_,,....»..
{J
(iii) \-V'¥1<;'1}1czr1' HM' },)1"c'_')(.'(.:*r;I]i.111' fc>]}c.}\>\.rL==-><.i { .\f1;.1§.-:f.i.s;1_n';:1fo is 1'19': in 221mtc)1*cie111c"éi%_§V€1'E'.%«1 'l-;<1w":}__"A _ ' <
10. Thv l(_*2.:_1'1.1L-*{.i Si11_.gi;.* :..;..([iag'c e1_'i".1ssxi*'L*r{-:~:.'! V"bc;)'E"VlT'1..1'i"ic%. q11<3s1im1 §\J'ms.l 2211:"! 1/3 in 'LEM: 2.Wjfi1':i'1'1V&1ii\"L' ~%1.§:1{.1' d{'('1j'1'I'1.€"Cl..II() zmswczrl" q1.1v.~at'ic.)1'; No.5 on §_;'1'<')1"1:1d. 'I:.E;12:'t~1'_ iVVi'~.'. '\'5"'1'.t1'\-'kl!' of 17133' i"i1'1('.wli1:;__--,>j on (..§:.1c--.':-;1i(_)1;i1. 1"\?<'>:s;.;1-~----;=..1'1c--'1 2';-._i1t 1.l"'1'CVVa';:_.{"t7i1i1'1z;11ivc. 1"I.€? Mt' it". 1T.11'11'T1n:_:<*c*:es;%e:.1ry II) _fc':~;'.;.3.1.f{_=5~i'.~';;:; !'_x'i;»;_ "<21:j'i:11i(>11 on I'.l"1(:' third q1.1csi,ic_).1'1. _ .I.*' 1'.1s'--:1;l_u::f. 1'f<'}I'};:}\>\z41j¢1~;§_-..i':1'1t* ":dc:n.*.is1'c>1'1 of I\/Izzdras I'1i[_5_->;i"1 i'>_['V"N:1J'£1yanaswaIni [1962 (2) Crl.VL.J;-- 61 'Madras 443] 1"c->fc.1'1"(..'<"} to :.i~;L1p1"a.
1}T1<)11\:_-_{}':«--I."_1At;-' v.ic*;=-i1t;1<"::j§ :J1:<_i;;;<2> vnf1.111'.<s ("fm:1'I' 11II'm'1a1c:*1_\_/' }"I'(3.'.«:E{I'i_i ].l U11' 5¥;"::ie;.§:_...§:2'1;a:v. $112.13' ;.:. .juim (*r;>1'11pI2;11'1':1 h_\.:' two 01' 'ifl{")1'i-?._ ]f)C'iT:f§.L"J§".lE% is»; I'1<)'i' c-:1'1'x-'i.s_~:e_zf_.;jL=*('.'i 1,1I'1(it.'.1' I"i"1c'> (L'.<,>(it;" of .'.("fI;iI1'1i]'1é-if I-:"1"g>L'<.::c'E1.1:'c*. hc £112.} nut" c)1.'dc==-*1" (.11"<)}.);;:).:.1"1j;{ of 2:1}] f'11§'%~§"1L'ji_" }I)1"()('{i('('§§I"§.§3;€$ i11i1.ie1_t:&-1"! i'>o.f'(..).1.*<:'* me I<-mmc-tci _ §\?'§"2'.;;fgi:s:1';:_i"c.* on the' §c>1'11i m1"12pi.e;-1.i11I'. r:s;';):':;-c'if'i<'T-2:1Hy fol' that 1"c?e1:'~.s011 0111\;', I1. é'.1}i)§,)£'2l.%."-F5 §'mI1"1 ma' see'-;1i('.i dL:{..'1':=s.i.()1"t I'¥T1;11A t'}'1€* icéz.11"11céc"1 Si1'1_;.;¥<,a «.__}:1.{'.1;._{<.~ <_>1"r;.i:=->1"¢=>{[§ ci1'(.::g.'3g.')i11g of E"1..1:'i.E'1e1"
1.)1'(.')(":§n;é(_'§1Ilgfs We-:§l:>:"«';_' 1':1'3.<;> §{'.':-:l1'1"1{:_'.(i ?\/E;--1;,§iSi.1'2..1i:'<'* in \.-'in-%\4-\s' Hi i'1iS €....__.("""'v-°'"'*v-«--.....»-