Bangalore Development Authority vs Smt N Jayamma on 10 August, 2011

[Cites 0, Cited by 7]

Karnataka High Court

Bangalore Development Authority vs Smt N Jayamma on 10 August, 2011

Bench: L.Narayana Swamy

?é:=jsif:z, :"§.:mf'iA Es:';;3A*;5z§a_:;é:':;;€3%L :€s§%;.:23.\:=z{;§:z:;,A,,_rx:;a§ SEE E}.§i¥€EEs%~"i'ET*€;%E3§7>ﬁ.§

  "§ii:1=":*:%:' ¢?.:::;:<";§;.:rs;ﬁ3r~s'z* j§N'§,} :'>:%:::§2 2:4: :i3'::::::»9u{::;:w2{>@e§ 2:>A3s_1.:g} ZN"

-- F. ._ «  :;>;':~;.zi;:>.:§§:;§.sa%.;2{>{:s3. {>35 $2'---$.35: :4-*s§;.§%: {}E%"" mg: :5}: A:i>§3L 53?? {f§%"EE,,.
 ~  ':g::;2N'<;;a:',<3§2:: §{iC§~§--'§{}}? :>§§<::::e;§<:2:::.:2:<;' 'j§'§~%§.%: sgzazy §«':3g~:
 V ; :'7:ze:§::;;x<a§:€;m<::?~; ;am'.> §:xa;:,:§*'s{:':':<}:x:a

EN' '§'§"¥§§ HEGH {fOUR'§' {H7 KAE?{N2-'§§';'3;§iA EYE' §3%j3:E'§§{§P&,§,{}E4EE'I
Ef}A'H7Zii} 'E'H§S Tfiii Ii?" 5EI)A'r' OF 1~':i_T{}U ET. 283 E   

E§£%3I:3'{}RI€  _
':"'§--£:T'«:= §~a0m:§:,,:i«: MR. 3:33-':"':<:z'«: E." E\EARA'.:*'EsE\E£% Sim-xrg%::%;Vv '  "

REGULAR FIRST APPEAL Eém xézfm j;gj;Q§_.j._.'  "

E3E§'£W EiE€-33 :

Er3AN€3ALQR}':Z EZ}E£VE1LOE>ME31N'1'ALJ'1'E"i£)RI'E'%2_ 
§.2:«:r>R:::S£<::\:*r£::> BY V    -A 
{TS CQMMESSEONEZR, ---- "
C';--:GW£}A:,A£«1_ ROAD   s .
§{UEX/IARE3ARE{ WEZS"§',   '
ANGALO£~?;EL»56G0'§.x  _  ' 
"   '"-1-:vvA;>§>:2L.mN*_1'

£252? SR1: mgvz G $;s.£:§:-i,.e%;ﬁ'::?3§§fr. Qizuz-%;"'§{&;{£:%.m~:E:£;:3E:., AIEEEI}
ANE}: V H % J ' ' 

$_m' £'*€,JAYA.Z\vEEv£;%- _ V  ._ ._

WEE??? SE5' 1":%fE'}"€.SEE}i,'§?=,_ £¥%;E:":£):'}Y, ' ; »--

,3-'iGE§} ,5X§3QU'§'_ 53 Yz«:;,2.a;§3, _  
iE_%?;§:ZSE_§}§NG ;;§_;f :~éa>¢ ma, *5 ~:_.féfr~: R;'§AE:N¢

25%" €:'§"2;,0S:5§ ':A;ra,K1;§,:asATNmézag--;;2::xi1':é:¢r~»§§z<)r§;,
w§:ge;.<,:>m <::z::§2::7r§<:'1=»:«. E3;-:?ssV€;»A:,ma;e:»30<

: RE:€;':§i3'GF'£'§} E:".E'*~E'§."'

:::m?:s;_,i;

 '--r§*é4-'-:':.$VT%§2::"%*;*:'V----:-?*£:,,:?:;':'f> 1353.329; Eegav (1: XE; E3: is 0:? cm AAENS3.'



?-.2

'.£.'%"IIS §E,E3'P%§AI,, C{}.1"v€EE'-£{Z§ ON FCHQ E"'§§%§A¥€IE\E{} THEE} ET}A';'. T§"'fE$-

CGLE 1593' D I'i?LE'§fiZ'£'{IfZ1:) EH {<2 E'O1,,L{)'+£»§ ENG:

JUDGEMENT

'£'§";@ ci€:f'<;?:'1{.%z»1:T1i?; is ihe: é1pp::%1I2:2;':1i_; 'Pizza: Ei}3§§7<;i.§.£1'ii_i'.'~ "

izizzziiezzgixlg the j1.1dg:{":1erzt. a.zt1{;i aiecree ;}21s:v§sé5fi»'£::§ an the files af Ehczr Civii JLzdgg::~:¥ .21: £.322;:1g;;;2__.E<}z'e§Q--.A 2, Thé: pa:'"3::§e»s; wcmiéi be re.éi't:%':"u:'s>.§§' to z§Vé§'.;3}'2:.iVi1ti{§ amd {it3§€*.£1{Ti&11"if. far the sgezke Qf<:(}2'1wf§:iém1<:.%:. _ . 3" 'Hie :"€sp<>11d€::1t'4pI,e1in13.i§"F'fiiéci i.Z#";?e:__s.~s:i§_t.A.£&7:i:':* de<:1are=;i,i<:m Ehzzii he has; g3::;:rf;:>,c:t::_?=.--c:E "%1§£§;£fig§E1i. 1:5"; L'1'.:'fs~;}":'<2::if{.v{>§" £326 Sui: :s3<:%1eduE<:~ ;:%'::'0p€:r$.y. E: E5; §;E3;_:_%._ <:"¢:s§;§:;"* €}'§f,_f{j}é1<:.._§}E.g§i'mi..;i£{fghzii; ha §3m*::?:2:s€d éihe §2'{>p€'rt,j; on '3-.§::»'}<4§ V§};i%¥€fi";=?é:AE'-?;§L3;,§'4i"}€'":,§:§. ta \Eix"€$t 89' and N<3ri:h {:3 Simiiifz 50' §}r"{}:::";L ;5r;:;éx;i.{>{;;ss }':}W:'2er and he has 3322?, mg} «:<}§':3§..;i;,::?:?£i<;:t;ﬁg}? ?;'2:iEd§:1g--V :Ejs,:_;§_;i<.; The s~2u_i€. ,s*<:%1€:§:.:§€ prapeﬁy s3;'.i:u21'£f<'::§i' §:1:"i%y;N;}'=~?'€;?f "E. .. _':;<}i:21E§;§; ::2€:a.;%:.a:'i1:g 4 :a;:;t:§'es,; 33 ;gm':%2f:§5.~:., téﬁrhigtil wa";is_"; ':;::::<§z1'§;r£?;j::§ E23; ééiéé €}<;>v€;";:1:mém, an §:>e%1ai§" sf iihﬁi' Eﬁéiziggifsiiagfﬁé §:§£?'%ii?§€§.§}f£§€f§'E§. £7"s§4§§1}3'3{}'E'§Eﬁ:~;' E3; E";'.':€:éi§"3:':'§ :5? ;3:*s5:§ir:::?%::::a°§; . .§'}{3E'j1iiA§:§i£?:.{§';f?§"1V"{§£E§.%?{§ 2.55 .22. ;:-mai {magi :'2<}é.i.§'E<:2:§:§{>:1 ::iaEi€<.§ f 39 '3 E3. {)3 the E3;::.ss;is9; zjaf "£';E'1€ ;ﬁc22§€.¥i_1'1;;§s; of t:h::": }:>a:*ii<%:=3, "Em: triai masrt. f':'amc:%<i {E16 foiE{:>1x;:i.:T:.g isssues:

in <>:*de321" H) p:'<;>vé;% 17:hz;:*. Case af tfzat §:>a'm:i<::.s-9, Exhe pE.:2.jE%':--=?; i'§§ e2<s;:t"z1£:'1é-3:5? {EPA h::>Ed:'%r azza PXR/'-1 .1/'iﬂii gm bgaéhaii' of the df{%}'5€é:1.{iTa'::§1'~ EEW-1 81 {BE-"V52 v»-he W<3r:-3 PEA and As$issi,.2i.:z2»t:. . E-1':5giﬁ:§§'é';.*V; "

pi.21ini;i§"§* i*:2:;.s pr@e:i:.:::ed EJXPI ":0 E355 {sf (E:{§:'.'?' § 'is. Spectéai Powegr 91" At£:(::':*I":@y and r1{}ti-s3:;§%"~~ ._1§ss«3uéd__ by }%_6iai€:iii%§*3I21 1'\E{)i;:ifi<;%5i A.r§521 23.3 per E;X.P§3, E1-;:x:..P24~.. 'Er-::;da:*s5<:{r;":c;?i'§'. and ::r1m.e1i:1?<>n E'€f§§iS?f.€?Y s:X_*i,m<:ég P:"<)§)<:*:f%;;g' 'E%1€;~g§T:%?i§£::_'_.«Eiﬁzfziaré;E 'i'2:::;'>: paid E'f3C€ifip'€; E;§e{7E::"i<:ii:}* E%iH,,_ ~£}'1'::?_gi::é§:i S2:;:£.<:>, <:?;v€§§ efiV-_2Vf:z'2e:'ij' ;3i10€:<§§.§r:»:phs5. Q1} ésiziiaalf of iihe <ié%§e:'i_"f2:i":"f,7--.7§?.3§<;';-E")-E, '"'E::.§ Ezm.-'«s;% "§">:=."-2&1 :na1'ke<:i ;':.22me§jy; P':°<?:§.§r:2*;=§i2li':'AE:E§>§:£§if{,:ésitE€}_z:;V;'- F2§:é":%.§""Ef'E0€..EfE:%2:ti<>:'";§ Awzsrzi, E3<,'2Ss3s35;5;§<}§": fa-/Za§1V"::::;?:éa,;=: V'€:'.€;"f3""ii.',': ;f:§f{:.'i"..{i':«'i'§§}:3r,T~~ G1' iihe :'";<':i'_§_'§'":'<,:.2H:i<):": a:§":.«:§ E,,a;§z<:s"a,:E; P§z~;:.§L 13?; '-71%;3-'.J§%j%';3;:i%.§%£;éa§~. g;::1>':.:né3€:%'E""f{>:" éhza ;2:p;§::*.§E2:m?;. <:<m*m?rz'1{isa éjhziié, ixézéé §§"§é3§': {?r::;:§::'§; V%:'.:A:>;%jg.:":":§i:%i.e%{% an e:";*{}:" in <':zﬂc:,:_E.2z_1;..i§1g§ *£:§2<*:

E§.r::*%'i-fé'.a:.E'§z3s'} 2.:,5_§; %:E§.:':% E_,.-é2"2_2*;1;2:éis'22'2 .f§<':%, '§.§'3;.':E. E2 5F&%z:z"$, ;' $5 2 g .33 &><: §§ 3 §§A§.§"?§$%§ 9 \ \ iii in the p:'es€:1£: was-se. it: is i".h:='%. ardn.1_i'£i:::%»c:i {tease cf iihesr Eﬁemgalmrer Ii}eveE<>p111<?:'1£': z%.2.1i:11<:>:"iE:y éfzexé, the lzmd E'121.s;vV'§;:::::=:z1 gieiiveztréiii by {I19 Gary:&?:'*:'.1.z":"1::?:.1'1'{. {<1 ijhéé B D A Vidff --.._=§:::.::

.'£.;':§.8. Z§}88. T1"§¢3'.T€ff(}f'E';, it is :19: <:>p{:%:'3 to fihﬁ 15.3 El}_--§i~»':;--r:§':{:§}i'§:it:<:?:£i " ihzlé. the izzrzd 5:-;i.i.1§ V€:":SiiS3 with 14m: €}::§sr::rr:n":c:1iI--21r1<i S.E%:':i;:i(_}:{1_ 1135. V 02' the: LiI1":iira£;i<:=§': Act: is; ap;3i.i<:ab§@. 'E'I*1'e ;§;:z5£ver:s5é:~.§3{i's:ét3s;$§{3.r1 far £2 };'e;::'S ci2.1i.m.et:i by "::h<:= pi;1iv:é;t?if;f gig-;V:1i:';sé€: .t_.'{:t.;:¥"B E} A has to be (éaxicuiexted from: the e:ia":f;.<:: emf __§;}h::=/ £3 E) A is f1€£'iﬁ'3.E'.'I' 2?: Cemreil G::w€:»:*j;1.:':1r3;'€*f. §3'(>;;""{.h7e._S"ﬁ}e>.."é,~:>...Q<)'a/emm9112:. It is zniiggz 2: Si&1€'.i1§'4{}I':2'_V €3.'i:_}":f?'}fC)}E°§'V'§,_'é;'.."Vf§§E€é'YC'§b'fé§, 3é':(E§'.iOE"i E. 12 Of the Li1mf.21i.§c322 .A<is¢; {::2i1":.:*:é:3%fV_..%)¢ 'é;§2z:}1?::;>d. _S:-séiimzz 54 amt': 65 of the L:i_::1ii'a€,i<):n Ac? 2:1:-3 :1.ppTE§::_z:%::.§<:: V' '§f7r£séé E:§é1r:::t%€% %;.%m3.:.1::%{v:E far théi 21% E} 1% reiieai zzperz 31:36 ";Ea.§£ig_g1§';.;<:§1i,':?:;"2§;<52:§:éd §:"j{'BQEE8 I\E§C 69,': AP. 'E"h<'-3: said {i€<*:i$i<m is ? ::,{_:g§. .21p§3§i::;:a.E'j;§_i;': £12: 'E,%'£,a%.j:§7;s{:ti:$ :3? '$36: pr€s;€::%;. {:ta::;e:: £533" £1223 E'Ei3;§:'{}f§5r§ zf2_:=. ::z:§se:~~ £135 E3€3::;-£3 :.:€_:i:=?-»',}.?:.i$$.;€,<:§ :32': :;E*:<: g§m1.z:'":€§ G? {is;--:§s'::':<f:€ 2%'-§f¥§i_IfE'{?é?£§V {3fii'_«§§}£¥§Eé%§§ if iihié :g§ai;':'z:i§'§' ﬁééiil 1'16 ES 22:": {5§:{r:"{;;2:§:%::2z' {sf N §E':%;e--..:§'é2i§: §§.::§'<'}§:n:?::"i:§;= .E-*E{::*.:*a:-7*: in Ehé? §3:"z:%:<e;:';t:";.§ €ff£§1;=3é§, §:.%.":<;2 §i;:§r2%;:;?§f E 2;

in M 1}":

21.25;:-;z::1':::s: §'1isa. 1f.igj%1§ {ink i'h<3. '%3a.s:~.;i5--.:; of a :z*e;;ji.$%z:ér:::e:1 :-3231:? <"1<:%r;%:i ;1_:._'1{i :«1{i:€:1" 32:1: d€,'€i?d._ €116? p::<>;;>s:*::"t:}; C&;£ITi'E§? 'ta ':36 a<'%q:.1i;.":'=.-'=.--c_i"a§f:_d"._ pas:-3es§s§<:>:': :3? v..-=hér:.E: €i€t1§'£?<;"1"€{3 'in [hf E% E} A. It 15-; f-.1¥f_1é% C2}, {km pE;?:iz1i.if'f !:.h2-1:4 Eéeé h£'iS p<:%rf'c:2<:i.<:%e:i .h.i.s,§ §ii"tfi<:':'~ >22vi'1::f%3 6.-_*.ffé:1a:*:'*'?;_ fﬂtem E';x,I}4 §ﬂ;§§E;1E11Si; 111%: B E) A.

12. M1 the facts and cir<t1.:,r:2ss£21':'x::V af t.l'i:3._c:1$é*:= ;:1i:»d aiacz baised on ihe <im:31ssi£>I1 sf I_Z3'i.¥.Ii..i&é:.:i::~=::j; C=::s'{3v1v9'A1?.,"§Vv9;:'1': «zzaf {Em Vi€3'?.V '{;h3I". t.E";€' '€;i°§2?:i §§(>:;.u"£1 €:"'m1"' in {?:;=n1pm:_iI"1g $2 §;€:a:"5-"s ;';€':"<:;A§:;:{j1:V1. Sestiien 1 32 of {M3 Li§11it.35L:0§1 €;.h<3 §;"es3<:nt Case.

1~E£:::1{:e:: 'z:§;1::*; T' ~»V. §;i:f'<>:':§E%_%'V§iV{%§'2:§;:_i<>z1 am a:'1$ws:r<%{i a.+::c:<3r&1?'I1 giy.

i_;':~:'.:§,h<:' :'€;::':»313E§{"é:E3_:i~:_.zappeai Eiabéézt 'as be ﬁiﬁﬁﬂiﬁﬁéiéi zmzi §f€;«,§$ 2:s.étEa><a§:i.i::g§§. ':&'ii'%I:3'}i:g:S§%:3{;i6 '~'z' '-a::ésv»?~*mm.

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court