Karnataka High Court
M/S Shri Kalmeshwar Co-Op. Credit ... vs Income Tax Officer, Ward -1, on 16 April, 2012
Author: Dilip B.Bhosale
Bench: Dilip B.Bhosale
EM ?HE %%EG§--§ CQEJRE' SF }<AR?~§A?AE<;€ ""~._V CIRCUS'? agma-: A'? Di~éARV'if.5£?;~--j"_ ~ _ .j: :
$£"%'ED $53 THE :3" 3%'? <3? §;?'§4§§,; %: 2§0%1k2: ~ BEEGREV « mg %~%G§'-i"8LE [%a'ER.3US;'?"~'§§C:E DEL?-9 3j'§';.%E:4?;"V§S"'AJ:%_.E gas: 9 e*\::::. 5&:§s3fa;2'%;2%; :2'F§:«§§% * é:if--'xg';!f;.' ; fjj ., _ \g'%;'R§\§QS$6:§j8§,s'28_;},;2,',; %5:§§%k@;2@:%::; sgiggg,/2&2; §25;?@,z2;a;;,2§ :§25--2%k;";£2@%7;2§ §2«§?2;%2@;3; §;573;*:sj:2; §2.9232;2%§;:% &§k%29@3z2s:2. 25.9; ;s;e3é:sag{$~;%~':2;.;si:é%% ~ ' 8ET:fv'EE§§;_ _ V' ' gvzggg Siéfié %:<;5;':_s:%E':a?w§«a;%;x;--;&';;f2 é.:'s:'2._-l?:::::{ @232? §{';s%:ZEET"':j, §*s--'%AR§-%T%%,fi\ C%i:<:Gf~§5'§, ;<;x:2i;§:g_:: 5,;«:, §E;.§;:;:,%%:as; " '-
R;E:?RE{5SE?»§'T§E} "SR? §?.?\§§i §><} %<§§£%i.?€fi~.§,, §E§§ET7%,:R":", E§"2E%1Té?§¥'EE §Ui1.}< £3§7?E£§§; %fif§1%;R$»{§,}; §E:§3;5'«E§?'«'E1 {:€3?'»'%§"v'E§S§E ?'=§§%, 5.3? E§"x§€3£%§"%'EE Eélxi ;i%§'3'?E§'a§"fE§ E3§:.£§!%%.E§'5§, ..K?ETE"?§§é'\iEj5€ 'Em M} T§"%E E§°'sé€Q?VEE TAX §E?A§?f'%;E?2I? §EPRESE§\iTE§ 53' E38 §E€RETAREA"R T%€E §¥'Ti?\§1S?;9fif £3? Z%7E?\éA§'~iCE; §\i$?\T%"% BLQQK; sggw 953.22%:-»::g@a§.. 3'.§,.§%:ét2:%i:;:§_%x;*-fig"
:3? 3?'; EEEEJAEV 3 NEEREELAGE, A92: mg R1 883 £115. i*{§¥'\3§§JE; fifizi'. 30% §.3} THEE WRET ?E'E"E'%"EC2§'~é :23 §~"::Ea"1;;:s§:3£§é g§;"?%A%;:a§$.. 2':6~_.;5;':é5:> 22:? GP CG§\é$"§"§Ti}TEQ§'\i as: §%'T*~$:>E,é{ ?7§?§x'%"E?\§G f:*:f3.Qa,L:ass';: €"§~§§, i%'~'3PL%%£§'~iE§ @R§E§ ?;i'aSS£§ 3%' E§~é{:5f,E.?f'FE "?;f3;'}ifC*§:?V§{§-§§;._:'%";§%§?xi*}~E{1}; EE%..§§§%U§'f§ 5%"? A_§'éf\§E)<£ERE~A, §;fiC?E§*f}2§3.2;'Z8'E;3.., ETC. ' 335,3 ¥\£@.5i§S§}2§§.2":
BETWEEN:
"§;~=:§ };%§\4é<%-%AF"=é§Ev *2":.%;;;u.KA éscmga '*€7§;:2i;_'-Er"i;V§E§\S;' £©~@P. C§:Es=;jf?;'1.i50::'zE;:'~{.$33,, %8QHQLRQAD,fi.""_ a;,V_"_< gwsxaamaz, 1Z--3ES737:'_B,ég£E;i%L.%<®7§',.. " 3. Rgsaésgr»-£E{:_ 555 2w<2Qsxé:";a.:?;;:§;v~§«E'C§E?;aR'€, ;..@E"E§'§§@;*ssEa ii 3%' 3 é~é 3 gm (2 é;~;;:4»«?:f ' 9: Lss:}££;§--'--2 :9 A3222 :3 :--"s£'é§:
2.' ::a:;é:<§:ar:A:: TA:<"::s§é:CE?;v. §§3..£.?é,%§ ; v".E'%é£Z :':§:»:sge:3_S§£§a;E% §?:§CG§'vEE "mg ;3:P%?'E;%L$, §§:.J§';:.:;'%%.,\ . ' :?§::§é;§5.T1'm;>: §E?£%R?"?~%E%'§"?
$59 $2' 33 SE£:°~'<:E"§AREéf?§ E §~s::%§:g??c~; £2? §r:"§:s»§a::':§; §%§f:2¥~2"'{":%§ §:€3€;%{! ' "'§"°';"'$.' ' E W 4 . éé AA §FéE': '\£'§§§*Eé?€E~§;§Siz*Ez ?..§;E§§€}§'K§$E§i*?§ EE§'§§€%§ E5 ?x§E%Rfié.,é§E§.¥g2§i;é 5:53? Q2: 5% K2 SR}. #38; §<,fi*2§"%§§:Ej§,, £'s§f}'x.f. %:QR "§"%€ES WRET ?§;"%"}'.TEG§'\§ E6 3158 E§€1é§ER ;i'%R"§"3{CLE§"w:2:~§T'§§V§'éE 22? C3? C{:}?\§§T§Tij'§"I§§"~é SF §§'>é$EA; ?R;$§{E§\§§ °%"Q«,...€7g£;§'~%f§':'%*§';"§"%?;..E §§'¥E?UG?'~éE§ GRQER ?;i?xSSEC? $2" §F'éCC3§\'%E ?§>< C1???-i7.ERf"Zf3§éR%§»:.}3;. §§3é?L§§ JET? §xi"\E§'\éEI><{§?\E~.!ig SATEQ 29;"Eif2%'3E?:; E"§"£L ;-. 'EVE. N6;6i99§jZQ12 §ET':i1?E§f\§:
Ears. :;:::%<Q?;z::'@@: ELAKBE ms :&<;',aR.';~=:.m".aa;<;.av.. ' I §'xiEERA\!!i2RI §'4AWAKAR ?AT':"E§\é smeisyggg sg:yA:~§:-:i_ $921" Raga, BELG,5s%.,§§'v'%, _ . .
R.E§REsE§~4':"E§ BYETS sEvC_;R'E.m§; _ SR1 §H;'%RA!'v§,%??§ M, ®i§?'C§§t?'§'?;2'C§_£fé;*i;v ...PETI"?§C>%€E§ :
8%' SHRL $&§\§§R?::%'! 3; %<i;;:;@<;;:'é'_':'j»:éf'géiaxgé3 : " ma:
2:, §§\§C§fv*%;E fax. 1}g::§§Ei§,§§,é'§§'!'§ 2% mg ;:o(v'1:§x/:iI's£;€";§::.:>§;:'g::=, 32>: ;2m>EA:s, 5gL§;a.:;r«; ' "
3% Ema Z§§C§%§E "mi .a%:':%;s;§?3f.§:zE:a;"§ R5?-?;§$g:a:"€g© ?5YvE?§'-SECRETRREAK, §'«§é"iES'?RY"§3§?v§1'EE'=;A%'3;§'«§§E9, F'=£fi§"%"%~%: a;3:;<; " " ?*;'vE:?2.! x..?\ES?@§\é:'::E§'=§Tfi-3 ' _ 32;:
:§:a:>;'3';..9x:§E§;a:,a§:, £2322: mg R1 3;; R2 %<;§'§::;xv:; 532:. mg £3;
A §'*'§«.
3&5??? :§E§§i"§§£§%""»§ ES FREQ i§§%§§ER §¥?;"?E£§.3E§ 226 QRES 2:3:?_a:*f*£;§§*:;s'm"a;?z@§a: E§Ké'éE>E.3é'<§ %§.§*§:r~ss€3 Ti} §.;j%fi;5'af§%-% fag ..«L':»§»2¥as ::;§§ @3353 aggsaa 5:' ::*a;$e?«'§E m:< :3%*%::£§a %'*5;i%R§~2§éj;a, " _ Egg 5%"? §§'é§'%--§E;>iii_§RE~§%; §5if§"E§ 23/EEZEGEE. wag ssaamagggzaxz §§_:ziE£...@ vzzasz gaaagag £25221? ggaaxagg :%s:'assv:z?; mzmséz gmaszsxsgg §E§-i§¥%§5 PSS'? sfigrzcg, MBSfiQt 5' ' g'a v. «_."' I ?{E?R'§SE%'%§TE§ av sgmggaa §%%;é;f*§Aé37E%__ _.=.,,;2§*s":f2*:o:a;:_=:A;:=;%__ {-3? $§~§R£. sfiéssmsvz 3' §<i.§{,§<A%5'a§*é§'-§..__;%3;§%.?;':}A._ _ AAED: V "
1,' ENCGME 'ma: s?§:cE§;;f :::€A§':é"ésgg;-,:.gieggggxg? A 2,; $53 i3_§§'4'3§%<§£SSE§¥'x%ER :3? Mia:%4"§?§4Ax~.;é'§é1E,§§.';3; ~ 8EL§;i.g£,3M,_ M * 4 .V 3' REjpg§sE'§g2f:<£;fs--- 5*?' 3;-'>'E?*'gf:3..vSjEj£'RE*E'2§;":?<§,i£3.--fi?,'V-- ' % mg' §%>'£§?a3§$'§§;'3<.£?§§':?~2$$éC§, «-NQRTEZ 8i.$C§%Z,' % iaiixfaf<§Eii;i€ij?Tii3_8§i§:--:?:_; = ,.%E$?{,:'§*a§§E¥x:T§ gjsxk {gas L$&:,E":;'§1E-E'Fi;§s*»s .__§Q}v, $6? $111 3: 22 ' 32:. Ex: :<;ég:a2é.%;f§;..;g::jig%---,.___§§§ R3): ~ _'?%i-_%_§S«%fe!§41f.°_'{ *?3+::*:::3'§as% :3 3:53 zgsayaga gmszgg 22$ ma 22%? :3?' *a;:s;:*,.§:"*:"'.:?a;:*7;%:;s§=-§?- ::~s:3ri:g, '§§g;a§'::2:@ ya Qi;.§;%S§-§ "mg ' 2: " £2; " ';??é;§:'$f i1=§_'_%":"':%:'é%:§_Q'¥~%§_E :".s:>< . @Es:c5:2g, '25%':5%§§'_ M ._.§}§;E4§;':§%?§'§?§----2*§.--£--§;--2;'--2§--§,-3; * ~ = M3?
1 msagvzg Tax @?;F:£:§§g xsmga §"E%9;%»§:jl§nI>f E;E:§A%.}f?~£~,~~-. ' _ _ ' .T 2, "mg fjS%'v'éF»"§ESSESE'aiE§ 0% E%\EC{fi«'§£ "E"fix>i ;3.,§:§3:E':EE}:i\;.S>'},""'~.V L"
5EL§;:u:vL " ~ ~ M.) : TEE E§'~éC§§'«'%E TAX SE?§\,;RT:?'»*?§§\§"§' ' RE?RESEF\§"§E§ 32" T%~§E §'~%E?'éI§TF?;'{ 3§"',§}:§'<§g%N{:§; ' "
?\éE§"é Qfiéfii, -. A ' £5? SR1. :E§a;',ax::; 3% 5a;EER;.':L;:§; A§a;._%=::">g R: $2' SR; £5; §~'Zfia?x§A¥1,;1\§,\£, ?QR?;--3j;A "
?HE§ WRE"E ?E'§'§":'Es"%fl,;<~'.;;. :;§:;i§§§;% ARTECLES 225 mi; 22? SF CGf\§STI"§L§T£Q?~é sf:--:N:>;;a; ;§.--.a,$sg:s};.%3.'.-T9 Qi..§!%S§i mg §M?U§NEQ GRSER-Réxgsga";.::3..';2:'x;'§'~e.E'>sie.;;':§~§,, "-mlrgs @§;:2;2§:;2. $52553 BY RES§v@:'<s..Q':'~:--a%? =§%§@,;1,...~§€T€fZ., .. {sag ?§9a§2i5'V?':";'.L2§'§';E.Z:
§£T:rz;5E:g; T' §'«%§S. 3;-éfi §%§4§§x§§<._S§~%:'§'§§G' R;3\'?;E'\fE £RE§E'? $Q°C_;€£"f7'*f * = ' S§}B%%siS§% §'-':;©;£':§, v§§%§'€-§{§A;EV 'é?§;3iRg wxxggzf 32$"? :A.:';-§j£,§é%53%sE:§§;:.§E,25' %:z'm:.:;E%§':*:£@ 52' :?§,v{51§%:EFé;2: §*%A;Fa§f-zG§R ¢,.§E"E";V§"EG§'z--§ER A§'xz',} V V _ 2. é1:a:% C}?§:§§:§§l,13E§f%§§?'§§52{§:};§3EL53z53;i3?3E. .?7%iE <:::~-§%?:§\z§gf§:§?::E§«': 23;: E§%éC£§§v'EE fiwazaggg g§':;.<;Aa;%»:2, ' :§§~€E §?\é{,"Q§'?'§E "§",§}-<i $E?,é§%;?§*='§§{'%§"? _. §;E?RE:'§E§"«§"?§E} E'? 3%? F'='§E?%£§$'??.'?' C2?' é'E§"ig5=f»§{:E§ ?€E":?'§ §EL§%:}f. ..§,E§?Q?é§EF€?S .;.§~%:£f:§£3.{I}_;f*xiE_:§:iE'~--é":?S v {EV ER? 3§EV:5:?i 3, §"~é§ER;§::_£\QE; §€'¥; FCER RE & R2 3%. M58' §<i;i'\?=3;§'£L, ASNE FGR R3} T3-£3 vggi? ?ET§"§'§C%§a5 :3 §~"I§.EQ L1§'\§E}ER ;aR?{<:1é.;*é s?"
22? 3? CSf'=§$"%"I?"i}"'i"Ei':§\i E§"\%E}E,5g; ?R,£1x'f§?\é{§ ":"s;'}._VQé.jg;sa.§s«; "WE E§~fi?i.§<3§E\§EB GRQER mggea av' :§\s<:<3;x5:E m.:}:"':;;>v?«ET?:':;*;E's'z., *%;f\;;:..aa'=. NQ.2::ii}; SEiG§:UM A? §§\§§'\§EX§..§RE~z§; SJATEE«€:f§'§1i.2.§2_{}§fl_ V EAR?' §§. §26?2f2§12 EEEVE 3&1. gazm CREQTT §§Ll.%~i..é.R§ §Asi:éLée<j;:'§;':»L.:x;:22z%eé:"2: LEG~<i'§:fA; fvEéH§1NTES%% :x:';:.§;:;R; §--3EL§{3¢x:::*§',.,,% . REPRESENTEE 5'? SS 1i\§CHARGESECRE°E£%RY, A i' _@§T:':"1G:\§E§. (3? SER; $;a;%¢eR§;':¥,:i:. :»<a%_:.%<;a5z':i:,"';f:§\:.';*;w».......7 M68: : 1' ' ' '
3. ':'§':§::<j>'§%é§ET' €£%..§%:i,SF5§::;i.;:»:;§ ;--.=;;;:R§« i%§'{3';2¥; 1;, gaggfiawv-L 2% "??%E 2;':'€.3:*>«:';*~i:_§§3':a&;'g%:"~:: %:::F_ '*:TA:>.;{::i::xf1E ':",:?:x $..??E,éL§; §§L€§AL)£?~s§'%, .
3% "'§%"% zéagaazxxéa TT%'"AZ¥;' §E?£%R"E'?»%E§'a§"%"
ESE§a§?E§8'5... _____
- A '§*:«~e:E §%%.::»2:§:i;Q;2' SF §Em§~€CE, §"«$G§fE"%% Egaag, » §~s§:zz: .;§:::;§»"3.:_§:::}a:; .,¥;E3g%»"2<::;m駧§a;"§"§ {'¢§é':';<:.§<LVV:§%;'=£g:sz:.,'§;' i'a§E:E%;3xéf%§; 932;: FS;% Q1 3: 9;:
'f~,;§.:i F"-{?B';' 1:§<,:,a:§as§A.:3, $§'x,!Z 533% 323:; ?§*€§'S;. %,?iJRE"§ §*"§TE"§€§?'§ ES FREQ U§'2§§E§} ;'3,R"?§CLES 22$ §a§'a§§ _:f2:7; §}'§: Vi:i:3§\§$»§w§"§i}"?E%3§"§ 5:2? §§"'=i%:}§,§; ?;'§r'3{'€§§"'\§5§ mi??? QijZ5§3?"'% '§"§i§ ._ "«E§"?.3i,§$§"éE$ $§é3'=§§, ?;5'a§§E§3 ff? §a§§?'éE}{2}F3~;E~i'~'y, §§§%?§$ 23»;'EE;'2i}E.'%_, ' . E'3?i:';' we €«.;'_;:
I_' 'E ¥§§g?. §2§?3;'2§§.2 Mfg §H§EE Ba5§$;§xV\§§§E'a?%f§i_§ Uggfkfii CRESE? S§E§?'§!§R§i'f'x §é'3x§*"'§2'3s%<?3a§<3: §'--§§':'§?'*'"%§:w§" ?'«"T:5iL§ EE3§LQ1E°\f€3;
éxézagzxsssi R353, » Sz§§'§§':ES%§¥3f!3,§3\ ' ?:%§§T. BEL§§iU§'*'§ "' i:}§?l3§_3 5.: .. ' _ RE? 3'? 3'53 G§§'%§E§i.§gL f""ig3x?'$is£i§ER ?E'T§WE7E$?§»§§§§ '' (3? SR: S£aE*éG§,é£'v§ 3. s<Ua§<;aR?§:::--v._ '~%.%t £%%\§$:
$5 zgagcamz Tax QFFECERQ'-%::s:::;:a:€;L_:x;f;::;.23:-;:l_;j_ E§fE:;<:;«g:m gigs;
SE "§HE C$M?¥?ESS§'3N EEL{3,éi.§£'VL "
ER Car~":§»¢--£i'§:x%'§:..f:;&x 2.19?
55 THE EF*é£:tZ'éé3i?"§:*f?;'1}{"§'E%7>b§%R7T§f'z5'<:'EE*§'~.§_§_ RE?RESEN"=§'E§3-- {ski ~ A "
EH5 %9:'f:é'ia:T:$i;?f§<i>5 @F§:.::?:?¢:v::::E, ?*€f{§'?f1f"?~% gmcx, ?'xEE'if's:' §EL§i駥':§*;$T}QG"3;., _ _' :,.RES?€:1%?*iEE?'é"%"E"3 5%'? 393, :'£,§22'A_:x: g.V.V2f:é't:«§:¥;:é:;;§:«;':a%'.;:z. ?::>§. RE & R2 5 21 iv: , 5,, §<;:.;'a:m;_ 'E FSR R3} ..4.%f;E§%::L:: 251%?" §2:E§?::;>§g :5 mgga EJFQSER s'l:%,"§"E{ZLES 22% M3 "sv-_,_»9'%2,-::G:§é:;"§':Tm"§'{;:';:§ Q? mgiag §§;:€:%--:& "EC: Qazaga meg 9:; >;agE:f::..:':sg:::.§%; ?;'-ESSES 2;? ;:§as%s£:<i;a2§-Va BfiCE'§§ 8% :2;2§;:::. VT"?
*g¥;§;'§é$;é2'é'§:';2§:2 ',_:;%--e§- 3 ggggg m:?:?::§;%@3§ V ='::a;--T:,:§3EF;:::::":%5§ 5333:? $§€EE"?'€' :.:§&§ .. '§'?:%Ez5«1E%~.;§iE} 593 :€"?§%§'*ii.T: %€i§%<§:--iERE§ ':%.§:»-<3,;a.s;m » 5%: 3:39 ' §§§'§§§,E§3EE"e§TE§ 3'? §"?$ §§5ZR§T,s'3§{%' ?E"§"E"§'Eé$§'xéE§_,
3.; Ei'*§C{3§'v"1E TAX; §F§ECE?,. E-fléffagfi §'\§Cé.E{E}§ :%§§_.§A£_§T'v'%, Z' "EVE £®§*'3§'fEES§E§?'éER G?' E?\§CQ%<%E TAX QFPEQLS, §EL?S,%L%§Vi£ "mg Igxgcegvaa "mx QE?;&§'<T?v'§§Fx§"§ REPRESEMEQ 8%' 1 A' .;
"§"%%E s«:§&:£s?Rv G? gzmgxgcgg §:§@R?:s:; aa,-:.s;:;sj<g §x%EW SE§j~if{~1§.{}§Gf:, < M} gay SR: gggvmxs 35 §a:§ERALAG:,§ ;:.:§'%;;.,_F09{";:::
32:, Meg: §<AN;ia'1fL,f%D'\f. gag ;*<:3.;:; ' "ms wag ?§'E§'§E£:}¥'§~.ES %";:L;§§:~ %g§'1éf%3'§.%R ;:Rf§::;:E5 226 mg 22:? G? <;G§\éS°§T§'L}T§@i'xi "s3V;:T..:£:xé1S::s;»;; $'%2§\::?ae~§ TQ Quéasa "mg Iivfirvziggxésa QRSER @3333 "A3" :*3i'§'4§€\é:E><.i§.R.£»g£a._§::,é3CTE§.} 9,/:2;2@1:,; av RES?§i'é£}EN'§' §'\E§';,§,E"}'7€:;'=--f - V ¥¥,.P. sé§.5;%{9'59§'f3%-;::?0%3:.:
gE'z':&i$~E%é:?" - -- .1 ii".
sags; g§I:.:%é§s? c,9;Eé:*§ **>>f:::V:;;:J*;-<%§;:;f:g> gaaaxaag ;.E,?"v'é§?Ei3; ,\ ' 3%; aaaszgz @,;:x;_::; ;a§:.§;@Aa3::§~; 27:3; Q-:',i§:G§;E§, ' V. '_ 9\E9?:§4;<:E§g;':'é;§ 3?:-:"~§.. _____ .. « 'azaxgaaé %:?v§9g:a;;£2<\;Ea \..?E'§E?E§f}§"a%E% 5%., .~{;,w., . "am , :%;7;'i.,:j;"»--$;a;«:%'£;;.%§§:.§«f: $5 §<:;L;<;::%::§ ;£'%i'}X!,} g§$;
e Ef'éii€f§%'%?{%E 'éiélé {}?i1ECE?.g EEQQQE §"x§i3VE,; E'*=»éE??;5f'2§Ez £@§'%%§'«'E§§SEQ?%§E§~ ii}? E?'%iC%'f,§;§'*€E "§',52IZ>< £?%§?"E£%i_;§, Eiékgégiéfié ';..,RE§P€:%\:é?5§§4%:*E$VV 36 T55 EF\§CQ§'v'%E "?£1>i §EiT3zi1R?§'5§E?é? REPR.ESE§'é"?E§ §':' ?"HE §'»§E§\i§STRf:r' G? E7E?'§.ii%'2§CE; §\§Ci§f?%% §LGC1<, mgw $ELHE~§§,§ gm ..,§'§$--:?%.@é;:%;§i'i§;:--"E5S"v.._ A. gay 39;. EEEVAN A NEERERLAQE, ADV, mg R: &.e'2':;:" , 3%; mg. Kamvzg Asaxa 37$? R3} " ' rags 'a:'%fRE'E" PE"E"E'§"IQ?«§ $3 $12.55 L:i'»s1:2§?§{ .2:\::2§"':':..:::,E;§:«.;"2;$'~.§;?<g'i:3 2.2? $%? C:Z}N§TE'"5L5"§'§Q!'é OF E?'»\i":Z'*_E_..£'a, ?§%:5'§_f'{E?'~§G Ti} "§E~%;§ . E§V'§PU§§'~§ED GRQER ?A€SE§ QT é3s37§§?'i§'.;,;'}{L§!3\',Ez§__;g '£?v;§§'§}?Q"~-1';§i;3"E_2fLZi3';2 ESSQES 8%" RES?{§§\§§E§\ET EEG 1, ET=C;__ ' ""3"?-EEEE y':!'»iR§'E' 9E'§.a:'f€:::_>:~ss§_"'Céym-:é3:5' "§;N Esé Véagssézggimxg;
"§'%%E§ agxsi, "H-i§=§E §C?i}R'§ %«2;:9§--§"%%_E :?e:;:_@w_:\x:g;; ?i:: H %'§€&ré_é§'%€: .4§€?é;$':%d .§::§_:}2i%..$ef.."f::f.'h éhe pariéfis, :>;V,..i.:: é?:i;€"g"'éi--:3__afisp 3;;/_\;f'§"§%f,';'f-3i%,'Ts;_§€"::;VQf"%§, thg mtitisrsers haw :ha§§es":r.gveé'--i:§'2Ve"'£é§':i§e;"s"gziqéiislzéé $3; §§f§e§"€:'2i Encame Fax Qffécerg ::;f€'L..;:§E:"f;§3r?e}:':':iijaéiéig, The €J}i"£€?"S imgzzzgréefi En €333 ,_ §ra;3»;3§--A:.s,2f"'zm"%: §éii:§?é:%;::_§_:f:_$A.aré'3 a§g;:€a§a§%e mafia?' sestian 246 sf %?*:}:c"-»E§:j::.Qr;*2£s'«.,f'§";é;< flat $3 2% petétégrzessg :5: mega 'agxxfl g §§g::§§§;3:§,§:§§%:Q:"E*:§;, "@282; E32523 aégs figs §§§§C§i§$§'ES 55; (''''T' §s;;--%;§%,;':':f:;?2s;'§?f%§§a:€é'§:£$€§%§:§§§; §§'E§é3é"E"§f§ gggsais %§$f$re Em "V séayz i%3i"€'2€'£§ €:Qi§§'§$%§ ?::¥ 3% ;%€'§§§§§}§'é§?'§ gzgisaméég a§§<~°:§§§:e aaiharézy hag é"'%€§§;§"%€€' §;:>€;$i{;€€:%§% %.:%":§ sgéggaés mgr aggfégaiiaag €32?" §E'E§j€?§:'T% zeiégf ':%%% ?:%§ 6558; ?§:%s §i:f\ 2% gabmigsiaa $5 igamefi §§%.é?'3§§§ fsr the §$€§':§§f':§;f'$ as:
men éismgtefi $3; 2&2 ieamed sauasei a§gga;s~%~:-:s:_i;{;.f:;é€'fig %"€$§§%'3§E¥'1%S. Hewavarg that £az~::*:$: be a §f<:§.a%%';§»:§ §§:§rs§:%%:u' this Cami: keapirzg the S§I§tf.§§Q?"§? a'§§e§} $ j;"3é:j2:dV%';f§'§..: figfigeiiate Azgthgréiy. it is {:32 :_§gar §5 'ti: w§'s;;"~%.i,;§%§§'§%§§§§é§§a:é'g Ruthgrity mg 3%: gsnsidered E%2fg§3'i3§%%{:atiG:2s fa: stay 5%? iirzis data In az':;: Asé:§;§g:,'§eé iha: these writ petiiiajxg sf by 32% fsiioaaziag s;"fi31?/.?
T58 dga:33aiééiazégé'i$é::§i"§;a'i{;'%.;iéé::*. ':i§;é'§aéfiessmsnt aréers unfier s§éa§§e:z§ §%§é_é§'%:v523¢::;2.§é stay aggiicaiiens flied $1; $29 Efié déciéasi '%"%"a% a§:;}§§§a:& §:s2i?§:"*i:~g $?2駧V.,e1:*2éea£;!@::§r :§ hear aaé éeciéa ééze stag; °a;:§§€a:*ai:§E:é$:s'V%'fiéeé the geiiiiarzazs 53 8}{§€fi§§§Qé3S%f as :;§G£$§%:§'av..:V§:§§ :.§§§§j§}::'%g§?§§§§§i a«2:§%:%':§:*: a gerissé af :2; %,ss%e%<:§ 52%;: A $fs'%;
V 'zséazgf. §, ':'%.f§¥'é'j'%~§§ csaizzsei &§§€§%"§¥'§§ €31" iézg §3§§'iI§€§s§§%"${:i€§ :3 5;
"::<:;§?3:m%%;%s:f§:e 33:3 35%: is: iézé agggééaia agtiaaréty ¥%¥§3:§'§§§'§ a T.";3.§;i:L'%»£;?§" af izaza aé:§e%<:§ fygm tafiayg £2 €S%"§§S§'§§§§;"'¥$ 9? $28 .;::23:%§§V§ §§'"§ 2%: sagas, 3: Eg @352 $15? 2:23 §€i§E§%¥":€§'$ 133 rags §.,.;;«*"
ages: fie juégmgnis :3? 5-Eégfi Cssurtg '€333 §u§§é3s:*ée'§:%:»a2 :*2; .®f'f sagfigasi 3% étééek Cage i§'1C§Li:j§fi§ {E23 gagiéeiéneg EE2§:i??"€§:i§%'?.E!__b'§;'Vi% §V§§§TL§;%L F§,3§'»5§ sag; Hg, 23; 232% 5mgay%%a ::;a%:;;m,T effecting magma tax recavary. §'?G»Q E ';3%:._$ ':i:;*:;;_5:'--..€§§'ii,:§*{e agpefiaie autharétg shaéi degaéé :3€%'$§$C1:§K5E am shaii $533 ' in SE3 étégiéjiaéged iémg, with '£§"1€S€E ©b3é3:"=£._a::~i«:::§::£ 532$ %\£'f§§._§€f.?;iiiQfE$ gre éiggagafi sak i i y1z%?;§92"*.%:§i€e 3:9: §;§%5@ ;3e§', 1:,-v»~v»~>>"¥