Karnataka High Court
K Srinivas Murthy vs The Bangalore Development Authority on 20 March, 2012
Author: Mohan Shantanagoudar
Bench: Mohan Shantanagoudar
....wi$vv<\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\§x MM§MM\\$&w\ § §vmm% :' \\\\\ \ \\ \ \ \ \\ \ \\\..\.\ \\\ %u\.««~«§.".u\\."xw\\\x .........................3§§§\xxxxxx\\\\\\\\\\\««\«\%§» \ \ \ xv \ ..$$ \u&..$....~.
A;:i%%s:€%.:y yam: fer 3535:} whiée *%;':f:_%2.§..2t':g B36:§:'3"::§§V:%駧%;:.,VEE:
stagé §§'§~GLEi hgé zgiiiézeé the afa:*emVé34fi:é:f:T2..s§d ;::_%:;?§:*:¥€'*g'Ii"'a_"
ané farmgd twee sitea am :w@='TV:é:--§d3.' 'T§:eV tfi%é:%._'~3E.:;Ve§.3 SQ farmeé ova?" the petiticm pr@p' é':i§; _a:*ej '*§%Jf:Te'i$ }b8aI'§i"'§§ §'::§3,§8:jA; 682,513 and '7_§:'%"z<;:éfé'§;:é§.%a;vereHpV§2E am €133' auétéam $3; the EDA arfsd we:f§_$Q.§:E v'$§::%:h--'§.VV'?;§*:b§'.i;.'§'pa{fies in the augtign pmceed2nggg'A';;f§'he:3--f§ih£é"r :i3'§_i:§é*eVv§:.éi§EienerS via; M, Kréghrzagga ' by féimg EJKLP, i\%Q%8§.GO/£9:}§?%'§és§i'§_fiQK;% :i.§:§aVr§fL§g§:..£éthe BSA :3 cancel the ausiim $aie§--.;§1:-fie' :%_§'&jAj_?;'3'ig*'::@*»«:'€;%' the third games $32 the gmzéaé tijai éfigérs gs. ;% §"~*":a£§L:ESit§$§: Q? 333$ b€§§"§§'E§ §;fg';':'%§.<:§35'f%i Qf;éjisee% :%é%«--E--a«g§. Th? Said wri: geiiim C§ET'i€ is ba €;%.é s§Vr':i§§§'*:>:f'rf:§=:.:i*§g8§1%? ag gm" €35 sréer Am2§x:§re~F, §5%§"'7@é{§5é%j';_émexarexg réxseaég that 33% fiflfia 513$ 7?',;§:§:~m§:teé" i:§?'§5;:;2?e V:§2%s {gaasfz E235: Eéée s?:es mfé i;§"% aaziiém $2': '_§ év*a.§%ig:ssL; %naitizé'.:%2§:*'é gasiées are sémxgé Q25: gf S\;.:'%i§@3§ <3? "4_.:.§§%;§:E_§§'*f§§§i'§a§§ 3:36 gm: @255 Q? Sy§?%@§3Sj4 sf éjigaaay, $a§ed '{¥9: _"§:;vg~§é gazhmiggiasz Eézég Cgaggi haxzigég feéi E9231: {he éiaggasied " »w«4;
§5S£;i' &>§?%g§<<\<x J,/«gm .M \m, » <\ Q/\ quastéan fias amen; fiirscied the ;3€iit%<:sners"7 .:fav%:?:~é'§ E;'¢§£..'T gggmazih 339 CM? Cami fa? aegg:*$§:"%va§§"";::"逧&r. .;«5§§':ér«éva'§%€%"'A the father 3? the getitimsrs §fter_ ge:txin_g é:§§é agprcachéd resgmfient ~-- EBA' re;.§'r@.$é*n,£é:t%VVé:{é'V"Vééiad 'V 2§§;2Qfi§ Seekérig far alés§:f:§_€€::.»~A<f>5f' §é.§"a_§éVV§*:°s.§:Ex;'éA"§'a;*z~d}sEte és': £282: 3%' {he saheduée wéthaiét aigaigitian. §;:ti§:..;:,é '@_§2 iifie §a §.e:. r*é§;:-:fe$e::2:éii0:%5, ihg EDA wéered fer sagrxg-3%'_@f:3f::%§~§_"Ea_;?:_§*-is} '?--%::r;:f§j'e;j_ is éeterming as is whether infaszitg-.:'§f§g '§j;§*%:;§:;3Ver'*:§g{ .'¥:.':f:::*....g'2e;*2ttit%a:*:ers was uiiiised fer f€3E'f'§'i5i"§C'»*:V!'"T§_ gr? ' The SEQ gai the szmzey awe mg t%{:2%§--._§:2€j ' ';gm:g gf 513$': S§,§f'\;'€'y'S are §r_§;d:§€e§"._§.§{:'V ;*i¥§§2n$>:"g§:1g':g";GV:.ana H, whéah gzigariy rsvsaé that Ngségiifii, 682% gm 1§3§.;'C izavé beg: "1é;%%'i: e d"':f:§€§%:>v__1§'§;'v3'§.f%§a;3§§i% $5 é}§5£}:3r gééiagsg Eagaé an %'"€:§ €§=.§i;, has paaséd 5 ?'ESQ§L¥§§G%'§ 3:2 Sagbgeai A ' '4 '_%f;§§;:§4;"i.§;;siT'3,fé__§%':'*§E,SQESQ6, $5226 gaay Q? fiié regaézsiéea Es fszmaé 5:»? iééé writ gfiétiiifif} gagsem $3; tfie §a§d é*é:$§3§:>§::.i;«§i@:"2, 32$ Bahia figs éetééeé 2% aéiaz aismatiase iafidjgiié ///Z;
xx 3:3 faxscujr Sf: the éégai i'e§€eseni:at:::e3 _$f?..%:_?_2e e_--s"'si:'va:%§'_:j:é 'Q:5;;§3€:*V "' 2:2? :39 Eand by makmg aggstigiiggézss 1'_'_'*:E;s:§§;c:~E:;§éagéééj regaiutégn fiateé :§gS,2§§6 an Ehég " L' date {:3 action hag been iakefi by:-§:%:§é"L_:BL[}~:~'%~_a H'ie'r:£e..€hEs wrét fieiiiiem ES flied fm igfié af©re4§*i*%e;j%':*:§'e:,>.:':i1e:§é :fé?%.iej;'f:3"'; 33 fig afc:§°e§*;"s'e:r§:_tl?§r2é:._§;g :§é€"~§§'e--i'E~:§Q_r§Tér$' fathsr éxaé gggjraached ihigé. N'e,81§§;'§? $€€§<.Ef'§§ a:a:§celia*::e:::._:@f s:3TAE1&*Tvj'.;:;ife;§;:i$ :'.%:§<et:;_:.:te=:i the EDA in favour of the thiré pagiéegsg' ::as%é3.. :¥;§'U.§%'FC§§'éS€§ thrse S§i€S Er: auctéga. Téjsgg :%1:f§§ée"§.%é;%g.Va":"a_ §fi§:3§"§:i§tjiy f§m";ed in the %§:*:d §€a?"§§3§ f;}§Agve§r véiiagé Qwags by $28 §ei:%t%$?:ers*"
§5t%:e§i. " .,_« §::«é_;f>.§_§e.,V::}7% ihe sama. § Wffifig §is§m§S$§:3&'3 wag *§f:':a»*:j§ befaré éifiis Cgwi Es: ':f:f,R we; 8295;??? ie «::.§é Te'é*ffé::t-..f:%:aéf i;';§"2QS€ '£;§'§§'"€€ §§"{€S zasege fmmefi if? §3z:§'xéQ.3G Q? A"4".'EE§féz9:"a%f;§a%2'§a%a asiiiage am iéfii ii": Sg,?€@§3§/4 G?" Uigsar, 2 "--Sa§aé 53:: 3&3} %%'§"€:§'2g gagbmésségm %*2%l?. §\i&$§.§S/§1? iame is
3. x.
"V"
be eieeeeee ef «me: Eieeriy ie {he father ef the
-( eeeeeace tee Cm? Ceeri §er° eeeree;'%e*;e"'s*e§;ef:;-e Subseqeeniéyg the SSA §tse--%§"'~?1asV.eee<§e¢f:eE§.re'Lseeey 'V eased en the reereeee€e:.§e:~1,_effiiife'ne-:§§eV§ée.eneEeV"arée feuee ihet the efeeereeetéeeed tfu'*ee.'eé'fLe:_:§ in the %e:1§ ef the pet§%:§eee:'e:_v'<:§E :}teeer véiiege erreeeeeeiy Uéeeer eéiiage theegh was vee--ceu'§"§ee 'e:e.eeEiEied eeeeeeeentiy ie the year' eetéeeeeee heee ie be ceeeeeeeetee se:::1:e:sA:§;e;~ _ e'eee;~ee; te eefegeerd eeteresé: ef the 7*e/_A§eee%eee§eVe'we'eeee §=eee;'§enee eee eeeeeheeeediy eekee ee *,%;he--VBB,e ':,e%eee'e§ eceeieieee ereeeedéeeeg has eeeeee e 4:".fCf%r%:5:..§V:e';~.__ee '"eee zieeexere-T ee eeeeieeee fie eiiee "--_eE%:eesfee_e'ee"eeeeieeed Eeeejeéeee fie feeeer ef tee Eeedéeeere 'Veef§'e%ee--2eet te eeee ef iee /ereeere; eeiieee eeeeeheeeeee; $3! the am. The geiiiimers beirzg the 3?' the 33% are esétiiisé is get the :2? €,§r§é;§§§rV':« &:2;':e><ure~T datéd 3911.289? ;3$ssé{.é I:>«§z :hg%&%%;g%sA mnsequantiy the getitisrsers are'v""L'eff:'i:%t§eé "%:£§'A_V':'SV§%/32% of the éevefgped finds 2:": Hats them.
Admittediy, the §$:§?:i,§n§rgi. "'§,§:;.;.'%§§.'**"Vé><tent Q?' :1 guntas was EDA wéthast acqigisitisrz Qwtisners are entitied :3 and in any éaywut as per ihza C§{cuEé"r»«...é;'2:*;Vé:s<_%§:V=}%:4""%;::_"~~'ijéted 19.:L2§3fi9 passed by $v§nsV.é°""::?;§a..egrzrsserty sf E515 gsetitiasnerg is uaé5§:'fié%'§3§§%--§3:'%E§'%:{§:*:..:,Qss$§3s%es': 3? $3; the BSA prégr :9 ms
- ihe' gaié Cérczgiaz £3 a;:>;.::i%;a"b!e't'<:: .
" _ ' ' a 駧.§_"?§§§a:§§a:*:: +~ AZ. is §;fra;.%ct§{:§.':$ -- 'fie. .;?§§r@a§:ééé:%éz3$' sf' fize § iEi§§3Z§'8'¥'%€§"§' dazed' ziagmagéi 23§:§g2.§@a gafi :5.2.2a§9 gg géy § is": the fight ,&§2n%:s<L§res~M,E*»§§.? and Q szgiiamy, gfgrameaiégneé arées' am as: mgriéts $3 eaiy -1- V but mt Eaiea' Shag awe <::z;ie:'* éémié: Q? séx rszo_:*:§§'2é:~f:}<:;~§§~;»«.A date <3? remipt af Ehig Qrder.
Writ ifieiéiésn is dispasefi sf ___._.%..
3:3.
Gssgaka \.
\\ x \ \\\.u.\..