Gujarat High Court
LETTERS PATENT APPEAL/1441/2010 on 15 July, 2010
Author: S.J.Mukhopadhaya
Bench: S.J.Mukhopadhaya
Gujarat High Court Case Information System Print PK �����2B??]{ ???o??>?H? p6%L?}? ?D???j<{??( Um?G??C c?X( ??sn?@?e??7?5\??* ? ?<"? ??@?E*Z ??5~? ?b?? ? ?T* ?a???? '?| )?K7?? ~??f"4?7IH4??v,?^c?D?T?5` f??
?.b?? .???#3O??'X? ? 6T ?P} $>b5??\??$??io?"???5 ?? 4J??S .?s???_ ??3GH??v??:? ?s??dbku?cAi?vo? pH?????x ??Unx??2d "?=rA?| {??1h) ?>f??@???L ??y#"?g??n??4'Q??9???U l7" %r [?@ ?'?Y?rJ???!???C:?? ??2 ni}? ?}? ?,?T?%??Lr??B?bL:T??K?/YN?t?$???Q??$ R y6?B1/x?? ?E ?" ?=[?* ?8H0~?E????d7??c[? M? 0? A?!?r N[t??~?L?f9U%? `?bt@b?/n5? ?@? ?+?&? ??#? ?3?'Lmj?_3??h ??1?[@S?F8?qn? ? ?? ? ?Rz ^?X?)?+ ??I6?j?+?;??a{??-? ??_ /@?w??- ??v &?FO?U????w2h?3YR?-H?? ? |/?9? ???iv??O? ?
?eQ {<? ?s?^??????l ?w?^x????|Z?/ ? ???JO??? ?'9Ok?^?????yZ;?Z,}??? ?-?G*????j??G ?# ?guv%;?iv%??o?LQ?A??? ?jB??? ??*??3?|?~v?;??P@e ?e??)?!?? R- O??? RJ?J?Y? ? 1>O?f?B.Wo?4??Y??%?{ n5V y? j???? x?? ]]r ???f?q?^??+?Q??R?? e??5 C?w?F d?? ????BN?? >BBS I ?P6???@M????:???z]??rR:? *???N?$ ?N?4Dn ??7Yg4???? p?,?N? ??y8}j?Y??? ?jY?;??.?& ?n? ??n???v??? ??9??5$?; z?U?? ??Q??W? ?k?I b???_?i??Z?d6? ,??x?4? A? ??d?? ??w?uo? ???z???? ?1?^T? u?$??3@W????^?&?0z ? ? ? ?? ? ? x? ] ?V??:
?O ?\n???e???M5?Ne???q ??oA)T 9~v?d?|?lu,??~n $p{d???C????8W??
N|? 3[? Y?s1wh]�Mp(?Qop?x?? ????D???o?Le???R H??? ? ??`?/`P?4O??n C??I?$b ? A'vC&8 ?>L?.?U??I3? ?k-?]G ?hDC= ?K??? ?9Uh ?! ? - ? Y}.??�7 ??? 5A?l W?#? Z?)? G3 @???Gf ????jAA? S???\??I?? ?`? ?�)n?@Y ?? u?i??6TS H?o \ ?|de ??N?3??? ??Gu ? ?
,6{m?o}OY???????�??h? u???????? PK A??? ��?)��PK � � �2B?<������������ ���styles.xml?ZK??6 ??W *?SeI~????4m? 4?n?^i???H?@R~??wH?z???f?9 0??p8?3 ?_?I?{?>xo)KPi?>&??N???v?%.?Y?PQ?? Ks/ ??&X?^?%�? ? K?? ??Y? ? k?I?.? {? N?rgF??~?hX?HR?Z??4?b?7 ???R??R? ?B? ? ??fr9? ?s?#C ? ? 8us?68E ?? ?( o*;?up? r)??P?Z? ??)??:E6? 7" A?\? N?i??MFf??HV;????-H( 4dj\???j?n?K? ????-?" ? "?+?H?? (?? ? ?u`? %?[R&?/I )0'F ????%]Fw ?? ?? t??FV?2?N-W_F?? %B,r:?? W?8 ?????? ?? ???`?|0?vSRya? O00X??`??? 1?;?K?Jo77?]P??T Y?? ??N?P v? ?? J3"?? cU?? ?6?
OpenOffice.org/2.4$Linux OpenOffice.org_project/680m12$Build-9286 darji 2010-07-19T13:47:37 1 PT1S PK � � �2B?<������������ ���Thumbnails/thumbnail.png??uP?A?.? ? B? ?5 ? O? ???eqw ??????]??}??u?)???n??L???gC ?P? ????P???+A?k????�?O7T?%((????"???N? ?I$ z?0?C?){?| P?0? d? ? ?pT?�r&}r8tF]ttt?i(D??`}t81D E1?? ? ??? ??{7????X??U?S ???'?;^????Q?/O#O? ?C??(?ekgP??M?? ??>* P? ?Mc?a OR 9? ? ?e? ??(?#?H???? ~?? W?,N ??W.K)*?=of*?l)g??wo#?? ???t?AC% :O? r?j`?|R? ?? %?z?Hyf?Yu? _?O???=mD N????'?y?Og?{???n%??T ???j?8 ?? u??/7sn?Q' ? ?? iS??T?? ?_U?
?Y H7?u????(???w?dWYa?? ?? � U?d?? ]?>?? �K???yms? ,??N ?????!?+?=??e?�$? C? X T? ?K????M#G9d% ? ?@? ?:A ??j??ne??(o] ?n7??\6?W]??P ?$3??2?s?V?M?W?? ? ? mq5~G??u???w?x(??X???g??? b?dGW?0 ?^ ??i;o ?&?? / 6%???? ?w?y?F?U? ??, ?KW ??u?? ??~i}} ?G?1?_??? ?~?v??^ ?j? ? ?q;k?kC ?+^??i?Qc?+. 6 ??=??p??> U?/? ??n? }g_???<?o# ???U?`?
p ????? [??(?A?!?F@ ??x?^G V?~?
x*??Q??a??y 42]o?z ??{mO P??? ?? x?? P? ?@? _??2??? ??7?? 2??? ??r???,^???;q????? ???l v ?g ? ??? cA` ??.?? k%Qn????\ ???? 8>?6-?1d?)??? ?_\ Q?Pt? ,)?? s??:=1`]??3??5 _???2?w ??? R??H9_?&?8 ?n? ??%+!?p" ? Y/j??}?F?? ???x?Wp??�m?u#? ??k?m Aw?J??�???$?$dd???H?? ?!? ?vM# h??"Q???t?h ??????? <6?^?Ip?w1??"???{1 ]r?c?? ? !?q .? ??}C?? '??N?c????@ ??V?E? ??.B ]?0?Z ????? .????AO g ???,T2 ?;??y???"cq??hn?O =>P?^W? ??.?? F )d .?o�???? A???n? M? I ?ZE? ? a???? ?O??? ??[Q?ph ? ,>??MU?7?x? ?;_? ? o?n?S+ W? JXa?Q lm l??s tq ?? ? ??????W5?GK??TR�??4?$???L-????!GA?? ?(WAf??t) SpE?C? \ ???:?w,,??i?jt??~ Fu?n?U? s??G? ?zeL?9B? P??v<?+?;, $X?8 ,?Q ? ?c`?Bc ???R??6?0??? ????- ?????3??7??5n???x?X7!?a???BX??Wa?.t? ?? f mo ?q \??L:+????O?n |? Q? ??*F??[??(x?? G~c]Zj??| XnW??? {??`h ?? o?5?-? ?y???rP?anW?tHt? I ??}??u~Q??F?aP ?u ?j P???"??@????F(?a @? y?G ?8???
?A?M????+? ? ??l?b?f? ????~x@u??dWdJ?? �Q??-??e? ?h???M??&?
0NRB?v3D????? ?o/??-? ?
??},?? j???8 ?O??W B3??:?j?;??b-h Il ? eSVv?|G'uk?c ? zP?pFB9'6??m?X,?6~I ?? ????m? ?g?>? ?? B>? ? ???4^???Bk??rF??V??P h\??u{???(????
?1?/??l?Y??J ????h?dU.? VB^?? 4??_??^?O 2 /V? ?F??, 7?N+Z ??(??7M?????"?%? ?( ?I L 5? ?&?W?3Lb? "??Rg?Q????ntB??lG? ,*?N??j?? ? ct???lh"?C??? ???}??*??1??{?}?e??#?N???K ]? \?\????-aM??i ?! Cc1??cg ?? ?"???~|??A5 .v?=L (}?
?n??$??=?? n!; =???9????|??!j??>?;?0S ? yA{?v?p'?4??u ?i? T????& ???? \I?b? D?gVVbH3 ?OZ? ] IL&>L^_)3?)) ??4?Q@????? Q? 0A?[iH??7^?|?>*6M????0??? ???#s??8?u??8C &L??
5????):_?s??xV'z?8? &?q??E??? [_Z??? f? s???<"?*??W?? ?9?Sp p5 )? h |? ;?$?? O? ??)bo?hw!?~? ?P 9???? q>0?&?L&Si5?H???2]w??gF [?? ?o/ww ??=?9h LC?Qg?? ??? ???k ?Lx7{ +?????Q?? ??a ? a?DrKY%? 8?`?>3 ?-? ??}Ir??l?CE/=???:]7x ??? J ??D?leJ?A??+?P?h?F$?w0 6?G??v9h?? ??%",2c?)`?? 8 h"?u ?>??8y? ? } ?? ????e>??"?VV ?4^?C|~y?l?B, 2 ?+~:*,"};?? ??? ? 6?}JD ?0? ?6i ???? |?r8|?lRo?0?~? ??7?H ??N7?;?w??f(9??u??I ?AA? -?-t^?? ? (C?g??]>8?'t?k;?-???B?d??%*?u?r?$???, ?Z?l?" ???D?J?Or 3a?? j?f?; ? ?Q �? ? ? K?0 ]c ??A6?X ?C:4?"??^? 3?? R???O4*?ZL ,??(r@ ??kp?7V?V?q? h???????B?m_?\9?: ?B-O??g>?B?X?#?jf?6?=? j ?%p?!?
0?
?,&?w4Lxo?2S~?,?k????Q?fq ?%???8 ?LA??H?} ?'[? ??
$$ 0???7 ??=?s83? R?Y? X ?n?? ?4h??:? ?e??^ ?| _??c?4?F? ???Y~P? y ]k?? ? ?O;5?? ?"V?@ ??CZ?? ? ??m9??S??`2Y?\(? ??8 M?? F?B]`?x?l? $j?
?????z?P !?!|?7?? ?S,??E????0 ??tZ?g????0f9? Q?????k5v0? ? ?_`??`Z??{+??A@?.?x /?(???'u?4X4~V? ? ?? }]JA%??W????[?w?@ h@???e,??]?kh ??e??? ? N `??3??%H ?AHre????, n&??_????KV s? ? ?A? "??z?!S?`5?=? 9R? ?o0( ?????_?\??Y!t?_?J? ? :?EA??_N??J?'WO??? ??D??J?? ~?l??P&??? ??#????Z^c?#?R??2?5? ??[/?C?}704?{?? ?{Y?W k???Zg?T; ?i?a?? ???O?h?+???7@? W ?????X?? C?u ??j?? ??F?3?t "K? ?,? y? ?h?Hg??? ??aL???t??]?O? Kq?2 ????s?a????.?olx??? .????t?r??? ??]?G??1?Ll?i_??[ O2s?!B? *?\? ??z VRJ?x?? +?U2???]? /t[wZG2??3 Ox"?YM ?xh ?F ? ? U?_??2V?? ??? (??J?2?5? $???/!i?? ?? 1A ?????Q?? ?; ?o?C y|c<=oJ&?!6?? ??&?r? l ?w??A?L>???=?p? s?il?0('?, O+Bp"??s ? ?? R?W?IE{?? ??c??H?s?0??T?W???PE ? ?` ???l?ZW?V* ??? vG?` ?.? ???$ lC$?u;??^zb!S\ ?(? ?N???Upq??b?E`??5(Qb?#.???T??? mi]-? n???d?Ttb ?X?j? ?p?%?0 ?>vWvM??r???v?|????n:???u5?????)�S ~ ?\?5{?? J mG????????1?? XR??o??y B? ??? ??$M?V?-? ? \? ???? ? ??J?7?f?D??yG?bF5???? R? ?M !?? .??p?n^??. ? Cng'??1W! ?R% I_ ??&? ?G$m?S?f ??] e y?? ??^x??? ?I? ???q????&s?Z????L??_??^?U?M?Q,?"?P o =q ?A?C?C??vp{?? #% ??c) ?@3?? +?% ??-?|"V ??~ s??^ & ?`??^??? ?????/HoN *?|l;? ? ??dx?G `?l6Q N?D2o?W?k?Nk Nuf8 ? t?
@,�??X O,?s?b?D??-e >xs^?r ?C?p0?x1 k ??S ? ????? `??L:? ???W?M?J??DN?(????<"? ^vl??7???x L! $ ??)}? I ?}H?bEs?)??a?b? U??L ?/??? ? fOH?O?=???h`?u??2? qp)L?B ?d?O???}|!?s?? ?#b?'?_ o9? 6(] ?U?????>?P? GG?e???O D???V???\? ^|??%??b2-x?R ??V???? ? ???2R? ?M?`I?z? ??Q??
-??0??sd;t>??????t ?{} ?w?%6 ???? hD?L???&E??Q_?U?E?f? ?qV?? ?xX?a?r? w<({i M7,{?_?n># ?l? ? , y 7? ?b -?_ ^a7H? ??M?(?j ??x ??Z ?8? ?9??L????? ?G[? buM ???3?
D?V#l??u?k ?
2Ks?F$ Yi?? ?tr?5?6 ??\^KN9 ]D?>?? ? ?Q??UH??J|B ?Dr?$O?.???ax?ic???4??fV+??Zx???M)?uI?e?r??&_ q????`?bm? 22??V?Ff2???`K?O ?f ?# ????*mI? ? ???3? ??W??�)??E?????*(?`S?Sh?#]jN7 r???6???~Of??[?{y "???? ??Q" ?'?G ? ? ???EG?????x?K?;?B,??l B: ?qT??K?bs' ?} L?D???Iw???L?}g{BcV??? s ??j\????!?j?I?5?%??????fK??K?
? |? "??w ?W ~ ??o]Ahe ? H??j???Y?? ???u?? 6 ???IAj?? cG?3H k? d? D?jR???b?h??U?^�N3/?;??%[? ?????? ?2??F ?L'?????\l ??2= ? R?/?D B?[u" <8? ?l?S???UB?$?KH????? .GJ? "?g?7? ^wX????Y?'? t?m?? 2. tJ??? HW9?b??? n????+?}????.18?????+?t??VU? M} gA$?j j??:??EN?nw?bo ??q ?d< Y[?2d?C?- ?w;O)?~}?,???1 y ?W??G4 + ? 7?Md?Xe???Od?9bX ??7C ?? ~?Cm??Vo??o ????? V?c?lQ`?v? h?6?;< ;j?i?? M?? L "?A?? ?????1?{? ??j?\??? ?:�? gT ??0x"? ? ?6T c/ !??t?? ? ?}R ???0=V??yoH2???F` X: *? ?2?y? a????JH?? ???Im?a |?? ?? ? ??'^B;??L%* 6^'?J?T?????"?/?? n???_?G????1O /$I? 1\*?h*??0? ????[z >??U|[?!% ???A ?? ?` ?H ?? ?~o#??2?F2?? ??QF ?R?@] ;?%? d??#?!J? ????$]???.?Q ????? F?5??S]????UY ???v?2F{ ]????G????? $?#???^?pL? ??x1f_JU???#? 'B?.? ?N?_?r+#}?o3?K??I [? ?) ?M???????W@?fZy51 F ?kH>S?'?;? ? ???59[?h? ???.??`+?NJ!?+/(}xF,}?C=? fHM??aN?
??@e ??????G?M 0??T???)?aV# ????r?c? . ??Y?[?F0?K?? I? _??>*G 1?#?vr?['??? OT??tG??? R ?2???E? ???I?i ?[*??|r ??? ???S.E???Y??' ?W? ????? ???a??????8 -bgd?q @??2ZJx,G}???J???}Z?�+?~?T??r?Y?Q)H?fHm\?FC6??^Q??.|?J? ?K?@ ?D~ ?q|2??? ?k?d ?um??Q\F?? ?nBn???!?q ?? c?n8??"?{:??C?C?P?`????? RJ ?.?? ?" ??M>?????? C?Rd ??_ g3 ? ??tEG,??$4{??x ?6_u? ?rw ?!2~? +???1 ? ??? f ? ?? ? ?
?j???%??]???M??????&u??~??fJ? n??m^?? ?? ????r???T??L?
~?E? ? ?/??CC?HAL? ?
{ ??f?X????E k L(? ?4?a??w f???Cy??? ?X???=??:n?N l?(??"F??!_?1?M? ??J?PI?q$??,?t;? ??Ww???W??z =:_??" ? K3 p?)f 9 ? ?k????e?'>GF?>B ` ???3r?a ?�'?/?J? ?4 $ p?] ???,+p?2?Q?8]??GI]b??? # ?? 3 Fq?#5{?k??]??{&???g?? / ??'x?t? ??v GEV&q ??y ?0???w???2?? z??? ???!??K>F?\8g?e ) ? ?mT?U : o? b?_?? 5?H�H????EjL h??R{?? ?v ?&#ue???bjd7?e(Ge??_ ??l? ? !?c ???? NV2?ix?? ??Q?669?W ??":p??:I?f "n ?~?b??Gu?d?�?a I? ?g??? 6???v???}1??.???? ? [??t???:?AW? ??+? Ot J)?Q?%= ?A_4c 6 ??/N?? ? N? &v) ?'=Zr}?s�r?F????| zQ ? ,JK_ ???? ?6 ?m??BGq?$.U? ~\?zH?? F>y ??qz??6 |???? G?D? ?~2 T@?z#?w ??S XA?$?e@??? L {7aK4?$3?O?FM? ?h~?d?o?+??J ?a??"??)?:>%??B??E??Z??/K??_?g?@?? %? ?: ?T?Z?? ?z?? #?A;?? ??;? ????q H?S U? 1???s i ??E 3?? ??H6?U? ??r~R?'*??? ?)?4???y8? ????? ?? H ??q?? ? ??~ ?7??S?t?7????$???G/ A? ?i?:???J ?83???r # ?W?(??Z?R)???? ??z?|>??K?V ?F9y?ZX ?O???t?? D?d???$?M/:U?+ ??)xv?R?!4xd_ ??o ??>q????? ? #g?D/#z ?4?g???uy e?.Lt.t? ?K??Y p??y? ? Lg?>?k?? g8 ?O ? SP ? 90?4???=?DK?\? ? }?? ? ?? ?o?*? w(7?r???? GUZR?:M 5?orW?W* PwdJ??????x T0?p?DI`mdv < #???`[?5?? F?~ ?o?pDH??6CI ?A;??(?a?g ?!p?4? I_ ??9_???]??d?_@?? ? b?4)?W ???>?l?( ? ? ?&??/z�Fpa?| ?O?X ??? ?�?? ?p ? c ? ?)??U p 0??>?#XS? :?T?�;
>??Mw??J?X?m # ??\G??qC2??/ ?t\ 3? ?H"5 #N?[ >?@?}???M-9?%?? ??& "
?J?0?j)????/Q eS?n?H? n%??????0?m?? ? p~ `???d?q?{?? F?-
??R?? 9??~?,? r+????TA??? @G??s???V[??l k"??)S~AR ??-????iW 5 h?w?U?EvlJHb�?+ ?\??)??e ?J? ?*??? ?O???l)P|p??d ?D?Lx?-h?G)??:d??i??)?Ugr?b????z ?I?? ?jG#?�L?? #L? 3???blU*?I????- $ u? ?M?VC? ?lI?B ?3 ? ?S?lT1? ?^? c?s?w?(/???If?v?Xj:?WC?V?^,(n=? ???K???Yu2k.o?
Z?? p? PK ".y?? ��C ��PK � � �2B?<������������ ���META-INF/manifest.xml???k?0 ????.?g!v?? ?mz?? c?Z i ?W????X?0 s????|?/ B'?C??=:/?N X?:3??e?6?S?&?w???j????Q%?,??)??f???r ?fhJ??2a;"; 0?7?? ??l P?J?T ?&w?? s)b:ZL??V?LP?5?u?}?y ? N :? *j?b+h?0`pS?uent!??}e? x T?p??2"( ? [? u? ?L???7?S??d??
??(??LR%??5?F?UK?] ? ? !?: ?) >?????w?VH? ?u,???V ?Top