Karnataka High Court
A M B Kotrayya S/O A M B Gurubasayya vs The Deputy Commissioner, on 19 November, 2011
Author: Ravi Malimath
Bench: Ravi Malimath
E E3'? '§HE HE??? CQUR? €333' E{;§EE\§P;TA§{A CERCUET' BENCH 5%.'? DE€ARE:Vf§I3 gm THE mm gm; GE' NOVEMBER : ' ' BE§QRa W_M ma HOWBLE :a;iR,J::s2*:CEf':':2§§;€;%:" :2/:;t§:;§.::?1;a':'§§ " A . WRIT PE'§E'E'EON N@,6§3f{2~._Q§* :03 .1'{iT§:£'~§%£~5R'*:'§".§ S}"
BETWEEN:
E. mm» x ' *z:::$:?: EELLARY, A.M.B KQTE?.AYYA,AS'j.{)j;~ Agmfi§.§::;;%..::'BAsA*;YA3 AGE: 53 f:'E:'2AE%*--S§ eI}cc:_.:3:§s'I1\:f§:V,$_s,§' R/AT: Rf-<3: 5E{Q'1"7E'UR; _:EQ;_.-KLQBLEGI, DIST: §%3E£gL1f§R'Y.:_ J 03;.3via'@_,¢g3~:G§;§:~«:;:3'*s/Q.C'.§i,:v:.R;:.J3z§DRA':"y'A, .A.<::E: V¥*"'g:.r.:a;R$%§ SEJSENESS, R/M': R;;G:VVK<;¥:fTa%.R',»»«TQ: KODLEGL DESTf'B_EiL5LAR¥';. ~ V .. «E%gE¢K'.~SHEK£E:%EAY%'A S; :3 . M . 3;, ;::ARFx,?E§R§;gm, & 38f5EARS:'; 93:1: BUSENESS, .R;.z:?.: :3/a..: E<:G"E"EU§€3 'EQ: E{Q§iJ{i£} 3: 5:;f1=..:' B;2:,;§_;;gE'z'! A =-.43:/E.Cé-,E€§C§'T5RAY"%';§ 8;'£>§E»!E.t3.§;3fi:EU?§':"};%'{Yg%§ 5?"? Y§;iRS§ SCLC: BUSEE'€§2SS§ R/33$': R:/G: E<iQ'?'§7/UE, '?Q: KQELEGL k ?E'iTE'?§G§'€ERS 5;; Sri: g ':5 ?2f':"}§'EL, ggmzacggag E' E ANNE'.;§<Ui*9:ES»B *.:§:a::éa§:32.:%.s 3:53;: éiiracz the :*'€$;::r:sn<:Eem:3 $9 CGE}S§éfi€Z° {E23 Ex.) AND L THE EEZPUTYCOEJE?vEESSEG_NER;._ PREZSEQING QE?F'£CER5%'E"*EL/%§7§£§E3? *:<;}_ HINDU RELIGEQUS 82, CEiAE¥;EE'A_BLE % "
ENDOWMENTS, '-- B§ST:BE1LLA§':',' j %
THE ASSISTANT Cazx/:T:\;::$%$*:<§;\:;*a:rg.
BEE-LLARY, W. V. ., 3§sT;BE1,~L»;g§*, gm) RESPONDENFS gsamsay
THIS ._EVRE'if'.§E:3F}"Fi{)N~--l:3 FELEED UNDER ARTICLES 22% & 22? QF THE. ':$QN.S'T§1'--UT1CiN OF INDIA PRAYENG m DIRECT "::Es§>aN3gNT 3:0»: ANB 2 'TO CDNSEDER 3?H1;:: . "RE?RESE3NTATiQ£\ES VIBE) " M13 BAND '53 PASS AN APPROPREATE H '~3:'H'§'$w'L"%%»%;wifiéé? ?E:?ETE$f\§ COEEEHQG 0%: mg ?RE:1£__MENz":§E?:' EEARENG 3';-gs wig, TEE seam': 4 j§EL?%JE§§:§'§HE §'®§§_,€f}W§E\IG:~ QRBEZR This ?:3':§%:é,e:: fisé sseéiéng £233" .23. *s5::*§*: :35 ,e**\ EM);
/M3 (J) :&p:*6$e:1':&%:ia::$ véfie A::n€:<:1re$'B E3 af1d,_;C;-Efiiiivf censequenfiai reiisfga 2, The case <3? pet2D:§e::er'S_i§ IE2;/EB): in. Kziei-'e..* inier se dispute bet:/vsen :h:=:shef:r3 §§*§_23f:e Karéfingeshwazg Q,S£\TC>,4;' E§€E»$"'*.fi--=v3:s f§€g§«T_éé*hi<fih ws;$ dwreed on 3w3~1§'?'6., °£T§.1}:re:%,i'te§;* branches ef Eaté Kariiingaj/§:a f§}eé geeking 'cc:
dézest respQ:1';i?§f:;1;{::~; 2V {E13 Padéézienai Distrisi f §:fim§$si:>::e:1. Beiiarjyg 'ta haniéovgfi? management of {£16 i::s%:é?;U::ief;.__e :" V:héVV.§T\}iL:::--: §E3'{i'€3:@fi€E"'S. The Cgurt by its Qrcfgar daieéi '-é':%_«» E;'E;"«i§§*'§6 E51636, a: para 5 a3 f€}HGE/VSZ- J *'v"5;;-, iew {he maiéer} Ehe jEr;:?: rgéief ' .3a:g§?::7.:;{é%5::§y €526 §>§i§?iG?'E:3?"' has FZGQEJ %§s::Gme ':f§*gfr§/:.;:':%7.z'a3';;;:s 5:: Efiéléi §f E916 ?°§$p@née%::s Ezarading Qz2ss:r?v.f?a€ §§$S€Sé'§:'}?'2 @225 5316' maaagemezzé sf E528 . _§}i";?Ei'§E2Eé€;*?% S22' Gumffiasa:ss3$%z225.::*z::3:,a::i:2?2/3,; Eétfuii is 3526 §}'€€§§§G?Z€3§" azmzi {Rae :§*2;emE3e:**s ::2f if'/zg §?'2:2?':C}3;. fr:
SQ far as :?:e secsné pmggzgr :3 C'C%?"i23€3'"?'?,€3C§, 52 §MW.W,V, direciierz is issued :9 E228 ?'€3g:?::3?"é§EEE"";{S 5:3 céasésfiér and giéspsse Qf {he 85} eaiied z'§pz"5se:*:is:;:f:'::_>.r--*f§_'j€Eéé:?f'=- by éfae petiiioner in ac(:@:'§E$.z*z<::e wiffv: 2:12;: .:z;::'i}f;€§'z--f{: . ?"<§':'CES<i}?Ze'l§:.'33€ iima 69 with {$2339 a;*:E3ser22r::i:{:>7?;;<;....a2'é Ad§rec€:'::¥%?.,$;'<€,§2;*5i..
geiiiian is dispogeci of: No 01?'d$rS(;£S :5 {::'"é'E§)t$e "} in pursuance Whsraof the I,De:pw:;y C§<:;§°:':.%;:§S'giener by the eréer ij;5ai:nexur€~C cafisidezing5-ihé««..r1£;V§:>:¥';:S<:4:1:;§,>;?;éQ:':-é'}::~23;$sed ea: eycier is £116 effe<::-- Eb3i"fTh€':':}}.€?f€3T§fVIE§SL11C€i:'=Ci? éhs Peeja is :0 be ar:rang:::5:_ §i'r5G;:;<:f'::'§jnL;§;:eV i:Q"":?::§ aumbsr sf persmzs represe::t:;:'V§V g«-.§ 3¥ch f3.:;f:§_§§ni§;i the pragaarzéozz sf 3:§:5:Z7
-v. a:::€;v_»»'§':§,r_*:er::13 A<"}~:**::;_§_:%:3 eight yearsg Thsrsafier 7_;%;g";$€xfL11*sé:$«B«v_&' E; rfipreseryéaiiona 'fiffiféfi made 333; 23:26 };3S;E§,.?.§ UI;:€I;$ Estisrs Ciaiad E2-§»2{.}1E and £5" §"€$§®EEé€:3'£S E 3: 2 Egaersin is "V.§~§i§§A§:Eé3.3fI'l:":'§'Vi..§Z '£318 dscyse 9? $329 Cévié Cigar: arzd :6» ._ *_.;3:.:":;z:'i3;*:'g7%3 tbs Pesga W{}i"§<I 32 Esyms af {he éiéizfi {ieguzi ".'VVV@€%i§$€e E£1*1§,€:* Ehsge a:'r::1.z::2s':a2:i:s:§$, Ehs prsgsizi ?etit:*a:r: is féfasé sssking far a :::a.r1éa§r;:,:$ 13:: €Q1"1S§§€E".'*___ figs repzré S&Q4E8C{3§Qf1a
3. Heafsi tha Esarrasci co:;fiééE'a§p.$a:i§g f§:»:f ééée p€Ei§i0I1€f'S.
4. Jusn: (me ;::);é*;<.>.}.&,::1<,¥."V'ir:é.:3:E>fé*'c":_:§?z urgédxén tbs Peéitian which wads as f9§E<>Wé:» ' 55 4' Eéespaxaéerzif 2' "z,:r'£' §&z:§§{ $0 seaside? Z318 " zxifiéé vxinnexurewfi and fl gi"'§z:21é;::;éré;?f:?%V " ififge an appmgzvfafe &€.¢§si@fi z'.:z4V;*.?:éV.2§?;;0.:€€r as 3&3 gams Ems 220?:
abe§:ez":; :§I:"i<"3 Peiéiiozmfisr Lageeicirzg an if;g§}2'?f@§23'i«;:ffé"§:.Ez*e:::i:;>:';; 'fa? imgieraenizézg 3:319 3 T. Cizxii CC=?;€E"§ 225038 £s22'a8xza:*€~A 522225 5'C'i2"der sf Eespgzzéenz $50.3 aide "-- iéé*:é::exus"€»C., €fz*2;af€2* {flags cirisumsiw/sags &§§?"@§Z??'§a€8 ::§i?'8Cf§§?1 may kizzdig 58 isszzecfi €22 éézg zlmieresgi 51;' j§iS€E}.':8 cgszéf gqzziéjgg 3 $1?' V» V» in the zzgiaiemeni 95 {he factg Q? the 523.88 iiais 3;sj§,__ psiétianer E333 is sag in paragfaphgfi "Q5 2": :3 submifiea' f'45':'3.:_.éézi§ié";m<;9?':r:"-..
Ezcazze giver: éhe reprgTs§nEgi:::A3éé:-- ia:z2"s:é--a{'z:: is Azizzexure-Q and §s%.::"§%:+e?2{?xr:e4§?_V ' }?es§a2m:£er:t §V<:x£ 33:55-'~--f.§ _-fa"'-:€Lz§:;:>§e%?ze:2Vf..vvfhe decree sf Ema poajca wgzfk, in :g.rf%2fz:.fs'--z;>f' C'7%f':z2i'Z O§€C?'€€ Effie s;:z:{;E'3. %'egzG1¥eséra§&€iC+2§;é f'*§<:r:2_:§£: :20: been c:§:»2z;'s:"z'V<;Z'§9§:j';*.iéé:€" has beer: Za§C€7"Zg "é}*:g_~jV R8g??"'€88?"3§§Zi{Z>?ZS '. aL'€é:.§E2;*.'e§§,zi;5:£?Z 2* : d€d:8,z'9f2<i?Zj§ are as £:2ne2<:25re»,B and _ _v {.g'2::iéxr E31536 cércumsianceg figs:
:?5i;5f€Vj§,'€0rz'e"é*s«.s_es2kin§ aw a;3prQ§ria:e C€§?'€C§§O?Z 3.95% same 92': éhevfeéfawiag amazzg '«-:>é";?'--f=,s;1*"" §?;*s;:;%:;0Zs. "' " "4«.__V'§'»§:€raf0é"s:__ 1' £215: cage 9? $313 geiétéansfg is $313:
7}3;"§}§3.€§§;gfif€S' B E wspregeaiaiéang have 586:1 zrzade by saéiqing ta E:f:Ej{§§€§'§}§::'ZE;'{ {he déarss Sf 1:316: iiivél Cauri
-3% /~"W~.,.
<1); my "ml and {£2 :*€-a:*:*a::ge ihe psgja x>:xa:"';< ii': ierms Sf '$26.. 95 {E26 Civil Saar': as narratéd by 2:326 ':h.€rr136Eve$. ._
5. The Eiéarnéd tjhei geiiiisners is unable s;::...%:c;v §he=w a writ Qf mandamus is exssarztéon <35
8. decree 'whezi 'aha:
is the sgie 13;§:§% _; sf mandamus cannet '§,?%fQ§'§s§0ns sf Qzider 21 of {he CPZC? and an efficaciaus E"€§H€C§}'., P€:--?Z}:'£?§{>i":S 'S1';};f§;f:: as éihisf Sseéiing £93' a writ :3? 1":3.a:1d,:§,:"::;;:.s 1:<::>"'6:<;éCu?:é Cam": §€CE'$€S ?€QE.l§};"€S is has d €§%.ré"c:%;if€si' £:§_.§.1:«fiE"3P}a..f;f.?§ azqé am effécacéaus famed}? as :3*?:*::;_§€:E:3:=@';'*2;:11f:;;i::V:f'€}:"§e:' 2% $1" {IP53 has beef; $s:s:2f::3gE:3':&Ej; _ giveif-8; g§»E%;~§€¢ Ejizfiez" ihége {:f§E'Ci3:I:S'iaE':£€S ihfiseferag Eéaiizgsf :'§':-é. C£*1":.S§;§€:§'€§ tséeaar '$18.: :29: 331?}? is :he pressszzi _' -?::f:£?:;'§:<>~:": 1§°ri2;0§e'us; biz: E2323 566$ §iE.€d 'v;€?:h@:,:': an}: %a31's,; HGT 'mih am? §?Q"n§S that wauié; atéraci 25; 2v:":T'f__ of mandamus. A<:r:e:~dir:g1§?g RSkf--
{E16 'vifréi ?€¥:i':§G:": :23 dis:r:'{5S'3é'¥;i._:'vv, f :