Karnataka High Court
Zino Davidoffsa vs Mahendra Kumar on 21 April, 2011
Equivalent citations: 2012 (2) AIR KAR R 675, AIR 2012 (NOC) (SUPP) 510 (KAR.), (2012) 2 ICC 643, (2012) 1 KCCR 13
Author: Aravind Kumar
Bench: Aravind Kumar
. _ ~m,~.&§§-'
W
.:"=a.ge{E axE;:>':1€,g»i.3 '}»'€_ _ -.
'1=?z;:»i'i§:z1 ']§'<é*:.ye:*s;,. ET {')%'i'?--f%. '§?"'E{;,1{>i:
7?'83<:»:7§£-- B. :?:3€s€:E.<,:-:rj EV;
~{§*;;1::g;;é:-%.3:fz. ~ E. {BS 1
IN THE HIGH sonar OF' KARNATAKA Air _
myrmx) THIS THE 2153* DAY 01? g§.PR.{L._..- ':23-iii. M
BEFORE: V « 1' : 4
THE HON'BLE MR. JUsT1cE»5.RAir:.Nn :2
M,F.A..No.475 g§;2; Qg;;
&
M.F.A.N':3;;:'74';':z2;;;;
M.F.A.N"o.475 OF 2011 '
BETWEEN 2
Z1120 I3avidofi"SA "
A Cc>1'p01'21{i0':"i '§<37'i'§,;,'21sji:i:5€:c:i '7: «V
Umiei" Ehéi Ezm-#5-<5: <§_E"-S*a,€.?.i--€.;i--eé;,"i';¢:zit}._
E-iavimrgj its r€%g'i'sf{'.€;7_@C1 <)ffi«:?é-3, _. T
At Rue §?E1i.1(?i§§,{1}"w--Et,*CI"EV?"3?U{}__ '
F:"i?::<>1:2:*;;. ?3\.x.r'§iT:2:a-%:'E'é':~V:'1{2 .
f
Lt»
;
R€:=pmSt%::é::::;fE h::':'3."€iz': 'i§jg.__£:'}i%
Cégiiééai§:1,:ta§:§_"'A:A,--i'g>i z<.*:;€;*:}-»' A """ " 'V
§\#1:".'Rie=:h:j.'aE,Eie;:€h:, V
§<>.n :j>?f__E;>; Ex}: .V§{:%EE§i',§;1§;
-sfizfi. ' L
' . .,;'%E3'§>'Ei§.;EA?~l'_§'
[BY SKI .8. R. KAMf~§'I.gA€I E*§,A'RAE'J', A.E}\?(:)CAT.EZ FUR
M ,2' S . ES U Ei)ARA SWAMY AN U RA?v'I E.)Af;€§. €iI}V{)C1A"I'E-S} "
AND:
14 I\i'Iah€;2:1<31'a KL.11{"£"£I-3.3;"
F'21i',hez"s;s naxmt 1104: }g<;11<m-*:'1 to _
the appeliariiz, 1m.:j<31: ''
Pr€3pz"iei.c7::
M 2' ss.As;s;<}<:;121i'.€= Inc. Imiia
2. Smtfvi m 21.121 P.2u~mar
\»'v'if€: <31' S}:i.?¥T211i1ez1dr21 KL:mar__
Mzijczr, V
Both 1f'c::3;pr:>'n(1e:1t.s; ha.ving t..E1ei1--"~.. V
Addressses521t
Nc:>§2§/' E, "?2-"<3 C1'(>:,.<.%:¥;~t;.., 1?;?'ié":.;'E<,i.."Ma%1j1' Ef.<;2?g.--;i1,
RajajiI1ag;a1', 5"? . ,
Ba':1g'211(>re M V:.:;;«. ~ " .aR.'E3SP()N"Il)E1\E'i"'S
{BY SRi.LP.Ri;%§¥ --£'~x'p",*-AV's?C{T;:;!>C:F'E>_F«'%€f:}::'??iv---SE"?3.RAGHAVENQRA 0.?
ADVOCATE FCR sI3;5'\V£4T,f3\'"§"{j}E;%;'E"~§_E'L'$.?>i3NSENTS)
&_'§'§~£IV_85'.:f;'v'§E_5';z~"%_ ES FA§'V§;§II}__'Ul'3E3ER €}R§)ER 43 REELEL EM OF'
C:}P.{i;' A{}§k.E?iES'I!" QRIEER DAT"E1§} 04. '§{3.2{f?E{} PASSEE}
{}NV--EAJ¥%[,N'O.2'v._§N+§Z}.i~Z;.E'~10.€'34¢§S?';°'2;0}{} (}}'€ 'I'E§E-- FEE: C3?' THE
XVIII A«§J}I)AE'£7LiZ}.I\§;'\§;.9' CETY CIVEL LEUDGE. }3AI'€GALC}RE7.
zit"»...§}§STvEES'i%§§€{3 'E.§§;i§§€§.2 E'E§;E3£f} UT\Ei.)EZR {EREEEZEQ 39 RULE 2,
32:21} 2 Of%*«..€fvEf;€;3-E?'{>R *1";
((95;
M.F.A.No.4'74 OF 2011
BETWEEN:
Zing ET)avid::)ff SA
A C()'{"p(3I'2}I'{',i.(}11 c>;*;g211'3ize:1
EE':1z:1e2:1* *::.h.£% laws; :_>f£T Ss*5Ei:;:r3:*221z'1<i
}»i.avir*:g its 1*é3.gisi:,&r<.:%d oi'E'i<:<-3
At. Ru<';=. F'2rL.1<:ig':1§; 2'5, CH--1?'OO
F1'ib€)E13"§-.§., Sw'itzer'la:1t1
R{3pz"a::-:sae:'1i.«:é<i he1*<3in by ii:-3
Cu11sst:it.:.1i:<:::1 At:t.01fm3y
E\z"Ir.Ra11LzI Setlai,
Son of late Sri.N.E{.Sei.hi,
Ag<:€1a_b0'L1t;4?» ye21r-8, __ 1 .
Vz1t.ikz1'1'<>we1*sq £O€h;'E?E{§;>r; =: _ '
B1.c«:?:k--B, Secttozf IR. 4' » ~ «
Gurgaszm V 122 06>: "
}{21rya:1gi _ .... _
In(i§,a, ~ _ _' . ,.APP£«:I_3'A'§\IT
(BY SR1,S;~¥§.:mvIA¢;i;?§;<:i%1;%xf§%;aN'. AE}VO(fA'E'E
Mfs3uSEEN1f)ARA Swgmxé Ami)' _R§iMi.}ASe A1§)'JC)CA'_'£"E;S)
fliié
3 . R%"§gaE1é?ffi"a:iI"a--v Eitgz ::f":;a§§*
Fat%:€:;*'s_s ':.'1:E1'I:i'£'%:': :':°*:§}€' §.<;';.'z<:m;n i:.n::>
° ag}§:%i;é.iEé.:'§:é; r1",1.2Vé.;§j_<";:;:<1;
E3:"{5g3:"iemzy .
_ ,{I<§.£Xs$<}<3§2.g,§:.€{ Em': linflézii.
1 7 FJ£L2':2g2§2?§ §3&?i3"I"i§éTi§"
~. « . 3iE'if'::a. <1? VS'§*-;?.,--.§'v'E a if: am gizzzi. 'E{:m*:;%;:'
' §s,:r'¥;:;_;::§;: ;
FOR
«<2
W1': C',1"('f' :.11'1{ier' the 2:1'ppEi€',aiii{1}3'1$ f'§_1.:3d ?::y* p1z2:__i3;'1i.iff I .A£\%{.>.1. arici U
Lmcier OE'd(;"i'1'" 39 £32,116; 'i. a:r'2<::"i 1?, C.RC ezéatiim to be <.iiie;1ms~i,ses_<::<3
it is (?t:)1"1§1€1'1{i€d that }53E€ii1'}§£,§.f?§"iv27$",Ci?E*E){f}I1*§E£.€.i.€3§2:,A'
0:*g;z111i;zs3e:i urzcictr iii": 6:: iaws of S\'2;fi'._:«i€:.:i1:;1:1§1V" Ai'1;'z{::.=*izf1g.
SWiii:2:er121n£i zinci F6'/13'1'€S€I'iti€fd £1'; IE'2V':Zi_i2:2VV_»byt '§.%(.)E1:i;v':i".«ii'i.TIEi1'§.€;?(i
2iti.or:r:e%y M'r.Rah:.:11 Sethi. If plaintiff has;
b<:er1 {:3.:r'ryi:':g_§ cm 'é,h<-2 }QT{f)OE'F"
wfih iiiszs ':'re1.cie :11.gzfE.< 1' iii} 1900. ii. was
«::<}ntr3:1d€d iI1'{.3'{}{i"Li{',{?C1 in £91}
and it fies the '4;1.;f:é1:3:1jiE_}* ?;':§1a'§' at? tfze. b€;;:§m'1iz1g§ {sf
{E16 £21.55? Cfff3I1'E[1:i';§z"~' Kiev [R1:::~2si21} '£0 C}s;2m;éva
§;'E§c*;x;;.:'¥:;:f::;%2'§%2a;v.¥¢1§;} H110 {I%i@:m."},.--*§ "§I§A\fE§I}OFF'L Z,in{>
"E'}éé'2?E§33§'E9"§f's£.'_ §'22;:!::'.h_&€'E'~ _{3§3em<;-':d 21 'i'<3b:1c:t<> i\Ii:~5fi';<~.s ;.':S§:0'Ef:;r :«;.mc§. Zizm
}mvm€;%*i;«*%~'msL%.%%%:;:g[;'::¢:f; in Eiifififi em:::% §:;z2?aVi:'1g §;;}:=::1§. éimzz in
V" §'};5":f§"'Ei_}{§;E**§F? ET}§'2£.I'3{§é?{§§ E',}§°{4,§€:§§\.'Ex§--',\:%'\L,V,§)>
i3g:fg;£%'::;':.i:'321,, §3;r;~1:2:.i§ 2.m::£ {fziba is; p€1*f<:«::§. E353 E=e_:'f:<:>1afie:ci§§;é;é zmd
'1¢é>§;3{=:;{ifé:-=a;:3V§i=::.A'E'{)ii)a.<'t{:<> mamu§_21<:{u_:'i:f:_g;j ss;£.2:i.rE'ed <:1"&:2;:i,i:'2g;j }:*2::':§;js: af
.....
j\Jé:22r&§""i,§i%;', 3:-m<"§ ii: 1::-"as zwi; §?é:?g§$i'.€:?.i.'€?{§. fazu" 2.2 §{}§}§; ,] §;3f;'i'i"_§_f.}{§ a%:--{i i4'§"i:.:;s;"' ii: had {*,§§§}§2"€?Ci 111:1 3:993. ii: $2-ass 211-SQ _ _{;€}:':"a".s§:':::§§:::a;_§_ 3:32.13' <?.s:i%::2{%;az1f', is; 2:%s5<.} iiiing ax': ;?:§_3§:x.%2Ti'§ ix? E1393 "VEEz%.:{75§__§s:»:{a'E:€,:2:Z§ E3:"{.:§;3€::*'é:jg; E.§<>2;1:'<:§ €02' aézamji£:iEe;2.E,§<:<1'1j§'z%:'11<'>::*;::.§ <3? €:E':€: 10
r:i<;=.fen(ia3'114 1'.'~E<').2 21$ ;§2;1z*t.}; wE:h<mi' <}E:»'éa.i:'1.E3'1g i::%21w;% <j>f'i.1'1c:% {Z011 I.'T;.. 1%; was zeaism c<>m.e3;'1<:Es::<.1 t.he?:1: _pe3op}€: E}€:1c31':gi.2'1.g £11': C1'}.ri:%s~ii2'u:1 <:{}211n1:.1:1iti§,: izirgely 13:33:? théf.' :.'12;m":r:>. "{)ax-»'i<.i",»"'i1}A'\f'§.¥§§O'F"§?5'f--~.. i',}_"1<:i'1' pas:-:€s«;0:'121£ 31213316 ztmd ass s;1,1<:}': it (:z;11'1:11é::'}'i__'i:}r::
(>119 part.ic:1.:ia.r i::1c1ivi(.Eu211 and i':1:1us;-3 Se€:'£.§0z1 9 czaf U116 'F1'a::k=: anti &'£er<:}1.;e:rL:--:€?';§Es§% .?x2'1.:«;v§'1:*i':.:s zérld the re3g'isi1'at.i<>11 {i(}I1€ "by t}:E€f.. <i"):'5fitc?c:*. 11:%if1%:":'<§§;§isE.eI' is; ifififgiéil and 2-15; ssucll Suit: is; 1101: mai:'1{iv:;2.it"2:1b].{;%}" r:1}:-::«:i fhai. <i'éf"én('123.':':»ii_.iS§ ussirzgg the trade
37. it was; (:{}'r::'t:ét*;
mark "E)AVIDOE'F'_' e3--i:_ifig:e s黧1i'ng its p1.'oc1u<:i: in the rnaz"ie:€:t: $i1'1o:: ias;§tf"E':_.?; _yéa,'r:~;4."'«~.._I'iT 'W:-£533 r;:«:>1'1.i:e1'1ded '{ha'é: L"£i'1d.€1.' ;':,1~'«:":f;.i«:3:': 9 <12? %j.§'1;:~"T;7:::z:§,g;'Mg::9?x5 ';":£%':".? 1992?} ira{§e .m:gi:*k. sf the :_ss<V::i'vb;&m':V:'€g{i$t.€e:'e{'E iE<:%g,;:aiEy. ii: wa_s~.; c:,m£'«a*::1d<:{i t.h2?:_'i; t:_:€2::_:ic% £'122;:fE«; zii' "§?}ia:i1':'iifi' was *<;ai:1ci {}3f"£§:«_,-' fox" 3 p<:-.:r£o{£ (.1? sasrvez':
'E 12 (31) Griginal plaint pm':-sfinted before the Delhi Egfigh Caurt Shaulzfi ham: been fiiafi bef0§'}e*'.::"f%;%}%:.VA' Bangaiere Ciijg Civfi Cauri: as it 15,
(ii) Eihwer sf Ai"iZC:E'£'}€}F of the p1;§a;in:$ff"$ }i'§3jp?ff;e&3£ei*;3?.;3.3::§i%}§. T rm": produced.
(iii) Lack Qf territorialg'uri;edi::£";iori;'"
{iv} E2';egi3trati.£m Certifiégzte trade mark in Qri_g¥i:::3.i}ii5$._._:10§f iétfié plaintiff' (2!) _odi'v.I:'_VI?:1.e§'1-;f;§faafa':% ::1§:'3é§~.r3fV:':ie plairztiff fig cantrary Egg the p£;;«5:sf§o:§s"%';{f'Traae Marks Act, 1953 {vi} A. -- .PI"€S€:1a'i?T_'§IG€fi*3€.{iiIi:gS am "required if) ha stayed an ' éécoiugt ef gjééfédéiicy 0? proesesdingg initiated by bfifara Enieiiecmafi ?mp€rtjg Baaré s_§%€3§i"~ig Canaeiiaizien af a§p€iE3.:}1:i3 trade mafia.
éyww 22 zmd .%3L:<:t}'1 cit~::£:is;é<>1'} }"f;"f}i.f3{1 upcm; by the i<32ém'1t2<.i €.?{}1,1I'1S<Z?_1.-.__If{}1' dc;?f'e1'1{§2::'1t' wo:..11«.:.¥ ;:'1<)i' be of ariy £1S3S51iS"{,.5."£I":{f€? to i'i1e3::11.
16. ii: w<m..Ici £~1£S(: be of r€3Ecj~*;*é§i.i':4;ée:?. 'ifs; <;%.:<_t:',:*;n:,i:_V 'the: I' JL.a(ig£I1€11i. of this Caurt", in [118 (32156: of Sé'<7:1'12:i_§§pi1 z'{t:«(._i"()f:1V1§?I"z3{V§s" --. Subbaialfz amd 0i:11i;=.1:*s5 'rep<>;"£z~.>.(i in " ~ pa1::agr21ph:-3 4, 8 and Z? whe3z'e_i_:1 it i1.€}i1je.=1.a':%;.,_v1.::3§ié2:*:. H b After hifélriilg the :1zfé%'13j.31<:§_2*1t.;:3V ,f§lC§.V'Ei1 1{T,€f{§ 01': bo't:h sides on this said ap ';:V>_1'i<:;§1'é.§.('_>':V'p1 Caufl:
dism1'Ss€d t'}:1<3 , _ tihzm, since:
{he c.21'Las3<:é (>j}E'«esE.:i;i_.<>i;%j;.. .f§)_1?' .f<;r p:;:.1~t.i'é:i0n is
23. re<::,trri;1M§; (}'If1é:;' "1i§:+t for 1:.h:% pi21i:r1t.ifi:S :13 €)bt:21i i'1 peffiT:§:;.si§>£1V--(>§'< (T_<)':¢_;.wa'9'£V:' below to wit'.I"1ciz'aw the ea1rii?<:r é;:,1it '£T}f<;1§V..21r1(i tic: sac/r:1~; pe'r':13iss:i<3r2 E10 fiie 21 fr€§$--E§M ..§,1:*1 :3 couid as \,V€H z1bar?.€i<>':"2. t}?.§i'i}f._§:':§.}i.{'4:?'Vs'i(}E.1E?:V":'531_§fi. x>uff:ici1 was; {E15351 Q': t.h<: C<>m'%;_ "'=é.;i"i.<2 L3i"i53f§é"i':€§'TL.i€)Z'1. ami {to %3:"i:'1E,% {E262 st;%c01':d ""s:;~2_::Vi'£:;;_iZ}:f 'V re:ii€:fI it is ajssz) {:§b$¢:23;'vs_-"~:<§ E:>§__: th :3: £';.:'i 2':? "{%3'<}t,z;%iv'v'Lfj_§*3 '§vh.:::ij,rz:I:'1:§1':2: $1.5: 3?" <i@f{%:'3<%21:'1€', in E',%1»:3 {).S.849€*3,/89 tgtéied (>11 23.08.1§}93 .;:f§;;<§,L§es_i':1.{t%%:a:E'::::r i':z.:sE"_>ar";c§ *a3.»"h{} is-3, iihfifi'. E-'="' {§€;?§€if'E."§€§2;?;i7;'{7i in i',Ei§§§--.4a;:%':":s€ :~:.s2.2iE. 2% par§.3; {ii} E:.'E_':¢:;*; 5:.-:a§::£ :=:ss:,.13Z_i'; mzssg an ' a?§'§%i%<_:%:.§§:?&> :"§i;§.:'&$£;%:'2'i:;5:'é.iw5 sf 'ij.E_'::: é;::=:si'22%it;: 27%" T§"Ei.?i£"ifi:§,«-*2'i§",%'E.IETi3*;;:3¥. g, _{:§::.i£i:3:»§ i:T;':1fe}£ §§ai:":'i:§ff is ¥:eii.h&:' earrying an bs3$£::€s$ is': India ;2_a:=i§'é*::g?-A&"i:§ affziae in Ezraiia; ané 33 gag}: he ambsniig {hat {E25 28 market, the gaefia ef the plaintiff szempany is Contrary 1:0 the plain}: a22e:*m€2'1iS and d02::u.meni$ filed along with '$16 piéini. 'iE'i*:@ phimiiff has stateci at paragraph 1% of the "
fimde mark/mama "D.&'Jf{DGFF" {signature regigtered in its favaugr in more than ti5<:'iaL=.;'1iir"ies Inciia. A ccapy cf the ii-at Qf wuntries 'TtjE1é"'iEf3:;~r:i€«.
g,{)&VEDQ};_~E:~ is regifitered <33: penkiiiag regisfi:ra.ti§f:;'A.hé€n fflefi as Dacument No.9. trade mark:
"DAVZDC'rFF" has beg'-ari §%§::;:gist:z;:re{j1 '-Cr«=3r.:_13T.§;91*:1»e;r13; No.19 with trade mark 9Vu§-;'=§6"'2%hiC}1 is vaiid far 3., peried of s€x:f§{éfi'VVy eé;i'$ they-gafter as per Dacument subsequent peried from @993 to 2{?€>{> V'é:ir:i,"3: 3/éihéliijfi".s€;'«éa%§:§I1L3;€,*d fmm 3£:2.05.2::;@e :9 reme§é§?§€'{§-----upia 30.35.26}? as per Decument E€§,E:%és. . "
18. ' ...?ir§}:°;R.iai;, .Eea:°1'1€& Camigai €03" defendanig viseuié. 3 '2:.pps;'r21_;:"s£'es««._ i:E§2j_:i:' pi.é§i:1i:ii':f is; 'amt: E'§2}.K7§'£'E§§ an ::n2a2':1 :'3§"§i<é::": RE i3T:{ii:g.:
':i;=igi'--.2:';%; .§;§,:<:E1 3i¢:= i*7§*:*é,::cfi in mmiiig E10 5: z;:£}:.':::E2.3siz>§g *a'hat: ii: is; met ;§:><'>$_'s;:£_'E;%E§é' £236" €i§'1f3 §§§2»§..§.:é_t',§ETf €'h.'::'§i' €72-'€:§2 if ii. E2213 §;'.i€} <}f§'é<:€: {sf E355 mézrz . _ ifs; f§_4:V'§<:i:?,;a:; §";.E}'iEE.-s? 2:2. :":'.;§;§:£i {:3 {£9 2% fitiié §'1::22" §':1_£la"§:':gfg3::z{3:':E. :'5§<':i:.§i>:':, Eizé 30 £1::»r<:e 2:1z1<:i VC§§§'i..1t:'; 1201: (31115; :a:'--3 an {$19 (121118 <3? pré:55e1§t.i1'1g Qf p1;1__i 1'1t. at B21:'1gz1.i_:m: an E 5.09.20} C} but é-i.I-SET) <31': t:.he c§--2j1:*i;<:{ "L:«A' pre3»:213i::51t:i»:>11 {sf §"}?"£2fE§}{EI'}'i', zippassai Q11 if}7'.Q}_.2{}E "
<:cmf:,e:m::i:>t'1 «sf Em;-mzeci céijzlzzstéi fer de1%::g'-1xii'é1:u:E'A at:t:c>:*11e:; had 1'10 a'ut4hc3ri*é.y $0 pré'3$e;::1'1i:
be &1C(3€p'{i€r€1 1201" f.I'1€;E frizading of t.r.i2$_ of pIz13;:m;iff fer' gzgrzmt of éT:%1} :p<§':1é1'1?y' .:':§.:3;j"é;1:}<:{.%§§'1é'.'" '" i-£t:=.};";€:<=:, <:0m:§1:si£:s12 0f the trial Ccmrt: C21E"1I10'E'. be S{.£'$t«€1ifl€ds m 2}. S11 :Er§;;!:":*:21§{,t§2.éf§':fi%%§:1"£,99*¢§ét;,:3id' c0:1'€:e:nt:i t;}:21§: {rial C:>1,m', ::%.:_":":7«Ti in :'%r;.m,i:'§g; Z ::<:§v:':<éA1.é.-:;:é{€:§Vz?z éiats }";.a.:sid 'é;hz;3¢ 1.: i'1{i€fI" Se{:t:§Qn 57§'};i.2}.?{"fis:%:fi E»iEé%:;}V¥ié"}4'§{:i:, E§9§ Eh:-3 .isss_;1,:€: s:}{_§:.:z*is3di€:E'.§Qz1 is $9 152:? s:;;%::-*:.:*:.:é:::fi;'::::;i" :~;,£'£{:'.é~"~ re{:{m:iimg; ('sf <3vE:ie;':ia:€: S§§'E£.'.€-3 §3§"§.E'i'12: Eiaaxisé 31 w02_'11ci {7c>2":.'é<:%n<i iihai. S3ec:{'.i<>:1 20 of Ciodia sf Civil §1'c;<:<:<:T1ur<:7 zmd. 8€a::t.i:::»r1 1:34 of '1':'2.1d<&: E'v'Za.1'Ie~:ss Acttz. I'€'f£'1't,ii1'{?é'~}g is be :°<::a::i 110:'m<>:'3i<31.::%;i§; .22md Sec:'<,i<::z1 134 cf T§"E;i.{.i€? M2'1ri«:_$ A<:*'i', '§.E~}'E)E1Z*._ 'is; in E-i.£§C§i[Li(T>E'1 £10 E5€<.:':;.i.<m 20 of Ccsaies cf Civéi Pr:=c><i?::"<ci':_._:;':"'<?':'-' < i_;:j:
-s5'upp::}1"1:: of this p:'<>'p«:>s;it.i<m he relies LIPOEE Jz41(i;g;;::.:=:if'x?:. :fi5§:I}Z'3<A:%i'f1__i"
E-Iigh C:;:su1'i. in Q2139 0f Intas Pha1;3;}:1a¢;Ae11f}£i4£3aI.{$.'"v'7:S{ Allergan Im::., reported in AIR 2003? DeiE1iV'Page'V:ii}8&, 22, Par <:<m't.ra I\/Zr,R21i, IE-3.&1£"£'§"t;'.'?§'} "{Z(}11}i'iE5$i31_fiiifv-2("1€§:'{EE"1€i€111'CS xmzlid vehe111e.:';t:§3; e:iei'e::'1ci VE,V'i'AZ:1{Vi Si'Li1{3E1'1i'{.E3 that piairlfaiff' has to sgiiisfy {2} 02%' S<3Cf;::i0n. 134 if Iffiiéi' is; moi: hzwirzg an officfi in 1;1§i;a afi:e:" §.n'.a1 wh«:%§E1e.:' Eriai {:{§'E.i}"§,: hé1$'i:;'C§f,§7jt§}f%i€f'i.3'LE{.i'i7i'E§('§i€}7i§{}I'i to $12}! £',§"1éT* E.:§'t»E.§.,E-,a Es"; :'e;:.1§:,:§)<3:*i <;»£' %1i§s.__ s%';E[_.E.'§~'}E"1"i:%'_\§l,§V9§',1.i'{.'_'fii'>E>' E=§.;<f: :'%::E§<;":s~s ;2;:»<m mas: jL:<§;,§:11.:;=:.1r1i". {sf EmZ:":s:?{%3§_€: S;::p:°<:?:.;m;: €'.L"::3:f;i:?"£ in ":'h<;% .n"z2:1§:.%;.é3:f {>5 M/safiheéha flange §§g=.VS?.fKu.§%i'ai11T1§i fépgrteé in 2036 AIR saw ?2.
W N& Q 32 FIN13INGS:~ 2.3. It is; :1«:3'é.:é(é&:t,§ fmm Thff c>z*<ia:%:" of trial. {f<:::,11fi-*::§.f.':21{[.1 V' (tame iii} 22 £'.{)E1€Zh,1$i{}I'1 iihzzt. uI":ci€r $411"):-:=;'<Eét:'i.i?'}1*i;. {2]"v€.:"§f€f{Vf'{"i.f:i1VE71 334 0f the: Act e:_;jLsest.i@11 of 't.e:*rii:c>:1'.i21}. j'L.aris§éi_i(€i:i<31': i.(§ i21"y"?1"1'€n':};}:i'i£ ' is ti) be (P321111. with. afiis,-I" dfiétiéililffd a11fi;:i'fi,:'. E1.;4:VL§é_: at:
:-'such 2;. {?()E1(E1i1Si{)I1 on the gj§};'c3f:.z:;_1"<.i iivégi: }'}c$§s§§;gf;I§§';/'<>r the ;3E21.:'u':1tif£" tic) say tflriat €fE"v'{3I1 WE1e:'§.$i.i:' '::'2":%() EI1{i:i.a. iii {#2111 be :'-gaid. it hang a. t:<):: fiE{b;*--,' E3a:'1g§e1ic»r'e for §E}fFiF1§;§€§11€fIT1'£, ;€%'::_'1pm:11<-3 Cmzrt: in }.V£/sf.Dn:)dh21 E§§<ms;<-§'c::i1§:3e r§i?r{é:".;"'<%£1--'t.:> .ga:,:g§ra E12155 hrriii as; {.iI'£fi63'Z "43. A <:21:is:€:A:>.f €:{:i;i<}§1" given {E8556 "bath u:'1de31° ma': _§._E%5?1.,éX{:E; ;é;&s.__VVé1Vis<; .L£I"1€3'§f3:E' iiize 1958 AC1 may be .fl:?2'v:é::}1.';:«§3;§;§L:1g;V"~f::<> s:>.>;i'.{-:m.. '£'E§1§% i;<z'rrié;.{>2"§a£ . £§¢;3;§1"§$:":'e{§ upim "%{..':1<:é {f<}ur'g in €;€r'r:"':&'s £3'?
i;Eé_5<:. "g3'r{w§§§E;_:ri}::§V {sf '€;§'1£:t {i<.}{ié3 0%" Civii Pmzta:ci':;m::
_ --V iixaiii§§;*;r:':;'§§fJE§? V aéaziii zaippijg $10 :2 5-51.5%? 0:' §}.I7{i}€f€?€{§1§f};§{ :3¥;1:::«:%:;f:r *;:§':<§ "E95? fixei, as 2:1i.s;{> Ejhezt E358 A<i:i:. S'L:'§::>~ « T: '::"\§2::?§_§<§;':. {:21} <3§°Sé::<::§.i<>n 52 <>f*{[%1<:-2 19:3? Aatii. ;:>3r<:3v§{%es,; far :1-:<.%{.ii%;'é{:>m3E §E>':::::_m.» ;'?3m::E": E§{i{.i§'€'.iéi)E':é'i}. §<:::f:f':,::f:"; wz;2.s-3 " §;s§'<:}*s;'§::§¢:%{:i: Silé 235; M <:::::2:':3§<% §h{é=. 2:2zz':'}':{'>:' iii} fiéaé 2: 31.2% 's 36 z;§.<'r€:i.<3:': 2-1I'i:%~3€. 3141?}-S€?(Tf.i(i}i'1 {2} ('}fS€(',i }'{}1"'E 6:}:
(if f:E1<'-3 N357 A.C:i1 pI"'(i3Vid€.'§%§ €01" an E:i(fi(ii'€'.§(i)I'§_a§ forum ...... V v
21., A£imii'i;s:飧1y, 1'10 swab ag¥(iii?.i{):'12:§ §<t):"1,.:1"1j E'*2--2i{i-- :W_ "
?3€:€t"1 Ctrtézaifiitl in i'€?I"I'£'}S <3? {hes }"}'£":'}\;"iS%':«'}:1{:;i"I'}.5'-3,_f§f. "
'L.hc=i 1958 Ac;',i.".
"Mg. E"<)r i:i":{:3 2-1:f0res-sagid c<7>r:<§_E_1VQf'1-:9-.Vi1{:»::.;_» t.hzi:.'--.wé? hé:1v<3 2'-1;'r§v€::i at af£.e:' sc1*:\:_tTi11i:ci.'_11gZ. ,f:{}':s:»_p:"{>2v§-ssic*;1":sa of S€('IiOE1 20 of £:h<3 Cc>d<::'~ of f'Civil_\.,._P1*é§x:%e{'1are zzmd S::'-:Ci'.1'cm 134 (}E'- fé.E3e £999 ami §321rt,ic::1_};a1ri3{_,.~ {i%1_<:=. 5 _j_1§}I'.E° :;:~§;_)'é;f,:..;';:.:T1--::"ef we {ierive SLipp{}I'1C f1'0Vm_ L,§.;:rz'c3111<:% C«:'>L11"a', in §3h€}C§IfI£: 1 N 7330} {$1.1pz*2:»:}' 'I'i1c%:'<=.i'<>f*:?:, v_;~*I:";5 under §€':(":{.iOE'i 134 of 'tE"};:;=z '§'§'ax«:.i€ " 21r:kiii.i0n::1} f{:sr1.:m 02-'er :?a:1<i,&'€§E3é)w3: ihe"'e;>.:j1Vé pr'«:.w_ic:ie€i ,t{.>:r £333? %,i':u:: p:'<:>'v§:~si<}r1$ of E2::{t§;'§'a:': I%,h€:*. {l§3',C. "E"_'E_'1.§$. is-3 ;::E.5s;<'; xlizezdézt iiiez'-u"
§§.:'§1:é_I'i' i%iEji'«::_ §::»:*7€j;s;is§§7§z;>':1s:s €:'I1é1{.'.iI€3d :..'1;'1.{Ez?r zaex-a:zE';»~:%§:::<%'E:§&:;>:%": {2} £'r§'Séé;:E*i.i<>z'2 '-£3-'§5'e:f:f"§':'21{i£: E1/§a:"'k$.A§';i: 2":m p:;::=§»;:2-:;cr{:§. ii:
-- 2;1.Es<} 3 $4': :'§'<§i',€;?{i §:§'1ai':. $3.5: p'1f{::wE5:»i(f::T'.3s5s =21? ;'f~§:;:§'t':'.i.<'>:"1 £32 0? C£f}§)f;;'§'Z:§€,;§'§"f;'t.. A<":f' an? 23E§*:20s:;£. pg.-zri mz;1i«:'3ri2: w§%h_ {he j "g3Ar':3%s?§,5§g.g;:>:':s :2? S<,*<?i:f§<.:s:": 2.34 <3? '_§'3°a1;_r:,is:?: E'£E221:"§~:$a gfazti. E§1..:§:":--
«%§;%j,%§i:,>;': {2} ca? $§?*€.E'i.i.<."3E'}; E35; <'%§§%;1:°iy' s--'»;%£42';;%:':,.2E2:'2.§..<.*:='=; :.TtT:;::'é' Eféé? ' %/"n,....,-
$4' ~.V:'1:3{.::':A_:.%§;;::;*:s "is; &%:~:'E'.:';'.:<'%i, r£=.§<;:s::s.':":i §}}'€,}V§S§{'}7:'3E€§ <:>:i' E.E'";_€: faati: *a:'§':§a?E': ' V' I < ....
44 ge;:'1eI*ai.e{i cm 1i'I"£€' €?Opi€i'.*S czsif '£i§"l_{".': pIa.i:'1i.if'i'.s; E:.:*21.<:i<3 m21fl«; '1't:gi:%§:'21t:i{3:'1 '«,-=i.»-ms ;3fzf<>cil11<:{a::1 z-11z:':21g.j';' 'é¢'ifl'.'i i'.}"2E;' plain': asi; U{){f13,1VE1"_l'€:3j1ii E\Ec}¢1.(§§ 1:3,, 1:2 a:":{:i 12A 'wE'1is:;:h ha:-1:; }i'1€)ii. 13%;": <:c.;>z'1_:§i?{é'€tz55g:.ai: ix; p1*<)per p€rsp<2c.t.i'w3 :'eéSL.aiti1';;g 3:1': em:):1e{:)%..'1s:s <);'<i€:"_--E:;(:ir:%§;.. p:s9.s$€:ci.__" HE'. ws:>1.:1d (:(:;r1i',<,-znci 't'.ha3.i' at. i:1ie*::'im s.f;'t',21gc3;:%:é1'ii'§f:%j21i:s:%::; s:::fficie;=,:'1%;*. <:%:1.<::1,1g;11 to slmw i'I'1a'i ;>1;¢1ir§:'i5:::i';'7f'» hagi its t..m.cie 'r11arE«; emd in $upp<;;:"i V i:f.V_i;1is.: R? :;.1p<3r;. Jtxdgnzeiii: of Gzzéru.-3 Spa :"~::%;:xc)r*:.€£2 in 2<3m{42} me 459 (§13e"}}3_i};
29. Pgér <€{§:':i':i.§;1: E\z".f3:'{f:§4~?k:;~:i'»£é2;1r:'1r:{§"{:0Lm$eE Ebr (ie§r:2:'1{i21:zt.ss w<:suEci co:1t:e3:1:i« Ehat: :"iri;€iii,i;§ {)'§._f£iE';L.;.a.;f Couri; at pamg.§;"21p11 8 of its <:>rd:&>::" 5: jay-:;i'; _;;%;:'M:§ §:i,e."€.;r '§::€-is? Iem%:'_:E. dEf3é§%s~; mfi {:2-23} far." i:i:§',<>1':ft:'§"<3n(:é;% and §}EE.1iE§§..i.?§§ 1*:;:::eé Ex:.:1i,>n~s;:ii'9£,é(i on a«:?:{'::_'2:,mE. <11?120;:--pr~:'>ciu<:£'§c>z;'3. 0%' {:>§i§,§i§1L-:1? r;_e;9't:§ ':2 .V "- _ _}~ FiNfiEE§§§;j§5_::.'«:"" X Bi}. <i:r<:i<ar is E?f>£é:'2..§".I."§.§§'1€E zzhisg ::<3§m:é:3E,i<'2:'1 E27: v.>'<m§<i §")€.'?
\ : :%§3xx.m< /1522 1.15159; an c::»pp<:zri1.::':ity to piE1{".':€ iihes? :'e;;§i$t1r21t:§<m {'<:*:'i.ifi<:at:.c {ffK»-'€E'1 ai i:he tim<-3 <.:fi:ri21i 'E11 ayrcler to p1'<}ve thaé': rcég.i$tr21ii{3':': E1213 b€&'.3'1 g§:'21r:i:v;%z:i in itis f21V{f}l.EI.' mad as -.'.':'§Li{]',h d:mbt': éL?I}T.€:i'§'.é:i.i}1€':(3; by 'éifae '{1."ia.1 Czmrt: all ilhfi' s£.a_;_;"e, of {T€}E'1Si{1€1.'i.I2§;{ an .:~1pp1ic:2:;t.i{_}:f:;"'£i§r--f 0f t;emp€>rz1ry ?.1'1jEL1Ii}£T'I'.i{)I1 is 110%. cmly pré-;tz112~:.t:_z.::;r:: . fi:.=.u1;';~..: 21.139 "
wi?;.1r1Qut 21:11; b:g1si:+s., At. this :'st:agc: ii: wmiigi 13:3 gi' ¥:se::*i<:£"i"£.- t.c3V:1g__)t:€:; 1';'l":£;é judgnmzzfi 0? Delhi High C{}1,EI"1i*iV.I"§~.i;h€ r:ir1;:1*£}:,eszf c>?£' C35:»f,~:>:i1_. e E;?.3paM Pvt. L-114:3", V3 Ozcjne Club I'f3}}()E'i'.€EC_i___TViI?i:_ P'f'C 469 (E3631?) at ;3aragr21p§*1 38 \'L'1'1i(V71*I-.¥;§i§&'i(3V1"i-'g "30, '?'};3e 0t:11<3'r' §s:§%M::.'{§:':':1ls;:-53101:'; i:}i§%"'-»%je.!E1{§fci:i;%1,.1T1i: is 1511121? '?t.h€:: ;3i.e1§.r2t'.§.i'f§' fiifhg"'4fi:éif{ifi<:e1£:&: far LESS in legal pms:%a::¢:1:g;{i:1_§g§s;:'1;>:;";(;i E;jé1:_a::11?c.:f§%VIy'V~%'ii<;:~:i iihfi <:<3pies of the r<3gi'$€.ra§_'_'f'}2é:: acir11issi::)r:.;'d<mia_1 ix":
'ithe pr::%:~;é':';i:" z::a1*i4£'§.>::* be £t2?m;'§<3<:i (am. ':33; €;E':<::=. par€.i€:§g._v 'E'1*:€=L'~pEa§.:1Viifi'Axtgéiifi"E213 am': £)§3§}{}i"{1.iI'}§fj,?° its file $1413: _"<C,f%?;1'§i£1{?§§j€S' 'bf ..§f£f§i§iSiif£iiZi{3§3 0:" ':10 $2;:.:.:m3.s:m. t:'E_';.:*: IT1f;'€'§£'E"»§r:§f:§:§:b'A§:;f§f§E{}%f'i:§'{}f§.?E€ 'E.":';1dé-3 E'v'E21z"§»: {}f§i{ff€ in s;3f§.'<§é::" 'E0 A§3fi{}'*g:'§: gr;-::'1i;:<;*d £3': §'a,v<)'u:* of {The pi2i.i;:;§:',i.§'£"§ V. .i{§.i§:1'é§EE>r@5 :?:§:3.§:: {3i:{§@<:i,i_{>:': 21:: 's.hi55 séagge .g§a:::": :'1<3%~. '¥j/v§<;::;_ (.'§V§;?{?§£§€3'{f§ in Ea:-7<§:,§r of £339 {,i<é§E3:'1<,%2m"€: as $133.9: "V.§;'%§§§}€(Z'T::ii;§.§§b ::?"§a£§$ fiiaési zhigt §3§1{}§,{){?€}§3§.{;%§}§ sf £'£?;_;*;§$z?;4§°:{i§1.i{i}i'E 49 C<::1"t.ifiC:21i'.<-BS in its; f21V<>z,11*. F1.:1"i;I'2é3z'._ iLi'1t?1'e no cie3"2ia.§ by '{.i"2ti': <:1s'3'f€1':<;i2mi, '{1:'1£-11. the p121i1'1iéf:"'n2«1:'; :'z<)iT {?;bi21it'18«::§ i'1"1e 1*t%gist:"21t'i::>I§. '1'}1:"sz'e3§3:i>':'c%; '£1116? {.}':3»_}e<?:'i .i<.>:'1 I1;-;'i..._ :1;uSI;a%1z21b1e".
33. I1";fa<:t: E.i'1er<3 is no cienizil by iljxg:i::%fs:>;'§%:ié1:"1"{§::1::€3'a1i'ihzg trad<3 mark reg3,'isi,=e1"e<i in Em»-':3'u.1* (Bf t,I1€%:"1i3i2$§_fétiff' '>.€):1*1_ iii"1.<§:
hzmd <ié:ft:'nd21r1i.:s th:"::nse1.v€:s '<f:c_)_':'::;~£i,<-3:'1c.i '~f'nai'_ i;:f21t§_<?3"'--..3.7q1é1E}::'?;= 2«1u'{,ho1"it:y has e1'r<me0usIy emd i1E:43VA;:1§.?§V'V:V:1A}/g;<. ggjr'sg ;'1i.<;%.{i" E"«i:*§:§AiiSff[.E'2l1.i('JE"1 9f the tracie mark in favczmr u2'0'L.zECi prime:
_f2::<:ie. eissgtabiigh €:i121"E; 4f,§r:§e>1f:é in fax-a:;1;r of ¥;.h<3 plaizitiff. Es.-Y<;~,i\ "--i_s§::f:z7V_ §§; c)§_1i.b§1:i.{}i'1 far zfiiingg 21 3223?. wit,he;).u"é,'*'p.z;§fi;:é{Ema (3%'E§:€€I'£.i§@i"ETé1~§;{% 1.: nder Sez;:ti:m 13'? :11?
'§'z'ac1e '§\z'£2u"k$§'--. fi11<:¥§:;,<..{ of £1216 Hist} C{}L§}""§, {>11 E;fE"1i£~3 }'.;'?.-§é§:';'§,t.'E'. {i;£}£?§§} &;<:r:.:i;§;'1y and SQUTEC £3 haeby ..... .. y 124 « stay 0? praceefiings £3-§t:A firs": <:<}z'1%:;::1::i§:r{7E by Sr:.KamaEa::E;:::.:'29a:":i §r'c:ar':1r3{§
4. .vs;f:::::§';=:$:;%i §:?ié;:1§:'§E:§§'§' ?;.E'":aéi as; ei."§'E.'f: a:§;a:é.€:*r 5}? :£"iE§:':;;§ séf 5:.e:;fi.:._ §3Eai:'2%1.if§' 51 SC("."£'.i{}§'"£ 124 of '£;§1<:~; "E'1*z;z::.i&% Maz'k:~; F':£.".'1', IEEEBQ is filciéci and pez:.e:1i1'1;; {:{3:1$%ci£:::'at:i»:m.
FINBING:~
38. ii: is; h<3:E«:i '$32' the 'arizai C::3ur'i' at §*);;11"2:§§:*2~11'>}f_:ff.'E _ :>rci:3r m1<ier che.11.Ee:1ge=: iihai; {i€f€}C'1d£1I"i't 1.2; en1:it'§€--:e.i}».-'§i.«i§~..s:§:€:k<--f0:_é
-stiay «:3? the ;_>r<><:e<;*:<,ii.1'1g_g;S wiwn 21 C11E:?f(;'.I}{?€fi 3;; r{§:¥§-1._g§ plea pE.'I'{i .f0r'i:h by the pIéu'.i'1i.3,i"i'._ iz'1v211.ici.if;,y sf r<3,gfiss*::"21_{i<}:1 0? deE'e§1§§;13i_fs Efzide' 2;a:1.rni.tt,<:d fact Ehat, piaimiff h21c£§.i'ii§'€g§ b€f()3"€ High Ccnxri of I3eih£...Ei;fc§: :ié§':§:1_d%a.f§i::: E;;éi<}::@?:§.'1§ereci 21p;3<éa;r21.:3c:E: and {fled iizeié &§?:'i'£1:;.¢::'z'-- Stiéfth pie-:2-1 'W218 }.":£§1i' pui: f{)1".,>§:a1'd. "}'.;EV'"§'éi'_V'v¥f1"i£fC§'%£A"$f.E4%€5Zfi€£Eii filed by i:.h:=é cie%£'»2é§.¢£i21£";t$ be:j.E}:3z*§j §}:3V_E:§f ifzifi, cii:5cE::>:=.-get €:i'12:-:.':. zmy s~;sm:t.h §3£r.-ia }1a1d'--';3€€:»:é " g32.,:"i';v.,§Ei:;"*§§.;*;15:i?::§4 Be tiazzi, it 1:32:35 215:; .:"ig,§f:'t:.Ey <}bs3€rvséd V' 593?. i:.:*.§:a,§W C:3:,1::*'s: "é;§';:%§i*&%':'1:i27a:::i.$s %12wing .21 :*i.gh't is {EEG "2=;%':*i%;§:e:'1 ..V§§?;;;:i':é::1_:a%::t. i:'1~.{E*:§% i:'1s:=;'€;az1€: {3':1S,e§ff are €,I"i'i'.iii{%{§ ta} :':%:.i:es<3: .s::;z,1;:fti: 2?: pies:
.i:%:s%§:".V x.a}':*~f.'z:"§;'aI-71'}. s:3;.e:-:i?ems1":?:: zmé is '£19 be €i.'.X£{:E"E1iE"it'if€§ .2.§s; $0 ';.%%*i'2-é5?i1'E':e:i% {.§e§'%::'T3<i2?a;:'3':. E12235 :"2::i:=:-:§r:§ 5:1,: ::fi.§": as Eikiéféh E2': 351%: if§'2.sst:2:a:'::. 53 55?. I21 €.'ii'€.i{§I.' tic; <3;><221mi11e :_%1§s C{i)I'}1ifi?i'1'§'i('§I.'§ ii; wci>1,:a§(i 23¢:
I'1€;'§{3€'S§E§£?t1':g,? :1) e><:t,rz"-mt: S£f{Tfi'i{}."1'I 1.24 (1) and :e;1.:}3--sa@z%I',i<>.1'1 {E3} 2§_I{>z1g wigs. -E5e:::i".i:>;": £30 {1} (er) zmd E~3€:<::t:i<>r1 31(2) {Jsf '§':*2:{%€: IQQQ szmd 331116. 22121:: <:=zX£',m.<:i'e€.1 §1€:%:1*<;?i;'1 ¥3r'31ow: V 124(1) "whe:'e. 171"; any suit; fer infri;':g§9.t11¢1':€';
I"i1E1I.'k.~ {2}} iihe {iefm'1<:i21z1t. p}f;"§::1{iE3 %':h:3,:' r:%g§f.§si.'r*21i;ic§;}.»--71gf" tE'"::'-53 p1air1E::if'f's~s tradi-3 rnar}«: €53» _ji:fn,fa.Ii'Ei;»' {)1f_' '~. {9} %:he defe':':d;;i.§1i: 21 iziéibzqéite i1ni'c3;:e:i* cizmse {:3} of .s~3ub~se<tt.i13:'.1 R2} €17? »$é%'{§j1.:i(3:'.1_.::3G', éérzzji ":.h<3: p127si:1§':if"f p1(;é21<:%s:é m 1L..§;":,.§;f:. _ E:'1 7-: i;«=:;1i1:ia:i,:;'1:3r 5)?""'régist:rai.ic;i3n of '£:h£;>. £§€':§'E3I"i:€i€i'I'EfSv §;:"::<ffi¢=:_ i*:1a%Es; ---- ' V ' '3' H<'r;l> <51 1 if H1 9 twsi 1'1 5233143" 1'¢-3-5}'-1 1"' 1*"?-'E {'§ in :3 <4 _.g ...... ; «., x.) H A '.4 V. A .., ' V. A ,_ 1 \,rl,,?_ .. K/ ,1 ,. V.' 1.. . , L/ M, 1, W." iam": ::s:;a;;:r'¥::ii s%.1a}E ~ """
Iii; --i§U2"s..'£j§3.:;'~ j{3«';:f<.':¥<::z¢:s::<i§_}:;_-__>;:s; fer :°r3:<:':.;ifi::":aiTi<>:'1 0%' 31hr;-2 :'<-3§;i:es%e:' 'aha: p§:;.:im.i§'£T% <22" :§e:§'e:%:T:<?£;m.'§"Ea; i::*z'1{ie;: "~ZE§E}..}§'I'k §}«:':'E'1d§§1§ Ei,:&§'<i>:"'€:-. ¥;§"1<'-> Reg§s--;;t:r:'::" {E}? é.é*:_<;% z'3x§}3;;_§{%E}21ir3 I-i§<:};7:.z*<:f, siiay 'aha ss:'e.,si'a' }_:>s3z1di:'1§,§ §"3".1€;'? i'é_;:"::--1§ V {:§.i$§3<>s5z2:."E iéf 5:§Li{';§E. §.}f(}€?€?€?{i§:E§_§&9Z 9 54 if :10 :~3L:<:_'r1 ;j;>:'<>c',@e,<:ii::'1g$ 21:1: p<':nc1ir1g £i1'}{.i the <':our'i'.. satis:-3£'ir::ci '£:.}"1at 'H16? p}.«:>.z;: 1"<:ég,z1r{ii':'zg meg? i'm.:*211i<:§i_fy sf i'§1<:% :'::g:issi.1'ati£;):'1 ofi.1?:e §.)§z:1i:':i.ii"£'s5 <.iefe%:1:12;1::"}.i's9. §_r21ci<: m.a1'k p:':;:1}a fa<*i<=. féiifsfi 211:": _1Zs§sa'L,1e 1_":;*:gz;z:*{i%:1'1gg 'i"}'1<% s:-:21m<:: arid zzfiiij 'V'. {E16-t Cm;-<3 1'}:}:" 21 _pe:r£c:a::i of 'i:'1'13"<::e »:jf1:Q1':t4E'1ss"§t'*¢:2fi";v ci2112.e3 of Ezhié. fizzlaliilg of the j.':;+'i'._»<T>":29§i<;§1°4'-E:<:a._L exlable to pzuiy {)(}I1Cr':?f1'"1(;?Ci 'i:r,> 1"a;);3Ey .'t,gj: 'vt:I'**;:'-.7' _Appe1_1at:e }30z1,z"d f<':rr '1*<3<tt:i.1"i(;%§:{;i<>:1 (if .:_;.'h'e.u;"<;%;gi駣%§§:"";' 'V E2445) "§:1m3, sEay_ (>f7 :51 Sgilit §'é:j.rr .{.i'1'é'_-in:f}"i.fézge1":1.e1'11:' sf 21.
trzzcie m211fi§._ _;s_-3-<?;:.£;t:i(;.11fsssfzali not ;:>re»:éh.1de '{'.h.f;'.' st:<3:,1:z*t. .i:7:f0§:>:1I}Vn12ii{.i:?1g"vVL.'a."s'§j,fV ir:*:,e1'Ic>c'L.§£;(;::"y {>1*der (i11€:'Eud,€r1g A;2>;:?1.7z7 *f,'i{'{.1's1'i1:':."~.' _grz11T:i.§:a;_;g an iz'1j:.m«:?.'{:i<::1, <ii:°::2c:ti:"iVg' 'c3%.CC€:V3Li.E']V('fxiffi}VECEQ VE§€i§i:{§9 z-1ppc3im".i£3.g 21 :"e=:<:eiv<=;ér £12" aat,i,a<:%1iii;;§ $11713! ;~3r<:ip_éri:j§.»ffg duri11§; 1;_h.e pezf:i_0{i 0%' {$19 s3;ia},{ .§§>f"Ei<;.<;> ss;ué§:".,, V L__'§3¥Q{f.'§ ::£:;;€t {)5 £1 §'«:%g§&;i.€:"€:(§ {.1"21{'I<% :11;-4i:"E§.§ bt%§:";g.3; €§i'Ei':'. 'i:}§ $12-E3655: f_ri}.:f"* mam '§'.i"Ei€i€', me-"ar§§;:s~s :'e?§,§ise;i:eér@£i z.mdé.=::* ':.E'1§&; y'-'§<f:%:. €§:*"E':i<:h 21:? §<§€:ié.E<i%;¢:E 3:" 1'1a*32;1r}}»' r€::S::',;*;'1E3ié;é . _.":;:aa{::§"; <.*;V'1:.}ée~:1f., in €iX€E°("f§8€;'E {Elf i':§':€ 1"§;§E§£: ':10 {E39 :,.zs~3é: 9:"
' .§;E:2;3._1 .--'E::'a{§e :'"m1rk; g;-.;»;iw;z~:'1 E3}: i'ii3§._-iii';-3§i.'i.'§;§€§{_}*I"E :.z'n<Ee:' fizisea 55 31{2)"I:'1 ed} itégfzzé ;31*<.)c:£:&*<:ii'1'1g§s ma: 21i'0r::ssaé(.i 2:
re_;_g;i.s;t.<;=:rcci i;r21<iae zzxzuéé; 5;haE1 not EI}{if ilesrici ta) me i.:'1vaii{§ an 'the: g3;m1,:I':c:'i £:}12:_t.. it 92.21153 :'1:_>t: 2": reg,:isI$.:"a'01e t41"a1£.§§=:"'--- m:aa"}<: ur:c.i<-3r .<3e:<:t:.i:)r'1 9 ééxctiégnit 1,3ip{_}Z{"I EEK.-'id.€I'}CT€3 (iiSiZiI'1(E{Zi'v-'€;%i'1€88 and th.:gaf[: Suzi}: e3vic}e*:I'1c€: wféizréa I'";'{3{:f. f 'V' :'~e;1,:a"r:rmi'é:'£:.::>,r:i. 1:19 £',i"_1_e>, E{egi_:»_=_;t'r21:' 'i3<3f<3;:e :*:;gi:s_i1'éi{:§cj':§{Eff it: pzfived t;ha.:[ thét E]E'21d€ Ilaark }é:1:':';.._Vt3e<:'.:'1fi-sac} regi5i:ere(i pr<}pria:%mr or his pré€1vs§tir::,<_ss;<>1' in j; i't:'i'{'2 215; "L0 h£1's;'€;'. b€¥CO}fI1€ ciisst:i1'1(:t',ivé5=,at t:_1r:..r;%' déiiacéé aff:i§t;gi:2st':':ii2f:;<3i":".
38. F'i"01'z'; 31 pc::r:1se11 £§f:_f;§'1«:>:_ 2x'f;s:>'§ze --"}~3».1f'()z§'. ;.i£:H1S, ii. u.-»*<}u1<.i Gfllfifgéf, t;h2:€: w%1€11? 21 .i§5: i'"i1@§€i :i';t':«::_ ini':*i-;fig€::'2s::':_1::. ztrf i",i'£ld€ mark and iE1j1_3.i'}()f.E.QT1i:_E33SE){3g}}ff*f(3Ef_. Si.EC1§§§ :-suit, (':2-ii} bi-3: stayeozi in i:§:;<-3 {;%v<;%ni,L:a.1ii£'.ie:% :-_é:i1}:':r_w:1*:z§:L>d<viii. _s:.1_E3§ses<:<:€',E<m (E) :32-znzciy when:
{as} {§€f€,i'1{i23..I1'E'."g}k§2%d5::¥'_ '€:§f,;:t:'«...§5égg,j§$%:,r;1'i::i.<:)n {pf g3Ea§11'2i:§fi"ss i;1:21s:ie :¥112:'E*i}:. E5f%.,.iE}VE§Eid,V '~. .....
{E5 "§=?'¥hf:*:'V<i€é'§h§§':~:?§';{g::%'i '--..zfa§::s€s:=; 5: {§€:§<:éE2<:€i 'L:§'2.d&?:' {T,i§E1Z§§?S€3 {{3} ::':«§" S§,i%}-- :1-seith.'-iT1é<3:"s. '{2}-'i.:'_:ef :%€;:r:::¥:j3?<:s:'": 39 azsii §'3§2.1im'.i§€ 2aE;~<;<> §'}EéE&:':{§;'E:§ i'.E'§E'f V._§§1%-"2E§§i<:§§viE;1:'»;' (35 {he :"Q§§is€Tr23E.§<,>:'3 €25 (ieEE%1'3::§a;:'1§.'.;<+; tm{;§€: :§':21s,:°Es:.. 56 {C} if there are any praceedmgs far rectifiagiion p€ndi1':g bafem the Registrar er' Appéziiate Baard 311:: :°€:Eai:3T_Q_n to p}a,:§1€,iff «:3? defendafifia tmdr.? nzaykz 9:"
{d} If €116 Court i3 Satisfiaé that plea rézgaifiirzg ' registraiion of the p1a,ir1tiff's or £,§%3'f€':1dar'§t'$ if?'gi<ieV";*:£ar1»§.,V u is prima f21<:ti€ Enable,' 39, when the afaresaid e1}e';;2:i:u-amIit'i€§s'--.afr{;aVéX:;'{§ifi€$ in the contexi: Gf present Cass,' t}d:§':"ai"'£he témfi of filing Qf abjections to temparary injunctian name1y§l,;'%x::'a.§ "Shad not iedged its 0bje::':ti@1'1$ €;::i¥' piaintiff before {E16 Regigtrarg {ff ' any appeai béfam EE1t{i'3€CtU£iE §:<0{per£y-- Said abj€(:t.:0:r:s hays 1366:}. fi;I;€d r%u:'2i'r":L§" by the <:Eef€17z&:~1;*1'£q 3.6., after £3-if.§'1<€i'§fV:L--§;:?a$"L§2'£;::a§€:éx§)§?"i3?1'é 1:13:31 Céurig, it s,>s,rm:E_d 3.§S§ émergés frafii ~..a E"f€;,Lé,~'a.di1'i§ $5 §é'fCf,;§0}."1 388.} {:33} and Seciiim
1.} £1f::a;%; i§2€:29;§é4j'.V'§':s3u§& be 33:: ésxésiing dispuii: betv;-Yea}: the " "%§;€§.1*i;i€:sA 2ieg;::3.T:°':;'§.,;":;'r2g "éhxs tradé m.ar§§; if}. q_":3.£*$i=.i{;}:: 33$ :2: {ha <=:ve'::'E %fiH,,.,..
22%?
is; :j%c:§.':'E.é>::'§1'£iaté{if' .g::»'i:2féim'.iff'ss 1§:ra{§:=% mz::?:*§<;f:':z»:;z:1<;% "i.}}AV§.E.){}FE?"*
4. .§'f%€;?<:{§4k;;}j:'1§A$é'3:;{_.i 2:34;" 21 §u><;m"f;.,«' E:*«1fa.:':::i b~:J §::'":5i§21z'1 :'<;%&§i<"ii:":;g; in m:e:j«:>r "V..i::::r;g3':3; E:;.g' *J§:*§:'m3 <3? i'E='::';%j3: E2€i:1g:§ 2.>:.v;1iEa§3§::? in ;-"HE E€::'i.{:éi.ng.§ s;%1<i:§};§§:f:.g_§ h'"w.__:";1;fis'E_Es§;""e::':<§ 2.»-*a:"§<.>z.:s=2 E"€3'Z"éE;§§ <:2:.:€'§s3:*-%;:s§. 3%": <,'={}:':€a:mE:;%d §;E':2.:£ 59 p1ai:'1t: ass I'}<')u::1zr"r"1:%m: Nam}. 'I.ez;m'1e{i. (T(_}LEI"3E5€¥1 fear p1z1i;1%:i'ff wrzmici also c?::>:1i:.<-ind fithgiii §::"i21§ Co1:1r:; has fa:-Lilfiii 112:» c:%<i>I1::9ic1<:z' the fad; caf "_pr§.<>:' 2.:1s3e.'1*' 0f $16: tm.,<i<=;% inzxrk 3.1': q'::s::sst:iz>:'1 by V' 1;.m(ie3 mark "{)A\fI§[}C)F'f?" in Indian {T€)ETf€.i:?:§5iii"}¥;3;S1;"§1€Z;3.' fie w(Jui<:1 2115-so c<31:":t,<;%z'1{i that: :10 re;1Vs_(>3:1 by <:ief<3:1":c1211":.*t. for u.g;i:1g {his trade 2E.'I:1Cii" is &1<k>pt:iz1gg this pa.rt.i:;:L.iIa1:° ::'1'::_1":9'}§%_ }.";'s;;siv§x 1Ag§"{4.zss<2£i by p1aim:iff211'1d (E()I1E°,€:'BdSVH011~C§I?S'iA§1i%3Li;§;%iI.'§b§)1T1*.":§é#f"A 3%%1iV5'1iiiffS plea by the triad Court E:h21i';_"'p?£ £§ xx%:fi}:1:fi%E:ix>"i€§¢::V.ff§é(:{}g:1iti<)11 £>£_' its '£.m{i<':*. mzirk arm} I"€ip1.EfE1E'.i{}I1 has reés::§t:eCE{Vv"i:f% it 155 :;spe<:i.f1=::a11y <::<mi:c3nded i:3'.?1'3.j_t:" mark "D;~\\/'E[}{)FF" is ..-F i-.~.'.'~.; "";' ;' './''' '"' " 4 3'" "._ :'":*;r»1s;g,€%:{3:3 .g.z: _ EEK'! §'a*<;~. :5/R<f?5 :23: CE:-'i§§S 2:; v:=:.:s3: r»::g::s1.r2:£.:=:}z2 :,, «::%:':ifi;§§E€;:a2§cL"pr{§:§:,2T{§<::ii :5-3E<mg,§ <2a;i'{'.h iihéz piziiizii 21$ E.)<3<:z.1m::=::':i; Péeza. 19, it is £5353%?"1§}.€}i'1V?Z.vi:'£.?i'.i.§;§€;"f€{ iiiiéli. ii W-*2?:S :'<%r*;m>J€:<i §';'<}m '£'é.n:.::% Eli} Eimes. E: %r ,,,,,, i 75 '34.' . -.
60 ;:>I_21i:1'£:ii'f"ss 1):';-n1d£::<::1 ;:21"<:}<;i1.1<riT:~3 zmi. 2'1';-*21i.I211E;3Ic** an i'1'1e £002.-:.I ma:'kei'.:i-2;. c:i£ep2:rt4:1:em:'.a1}_ $t.c3;*es, <h1'{}; f':r_*r;=,*r;r sslmps 21:; I:'"1r:,1§.21:1( Air";}<>1"1:e§'2,:_1':d 3 :31: 23<é{t::mm'. af Ii':3e2'2%&isaz1i'i<3:L ifi :::c':c>:'1<'>mi<': fbzmit, ..~«~;;>~.1.:;;it§t"i£7i',é;' pmduc7ti.s re3_di1§; 21*.-*2.1i12.1E.:>i<:2 :1(:I"c>s;s:=:;t:'"if1r1i_';:%-« .<:0.1.m_Ii:.%f'jg}';'v Vii? <:.*<T}:':1i.e:'1de:-,?:<1 that {}K7{i?I" 'itirle years}; s2:e.E<:?:%; i:'__1 IIj1<:i_ia '<.;_»§" 'p.1zs.i1i{;ii'f7.s§' pr0d:.1c1::s has i1'1€.Ti{'EE€.tS€;'.C§ year' ii} is iihat: p1air3.t:ifi's p:°<)(i1T:<:*.f:. V *"1..:.;{_1"<'1c'::'t="""t;E.;:Lé:j'. f1r;;_(1r;=: :V1'i.23'3f i<e; /' E3.€Zt.1T§fE "DAVIE)OFP'" ar<;é " in s;ev<3:'::1E im:e,rz1ati0:1aI 1LTIT1E'L§;&3.f'~Zi'I'Té:€V':;E5 T'\'\7'i'}:iji?i'ig>{%'§i§}3?{',11E'1i'i()I'I in India.
21:15} an E?i{?(3{)1.iE'.E.€';_', E3»? i:'1f«::>:'ma1:i€):1_ via Inmzrnet '{;I*"1'€:'..";v5Vi_v*'«:'V>§vr:inot:5 (}fé".?1€*. ;.3Iz1.in'{.iff is actceesssibie: to i:'1'1:§t §1'1C1f_a,. It is 21-11% <:%cm."i':e1'1ciec§ "{ha1':, in vi§?:*.x.: 'A85 §"i%7: <V:a3:*22}; ' :*2x§%h:=:r:gg;a ::{:;m::;~{_;:§_ ihtj <i'<3V%'v§.§éi:rz1§:i;:';:; z1E;.E§ 'i'»;>H 'z:§'1e~s's:.':: §;§<)0d;<:e via: E:1'£.<-:?::"m:{ .221;-5 my-aii £*r<3:1f§. E-21;'; V j 41. .'-.?€%:{ {%é>:'::.'£'.3"2:. M:".Ra.L §€::r.m~?d {':<;;e;::':s;.c:E app::?ari:1g flag"
$ c ;:=§_~:*§};%:i::::%zm;1?55..Aw<;2:,1%d <?<'>:'T:f;.e:%':'2€:§ E;%1a§' "§i).5X's;'7E3T}§£}§?'E'="' 2.: ::1{}m'1m<rs1:
:_:fn:3:";':'s;_:s 0? {f:§'"s_':".§s'~r;i:§2:m <%{::":2m:,.::':§é'y a:"':{_£ "§}_z%'%»'ET§,}{j}§?E* 35-: .'w '~ $9..-
§'§{>«>>"§.
69 £1i:%;<%a.1s~s:'~:.eci 53:1" e:1'1211:¢&ieé:£§ by 't1hé.:-.*. {$1.211 C<}11rf.. II'Ef£'i('.§5' pmvi$i{3:'1_€~; of 'E"r21e:i»:é §\!Ia1:"1<:s Act; 1§3E3'Q c:1<.>€::ss 1:101, 'r1a:v€:; ;411?::; st--§f§::'1g"é3.:i":;.%A4 §::1*:;>hébii:.i{>r: as w2:1s:~; £?.:}:.1:'z:.i in $8/(,",.'i§{}I"§ 9 {"}f "i:."i':m:=. aid E}i<3f"£:-§1'2;%"""T V' it fiiéiya fact" r€rnz1i:1s; $111221: 1'.ti2~1d€ V1¥z":":21z'§';¢ "I'}A'_J.IE){'}FF'3»'._fig'~., ':'e:g;isi.c:"cé(i in India by iihe _p123.im':iff', _ _ % . __ V 483 Sect_ic:=:"; 31 as i1:>um.i :1': "E2136 .l.9'§9, A<j:7§ Ai§~.: i.tf;W §:s'e1.:'i :'}.121E;e3zria with S<:(:"t:.i01'1 31 0? $116 '1"'r:1_(i{§:'»v;3,:gV£iu 1\IIc;%t'€?«}1;121civV§§s3£: Asst IQSS. Thu$,, 21 g3re.s:1:1:1p'{.i0fi wili'-L_1/1éf1i%:e:r _d:*em-*1}; abam", §}E'ii"1'L":'i facée: €\:'i€§€F§C§;§_ 5€)f:j v21:EiVd'i't.§~* ::"¢g;§:=<e;h1':g«,f::P'::>: i'.:'21c§é: mark.
vchich is ah':3:a;c.1y i':':_.:;?ajI'§ --23;::i:.i+:3:é fin'. in1'f.iz'1§;en1e;.v£;:. 'f'h<3 1'egis'¥::ere:=:i _£:<:s*:£' h;::V;1'¢A&»-*&=,'t.--z>..;2.;ic>d'L5<:€ cvi<§e;1<::€,- (£1159 or z*e;3a.1§422€.§{;;§.., <>E' .__3§"¥1 iéz'€:E}»* reg; am théi: .f';3;<:'§; sf 2%:-:g§i$':::*a?_i=:}';': 'Gf :*;VéV'2i':--:ifé: in e:%K:§<i€::";::<;% Sf ;):'{.>pr§:1-?:i<§:":+;§'1é;3$ £35-:5 fix; E}Vfi§:¥E,§{j€:?{i.V .... .s9;a.:b#Ss:<?:i.i:>;T: {2} €§E§(?§;:"iE'€i.'3 "i:h::i '$16: 1
3"é3g§§$'i{':I°»i;?{§ "iV.:f2§..:.§5é" :"::~.i§':*'§: :s;.'h:-iii 2':o"i' be 22.9%. Es} 'iiréf Em-'2*:hi{§ an £Ei*z.<-3:
'-§;.r:;}u;:'1c*§ figzié: it 2350:: 2:1 :*<:>g;i$%,1"ei'E3Et% iragie mark :,s:m'.£e§; Se<:%,§0':1 » E_f%~,...és::«;;:;:<:?'pé;' %;.2'§}<:é:'::: {?'%f§€'§§:§'§{2€3 9%' {§.iS'§i'§.E.'.1{..'§f.§*~Z€i'E"§€3f*5Si3: 2-2':'1{§ ééizii'. se;:.:<::.'n Vs-1:9é:%<=:§§5:'2-'£_::="%_2%*;:s§ :'::::>%;' §:=;«::.E}mi"é',E'_a'=:{:§ _§}i."i€'}'§' ':1: 2'<2;;;:s;i.:*e.:.E:i<:»:'2_' 21:?' it .§=.":é *:;.:T> Ex? M"...
E';
Z& % % '?2 ssa;.1I3I1f1i*{:t:.eci by dé::fe:'2{1e1'm: sand Ef~3L,i€I§1"1 it: xx.-'<,::u1d :'::::~t': Ems? fe 22:3 m'1"ter the sgzziii ci0r11aiz1..
51. $"E:1c:e thza d£c?f€r1'1ci2mt. has; :ra.is:~3r;éci a plcsa H1211' §;>_'§"a:;.é_9,;'1~i;.i'f§_
21.ffi{;"I" 11.2wi:1g,§ <3b"i:21iz1€=d tiara reg_};E5st.'x*21€.i<>1'1 of 'i:h<e:=. "t:t*aCi;;§"--n1a1fK 'C>ri"': ' 30.05.1986 Whi{.',h was; valid 1,E§3§{) 19€'a:'3';~--31.i; dici V:'1}i;ri: c3bf:.9;3f.1's'V r:3:'1ew21E éiikmreof E:11".1€1 as e=_;'L;:::h it c:<):'1_i:%:::1é£-.351' ihé1i__{i'€i'e.;'1{i.§fiz3.fv took Siéipfi to iibtain 21 S<321;a:"c:1": §e:;1ft i'f<;=:3.::' --'".IA"':'*:§d'é: "VRii'2:fks Regiswy as per the CI{)<:'Lim<::?1€'._ pra3§1':Ii<,:':%:i' eilzimg w'i*:'I§r:y t=}';;':ie reply si:aten1ez1§. (.'fi.£<~3.d in {he prr;2s3e_n.?:.' a.pp5€:é}:1s;.}., tjX.:p€'(?ii€(i <3? 21 prud£:*.x1%:. b1;ssi1:m%ss:11§-311."arid f{§1£I1§{§. fE12i«§..f}5i€iEf€3 @5215 :10 prior user aiaé .223 Such ciie£E%:1g":_2i':1."E VC:'1'ai:fi':¥3fjfgé' pI:"<>+:?<3.e<:3;e-"r::'}; {:0 12% the fI1".':1eT§,é:* Iifiaflé '\:fi{€.'::2V§'.::,z't. £}}' 'n.§§1<i:"aI1<:e. In araier :0 <%§»:2;n<1V§::"z--r;>MV :1£%;~;2:T1 raisaed fay the §ez1:':1§:*d {jmmswfi fizzy <§§E':::L§Ei:%1_:iV'2:§'.' :>§%§1.zi€§ 21§:s<§ 'ix: 2'1es:tE%s§s:21::';-' 1:20 «:%x2.4;mi:'2e;% §§.21'*f£><iV%;.;.;fi§;%{§ :i€sf&21%1{§231:1€, ai<}1':;;§ WEEE1 ::§'1€ :'€2g}i};
% &§§;e:i4<3§?:€:1_f: :':2:z.;:i'£';~:éjE'§,s/ §'.§:3§%~~ Ci{}§'E1i'E1i,1.Y1i.{if£i"E13:31': €L§E%f.{E{§ 22. E {}.20{}1. ssziizi 'ii?' E"szw<:i §i;s::1::':_ <'>i:2::é'n"1.:.2_:r1.i.c:a§,s:::7£ €10 igizs {E€r:§E;%n<:i;2:§'}{ '::3jg 'ma-'-2 'E':"2';s.<E<:% 2isE'.:>:{z'3«;§?; .A §32.::"5:::u.:?::T:§.. Ea; E"§f:t? 2:§_};3§§{:232€.§<:»:3 :"2a;.>,é:%i .i.§2i221iE li;}jz:=*ss;i:.i::>:':"2m<§.V,-'<31:giiiaéxzz iis §"}E"§{}§"' E.iE:';£E, aw -------- J ' 73 S'1.:'i3n1i1:.t:ec£ by ijhe c§efe;::1{i21t1t ezm. 2é"%.{}'?.I.E388 :'esCe:":1s:i.1':g fzfsr' r&?ggis;tT.:'z1t.it'>t1 0f thy: '£'3"2Mi€: n2211"'2~: "i}A'u*"IE)(}F'F thés: "'I"re3:cic;": M;11'k Rs:*.g;;.is:~;§:ry 11 ans 5;}3e<t§fi£:2i1}y i:'1.f<i;;"'r1"1.e.{i "éihe: s';€.{t<>I'1t:E (16f%:%:":d;;£_:';i:~.. 'L,EE'§€§{?I":
"5. The znark Si,1bI11ii"{{;':{.'1 fer '1"t%g,i$%;:.'22:t.»:ian .i_*Cv14{;ff'§;;f$'.1':'"f.':'V,iV1_! '. xviE.h or ciezteptiveiy Sifililéii' tit} thé: ré:;.gg;i&;t;er£%<i ' iI.Iffc'1i:i:§_;» ma1fk{ss) 21:.1c};'c)'r ma1fk[s) fi$Vri~r;>:."' ap;}1.i<:a¥:::i{;a:'":., Smith r<:;)Vr:':ft.' "§"1§':1°exx.-;iii.i:--'5_
52. 'I'h<3 s€:21z*c:f::' ':€fi1§~:>'r1fJ e:tm:?§<>$ec1 E10 this :3:1cie:);'s3(::11e:m: £iiss<:§<}se that:
applittaiizbrl dz§"t"é€iV'V:3O.05x'§986 has beer:
:'é3gi:5%;e:=:"€:d :::'§V%:2« aim 2-2;és:s{> r::f£::s<*:'t,ec£ in rm: "§1iSi:{}.i'§' ..2i*xr':i§'E21:§£;3; in %':}_1{;% 1x?€b$§1:<3 af fiche '?:'21{i€: é_§£if:§}f§ the {£€:i7é::':da:1':i: <:::2m.::2.<::t; ffiinfi: iii-i~ §g;m}i*:,a;f:_<:_<:? 0:':.:'£f§f7逧£'€"f'§f}§3§'I1§§ §'."I.€.§ ;;::;°%<>z' 2.25%' <3? 'a.E1q §j:,:"a<;:Ee:: mafi. in E ».> uks 74
53. The £§efe:1dar:t$ having Set up a plea af the ward "DAX?IDOFF"' Canxmfz be registered under the Trade Efiéiariia get;
1958 as it is; a gurname relaiingf ta a Chrisgzfiazz C03'Z?:'i":J.;?£E'3§;'{.:;V cannat at th€ same breath daim _iI?:$ prier use aiiié * ciaim that staid gurnanae is beigrag used byit. 4.$2:c_1usV§%fa::1y in, V' Indian Market, 03:; the ssirerzgth A 3;pTf:§E_i§: 72;.f'.:iG:§ registratiam pending as an 'Act coming inta force} and this: .j.§z011'1.§i"'¢;1L'%§3¢*3.i4'i§,t g0' "t<3Vv--.§£<;v:';s£z that daferzdarits am attempting it Wauid aiso be sf reiavanae that the Search §"€pG1"'{ $aE'd the deféndani: and prafiucad wojuid clfiariy go :9 S%10W 1 ' ' V 'V "V ' 1313?.
33 per gig *:f.i'{:1§€ mark N0'45z1+8?5V $53.3 Lé}?§ady'V-.reAgiSt~é %€§ and mug dafenflantg were 'aw '-%hi$A.tra:;iéé:':;1'a;r':§ was ugeci earlier by ihfi plaintiff amsgi *e:.§;'>§§}};3:.<fé3;'{i_§::.;if:::V:*A.:fé;i2€wa§ was ands? active {iGE'3.S§Ci€"}I"8f€Zi.{}3'£ 'Q32' R€:g}is_{:r}r., caniezsriiarz of theggizagfrrzed caungeé '*§35,;§;3;é2:r:n,;§ §5§j__%€sp@::§e':'fi;s that ma ::3.c<::€3u.§}'£ Qf 'f,h£:§.'=::E being a W4_'"%§3;'jé;s:':::;ia§%2{'.--'S€{t€;§<::: 9 zmriaaz' ihe: '£';*a{i€: i%€a:*T;s§§ ,?a<:i., E§58 ané >-?%f2:;%z::<%~ 75 '::rei':xs.?e<;%'1'1 19333 $10 I'E}'E}8 pLi2e1im:.if'i°':«is I::'2.1<k=* :."1"1..2-ms: 'M133 ;'1C;{': 3:: v::g'L.2e zmd it was c.1e<:%r:'1£:%<i €10 112m: 13€3€,'..1'} :'€¢t":1.<3"w%ci fI."{i}'I1"i 'i'r21<,'i<:tfEV{;%;':fk&; R€i?giSi'.%E'.'§' «:'re:1§'1:'1(>t: 31:26: z1.(:Ct'3pi:ec§.
54-. 'I'h€;: zwxt: r;:0m11a:*y q1,1€$t.ic3'1': i:_1"1é:J(; 'x:-v<;u.i'i;i 21.1,-i.«::~[;:5:--;_"f'{>:f ' ::<>1'1s;ie;1€;:ra{i:>r1 by this C<m:°"£. w::»1.13.'c--3u '"'E:*>i.-'t ass '---:<§'w.1:'€"'31€:Vi:?"s.é%:;' f:.1'1t:~:
defkzzldzim: C.f£iI1 be <t<3I1;<si.r:..'1€:i 21s:;V_V---z--:. pri§3sj L:s;ci%'r"~.;1z1_{;'% if 59%;} pIa1intiffs (:2-u1.not. be held {,0 '£3+:%. 'p3fEL--3I;* ;1::'5,:n éfz ._1'ess'L.:i%E;: 01' which the {:rr:t'l€:1' refzlssizxg ggmxxi. c::ii-V %;s:%t1;:;3{3--:f;?c..;f5,;" 'i:1ja£':;7t<it:i<):1 by 'i:riai C0uir'f{. is {.6 E323? _ _.,:a§i?E'.ir;:';i'€:;2._gj . 0.? ~:jex;*<~§:_"::§€{i Trsétpzéregi {Q be <;::}'nsidc31"€::s:¥. in <>'yd€%:f '$.59: c:':';'r:«.2;3:'T'i::§' :,.:p:>'n E§§E,1(Th €X'€fI"(7}'i;E'§E3.; it Wouid be §3e{ies§:§21.1'§VV €153" €éx"?.,ifg1c:'£,'v1:f?;V}';::%:";;}.§iCig111_<§f£'i$ (}f the E*i0:":°bE<: Apex c;1%":»1s*:.e*¢;':z%, <1?' :z*<::§,{_i_s3't::i;"r:"s<.§ i;ra£i£: mzzxk ifiamrt Wh aim 251<:%:i.:'3z1 €t>;f i:§_:j.E'.:fi_':":§ {tame E10 ix: (:a:3n:3i{i-rgredVand'2mssv§r:=:1"<=:{i:
ii} figszgfé '-":I.9€$;§5 93% »» Kama; Fandit Eurga mg:
$hé:ma"V$v»-Nafiératna Pharmaceuiicai Labsratcries "2§§. "*-- W-E"z€i§*;""'z>:"::;t:«:'?: ftizé.-,1. a.z:«:»;s-:% %:3§..-=' '€E'i.{':'f {:36§.3e:':{ia.:.':i, <31? E12': 9 K V::3§;::s*°§_«z:; %,a:E_:§<'%E'1. 21% e:.:3g:.%.z:'::-:%<:§ ii} i.3':E":"'i§"2_g::% :'§:":<: ;::§;:'§r:i'.i§'f'§-a E?» ?
'v.,{E§s:"cég2:;"{ii':. E1316: pEi£"'§)§?:i '~2s:E3£<::}": E-iE"€:'.'. {:<:>rm*;:a<:::':". 78 Was; 21 {".()§{}L.11'£:iI{? i.m.ii,21_i:i<_m of ihzat. 1:112-1.1r1«: 'N:1va.1*2ii.;'1a..___ Pilzzxtazuigg'. E\rEr.Ag§21..z*w21§21 has 22:gzai.z'1 :st.1'@sss5st':c:,i {The E.§'i£-ETI the "N'21v21:*at.1z21' v..-?hic:i1 £f€}E'1.f€.~'7{'IiTfi.t1§€'7(§ an {'3SS}-ffi?§'.i'§}'§.A§;§3...',A. §:z2:£.1't {sf i'e21141.:;"re of 'Chi? R{?§_§'i$i€?1'E?d "i're1<ie M21:".1.<: '2;1VVL' {i€:scr'ipiTivw:'a w:3:'c1 in mmm{>'1'1 2139 g;-V1"1'(71'-1;:.?Tza'£;'_:i:£:' of §.i1i:e; wuni in ':.he;: 2;;;:;;3<::1':2?£':.ji'.'s:§ T ~'x"ii12:'3i»'}«;: cii$;1*ege1:'ci:=2<.i; ihfiffi w<:~uh:i I'}.«Z3I".. E36 e:*%'::g_«;>'i.Lg.__:1"; T:m;::}::2$:fViz1.i .131": for '£1<>1c1ing§ tha":. the 21pp:§}E'::.IjTi1.» had Vi;,~5;_éi:iT ifijtcicé II1.':11'k which was cie€:¢>p¥'.§V<%iyVAV'$s'i:":i.i'§;1£"" 11;'; t,i12i7t:"Ui"'Vi,h<3 :'e:.s;p(3n_de1'1£i. But this; ";43";'%<':.T«:i:¢:ic%=.r;_*1v,<,%§§ ix222:§i;1.::j:Ac;:§;ini0:':. or: ig1'1(}£'iI1§_;§ {hat t:}.3:ev 21.;>})2::}1e1:fd; 'Ex'? Ilzwté e::>~:p}ai};1e3ci e.211"'§_§é:§9;;{:::t4§if§QCE:16; «ziissirfiaimer in regarzzi {:63 .i}1e::'§.;ct§§'§)L3;'ide1'3E.' In 't:h<3:<ae3 <":ir<::u::1 s.-:te>;--:r*: . ':1 2«i'r'k.~-v 14:2» {éoxlapzmzéi with i_E1_e1i'. u§3:§«:Z ;bj»," i".E":e:'. @r:t.ir@ 1*:=%g,}§i.s2f;e.;*e£i Ezlarli §::93;c;:§z.'1%::?:i1":;_'§V._ 1:'i;.iA'e "Navz-1r2:1i;r1a'( E~<,,;e:£'1 ej}§IhE1'°§R7§§§€?§ ii. T:';i§'§_§;§ETiE'3}f fiéifié 'Em. <?m'":':'<-%><t': % »"\}'\s'1'2_;<-:%:'é?:V €?:€}i:.?f§ f§1{}'E'E nzzifks are i"m::Ez.zz;%:3<i in é;"h§r i:}:'2;1{iE<:% L:j'::_2:r;:;-*"_1':s:5; '£',&:}:"'E:3:€_% <:€}'::":';§a;'e><i SE' in {me 05 *g,i':_e_:'::5 ?:§';é: §32.'{:§:»€~,:° <'::>z.:';i¢:§,€: £52.; '?',{'!} f.§{§{i}§{ 2:: 32:: ;:1a1"k:+; wh{>§s;: 21:':a{:i 2'14}: £10 2 %~ ' V fE"§fms;§ ":f§e:§f@1';{i2:::"f' =5 82 helti 'tha.'{: this p121ix1't:.ifi'"}1as§ ¢:.*:"~'si:a1:>§i_::'-;11:;.=ci1 21 prima facie Ca"-1:--fsc> z'u1£i irr«:3p2'-1:"e::}31€r pr€r_§1.2:ii£.:@ in §i;:s«3 i21\T-'<;n.:r w}j1i<~.§f1 {EEEHS Ectar _p215e3ssi:'1g" 21:1": ~a'1*de:* of in'i,{%:*im E'.I.'"£m}§E,11'1{ff'C';{32'1:.'"- re:3;t.rai:'1i1'1g the d:%f"e:'1<iz1r1i'.--<:<:e111pa.1'1y \>sshi.c'r§'1 -5 e::0:":2me:";<:e iis bz,1si:T1es::s §re::»m :.1.*£:i].is5i:1g i,i1<::..:'1gi'1*:s1{% _ '£2116-:'1{irei' or 'Me?a.hc:'1.d2*21 zimii §?§2i}'i€ff1'}r§1"§1E .f-.':' ":'_%::*.-- §):,1r;:>c:}5e sf its; tr°21de and bL;:;i.:i-mtsss-3,"A.fI'E'::fl:':"<;駣::*€V§~ .%i.».§'Ee3 Divisian BQHCF1 of the High C{5i;;:..1ji'§~si?21.1'1nt3*:;big: --§'z111}§§%{£ Far {:<>:1i"i:*n1i1_1g the 03'<ie1'~.;>'i" injti'i1'<:1§1'<>:'i"--;:}a1ss$ed"E:>y"the E€a1*:1r:<i Sizlggie Judge".
55. in has <}bi:3.i;<1eci r<3gisi3n21.t,i<)1'1 sf §.)ef€,'1'1<i2111%;4 cxiziirrass that -E§{?C3{}":"id é,§i§f§¥.'i§{%<7£¥'§.f,.._E'§€ffi' 't3usein£;>,s::'; in %:<:*:§<;t.iEa%s5 with the tradé:*mark« 1998 E31': 2004 21..s:1:i first.
Q'?S'?E£'{i'¥}i'ié';3IF§_fif§.§%§'1'{, {sf E;s':.;s?-§:11r:.<:=:s§:s; in 2904 is z,:si::§§ £;i1Eé:'._:;:"22.,€§€._n:.2;r%T'rgfiegaiy 2-md w§'::h<m€. a.r'2y E6? or E'2ifn{§..:"a:1€:e. <:_izz._im Eli} "E1221? s:~sa§.aE)2:§s'E'1E:{;i ii:-5; e:3w:'1 "::'e;:1:'::.Va'€,im"; ggxrégi §gi<}<::<iwi1E in "aim? fisid <13?' zt<:22::.'";':.:f"a.<ti.m°i:'2g;: <3? f;;'_g"a>__':f2":":a:€i%':";,;:s.5é «--:,m{§<;*::" §r.:»i::i<3 ::1.:a:'r}; "E'};"-x'.fE'ET){}E<'F", ii. 2%,--*e::n..:i{§ 'ix:
-:._;«';;<:::T:.::,!g "Elf? :'1<3~€.e:% 212%, i.E':%s5 '§i£§'"3{3'€?.i§§T€;?. i:%":ay£:: ::'k>.f'§%:2:'§:3m gmé: 84
mark, Tbs iratia mazk "DA"'~EIDQFF" useé by théé daffindant when can1pa.red with the regigterézd tradé mark if the plsfizjtiff arzé Ezeid side by side and 2:gh€11 tbs: <}x:era;i_1 :s3im£§3_.:'.i.*§y".j'i,$" compamd having regard :0 the iZ'f{}1}1pOSif€ u?0rd$.V;,:§§'&..d '?é%%C:*?i1i1 13:?" the piaintifi" and defendant to HR? gocfig garments and a criticai €:0m'pa1fis.Q n. o4f'*-fife txvQ.'v--'V~r1%1if;}?es'i'39;f%; made, it vmuid gmergfi that an pur<5E*;.;§sT<:;": 0f :gv;:rage irzieiligence and imperfscf 'be VfiAéc§;v::ived by th€ Gveraii similarity gff the tH::s._2* é»' '-Vmgard {G the geads in queaiiexi; 1'}E.§..'Ef1%3}_'3J' garfr£§::§ts;..V' _
56. I:;r1""{'3:;*--d;é'}:% t{5'fi.¢:*X3;::1i?r:e éxéiiéifzer the}? ES deceptive resernb1ance%"'-'fwfa' _f3Me:i*t.':3. _?;"19:i.2'€ Ea bf:
considsration §:a:':--:.€£y V 53}F"..W§§ §=F$._ufi'3¢ §fiE"s0n$A.vwhom the r€s;:3mb§an€:e must; bs gafiaéég .::;vg':m§=;.;'sse: and 'V..{_§:} td'.:x..?§*3.at z*':fiEj_£:§;' of c<::mparise'§1 .':1i"€ is 53 aéaptéjzi in ' ;'_L:fi§§:1g§ éé2<;h€:%aer Si.-.i€.'fE} §'€$emb§ia.n{:e QXESVE-$6 °§€==<\g,U...
85
57. In 1':.hi:=:s b£E(?}ig§E'()1,1I'}£Ii azmd §3:_1i':1i:T1g_§ {}I7z€:.'S%£'.'.§f am-:.>__ {he s'a§'1.<3es of 21 <:2.:s:".<;:me:' th,{i~; t:r2~1<i€s r1121;*k_ in qu<;>ss£:.i<31T2 is; a?x;=;1':1i'I'2.ct;'g the «::»:1iy ir:11:E?rer2c.e t:%f121i. wzmlii he'-zve 31:} ha-=3 dregzx-arr': ';-'\'§}"i:f1{,iAAb'€?. '§i'E"€fé"'-, ' c%:,1.$i;<3:1'1e':* Wonk} gt) by the worci "I')éX.'J{I;3_{)FE?"' v._ij1'%1e"', s;in1i1a:'ii.y in the worziss as aiso itses st.y_Te=: 2§u1:i( t'.}':uss 'as_g;fAfa..'11Fi.13E.c%'*V {fL.£S'Ui}1T{1Ef§" wcmigd b€3C{)1'E'1f;-'r 21. ficjr '€51-.s ,ct,':1; 'dc<:e.ii:. A ENE; this which c>L1g}1i: not ta ctcuun-i:7i'1é:.'r:r:*e(i.--'«..Vzitzii __ <::z1_11n0f; be:
.r"i .." 'f%12.1:s,~"de'fe:'ic§im.t.E':saving amt: '::>€r<m ;:»s;31'r:11'tt€d to be 21§1§jx..-fix abie £10 es;te1b.E§sfi'1 931$' its?!' ':h'i:'=:3.' 'Lz1&é;a:'Lis+; fvftér 1.1s£1;1g Eh:-3 xx.-v::;:'e:i "f;>AV§I)QF'F",J Ebr §3f(E%{3_1;(:f,S.._ r1'1_2'1.:mafé2<:t.u:'e(£ by it": cam1(3t: <:0nt€t:":d iiidat w<'e;'<i 'f1i);:~';$ViEl§=;3FET._'_'.1.'{3'fai;<:s £10 2: S1:11*:'1arr1€ £:11'}C§ alga Ehif :'321.£13(é {'3'§"*;~'; £3';
1,1.s::ig: §§z1.¥ft.§<'%'z:Egifiy %;'J_h€i?I"} ii: hm; i:'1€e:'°':'§aitiamaf :*e:.;:}:.z£;.&t Eléf £15 p:*<}«:i1.2A<'1---115:3 v«.T'.::z,;f'm%.'faéj Sazrxe itimegé def€:'z<:§a2u'1i':'ss~s {',£i.E'Z.E1{,}§'. be LT ' . ,§}§.£:Z:§§°E.§i§:E»;" 5'
1.g3£EV:ai';':1i£:.i;.i;%€§ iii; :,:'_:%§€: -E.:«?:«:% W*,;'':; :'%§Tc§IEEf;? §i£;1§Z"E{f fan' §;h€§:* §.;§:g1i';1. §"£2=m':€.
if:'£~:%E=--C€sm:"i <:<}::*:2mE'£,'::€:£§ 21 §e::ri<}e..zs s::~:"'::*<.>:"* in 3'1€T}§l' E1{'§(§,E'f;-"f:'.~".;-.'-%;iE'E§j EC} 2-1::':£.'£ €.'ié3§'Ej}r' Eihfif :"*::éEi_€§ <5? '§{'.E'}E'§3€'}§'EiI"}? §§'.'}_§E3:.:'"s{?§.§{}'E.'"i tr} iiiuf iwfif"
88
E}E':1I1"l€;"?1}_! pji'iI'I1é:l fé1e:"*.i.€: iitzistx 1'3z:z.}am:r3 <::>f {?(3I'1V€?f1if3I'1('.§E? and i.rr«:2p21z'abE€ 1()::~35:s <31' i1'1_§L.1:';yz 2111:: in fézvziur of disc%L.zssed he:%1*€:i:12;:b<3ve zmzi tihe Ca€1c:i1.1ssi.<::'1-Ihatg z*€*c;':._1.§§j€.s' '*;::§[' i dfawll thai piziintiiffs mzve mzaxde (311.3 ztzasc'$5":-"--g::é;'1§':»%, '«:?;:f' T§?I11jJ()F£1}').7 i1'1j1,11'1ci'.ion. }éI.@z1<:e f<)11c>wi3'1g c>i*.de1f_i" ~ '; ()RI)ER' __ "~~ {1)App<~3a1s MFA 475/201 1 3:3:-::i:.. ?'ii-£201 'Ei;:i€.%"VjE:;Ej.€E-r(§b3r- 2111<)wed .
(2) eras; pasggemggmi O£:S.6¢i--%§"?;"§2;?C?Vi_i3ww.<;i€;:f,r:%cE 04..m2010 011%} s {3}131}3}§}i{?é'§1',€€i{'i;§§="fiiffiéi"E3}?:V£i'i,€if. ;3Eai11{,ifi:%3 i.A.I\E (3.71 931$} H in {).S.6~<§8? ,6' 2036 "es:fc,. Et€r<%E3§,r 21.1I(>xved.
iazf. am {:0:':<':§=:rrg@{£ {heat ssame: shaii £55 na;r:1.e.£.},r €.'r:<: §§};§1.2::_E <3:;.3§'.a<3zz":«:: <3? E:E:€:
2": iiiiza <-,-*:v<:ni: (sf §;§a.i:':'£i§f' sméii bi:?ti1'"§§ £.§:'§:'*;';=i:§'£3:+*;-<%>,<i§ triai C{}:,:.1'"z: w<>uE=€§ E3£-3% 32%, Eibaritjg ii} = :;j'z§;1§2i'£ff3,.r §;h::% C('}E%}§I:'i§ pa3;';~:E3~3c? E33; p'£213E_r':i:§§§' i:";::::imi'§3?_:':;:;f u M {:;::;2..:'§E:i.§'§{?a2§;i:.:2'3 eztsi" §£§;i~s:§ if ;5:§':§; ;<~s::,.:_§'"§<'%:'<z{'i E35; §_:E':s:? E piaim; if "
89
C1€?f€§3'1Ci1E1'I'E"{' 011 z-1»:?<'.0um' «:3? ozrier <2? £'<;%mpora1'y' iz'1j1.1;'1.<t:t.i{>rT: {)pé;T'..I"'E1"{,iI1g sigaximsti 1'h:;%m. SEEN