Bombay High Court
Milind Shantilal Rathod And Ors vs State Of Maharashtra , Water Resources ... on 30 January, 2023
Author: Sandeep V. Marne
Bench: S.V. Gangapurwala, Sandeep V. Marne
Digitally
signed by
VINA
VINA ARVIND
ARVIND KHADPE
KHADPE Date:
2023.01.31
10:46:14
+0530
Vina Khadpe
1 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
WRIT PETITION NO. 8568 OF 2022
1) Milind Shantilal Rathod
Age 32 years,
Email: [email protected]
Address: 304, Amish Park,
Western Express Highway,
Near Amar Palace, Mira Village,
Mira Road, Thane - 401 107
2) Ajay Santosh Ahire
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
Address - At. Post Arai, Tal. Baglan,
Dist. Nashik 423301
3) Jadhav Prasad Dnyaneshwar
Age - 30,
Email - [email protected]
Address - A/P Panchashil Nagar, Vairag,
Tal. Barshi, Dist. Solapur, 413402
4) Amol Baban Varpe
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
Address - At - Shirapur Post
Nimgaon Tembhi,
Tal. Sangamner, Dist. A. Nagar, 422605.
5) Vishal Sheshrao Chate
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Addarsh Colony,
Deulgaon Raja, Buldana - 443204
6) Suyash Shankararav Babar
Age - 29,
[email protected]
Address - Bhanudas Niwas,
Vina Khadpe
2 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Ganesh Nagar, Kale Ran Chopadi,
Tal. Sangola, Dist. Solapur, 413308
7) Zore Dnyaneshwar Vyankat
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
Address - A/P Borgaon Raje,
Osmanabad - 413501
8) Vakte Samrudhi Shankar
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
A/p. Jeurkaumbhari, Kopargaon,
Ahmednagar - 423601
9) Mahapude Sagar Eknath
Age - 28,
Email [email protected]
Address - Vambori, Rahurl,
Ahmednagar 413704
10) Kalyani Balasaheb Behare
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
Address - New Gilani Nagar,
Yavatmal - 445001
11) Vikram Arun Gadge
Age - 26
Email - [email protected]
Address - Wasudeo Colony Arni Road,
Yavatmal 445001
12) Pooja Shankarrao Lande
Age: - 27,
Email :- [email protected]
Shevgaon, Tal- Shevgaon,
Ahmednagar-414502
13) Andhale Swapnali Parmeshwar
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
Address - A/P. Pathardi, Pathardi,
Vina Khadpe
3 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Ahmednagar- 414102
14) Tejas Sanjay Gaikwad
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
A/P Bhosalewadi, Po. Ahire,
Khandala, Satara - 412802
15) Keshav Madan Chavan
Age - 27,
Email - [email protected]
Address - At - Belkheda, Post - Asegaon - Pen,
Tal. Risod, Dist. Washim - 444510
16) Swapnil Balasaheb Ghanwat
Age - 27,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Shreyas Sagunamata Nagar,
Phaltan - 415523
17) Rahul Tanaji Kadam
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
Address - A/P. Tandulwadi, Tal. Malshiras,
Dist. Solapur 413310
18) Kokani Sachin Kiran
Age - 23
Email - [email protected]
R/At - Palsun, Post - Dhong, Navapur,
Nandurbar, 425416
19) Balaji Rameshrao Newale
Age - 28, Address - A/P/ Markhel,
Degloor, Nanded - 431718
20) Shubhangi Ramdas Gadade
Age - 24,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Tandali, Tal. Shirur, Pune
21) Omkar Jalindar Shinde
Age: 26
Vina Khadpe
4 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Email: [email protected]
Address: C-2, Anna Nangare Nagar,
Vidyanagar, Saidapur, Karad 415124
22) Nikhil Nitin Dhale
Age-25,
[email protected]
Address-A/p Terwad Tal-Shirol,
Dist- Kolhapur-416106
23) Akshay Arjun Nagargoje
Age-26
[email protected]
Address -Yewalwadi, Tal. Patoda Dist Beed
24) Sagar Dnyandev Kokare
Age - 25
Email - [email protected]
R/a. Ahilyanagar, Dhumalwasti (Pandare),
Baramati, Pune
25) Sonali Arunrao Dehankar
Age-26,
[email protected]
Address- Nitin Stahade, S/NO 40/A,
Behind Gupta Bulding
Samarthwadi, Yavatmal 445001
26) Pawar Akshay Netaji
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
At Javkheda, Po. Varul, Shirpur,
Dist. Dhule 425427.
27) Hulage Kiran Malhari
Age - 24,
Email - [email protected]
R/a.Goradwadi, Tal. Malshiras,
Solapur - 413107
28) Tejas Chintaman Kunchale
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
Vina Khadpe
5 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
R/a.H1/33, Shubham Society,
Wadgaon Sheel, Pune - 411014
29) Abhishek Hanumant Gheware
Age - 23,
Email - [email protected]
R/a. Adarsha Gruhanirman Society,
Bhanu Nagar, Osmanabad 413501
30) Mayur Jagadish Vanarase
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
R/a. M.P. Bhalgaon, Pathardi,
Ahmednagar - 414113
31) Amarnath Girishrao Bhusse
Age - 24,
Email - [email protected]
Address - At Post Loni (BK), Ardhopur,
Nanded - 4317046
32) Prasad Shankar Thopte
Age - 24,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Naralicha Mala,
Pimpre Khurd, Pune - 412102
33) Siddharth Somnath Shardul
Age - 24,
Email - [email protected]
R/a. Police head quarter, Line 3, Room 98,
Gangapur Road, Nashik 422002
34) Somanath Vishwanath Pawar
Age - 23,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Hinganangaon Powanda Road,
Hingangaon [Khu]
Parandhu, Osmanabad 413505
35) Prathamesh Dnyandeo Kadam
Age - 23,
Email - [email protected]
Vina Khadpe
6 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Flat No. 21,Subhash Terrace,
Katraj, Pune 411046
36) Indrajit Sanjay Patil
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
Address - A/p Chinchani, Tal. Tasgaon,
Dist Sangli
37) Gajanana Vishnu Gavane
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
Address - At Pegargavhan, Post Bharaswada,
Tal. & Dist. Parbhani 431521
38) Rajas Arun Kundkawalekar
Age - 24,
Email - [email protected]
Address - A/P Sakharpa,
Tal. Sangmeshwar, Dist. Ratnagiri.7
39) Shrijeet Sunil Gaikwad
Age - 24,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Awase Wasti, Amrai, Solapur.
40) Nitin Gangadhar Daund
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Bank Colony
Behind Ape Autoshowroom Parli. V
41) Alpasha Dilip Bhoutmange
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Plot No. 593,
Angulimal Nagar, Nagpur
42) Pritamkumar Dilip Waghmare
Age - 25,
Email [email protected]
At Po. Ratnapur, Kallam,
Osmanabad 413525
Vina Khadpe
7 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
43) Dwivedi Akshay Jayprakash
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Shymala Sadan, Mogre Layout,
Ballarpur, Dist. Chondropur 442701
44) Sarang Sanjay Pawar
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
Balaji Plot, Anjangaon, Sarji,
Amravati - 444705
45) Harshvardhan Vithalrao Awale
Age - 27,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Teerthrup Niwas,
Bhakti Nagar, Latur-4135128
46) Upendra Onkar Patil
Age - 27,
Email - [email protected]
At post Sakali, Patil Wada, Tal. Yawal, Dist. Jalgaon 425302
47) Rathod Kanchan Hiraman
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
Address - 13, Jal 40, Govt. Quarters,
Forest Colony, Ring Road, Jalgaon 425001
48) Nagesh Tukaram Jadhav
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
Address - AH2/13, N2, Thakre Nagar Cidco
Aurangabad-431003
49) Mayuresh Kiran More
Age - 23,
Email - [email protected]
Address - 23, Samadhan, M.D.Pawar Chowk,
Khambe Gali,Uran - Islampur 415409
50) Vivek Jyotiram Khandagale
Vina Khadpe
8 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Age - 29,
Email - [email protected]
R/At Post Terkheda, Tal. - Washi,
Dist. Osmanabad - 413525
51) Gautam Charandas Zade
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
R/At post Mannerajaram, Bhamragad,
Gadchiroli - 442710
52) Sujay Sarjerao Patil
Age - 30,
Email - [email protected]
A/P Kameri, Walwa,
Dist. Sangli - 415403
53) Dnyaneshwar Sopan Kale
Age - 29,
Email - [email protected]
Address - A/P Paniv, Malshiras,
Solapur - 413113
54) Varekar Swapnil Shamrao
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
Address - A/P Manjari, Tal. Sangola,
Dist. Solapur
55) Jaydeep Shankar Patil
Age - 29,
Email - [email protected]
A/P Urun Islampur, Patil Galli,
Sangli - 415409
56) Varsha Mallik Nalawade
Age - 24,
Email [email protected]
A/P Waiphale, Talevasti, Tasgaon,
Sangli - 416312
57) Swapnil Mohan Waghmode
Age - 27,
Vina Khadpe
9 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Email - [email protected]
Address - A/P/ - Vita, Dist. Sangli
58) Shantanu Dhananjay Koyalkar
Age - 24,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Jayraj Homes, Narhe, Pune
59) Deepak Chandrakant Shinde
Age - 24,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Sidheshwar Colony, Tasgaon
60) Pratik Rajendra Pithe
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
A/P Morve, Tal. Khandala, Satara - 412802
61) Akshay Bhanudas Totkar
Age - 29,
Email - [email protected]
Plot No. 158, Sec. 19, Koyananagar,
Chinchwad, Pune - 411019
62) Prateek Ravikant Dabhade
Age - 25, Email - [email protected]
R/a. H.No. 407, Dabhade wada, At - Chincholi, Po.
Dehuroad(cant) - 412101
63) Prasad Chandrakant Tamboli
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
Address - 16B, Darshrath Nagar,
Nalwar Road, Nandurbar 425412
64) Mangaldeep Dilip Thokal
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
At Po. Rithal, Risod, Washim 444510
65) Chetan Kailas Bhavsar
Age - 24,
Email - [email protected]
Vina Khadpe
10 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Address - Anand Nagar, Nr. Ganapati Temple,
Bhadgaon 424105
66) Vaibhav Mohan Jadhav11
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
A/P Koulage, Tal. Kagal,
Dist. Kolhapur - 416235
67) Akshay Mohan Jadhav
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
A/P/ Koulage, Tal. Kagal,
Dist. Kolhapur - 416235
68) Sankarshan Alias Tanmay Dhanajay Mane
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Margai Galli, Shivaji Peth, Kolhapur
69) Shubham Shrikrishna Bagle
Age - 28,
Email - shubhambagle [email protected]
R/a. Ward No. 5, Dhamangaon Badhe,
Motala, Buldana - 443104
70) Samadhan Harishchandra Kashid
Age - 24,
Email - [email protected]
A/P Malshiras, Tal. Malshiras, Dist. Solapur
71) Ganesh Babaso Shinde
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
R/a. Row house no 16, Swami Vivekanand Nagar,
Phaltan - 415523
72) Pankaj Bhauso Arjun
Age - 23,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Malhar Niwas, A/P/ Lalpuri Kalamb,
Walchand Nagar, Tal. Indapur, Dist. Pune 413114
Vina Khadpe
11 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
73) Sanchi Ashokrao Sonawane
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
Address - A/p. Tarodo Khurd,
Nanded 431605
74) Shraddha Sanjay Gokhale
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
R/a. 771, Buddha Wada, Vadgaon Haveli,
Karod Satara - 415124
75) Shubham B. Kaninde
Age - 27,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Ekamba, Tal. Himayatnagar,
Dist. Nanded
76) Bhupesh Subhash Shirsath
Age - 27,
Email - [email protected]
Address - 86, Sharda Nagar, Dhule
77) Vivek Chandrakant Hegana
Age - 30,
Email - [email protected]
Address - C/o. M.A.Chougule,
Savali Road, Miraj 416410
78) Vaibhav Vilas Maharnur
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
R/a. Hrushikesh Hostel, Manajinagar,
Narhe, Tal. Haveli
79) Shekhar Navnath Awatade
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
A/P. Viswade bk. Tal. - Mohol, Dist. Solapur
80) Bhushan Vijay Pawar13
Age - 25,
Vina Khadpe
12 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Email - [email protected]
Address - Swaraj Boy's Hostel, Nashe
81) Chandrashekhar Gajanan Mali
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Narhe, Pune
82) Sanket Shrikant Koli
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Narhe, Pune
83) Hrushikesh Prakash Jadhao
Age - 24,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Akola, Bansaranagar,
Kaulkhed Road, Akola - 444502
84) Prateek Vishwanath Mendhe
Age - 27,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Vishwanath Mendhe, 121,
Rahate Layout, Parsodi,
Umred, Nagpur - 441203
85) Amol Ashok Ghuge
Age - 24,
Email - [email protected]
At Post Ghoteon,
Tal. Shevgaon,
Dist. A. Nagar, 414502
86) Prafful Haribhau Patil
Age - 24,
Email - [email protected]
At Post Tarang, Tal. Miraj, Dist. Sangli 416410
87) Nishant Sudesh Jadhav
Age - 29,
Email - [email protected]
R/a. 04, Nandan heights,
near Shikrewadi ground, Nashik
Vina Khadpe
13 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
88) Pranal Prakash Jadhav
Age - 27,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Flat No. 2,
Aashiyana Enclave Apt. Apurva Colony,
Shivram Nagar, Jail Rd., Nashik 422101
89) Jayesh Dilip Kelkar
Age - 29,
Email - [email protected]
Address - F/6, Yashwant Sahniwas,
Opp. Ekvira High School,
Vidyanagari, Deopur, Dhule 424005
90) Rathod Kartarsing Pandit
Age - 27,
Email - [email protected]
R.At Nanda Tanda, Tal. Soegaon,
Dist. Aurangabad
91) Hitendra Bharat Patil
Age - 30,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Flat No. 9, Krushnej residence,
Wavare Nagar, Nr.Mahadev Mandir,
Kamtwada, Nashik
92) Rahul Govind Thavil
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
Address - At Garmal Post / Tal. Surgana,
Dist. Nashik 422211
93) Vishal Eknath Chaure
Age - 25,
[email protected]
R/At Karambhel Kanashi, Post Dalwat,
Kawan, Nashik 423502
94) Shubham Sambhaji Patil
Age - 24,
Email - [email protected]
Address - B/4, Saibaba Row House,
Vina Khadpe
14 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Behind Meenatai Thakare School,
Kamatwade, Nashik - 422010
95) Akshay Shamrao Kadam
Age - 24,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Raskamal, Sangori Laus No. 2,
Near Lam Road, Deolali
Camp, Nashik 422401
96) Vikas Devkisan Saham
Age - 24,
Email - [email protected]
Address - At Post Vadgaon, Pingla,
Tal. Sinnar, Dist. Nashik
97) Swapnil Laxman Kumawat
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
R/a.02, Samarth R/h, Lamkhede Mala,
Panchavati, Nashik 420004
98) Harish Ramdas Megha
Age - 24,
Email - [email protected]
Address - fat No.10, Vakratund Apartment,
Prabhatnagar, Mhasrul, Dindori Road,
Nashik - 422004
99) Rahul Deviraj Chavan
Age - 31,
Email - [email protected]
Address - 8, Nilkanth Krupa, Sneh Nagar,
Dindori Road, Mhasrul,
Nashik 422004
100) Ahire Gokul Subhash16
Age - 27,
Email - [email protected]
At/ Post Jad, Tad. Baglan,
Dist. Nashik - 423301
101) Pratik Anil Gaikwad
Vina Khadpe
15 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Age - 24,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Plot No. 134,
Happy Home Colony, Nashik
102) Priyanka Pravin Nikam
Age - 27, Email - [email protected]
Address - Pragati Colony, Upnagar, Nashik
103) Saily Sarang Agre
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
Address - B-2/402, Nirman's Vrindavan Gardens,
Kedar Nagar, Nashik - 07
104) Prajakta Sarang Agre
Age - 23,
Email - [email protected]
Address - B-2/402 Nirman's Vrindavan Gardens,
Kedar Nagar, Nashik - 07.
105) Manish Dilip Patil
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
Address - 09, Shivaji Nagar,
Wadibhokar Road, Near Stadium,
Walwadi, Dhule 424002
106) Rohit Vilas Pawar
Age - 24,
Email - [email protected]
Address - 15, Hemant Deshmukh Hou. Sty.
Near Patil Nagar,17, Deopur, Dhule.
107) Kailas Prmeshwar Gholve
Email [email protected]
R. At Post Sarni, Sangari,
Tal. Kaji, Dist. Beed.
108) Bhakti Kiran Patil
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
R/a. 23, Anupam, Rajeshwar Nagar,
Datta Mandir, Deopur, Dhule
Vina Khadpe
16 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
109) Yashodeep Narendra Borse
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
R/a. 23, Anupam, Rajeshwar Nagar,
Datta Mandir Deopur, Dhule.
110) Gutte Shivaji Bhanudas
Age - 27,
Email - [email protected]
Address - At Guttewadi, Po. Andhori,
Tal. Ahmadpur, Dist. Latur
111) Sanjay Gajanan Punde
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
Address - At - Jastgaon, Post - Warud,
Tal. Telnara, Dist. Akola 444108.
112) Datkhil Mahesh Machhindra
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
Address - At Saidapur, Po. Phulsangavi,
Tal. Georai, Dist. Beed - 431143
113) Narayan Sahebrao Asore
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Sant Janabai Nagar,
Tal. Gangakhed, Dist. Parbhani18
114) Akash Dhanraj Patil
Age - 29,
Email - [email protected]
Address - A/p Sakol, Tq - Shirur Anatpal,
Dist. Latur - 413544
115) Kalpesh Avinash Kamble
Age - 32,
Email - [email protected]
Address - at post Siddharth Nagar,
Karmala, Dist. Solapur 413203
Vina Khadpe
17 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
116) Ankush Shriram Jatale
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
R/a. Mahagaon Road, Nageshwadi,
Yavatmal 445206
117) Shelke Vaishnavi Anil
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
A/P Annapurna Nagar, Station Road,
Kopargaon - 423601
118) Vikrant Yuvraj Patil
Age - 30,
Email - [email protected]
A/P Kasare, Tal. Sakti,
Dist. Dhule - 424310
119) Kawade Sujata Jayawant
Age - 30, Email - [email protected]
Address - Plot No. 91, Behind KBP College,
Pandharpur, Tal.Pandharpur,
Dist. Solapur - 413304
120) Vaibhav Dhanaji Shinde
Age - 24,
[email protected]
A/P. Kanhapuri, Tal. Pandharpur,
Dist. Solapur.
121) Shital Ashok Bharati
Age - 24,
Email - [email protected]
A/P. Kanhapuri, Tal. Pandharpur,
Dist. Solapur
122) Nehe Rahul Kailas
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
At post Sawargaon tal, Sangamner,
Ahmednagar
123) Atul Sunil Mane
Vina Khadpe
18 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Age - 30,
Email - [email protected]
A/P Shendage Wasti, Wagholi,
Malshiraj, Solapur - 413112
124) Harshraj Dattatray More
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
A/P - Anawali, Tal. Pandharpur,
Solapur - 413308
125) Rajvardhan Nagesh Patil
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
Address - A/p Kada, Tal. Ashti,
Dist. Beed - 414202
126) Vaibhav Jagannath Thodsare
Age - 26, Email - [email protected]
R/At Govardhanwadi No. 1,
Post - Dhoki, Osmanabad 413508
127) Waghe Suraj Vishvambhar
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
Address - At Jawalga, Post Kharola,
Tal. Renapur, Dist. Latur
128) Kapil Rajesh Jaybhaye
Age - 27,
Email - [email protected]
Address - M27/2303,
Maharashtra Housing Board,
Yerawada, Pune - 411006
129) Bhandwalkar Krushna Arun
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
A/p.Watephal, Tal. Paranda,
Dist. Osmanabad - 413505
130) Nivedita Ramesh Algat
Age - 25,
Vina Khadpe
19 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Email - [email protected]
Address - Plot No. 60, Jail Road,
Nashik Road, Nashik - 422101
131) Sanket Jaysing Divate
Age - 24,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Saimeet Building,
Wada Colony, Shirur - 412210
132) Abhishek Jagannath Kusalkar
Age - 25,
Email [email protected]
Address - Lane 2, Madhav Nagar,
Near City Hospital, Dhanori,
Pune - 411015.
133) Pravin Ramesh Pawar
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
Address - At Shekapur, Po. Alegaon,
Patur, Akola
134) Chetan Prakash Patil
Age - 27,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Vrundavan Nagar,
Shahada, Nandurbar
135) Yogesh Vitthal Shinde
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
Address - At Post Chikholi, Tal. Patota,
Dist. Beed 413207
136) Suraj Somnath Swami
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Vrundavan Building,
Lane 1, Shahu Colony, Karve
Nagar, Pune
137) Priyanka Balwant Magar
Vina Khadpe
20 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Age - 27,
Email - [email protected]
R/At Ghumera, Post Velapur,
Malshiras, Solapur - 413113
138) Shrikant Motiram Shinde
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Shivnery Nagar, Degloor,
Degloor - 481717 [Nanded]
139) Gajanan Prakashrao Patil
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Shahaji Nagar, Degloor,
Degloor - 431717 [Nanded]
140) Snehal Dnyanoba Kotme
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
R/a. Snehal Niwas, Vikram Nagar,
Barshil Road, Latur - 413512
141) Kajal Champalal Meshram
Age - 27,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Near Hanuman Mandir,
Baba Masthan Shaha Word,
Bhandera, Maharashtra - 441904
142) Aditya Bhimrao Gaykwad
Age - 29,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Plot No. 19, Manihar Layout Jamb Road,
Wadgaon Road, Yavatmal [R],
Yavaatmal, Maharashtra - 445001
143) Sanjeet Bhagwan Jadhav
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Hujare Galli, Pargaon,
Dist. Kolhapur, 416113
Vina Khadpe
21 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
144) Shreyash Kailash Nimbalkar
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Vikas Nagar, Near Anandwan, Warora
145) Nikhil Sudhakar Dhobe
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Maharana Pratap Nagar,
Nagpur Road, Chinora, Warora
146) Chirayu Madhukar Barekar
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Nutan Adarsh Colony Chimur,
Chandrapur
147) Sanjot Dilip Khandre
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Q. No. 49, Indira Nagar,
Ghugus, Tal. Dist. Chandrapur- 442505
148) Shreyash Dnyaneshwar Kumbhare
Age - 24,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Laxmi Nagar, Opp. to Raj Lawn,
Chandnopon - 442401
149) Udaysingh Samadhan Jadhav
Age - 24,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Atit Satara, Maharashtra - 415519
150) Shubham Shivaji Ghadge
Age - 24,
Email - [email protected]
R/At Yerunakarawadi, Post - Darekhurd,
Jaoli, Satara - 415020
151) Sanket Sanjay Bagade
Age - 23,
Email - [email protected]
Vina Khadpe
22 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Address - Flat No. 606, B-wing,
Aadarsh Krutika Molacha Odha,
Satara - 415002
152) Ankit Devidas Thakre
Age - 29,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Post Surgaon, Umred,
Nagpur - 441204
153) Kaustubh Anilrao Madankar
Age - 27,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Mahatma Fule Teachers Colony,
Tal. Odhi [Ba.] Tah. Nagbhid, Dist. Chandrapur
154) Rahul Bhikram Patle
Age - 25, Email - [email protected]
R/At - Chichgaontola, Po. Gankhaira,
Tah. Goregaon, Dist. Gondia
155) Vaibhav Jageshwar Gahane
Age - 27,
Email - [email protected]
R/At Post. Sendurwala,
Tal. Sakoli, Dist. Bhandara
156) Snehal Ravindra Meshram
Age - 28,
Email [email protected]
Address - Raghuji Nagar, Nagpur
157) Alisha Narendra Sahare
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
R/a. 538,Nagarjun Colony, Nara Road,
Jaripatka, Nagpur - 440014
158) Viral Chandrakant Chavhan
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Bhimaji colony, Sulezari, Nagbhir, Dist. Chandrapur.
Vina Khadpe
23 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
159) Saurabh Yuvraj Sankade
Age - 27, Email - [email protected]
R/a. Plot no 93, Maa Tuljai Nagar, Gargoti,
Narsala, Nagpur 440034
160) Anup Pradip Jadhao
Age - 27, Email - [email protected]
R/At. Deurwadi, Post - Chikhali, Arni,
Yavatmal - 44510325
161) Diksha Deepak Burde
Age - 24,
Email - [email protected]
Address - 64, Ogale Road, Nagpur - 440032
162) Nikam Mayur Arun
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Shanti Nagar, Near Old SIS Road,
Malegaon - 423105
163) Bhaskar Laxman Gaikwad
Age - 30,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Shiv-Bhandane, Post - Dalwat,
Kalwan, Nashik-423502
164) Swapnil Yuvraj Rokade
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
Address - 45, Vakratund, Saptashrungi Nagar,
Takali Pr., Chalisgaon, Dist. Jalgaon - 424101
165) Dhavale Bobbyraje Prafull
Age - 29,
Email - [email protected]
R/a. A-271, Karnik Nagar, Near W.I.T. College,
Solapur - 413006
166) Akshay Ananta Shiraswal
Age -27,
Email - [email protected]
At Post - Teachers Colony, Murshadpur,
Vina Khadpe
24 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Ashti, Beed 414203
167) Vaibhav Ramdas Gote
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
At Post - Tondgaon,
Tal. & Dist. Washim- 444505
168) Darade Yogesh Ramesh
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
At / Post Nalwadi,
Tal. Sinner, Dist. Nashik - 422103
169) Tejas Prabhakar Marathe
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Dnyaneshwar Nagar,
Near Gavati Banglow, Malegaon
Camp, Malegaon, Dist. Nashik - 423105
170) Vaibhav Subhash Panpatte
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Plot No. 39, Venkateswara Nagar,
Nanded - 431601
171) Pravinkumar Damodar Lanje
Age 28,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Pragati Colony, Nahar Road,
Sakoli, Bhandara - 441802
172) Abhishek Tukaram Patil
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Plot 11, Durga Colony,
Bhusawal - 425201
173) Vedant Atul Patil
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
At Post Talegaon, Tal. Jamner,
Vina Khadpe
25 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Jalgaon - 424206
174) Sanket Anant Kadam
Age - 29,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Plot No. 31,
Samajbhushan Society, Manish Nagar,
somalwada, Nagpur.
175) Pansare Akash Haushiram
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
R/At - Sable Vasti, Jakhori,
sangamner, Ahmadnagar - 422605
176) Shelake Dipak Dharma
Age - 39,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Plot No. 31/B, Dhatrak Phata,
Balram Nagar, Near Water Tank,
Panchvati, Nashik - 422003
177) Somnath Uttam Varade
Age - 31,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Adgaon Bk. Tal. Rahata, Ahmednagar.
178) Narendra Ramratan Gawande
Age - 26,
Email [email protected]
At Post Pahurjira, Tal. Shegaon,
Dist. Buldhana - 444312
179) Rahul Prakash Yedage
Age - 30,
Email - [email protected]
At Post Mahud BK.,
Tal. Sangola, Dist. Solapur - 413306
180) Shubham Panjabrao Mahure
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
At Morshi, Tal. Morshi,
Vina Khadpe
26 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Dist. Amravati - 444905
181) Pavan Sureshrao Gulhane28
Age - 32,
Email - [email protected]
A/P. Virul Ronghe, Dhamangaon Rly.,
Amravati - 444709
182) Pratik Marotrao Taywade
Age - 29,
Email - [email protected]
A/P. Arjun Nagar, Tal. Amravati,
Dist. Amravati - 444603
183) Akshay Rajendra Kothavade
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Pathak Lane, Amalner,
Dist. Jalgaon
184) Sarang Jagatrao Deore
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Plot No. 100A, Gondur Road,
Nr. Stadium Vivekanand Nagar,
Walwadi Shiwar, Dhule
185) Pardeshi Piyush Satish
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Plot No. 68 (A), Gawale Nagar,
Deopur, Dhule
186) Rahul Gulabsing Paradke
Age - 27,
Email - [email protected]
R/At- June Dhadgaon, Dhadgaon (Akroli)
Post - Dhadgaon, Nandurbar - 425414
187) Chetan Shamrao Algamkar
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
R/At Omari, Post - Konsari,
Vina Khadpe
27 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Chamorshi, Gadchiroli - 442603
188) Rahul Yashwant Kondkawar
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
Address - At Po. Chamorshi,
Dist. Gadchiroli - 442603
189) Kedar Devidas Madavi
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
Address - At Po. Chamorshi,
Dist - Gadchiroli - 442603
190) Swapnil Haridas Chaudhari
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
Address - At Po. - Chamorshi,
Dist. Gadchiroli - 442603
191) Jagat Devidas Madavi
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
Address - At Po. To Chamorshi,
Dist. Gadchiroli - 442603
192) Pratiksha Yuwaraj Bondre
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
Address - F - 105/5, C.S.T.P.S. Colony,
Urjanagar, Chandrapur -442404
193) Punam Pandurang Urkude
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
R/At Kavtha, Post. - Nimbha, Samudrapur,
Wardha 442301
194) Ajit Arjun Patil
Age - 29,
Email - [email protected]
R/a. Vishwvakarma Apartment,
Flat No. 2, Balbhim Colony,
Vina Khadpe
28 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Kasaba, Bawada, Kolhapur,
Post - Kasaba, Bawada, Karvir -416006
195) Hankare Akshay Abasaheb
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Ramnagar, Kolhapur Road, Sangli
196) Rahul Rajaram Jadhao
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Aamni (Khurd), Mahagaon,
Yavatmal - 445205
197) Ashok Rohidas Jadhav
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
At post Shahane, Tal. Shahada,
Dist. Nandurbar - 425444
198) Badadhe Suraj Dattatray
Age: 26
Email: [email protected]
Address: Kesapur, Rahuri,
Ahmednagar 413415
199) Torwane Swapnil Kailas
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Sakri, Dist. Dhule
200) Devare Lalitkumar Ananda
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
Address - 3 'A', Kamal Kunj Nagar,
Nalwa Road, Nandurbar
201) Ganesh Gomnath Wagh
Age - 29,
Email - [email protected]
Address - 398, Hudco Colony, Karit Road,
Nandurbar.
Vina Khadpe
29 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
202) Padmore Ravi Atmaram
Age - 30,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Plot No. 20, Sharamsafya Colony,
Gondur Road, Dhule.
203) Khandekar Maduri Netaji
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
Address - At Post Nilkumabe, Dhule
204) Chaudhari Gaurav Dilip
Age - 29,
Email - [email protected]
At Post Mod Talode, Nandurbar
205) Kankhar Rahul Lotan
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Plot No. 12,
Hinglaj Mata Nagar, Nandurbar.
206) Rupnar Sopan Appaso
Age - 30,
Email - [email protected]
Address - A/1, Nagaj,
Tal. Kavathe Mahankal, Dist. Sangli.
207) Abhijit vijay Pawar
Age - 30,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Plot No. 102, Ambikanagar,
Keadgaon Nagar, Ahmednagar
208) Gate Somesh Tanaji
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
Address - 26/1480, Amrutkumbh,
Near Gajanan Maharaj Mandir,
Post Colony, Osmanabad,
Maharashtra - 413501
209) Panke Saket Shashikant
Vina Khadpe
30 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Age - 24,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Shikshak Colony, Tambri Vibhag,
Osmanabad - 413501
210) Pirjade Waseek Taufeekahmad
Age - 24,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Bhanu Nagar, Near Central Jail,
Osmanabad - 413501
211) Piyush Umakant Shrikhande
Age - 27,
Email - [email protected]
Address - S/o. Umakant Shrikhande,
Mu. Khokarala, PO.Mohadura,
Dist. Bhandara - 441906
212) Swapnil Purushottam Samrit
Age - 27,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Gramseva colony, Mu. Khokarala,
Po. Mohadura, Dist. Bhandara - 441906
213) Kamlesh Jagmohanlal Madavi
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Bela, Bhandara - 441906
214) Jayashri Tejrao Dhote
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Sitabordi, Armori,
Gadchiroli - 441208
215) Ankit Dnyaneshwar Lokhande
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Samta Nagar, Armori,
Gadchiroli - 442605
216) Kunjan Prabhakarrao Sawarkar
Age - 27,
Vina Khadpe
31 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Email - [email protected]
Address - Koranja (Ghadge),
Dist. Wardha - 442203
217) Vaibhav Bapurao Pandit
Age - 27,
Email - [email protected]
Address - At Post Selu, Tal. Washi,
Dist. Osmanabad - 413507
218) Harshal Mangilal Rathod
Age - 29,
Email [email protected]
Address - Aras Layout Tower, Lane, Buldhana
219) Manali Manohar Mhase
Age - 22,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Ayesha Complex,
C- Shilphata, Khopoli - 410203
220) Akshay Manoj Atram
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
R/a. Angad Nagar, Bamanwada,
Rajura, Chandrapur - 442905
221) Swapnesh Popat Raut
Email - [email protected]
A/p Medshingi, Tal. Sangola,
Dist. Solapur - 413307
222) Omkar Jalindar Shinde34
Age: 26
Email: [email protected]
Address: C-2, Anna Nangare Nagar,
Vidyanagar, Saidapur, Karad 415124
223) Sanap Shivraj Dinkar
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
Address -Wadzari, Post - Domari,
Patoda, Beed -414204
Vina Khadpe
32 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
224) Vrushabh Vinod Sawai
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Saikrupa Colony, Sai Nagar,
Amravati - 444607
225) Pranay Dipakrao Nilawar
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
Address - M. Gandhi Ward,
Umarkhed, Yavatmal - 445206
226) Sujit Rajendra Patil
Age - 29,
Email - [email protected]
At Wadgaon, Post - Vani, Tal. Dhule,
Dist. Dhule 424318
227) Sourabh Balasaheb Borate
Age - 29,
Email - [email protected]
Address - At Post Vaduth,
Tal. & Dist. Satara - 415011
228) Hitesh Mahendra Bahadurge
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
Address - H/S. No. 2661/B,
Lane No. 5, Dhule.
229) Gourav Sanjay Shinde
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Shinde Galli, Samdoli,
Miraj, Sangli 416427
230) Pravin Prakash Takale
Age -30 ,
Email - [email protected]
R/At Post - Kavalapur, Tal. Miraj,
Dist. Sangli - 416306
Vina Khadpe
33 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
231) Akshay Vishnu Hadke
Age - 29,
Email - [email protected]
R/a. Kojagiri Colony Niwara,
Kopargaon, Ahmednagar 423601
232) Rajesh Raosaheb Chikhalkar
Age - 24,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Plot No. 21, Room No. C-5,
Datta Dighambar CHS,
Mhada Colony, Mulund [East]
Mumbai - 400081
233) Ajay Prakash Hatte
Age - 31,
Email - [email protected]
Address - At Post Talwada,
Tal. Georai, Dist. Beed
234) Apurva Prakash Bhoyar
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
Address - 44, Kabir Nagar, Nandanwan,
Main Road, Nagpur
235) Kachare Shubhangi Balasaheb
Age - 27,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Ahmednagar
236) Andhare Babasaheb Dnyaneshwar
Age - 31,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Near Andhare Wasti School Mankeshwar,
Post.Mankeshwar, Tal. Bhoom,
Dist. Osmanabad - 413504
237) Aditya Kishor Raut
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Mauli, Near Kedar Apartment,
Rautwadi, Akola
Vina Khadpe
34 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
238) Pratik Vilas Khairnar
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Sanmitra Co-op.Society, College Road,
Lasalgaon, Niphad, Dist. Nashik, PIN 422306
239) Shailesh Mulchand Ratanpure
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
Address - At Post Dhapewada,
Taluka & Dist. Gondia, PIN 441911
240) Swapnil Sanjay Choure
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
Address - At Khandala,
Post - Morgaon, Beed
241) Govind Bhaskar Bikkad
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
Address - At Post Naholi,
Tal. Kaij, Dist. Beed
242) Tina Wasudeo Zungare
Age -33,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Duplex 48, Hingna Town,
Vidarbha Builders, Dhangarpura,
Hingna, Nagpur - 441110
243) Ashish Rajesh Mekhe
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Gadge Nagar, Chandur Bazar,
Amravati - 444707
244) Nikhil Sakharam Atram
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
Address - At Chopan, Mandawa,
Korpana, Chandrapur - 442916
Vina Khadpe
35 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
245) Nishant Eknath Bhamare
Age - 24,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Plot No. 56, N.S. Patil Society,
Surya Nagar, Deopur,
Post - Dhule, Taluka - Dhule,
Dist. Dhule - 424002
246) Nagargoje Prakash Dasharath
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
At - Malegaon, Po. Pargaon,
Tal. Shirur, Dist. Beed - 431190
247) Rameshwar D. Chavan
Age - 29,
Email - [email protected]
Address - N-9 K, Pawan Nagar,
Hudco, Aurangabad
248) Sachin A. Pendharkar
Age - 30,
Email [email protected]
Address - New Shanti Niketan Colony,
Jawahar Colony, A'bad
249) Wagh Appasaheb Bhagwan
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
Address - At Post Chauka,
Tal. Dist. Aurangabad
250) Kiran Bhagwan Jadhav
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Jawala, Tal. Dharur, Dist. Beed
251) Umesh Kisan Pawar
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
Address - At Post Shindi,
Tal. Chalisgaon, Dist. Galgaon
Vina Khadpe
36 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
252) Baliram Vishnu Kande
Age - 27,
Email - [email protected]
Address - At Kandewadi, Post Hingani,
Tal. Dharur, Dist. Beed
253) Sachin Ramkishan Gadade
Age - 30,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Vidhya Nagar, A-40,
Smruti Niwas, Parali - Vaij, Beed
254) Pradeep Ganpatrao Kadwade
Age - 30,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Varad Niwas, Yogeshwar Colony,
Gangakhed, Parbhani
255) Rutuja Mahendra Ambhore
Age - 23,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Gajanan Maharaj Mandir,
Garkheda, Aurangabad - 431001
256) Trupti Vasantrao Sakhare
Age - 24,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Gurudev colony,
Behind Ajinkya Colony, VMV road,
Amravati, Maharashtra - 444604
257) Gaikwad Rohit Rajendra
Age - 29,
Email - [email protected] Address - H.No.
5/12/89, Padampura, Aurangabad
258) Prasanna Ramesh Raut
Age - 31,
Email - [email protected]
Address - C-10/47, Sneh Nagar, Aurangabad
259) Hatte Shubham Babasaheb
Vina Khadpe
37 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Age - 24,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Twarita Niwas, Naik Nagar,
Georal, Beed - 431127
260) Vishal Motilal Rathod
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Ektuni, Adul, Aurangabad.
261) Vishnu Namdev Kale
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Vitalnagar, N - 2, Cidco, Aurangabad.
262) Shrikar Nagnath Kasture
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
Address - N-4, Cidco, Aurangabad.
263) Tushar Prakashrao Jamdade
Age - 24,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Parvati Nagar, Hudco Road, Parbhani
264) Akash Namdeo Doke
Age - 24,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Mukund Wadi, Aurangabad.
265) Kurund Vivek Hanumant
Age - 25,
Email [email protected]
Address - Quarter No. 38, PWD Quarters,
SBC Board, Osmanapura, Aurangabad.
266) Akash Madanrao Kachare
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
Address - At Post Gajanan nagar,
Maialgaon, Dist. Beed
267) Darwade Shreyas Rambhau
Vina Khadpe
38 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
A/P Ahilyanagar, Newasa Phata,
Tal. Newasa, Dist. A'Nagar.
268) Mahesh Shantaram Salvi
Age - 27,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Shivshankar Colony, Aurangabad.
269) Deshmukh Hemant Ashokrao
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
R/At Wazar Sarkate, Post Bellora,
Tal. Mantha, Dist. Jalna
270) Sanjay Kantrao Jadhav
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Laul Vasti, Vitthal Nagar,
Patoda, Dist. Beed
271) Vijaykumar Shankar Parpelli
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Post Colony, Old Pedgaon Road,
Parbhani - 431401
272) Abhilash Shantappa Patil
Age - 27,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Chandraratan Niwas,
Pachod Road, Ambad, Jalna
273) Kamble Manoj Goroba
Age - 28,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Anandwadi, Post - Ambulga (b.K.)
Tal. Nilanga - 413521
274) Mangesh Harishchandra Gadkar
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
Vina Khadpe
39 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
At Post Tugaon, Tugaon, Osmanabad,
Maharashtra - 413508
275) Shaikh Ahamad Habib
Age - 26,
Email [email protected]
At Hokarna, Post Wanjarwada,
Hokarna, Latur - 413514
276) Shaf Ajmoddin Shaikh
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Katghar, Mohalla, Ausa,
Latur, Maharashtra - 413520
277) Shripal Anandrao Jadhav42
Age - 27,
Email [email protected]
Address -Nilanga, Shirol Va, Latur,
Maharashtra - 413530
278) Sanjivani Shridhar Pawar
Age - 25,
Email [email protected]
Address - At Shedashi, Taldev,
Post - Ransai, Taluka - Pen,
Shedashi, Pen, Raigad - 402107
279) Balbhim Shivaji More
Age - 28,
Email [email protected]
Address -At Ganjur Post - Rameshwar,
Rameshwar, Latur 413511
280) Akash Ashokrao Mirkale
Age - 29,
Email [email protected]
Address - Latur Road, Latur,
Maharashtra - 413513
281) Mahesh Mohan Dharmadhikari
Age - 29,
Email [email protected]
Vina Khadpe
40 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Address - Sambhaji Nagar, Latur - 413512
282) Sanket Sanjay Dhumal
Age - 23,
Email - [email protected]
Address - 4B / 201 / Mankhurd,
Mumbai - 400088
283) Suraj Dadasaheb Jadhav
Age - 24,
Email - [email protected]
Address - PLOT NO. 122/C-4 Tarangan Society Thane.
284) Akshay Sarjerao Pawar
Age - 24,
Email - [email protected]
Address - 708, Bhagirathi Building,
Mankhurd, Mumbai - 400088
285) Nimbalkar adesh rajendra
Age-29 Email- [email protected]
Address- Behind Mahesh talkies,
Tarakpar, Ahmednagar.
286) Sonnati Parshuram Navnath
Age-30
Email- [email protected]
Address- sweganga Nival,
Alamgir road, Bhingad, A nagar
287) Kotade dipti goraknath
Age-31
Email- [email protected]
Address- A/P pohegaon,
Tal kopargaon, Dost A nagar
288) Kerale aditya sadashiv
Age-26
Email- [email protected]
Address- Tapovan road, Ahmednagar
289) Chimajee mahadev lad.
Age-29
Vina Khadpe
41 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Email- [email protected]
Address- Anandnagar, Tal Pathardi,
Dist- Ahmednagar 414102.
290) Dhakane Pravin Raosaheb
Age 27
Email- [email protected]
Address- Anandnagar, Pathardi,
Ahmednagar- 414102
291) Ganesh vitthal Jawale
Age- 28
Email- [email protected]
Address- Wadule, Wagholi Shevgaon,
shevgaon, Ahmednagar
292) Hemant Shivaji Abhale
Age-29
Email- [email protected]
Address- Plot No 35, Ganesh chowk,
Bolhegaon road, Nagpur, A.
Nagar 414111
293) Nutankumar Raju pachore
Age-28
Email- [email protected]
R/At Bahadarabad, Hal Kopargaon,
Ahamadnagar, 423605
294) Manish Tharmas Domale
Age-24
Email- [email protected]
R/a. Ward no 6, Near SSJ college,
Arjuni/morgaon, Gondiya-441701
295) Harshada Motiram valvi
Age-27
Email- [email protected]
Address- At. Padli, Post Sisa,
Tal. Dhadgakon, Dist-Nandurbar
296) Rakesh maske
Age-29
Vina Khadpe
42 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Email- [email protected]
Address- 100ft road, Ashirwad Bunglow,
khokale Mala, Pragati Colony, Sangli-416416
297) Rani Manoj Rokade45
Age- 24
Email- [email protected]
Address- Gandhi Ward, Brahmapuri Road,
Tehsil- Desaiganj, Gadchiroli 441207
298) Swapnil digambar patil
Age- 24
Email- [email protected]
Address- Wadarpura, Panchasil Nagar,
Amravati 444602
299) Prashant Shivaji Tarange
Age- 26
Email- [email protected]
Address- A/P Bhamburdi, Tal Malshiras,
Dist Solapur 413111
300) Kishor Shamrao Nale
Age- 29
Email- [email protected]
Address- A/P Dudhebavi,
Tal- Palthan, Dist- Satara
301) Kaustubh Keshaorao Sonule
Age- 27
Email- [email protected]
Address- Vidya Nagar Gujari,
Ward Bramhapuri, Dist-Chandrapur
302) Dnyaneshwar shriram kharmate
Age- 24
Email- [email protected]
Address- Al Bavi, Post Br Yellamb,
Shirur kasar, Beed 413249
303) Rajkumar Ashruba Khedkar
Age-24
[email protected]
Vina Khadpe
43 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
A/P Ghatsil Pargaon,
Shirut Kason, Beed - 413249
304) Santosh Kailash Kawade
Age-26
[email protected]
A/P Hawale kadlog, Tal-sangamner,
Ahmednagar 422605
305) Sagar kishor somani
Age-26
Email- [email protected]
Address- At Borkhadi, Tal-Sengaon, Dist-Hingoli
306) Paul Pandurang Rameshwar
Age-26
[email protected]
Address-At Digars J, Tal-Selu,
District- Parbhani-431505
307) Ashwini Shivaji Jadhav
Age: 25,
Email: [email protected]
Address: Plot no. B-09, Gut no. 170,
Satara Parisar, Aurangabad
308) Patil vaibhav manohar
Age-26
Email- [email protected]
Address- 3 Aadhar Nagar,
Walwadi, Deopur Dhule, 424002
309) Shashank Vilasrao Bhosale
Age-23
[email protected]
Address- Shahunagar, Hanuman mandir,
Beed-431122
310) Pushkar Vijay Lakadey
Age-24
Email- [email protected]
Address- Armori Dist, Gadchiroli - 441208
Vina Khadpe
44 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
311) Shubham Gyanilal Karanjekar
Age-25
Email- [email protected]
Address- Srinagar colony,
Nr. Gobade Hospital, Sakali,
Bhandara, Pin-441802
312) Sachin Haibati Devkate
Age : 26
Email: [email protected]
Address : 15 Mangalwar Peth
Karad 415110
313) Rupesh Rajkumar Chopane
Age -28
Email : [email protected]
Road no. 3, Vyankatesh Nagar ,
Ambajogai Road, Latur - 413512
314) Sushil Rajaram Pawal
Age. 28,
Email if. [email protected]
Address Shahajanpur
Post. Shirasmarg Tal. Georai,
Beed 431122
315) Apurva Waghmare
Age- 29,
Email - [email protected]
Address- Dubbewar lay out near
Navajeevan convent school,
Pusad Dist Yavatmal
316) Vrushabh Anil Poche
Age: 25
Email: [email protected]
Address: At post Shivpuri
Tal Walwa Dist sangli
317) Ankit P. Narwade
Age-24
Email- [email protected]
Address- Vitthal Nagar, Mehkar
Vina Khadpe
45 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
318) Balasaheb Ashok Konale
Age- 23
Email- [email protected]
Address- Vithai Niwas Sundar Nagar
Ring road Nanded.
319) Farakte Sujit Shivaji
Age-26,
[email protected]
Address - At Post Kasaba Walve
Radhanagari Kolhapur 416221
320) Anuja Raviraj Mandlik
Age -25
Email:[email protected]
Address: Near Airport Road Nanded, Nanded
321) Pavankumar Ganpatrao Narwade
Age- 27
Email- [email protected]
Address- Narwade Niwas, At- Dongrai,
Chakur, Latur- 413518
322) Vikeen Ramling Nirmale
Age-29
[email protected]
Address- Brahmanand nagar, Kamatgar,
Bhiwandi Dist Thane 421302
Post Dhamankar naka
323) Vishal Gokul Vichave
Age-28,
[email protected]
Address -at Post Vichave, Tal Raver
Jalgaon 425508
324) Bhagyashri Rameshrao Thele
Age-30,
[email protected]
Address - Abhiyanata Colony, Amravati
325) Akash rameshrao Thele
Vina Khadpe
46 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Age-24,
[email protected]
Address-9, Abhiyanta Colony, Amaravati
326) Pratik Dattatray Muluk
Age-26,
[email protected]
Address-R-1333, Muluk Niwas,
Nr Piramal Vaikunth, Balkum,
Thane(w)-400608
327) Pranita ramchandra vekhande
Age-26,
[email protected]
Address- Gurutirth Niwas , Yamuna Nagar,
Cherpoli, Post -Aware, Tal - Shahapur,
Dist- Thane Pin 421601
328) Mayur vikas patil
Age-28,
[email protected]
Address-C-3/104, Tulf Vihar,
Gokul Nagori, Kalyan
329) Hritik Rajendra Yadav
Age- 21
email- [email protected]
Address - Pathanwadi, Malad,
Mumbai-400097
330) Shubham Surendra Mahesh
Age-28,[email protected]
Address-105/pension Nagar, Nagpur
331) Rohan R Dhore
Age - 26,
Email id - [email protected]
R/a- Ganesh Mandir Road,
Lahariya Nagar, Kaulkhed,
Akola 444001
332)Manish Sanjay Jugale
age - 25,
Vina Khadpe
47 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
email- [email protected]
address - 12th lane , Mauli Complex,
Jaysingpur 416101
333) Shubham Ramesh Barai
Age-26
Email- [email protected]
Address-Om Sai Nagar, Taluka- Mouda,
Dist-Nagpur-441104
334) Swapnil Dattatray Khedkar
Age 30,
[email protected]
R/a. Waman Bhau Nagar, Pathardi,
Ahmednagar 414102
335) Nilima Ashok Bhere
Age : 26,
Email : [email protected]
Address : Gurutirth Niwas , Yamuna Nagar,
Cherpoli, Post -Aware , Tal - Shahapur,
Dist- Thane Pin 421601
336) Anurag Ashokrao Sangole
Age 29,
Email- [email protected]
Address- Yeshomangal colony
behind Meghe Complex VMV Road Amravati.
337) Satpute dhanaji dada
Age-25,
[email protected]
Address-a/p-Tandulwadi,
Tal-Malshiras Dist-Solapur-413310
338) Jadhav Radha Shivaji
Age-24,
Email [email protected]
Address-Turori, Tq- Omerga, Dist-Osmanabad
339) Rameshwar shobhelal dhurwe
Age-32,
[email protected]
Vina Khadpe
48 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Address-near Pratap Vidyalaya, Yavatmal
340) Akshay Panjabrao Aher
Age-23
[email protected]
Address- Yeldarkar colony,
Basmath road, Parbhani
341) Dhiraj Dileep Zudpe
Age -25
Email- [email protected]
Address- indradhanushya b1,
behind Govt Rest House,
Sneh nagar Nanded-431602
342) Pratik Kalidas Walke
Age 27,
Email [email protected]
Professor Colony, Naginabag Ward,
Chandrapur 442401
343) Shubham Pramod Koshatwar
Age 27,
Email - [email protected]
Address- Shastrinagar, Arni Tq-Arni
Dist - Yavatmal 445103
344) Kiran Dinkar Tandale
Age 27,
Email: [email protected]
Address: Rajuri, Beed.
345) Navnath Vaijnath Shinde
Age 27,
Email - [email protected]
Shinde Niwas, Behind Akshay Hospital,
Ram Nagar, Ausa Road, Latur 413512
346) Thavil Anil Krushna
Age-28
Email- [email protected]
Address- Pallvi RO HA NO 21
Shrayu Park, Adgaon, Nashik-422003
Vina Khadpe
49 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
347) Pranali Narendra Tidke
Age -25
Email - [email protected]
Address - Kazi Nagar, Sant Kabir ward,
Bhandara 441904
348) Devendragiri Dattatrayagiri Gosavi
Age -32
Email - [email protected]
Address - Row House No. 4,
Swami Samarth Nagar, Adgaon Shivar,
Nashik 422003
349) Saurabh vinod umalkar
Age -27
Email - [email protected]
Address - Navin chal, Vidharbh mill
Achalpur 444806
350) Vijay Laxman Shinde
Age 29,
EMAIL:[email protected]
Address: at Po.Selu, Tq . Palam, Dist.Parbhani.
351) Ashutosh Diwakar Wankhade
age - 24
Email - [email protected]
Address - Hiwarkhed Rup ,Taq- Telhara,
Dis- Akola
352) Kishor Dnyanoba gire
Age : 25,
Email : [email protected]
Address :at Post Gaul ,
Post - Gaul, Kandhar, Nanded 431714
353) Saurabh Ashok Sonkusare
Age -28
Email [email protected]
Address - Plot no.38, Warkhade Layout, Tilak Ward,
Opp kashyap plaza, Warora,
District Chandrapur, M.S. pincode 442907
Vina Khadpe
50 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
354) Pradeep Kshirsagar
Age - 25 Email - [email protected]
Address - At Post- Ozewadi
Tal- Pandharpur Dist- Solapur
355) Patil Surajkumar Satappa
Age 26, Email - [email protected]
Kanthewadi, Radhanagari, Kolhapur - 416211
356) Gunjal Snehal Uttam
Age 25,
Email - [email protected]
Khandgaon, Sangamner,
Ahmednagar - 422605
357) Nikhil Pradeep Agrawal
Age 25,
Email - [email protected]
A114, Dreamz Park, New Ganesh Colony,
Amravati - 444605
358) Vinod Vyankatesh Suryawanshi
Age 30,
Email - [email protected]
R/a. 193, MHADA Colony,
Latur - 413512
359) Vaibhav Madhav Khadgi
Age 23, [email protected],
Address- Juni Mangalwari Kawdu Patil Akhada,
Nagpur- 440008
360) Reshma Kisanrao Kitukale
Age 25,
Email - [email protected]
Masod, Kurol Purna, Chandurbazar,
Amravati - 444723
361) Rushikesh Pradip Taralkar
Age 24,
Email - [email protected],
Vita, Khanapur, Sangli - 415311
Vina Khadpe
51 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
362) Khandebharad Mayur Pralhad,
Age 26
Email - [email protected]
Kumbhari, Deulgaon Raja,
Buldhana 443204
363) Roshan Gulabrao Thakare
Age 27,
Email - [email protected]
Samarth Nagar, Akola road, Patur,
Akola - 444501
364) Kshitija Ramchandra Sankhe
Age 26,
[email protected]
Address- A/P Kumbhavali, Boisar,
Tal/Dist-Palghar - 401501
365) Nilesh Sushant Biswal
Age 26,
Email - [email protected]
New Mahalaxmi Nagar,
Amaravati - 444605
366) Akshay Ramesh Dharmapuriwar
Age -27
Email [email protected]
Address -At Junasurla
Po. Gadisurla, Mul, Chandrapur
367) Satish Dattatray Bhavar
Age -31,
Email - [email protected]
A/P Bramhgaon, Ashti, Beed-414203
368) Kailas Ramesh Rathod
Age -29,
Email - [email protected]
Address - A/P Sakhara kh., Ghatanji, Yavtmal
369) Likhit Vasantrao Pandav
Age -27,
Vina Khadpe
52 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Email [email protected]
Address -50/A, Gurukrupa Colony,
Rahatgaon Chowki, Shivaji Nagar post,
Dist - Amravati
370) Roshan Mohan Gite
Age -22,
Email - [email protected]
Address - A/P Shingave, Niphad,
Nashik, Pin - 422210
371) Ashwini Jayawant Patil
Age -23,
Email - [email protected]
Address - A/P 64, Pramod Nagar,
Sector 2 , Devpur , Dhule
372)Vaibhav Shashikant Deoghare
Age 27,
E-mail : [email protected]
Address : Flat no. 15/16, Jitendra Classic,
Near Cummins Hall, Lane no. 3,
Dahanukar Colony, Kothrud,
Pune - 411038
373) Shubham Ramdas Umak
Age -27
Email - [email protected]
Address -At post Kakda Tq: Achalpur,
Amravati 444808
374) Manasi Mahesh Harkare
Age- 27yrs
Email- [email protected]
Address- 72, Shree Guru Namoh
Naik Nagar, Nanded
375) Milind Ramesh Rayate
Age - 28
Email ID - [email protected]
R/a. Shishak Colony Kundal A/p Kundal,
Palus, Sangli 416309
Vina Khadpe
53 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
376) Ravi Sudhakar Karve
Age 28
Email Id [email protected]
Address - Nand vihar, Anikat road,
Khamgaon, Buldhana 444303
377) Shubham Shyamkumar Nawale
Age - 28
Email ID - [email protected]
Address - Somwarves fule Chauk,
Akot Pin 444101
378) Prathmesh Prabhakar Nanhe
Age - 25
Email ID - [email protected]
Address - Om Shivniketan Colony
Shegav Road, Amravati 444604
379) Pradnya Diwakar Wankhade
Age 28
Email ID [email protected]
Address - Kharonpura Hiwarkhed,
Tal Telhra Dist Akola 444103
380) Chetan Sudhakar Bagul
Age 26
Email ID - [email protected]
Address Plot no 11, Arunodaynagar Sakri road
Dhule 424001
381) Prajakta Sidharth Bansod
Age 27
Email ID - [email protected]
Address 16 Aai Niwas Dandekar Layout
In front of Javahar Highschool Jam Road
Wadgaon, Yawatmal 445001
382) Pranav Rajpalrao Shinde
Age 29
Email ID - [email protected]
Address - Netajinagar Nagar
Kalge Hospital, Latur
Vina Khadpe
54 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
383) Akshay Dnyaneshwar Kasar
Age 28
Email ID - [email protected]
Address - Tirupati Nagar Raver
Tal Raver, Dist Jalgaon 425508
384) Dinesh Shivdas Vyavahare
Age 29
Email ID - [email protected]
Address - Ap Karkamb Tal Pandharpur
Dist Solapur 413304
385) Sudarshan Vasantrao Khairnar
Age 28
Email ID - [email protected]
Address - Survey No 85/2, Plot No 50,
Shree Nagar, Biladi Fata, Deopur Dhule.
386) Diksha Vijay Meshram
Age 25
Email ID [email protected]
Address - Ambedkar ward Gandhi Chowk Bandhara
387) Jayant Rajendrakumar Tudme
Age 24
Email ID [email protected]
Address - Shankar nagari 4 Asarjan
Nanded 431606
388) Aniket Dadasaheb Muley
Age 24
Email ID [email protected]
Address At Bhioggaon Post Mangrul,
Ghansawangi, Jalna 431211
389) Kishor Kisan Kamble
Age 28
Email ID [email protected]
Address a/p Shindewadi(H),
Kavathemahankal, Sangli 416405
390) Bhushan Anantrao Kadwe
Age 29,
Vina Khadpe
55 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Email: [email protected]
Ayodhyanagar Near Rammandir,
Nagpur-440024
391) Akash Namdev Chavhan
Age 25,
Email ID [email protected]
Address - A/p .Ningnoor Tal Umarkhed
Dist Yavatmal-445230
392) Ganesh Bapusaheb Raut
Age 25
Email ID [email protected]
Address - A .Paduli (bk) Post Antrwali tembhi
Tal Dist Jalna
393) Pratik Ramesh Jagtap
Age 26
Email ID [email protected]
Address - Akash Apartment1, Block no. 6
Kamalnagar Kamathwada, Nashik
394) Swapnil Vijay Vispute
Age 26
Email ID [email protected]
Address - Omnagar Deola, Tal Deola
Dist Nashik 423102
395) Shubham Balkrishna Jadhav
Age 26
Email ID [email protected]
Address - Vanai Apartment
Ektanagar Nashik 422013
396) Pranav Shekhar Dalvi
Age 25
Email ID [email protected]
Address -7388, Nr. Chande Bekars Maliwada
Ahmednagar 414001
397) Pratik Pramod Londe
Age 27 Email ID [email protected]
Address -VMV Post Mahendra Colony Pandari Maruti line No2
Vina Khadpe
56 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Amaravati 444604
398) Kaustubh Ramuji Dhurve
Age 26
Email ID [email protected]
Address -Chadur bazaar
Dist Amravati 444704
399) Bipin Dnyanadeo Nikam
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Amol Chs, A - 201,
Plot no B - 185/186, Sector - 19,
Kopar Khairane,
Navi Mumbai, 400709
400) Omkar Ananda Pachpind
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
Address - A/P Renuka colony,
Ganesh Nagar, Kalwan,
Taluka - Kalwan, Dist Nashik 423501
401) Mayuresh Baban Hadawale
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
Address - A/P Rajuri, Taluka - Junnar,
Dist - Pune, 412411
402) Harshavardhan Pradeep Sabale
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
13, Sawant Colony, Shahunagar,
Godoli, Satara - 415001
403) Rohan Jadhav
Age - 27,
Email - [email protected]
Bhavani Nagar, Aurad (Sha),
Taluka - Nilanga, Dist - Latur
404) Sunil Ashok Dhanwani
Age - 29,
Vina Khadpe
57 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Email - [email protected]
Address - Janta Vasahati Parvati,
Lane No - 43, Pune - 411009
405) Ambana Shrimant Gudodagi
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
Address - A/P - Ekundi, Tal - Jath,
Dist - Jangli, 416402
406) Rushikesh Govindrao Karad
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
Address - A/P Pangari, Taluka - Parali -V,
Dist - Beed
407) Akshay vasant Adole
Age 26,
Email- [email protected]
Ravaji Jadhav Chawl beobin shivajinagar Naupada
Thane (w)-400602
408) Samir Subhash Sanadi
Age - 26,
Email-samirsanadi [email protected].
At Maroli, Tal-Mangalwedha
Dist-Solapur Pincode- 413322
409) Bhagyashree Dilip Patil
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Chopada , Jalgaon
410) Tushar Ramesh Kathale
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Green Park Society Ujwal Nagar
Yavatmal 445001
411) Shubham Shankar Patil
Age - 26 ,
Email- [email protected]
Address-Gurukrupa Nagar Nanded
Vina Khadpe
58 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
412) Ram Agrawal
Age - 24,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Plot no.91, Shivaji Nagar,
Sillod 431112
413) Sonali Guruling chougule.
Age - 26,
Email- chougulesonali [email protected].
R. S. No. 242/14, Plot No. A-51,
Apte nagar Kolhapur Pin- 416 011
414) Manish Manoj Patil.
Age 24
Email- [email protected]
Plot No-97, Shraddha Nagar Near Nakane Road,
Deopur Dhule.
415) Vittal Tayappa Gadhave. Age - 28
Address - At-umbergaon;, Post-Dighanchi,
Atapadi Sangli-415315.
416) Suraj Bapusaheb Gurav.
Age - 24,
Email- [email protected].
Address - A/P-Bhandarkavathe,
Tal-South Solapure, Pin-413211
417) Vaibhav Narhari Umredkar
Age: 23,
Email: [email protected]
Address: Dyaneshwar Mauli Apartment,
Nerul , Navi Mumbai
418) Aishwarya Kashinath Kapte
Age:28,
Email- [email protected]
Address- Rajiv Gandhi Chowk Latur
419) Akshay Madhukar Raut
Age: 27,
Email: [email protected]
Vina Khadpe
59 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Address: Barbole Plot Barshi
420) Prajwal D Bharadkar
Age: 24,
Email: [email protected]
Address: Ramkrishna Nagar, Nagpur
421) Anna Jaywant Jaybhay
Age: 27,
Email: [email protected]
Address: Jaybhaywadi, Ahmednagar
422) Kalpesh Uttam Erande
Age: 22,
Email: [email protected]
Address: Indiranagar, Lane No 9, Sangamner
Dist-Ahmednagar
423) Tanuja Sudhakar Ade
Age: 25,
Email: [email protected]
Address: Shree Datta Vihar Colony, Amravati
424) Ranjeet Jaywant Kawade
Age: 29, Email: [email protected]
Address: Link Road, Pandharpur
425) Tushar Balasaheb Wabale
Age:26,
Email:[email protected]
Address: Belapur
426) Nikita Prakash Chowgule
Age: 25
Email: [email protected]
Address: Kadamwadi, Kolapur
427) Neha Suresh Sonar
Age:29
Email: [email protected]
Address: Chopde Nagar, Fattepur
428) Prathmesh Rajendra Kotkar
Vina Khadpe
60 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Age:24
Email: [email protected]
Address:Deopur Dhule
429) Manesh Baburao Dandge
Age:30
Email: [email protected]
Address:Sawangi, Aurangabad
430) Priya Vinayak Chumble64
Age:26
Email: [email protected]
Address:Kranti Chowk Nashik
431) Vishal Nimba Tatar
Age- 31,
Email- [email protected]
Address- Datta Colony, Mitranagar,
Satana, Baglan, Nashik.
432) Rohini Bhaskar Jalkar
Age:26 Email: [email protected]
Address: Subhashnagar Miraj
433) Yogesh Shivaji dhange
Age:26 Email: [email protected]
Address: Lokmitra Nagar, Nanded
434) Gadhe Jayshree Namdeo
Age:26 Email: [email protected]
Address: At.Chilpimpari Post Daregaon,
Tal- Mudkhed Dist-Nanded
435) Rajesh Jakur
Age:27
Email: [email protected]
Address:Jagadamba Niwas Nanded
436) Sagar Babarao Bhong
Age:28
Email: [email protected]
Address:Shyam Nagari Pandharkwada
Dist. Yavatmal 445302
Vina Khadpe
61 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
437) Sagar Bhimrao Patil
Age:32
Email: [email protected]
Address: Kolhapur
438) Swanand Salunke
Age:27 Email: [email protected]
Address:Prakashnagar Latur
439) Palash Renudas Kale
Age:29
Email: [email protected]
Address:Nagpur
440) Aishwarya moreshwar charde
Age:24
Email: [email protected]
R/a. Plot no 20, Khandelwal layout,
Narkhed, Nagpur- 441304
441) Dhatrak Dhanashri Sahebrao
Age:25
Email: [email protected]
Address: Hinganwedhe Post-Kotamgaon,
Nashik, 422105
442) Masal Umesh Bharat
Age- 25,
Email: [email protected]
Address: Ashtekar Plot No. 37
Abhaynagar Sangli.
443) Anuja Anandrao Bhosale
Age:29, Email: [email protected]
Address: Plot 81, Vidyanagar,
Phaltan, Satara.
444) Ketan Vilasrao Abhale
Age:29,
Address: A/p Madhi Khurd, Tal-Kopargaon,
Dist Ahmednagar 423601,
[email protected]
Vina Khadpe
62 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
445) Mayur Nimba Aher
Age:22
Email: [email protected]
Address: Nivane
446) Parinit Shahare
Age - 29
Email - [email protected]
Address - Trumurthi Nagar,
Deori, Tal - Deori, Dist Gondia
447) Kshitij Shivajirao Shinde
Age - 24
Email - [email protected]
Address - A/P Maldiapur, Taluka Udgir,
Dist - Latur, 413517
448) Niranjan Tatpate
Age - 25
Email [email protected]
Address - Hrishikesh Hostel, Narhe, Pune
449) Govind Sanjay Nichit
Age - 26
Email - [email protected]
Address - Shubham Layout, Kathora Road,
Amravati 444604
450) Sanket Sanjaysinh Gaikwad
Age - 26
Email - [email protected]
Address - Kadoli, Taluka - Panhala,
Dist - Kolhapur
451) Sejal Rajendra Patil
Age - 24
Email - [email protected]
Address - Plot No 26, Nhagwati Nagar,'
New Malegaon Road,
Chalisgaon, Dist - Jalgaon 424101
452) Prabuddha Khushalrao Ramteke
Vina Khadpe
63 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Age - 27
Email - [email protected]
Address - Sai Nagar, Yerawar Layout,
Pimpalgaon Road, Yawatmal 445001
453) Meghana Vijay Lokhande
Age - 25
Email - [email protected]
Address - A/P Dabha, Tal - Babhulago,
Dist - Yavatmal 445101
454) Suhas Vilas Lalpate
Age -27
Email - [email protected]
Address - A/p- Rajuri Ral-Jamkhed
Dist- Ahmednagar
455) Mayur Sarjerao Patil
Age - 28
Email - [email protected]
Address - Professor Colony, Wadibhokar Road,
Dhule 424002
456) Deepak Dinkar Kayande
Age - 28
Email - [email protected]
Address - Aurangabad
457) Nishant Sushil Deore
Address - A/P - Navi Bej Kalwan,
Nashik 423501
458) Gaurav Rajeshwar Burkhande
Age - 30
Email - [email protected]
Address - Near Wali Baba Darga,
Besides Shree Ganesh Temple,
Plot No 63, Achal Vihar Amravati
459) Mahesh Sahadev Kadam
Age - 30
Email - [email protected]
Address - C/O Sahadev D Kadam,
Vina Khadpe
64 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
3/1/A/19, Radhikanagari Society,
Near Pallavi Hotel, Kupwad, Sangli 416436
460) Mohanish Hemant Patil68
Age - 25
Email - [email protected]
Address - 70, shrikrishna nagar, peopur,
Dhule 424002
461) Shubham Thakare
Age - 23
Email - [email protected]
Address - 83, Shrirang colony, Nirmal Apartment,
Flat no. 3, Deopur, Dhule-424005
462) Nikita Bhausaheb Hagawane
Age - 24
Email - [email protected]
Address - A/P - Matori, Nashik 422203
463) Pravin Chandrakant Dhage Age:24
Email:[email protected]
Address:A/P Sonand , Tal Sangola 413307
464) Mahesh Dnyandeo Dushing
Age:23
Email:[email protected]
Address: Umbre, Rahuri,
Ahmednagar 414105
465) Priyanka Bhausaheb Ghuge
Age:27
Email:[email protected]
Address: Shahnoorwadi, Aurangabad
466) Vikas Ashok khilari
Age : 28,
Email : [email protected]
Address: At post Kargani, Tal: Atpadi
Dist : Sangli
467) Swapnil Madhukar Waghmare
Age:29
Vina Khadpe
65 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Email:[email protected]
Address: Bharat Nagar Digras Yavatmal
468) Saurabh Sambhaji Gawade
Age:25
Email:[email protected]
Address:Mirdhe, Tal Phaltan, Dist Satara.
469) Dattatray Vasant Bhoye
Age:27
Email:[email protected]
Address:At Kadvyachimali Post Dehere,
Jawar, Palghar 401603
470) Kiran Gopal Keskar
Age - 28
Email - [email protected]
Address - A/P Birobavasti, Lonand,
Taluka - Khandala, Satara
471) Shreneek Chandrakant Harage
Age - 22
Email - [email protected]
Address - Jangamwadi, Rendal Hatkanangle,
Kolhapur,416203
472) Unmesh Anil Mane
Age - 23
Email - [email protected]
Address - B-601, Sun Orbit, Sun City Road,
Anandnagar, Pune 51
473) Snehal Vijaykumar Daund
Age - 27
Email - [email protected]
Address - Rajarampuri, 13 Lane,
Shanti Apartments, Kolhapur.
474) Dhanashri Dattatray Ghorpade
Age - 25
Email - [email protected]
Address - Nisarale,
Tal - Satara, Dist - Satara
Vina Khadpe
66 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
475) Aaba Tukarama Kale70
Age - 24
Email - [email protected]
Address - A/P Malegaon BK,
Tal - Baramati, Dist - Pune
476) Ajit Digambar Lande
Age - 26, Email - [email protected]
Address - A/p Dhorajalgaon, Shevgaon,
Ahmednagar 414501
477) Sagar Veer
Age - 25
Email - [email protected]
Address - Laxmi ICON, 1001, Sector 44A,
Plot No 69& 70, Seawoods (W), Navi Mumbai
478) Prashant Shankarrao Fating
Age - 25
Email - [email protected]
Address - Tadeshwar Ward, Pauni,
Tal - Pauni, Dist - Bhandara
479) Suraj Manikrao Pawar
Age - 26
Email - [email protected]
Address - 41, Pedgaon, Kalamnuri,
Hingoli 431701
480) Rohit Rajendra Kale
Age - 27,
Email - [email protected]
Address - A/P Knanher, Malshiras,
Dist - Solapur
481) Anjali Ashokrao Somvanshi
Age - 24,
Email - [email protected]
Address - A/P Mohadi, Taluka - Dindori,
Dist - Nashik
482) Kadam Sunil Vikram
Vina Khadpe
67 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Age - 27,
Email - [email protected]
Address - At - Ambesangi,
Post - Sankhed, Loha, Nanded
483) Pratik Chandrakant Junghare
Age - 24,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Plot 43, Ayodhya Nagar,
Behind Dattatray Nagar
Primary School, Nagpur, 440024
484) Saurav Ashok Chavhan
Age -23,
Email [email protected]
Address - Krushna Park, Arni
Dist Yavatmal-445103
485) Pankaj Bhanudas Raut
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Vishwas Nagar, Warora 442907
486) Jayprakash Anil Ade
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
Address - At Banjara Colony, Pusad,
Dist - Yavatmal MH 445204
487) Baswaraj Laxman Birajdar
Age - 27,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Narayan Nagar,
Near Arya Samaj Tample, Latur 413512
488) Ankit Kamlakar Fuldeore
Age - 25,
Email [email protected]
Address - Shivroad, Satana Naka,
Malegaon, Nashik
489) Vikram Arun Godge
Age - 26,
Vina Khadpe
68 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Email - [email protected]
Address - Wasudeo Colony, Arni road,
Yavatmal 44500172
490) Varsha Popat Solunke
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Plot No 37, Gurudatta Colony,
Chalisgaon-424101
491) Shubham Sanjay Songire
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
Address - 1 Anant Apartment, Durga Nagar,
Peth Road, Panchvati, Nashik-422004
492) Jitendra Tulshiram Dhabale
AGE :- 27,
EMAIL :- [email protected]
ADDRESS :- Balaghat Road,
At post Nagra, Gondia
493) Vijay Shivajirao Saware
Age-27,
[email protected]
Address-At Post Chanai, Tal- Ambajogai, Dist Beed
494) Lalit Ravindra Deore
Age-26,
[email protected]
Address-At post Walwadi,
Wadibhokar, Dhule 424002
495) Mangesh Diliprao Galdhar
Age-27,
[email protected]
Address-Laxmi Niwas,
Sant Namdev Nagar, Beed 431122
496) Nikhil Anandrao More
AGE :- 29,
EMAIL :- [email protected]
ADDRESS :- Khanda colony,
Vina Khadpe
69 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
New Panvel 410206
497) Sudhir Tukaram Dhage
Age-26,
[email protected]
Address- Ghanand Tal. Atpadi, Dist Sangli
498) Neha Satejrao Dhok
Age-26,
[email protected]
Address-Mahajani Plot,
Royal Regency, Akola
499) Saurabh Sunil Putange
Age-26,
[email protected]
Address- Plot No. 12, Flat No. 4
Sector C4 Town Centre CIDCO,
Aurangabad, 431003
500) Pushpak Manohar pawar
Age:-28,
Email:[email protected]
Address:-Anand society,
Behind PWD offce, Malegaon camp ,
Malegaon Dist. Nashik
501) Vasudatta Balaji Pame
Age:-26,
Email:[email protected]
R/a. Swami Samarth nagar, MIDC Road,
Matruchaya Niwas, Latur
502) Dishant Rajesh Gaynar
Age:-26,
Email:[email protected]
Address:-Arni Road, Vaibhav Nagar, Yavatmal
503) Pallavi Shamrao Mohture
Age:-27,
Email:[email protected]
Address:-C/o Y.A.Kapgate shivaji ward,
VTC Sakdi, Bhandara
Vina Khadpe
70 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
504) Rahul Shivshankar Ghodekar
Age:-26,
Email:[email protected]
Address:-At Post Jambajar
Tal. Pusad, Dist. Yavatmal-445204
505) Shubhangini Jagmohanlal Madavi
Age:-27,
Address: Bela ,District-Bhandara
506) Sneha Sanjay Parekar
Age:-24,
Email:[email protected]
Address: Pune
507) Mauli Bhise
Age:-26,
Email:[email protected]
Address:-At. Ekurga, Post Jawala(kh),
Kalamb, Osmanabad-413507
508) Gagan Annaji Raut
Age:-28,
Email:[email protected]
R/a. Budhewada Post. Zarpada,
Arjuni/Mor, Gondia-441701
509) Snehal Ramhari Shinde
Age:-24,
Email:[email protected]
R/a. 162 Shree Ram Krishna Niwas,
Shakuntal Nagar, Pandharpur
510) Rohit Ramesh patil
Age:-26,
Email:[email protected]
Address:-Room no. 2, Chawl no.1,
Cout Naka opposite Commissioner Offce,
Thane West-400601
511) Rahul Thombare
Age:-25,
Vina Khadpe
71 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Email:[email protected]
Address:-Navi Mumbai
512) Shashikant Anandrao Uikey
Age-29,
[email protected]
Address-At post Jarawandi Ta. Etapalli,
Dist Gadchiroli
513) Vishal Vishnu Bharsat
Age-27,
Email- [email protected]
Address-At Rampur, Post . Khoste,
Vikramgad, Palghar-401605
514) Omkar Anandrao khamkar
Age-23,
Email- [email protected]
Address- 808/1 , plot no - 225/26,
B ward Katyayani Complex,
Kalamba Road, Kolhapur 416007
515) Krushna Apparao Raut
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Baba Nagar , Shivaji Nagar,
Nanded 431602
516) Vikrant Hansdas Mate
Age-26,
[email protected]
Address- Waghmare lay out persodi,
Umred, Nagpur 441203
517) Parmeshwar khushalrao Hawanna
Age-27,
Email- [email protected]
Add-at Dongargaon Tal. Jalkot
Dis. Latur Pin 413532
518) Sadashiv vyankat Mugale
Age-27,
[email protected]
Vina Khadpe
72 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Address- Laxmi Colony, Latur
519) Sudhir Sahebrao Nande
Age:25,
E-mail:[email protected]
R/At. Vilegaon, Post. Giroli, Tq. Manora,
Dist. Washim, 444403
520) Pranav Rathod
Age-27,
Email - [email protected]
Address- Gawande colony, Nr Civil Court,
Karanja Lad, Dist - Washim
521) Ravindra Suresh Paradhi
Age -27, Email - [email protected]
Add- at post Engaon, Tal Bodwad Dist jalgaon
522) Dhiraj Sanjay patil
Age -28,
Email [email protected]
Address - Sane Guruji Housing Society,
infront of Indira Gandhi school Amalner
Dist - Jalgaon
523) Kartik Shinde
Age - 29,
Email - [email protected]
Address - 16, Suryechchha,
Shivsagar Colony, Chitod Road, Dhule
524) Ajay namdeorao Markad
Age 27,
Email- [email protected]
Address- at post belora, Tal Pusad,
Dist Yavatmal 445215
525) Vishal rajaram sanap
Age-27,
[email protected]
Address- Sonoshi, Sangamner,
Ahmednagar
Vina Khadpe
73 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
526) Vaibhavi Dige
age -26,
email- [email protected]
Address- F5, Meenakshi Apartment,
13th Lane, Rajarampuri
Kolhapur 416008
527) Ruturaj Suresh Nimbalkar
Age -24,
email - [email protected]
Address - A/p -Kolhapur,
Tal - Karveer, Dist-Kolhapur
528) Mayur Dattatray Raut
Age- 24, [email protected]
Address-At Post Alegaon, Tal. Patur, Dist-Akola
529) Pushpraj Ghanshyam Bante
Age-29,
[email protected]
Address-MSEB colony , Bhandara
530) Sanket K Korde
Age-23,
[email protected]
R/a. Ward No.2, House no 116,
Kamptee Road Khairy Akashwani
Nagpur
531) Prathamesh Umesh chavan
Age-23,
[email protected]
Address-Plot no.65, Salokhe Nagar Kalamba Road
Kolhapur 416007
532) Aditya Suresh Kate
Age-27,
[email protected]
Address-At Post Talasari,
Taluka Talasari, Dist Palghar 401601
533) Saurabh Sunil Patange
AGE - 26,
Vina Khadpe
74 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
EMAIL - [email protected]
ADDRESS - Plot no.12, Flat no.4, Sector C-4,
Town centre, CIDCO, Aurangabad, 431003
534) Rahul prakash Dumbare
Age - 26,
email - [email protected]
Address - A/P rajuri , Tal - Junnar,
Dist - pune - 412411
535) Lokhande Kumar Anandrao
Age-25,
[email protected]
Address-Dhumalwadi Taluka,
Baramati, Dis Pune
536) Rohit Rajurwar
Age-26,
[email protected]
Address- A/p-Degloor, T-degloor
Dist- Nanded-431717
537) Akshay Govind Hajare
AGE:27,
EMAIL:[email protected]
Address:Lakshmi colony, Latur
538) Ankita Pundlikrao Agole
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
Address- Dhole colony virul road, Chandur Railway,
Dist Amravati - 444904
539) Mamta Devanand Kadhane
Age- 26 , [email protected]
Address - Kale fle, Nr Hanuman Temple,
Dist Washim-444505
540) Himanshu Suresh Chaudhari
Age- 28, Email - [email protected]
Address - 68, Mangalya , Shivaji Nagar,
WB Road, Deopur, Dhule.
Vina Khadpe
75 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
541) Vishwas Vilas Patil
Age- 33, Email - [email protected]
Address - A/P Kasegaon , Nagobba Galli,
Tal Walwa, Dist Sangli
542) Barge Samir Sitaram
Email id [email protected]
At Post Shingave, Tal. Rahta
Dist Ahmednagar 413708
543) Vishal Prakash Ahire
[email protected]
Address- Anjani Row House Plot No 19,
Tambe Mala Shanti Nagar,
Makhamalabad Road, Nashik.
544) Nanda Kadaji Bhandarkote
Age- 27,
[email protected]
Address- Shanti co-oprative
Housing Society Latur
545) Chevale Suresh Laxman
Age-29,
Email- [email protected]
Address-At. Post Sindhgaon,
Tq, Renapur, Dist. Latur- 413527
546) Rohit Mohan Jagtap
Age-24,
Email- [email protected]
Address- bhairavnath Chowk yewalewadi,
Walwa, Sangli..
547) Mayur Mohan Bhangarath
Age -25,
Email - [email protected]
Address- Talawali Baragaon, Post-Tokkawade,
Tal-murbad, Thane.
548) Prachi Bharat Mache80
Age- 26,
Email - [email protected]
Address- At Post Tisgaon, Taluka Pathardi,
Vina Khadpe
76 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Ahamadnagar
549) Ravindra suresh paradhi
age- 27,
Email- [email protected]
Address- at Post-Engaon,
Tal Bodwaad, Dist-Jalgaon
550) Trupti Ashok Banthanal
Age: 23
Email:[email protected]
Address - Vidyanagar, Karad.
551) Amit Devrao Borkar
Age-24,
Mail Id- [email protected]
Address- Patel Chowk ward no.2, Armori
552) Bharati Changhode
Age: 27,
Email: [email protected]
Address: Valmik Nagar Banosa Daryapur,
Amravati 444803
553) Ketan Rajendra Sawant
Age: 27, Email: [email protected]
Address:26 Anand Nagar Dhule,
Aadhar No: 6481 1022 8698
554) Gavali Shubham Sunil
Age-26,
Email-: [email protected]
Address:- A/P Antapur Tal.Baglan
Dist.Nashik
555) Swapnil Tukaram Jadhav
Age :- 29,
Email :- [email protected]
Address :- Gautam Nagar Aarey Colony Road
Powai Mumbai 400087
556) Kamble Shashikant Gopal
Age: 30,
Vina Khadpe
77 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Email: [email protected]
Address: At Post: Dhalegaon, Ta: Ahemdpur,
Dist: Latur 413523
557) Arpit Pramodrao Deshmukh
Age: 29, Email: [email protected]
Indira Nagar, Chandur Railway, Chandur Railway,
Amravati - 444904
558) Sushil Rameshwar Siraskar
Age-26,
E-mail - [email protected]
Address Goyanka layout,
Near jawahar nagar, Akola 444001
559) Akshay Gajanan Patil
Age: 26,
Email: [email protected]
Address: Tara Niwas, At post Sasunavghar,
behind Royal Garden Resort,
Taluka Vasai, District Thane
560) Sandip Shivaji Kumbhar
Age : 29,
Email: [email protected]
Address: A/P - Shamgaon, Tal - Karad,
Dist - Satara, PIN: 415106
561) Shivani Shankar longadge
Age:25, Email- [email protected]
Address:Svyam Kushal Apartment,
Ganesh nagar, Tukum, Chandrapur
562) Deore Aniket Jagannath
Age- 25,
Email- [email protected]
Address - Swami Niwas, Sonar galli,
Umrane Tal. Deola Dist. Nashik
563) Ashvini Vijay Ohal
Age -27,
Email - [email protected]
Address - S.No. 10/14, M1/3, Golf Club Road,
Vina Khadpe
78 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Near Narayan Sweet Home,
Yerwada, Pune- 411006
564) Shraddha Dinesh Agrawal
Age- 25,
Email- [email protected]
'Shriniwas', near Jain mandir,
Subhash road, Parbhani, 431401
565) Sairaj Sadanand Hingmire
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
Address - A/P Islampur , Tal. - Walwa
Dis. - Sangli
566) Abhijeet Satish Sakunde
Age- 23
E-mail - [email protected],
Address- 7/A Keserkar Peth, Satara - 415001
567) Bhavana Bhikkan Bhadane
Age:27,
Email: [email protected]
Address: Meera Nagar, Acharya Donde Society,
Shahada-425409
568) Shubham Nimbokar
Age : 25,
Email : [email protected]
Address : Tower Line ,
Kathora Road , Amravati
569) Shrikant Dipakrao Mahindre
Age:- 24,
Email:- [email protected]
Address:- Ravi Nagar, Near Changani Nagar,
Amravati
570) Swapnil Prakash Kutwal
Age - 28,
Email Id - [email protected]
A/p warwand (Near victoria dam),
Daund, Pune - 412215
Vina Khadpe
79 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
571) Anjali Ashok Batale
Age:- 23,
Email :- [email protected]
Address:- 12, Amrapali Society, Shegli solapur
572) Kalyani Prashant patil
26 age,
Email - [email protected]
Address: 24 a, Janaki Nagar, Sakri
573) Amar anandrao Mane
Age -23,
Address - A/p Rajache Kurle,
Tak - Khatav, Satara
574) Vaishnavi Bhimraj Dane
Age:24,
Email ID:[email protected]
Address: RH NO.48 Kasliwal Bhagyodai
Near Shivajinagar Railway Crossing, Aurangabad.
575) Vijay Bhagawat Masal
Age 25,
Email- [email protected]
Address: A/P Marawade
Tal.- Mangalvedha, Dist. Solapur
576) Shivprasad Govindrao Survase
Age:25,
Email: [email protected]
Address: At post Madansuri
Tq Nilanga Dist Latur 413512
577) Mitesh Mahendra Gawali84
Age : 27,
Email: [email protected]
Adddress: 405 Mangalwar Peth, Satara
578) Manoj Bhikkan Bhadane
Age:29,
Email: [email protected]
Address: Meera Nagar, Acharya Donde Society,
Vina Khadpe
80 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Shahada-425409
579) Ajinkya sunil sonje
Age 27,
Email id :[email protected],
Address- Guru Kripa Bhide Bag Deopur,
Dhule 424002
580) Srushti Sanjay Shirsath
Email [email protected]
Address-Deola Tal-Deola, District -Nashik
581) Tejas laxman Thombare
Age 25
Email address - [email protected]
address - at Post Kawadewadi,
Tal Koregao, Dist Satara
582) Saurabh Sahadev Patil
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
Address - Indiranagar, Nasik-422009
583) Omkar Tulshidas Gondarkar
Age 24,
Mail id [email protected]
Address- Mayurban Society,
Ambejogai Road, Latur
584) Kawtikwar Akshay Satishrao
age-25,
Email - [email protected]
Address- Cidco new nanded
585) Pravin Nadekar
Age:25,
Email- [email protected],
Add: A/P Rajur,Tal.Akole,
Dist.Ahmednagar 422604
586) Bhavana Vilas Chavan
Age: 26,
Email: [email protected]
Vina Khadpe
81 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Gulabchand Nagar
Karhale layout Ward no 1
Buldana 443001
587) Narwade Kishor Balasaheb
Age: 26,
Email: [email protected]
Add: At Post - Pimpri shi, Tal - Kallam,
Dist-Osmanabad 413510
588) Shubham Panjabrao Wankhade
Age - 26,
Email - [email protected]
Nityanand colony , Sai nagar, Akoli road,
Amravati 444607
589) Shraddha Ahirrao
Age -25,
Email- [email protected]
Address- Karve Nagar Pune
590) Aniket Ramling Bhosale
Age: 26,
Email ID : [email protected]
Address : Uruli Kanchan,
Tal- Haveli, Dist- Pune 412202
591) Pradip Shivaji Shevale
Age- 28,
Email- [email protected]
Address- Plot No 101,Sr N 68 A1,
Vinayak Residency, Behind Sunny Hotel,
Surya Nagar, Ahmednagar
592) Ashwini Ashok salbarde
Age : 24,
Email: [email protected]
Address: Ward No 10, Near Vitthal Mandir,
Narkhed, Nagpur
593) Narale Kiran Kuber
Age:-26
Email:[email protected]
Vina Khadpe
82 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
A/P-Paryanti, Tal-Man, Dist-Satara
594) Ghule Sujit Malhari
Age-25, Email- [email protected]
Address - Akluj, Tal-Malshiras, Dist-Solapur
595) Swapnil Madan Pandit
Age-29,
Email-swapnilpandit143@gmail. Com
Address-Gove Galli, Mangalwedha,
Solapur 413305
596) Rohan shivaji divate
Age - 28,
Mail- [email protected]
Near Nana Patil Putla Swagat offset Vita,
Tal-Khanapur, Dist - Sangli
597) Abhay Dagdu Holkar
Age - 25,
Email- [email protected]
Latur Kalamb Rastyacya Bajus,
Harangul Kh. - 413531
598) Mrunal Krishnakumar Bramhankar
Age:- 28,
Email:- [email protected]
Rajgopalachari Ward in front of Nimje Hospital
Bhandara 441904
599) Shubham Bharat Shindepatil87
Age-26,
Email- [email protected]
Address- Rajsinhnagar 3 , AKLUJ,
Dist. Solapur 413101
600) Bhusnikar vaibhav vijaykumar
Age : 29,
Email id : [email protected]
Address : Shiv Parvati Niwas,
at Post Murud Akola, Latur 413511.
601) Mayur Ramesh Gholap
Vina Khadpe
83 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
Age-27,
Mail id- [email protected]
Address- Veer Hanuman Nagar,
Ambajogai Road, Latur
602) Pravin Sambhaji lande
Age - 27
Email - [email protected]
A/p-Dhorjalgaon She, Tal-Shevgaon
Dist-Ahmednagar -414501
603) Saurabh Gorakh Takmoge
Age - 25,
Email - [email protected]
Address- at Post Kavhe,
Tal- Madha, Dist Solapur
604) Nikhil Anil Shrawankar
Age -27,
Email - [email protected]
Address- Plot no 14, Rajani Nagar,
Khat Road,
Khokarla, Bhandara - 441904
605) Shivaji Madhav Bhende
Age -28,
Email - [email protected]
Address - at Post Jamb bk, TQ Mukhed,
Dist. Nanded
606) Sandeep Anandrao Pingalwad
age 25,
Email : [email protected],88
Bhokar, Tq Bhokar,
Dist.Nanded 431801
607) Sandesh Satish Barbole
Age 25,
Email [email protected]
Address-Jaisinh Grihssankul Sangramnagar,
Near school, Akluj, Tal. Malshiras
Dist- Solapur 413101
Vina Khadpe
84 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
608) Sonawane Bhagwat parasaram
Age:-29,
Email:[email protected]
Address:-At Sheri Bk, Tal. Ashti, Dist. Beed
609) Rankhamb Shubham Gorakh
Age- 26,
Email- [email protected]
Address- Shivneri Nagar bypass
Osmanabad 413501
610) Patil Vaibhav Balasaheb
Age : 24,
Email: [email protected]
Address: Raghukul Niwas,
Khopegao Road, Pragati Nagar, Latur ... Petitioners
Versus
1) The State of Maharashtra
Water Resource Department
Through its Principal Secretary,
Mantralaya, Madam Cama Road,
Mumbai 400 001
2) Public Works Department
Through its Principal Secretary,
Mantralaya, Madam Cama Road,
Mumbai 400 001 ... Respondents
Ms. Neeta Karnik a/w Mr. Sangharsh Waghmare for the
Petitioners.
Mr. Ram S. Apte, Senior Advocate a/w Mr. Harshal P. Nahata i/
b. Mr. P.P. Kakade, Govt. Pleader, Mr. B. V. Sawant, AGP for the
Respondent No.1- State.
Vina Khadpe
85 / 105
(38) WP.8568.2022.doc
CORAM : S.V. GANGAPURWALA, ACJ. &
SANDEEP V. MARNE, J.
RESERVED ON : 16 JANUARY, 2023
PRONOUNCED ON : 30 JANUARY, 2023
JUDGMENT ( Per SANDEEP V. MARNE, J.) :
1. By this Petition, Petitioners assail the judgment and order dated 5th July, 2022 passed by the Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal, Mumbai (Tribunal), thereby rejecting Petitioners' Original Application No.750 of 2021. They had challenged advertisement dated July 22, 2019 issued by Respondent No.1 for flling up posts of Junior Engineer (Civil) Group-B (Non-Gazetted) in Water Resources Department to the extent it sought to exclude degree holders from participating in the selection process.
2. Facts of the case, briefy stated, are that an advertisement came to be issued by the Water Resources for flling up posts of Junior Engineer (Civil) Group-B (Non- Gazetted) prescribing the eligibility criteria of 'Diploma in Civil Engineering or Part-time or Distance Education equivalent to a three year diploma in Civil Engineering recognized by the Vina Khadpe 86 / 105 (38) WP.8568.2022.doc Maharashtra State Board of Technical Education, Mumbai.'
3. Petitioners, who hold degree in Civil Engineering, felt aggrieved by the eligibility criteria prescribed in the advertisement which apparently sought to exclude them. Therefore, Original Application No.750 of 2021 came to be instituted by them before the Tribunal challenging advertisement dated July 22, 2019. Reliance was placed before the Tribunal on Recruitment Rules being 'Junior Engineer (Civil) Group-B (Non-Gazetted) in the Public Works Department and the Irrigation Department, Recruitment Rules, 1998' (Recruitment Rules, 1998), prescribing the qualifcation of '3 years diploma in Civil Engineering recognised by Government or any other qualifcation recognised as equivalent thereto.' It was contended that the qualifcation of degree in Civil Engineering is covered by the expression 'any other qualifcation recognised as equivalent thereto'. Reliance was also placed on Recruitment Rules notifed on April 25, 2018 for post of Sectional Engineer (Civil) Group-B, wherein the Junior Engineers recruited with qualifcation of degree in Civil Engineering are included in feeder cadre. Reliance was also placed before the Tribunal on Vina Khadpe 87 / 105 (38) WP.8568.2022.doc the judgment of Apex Court in Puneet Shama & Ors. Versus Himachal Pradesh State Electricity Board Ltd & anr 1. The Tribunal proceeded to dismiss Original Application by its judgment and order dated July 5, 2022. Aggrieved by the judgment and order passed by the Tribunal, Petitioners have fled the present Petition. When the present Petition came up for hearing on July 25, 2022, an objection was raised on behalf of the State Government about delay in approaching the Tribunal on the part of Petitioners. This Court, by its order dated 25th July 2022, recorded that the Tribunal had already condoned the delay vide its order dated 30th November, 2021, which order was not challenged by the State Government. When this Petition once again appeared before this Court on 28th July, 2022, this Court granted liberty to the Respondents to hold the examination on the scheduled dates but restrained them from declaring the results without obtaining leave of this Court.
4. Appearing for Petitioners, Ms. Karnik, the learned counsel would submit that the Tribunal has not considered the submissions advanced before it in right earnest and has 1 2021 SCC Online SC 291 Vina Khadpe 88 / 105 (38) WP.8568.2022.doc ignored that the degree holders are also deemed to be included in the eligibility criteria for appointment to the post of Junior Engineer. She would place reliance on the Recruitment Rules for post of Sectional Engineer which were earlier notifed on June 16, 1997 and came to be amended on April 25, 2018. She would submit under 2018 Amended Rules, Junior Engineers recruited with qualifcation of degree are considered eligible for promotion to the post of Sectional Engineer. She would submit that based on provisions of Recruitment Rules for promotional post of Sectional Engineer, it is required to be inferred that degree holders are also eligible for being appointed as Junior Engineer. In this regard, she places reliance on judgment of Apex Court in the case of Puneet Shama (supra) by contending that in the identical circumstances, the Apex Court accepted the qualifcation of degree for recruitment on the post of Junior Engineer. Ms. Karnik would also place reliance on Government Resolution dated September 9, 2021 prescribing the Model Recruitment Rules providing that candidates holding higher qualifcation than minimum educational qualifcation are also required to considered eligible. She would rely upon Government Resolution dated April 16, 1984 by which gazetted status came Vina Khadpe 89 / 105 (38) WP.8568.2022.doc to be conferred on graduate and other Junior Engineers. Relying on the said Government Resolution, she would contend that Junior Engineer's recruitment with qualifcation of degree in Civil engineering is once again presumed while issuing the said Government Resolution. Ms. Karnik would also rely upon the Corrigendum dated December 2, 2017, providing that in the event of candidates securing same marks, priority is required to be accorded to the ones possessing higher qualifcation. Ms. Karnik would contend that now the post of Civil Engineering Assistant, which is lower post than the Junior Engineer, can be flled up by appointing the degree holders and that therefore, it would be highly illogical if degree holders are excluded from the selection for the recruitment on the post of Junior Engineer.
5. Per contra, Mr. Apte, the learned senior advocate appearing for the State Government would oppose the Petition and support the order passed by the Tribunal. He would submit that the provisions of Recruitment Rules are required to be scrupulously observed and that this Court in its power of judicial review would be loath in reading the same otherwise. Inviting our attention to the Recruitment Rules 1998, Mr. Apte Vina Khadpe 90 / 105 (38) WP.8568.2022.doc would contend that the Rules clearly permit only diploma holders to participate in the selection for direct recruitment for the post of Junior Engineer. He would submit that the words 'degree in Civil Engineering' are absent in Recruitment Rules and this Court cannot read the same into the Rules. So as far as the Recruitment Rules for the promotional post of Sectional Engineer are concerned, Mr. Apte would offer an justifcation for including the degree holders recruited as Civil Engineer in feeder cadre for Sectional Engineer by submitting that there used to be recruitment of degree holders as Junior Engineer in the past. He would invite our attention to the provisions of Government Resolution dated December, 19, 1970 laying down rules for appointment of Maharashtra Engineering Services Group-I and II. Inviting out attention to paragraph 9 of the Government Resolution, Mr. Apte would contend that the degree holders could be appointed in the Engineering services and in order to cover such Junior Engineers recruited with qualifcation of degree in Civil Engineering, clause (a) has been included in the recruitment Rules for the post of Sectional Engineer. Mr. Apte would rely upon the judgment of this Court in Sangram Ramdas Gholve Vina Khadpe 91 / 105 (38) WP.8568.2022.doc and ors. versus State of Maharashtra 2 in which this Court upheld the action of the State Government in excluding the degree holders from participating in selection process in respect of 75% posts reserved for diploma holders. Mr. Apte would submit that the judgment in Sangram Ramdas Gholve (supra) has been upheld by the Apex Court by dismissing the Special Leave Petition on 2nd September, 2016. Inviting our attention to Government Resolution dated April 16, 1984, Mr. Apte would contend that the degree holder Junior Engineers are already treated as Gazetted Offcers and the Government Resolution conferred similar benefts to diploma holders on completion of prescribed period of service. In support of his contention, Mr. Apte would rely upon the following judgment;
1. Nair Service Society versus D. T.Beermasthan and ors 3
2. Zahoor Ahmed and ors versus Sheikh Imteyaz Ahmad and ors. 4
3. Qazi Gousia Jeelani versus Mehraj Ud Din Najar and ors. 5
6. Rival contentions of the parties now fall for our consideration.
2 (2016) 5 AIR Bom R 783 3 (2009) 5 SCC 545 4 (2019)2 SCC 404 5 2022 SCC Online J&K 542 Vina Khadpe 92 / 105 (38) WP.8568.2022.doc
7. The post of Junior Engineer (Civil) is to be fled in accordance with provisions of the Junior Engineer (Civil), Group 'B' Non-Gazetted in the Public Works Department and Irrigation Department (Recruitment) Rules, 1998 dated January 1, 1998, Rule 3 of which provides thus:
3. Appointment to the post of Junior Engineer (Civil), Group'B' non-gazetted in the Public Works Department and the Irrigation Department shall be made either -
(a) by promotion of a suitable person on the basis of seniority subject to ftness from amongst the persons holding the post of civil Engineering Assistant who have passed the qualifying examination for the post of Junior Engineer conducted by the Engineering staff College, Nashik having not less than three years regular service in that post; or
(b) by nomination from amongst candidate who -
(i) Are not more than 30 years of age;
(ii) Possess a three years diploma in Civil Engineering recognised by Government or any other qualifcation recognised as equivalent thereto .
8. Perusal of the above 1998 Recruitment Rules would indicate that holders of degree in Civil Engineering are not made eligible for appointment on post of Junior Engineer (Civil). However, the Rules includes the words 'or any other qualifcation recognised as equivalent thereto'. It has been the case of Petitioners that the degree in Civil Engineering is required to be included in the above expression used in the Vina Khadpe 93 / 105 (38) WP.8568.2022.doc Recruitment Rules, 1998. The advertisement prescribed following qualifcation;
"6. Educational Eligibility : The educational qualifcation of the candidate mentioned below must be held in full on the date of publication of the advertisement.
6.1 Passed the Secondary School Examination and 6.2 As per the Junior Engineer (Civil) Group-B (Non-Gazetted) Posts (Amended) Recruitment Rules, 1998 of the Public Works Department and Irrigation Department, government approved Three years' Diploma in Civil Engineering or "Part- time" or "Distance Education" equivalent to a three year diploma in Civil Engineering recognized by the Maharashtra State Board of Technical Education, Mumbai.
Equivalent Qualifcation" of Diploma from a recognized University / Maharashtra State Directorate of Technical Education as follows (Duration 3 years) Diploma in Civil and Rural Engineering Diploma in Civil and Rural Construction Diploma in Transportation Diploma in Construction Technology"
The advertisement thus specifed what the equivalent qualifcation would mean. The advertisement has not stipulated degree in Civil Engineering either as main qualifcation or as an equivalent qualifcation.
9. Faced with the above situation, Petitioners have relied upon the provisions of the Recruitment Rules for the post of Sectional Engineer notifed on April 25, 2018, Rule 4 of which reads thus;
"4. For rule 3 of the Principal Rules, the following rule shall be Vina Khadpe 94 / 105 (38) WP.8568.2022.doc substituted, namely-
3. Appointment to the post of Sectional Engineer (Civil), Group-B, (Gazette), in the Maharashtra Services of Engineers shall be made on the basis of seniority subject to ftness, from amongst the persons holding the post of Junior Engineer who,-
(a) Possess a degree of statutory University or of recognized institute, in Civil Engineering or any other qualifcation declared by the Government to be equivalent thereto and joined in this cadre willingly, and have put in not less than fve years regular service as a Junior Engineer on regular establishment in the Department; or
(b) Possess a three years Diploma of Statutory University or awarded by the State Technical Education Board in Civil Engineering or any other qualifcation declared by the Government to be equivalent thereto ; and have put not less than fve years regular service as Junior Engineer on regular establishment in the Department; or
(c) Possess an Upper Subordinate Certifcate awarded by the Osmania University, or any other qualifcation declared by the Government to be equivalent thereto, and have put in not less than seven years regular service as Junior Engineer on regular establishment in the Department; or
(d) Does not possess any of the qualifcation mentioned in clause (a), (b) and (c) above but have put in not less than ten years regular service as a Junior Engineer on regular establishment in the Department:
Provided that, Junior Engineer possessing the qualifcation and experience in clause (a), (b), (c) and (d) above should have passed the Professional Examination specifed in Appendix - I of the Maharashtra Public Works Manual for the post of Junior Engineer, before appointing to the post of Sectional Engineer (Civil), Grade-B"
(emphasis supplied) Relying on Rule 3, it is contended that a person recruited as Junior Engineer with qualifcation of degree and not less than 5 years of service as Junior Engineer is eligible to be promoted as Sectional Engineer. On the basis of Clause 3(a), an inference is sought to be drawn by Petitioners that Junior Engineer can Vina Khadpe 95 / 105 (38) WP.8568.2022.doc be recruited with qualifcation of degree in Civil Engineering.
When it was put across to Ms. Karnik that clause 3(a) might cover Junior Engineers initially recruited with qualifcation with diploma but who have acquired degrees during their service, she would counter said suggestion by submitting that such persons would be covered by clause 3(b). It is therefore submitted that if a person holding degree in Civil Engineering is held ineligible to be recruited as Junior Engineer, the provisions of clause 3(a) of Sectional Engineer recruitment Rules would be rendered redundant.
10. This is how an inference is sought to be drawn about the entitlement of degree holders to get recruited as Junior Engineer by relying on provisions of recruitment Rules of promotional post of Sectional Engineer. It is submitted that the same can be done on the basis of judgment of Apex Court in Puneet Shama (supra). It is contended that in Puneet Shama (supra), the Supreme Court relied upon the qualifcation of higher post of Assistant Engineer which included degree holder Junior Engineer in feeder cadre and on that basis, the Apex Court held that the degree holders to be eligible for recruitment as Junior Engineer. However, close scrutiny of Vina Khadpe 96 / 105 (38) WP.8568.2022.doc Puneet Shama (supra) would indicate that the same has no application to the facts of the present case. In Puneet Shama (supra), the Recruitment Rules for promotion to the post of Assistant Engineer inter alia included the following feeder cadres:
(iii) from amongst those persons who pass/acquire the qualifcation of AMIE (Section A & B) or who acquire Full time / Regular Degree in Electrical Engineering / Electrical & Electronic Engineering / Computer Science Engineering. Electronics & Communication Engineering & Information Technology in service after confrmation to service = 5%
(iv) Drawing Staff:
Circle Head Draftsman possessing Diploma in Elect. Engineering or Diploma Certifcate of Draftsmanship from a recognized Institute having 5 years' service in the grade falling which 10 years' service as Draftsman /Head Draughtsman / Circle Head Draughtsman and failing both total 15 years services in the Draft cadre. = 4%
(v) Before joining the services as JE who possess Regular / Full time degree in Electrical Engineering / Electrical & Electronic Engineering / Computer Science Engineering. Electronics & Communication Engineering & Information Technology from a recognized university approved by the AICTE. Ex-servicemen who have the relevant qualifcation equivalence to a recognised Degree in Electrical Engineering or Electrical & Electronic Engineering Stream / discipline recognized by the Govt. of India or person who posses AMIE qualifcation in above stream / discipline from Institute or Engineers (India Calcutta) after confrmation to service . =5%.
11. Thus, in Puneet Shama (supra), 5% vacancies were reserved for those diploma holders who acquired degree qualifcation during the service as Junior Engineer and 5% additional vacancies were reserved for those who hold degrees before joining as Junior Engineer. Thus, express provision in Vina Khadpe 97 / 105 (38) WP.8568.2022.doc the Recruitment Rules for promotional post of Assistant Engineer for consideration of Junior Engineer recruited with qualifcation of degree indicated that Junior Engineers could be recruited as Junior Engineers. In the present case, there is no such express provision. In absence of an express provision, what is sought to be drawn is a mere inference.
12. It is well settled law that the judgments are rendered in the light of facts and law involved in each particular case. With slight difference in facts and law, the judgment would become inapplicable. There is clear distinction between the provisions of Recruitment Rules of promotional post of Assistant Engineer in Puneet Shama (supra) and promotional post of Sectional Engineer in the present case. Therefore, the judgment in Puneet Sharma (supra) would not apply to the present case. In this connection, Mr. Apte has rightly relied upon the judgment in Nair Service Society (supra) in which it is held in paragraphs 48 and 56 as under;
48. Several decisions have been cited before us by the respondents, but it is well established that judgments in service jurisprudence should be understood with reference to the particular service rules in the State governing that feld. Reservation provisions are enabling provisions, and different State Government can have different methods of reservation. There is no challenge to the Rues, and what is challenged is in the matter of application alone. In our opinion the communal rotation has to be applied taking 20 vacancies as a Vina Khadpe 98 / 105 (38) WP.8568.2022.doc block.
56. Different State Governments in the country may have different methods for providing reservations, and these will be valid as long as the method adopted by a particular State Government does not violate any constitutional provision or statute. It is not for this Court to decide on the wisdom or otherwise of the said method of reservation. This Court should exercise judicial restraint and not interfere with the same unless there is some clear illegality. In our opinion the method prescribed by the Rules made by the State Government suffers from no infrmity or illegality, and hence the High Court acted wrongly in allowing the writ petition.
13. The judgment in Puneet Shama (supra) has also been considered by the Apex Court in its judgment in Qazi Gousia Jeelani (supra) in which it is held in paragraphs 19, 20 21, 22 as under;
19. Similar argument based on the judgment of Puneet Sharma's case (supra) as is raised before us by Mr. Jan, learned Senior Counsel was also dealt with in para (19) of the judgment (supra) which reads thus:
"19. A careful analysis of the facts in Puneet Sharma's case (supra) reveals that though as per original rules, the prescribed qualifcation was diploma in the relevant discipline, yet a clarifcation was issued later on declaring that the candidates with higher qualifcation are also entitled to apply or be considered for appointment. Besides this, as per the rules relevant to the said case, 5% of sub-quota was earmarked for those who held degrees before joining as Junior Engineers. It was in these circumstances that the Supreme Court held that rule making authority had in mind that degree holders too could compete for the posts of Junior Engineers. In the instant case neither there is any specifc rule which makes the degree holders eligible nor is there any clarifcation issued by the Government in this regard.
Further there is no such material on record from which it can be inferred that degree holders are eligible for the advertised posts. Therefore, the ratio laid down by the Supreme Court in Puneet Sharma's case (supra) does not apply to the facts of the instant case".
20. We entirely agree with the view taken by the Division Bench in Vina Khadpe 99 / 105 (38) WP.8568.2022.doc Aijaz Ahmad Ahanger's case (supra). It needs to be noticed that in the said case, Jammu and Kashmir Para-Medical Council had issued clarifcation to the extent that the Degree in the relevant discipline could be considered for the post for which prescribed qualifcation was Diploma on the ground that Degree was a higher qualifcation in the relevant discipline. The Board had not agreed with the said clarifcation and went ahead with the selection process ignoring the candidates possessing Degree in the relevant fled. The Division Bench, as noted above, approved the decision of the Board.
21. Without dilating much on the issue, suffce it to say that it is trite law that, a person, to be eligible for a post, must possess the qualifcation prescribed for the post and it is not within the province of the Courts of law to read the higher qualifcation into the qualifcation prescribed in the rules or the advertisement as essential qualifcation.
22. In the instant case, the qualifcation prescribed in the Advertisement Notice for the post of Workshop Assistant is not the minimum qualifcation, but is essential qualifcation. That means a person, seeking to be appointed as Workshop Assistant must essentially possess the qualifcation prescribed. Indisputably, the appellant does not possess that qualifcation. The writ Court was, thus, absolutely correct in holding the appellant ineligible for the post in question and consequently, quashing his selection and appointment. The view taken by the Writ Court is, thus, unexceptionable and cannot be interfered with.
14. Now, let us proceed to examine whether even an inference can be drawn to the effect that Junior Engineers can be recruited from amongst degree holders. As observed above, such an inference is sought to be drawn on the basis of Rule 3(a) of Recruitment Rules of Sectional Engineers. However, Mr. Apte has successfully demonstrated that there was a Vina Khadpe 100 / 105 (38) WP.8568.2022.doc provision in the past for recruitment of degree holders as Junior Engineer. Firstly, Government Resolution dated December 19, 1970, seems to indicate that individuals holding degree in Civil Engineering could be recruited in Maharashtra Engineering Services. Secondly, Government Resolution dated April 16, 1984 would again indicate that the State Government used to recruit candidates with degree in Civil Engineering as Junior Engineers in the past. The Government Resolution indicates that a decision was taken in the year 1981 to confer the status of Gazetted offcer on Junior Engineer holding degree in Civil Engineering. On account of demands made by non-degree holders, Government Resolution dated April 16, 1984 was issued conferring Gazetted status on 3 years diploma holders on completion of 5 years of service, 2 years of degree holders on completion of 7 years of service and non-holder of diplomas after completion of 10 years of service. Thus, while degree holder Junior Engineer were treated as Gazetted Offcers from the dates of their appointments, the diploma holders and non-diploma holders were conferred such status in a staggered manner on completion of requisite years of service. Thus Government Resolution dated April 16, 1984, is yet another provision demonstrating that the State Government Vina Khadpe 101 / 105 (38) WP.8568.2022.doc used to recruit the degree holders as Junior Engineer in the past.
15. Thus, it can not be contended that the provisions of Rule 3(a) of the Recruitment Rules of Sectional Engineer would be rendered redundant if degree holders are held ineligible for being appointed as Junior Engineer. In fact, Rule 3(a) is included to cover cases of such Junior Engineers who were recruited in the past with qualifcation of degree in Civil Engineering. Therefore, reliance of Ms. Karnik on the Recruitment Rules of Sectional Engineers as well as on judgment of Apex Court in Puneet Sharma (supra) is misplaced and no inference can be drawn to the effect that the degree holders can be included in the eligibility criteria for direct recruitment on the post of Junior Engineer.
16. In this regard, reliance of Mr. Apte on judgment in Sangram Ramdas Gholve (supra) is apposite. In that case, this Court was concerned with the issue of reserving 75% post of Junior Engineer for diploma holders only. This Court was pleased to uphold the Recruitment Rules making degree holders ineligible for appointment against such 75% post of Vina Khadpe 102 / 105 (38) WP.8568.2022.doc Junior Engineer. The Special Leave Petition fled challenging the judgment of this Court has been dismissed by the Supreme Court vide its Order dated September 2, 2016. Though, the issue involved in the present case is not about challenge to the Recruitment Rules, the principles enunciated by this Court in Sangram Ramdas Gholve (supra) about excluding degree holders for appointment of post of Junior Engineers are fully attracted in the present case.
17. Before the Tribunal, Petitioners did not challenge the provisions of Recruitment Rules 1998 for Junior Engineers which excluded degree holders from eligibility criteria. As reiterated in catena of judgments, this Court would not be in a position to read something which is missing in the Recruitment Rules. Merely because degree in Civil Engineering might a higher qualifcation than a diploma, this Court would not be in a position to interpret the provisions of Recruitment Rules and direct the State Government to consider candidates who are not eligible as per the Recruitment Rules. In this connection, the reliance of Mr. Apte on judgment of Apex Court in Zahoor Ahmed and ors (supra) is apt, in which it is held in paragraphs 26, 27, 28 as under;
Vina Khadpe 103 / 105 (38) WP.8568.2022.doc
26. We are in respectful agreement with the interpretation which has been placed on the judgment in Jyoti KK in the subsequent decision in Anita (supra). The decision in Jyoti KK turned on the provisions of Rule 10(a)(ii). Absent such a rule, it would not be permissible to draw an inference that a higher qualifcation necessarily pre-supposes the acquisition of another, albeit lower, qualifcation. The prescription of qualifcations for a post is a matter of recruitment policy. The state as the employer is entitled to prescribe the qualifcations as a condition of eligibility. It is no part of the role or function of judicial review to expand upon the ambit of the prescribed qualifcations. Similarly, equivalence of a qualifcation is not a matter which can be determined in exercise of the power of judicial review. Whether a particular qualifcation should or should not be regarded as equivalent is a matter for the state, as the recruiting authority, to determine. The decision in Jyoti KK turned on a specifc statutory rule under which the holding of a higher qualifcation could presuppose the acquisition of a lower qualifcation. The absence of such a rule in the present case makes a crucial difference to the ultimate outcome. In this view of the matter, the Division Bench of the High Court was justifed in reversing the judgment of the learned Single Judge and in coming to the conclusion that the appellants did not meet the prescribed qualifcations. We fnd no error in the decision of the Division Bench.
27. While prescribing the qualifcations for a post, the State, as employer, may legitimately bear in mind several features including the nature of the job, the aptitudes requisite for the effcient discharge of duties, the functionality of a qualifcation and the content of the course of studies which leads up to the acquisition of a qualifcation. The state is entrusted with the authority to assess the needs of its public services. Exigencies of administration, it is trite law, fall within the domain of administrative decision making. The state as a public employer may well take into account social perspectives that require the creation of job opportunities across the societal structure. All these are essentially matters of policy. Judicial review must tread warily. That is why the decision in Jyoti KK must be understood in the context of a specifc statutory rule under which the holding of a higher qualifcation which presupposes the acquisition of a lower qualifcation was considered to be suffcient for the post. It was in the context of specifc rule that the decision in Jyoti KK turned.
28. Ms Wadia sought to draw sustenance from the fact that the holder of an ITI certifcation can obtain lateral entry to the diploma course. The point of the matter, however, is that none of Vina Khadpe 104 / 105 (38) WP.8568.2022.doc the appellants ft the description of candidates who had secured an ITI certifcation before seeking a lateral entry to a diploma course. Plainly, when an ITI with matric is required, a person who does not hold that qualifcation is not eligible.
(emphasis supplied)
18. Thus in Zahoor Ahmed and ors (supra), the Apex Court rejected contention that Diploma is higher qualifcation than the required qualifcation of ITI. We are therefore unable to hold that degree in civil engineering is a higher qualifcation than diploma in the context of requirement under the recruitment rules. Reliance of Ms. Karnik on GR dated December 2, 2017 would be therefore of little assistance. Government Resolution dated September 9, 2021 merely prescribes the Model Recruitment Rules, which will have no application in the light of existence of statutory recruitment rules.
19. In the result, we do not fnd any error being committed by the Tribunal in dismissing Original Application fled by Petitioners. The Petition is devoid of merits. It is dismissed without any order as to costs.
(SANDEEP V. MARNE, J.) (ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE) Vina Khadpe 105 / 105 (38) WP.8568.2022.doc
20. At this stage, Ms. Karnik the learned counsel for Petitioners seeks continuation of interim order. Mr. Apte, the learned counsel for Respondents opposes the said request.
21. Considering the fact that the interim order was in operation, the same is continued for a period of two weeks from today.
22. Needless to state that on lapse of two weeks, the interim relief granted shall come to an end.
(SANDEEP V. MARNE, J.) (ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE)