Gujarat High Court
CRIMINAL APPEAL/864/1999 on 9 March, 2010
Author: S.R.Brahmbhatt
Bench: S.R.Brahmbhatt
Gujarat High Court Case Information System Print PK �����?Fi?H?g^<"?,{,?? ??P4??P???,"a?1>?-?0??si:@??`?|"1 ??E??V ?0?m H??}?'k??�xc&?g??d2?&v"i??u????? ?? 4?#W>??px?\ ? ??=? D9\?f?3? ?x-f%0 ?Q???S? /9\? ?N#3?|?
1_ ?Db?j???j????0?s5?
?ovk >Z?\ d??8??#OEf ck??7? ?u?r? ??? qo??? /s" ???A?L`. lE?�KO?3a?????z?d???t?p??B?p?>% ?y O? ?
? N ?q�>Q?a~ T??X?XP?H??t?B?2?F/? ????,{?!s?}Hbe?x?h~I??oA?g ?tN???? z& ?G@?/?>K??xD????8b??d? $???zc ,?Tq???cat?W ? T ?8 ?pI"?u4S&Yo?????? An??7?%???cQ?A ??? ?%??#&T???1 ?UH2 H???& K?^9Q??9? `???LM1?;?lT ?pI???M?????Na?? ??s ??????J(??? ?z H_&? ?l ???B?z#?Ga>?????j?y tY??? ?w~ x?f? ???S?6??s? m?#A? < ?X? v??4l#?? ?? ?i!hh?5C ?=?}UR?,$ !Z?J=?P3 kCl-?^/ Z?`3O+ ?W?9??? =??c???Y?V4??f=k |GO=?X?? 7?#??s?+ +?*?]?U?? ??Q??9?v5 ?/j?!????j? RQ? b ?d;??f??? #/ ???? D? ?'?+??g??3 ??_=I? hH??i?
??
???FB?9?.??????y}??? ]??x?^???z??y??4?g?o?KB??CA/?Vx}??????-?? ? ?<3? ?|]??k???U%??`4 _+ ???i(}B?^ ??Fw?1G??71??????F???f???0???s?eN;?V?? 5 ?3&?Gf?AW Q??S ??b?l? ?� _)?N ? ,2 &Y?`l;{Z?? ??}?\N_\R???Z? Y\?p i?!?? ???~?.?:]t?
}?u;n ???K?=??s??? ??4o?? r ??? ?P?? ?G?E?-LTK??? =Hxd?p?: 2A? ?
??c ?? ?/?1'???`l ?i? ]j^?? ??? jw?????? z?:?y |y~?v??5j??gE? ?^??%??7r?/ ?m+ ?YZ :??"? ' ?? ??? k f 1)????e??m?R?{Gk?3 @ ????!?C"???. i1 ??#?y?_Q? lB|$ B8$?G? +V??0?+?]l?? +? V!fXE?a?? k fX a?? 3?L???>?4?vn??B??????3??>?? ??!,& ?E9d ?!? ?P1\L�} ? ?^U??????)D ?(-?=i??C ? ?? ?2-?@ ?p 1?? ???^? v ( ??? - ??89?G1dm jZ?)?S ?? ?{L?? ?C?C???Y f?6? ?;?I5 ?V?c??9?z????a????? Q??? ? ,X< ??4`?? $4? G&? ? ?! +m=B? k? ">?x ?% Fs ??[?? &/? ?9_Nm? PK sc|? ��?:��PK � � �?Fi<������������ ���styles.xml?ZKs?6 ??Wh?iO?(J?-??:??4? N?tz?HHDC �?#?? ??K %9vG?? c?, ??b ???K?? 3Nhz???3?i@C?? O? ???7t?" ?
i?'8 . ? ? LN? ?9? m?? ?zhH?? ?F#O?? ??^?B ??;K?? ??Gt+??? m{? �?0? -???v??(????? ?x?(KPi?.&?N???v %.?Y?Pa?? Ks? ??&X?^?%�? I?1!?6???&s ? ??(?x?? ??6 V4N?3t ?3d uQ.? C?I????,B ??-!??A??@ ?? ?X??0 ?t??5 ?T 4O ??||, ? N\? f?ZT+??'u?? $???p??;3???ngD?BF??"4?I ?1????Z 2??? ? 8x 6??F*?? bHE ??h?E8E ?? ?0 o*;?u D?3???i r?p b(k? ?j #?q? T.2 ^???:??????'?? ???? $? 25???&?Z??[??/E?:?py ???p?H??6?m|�?r ? ???@? ,9? ?K?$?%?? ??(?_????#?>a??????d'/S??r?e4? !QB?B?3?M?b?9 %?T^??? ??d?T ?u??? ? x??R?{?Mv %??? ^?Ty??. J??B??y4 ?&?T9wKD???q ?:?? ????yYlUpn6J% )?????_ ?3?sB\N?? 8????.??R?e ]? ???{???? ] ?` hP?'!d ?' f??dV U?K?? ?1??C?;%A7??-??m ???"T?^? '??W?Pw/ !??j?y?~ >?:3? %???yx?.??? T ?'N?*???d ? `n?,?O? Y?]? ?:[? ??=?????#(IK ?
h?!A??L 8y????a???=` ?? ??5 ???5w??2p?Q ??????P ???y?fR?p?? E? [?b??q?'j?? ??]? w?"?N?&D^???~G???R/a?EYsuQ?L/a???]?5?? ?W?4Eu W???
!??+?"z???? %L??nP?cU?[j?J???jstS?WR???*MW ???YB? =r??RMeG?~ Wn?_7^?l?(?T;??J 2???gNyX????_?{?N ?F???????}) ???_?*} ?uw?2?n?84 S???h5L- ?w??p|m>4 QTt???????= 0? J??T??u?AkF?sxa? ??&? ?? ?7?q[????|4?y?m}6?i ^??o ?G? ?i?
?]vt??W2;?? 5E?&? ?V? ?B??k?j"?q ?Ha?x?M?�? ? ????^?D??w? ?Yz??z?@ ???? mQm=??L? 7c?mT?>N??It?vq?i>)/ 6???w?)P?|?w?O?n?{g???, ?@ [ ? ??z??kK???????????U??s?:]_? ?h?? ??? ?p?q?1 ?2 ?9???Y?EsR??jj?? ???T?[?????O?
OpenOffice.org/2.4$Linux OpenOffice.org_project/680m12$Build-9286 venu 2010-03-09T14:24:17 venu 2010-03-09T14:24:29 2 PT13S PK � � �?Fi<������������ ���Thumbnails/thumbnail.png?{uX?s%??Np???? ?Lp?? ?=? ???? ? \ 4??? ??w??>;?0??>]U?U????7LYQ ?
?? ??F((h( 87k*?%((SOR?n ?? ?j???
b????MP? ?( ?Q?Y(((?"????S?#??M???H"D?"???? 4??+?? ?? lLe?G k?? ?7?eYY?&>+?=?????Vv= ??vy??Y??`b??? ??S :K?cD ?9? H? R?Qt$y@? ?? *? ?Y?BI???i???c?l ?~"$\ &S? ?? ??(?|5???Y?? ! ??:?DR?x?? q^??k M+.K# ?3??J"?E? f???} Z?z? ???>??- ?
?? ?q?o?o ??+9 ?hP????
?? ? ??G?`?}G??}u? ?y~|<% 5??>??? ????j???>? !???? )?c?? ??y?[??gi-????}>l??L? y???Z?8D?T? ???[k?Dz??+?CI? w???R???f??
??Zu?? ?/? k ???(?z8H?'?b{??;?{?G?x?t?d?0?+ O???P??dB????? ?X?7Qz??;???}PZ g? ???iW4???w?qig???? ??w .? JB?? cw???@D? HN e?X ??~=??O? ??]wy???O?|? ?O?'C0?-� ?L??i!?F? ?*??
/z'n? n?2?5Su ? ??l+?Y!` ?? ?X? ?l{?, ???
?z?F?O ?>?$ ?????(??o^I;?yL?y?
???/* ?????% JH1??g???xE!??k???? >�??>? O??_6?
;#???C?M? v ?+ ? ???x?"/?!???? ?"6 ePFHs? ???(?D?? ?*?.? O????zo!?T ? ?;? ?(ST?(??~h??
?sW?h ?? ? ????Y?~{?f??#??x } ?/ ?p????s??? ?^?[??}?G?????'r??::?B????S???SS).+?? ?x??
? ?{?B?>?w?.???>?? ;?r??%W!6o?A?1t????&? ??b?p??P? YB?????@p?? u?3q z?O ??Ke??????_???p?9[?s?|ZG? ? ?? ?;n/=? ?mR???w3g3Y?A?Lt @Io?? 5?? ??F�cn C e?t??? ??? bD?(?>~1??V???9?%U?P? I ??q ?
???|??x ?dA?-? ??:E?/? ? ?? 4? ?r??z?'Dj??e?S?22?F?#%?]?? W ???w* ??G#??? ?62? ?o?g? ? w.?w?OKy???U?!r?5??+? ?gtd#? ZE_!?? ? `lP i?? ?.?w_Be??O}+! D?RR?????? Nc^a ??$N?
?,? g?^?j? DO?U?? H ???|??? D n' ` | ??3x a??'?V3E?^??pA.?P? ?{FJ>EcnN?? v?o?\???? jW[ ?W??Bh!J?|?r??W?E^? ??T2 ? 9? L"?4F???98*G??DR/ ? W?|?????4Z?s?????A ???*(R?n?? ?*W??F?#xR? ?]?f/'?2 g???& A????v?:,? %.1??%??O'{?? /3? *B?ERV? ?R ?D ???zO;8???Ru+???y?>??? N? ??: 0??,? ?F ????UA?]?H&???_?a??rw?>u~E?�\? ??_w?+c?]?h?M??W?
?C?tW.??;?% {??lJ?(nm;h,??: ????g X??Gf,????! OSc?y?t3k\#?w? ?)?I? ???? ?????Eb,???`??9I??? ?B IX????V??Z?y?yO?? ?' ?????`??%o?G(?)?q?V1??}X?? M??m??F&?L?????? XAp??a 99? ?,?nJ ?4 ?F??W??6KxE ?a ??4??m?Q?Z??@9 M#?W??Va ?D%iO?FV?\{G??$n ?:m? d?W????? ?+?W??? ?I, (?H?M V=O? ??}??n"$jh61??|%??,?4?]-?H?&%?? P?; +/???t;'??z4? ?$+;>[?g?????Y ???? ?g _????5 B?? U??{???*??X? ??.{ ?|?:? ?Vg ? ?oK??? ?' ?"?e&v;?
G???/D? c?U?? ??u?? *7x �?Q |?] +???$?:oW?Gv?(C h?>?o?C?
?u?gd?"?r !M?_ ?0 ??_??Z?z/??@ !?M 1 ?? ?;?r Ars?|?? ?'"?
??????M??:??3??=}`? ?DF?o? ?? ??"?gQ ?#Z?UR ?" q? `6W*D oI?_?d? ??Tz? ?$N??? AZ? C?l :?B? ???l??3W�??? %?e? !?Y ?
5f?bk8?G?d*? !-?? ???|s??? t????T????? ??? >?? ??? ??? =?F?
?.=|> ?? Jt?L? ? ?? ?Hf%??Wb$??_ I????%?cL??^ ? cn?{?S?. g F+??_ N?? 0?Y?ov??9\? ?uT(H?qJ ?T4"~i;??? 8?? r?9??.W? ? ?? ???B ?1???�?????0 D ?&y ?U*+?a?H ?[? ?3v? B ?fr itUN??? T?
h??i?? c?7???U?MQ=g v?<�?fC *Y {C??b????S??>? ?L? ??r??3??v?????f?gx@,???A???pH])? ??6?9dH??1G631?D >Fn?B ?r?M???s9?b3 ?# _q D P? F?qC????7 a ?W???5??V??}RN/E?/+?IPZ? q?S??'>.??N ??i?=?? ??s?? )?P�;?i.E(!?e?? -???M,??? ????U?!3pV{???+H? o?ZJ " y.?9? ?"????Y?9o\*$?!??f/K?L????\J????z??bsC???0? ??
?0??$ ??i?y ??z??;? ?f??N;?I 3? ?G ???jm�???'" ??_ ??j??X ? ??pA ?l?H? ???z^{?[?8??5 @?? Mo?e;?m ;S??c????u ?/fA]?k*;B?]fk??R? h??}?"K;?I???L?iMh??? ? ?V?0?? ??k??? w}?!??` f? u?4p :*??? -;6 ?T??.U7U?cL? ??O?.?pS U??U?M ? .??_ ? ??? p??? ? ?o n {? ?]? ????z?G?e ??5?\TK? ?BwG ?? ?mb ??E??e? ? ? ? ?~?e?b$u?????Baw??
g??Gf?]???u?? |'26????@????D=4&?I4U ?u?d3A?? ?Rz??qk&7er?I?4)?h((?n2b5IN?? 0?? ??* ?y??n ????~??? ?#AW;??4?? ??s??W6???a0?? o??x?e??%i? ??,?Z2?? ?]?%9 c?9i?!???y�$???Z(9t ? ??:&??O?[5F} ??? }v?u>??&??? T??? / ??C? ?v??pa? ? ??c????V??jc?
??N ?? ???e~?Y/?7??V?]?� B?{3??PL???? ?*?? ?s????? ??+ ??!??vq??*? t?Q???.4pV?p ?c ??Y?j??q??s??�??R? bA??? ?E????E?? ??N}???$ ?O<?~x=? ? ?N'???]??*??? @?Wk]? ???A???> u$???? ?)' A ?d??PN?? ??`?????W :?R%FO? ? ???? L? '?w?T?6 >N ?q Vl?y??Z.)8# ???CA�??i???tj???d? s?? `GP^?Qn ?? ??3_? L?/?g?0???L ?A,?????#r?? %dUj? ??,???D ??? A?? O?2??? ` ?#;?7J7?? ?{/7d ?
pW?>?G ?? ??, ???G?
Mu?v??????l?? ???? ??d?b?!????pB ???d?7?Vp ?Y]V??wS??dq? f?
???)6?S$ ?n?? ??b=9???R?Z??'??Y>$?T?"B ??/? ?xC???x?g?e.j?b?o*?$G?+l?%[$D?Vm ??$ $??Y??/F 5?>?? ? ?P?g?????j??n Pl�? s??????: [ ?? _~] .? ??"$?R??aTQ? u???<#????\d?? ??�;`???xM"? U?JN0 ?F??]D;~??EMy?}??7tv??!?[J?( ??H?y??u??E? Z?huH ?3? x;?R ? k?t????s? ?-u{??3??fY??+?�u"O?P_HQ?\K ??C??? z2 o????j?s??{??A$f??? ? ??W? ?,??p1?U?t?$?q(%Ju??'*2S?a/?~ ??it?"AI?}?w?Y ???{ v?? U?(+} -.J?F??'???? JC?l?kd??H?'\?o|;
y?R ?Q?{?J? ? h "Rw??;??R ?2/?M?z?C???\??o ????!p:?[o!?s???7???V7?]?-???B?U_?7???1 b?1??
? ?M?4fk? ? ? jqA?Q? ?gmi ?- ???N$??bRR? ???T??v?Z R?2R ???"F? ?Sq9?? ? ?o~??Q 4????/V?t4{????a8? A?[% ?c3?1o??? k ?i??-?hrn??v?h~w????Y ??{qW?n?.Qr? S?#? ?D?? ? l??(??Z�<'?}> ? L?r/Q? a ?(oy?V?~ ?? ?g ???6?/?}/^?_?wbg?V? ?tO??m?Em ???S?X&?aOR ?Hi>&V{ ??5?(ex?v?v ??:8??? eO9Y??~? ?4??^n?s9 ?d ?u ?[?????P?x?L? W ??M.?bN????t??? ?\?.
???,U?T ??QM??!? ?P?A?Ez :???:F?? f??
?d?l??k?4?cO?C ?G?d X?? ?S?? ????1??@?????M$?- (i'U1 A??IIO ??b??Eu??6K ??oA?*??&?J?M?Hc??jTd?z? N Wj?k?? ?j??d\f?U?]??? ?)?5S?xz?x ^?Y ]7'L~???[ ?G ?? {? ?1 ? _ ??'( ?BH\4? J? "?.Jj??h? m# ?w ?}oWk ?-tP??=p?jF'?% a?"??~ ? ???ld? ?o? u? ? ?w? ?]?z??C hB? ?? KE ?R??`=-$nz?ymB? ?f?cv
-? ??3!}?Rv???? ?gS &????
cR?a ? f ?N???4?f{??9}QX �?&??A) W`???R? Y(v?}?
? ??} o?DU[?????6? ?N?3.y_?l - g ??h?v�Po?? _???N??c?~??'??S?t :???o? EUN??g8S 4 ?d?Z ? O 7?(?? 9??�R$?? ?, ? @x?.?A??l?`~?r?=? ??v)l?F T? ~?7??e?
??lp?fG?QW?w5:??$?WM?EL??U?D ? ?c:?O'? \?;??C??3R?g????? ??@? ??k?? ^�G?s ??x?r?T[?(7?M??Nz?e?Mo?AR?i =K?U?l???Z S???M?I?/ ???K1????tC.?{??BT ?7 \?A *T?xyH??? 6 ?3\?? ?|/? ??" d F7?j?p?Bg r F ?\J ? ?B m I??crQ > ???S ?)??U???C???M?M-^ ? ??? F?K }??????x ?Y???n?.??/?+?S?? f+ ~+| ???J ?s?n?[E W'?Yo ????m?&???fR?PzL N ?lZ?:>(?V?QH?gf?6?? ?z??? ?H??i?E{??,$ ??|??_???GCk$P?{?1?f??9�???n?? j?'??3W???Bl8[??x?n? ?.?4??k t{AiI? ?a? O' ? s*{,>E :??Rk??? 9}R?&Fa .??? ??w???mjhs16 ^7?[??H??? D ?c?.DT?? ;~&R?@?I ?{`<7?8aq????j ?ts0?? ?L?s? ?????wpU )da? 5??`6??e?vR,(????pq ;?,[-(:?2a??? ?Yp"&?P[!]N?fT??
?O??b???|$?u??h??i????O?X????B?|8(??.??:S?X?~,r ?EA\??Y?N?4W<^,Q }??? ? ???woWl??5 ????n? ?%L ?A{ J j P? ???&? tE?o$??8? ?Y?RMM?J?P?`z ? ???{!/SQ-x???L?9 g?
????`2 ^?2? ?/? ???pX?|? ?�? ?i ? :[?xD? ??Ti?a:?w???"?/?? ??pD J?U???&E?%& ??d???| ???$[ Kj?A?? ?!5P~Y??jC ?K ~ u???c`B?? $*?HY??&>?P@@V? ? ?V ? "?Z?xQ?6? ?"P?1: ? |zv?C ?[?8??9?e &?? qG"?AJ9??,&??Pk%??V ??_?~ ~? ; ?$?z ????}?q??^?R>??'3`?:?G`? |?vX�aX?r???t8?*d Z?8fW????:
????????jC?Y '??(�?% gJ?????~79 \db?? $|? %?????\!?AU^?v????E[z? ??4 ?x?77Yq??E ? 1?>??io??k?E ;?E??.?nd??G~Zj ?N?.?f?N????K?p?? o;)l???? U?S?r???A ? ?$1 ,??? q?????4?? F??a:?P?w??PE?`K ?$8????????{??vC?~?????~ _ ?? ~?*?Z? �?x?,??,h a?s?�x?>? ??JJ?????p f???Fy ??e97??_?%?R?6$?C??H^ +?s.?S??'????S? *??e?]*?V?{??Q? ?J?m-!+? ? S?6]?@??f?????[/?@{ey|b ????j/??m??>? ?\sX ?& F9o? ?w????? ?? cdG?N?i? ?(??M?a [Lb%??@W 29/{i???t? ?1?-?\?O ?.?2g?;.?k? `?ApR? ?I?sT?? ??>Am??2?F?M?x???? ?: ?/>Vk?]?. ??`?F ?o??e?s ??O???A'? ?? ??�H/$?uI???S?}??I????s 3n$-? c7??{1*?t??K?oE??i?? N?!l ??
? w>? T M??\L???u?4Y nk???rP ? ?dQ?in} ????Y)?sb5gT}R\A?H4\??\??R $` ??1k|?(Z[ ??# ??p+???Qy? 7??\??U:? ? ???:?�`?? <^? "I ??#f.??? ??# \ ?S??$??Y??6< ??a>?p ?C?i???6Pa p?a|J???? [m J+??]U;)-?? ??I+?_ X??D??, i?????.??Ks?V?;c???,1#??j?X?? [?E? ~?+?5??`?/;>?y;???}?N???G{??x {???u??9?? ? ?q?Y?'w?J[) ?l'VT?$??x???ye?? ? u??p??2?}6??i +??J+?)???Y8????^" R??K#?cY??P?(??E l H??f? ??j ?3??70??:?z?@?? ? ?[(?? ?1?n?r?DZ?]?G7?w; ?Y??a??)1?????C?d?o ??B??? ??2?g? 9,????G?{?O?l/_?? U?}{G ??if?? ??Fz??!????+ E?? kp?7?; ?C???P?iN?!!??!?/ @& ]?'??|X??
?wyR0?? ??"?U?'=?M??Q?uug?H?y??� N Zq^? ??-4s0????g?I?u/? ?A%*N]9w?? ???$4??-/?0D?- L????y??ED?} ?F?UzwW??1?F ??I?m??r*I? } 3V?r%C x?&/??T???h ??????????X?+??{O?w?m?P??'iE?* C?? PK ?+&?96��?7��PK � � �?Fi<������������ ���settings.xml?Y]s?: }??"?w?G?P2 CJ/ ?fn???od?G? ??l?$`Rb?S ?????sv??o????T ?[?z^q?@x? bv??)??`?R"R |X???? K?+??? Z8ov? ?m?=U?i7?????l#? r+?!x?????[LnQ??oq&^ 9?0]?q/?
? ?a S d???$ ??m?6??}I?- ?EV?
7???I??c?? ?cJ ? 7b??+ P?E??:M{??? ? ???)ll?AW??}?*`b O?????LP?4F T?G? ??6 "Wm? Wx????KZ*;|???
??c)?LP b4G Ko?k}?�???G?m ?X?d???? F?- ?a?!.? l?5?? oum??;?C??p?ZF?E?kt0 ?p?f\i??Lx? ? ???p? ??^?C>??2??:?Kt7g $~??g???Zq! P? ?o??vc?(?U?[;? ?? ~�PK uT 2i ��? ��PK � �����?Fi Top